HFS10/P6: Communal Award, Poona Pact (1932): Salient Features, Evaluation

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 125

  • @bikramghosh1450
    @bikramghosh1450 4 роки тому +13

    Its 4yr running Pratik Sir history lecture is still so relevant.
    Once again concept is the king proved.
    This lecture series will make an another history.

    • @thequantum-plator
      @thequantum-plator 2 роки тому +3

      Because its history, not current affairs

    • @_Chetan.
      @_Chetan. 7 місяців тому

      @@thequantum-plator History is also an evolving subject. I am doing for FastTrack Revision.

  • @tanishq904
    @tanishq904 5 років тому +29

    Babasaheb Ambedkar is true hero of the country he raised voice of depressed class people in the proper platform and Hindu society had been already divided in multiple castes for malice purpose when facts coming to picture you people are alleging Babasaheb Ambedkar for dividing hindu society,Hindu society has caused maximum damage to depress people then why should they be part of the hindu society....Jay Bhim Jay Bharat Jay Sambidhan. ..AMBEDKAR SHIKSHYA VIHAR ROURKELA ODISHA.

  • @mailtosadhana
    @mailtosadhana 7 років тому +29

    Hats off to you. May all your dreams come true.

  • @harshgarg5461
    @harshgarg5461 8 років тому +6

    Sir, ur videos are so comprehensive as well as concise that it could be completed in a very short time....Thank you:)

  • @ashishkurweti1603
    @ashishkurweti1603 8 років тому +29

    baba saheb is one of the good leader in indian history

  • @garg.shelvi
    @garg.shelvi 5 років тому +2

    I had read all the stuff multiple times previously but able to connect links and understand thoroughly only with ur videos sir
    Thankyou so much , explained so well.
    You are a savior 😊

  • @CSEonics
    @CSEonics 3 роки тому

    The most precious thing on UA-cam for me.
    Thanks a lot sir ,I will be always grateful to you

  • @anirudhkhartade7122
    @anirudhkhartade7122 4 роки тому +9

    02:30 India mein unity kaha thi sir, pehle se hi 6000 se jyada jatiyo me bata tha desh...

  • @abhishekjadon605
    @abhishekjadon605 3 роки тому

    Thanku sir ...abhi tak pure utube pe itne acche se history kisi ne nahi pdai h sir

  • @theworld7583
    @theworld7583 5 років тому +4

    No need to join any coaching institute for history this series is more then enough for any competition examination

  • @tarun19_99
    @tarun19_99 8 років тому +21

    great sir.....now no need for ny history coachig

    • @sangharsh2659
      @sangharsh2659 4 роки тому +1

      Hann sahi kaha bhai.
      history itnihi to he😝

  • @prashantshukla6642
    @prashantshukla6642 2 роки тому

    Best teacher ❤ ♥ 💙 💖 💕 💓 ❤ of modern History

  • @lakshyasingh4848
    @lakshyasingh4848 3 роки тому

    Thank you sir for amazing lectures. May GURUJI MAHARAJ bless you 🙏😊

  • @dipanwitaroy146
    @dipanwitaroy146 4 роки тому +1

    Loved the lucid explanation.. Keep going sir!! Lots of respect for u ❤

  • @royalera512
    @royalera512 8 років тому +7

    Devi prasad Hai kya..??? Your explanation is just awesome. Keep it up 👌👌👌

  • @KuKstudypoint
    @KuKstudypoint 6 років тому +5

    *Jai Hind Sir!*
    (17/05/2018)➡️(12:17 pm)

  • @harshgautam6160
    @harshgautam6160 7 років тому +27

    its strange how casually we talk about freedom fighters underminning the fact they gave their life for us i feel sad looking at people talking and making fun of our forefathers

    • @sairammalekar8504
      @sairammalekar8504 5 років тому +11

      It is just for purposes to get to know n easily remember things n events in nationalist movements... every one of us respects leaders... no need to take it in other way bro

  • @KuKstudypoint
    @KuKstudypoint 6 років тому +5

    *Jai Hind Sir!*
    (08/06/2018)🛡️(05:58 pm)

  • @amanbishla
    @amanbishla 2 роки тому +3

    Brilliant Lectures Pratik Sir :)

  • @jahnvisharma6032
    @jahnvisharma6032 Рік тому

    GREAT TEACHING, THANK U SIR!

