What is Communism? | Success and Failures of Communism | Dhruv Rathee
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 тра 2024
- Has there been any successful implementation of Communism throughout the world history? What were the communist ideologies of Karl Marx, Lenin and Stalin? In this video, I explain the history, the success and the failures of Communism in detail. Welcome to the brand new educational series: Basics by Dhruv Rathee. In this series, I will explain complex ideologies, terms and foundational topics that everyone should know about!
Link to Sapiens Book: amzn.to/38QX56d
Thanks to Manav for editing: manavisuals?igs...
Support my work and join as a member to get exclusive stuff:
1. On Patreon: / dhruvrathee
2. On UA-cam: ua-cam.com/channels/-CS.html...
----------------------------------------------------
MY FAVOURITE EQUIPMENT:
🎥 Studio Camera: amzn.to/2McQ8Vs
🔎 Studio Camera Lens: amzn.to/365fYSs
📸 Vlogging Camera: amzn.to/2Y6hoaP
🥢 Vlogging Tripod: amzn.to/2KKdcuq
🎙 Podcast Mic: amzn.to/3qLPkpq
MY FAVOURITE BOOKS:
📖 Sapiens - amzn.to/38QX56d
📖 Homo Deus - amzn.to/3o1nzIB
📖 Mahatma Gandhi - amzn.to/3n5fQYN
📖 Juli’s Hindi Learning Book - amzn.to/3bhAcvx
FOLLOW ME ON:
📩 Telegram: t.me/dhruvratheechannel
📸 Instagram: / dhruvrathee
🐦 Twitter: / dhruv_rathee
▶️ UA-cam Channel: / dhruvrathee
🎦 Vlog Channel: / dhruvratheevlogs
MORE VIDEOS:
🗺 Ground Reports: • Ground Reports
🇺🇳 International Issues: • Current Affairs (World)
💲 Finance Videos: • Financial Education
📚 Educational Videos: • Educational Videos
🇮🇳 Indian Issues: • Current Affairs (India)
🎦 My Vlogs: / dhruvratheevlogs
----------------------------------------------------
0:00 Introduction
2:31 Primitive Communism
3:38 Ideology of Karl Marx
6:20 Rise of Lenin
8:06 Soviet Communism
12:10 Successful Ideas
14:52 Failures of Communism
17:40 Was it ever Successful?
Next video in this series will be on Feudalism and Capitalism. If you enjoyed this, please share this video. It is only because of your support that this has been possible. I would also really appreciate if you can support this work through Patreon or UA-cam Membership. This kind of animation and graphics are very expensive to do. Regardless, big thanks to each and everyone of you.
2:31 Primitive Communism
3:38 Ideology of Karl Marx
6:20 Rise of Lenin
8:06 Soviet Communism
12:10 Successful Ideas
14:52 Failures of Communism
17:40 Was it ever Successful?
Great video! Looking forward to more!
Nice video
मुझे बहुत कंफ्यूजन था, बार बार Google Karna पढ़ता था , thanks bro for This video 🤘😆
I am big fan of karl Marx
0:00 start😂
where a 19 minutes video makes more sense than studying the whole year in school
Should've read em school books instead of wasting time ! ☺️
@@srv1347 so true
totally bastard content, illiteracy
Guy sucks
Padh Lena chahiye tha tab 19 minute and one year me difference lagta
For those of you who don't know this series , he will be covering all the ideologies like communism , capitalism conservatism , liberalism , both right and left wing ideologies....
How do you know?
I mean just for curiosity
@Genghis Khan 9
Ayega toh modi hi
@@apkasonal455 koi kaam nahi hai kya......modiji khud apni kursi ke peeche itna nahi pare honge....jitna tum ho
@@apkasonal455 Aur sabka kaat ke jayega
This is best perfectly balanced video regarding communism in any Indian language. It checks both sides. 👍🏻👍🏻
watching your video is far better than reading 2-5 hour academic books. your content is really helpful
Without reading academic books, you will fall prey to half baked truth like these.
Title of Dhruv's Biography -
"Around the world in 5 T-shirts"
😁😁
😁
Good one!!
😂😂
Weall that's good
Surprising accurate!!
