Cluedo But, THE KILLER IS STILL AMONG US! | House Rules
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 кві 2024
- If you want to come and see us LIVE at the UK Games Expo, you can get your tickets here: www.ukgamesexpo.co.uk/events/...
Don't forget to join the DOMMUNIST PARTY! norollsbarred.com/product/joi...
Check out norollsbarred.com/ to stay up to date on upcoming board games courtesy of the channel's own DAN 'THE TRUTH' LAYTON.
For uncut Board Game Club episodes, King's Dilemma Campaign eps, exclusive Clocktower eps, access to our Discord and MORE, join NRB's PATREON / norollsbarred
Subscribe to our brand new RPG channel: Chaotic Neutral
/ @chaoticnrb
Our gorgeous board game table was custom built by GeekNSon. Check out their store using our affiliate link and get a FREE Dice Tower with each purchase of a table: bit.ly/NoRollsBarredXGeeknson...
Follow No Rolls Barred:
Instagram: / norollsbarred
Twitter: / norollsbarred_
#BoardGames #Tabletop #LetsPlay
UA-cam Channel Comments Policy
We appreciate the comments and opinions our viewers provide. Do note that all comments are subject to UA-cam auto-moderation and manual moderation review. We encourage opinions and discussion, but harassment, hate speech, bullying and other abusive posts will not be tolerated. Decisions on comment removal are made by the Community Manager. Please email us at support@wrestletalk.com with any questions or concerns. - Розваги
Love the implication that the Butler is not only assisting the murderer by knowing who he is but also carrying a gun to shoot people who make wrong accusations 😂
It fits with one of the movies endings lol
"Why shouldn't we get away with it?"
You know what would have been pretty funny? None of the players were the killer. The butler did it (obviously).
@@ColonelSandersLite okay that would be hilarious because paranoia would have made them turn on each other while the butler watches
"Blood on the clock tower but we're actually just playing Cluedo."
Blood on the Clue Tower
@@MultiClassGeekclue on the clocktower
Cluke on the bloodtower.
@@scyobiempire4450 Glue on a clocktower
@@noahclaycameron Clock on the Gluetower
Laurie suits the "Potentially shady butler" look so well. I'm absolutely here for it
Absolutely. He's got the 'curt bow of either professionalism or seething resentment' nailed down.
There is no one I more wanted to be professor Plum than Jon, so it seems like so far the casting choices have been fantastic!
And I must say, looks rather dashing in that suit
Potentially? :P
he feel like he's the type of butler to have cleaned up some bodies in his day for sure.
I love the fact that mr Chelsea is just a Pokemon that can only say his own name
Chelsea!
Chelsea!!
Chelsea!
Chelsea!
Chelsea!
Tilly and Jon both played a very cool game. Tilly figured it out and purely needed to buy time to walk across, and then Jon bought her that time by hiding that he had Miss Scarlett. Fantastic.
Maybe it's just because I play the game a lot, but I thought that Jon continually guessing Miss Scarlett would have been a dead giveaway that he had the card in his own hand.
@@scdwolfboy I agree, because Sullivan knows that Jon must have seen Miss Scarlett the last time he guessed, the only reason to continue guessing the same card is because it was correct (which Sullivan knows it wasn't) or because you have it in your hand. In this variant especially since you don't know who has the card and thus how far around it got so your guesses would be literally be valueless.
While correct, it was possible for Sullivan to think Jon kept asking for Scarlett cuz Laurie kept showing him everything BUT Scarlett. Either because Laurie could be trying to help Sullivan or just unravel Jon -both equally likely 😂
@@SorwestChannelbut jon guessed billiards room and rope alongside Scarlett. Sully knows jon must have been shown miss Scarlett
@@Siennarchist oh did Sullivan choose how to kill Mr. Boddy? I must have forgotten that info if so. I assumed Sullivan only knew he was the killer, not the place or weapon.
It was at right this exact second that I realized the joke about the victim in Cluedo being named "Boddy", that went right over my head as a child
Just wait til you realize for the title!
In America, he was called Mr Black
I thought the victim was called Dr Black?
@@MrSamBerrett1 I checked this on Google and he was Dr Black in the UK and Mr Boddy in North America.
