I actually really like Casey as a temporary member, he adds his own take to the songs, like the "let us sing!". I don't think he's better or worse than Joe, he feels like his own thing.
Yeah I love the weird shift in energy Casey brought compared to Joe. Casey also seems more expressive in general than Joe which isn’t good or bad in itself but funny after hearing that Joe perfoms like an Easter island statue most of the time
I never disliked casey shea as a temporary replacement for joe, but I always found it really funny how different the two are based on personality/style. joe has to be one of the most difficult people to replicate
My favorite parts The baby crying Casey pouring all his heart and soul into the “Let us sing” Casey getting attacked by a mic Zubin almost snapping his back trying to sing into the mic And Casey trying to sing into the mic and failing
i saw the last joe hawley year at the bowery ballroom on his triumphant return right before the end. i have photos. the best band in the world. the incomparable april smith and the great picture show opened for them.
if they play good day ever again can we all just PLEASE bring a piece of lettuce to throw on stage when they start singing “let’s us sing ! let’s us sing !” PLEASE IM BEGGING YOU
@@naturalketchup1791 they released a musical masterpiece then just left. And it's so unfortunate because they were incredibly unique, intelligent and creative individuals. They Just didn't get the attention or following that they deserved
Exactly how popular were tally hall back then? They were in lollapalooza which i assume is a big deal, and good day got huge but they were doing a lot of small gigs, at the same time in every live performance i see the crowd is always very enthusiastic and sings along with all the songs, so i wonder if they were really popular even back then.
Matt G from Wikipedia: In their 2010 March tour with Jukebox the Ghost and Skybox, it was reported that Joe Hawley had unexpectedly backed out of the tour. Hawley was replaced with Casey Shea, who wore a black tie. On March 25, 2011, the band announced that all five original band members were still together.
What response? Anyways, I think TH wouldn't be the same without joe. He literally wrote the songs that were popularized these days. That includes: Ruler of Everything, The bidding, and Hidden in the Sand. Also, Hawaii Pt. II, most songs there are written by him which also is really popular album that also introduce the band to a wider group of audiences. He may have done terrible things, but I hope that doesn't invalidate what he did for the band and the music he created.
joe hawley: *let us sing*
casey shea: LET US SING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lettuce sing
@@realnerd9lettuceing
Letter Saint
Ladder Send
He went all out on that
let us sink
"I'D LIKE TO SAY HELLO AND WELCOME YOU GOOD DAY THAT IS MY NAME" *crying child*
Yeet the child
That child was me.
*I WAS A PAID ACTOR.*
@@TheDemonSociety are you fr? if so you’re a living legend
@@subparcrow No, I wasn’t haha. That would’ve been funny though!
good day vs crying baby
tally hall: starts playing
small child: my time has come
şčŕėæm̥
sorry that was me
@@calimber wait, really?
@@calimberCLIMBER
@@Colled SUNNY
2:43 that kid was NOT having a good day
underrated comment
He was mad because they got his name wrong, it was not good day
i love how they play through all the hiccups and just laugh it off
TH: *starts playing*
That baby: I am extremely displeased with this set of circumstances
I actually really like Casey as a temporary member, he adds his own take to the songs, like the "let us sing!". I don't think he's better or worse than Joe, he feels like his own thing.
Yeah I love the weird shift in energy Casey brought compared to Joe. Casey also seems more expressive in general than Joe which isn’t good or bad in itself but funny after hearing that Joe perfoms like an Easter island statue most of the time
@@SlamDunkPyro
Rob 😊
Zubin 😊
Andrew 😊
Ross 😊
Joe 🗿
Tally Hall Reunion after all???? (Heavily Coping)
Nothing beats joe
I thought it would sound weird without Joe but Casey is a good replacement. He has a different singing style but its still good nonetheless.
replacement is a strong word
:)
*substitute
LET US SIIIING
replacement is the right word
I never disliked casey shea as a temporary replacement for joe, but I always found it really funny how different the two are based on personality/style. joe has to be one of the most difficult people to replicate
CASEY KIDNAPPED JOE!
LOL you are that UA-camr that explained about Tally Hall.
that baby knows
TALLY *casey*
LOL i love how chill that performance is
LET US SING!!! 🔥🔥
@@artsmyname15 okay maybe not chill lol it just seems like a casual performance that got really chaotic
Why does everyone dislike casey, he did good.
I agree. He did what he could.
