TAMRON VS SAMYANG - Which is the better 35-150mm f2.0-2.8? ENGLISH 📷 Krolop&Gerst
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
- With the coverage of 35-150mm focal length at such an open aperture of f2.0-2.8, Tamron has really introduced a new standard for E-mount with this lens. The focal length range really covers a lot, which is why this lens is amazingly well suited for a wide range of applications. But do not want to talk to much about the Tamron itself, there is already a video out there.
BUT - Samyang has also launched a lens, which also covers 35-150mm starting from f2.0-2.8. Phew!
That is something you first have to imitate. And then also in cheaper, where Tamron as a company is already known for not selling its name. That leads to one unanswered question above all: Which one is the better of the two?
----------------------------------------------------------------
INFOS zu unserem SETUP
KAMERA-AUSRÜSTUNG:
🎥 NIKON Z9: www.nikon.de/d...
⛮ Fernsteuerungshandgriff MC-N10: www.nikon.de/d...
🔎 mit NIKKOR 24-70mm 2.8: www.nikon.de/d...
🔎 mit NIKKOR 70-200mm 2.8: www.nikon.de/d...
🔎 mit NIKKOR 28-75mm 2.8: www.nikon.de/d...
🔎 mit NIKKOR 105mm 2.8: www.nikon.de/d...
🔎 mit NIKKOR 35mm 1.8: www.nikon.de/d...
🔎 mit NIKKOR 14-24mm 2.8: www.nikon.de/d...
ZUBEHÖR:
📹 DJI Ronin RS 3 Pro: www.dji.com/de...
🔈 Hollyland Lark 150: www.hollyland....
💡 Zhiyun FIVERAY M40: www.zhiyun-tec...
⭕ Insta360 X3: www.insta360.c...
----------------------------------------------------------------
Wenn dir das Video gefallen hat, gib uns doch als kleines Dankeschön einen Daumen nach oben und abonniere unseren Kanal, um keine neuen Videos mehr zu verpassen!
----------------------------------------------------------------
Viel der von uns genutzten Musik stammt von Artlist. Für video-affine Menschen ist das definitiv eine sinnvolle Sache, die man sich mal anschauen sollte.
kg-link.com/ar... *
Aus der gleichen Schmiede kommt übrigens mit gleichem Abo-Modell ein Portal für Stock-Videos.
kg-link.com/ar... *
----------------------------------------------------------------
Krolop & Gerst BLOG: blog.krolop-ge...
Krolop & Gerst STORE: store.krolop-g...
Krolop & Gerst WORKSHOPS: workshops.krol...
Krolop & Gerst bei FACEBOOK: / krolopgerst
Krolop & Gerst bei INSTAGRAM: / krolopgerst
Die mit * gekennzeichneten Links sind Affiliate-Links. Die Links hängen mit dem Partnerprogramm von Amazon zusammen. Sie dienen dem potentiellen Käufer als Orientierung und verweisen explizit auf bestimmte Produkte. Sofern diese Links genutzt werden, kann im Falle einer Kaufentscheidung eine Provision ausgeschüttet werden. Ihr könnt euch die Produkte natürlich auch gerne woanders kaufen.
Please produce more reviews in english! This was a very good one and certainly the best one on this topic - and I did watch them all. No other review mentioned any of the things with flare or corner AF. Thank you.
Well, I think this video is a another case of lens sample variation for both the Tamron and Samyang. It happens with even the best of lenses. I've seen seen a number of head to head Tamron vs Samyang written tests and videos that show different resolution results at the different focal lengths, they are basically tied. I do think your finding of the Tamron having a wider 35mm angle is not a sample variation issue, it's been verified elsewhere.
On the Samyang autofocus performance, I wonder if you were testing the lens with the updated 2.0 firmware? BTW, the two lenses have different optical formulas in terms of number of elements and groups: Tamron 21 elements-15 groups; Samyang 21 elements-18 groups, so there is no copycat issue there.
Not to add any thing to the disscusion witch is better...but from an artistic point of view I rather have the flaring Samyang...This is the same as with the Sigma 105mm f1,4 Art and it looks so much better that the 100% clean look...And I use flashes to correct the light in those situations.
Lovely and amazing breakdown. For those who are able to get a used copy of the Tamron and have ability to return of the are issues, it's an amazing lens to add to your kit.
awesome review. the best VS i saw on the net. thanks 🙏 i appreciate your impartiality and balance
Thanks a lot for the very good and in-depth review. After watching this I decided to buy the Tamron lens.
Thumbs up just for doing this review in English
This is the video i was looking for. A fair comparison between this lenses. Thank you for the video.
Really nice seeing you also filming in english 😊excellently done!
Excellent review, thanks for doing it in English for us non German speakers. Glad I bought the Tamron.
First of all, thanks for the honest review, and the review in English. most of the 'reviewers' were sent their copies my samyang and as such, almost all of them painted the 'rosy picture' of this lens. But after watching this reveiw, I can safely make my decision. Plus, the Tamron lens is on sale here in Sweden with the difference between the two dropping down to almost 250 euros. so naturally, I would go with the Tamron.
Best comparison I've seen on the topic. Thanks!