I don't know if this is a "back when I was a kid" thing or a British thing, but the dead man was always Dr Black when I played. If it's British, we lost the pun with Mr Boddy but kept one with Cluedo.
Laurie looks like he's about to tell me what worlds I'll be entering in The Twilight Zone.
...or the soup-of-the-day at the Restaurant at the End of the Universe
Where do I sign up to have Laurie tell me both of these things?
Of course Dom is Colonel Mustard
Getting killed first just freed him of any obligation to play the game, leaving 100% Doing A Bit.
I said the same thing 😂😂😂😂😂
Expectations met and exceeded! 😃
Comrade Mustard
A coward's character
Dom needs to remake Cluedo where all weapons are different size boots and boot treads. Dom presents "Whack Whack"
Okay but it should obviously be called "Shoedo"
@@DasGanon Shoe-Done-It.
The Gum-shoe Game
Tilly initially having a hard time keeping track of everything then immediately honing in on Sullivan is such a mood.
If you ever play this again, I would recommend a change. Dead peoples' cards can be shown to anyone in the room where they died only, rather than being publicly visible. It would create a location the killer could target.
nice 👏
That’s wicked.
+
You know, you would think you’d be able to tell that the murder weapon was the rope just by looking at the body.
“Oh, he seems to have been strangled to death.”
“Indeed, but with what? Could it have been this gun?”
“Perhaps he was strangled with this bottle of poison? “
In reality the body is just horribly mangled and was assualted with each of the weapons as a diversion technic to make it harder to find the cause of death
Also, you should easily be able to learn which room it was.
"Okay guys, our host has been murdered. Now lets go find the body"
@@travisperkins9920 I think the idea is that the killer can just. move the body.
@@travisperkins9920 The body (of Body, in some versions) is found on the central staircase, which is why many versions of the game show the chalk outline there
Dom has now pretty much assumed the position of House Rules co-star alongside Sullivan
House Rules began as a Co-op hosting and is certainly the best that way.😊
Yeah and its a great addition. It was always strange how the series started with having only sully in the videos.
@@loganb7081 💀 lmao, oof
Upgrade tbh
@@loganb7081wait I genuinely have no idea what happened to the other guy?
Massive props to Laurie, who did a splendid job playing the butler and moderating the game!
“Cluedo, but they’re zombies and the victim keeps coming back to life”
"Ms. Scarlett, with the revolver, in the Ballroom."
"The zombie goes down."
Or.
"You fumble looking for a gun. Unfortunately, you don't see one and are promptly eaten."
@@dragonkingscott the more I think about this idea, the more I realize it’s just Resident Evil 1
Some "House Rules" are just entertainingly silly, but I actually think that's a legitimately fun alternative way to play Cluedo. Great job 👍
Not at all balanced, but fun lol
Jon Gracey as Professor Plum is strangely spot on
Also, very handsome
They all kinda fit their roles very well
If you’ve watched the movie, he looks like Mr Green
"It's a cowards weapon!"
"I'm what's called an armchair colonel."
I adore this character. If you play again, please bring it back.
Laurie as Lordsworth? Instant like. Tim Curry would be so proud.
I think it was lozworth.
as in, like, lozzie (a common nickname for Laurie, to my memory)
I thought the butler's name was Wadsworth in the Clue movie.
@@killer_rabbit42 It is, but the L is for Laurie.
@@killer_rabbit42in the play, that’s what it is
Can I just say, it should be a house rule going forward in all episodes that the players must wear an outfit that matches their piece to make it easier for plebs like me to follow along!
omg trex for monopoly let's GOOOOOOOO
I spent ages thinking Jon was super forgetful for some reason, like how is he not remembering he has miss scarlet, not realising the strategy at all. Absolute genius play, props to Jon.
All of the House Rules that I've seen so far have been trying to make a game unworkable or painful to play, so no one would want to play them a second time. This actually has potential for replay, or being a proper game. I like it.
IDK which ones you've been watching, but that's rarely ever the case. It's always for fun and to raise the stakes in a different kind of way, not to be purposefully unenjoyable or "painful".
I mean, I guess the Monopoly is "painful"... but still for the fun of it. Otherwise why would they continue to do it over and over again?