Bhai editing is top notch..🎉🎉
Namuskaara guru
His team is doing great job na 😮
Yes I'm impressed 👏👌😎
Kannada kuwara
Hi Kannada kuvara... hegiddeera ??? Namaskaara !!!
Loved it, reminded me of school days. We studied this in history. Stalin Lenin cold war. Wish you were my teacher back then. Watching your videos are so educational.
ঝান্ডার রঙ যদি ফিকে হয়,
রক্তে রাঙিয়ে নিও কমরেড... ✊✊✊
I was stunned by seeing only 4 mins of the video. The animation and editing is perfect and more interestingly it was never seen before
If only he could make justice to the editing with content that makes with content that wasn't so insensible and mis-/un- informed...
You actually explained the chapter "Socialism in Europe and Russian Revolution"
Class 9 students can Understand 😅
I am in 8th now in 9th i can easily learn this chapter
Yes, and great that "socialism in europe". Europian socialists changed the definition of communism, and what non-communists think as 'COMMUNISM'. I know lots of people who think that Hitler was communist and was a very good man. Wtf
@PM Сен ақымақсың india abh socialist ni h
@@hehehellohi_ North Korea hai
@@user-uk8hy3ln1d acha
Hi Dhruv. Thank you for such an informative and easy to understand video. I studded in Pondicherry University and stayed there for 2 years. During this period I visited Aurovil several times and got the chance to understand their culture and their concept closely.
Preparing notes for my socio political philosophy. This helped me much
Op Editing Dhruv Bhaiya
Hello bhai please support Karo
How to revive dead channel?
@@Noone-nu1wr manusya bhakshak
Editing karne wala koi or ha
OP Dhurv
Hello! I from Sindh, Pakistan, want to request you to make your video on the topics of European history, periods of progress and Greek philosophers and their philosophy. You have highly inspired me via your content and presentation method. I am greatly thankful to you and your team... Love from Pakistan ❤
Hey,,,i am from Bangladesh 🤟
@@technicalmaster4378 hi bengali brother
From India, Lucknow
@@technicalmaster4378 chomula
@@Johnny_Aniket from Varanasi India bhai 😂
speechless after watching the EXPLANATION of the concept of COMMUNISM. Great service you are doing to the community.
the editing level has suddenly reached the moon
New editor xD
Too much editing
i noticed that too.
Shi baat
@@sahilchouhan6459 Exactly. It has been edited to a point where it has almost started to annoy me.
editing is mind-blowing and sooper
Akir edit kisne kiya h
Description dekho
@@LalTamatarOfficial Names are written at 19:36
❤️❤️❤️
nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
Casteist society like India definitely need communism marxism at least as social model while economically we can still be capitalist 🙏
Kaun. Kaun 2024 me dekh raha hai
Abhi dekh rahe hai😂
Tera baap
Me
Me
Me
He is better than my Social science teacher , she talks about her dog more than Hitler!
😂
Edit: damn you guys it's first time I got 1k likes, thank you dumb teacher because you are the reason.
😂😂🤣🤣
Is that true can you explain...?😂
I mean how can a teacher talk about his/her dog in lectures..
He *
@@mayurijoshi8703 because she is idiot
@UCeRlPYOSf-sPwwQZZmP2ZaA no I am in 10 just thinking about boards 🤣🤣
In best Korea, we talk about our supreme leaders struggle in social class
The editor deserves a raise.
Your this video is better than whole chapter 2 of 9th class.
Lmao
Exactly, we have a 20+ pages chapter and still students stay confused.
Main abhi padhte mein hi search kar rahi thi!! 😅
Napoleonic Philosophy and Nationalism
Literally you made the concept totally clear!😍
Dhruv rathee is communist
Because despite a well educated and well settled man ,he has only 4 5 set of t shirts in his wardrobe
Salute you comrade😎🤣
Edit-bhai joke ko joke ki tarah lo na kya ye steve jobs,Zuckerberg k example ya minimalist bol rhe ho
Judge ya target thodhi kia hai
🤣🤣🤣🤣
LoL 😆
😂😂😂
Dhruv should watch it
modi ji ko bolo apna wardrobe donate kar dein
Just because of you I have started taking interest in History.