1 he's not joe 😡
2 he's emo 😡😡
@@ппилфий No
Casey’s voice is energetic and happy it’s nice, especially when it’s those “let us sing” moments
He's great tbh, the "let us sing" felt weird and funny but that's his way I guess XD
Honestly though, this is pretty wholesome. They're all just vibing together.
THE sixth secret tally hall member
Technically 7th, you forgot Bora
@@timeforamunch2616 8th you forgot about jason
@@Deezboyofficial he was the mail guy, right?
@David Broonic that's what I was thinking
@@Deezboyofficial 9th you forgot rick lax
That child really didn't like that first line 😧
My favorite parts
The baby crying
Casey pouring all his heart and soul into the “Let us sing”
Casey getting attacked by a mic
Zubin almost snapping his back trying to sing into the mic
And Casey trying to sing into the mic and failing
ok but who brought their child to a tally hall concert
I wonder if this kid know they were in this video is so strange has been so many years ago
I would tbh
WTH is tbh?
@@Loui3star to be honest
@@kat_dna thank u
the kid who cried is most prob 11 rn. I wonder how they're doing
More like 13-15
kinda weird that they might find this video one day, one very good day
AND I WONDER AND I WONDER
THE WIND KNOWS, THE WIND KNOWS (sorry-)
4:58 andrew (:
it mightve been so great seeing them live!!
7 years ago..
i saw the last joe hawley year at the bowery ballroom on his triumphant
return right before the end. i have photos. the best band in the world. the incomparable
april smith and the great picture show opened for them.
@@RaelNYC care to share these photos?
@@daeskiz4031 How so? They're really good photos, I use a real camera on manual.
@@RaelNYC Idk, if they are physical photos just snap a picture with your phone
that baby is like 12 now
13 now even
Fr lmao
yeah he's in high school probably (13-15?)
HELP NO THIS COMMENT HITS TOO HARD.
@@ItzPokemon Real
This was a fun mess.
0:51 *lemon demon*
song starts at 2:39
Thank you so much
if they play good day ever again can we all just PLEASE bring a piece of lettuce to throw on stage when they start singing “let’s us sing ! let’s us sing !” PLEASE IM BEGGING YOU
LMAO
@@HarpiGorillaTag IM ACTUALLY BEGGING IT WOULD BE SO GOOD
@@tailseatingnails i dont think anyone should bring anything to throw on stage
I can't believe dababy was in the audience
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
@@x.a.t.u hehehe >:)
he didnt get a shoe thrown at him either!
i know its been over a year since this was posted, but clicking the replies on this comment made my internet crash
@@sirholychicken3632NO WAY!!!
4:35 chill bro we're letting you sing
LET HIM SING.
This has to be the most unsyncronized tally hall performance ever lol
omg I can’t believe it, it’s Nega-Joe
N WORD!!!
N WORD!!!
N WORD!!!
N WORD!!!
N WORD!!!
Nobody outpizza the house baby, house always wins let’s goooo
me 12 years later thanking Pizza House for Improvising 👏👏👏
aw man i wish the mics were working
i could barely hear what they're saying ;-;
nvm it was funny seeing them take turns on the 1 working mic lmao
omg it’s tally hal
Casey’s vibe is immaculate in this!! LET HIM SING!
It’s too bad Andrew’s barely showing up on this video
give my boy some more screen time! ross too!
ross :(
whoever that child was i hope they remember this concert now
He's now like 14 or 15
@@elsapo4345 didnt know thats cool
lettucing
I agree
EVERYONE LOVES A POTATO MONKEY
I STEPPED ON GUM! I STEPPED ON GUM! OOOHOHOOOO!
LET US SING@@TrentonDoesStuff.
@@tempestasvilgilia birds & bees & television,
@@TrentonDoesStuff. cardboard houses, x-ray vision,
@@tatterytmany little silly rhymes
Thats just disrespectful man that baby needs to learn lol
But at least it went with the song 🤭
CASEY DID ABSOLUTELY AMAZING AT THIS PERFORMANCE
tally hall reunion when :(
two members probably wont show up if that happens
tomorrow (real)
@@tally_hal damn, you're everywhere on Tally hall UA-cam. but I suppose that makes sense
@@wash8533 who?
@@LucyWest370 PROBABLY
This is so scuffed I love it
John Lennon joined the band?
that's casey shea, a temporary substitute for joe hawley
wonderful
i like how they handled the near mic disaster lol
That kid was not having a good day
I wonder what colour Casey’s tie is, you can’t see it too well in the video
Black
Probably black or gold.
child was NOT having a good day ❌❌❌❌❌ we need to improve him, COMDEMN HIM TO THE HOUSE OF ONLY TALLY HALL MUSIC
Yo u got discord? I wanna talk to u about tally hall
@@Roll_dude yah, i do
@@whyamitomato what us the discord
@@Roll_dude bubblelovesskye2763 is the user
can't believe joe died
Joe-visible
4:10 rip
Does casey have any independent music?
