You know, we need more fan-made content on this theory. I would love to see a full chilling story on what would happen. Especially with the other engines' reactions to this shocking deception.
Oh man, I never liked the idea of two Henries, but that was before I thought of what good story potential it had. This video was fucking fun, a great what-if 👌
I personally don't believe the two Henry theory and I personally see it like Henry had a rebuild and had the boiler removed from the smoke box to prevent killing him, then stannier took a black 5 which had had a severe incident and was going for scrap and maid a boiler with less taper so the LNER smoke box fits a LMS boiler and then to help sir topham pay crew for the work he sold Henry's chassis and cab +tender back to greasly who rebuilt it for an A3 or a custom V2 and then Henry came back as a black 5
Why would the LNER want anything to do with the chassis, cab, and tender from a failed engine, built from stolen blueprints (and possibly parts as well), for Gresley's A1 Pacifics?
ooookkk uhmm that happened the ending thats the shed where the real henry is ok now i know the truth i would rather help the real henry and not the fake one this is going to give me nightmares know😥😥😥😥😱😱😱😱
My whole thing was that Henry II was just a random Black 5. Having a special name wouldn't really fit. Plus I haven't really heard the name Eugene in any Thomas thing before lol
While I hate the two Henries theory, this is amazing! This proves excellent fan content can be made from bad theories! If you want another example of excellent fan content of this theory, check out WildNorWester’s take on this theory!
My personal theory is that Henry 1 was sent to crewe round about the same time stannier made a prototype of the LMS Stanier Black 5's Henry 1 was attempted to be fixed but there were far to many problems, however Topham had an idea Replace the smokebox door on the Black 5 prototype with henry's and it worked, so henry 1 was taken in a failed engine but bought out a lms prototype
I like how it's left to the viewer to decide what the dream means. Is this engine really Eugene, and he fears that the original Henry will return one day, or is this still the same Henry we know and love, and has been having nightmares about his fear that he would be replaced after his accident with the Flying Kipper?
2 henreis theorry????
hello jt
hi rondog
Hey rondog don't know if you saw this but hi
I really hate you. stop getting in my way.
@@Rondog248uh dude, you're talking to yourse- you know what nvm
You know, we need more fan-made content on this theory. I would love to see a full chilling story on what would happen. Especially with the other engines' reactions to this shocking deception.
I don't like the take on the two henrys theory although I still feel Henry when to crew for a complete overhaul and came back as a Stanier Black 5
It's "Crewe", not "Crew".
Same
@@Anthony684 autospell most likely did it
Oh man, I never liked the idea of two Henries, but that was before I thought of what good story potential it had. This video was fucking fun, a great what-if 👌
Please. I want a sequel. Your execution of the 2 henrys theory is great, & i want to see you expand upon it. 11/10.
Who would Think that a simple thing that Awdry write would cause the 2 Henry Theory in The First place.
This was amazing. The fact he had an eye patch was amazing. You did great modeling the eye patch and scar. Keep up the amazing work!
I personally don't believe the two Henry theory and I personally see it like
Henry had a rebuild and had the boiler removed from the smoke box to prevent killing him, then stannier took a black 5 which had had a severe incident and was going for scrap and maid a boiler with less taper so the LNER smoke box fits a LMS boiler and then to help sir topham pay crew for the work he sold Henry's chassis and cab +tender back to greasly who rebuilt it for an A3 or a custom V2 and then Henry came back as a black 5
Wow
Why would the LNER want anything to do with the chassis, cab, and tender from a failed engine, built from stolen blueprints (and possibly parts as well), for Gresley's A1 Pacifics?
This was a really interesting take on the Two Henrys theory
I think the original Henry went a little bit insane. I did like the eye patch he had after the Kipper accident. Great job Ty. 👍
I love how it keeps you guessing. Is Old Henry the villain, or is it New Henry (Eugene)?
Hi, I realy like your vídeo, and I want to make it for my channel, but on Spanish, can I adapted?
Claro, ¿cómo debo enviarte el script?
ooookkk uhmm that happened the ending thats the shed where the real henry is ok now i know the truth i would rather help the real henry and not the fake one this is going to give me nightmares know😥😥😥😥😱😱😱😱
This is what happens when you have 2 Henry’s on your layout
how is this even posesbole i thought henry 1 was scrapped but stil alive i thought he was a ghost and haunted henry 2s life for god knows how long
I mean the videos good but it would be more fitting if Henry ll was called William, after William Stanier.
My whole thing was that Henry II was just a random Black 5. Having a special name wouldn't really fit. Plus I haven't really heard the name Eugene in any Thomas thing before lol
Henry as an LNER A1 Pacific and a GNR C1 Atlantic is being villain.
Loved the customs, voicework and script!
Would you consider making sequels to this? I would love to see it be a whole quest to put an end to Henry 1
The whole thing is that it was dream, leaving it a little ambiguous
@@tyhappyproductions ohh ok, I thought maybe that would have been like some kind of vision trying to tell henry that it will happen
Man this was ... Idk how to Say It like It was like sensation of .....
I don't really buy the whole two Henrys theory thing, however I have to admit that this is really cool!
:0
Hen hen 1 return??
I loved it
How did he get that scar
Clever adaptation to the 2 Henry theory
FNAF HENRY!!!!
While I hate the two Henries theory, this is amazing! This proves excellent fan content can be made from bad theories! If you want another example of excellent fan content of this theory, check out WildNorWester’s take on this theory!
I love this take on the 2 Henry’s theory!
This is good
Good Work With The Video.
can I adapt this?
Sure
My personal theory is that Henry 1 was sent to crewe round about the same time stannier made a prototype of the LMS Stanier Black 5's
Henry 1 was attempted to be fixed but there were far to many problems, however Topham had an idea Replace the smokebox door on the Black 5 prototype with henry's and it worked, so henry 1 was taken in a failed engine but bought out a lms prototype
I am so happy 🤠😎🥰🤗😍 that herny and gordon in the video.
I want to see a sequel to this
Eugene 😂
Stop, just stop.
I like how it's left to the viewer to decide what the dream means. Is this engine really Eugene, and he fears that the original Henry will return one day, or is this still the same Henry we know and love, and has been having nightmares about his fear that he would be replaced after his accident with the Flying Kipper?
That’s for me to know and for you to find out :)
@@tyhappyproductions Of course, but I have a feeling that this is something that will remain a mystery, forever.
@@tyhappyproductionsWhere did you find the creepy wind ambiance from in the credits?
So, Henry 2's real name's ''Eugene''?
Hmm interesting. Very amazing!
There are two Henrys
So fucking dark
Amazing dude
3:43 HENRY THE GREEN ENGINE, YOU WILL BURN IN THE FIRES OF HELL!!!! 'Evil laugh echoes as the backdrop shows the burning fires from hell'
Why does Henry 1 have a eyepatch on him with a scar?
From the flying kipper crash
@@tyhappyproductions was he eye injured from the crash or something?
@@locomotivefanproductions2090 yes
😵🥴😵😵😵😵
I hate this theory, there is only one Henry, you can literally REBUILD an engine, just get new parts.
ok