Thanks a million for making people aware of their historical roots.
Lol
Then start watching Rajiv Malhotra abhijeet chavda they are scientist this guy rathee is a bigot
Please shift to other perspective too because history has too many different angle don't just stick to one person.
@@Healthandnutritiontips 😄 bigot ohhh really 👎
@@ANKUR_UP44 yes most of the time he shows only side that is profitable for his propaganda
It's really very simplified, seriously it should continue...
Iam aspirant of css exam and i appreciate your efforts and endeavours; though, i have searched a lot but your videos are beneficial!
Have you passed your exam. How was your test.?
Never seen such good Animation dost.👍🏻
More than 100M people fell victims to communism around the world
May their soul rest in peace☮
@@skrillex6044 first do research then yell🙏
I've seen
Kabhi aman dhattarwal ka channel ni dekha kya
I guess some animation are from movies😅
Dhurv, also make a video on "Fascism".
Actually, now a days we are listening this term a lot.😂😂
@@kushjindal2939 yes. Modi is more agressive. But can't tell if he is facist.
Very true... but he will again start getting threats from the 'extra decent' people of our country🤣
@SHIKHAR Real May be it's a beginning.. Just take a glance on the latest arrests cycle!!!
@SHIKHAR Real many things happened problem is you are ignorant, look at how many people are getting arrested on thee charge of UAPA, even journalists
@SHIKHAR Real Modi is not as fascist as his government and Yogi Adityanath
Very informative dhruv I wanted to know in detail that you have provided thank you so much 🙏❣️
Wonderful video, one of the best and crisp ones I have ever seen. I liked the example of power vacuum
Lgta h bhai ko naya editor mil gya h 👀
@jithu krishna Toh tu kyu dekh ne aagaya....
@@adnanaftab5542 😂😂
@@adnanaftab5542 roasted
@@adnanaftab5542 destroyed in seconds 😂😂😂
Tu yaha bhi agaya
This is what world needs - unity and dosti bani rahe (among us).
He got completely wrong information about communism whatever he said in this video that's not the concept of Karl Marx's Das kapital. most of the things he explain are about Anarchism. He got a very little information actually misinformation . In fact Karl Marx said this very clearly, anarchism can be possible in the extreme level of socialism.
@@ronniedebnath9975 ohh thnks for info
@@ronniedebnath9975 Have you ever studied karl marks book?
Socialism is mechanism to achieve communism.
Commun is group of persons. From this word came communism.
Asal matlab to aap hi samjhaoge. Isliye hum sab kuchh samajhne yahi aa jate hai. Aur is confidence se bhi yaha aate hai ki ab to samajh aa hi jayega. All thanks to you and your team 🙏🏻
I wanted to leearn about these things since so many times, but this taught within 19.56 minutes, thanks a lot
Bhai ye kaafi kam smajhaya hai
There are numerous book on communism... please read one of these
@@brewedmeditation2886 kindly suggest
@@DastaanDrift start with _Socialism: Utopian and Scientific_ by Friedrich Engels, _Principles of Communism_ by Friedrich Engels, _The Three Sources and Three Component Parts of Marxism_ by V.I. Lenin!
You can find basically any book you want online too. Happy reading! 👍🏾
@@aman6735 sahi he par video me limitations hoti he, just like arts and commercial movie,
Le everyone to their social sciences teacher : Teri toh ...
He actually explained better than my school teacher
I saw you in power train comment 😂😂
@@ramdeokumar6657 I have subbed to that channel also ◉‿◉
@@MO-fg2cm bro I like that channel too but wahan dhruv ko bahut criticize kiya jata hai comment section me😡😡😡
Bicycle lover ke liye new travelling video
Love pro bicycle;YT
Best educated nd knowledgeable person on utube in India ..knows everything about world science history politics etc..
Dhruv sir.... I am teacher by professional.... Your video is very informative...it helps me a lot...some facts are not clearly defined in our book... But after listening your topic , I can explain my students vividly... Thanks... Provide us more information.
Dhruv sir,
Here's a few topics I would like to learn from your explanation. You've already mentioned to discuss on few, still I'm just trying to give a full list.