@@KaiLucasZachary Connect 4 begs to differ lol
That little smirk Laurie gave when revealing the location - Blood on the Clocktower viewers know what's up xD
I'm not sure if the hidden cards were pre-planned, but I love the fact that "With the Rope in the Billiards room" is exactly how the maid (who in the original game was Miss White) was killed in the movie!
Movie? :o
@@SuperMichael996 oh yeah theres a cluedo movie, and it has multiple endings too
Well as it’s American it went by Clue
That's what I thought too when the cards were shown !
I love to imagine these house rules as an actual game that you gather other people around to play, but then you tell them, "Oh we play it different in my house."
Mostly it works. "We do shots with battleship," "We do backwards poker," "We do vibes based guess who." But this one would be such a hard sell. "We do an elaborate 6 person social deduction game, with a GM and everything."
Jon played that amazingly. Bluffed not knowing the killer the whole game.
of course it was the Billiard Room. it was the Billiard Boyz
Billard boyz is a dfferent era one is banished from online and the other is rarely on the main channel.
Sometimes the House Rules episodes are just silly fun, but every so often it vastly improves the game. 100% I would play this version as a party game. Well done whoever did the design.
The fact that Tilly called it while still not fully understanding how the game works is amazing
I really enjoy this adaptation of clue/cluedo - the added blind factor really increases the difficulty of what is often too easy of a game.
Laurie is trying to gaslight everybody in to thinking it's Sullivan, even though HE is the butler! It's always the butler!!!
They should have brought Sherkey Houses, he'd find the real killer. (The cat)
This is now one of my favorite House Rules episodes. I like the goofy episodes, too, but I really love when you guys create something that makes me go, "I wanna play that!" What a fun way to elevate Cluedo :)
Maybe its just me but the murderer seems very underpowered.
The most broken thing is someone seeing a person card as that basicly confirms that person is not the killer and the information can be trusted. I think a person card should only be shown if the other 2 where shown already too someone too make it the hardest too find out.
Maybe i missunderstood the rules but how can the murderer figure out what card someone is holding?
Also if someone gets murdered maybe the cards shouldnt be revealed but put into the hands of the other players.
Amd finally maybe the murderer may be allowed too see who else in the ropm as him
I believe it is the guessing part of the killer as a win condition was really hard. It just felt really hard to guess what room they are in and a card in their hand, which makes Sullivan killing two people impressive. While having enough rounds to kill everyone in this game, we seen at the end of the game guessing what room they are in is the hardest part. So there was plenty of time to collect information on who did it.
Things I would probably change is the killer will know how many people are in the room with him, not who with him/her just how many if any are in the room with him/her. Secondly, the killer doesn't have to reveal the cards in their hands. This removes a lot of information from the game for them to spread misinfo. Though when theyh kill of another player the cards become unlocked. So as it comes down to the last innocent can start narrowing down the missing information. A third thing I would do is spread the dead player's cards face down in different rooms like the two rooms that players can check if they are in that room.
Something for the innocent players, is when they check the card it will get revealed to the table as public information the next round. Meaning the have a turn to move before the killer gets a chance to kill them.
Stuff I would experiment with is the killer being able to kill someone in the same room as them without the guess of a card in hand. Maybe the killer can swap the face down cards on the board with one from their hands or remove the card from the board completely. Thematically it being the killer planting or destroying evidence.
i think a possibility of adjusting this is such that the killer's hand is always the other players' cards. that way the non-killers can't immediately know who's trustworthy by being simply dealt that card. you could also adjust the rules so that when guessing, players are always shown weapon/room (if possible) before being shown suspect (if possible).
Laurie ALWAYS looks better without a hat
I couldn't see much with the glare..
Note, I do also agree with the still looking good without a hat
💯 agree, ditch the hat Laurie! Unless you're cold, then that's understandable. We need better aircon in the game studio! #FreeTheHead
Nice to see a House Rules with more people. Always nice to see Blair involved ❤
Jon's strategy of guessing his own card while looking for the location, and pretending to be sus of Tilly thus confusing Sully of the cards was brilliant.
The "coward's weapons" bit is maybe my fav bit in all of NRB. idk why but it just snuck past all my defenses and absolutely slayed me!
