man i feel so bad, they are so incredibly good but you can tell they are so nervous that they didnt perform at their best. im sure they beat themselves up over this one. its a shame
I've gotta say, I can't imagine how hard it would be to pull off a live performance that good on a talk show. Really! Time is so limited for sound check, there is usually NO rehearsal time at all. Just the set up of all their stuff must have used up whatever time was allotted for "Musical guest set up." I somehow missed this band when they first were on the scene. I actually heard about them from my kid a few months ago! I'm a professional musician and teacher and retired classical/opera singer and from my perspective, knowing how any kind of TV thing is organized due to time constraints and union contracts, the fact that they sounded as good as they did is astonishing. As I watched this I was thinking if I'd been in the audience for that taping I would've been completely blown away!
I guess they're too used to the album version. The live version of a song always has slight mistakes, especially with songs like this that are REALLY hard to perform live.
lol i find it funny how aggressively they keep strumming their guitars. and boy oh boy andrew is going *hard* on the keyboard, headbanging and everything
All these years later this is still infinitely better than the Ruler of Everything performance where Rob and Zubin’s mics weren’t even turned on lmao in hindsight the haters were ingrates in comparison
bruh this is a very standard live performance, they did incredibly considering they have 3-4 people singing at once? whoever hates on this has never seen a live performance in their lives lmao
With all the modulations and tempo changes and everything this song does, it's gotta be pretty hard to play as good live as the studio recording. I thought they did awesome!
MARVINS MARVELOUS MECHANICAL MUSEUM - IS FACING THE WRECKING BALL, The City of Farmington Hills has pretty much nailed Marvin's Museum for demolition as the landlord wants to demolish the whole TALLY HALL or what's left of the mall and put in a MEIJER'S and 3 major stores and three stand alone restaurants near Orchard Lake Rd. His fate will be known February 12, 2024. @ 7:00 PM City hall 31555 Eleven Mile Rd, Farmington Hills, MI 48334. You wanna save the mall this is your last chance to let the City you want to Save Marvin's.
This performance was really good, ppl are just saying bad stuff because they were nervous. Imagine having to play for a whole live TV show, which gets aired, and performed in front of a lot of people already. It takes talent to keep going while you’re nervous.
man i feel so bad, they are so incredibly good but you can tell they are so nervous that they didnt perform at their best. im sure they beat themselves up over this one. its a shame
I've gotta say, I can't imagine how hard it would be to pull off a live performance that good on a talk show. Really! Time is so limited for sound check, there is usually NO rehearsal time at all. Just the set up of all their stuff must have used up whatever time was allotted for "Musical guest set up." I somehow missed this band when they first were on the scene. I actually heard about them from my kid a few months ago! I'm a professional musician and teacher and retired classical/opera singer and from my perspective, knowing how any kind of TV thing is organized due to time constraints and union contracts, the fact that they sounded as good as they did is astonishing. As I watched this I was thinking if I'd been in the audience for that taping I would've been completely blown away!
@@ellam3nno you seem really cool, I thought they did great too :D
Can you post where it went bad? I feel like this was great?
I love this performance unironically!
how did you even post this comment 13 years ago, this video was literally uploaded 9 years ago
3:21 Joe Hawley observes the audience to identify the immortals
Checks to see if anyone else can see the Zimbabwe songbirds
@@kerchow1837 Lol
He Looks Like he Wants to Murder Someone…
He saw banana man
obviously they're nervous, but i dont think it was affecting joe that much. his face and eyes are very relaxed.
lol he always looked so tense in liveshows to me
man cant even keep a straight posture
@@tally_hal me too man, me too
Zubin is just vibing, so calm
Joe shouldn’t have been too nervous considering the fact that he was a child actor
@@Wdast despite his career as a child actor he looks really nervous or stressed out on most of their live performances, especially the early ones.
Why do people hate this preformence? There are lots of harmony it's gotta be hard! They did really good for this!
I guess they're too used to the album version. The live version of a song always has slight mistakes, especially with songs like this that are REALLY hard to perform live.
I love this version sm
i think because there's not a ''let us sing!''
lol i find it funny how aggressively they keep strumming their guitars.
and boy oh boy andrew is going *hard* on the keyboard, headbanging and everything
omg it tally hal
All these years later this is still infinitely better than the Ruler of Everything performance where Rob and Zubin’s mics weren’t even turned on lmao in hindsight the haters were ingrates in comparison
Yeah exactly. Compared to the other live preformances I think this one was one of their best
bro my favorite part was when zoobs said " "!
bruh this is a very standard live performance, they did incredibly considering they have 3-4 people singing at once? whoever hates on this has never seen a live performance in their lives lmao
Zubin looking at Joe for reassurance at that one part
THIS IS SO GOOD ITS LITERALLY IDENTICAL TO THE ALBUM VERSION
ok its not that good
@@sbubbt2318 you're wrong
I mean it's good but it's not that good
I mean, what do you expect, they were nervous
3:30 lettucing lettucing
lol
also HENRY!
Letter c letter c
With all the modulations and tempo changes and everything this song does, it's gotta be pretty hard to play as good live as the studio recording. I thought they did awesome!
Yeah, a song like this would be extremely difficult live. Brave of them to attempt it!
What are people's problem with this performance? i seriously think its really amazing
Andrew is just jamming
Lmao
i think Rob was the most nervous
Yes.........