1. Communalism
2. Socialism
3. Feudalism
4. Capitalism
5. Leftism
6. Democracy
7. Rightism
8. Liberalism
9. Majoritarianism
10. Libertarianism
11. Meritocracy
12. Differences of apparently similar ideologies.
13. What India is according to it's constitution and in practice.
14. Comparatively better form of society or any new ideology.
Thank you sir.
Knock knock tera baap aya.
I hate Arnab
TOpper spotted
Sale tution he lagale muft me
Add fascism into that list too.
Dhruv's content is improving rapidly
100/100
☭
@SomeRandomGuy ❤
@@aratirao9007 who is aditya rathore
@@aratirao9007 oh sorry woh mere 1 friend ka name aditya Rathore tah isliye mein confuse hogaya
Loved the episode. Appreciate it, Dhruv jee
GREAT!!!!!
explained in a very systematic and simple way.
The editing and animations OMG! I just can't take my eyes off😳😳👌💥
People shouldn't be afraid of their government. Governments should be afraid of their people.
💯
Hey i saw your Twitter Handle. Looks like you're famous
@@mayurijoshi8703 lol Dude.
Best Korea- we don’t do that here
@@hyderabadi8605 savage
When a party wins a election, we say that they are now the ruling party..bt it should be 'serving party'...govt is there to serve the people, not to rule them..but if people don't believe in that, then it won't change
Thanku very much bhaiya i had a lot of confused regarding this... But your explanation makes this ideology crystal clear to my mind... Hats offf
ऐसा महसूस हो रहा है कि हमारी शिक्षा नीति बहुत अयोग्य है जो हम पर मोटी मोटी किताबों का बोझ वर्षों तक डालकर रखती है जबकि ऐसे वीडियो विद्यार्थियों के लिए ज्यादा लाभदायक हो सकते हैं।
ध्रुव राठी आज के समय का एक सबसे बेहतर educator बन गया है जिससे हमारे शिक्षकों को प्रेरणा लेकर अपने काम को बेहतर बनाने की कोशिश करनी चाहिए ताकि विद्यार्थियों को शिक्षा पाने में सरलता, रुचि और मदद हो सके।
Legend says when Dhruv came late in school , his teachers apologised for coming early
Nice one😂
But he is not right , He is always left 🙂
Yea🤘😁
Way too repetitive, I heard this from who want millionaire
This applies for Putin lol 😂
Everyone: Dhruv Rathee is new sst teacher..
Le me_ Observing his new editing software😂😂
He has a team of 4-5 editors😉
@@gyanp28 Have a look to his description, he has mentioned about editor...
Juli ji sikha rhi hain...
Manas is a good editor. I've seen some of his work.
@@gyanp28 1 editor hai bhai
I have my presentation in cllg on 3rd June on communism nd when I saw ur video uploaded on this it just gives me satisfaction that this sir will definitely help me .... Nd when I saw ur video it is literally just beyond words thank you so much sir....
Very well explained in depth & with passion.👌🏼
Modi: I will not provide jobs💁♂️
Dhruv: Let me hire some Animators and Editors😎
The mouse click sound at every transition is a bit annoying while using earphones. Other than that a good edit and your content is great as always...!
Plus one to that
Yup, that's a little distracting
hmm +1
Should be less
Ok, will correct it. Thanks for the feedback :)
Dhruv rathee video teach history of class 9th and 10th very nicely . Good for student
You're great Dhruv. Your videos are excellent. Love you bro.
I was waiting for this video..... Shukriya bhai
How many years will you mother live???
1). lgnore = 0 year❌
2). Subscription =100 years.....
अंध भक्तों के मुंह मैं अगर मोदी थुक दे तो अंध भक्त कहेंगे देश हित के लिए ही थुका होगा
( अंध भक्त दूर रहे )
Follow___Support
How many years will your Family live ??
1.) Ignore = 0 years ×
2.) 1 subcribe = 100 years √.,
Ayega toh modi hi
Aisa kyun?
Legend says when dhruv was in school the teacher used to take permission from dhruv to speak.
It really shines through in your teaching!!!🔥✨
Mene dhruv rathi ki ek video dekhi aur phir mene saari dekh dali ….research, logic, and honesty ke liye 👍
Every class 10 (cbse) student should watch this!!!!