I am a wedding photographer and I have a Samyang 35-150mm f2-2.8. The only thing that really bothers me about it's the size and weight, but this problem also has the tamron 35-150mm, which is only 40-50g lighter. This lens worked perfectly for me at 3 weddings. If I were very rich, yes, I would buy the tamron, but for my budget, I'd rather buy a samyng and another lens for the difference in money or another camera
in California, avg wedding photographer makes 8k per gig
@@yottooverland Can't complain about the price. Sony 70-200 costs 2500$. This replaces it and the 24-70 for the most part. I'd rather buy the Tamron over the Samyang. The 5y warranty alone is worth it.
Thanks for the video. Clear concise and in English too!!! I think ill go with the Tamron. Too many advantages. If i ever see these 2 for sale used i would always look at the tamron listings first as it is optically superior
Thanks...I'm saving for one of these,...I will go for the tamron then.
Your english is great. Thx for the review.
Great review.
Great video. I was looking forward to this detailed comparison.
Thanks you for this. I have even looking for a video like this for awhile.
Thank you for the review, indeed not many similar reviews available, one even telling Tamron is worse.
This should be enough to ignore the new lens - I have Tamron and it's already losing quite a bit in AF compared to 70-180mm, but I'm in the process of switching anyway due to the wider short end; losing even more in AF capabilities would really hurt. If only the zoom ring was not so stiff and rough... this was my main hope for Samyang, that it is easier to turn, but other reviewers were already negative about that.
Hey there, wonderful video! Very quality :)
I notice you had a selection based on a grey / brown dog running. I'm most interested in these, because I'd like to know how the Samyang's Autofocus tracking performs on subjects which move very quickly. Very important for sports / bird photography and videography. Let me know if you have any tests for the Samyang based on this, many thanks :)
Great video mate❤
The colors on the Samyang are way more natural. Why Tamron allways has that disturbing warmth / yellow tint ? I had the 35-150 Tamron- Perfect picture quality but because of thecolors I went back to GM 24-70 ....
Good review. I found exactly the same testing Samyang.
Fantastic video. I am just starting out doing paid portraits and headshots with the A7r4 and a7r3 as a back up. Which lens would you recommend?
If you are just starting out with portraiture, get a sony 35mm f1.8 a sony 50mm or 55mm f1.8 and a sony 85mm f1.8 you will not need more than this for portraiture and headshots
Amazing job comparing those two lenses. As you mentioned it at the beginning of your review, there is not yet enough information available on those competing offerings, and your comparison is very professional and balanced. Danke!
Merci!
Thanks!
Definitely it was worth TQSM
“It’s not the gear”
🤜🏽✨🤛🏽
Very good review
Very interesting lenses considering the times when a 35-70mm f/2.8 was a "wow".
Wait, how and when such a lens lens would make a positive impression? 24-70mm seem to be an old standard, and it's a considerably longer range.
35mm was always very problematic. I used to have Sigma 24-135/2.8-4.5 long time ago, that was a great range. I wish somebody would make 24-135/2.8.
@@USGrant21st we don't have even 24-105mm F2.8 yet, there are patents as I recall, but nothing physical. I guess getting to 5.5x constant aperture zoom could be also hard to achieve.
@@marcinmrzyglocki 24-135/2.8-4.5 was not hard to achieve, 28-200/2.8-5.6 is also not hard to achieve. Zoom range is not what makes it difficult, it's having f/2.8 at the long end. The lens would have to be big, perhaps as big as the 35-150/2-2.8, but people are willing to accept that. Btw, the rumors were Tamron was bringing 35-150/2.8 to the market, a much smaller and lighter version.
@@USGrant21st I did not see any rumors for constant 2.8 and depending on the ergonomics (well, basically the zoom ring) I would get such a lens - range is great, the difficulty of use not.
Tamron is king 😊
Martin, now you have the opportunity to prove your linguistic balance. For starters, I'd be happy if you used just one German word in your English test report, when you already have ten English words in your German test report, only a tenth of the amount of English words you use in your German test report, of Leichtigkeit (lightness), Luftigkeit (Airiness) and Stimmung (mood) of the picture results of an optic you could speak and explain the German words in English, if you dare, but there I have so my justified doubts, not even in the carnival time, in which much is permitted, something like that would occur to you macho with the exemplary self-control. Only the other way round it is natural for you, why? If we Germans are constantly confronted with very many English terms by you, it could be interesting for some English speakers to become familiar with very few German terms. For example, that BMW does not stand for British Motor Wagon. Praise to whom praise is due: Your English review is free of marketing superlatives.
Bist du besoffen?Warum machst du Videos auf englisch?Ich hab die letzten 3 Jahre kein Video von dir verpasst, aber.....?!
Bitte sei fair, er hat diesen Test zuerst in Deutsch geliefert.
Es ist sein gutes Recht, seine Prüfberichte auch in anderen Sprachen zu veröffentlichen, um mehr Geld für seine unabhängigen deutschsprachigen Prüfungen zu generieren.
Just watch it anyway and be done; there was a German version already with most likely the same content and conclusions.
you have a problem man
Willkommen im Jahr 2023