I tried watching from Tilly's perspective, by closing my eyes for everything else besides the group meetings. I had no idea what was going on. I guess I'll need to watch it again, without closing my eyes. The reveal was exciting though.
Jon continuing to rock the purple suit.
I really enjoyed this one. I hope this becomes a regular one, like Dom's Monopoly
That was amazing please do more stuff like this, I was literally cackling this entire episode with Dom's tough army guy who's actually never gone to war, sullivans chelsea? and tilly blair and jon are always amazing. Can't forget the amazing gamemaster/butler.
I must say I LOVE the outfits in this episode
I mean... In regular Cluedo, the killer is still among the players. It's just entirely irrelevant, and the player who is the killer still wins upon finding the killer/room/weapon combo.
Laurie looking mighty dapper in a suit. In fact they're all looking very fine in their outfits
"Oh, someone dropped this gun in the hallway, come in handy when someone gets a question wrong." -Laurie the butler probably
Clue/cluedo is genuinely one of my all time favorites. I have a special edition that disguises itself as a book
I bet it was Tilly, with the knife in the studio. Because she's tired of Dom and his attacking her during Monopoly But...
Tilly, with an ice pick.
Can we appreciate what a great job Laurie did as the butler/host 💖 and also everybody looked amazing, especially Tilly
I love how everyone knew someone died the moment Laurie said he was pleased to announce... 💀💀
I'm glad Sulley explained the name. I was confused at first and thought this was a diff game from clue 😅
After watching some, I realized it is a slightly diff game...
I didn't know that 47 was a butler in a fancy manor
I love how well dom gets into his characters
So fun seeing NRB play Cluedo, thank you for this awesome video and loved seeing the House Rules twist, it adds a great, fresh twist. 😊
love the idea, although i'd love to see an updated version where it's a little bit more balanced for the killer!
Haven't finished watching the video yet, am loving it all so far.
This is such a cool house rules twist on the game. I would maybe add in an accomplice to this take on the game so it makes it a little more balanced for the 'guilty' team. Maybe have the 2 cards in the 2 locations be 2 character cards and maybe 1 other innocent person has a a character card - therefore the players have to risk something to get the massive benefit of trusting another player. Otherwise it seems a bit too easy to secure confirmation chains. But I may be totally dumb with this thought. 😅
I really love the House Rules version and everyone played so well. 😊
In love with this house rules! As someone who finds Cluedo boring to replay, but has a girlfriend that loves it, this looks like a fun middle ground for us!!
Why am I not surprised Dom is Colonel Mustard
You can't fool me. Miss scarlet is just Harry peeps wearing a dress
Nah, looks more like Mrs. Dave.
I love this version of Clue(do). So good. Removing the roll-and-move and making it social deduction is so clever. 👍
What a brilliant move by Jon. Well done.
I genuinely think this is 1000x better version than the original (although that's been true of every "House Rules"). Was a great watch!
This was one of the best house rules ever (behind communopoly!)
Not sure what prevents them from just giving all of their information immediately, the only thing that keeps them from winning almost immediately is if someone other than the killer has their own card, then you’d have to pick between those people. (Or if it’s one of the two cards.)
for the same reason you don’t give away all your information in regular clue. if everyone tell the table all their cards, there wouldn’t be much of a game left, and the next person up would automatically win. yes, they’re technically playing as a team, but the threat of death means that there’s still motivation to be the correct guesser
@@mvwinf if you're playing selfishly I suppose, but no its not even remotely comparable to normal clue in that regard lol. One is a team game in which you all win by giving your info, the other is in individual game where you want to share no info
@@imdadirtydan I think in this case, any given information would help the killer as well. not to find the truth, of course, but if you guess plum hall wrench and you say you saw hall, then the killer knows you’re actively in the hall rn. and if you say you saw wrench, then the killer can narrow down their list of people who might have that card. if someone corroborates you, then it’s already down to just two people. I do see what you’re saying, though - it’s hard to turn a solo social deduction game into a team one
@@mvwinf The killer doesn't have time to kill all of them because they're already found out. That's the fundamental issue with the game. They have almost all of the information to begin with and there's no reason not to share it other than possibly dying, which isn't an issue if you just figure it out using all the info to begin with. Even if they don't do this immediately all the dead players cards get flipped, so by the end of the game there's no way you don't have the information to figure out who it is.