He explained it in very interesting way!!
10th icse too
Why sir , so everyone become communist
@@xterminator2921 he explained the meaning of communism, and how it works.
Not for them to become communist.
This video is for educational purpose, if you know what that means
hmm
I think class 9th
My social teacher said this lesson in my school.
But I understood more in this video.
Edit: What is happening in my comments?
if you think either your teacher or this "intellectual" lecturing here are telling you the truth then my friend the problem is with you that without ever cross-checking their blabbering you believed them right away... they are efficiently doing their job of spreading bourgeois propaganda and disorienting laymen like you and me.
there was a time when even i tried "to know and understand" communism through UA-cam. we get to know the truth only when we read Marx Engels Lenin Stalin Mao ourself, only then can we understand what Marxism is, along with revolutionary practice ofcourse.
my advice to you is to start reading everything yourself and find a revolutionary group of marxists around you (not cpi, cpim, cpiml-lib, or trotsyists).
i seriously and sincerely started studying human history, dialectical materialism and historical materialism and volunteered with RWPI to know what is the essence of marxism leninism.
@@atharvs1 Lenin, the guy who distorted Marx?
@@abhi95934 How did he repudiate marx, O person who understands marxism better than all Marxists
@@atharvs1 🤣 itna gobar likhne ka time kaha se milta hai,
Why did Nazis say they are Socialist?
Amazing explanation by Rathi sir❣️
Awesome explanation brother.
Love from Bangladesh ❤️
Content has always been great, but editing & animation is phenomenal.
Everyday I notice that the thumnail is changing
1st day : The man was not wearing any glasses
7 hours later : He put big eyes on him
2nd day : He is wearing Thug Life glasses
Update no. 3 : Now he is showing Victory sign(✌️) 😂😂
Keep updating 👍
@@riyachoudhary6195 sure😂
🤣🤣 true
It's not a normal man, it's the great Karl Marx
@@daisuketakahashi5872 yes I already uploaded my comment 😂
Dhruv .. make more videos in this series please
Marvellous teaching bro... Now my mind is all clear to understand what communism actually is. Thank You so much!
New format looks really good! Could have described a bit about reforms made by EMS Namboodiripad who led India's first democratically elected communist government in Kerala. The land reform and education bills brought by his government were ideas directly borrowed from Karl Marx.
Exactly
Sadly lost in dirty politics.
He should be respected but I won't because of his pro China remarks
yup, thanks for reminding that point ( even though i only heard about that nd dont know the details )
@@albinjt1 he did that on radio
Sir. My all doubts now got cleared after 27 yrs. Best education video indeed. 🎉
pak chin jarmni Dikh Raha 4g me Karodo garib ko Sains Se Atanki Videsho me Sains Vala Robot lutera
😂❤
If it's true then you aren't really educated
😂😂
Nice explained please make more videos like understanding of political theory, and also normative and empirical theory.
1. 0:24 A new video series on basics
2. 0:48 Communism Definition
1. 1:03 Example on 2 men
2. 1:23 What audience will think about it
3. 1:39 Structure of communism is: Money less, class less, stateless. Means of productions are owned by labor.
Actually today i realised how interesting history was during school times.
Just the thing was that we didnt got right teacher to do so
Which made us think that history was boring🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
P.S Now i am a science student
I never thought that as I didnt listen to the teacher and studied on my own
you too didn't read the history books otherwise u would not have said this.
Hmm 😄
@Sameer Ahmad bhai dharam nahi badla h isne 😂😂😂😂😄
Yes
19:40 Amazing Job Editor Manav Kwatra 🔥
Also great research Vijeta Dahiya 👍
Vijeta is my brother 😎
@@vijaydahiya6378 really?
@@supremeleader5516 yes dost.. you should have guessed by the name..vijay vijeta
@@vijaydahiya6378 hmm
Very simplistic explanation of difficult concepts❤🎉
Best way to understand political science what a way sir that you had tought so impressive.
Bhakts be like: Finally, Dhruv Rathi exposing his propaganda
😂😂😂
Kon
But all dictators come from liberandu ..