  • @himanshurawat1048
    @himanshurawat1048 7 років тому +3

    love to watch your videos .. thk u sir

  • @shaikhhuma4371
    @shaikhhuma4371 5 років тому +1

    Alhumdulillah.. understand clearly.. with questions.. Thank u sir

  • @sonnyethan9588
    @sonnyethan9588 8 років тому +2

    Thanks for the strategy comprehension.

  • @sandeepchandsandy3037
    @sandeepchandsandy3037 4 роки тому

    hats off all teacher who make us officer

  • @abhaymoolniwasi2185
    @abhaymoolniwasi2185 5 років тому +9

    हरिजन शब्द गाली से भी ख़तरनाक है

  • @ShayariByKamaal
    @ShayariByKamaal 7 років тому +4

    Really good one..,

  • @deepthishenoy4295
    @deepthishenoy4295 8 років тому +3

    THANKYOU SIR

  • @sivapranithaaraviti4503
    @sivapranithaaraviti4503 4 роки тому

    Wow great teaching sir

  • @lx_dhanush685
    @lx_dhanush685 4 роки тому +1

    @12:25 GIA 1935

  • @divyanshuverma2442
    @divyanshuverma2442 3 роки тому

    Sir, the reserve bank of India was established under RBI act, 1934 and began operation in April, 1935. The Govt of India act came in Aug, 1935 and the draft of GOI 1935 in Feb 1935. So, how did GOI 1935 help in the creation of RBI ?

  • @pravashkandi
    @pravashkandi 4 роки тому

    Joint electorate was not for Harijans. It was for Depressed Class which was later replaced with the term Scheduled Castes in 1935. Scheduled Caste is not same as Harijan.

  • @rakeshvikramaditya8078
    @rakeshvikramaditya8078 8 років тому +2

    thank you sir

  • @PriyaMBBS_19
    @PriyaMBBS_19 7 років тому +5

    thanks

  • @Shiv4u
    @Shiv4u 5 років тому

    Fabulous sir👍👍

  • @tejaschavan5165
    @tejaschavan5165 5 років тому

    5:27 MORLE MINTO KI VIDEO SIR KAB DIKHAI? They are missing...please upload

  • @mochansolanki735
    @mochansolanki735 6 років тому +2

    unprecedented.

  • @amlandutta7006
    @amlandutta7006 5 років тому

    Should have 1M

  • @darkworld400
    @darkworld400 5 років тому

    Thanks sir a lot🙏🙏🙏

  • @saurabhsingh-ow7ue
    @saurabhsingh-ow7ue 3 роки тому

    thank you sir....

  • @rubinasadangi7832
    @rubinasadangi7832 6 років тому

    Thank you Sir.

  • @Rajanand0077
    @Rajanand0077 5 років тому

    Good lecture .👍

  • @shashidharan6492
    @shashidharan6492 5 років тому

    what does it mean dalit was larger part of hindu society at that time...@1:55 can u elaborate

  • @kumaramit695
    @kumaramit695 4 роки тому +3

    Sir aapne Gandhi ko jyada focus kiya, not real mention of ambedkar who is real india builder

  • @indrajram5786
    @indrajram5786 4 роки тому +1

    Jai Bhim Jai Bharat Namo Budhai poona pact lagu karo

  • @yogeshsurti7197
    @yogeshsurti7197 3 роки тому

    Ref. Mahadevbhaini Diary part 2 (Gujarati ) written by shri Madev Desai, Mahatma Gandhiji' Secretary.
    The poona pact was signed by Madan Mohan Malaviya and Dr. Ambedkar and others, on 24-09-1932. Immediately on 25-09-1932 the poona pact was further signed by the members of *The Hindu
    Parishad* in Bombay. They not only signed, but passed thee resolutions for doing best for the depressed class. But unfortunately it was their last meeting as could be read.
    Can you throw light in this regard as to its history and why it dispersed immediately after signing the pact escaping from its responsibility towards the depressed class?
    I think without these facts the story remains incomplete. I seek your help to known.

  • @abdullahaznoorahmed9109
    @abdullahaznoorahmed9109 5 років тому +1

    Sir who are depressed classes plz plz say ...

  • @Sourabhtandon24
    @Sourabhtandon24 6 років тому

    Jahanpanah ❤️

  • @football8110
    @football8110 3 роки тому

    Thnks sir

  • @akshitgupta4674
    @akshitgupta4674 7 років тому +2

    Do Sikh were also part of separate electorate? If not did they get it later.