Andrew is just vibing with his aggresive head bops.
MARVINS MARVELOUS MECHANICAL MUSEUM - IS FACING THE WRECKING BALL, The City of Farmington Hills has pretty much nailed Marvin's Museum for demolition as the landlord wants to demolish the whole TALLY HALL or what's left of the mall and put in a MEIJER'S and 3 major stores and three stand alone restaurants near Orchard Lake Rd. His fate will be known February 12, 2024. @ 7:00 PM City hall 31555 Eleven Mile Rd, Farmington Hills, MI 48334. You wanna save the mall this is your last chance to let the City you want to Save Marvin's.
I don't get what's so bad about this performance.
They are nervous during the show
@@daviduarte8208 I know they were nervous but I thought they did pretty good, outside a few moments
This song is fucking hard to let alone compose but play live without screw ups...I think they did perfect. This takes ALOT of talent
@@lotusnaturals1897no they performed good day
@@daviduarte8208i would be too bro
the voice of Joe are perfect in this presentation, in the others he always sound cracked ;(
I WAS NOT EXPECTING JOE TO DO THAT SOUND AT 2:11 TOO OMG ༼;´༎ຶ ༎ຶ༽༼;´༎ຶ ༎ຶ༽༼;´༎ຶ ༎ຶ༽༼;´༎ຶ ༎ຶ༽
i love the silly color tie band
thwm so silly XD %
@@hotcrazy15 real
I ACTUALLY LOVE IT? THEY DID IT SO WELL!!
there's nothing wrong with this performance!!
Oooooh. Andrew is so cute with his being into it and everything. *wiggle* I heart him. Also, they were all nervous, Joe is better at covering it up.
*wiggle*?
Uhm
@@LucyWest370 2009 die hard fans
This was uploaded 8 years ago and this comment 14? Wow dude time traveling
This is the most 2009 internet comment ever
3:21 scary joe
.............yes............
He’s judging you 🫣
i love rob so much,,,
Me too--
Real
Lettucing Lettucing Lettucing Lettucing!
Leracing
Lettucing
Lettucing
LET US IN
lettucing
no he was definitely saying lettucing
They’re nervous in this.. ;-; I can tell. Don’t judge them on this one!
2:54 who cutting onions in here-
what are people talking about? this is literally one of their best performances of this song in my opinion.
3:30 HENRYYYY!!!!!!!!!!
YEAHHH HENRY
What's it actually called? I just remember it as Henry
@@sumayyahqamar2007 vibraslap
3:28 lmao 😭
Very good performance you other guys just keep stepping on gum don’t you geez!
No
Yeah no...
No, i keep stepping on nuts
3:30 HENRYYYYYYYY
This performance was really good, ppl are just saying bad stuff because they were nervous. Imagine having to play for a whole live TV show, which gets aired, and performed in front of a lot of people already. It takes talent to keep going while you’re nervous.
how are we getting 12 year old comments on a 6 year old video
probably privated and then brought back or unlisted for a bit
@@goopyhead fair
왠지 모르게 드럼 소리에 집중이
I LOVE IT I LOVE THEM ALL AND THEIR MUSIC
the camera got a bit too close to andrew at two points in the video
En cuales?
@@NombrePro 0:48 3:11
yall chill, this got unlisted w out the OP knowing, and a comment brought it to their attention so they fixed it. THATS why we have 15 yr old comments
Gyatt
SICK
Quien esta enfermo?
@@NombrePro tu MADRE lolololo
@@dead_acc_t me troliaron nooooooo
Begins with an M, y'all
This is good tbh!!
If y’all are wondering, this is the main reason people don’t like this performance 3:09
Joe still sounded amazing but zube and rob were just a bit off
Fr especially rob
joe sounds the exact same as the studio release lol
I like to say good day 😊😊😊😊❤❤❤
poor rob :(
crayg furg the sun 😎
CRAIG FER-GUS-S*N!
Joe had an outstanding performance and carried with andrew.
1:02
wah wah
EAAAGH
🤠
Andrew carried it tbh
FAN DE TALLY HALL Y RULOMBO????? PIDAN UN DESEO PAPUS
@@califato_almohadeballDamn 2 fans de rulombo y tally hall, epico
@@califato_almohadeball 3 FANS DE RULOMBO Y TALLY HALL 😦😦😦😦😦
2020
didn't realize I commented on this a year ago oh wow, hi me
2022
2022😢
2023 ⚰
@@NoreooeroN 2023 Part II
why is this hidden?
No idea! It's now public.
@@travismaynard cool
In the sand ;)
They should have sung ruler of everything lol
No one knew Ruler at this point, Good Day was the only song people knew them for. I mean, it was in the sims.
this makes me nervous. i love tally hall, but they seem so tense and the beginning made me cringe.
id say a mix between weezer (awesome band) and a band like Barenaked Ladies (pretty good)
I'd say Tally Hall
Ewww weezer no
@@rob162100 the original comment is 12 years old
@@Buttgun ewww weezer still
@@rob162100 it really feels like a 12 year old comment
😢
👍👌👏👏👏
why is joe eating the microphone
crazy food
Does anyone know when this aired?
wonder about no things
Huh
periods and lots of question marks
ughhhh i miss that stupid color tie band
3:30 HENRYYYY!!!!!!