@@namanchawla6188 yes
@@namanchawla6188 exactly
You are going to become a true teacher to all the students of 🇮🇳 India
noo!
not at all... he's outright lying about almost everything here in this video
asa teachar ho to bachhe ka future nark ho jayega😂😂😂
Superb sir ji 👏👏👏👏itna Sara Gyan to books pdkr aata jo ki koi nhi pdna chata .. thankyou so much such videos sir ..very informative content.
I finally have a clear idea on what communism is thank you soo much Dhruv Rathee
It's a coincidence that currently I'm reading The Communist Manifesto...
I don't think so
please do read it fully... you'll understand how much this stupid pseudo-expert is lying
@Abhi Raj पढ़के तो मुंह खोला करो! तुम भी और महान इंटेलेक्चुअल श्रीमान राठी जी भी
@@atharvs1 Ohhhh, thank goodness! It is sooooooo horribly and ridiculously wrong. Going through the comments section I felt alarmed that so many people will actually take this video as accurate explanation.
@@radioactivedetective6876 and thus we must attempt to tackle such bourgeois libbu propaganda with counter arguments or by exposing their lies.
I am working as a lecturer of political science and i must say that you explained communism simply. I share this video and suggested my students to watch it so they can know more about communism.
@@aratirao9007 tu uski patni hai kya
Best video for students who r Preparing for Compatative exams..❤❤
Wow it was really helpful.
Thanks a lot providing us these knowledge
Karl Marx should have written a disclaimer in his book, Dont try this at home school or anywhere
True
Ayushman bhav
Awesome bro
True🤣
ha ha
Congratulations 9th class students,
Today you know everything before eveyone
Tomorrow is my history test. And I have this topic. 😅😅😅😂
@@anusmitaroy6869 bro ur school mine is also tommorrow Sst exam
@@anusmitaroy6869 nope it's a general vedio wouldn't ever help you get even average marks since it's simply more of an opinion based vedio NCERTs are fact based
Haha i am in 9th syd and i was thinking the same.
April me mera 9th hoga
I have been watching Dheuv Rathee from 6 months. I gani much knowledge thanks sir ❤❤
❤
Communism has erased caste based discrimination from West Bengal
Lmao sure pakistani
Dhruv bhaiya , this is awesome kind of video, 1 am a19 years old student, i am following your channel since 1 year and i learnt many things and still learning. Thanks bhaiya, 🙏
since nhi lagate 1 year se pehle
for lagate hai
@आर्यन तिवारी U are saying this maybe because you support some political party that he doesn't, same reason you dislike AAP govt, Just imagine why don't you have any problem with bihar govt because your party is tied up with that but in reality AAP govt is better than bihar govt, same rule apply with youtubers, Just follow what's beneficial for you only, not what your party believes.
This is amazing.
It reminds me of the those days when i used to study sst, back in 9th and 10th.
You have very good knowledge of human society in of terms economic, political and civilízation .
Outclass really cleared this concept by outstanding way
Can we appreciate the fact that he never clickbaits us!
Why you are spamming everwhere
Hey ! Xavier. I'm your big fan.
Same comment xavier bhai... Pichle video pe bhi
Yup, certainly we could
Can we appreciate this guy for comment everywhere by "Sanskari Word"?
DEKHO BHAI, Chahe koi kuch bhi bole Dhruv ke khilaaf, you have to admit, no one can teach You Political and Geography better than him🔥🔥.
My school teacher crying at the corner 😂😂.
Excellently explained 👌
I truly said, I have been thinking about it for the last two-three months. I will dedicate my life to unite all the three countries.
I have felt in love with the animations, video editing, sound effects and other extremely small details. This is too awesome video editing, Salute to the editor.
Then check out
Rj bucket list
Kriti chow
Mongo boi
short feedback to the editor of the video. Please avoid putting the sound effects in the video. It is a bit annoying
Best thing was d way he trolled nada!😂🤣with his editing skills
At which time stamp 🤔🤔 I didn't find any thing like that
@@adityabhagwat9074 not in this, past videos
He hired team to do these things, he already said in the blog channel 🤑🤑
Thanks Bhai, we will definitely support you, you carry on
Dhruvrathee you are doing excellent.iam from Pakistan your work is appriciable specially with written English translation.keep it up .