@@imdadirtydan this feels like a very utilitarian view of the game to me. in social deduction games, there’s always a chance anyone could be lying. if you all go around the table and say your cards, there will be discrepancies, and it may not be obvious who is the cause of said discrepancies. so you wouldn’t be able to automatically trust any information you’re given. also, not least of all, that just doesn’t sound very fun? if the game was only figuring out who the murderer is using the cards you’ve been given, it would be werewolf with layers of unnecessary steps. part of the fun is playing detective, even if it’s not the most efficient gameplay strategy
I love when they play dress up/larp
Dang this was fun, it's a pity they usually only do a game once, because i would really love to see them do this again!
I see absolutely no reason why they can’t do this often with more tweaks to balance gameplay a bit more. Absolutely enjoyable!
House rules truly makes my day! Can’t wait!
This is a version of Clue I've always wanted...
the color-coordinated outfits are _absolutely so good_
Laurie looks like a butler in a Guy Ritchie film who secretly is a weapons expert.😂
This was really great, all the details were simply perfect and everyone was made to play their role. Awesome!
Laurie has grown into the role so well, I'm glad he seems to be enjoying it! Amazing episode, would love to see this one done again!
10:15 that Stamford Bridge joke had me in tears😭 and now I can’t stop thinking of a football themed Clue game
25:30 Three Scorpios, very brotherly...the Scortrio?
4 Scorpions and 1 Virgo (Blair).
@@lucone2937a scortet then!
I'd see this again. One of my favorite house rules.
"Colonel mustard, where would you like to go?" Immediately shown two back to back Popeyes Chicken ads.
12 seconds in, Dom makes a Father Ted reference, immediately thumbs up the video
Hilarious they used terrorscape for this. Speaking of which, more terrorscape please!
I don't think I've seen Sully or Blair so dressed up before - they look great! (As does everyone else, of course)
Missed opportunity to declare themselves “Scorpibros”
Clue/Cluedo was not originally called 'Murder' it was based on a parlor game by that name. The board game was originally called 'Cluedo' which it still goes by today.
I think it's a joke about the number of times they would get comments about Monopoly originally being called The Landlord's Game.
i JUST NEED THIS CLUEDO SET WITH THE FULL MANTION NOW, NO ROLLS BARRED KEEPS increasing my cravings
Colonial Mustard discussing mustard is my favorite part
This has actuly made cluedo more interesting honestly i think this is the first house rules where i could see myself playing the game and it be fun XD
I always liked how in some versions The Butler is named 'Diddit' (although of course ironically he's never a suspect)
Dom being a Scorpio surprises no one
I have been eagerly waiting for them to take on an actual social deduction version of Cluedo and they truly did it justice. Loved it! I hope we get to see another game of this some time.
Having played American clue all my life, this is a wild version. Like, the game feels soooo much slower but much more tense.
It is a crime that dom is innocent honestly as a certified piglet I am furious
Very good!! Damn I'd love to see more games of this version but maybe because its become a proper social deduction game which are always great with this cast
I've suggested this variation on the reddit and long before NRB, it seemed like a fun twist on the game of Clue, but I was never smart enough to figure out how something like that could work. This is brilliant.
you should check out Cluedo Conspiracy
Nice to see Jon embrace his purple-fellow-ness 👀
I hope they'll play this again!! It was so fun to see them all having fun and in character- and if they were able to play with six people, oh goodness, it would just be so baller
33:11 that subtle headshake...Dom knows
Yes... because he just saw someone give a guess and not get any cards back in return.
Normally House Rules intentionally ruins games. This time you made it WAY better.
Laurie as a butler fits shockingly well. Definitely not a character for Dom at least 💀
Just want to comment and say how awesome Jon's nails are and the pink goes really nicely with his purple(/plum coloured) suit. 😊👑
This was so much fun to follow along with! Please play more of this!
Hey wait a minute! This isn't Blood on the Clocktower!
That was fun! We needed a round 2.
Thanks NRB.
Dom and Sully have to be my favorite people on NRB hands down. They’re so hilarious