  • @vaibhavsl9852
    @vaibhavsl9852 6 років тому

    sir pls do refer some other materials rather than spectrum coz that will improve our knowledge and idea

  • @kanaklatamahato6888
    @kanaklatamahato6888 5 років тому

    Nice

  • @abhaymoolniwasi2185
    @abhaymoolniwasi2185 5 років тому +1

    ग़लत जानकारी

  • @kuldeepsrivastava3601
    @kuldeepsrivastava3601 8 років тому +2

    sir agar 1935 me reserve bank bni to 2015 me satabdi kaise mnayenge.

  • @vbrr6508
    @vbrr6508 5 років тому +5

    saperate electorate ki maang babasaheb ne isliye ki thi taaki jo sadiyon se jo discrimination chala aa rha hai wo khatm ho jaye, dalit normal citizen ki tarah ji sake....
    gandhi ji ke hisab se unity ko lekar chalte to dalit wahi ke wahi rah jaate. also gandhi doesn't deserve mahatma title.

    • @vbrr6508
      @vbrr6508 5 років тому +1

      here the truth
      ua-cam.com/video/TrS8vkRQhSQ/v-deo.html

    • @Spartan-fi9je
      @Spartan-fi9je 3 роки тому

      Bolne ke liye dalit aaj bhi vahin hai
      Bas ab gaali sunne ke liye reservation milta hai
      Gaali toh ab bhi padti hai

    • @sahilgaikwad1387
      @sahilgaikwad1387 3 роки тому

      @@Spartan-fi9je this is the only reason ki india kabhi superpower nahi ban sakta. ❤

  • @AbhishekPatel-xr4gv
    @AbhishekPatel-xr4gv 7 років тому

    if you are saying that " the depressed classes had a larger majority at that time..... " so why were the separate electorates being given by the British Government....??

    • @indianmysteries3171
      @indianmysteries3171 5 років тому +2

      Because they was slave of upper cast people and they was untouchables at that time and thousand times poor than any other classes in india

    • @MoumitaBiswasriki
      @MoumitaBiswasriki 4 роки тому

      indian mysteries They still are.. Discrimination still exists.

    • @Spartan-fi9je
      @Spartan-fi9je 3 роки тому +1

      @@MoumitaBiswasriki Don't worry reservation is not going anytime soon. Neither is the discrimination arising.

  • @ramchandrapaswan345
    @ramchandrapaswan345 7 років тому +6

    Reasons best known to him, Mrinal Patel is not honestly illustrating Puna Pact in logical consequences, certainly with clear intention of misinterpretation and hiding of facts. Most probably either he himself is not logically Clear, or intentionally he is escaping from disclosing truth with a view to undermine the Struggle for More Power to Weaker and Downtrodden Sections of the country. A teacher must teach True INTENTION and Consequences of Indian History to the Student.

    • @ShwetankT
      @ShwetankT 6 років тому +10

      He is teaching for clearing this exam, not for doing PhD.

    • @shubhashishpandit6083
      @shubhashishpandit6083 6 років тому +1

      Shwetank T agreed pal. Just clear it and move on. Already there are too many subjects to cope with.

  • @sr1621
    @sr1621 6 років тому +4

    Bharat ko angrejone nhi toda yaha ki jati vyavstha aur varn vyavstha ne toda tha, angrejone dalitonko savrn hinduoke atyachar aur julmose bachaya tha, reference book Gulamgiri of Mahatma Fule

  • @pradipgiri735
    @pradipgiri735 3 роки тому

    What is separate electorate

  • @JagsirSir
    @JagsirSir 4 роки тому +1

    Commual award laggu hona chahie tha.

  • @letsgostudystudy941
    @letsgostudystudy941 5 років тому

    Sir please question Hindi me bhe me sbhi questions samjh nhi a rhe hai English me

  • @niksfloyd
    @niksfloyd 5 років тому +2

    My God what a horrible explanation of Poona Pact, no mention of Simon Commission, no mention of first round table conference, no mention of Ambedkars reaction on Poona pact.. This was a typical coaching centre explanation.

    • @Spartan-fi9je
      @Spartan-fi9je 3 роки тому +3

      This is relevant to UPSC. Aapko Poona pact ke saath babu shona khelna hai toh uske bhi 2-3 ghante ke video hai UA-cam pe. Vahan pe jaake manoranjan kare apna.