F Joe
He does! Here's a link to one of his songs
ua-cam.com/video/jfBtKFGMgPY/v-deo.html
@@aleatorioda_meia101 Big words since u look exactly like him
@@escapefr0mslender What? Look's like me? Not on the face of the earth
@@aleatorioda_meia101they never specified which joe
2:39 when they start singing
nah im all for the stage banter
I got scared lmao they synchronized perfectly
The child's cry at the start is gold
**LET US SING**
Tally Hall is Shamrock Freddy approved!
emo joe arc
starts at 2:39
I'm gonna cryyy
I wanna see them in concert T_T
I'd travel all the way to usa to see them perform fr
They've been disbanded for awhile I think
@@daisysabashed9661 yeah theyve been on hiatus since 2011 i believe.
@@naturalketchup1791 they released a musical masterpiece then just left. And it's so unfortunate because they were incredibly unique, intelligent and creative individuals.
They Just didn't get the attention or following that they deserved
@@daisysabashed9661they said there was a huge possibility of a third album sometime in their lifetime. Let’s just hope that time is soon though.
The baby probably cried because Joe was't there
Exactly how popular were tally hall back then? They were in lollapalooza which i assume is a big deal, and good day got huge but they were doing a lot of small gigs, at the same time in every live performance i see the crowd is always very enthusiastic and sings along with all the songs, so i wonder if they were really popular even back then.
That child wasn't having a good day
Zubin without his glasses feels so wrong
wheres joe
cancel tally hall they make babies cry 😡😡 #tallyhallisoverparty
#canceltallyballs 😡😡😡
#canceltigerhalloween
#christianmomsagainsttallyhall
#canceltallysatanicalls
Where's Joe?
Matt G
from Wikipedia:
In their 2010 March tour with Jukebox the Ghost and Skybox, it was reported that Joe Hawley had unexpectedly backed out of the tour. Hawley was replaced with Casey Shea, who wore a black tie. On March 25, 2011, the band announced that all five original band members were still together.
man dead wtf
Joe Mama
@@Lellistair that doesnt answer the question, but apparently it was because he had a restraining order
@@LucyWest370what did bro do
Oh no, no Joe
The little man was not welcomed good day
look at zubin man, hes as hot as always.
I mean if I’m being honest. If I was in a room with someone name being “Good Day” I be scared shitless with stranger danger
what happened to joe in this performance?
he cannot join the tour for forseen circumstances and he was replaced by Casey Shea (The black tie) on tour
he died😔🪦💔
even if Joe is very good at singing I’ve come to like Casey cause he’s interesting and hasn’t done anything problematic as far as I know
2:37
3:29 CORONA
aw shieeeet
Corona walk or sleep or eat 😳
"He never liked to speak CORONA walk or sleep"
Casey is a good replacement but where is Joe?
He had to do something regarding a restraining order at this time I think?
@@SlamDunkPyro oooh alright
@@xoashgames5634don’t quote me on this but I’m pretty sure he violated that same order too lmao
Joe left the chat
Casey Shea is his substitute.
CASEY!!
what a fine babe (casey)
Joe :((
Joe mama
Sorry i had to
What happened to joe?
He had taken a break during this time for personal reasons
He died 😢
@@unapersonaenyoutube1740no?????
Nooo it’s not the same without joe
the baby is not a fan of tally hall apperently
Wait where's Joe?
He cannot join the tour for forseen circumstances and he was was replace by Casey Shea(The black tie) for the tour
@@Evil_Andrew_Horowitzbrown right?
Casey should replace joe permanetly
For real
Casey and Bora >>>>>>
You guys haven’t even read the bands response or the doc have you
@@Koichi-Kun no, this comment was before the response came out
What response? Anyways, I think TH wouldn't be the same without joe. He literally wrote the songs that were popularized these days. That includes: Ruler of Everything, The bidding, and Hidden in the Sand. Also, Hawaii Pt. II, most songs there are written by him which also is really popular album that also introduce the band to a wider group of audiences. He may have done terrible things, but I hope that doesn't invalidate what he did for the band and the music he created.
YES THIS IS DONE. 🤖
(Rob-ot)