  • @satishjhajhda8164
    @satishjhajhda8164 3 роки тому

    👍

  • @gauravrai4386
    @gauravrai4386 3 роки тому +1

    Dear people of the depressed section of Indian society, raise your voice for a separate electorate.
    Start asking for a separate electorate in exchange for Reservations.
    This is the only thing that can emancipate you from the social evils of Hindu society.
    It was the dream of Dr. Ambedkar, and we have to fulfill it at any cost.
    People will try to lure you in the name of Hinduism. They will ask you to unite but remember Hindus were never united and never will be. "United Hindu" is just political propaganda and that will never going to come true.
    P.S - Hinduism is not a religion, it's a way of life in which every lower caste has to accept the supremacy of the upper caste.
    Rajput has to accept the supremacy of Brahmans, Yadav has to accept Rajput, and so on.
    One last thing-
    "Never ever trust an upper-caste Hindu in your social matters. They will never favor you."
    "Educate - Agitate - Organize"
    #JaiBhim #JaiBharat

  • @rajeshpanwar7301
    @rajeshpanwar7301 3 роки тому

    Jai bhim jai mulnivasi jai savidhaan

  • @adityanastik.followerofpwa1203
    @adityanastik.followerofpwa1203 3 роки тому

    Jai bheem

  • @ashwanisaini550
    @ashwanisaini550 4 роки тому

    👆

  • @KuKstudypoint
    @KuKstudypoint 6 років тому +1

    *(24/11/2018)*

  • @Dineshverma-de7xg
    @Dineshverma-de7xg 4 роки тому

    Untouchables to waise hi alag h, uchi jati k log unko waise hi nich samjte h. Higher cast not taking food, water from there hand even they are not allowing them in the minders, they cannot enter in untouchables house, they can't fetch water from the common village's wells, they are not allow to touch public utensils, when they walking in front of higher cast they have to remove there slipper and have to put them on head, they always have to carry brooms and spitting pot with as they are not allowed to spit on ground. They can't hoard money if they do and a higher cast person want it, he can loot that money. And more many more atrocities prevailed in the past if any body wish to know please go through Baba Sheba Ambedkars literature.

  • @sandip4300
    @sandip4300 3 роки тому

    Hello

  • @amitm1157
    @amitm1157 4 роки тому

    Poona pact is not valid and it is crazy.

  • @dvinit1280
    @dvinit1280 5 років тому

    gandhi nothing more than hard core politician .he had nothing with dalits.

  • @aryanraj-wc3tf
    @aryanraj-wc3tf 5 років тому +1

    This man is teaching wrong. He is saying that English men was making partition and hatred by giving separate electorate according to baba saheb.
    Really this teacher knows very less about real history may be due to being of an upper caste making nonsense about the communal award being given by English men.
    He is saying that mahatma Gandhi was right which is absolutely incorrect because that man was doing nothing any welfare towards in comparison of baba saheb.
    Baba saheb is our god forever.
    Listen O half knowledge teacher, please first you go and sit to read history very carefully without thinking of being any upper caste.
    Is it OK ??
    Good bye.

  • @wanifaixan77
    @wanifaixan77 3 роки тому +1

    Greebo ka unacademy

  • @RaviSingh-ox6hy
    @RaviSingh-ox6hy 5 років тому +1

    Mote sahi padha le

  • @raghavendracraghavendrac41
    @raghavendracraghavendrac41 5 років тому

    gandhi kalla nanna maga

  • @MegaMar20
    @MegaMar20 7 років тому +1

    Poor understanding of Poona Pact is showing through.

  • @arrows8367
    @arrows8367 7 років тому

    call him gandhiji not gandhi

    • @akshitgupta4674
      @akshitgupta4674 7 років тому +10

      No one gives a fuck if he calls Gandhi or Gandhiji. Focus on the learning and not on things that doesn't matter. If you cannot write a word of appreciation for this guy, better not comment at all.

  • @manishjaiswal5075
    @manishjaiswal5075 7 років тому +1

    need more practice of teaching for u..... try to explain to others .... not to yourself....

  • @ScamAlert1001
    @ScamAlert1001 6 років тому +2

    10:40 devi prasad :P

  • @paravellyshivaprasad3243
    @paravellyshivaprasad3243 5 років тому

    Thank you sir

  • @ayushithakur6292
    @ayushithakur6292 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you sir

  • @sreelakshmi4382
    @sreelakshmi4382 Рік тому

    Thank you sir 🙏