Fabulous performance of this forever-young piece of music. Can't get enough of that harmonic and polyphonic overabundance with that substrate of romantic expression. What a genious Schoenberg was! Thanks for the upload!
I’ve always wished that this style of composition had lasted longer before eventually moving on to the atonal masterpieces. I also love what came next , particular Pierrot Lunaire, the violin and piano concertos, the string trio, etc. but this frantic ‘on the edge’ of tonality was fantastic.
Thank you ( and not only because it’s International Thank You Day ) for Descriptions. Life makes corrections. Cristian Macelaru and WDR Symphony have proved it again.
I looked for the longest performance online and it payed off handsomely. Wonderful playing and conducting. My only objection is the pull-up at the very end!
This isn’t the original version for 15 instruments. But they are playing so skillfully and tight that it has the clarity of the chamber piece. I often find this piece, one of my favourites,sounds muddy with larger forces. This is fiery!
Fantastic performance of one of the 20th century greats. Weird rit in the final 2 seconds though, but the rest was the best I've ever heard the piece played.
I played first horn in this wonderul piece of music many times with the Ensemble Modern on tour. There were several conductors, notably Ernest Bour, and Friedrich Cerha. We did the original version with 15 instruments which I find much better. One of the best performances was in the Kölner Philharmonie - with its fantastic acoustic. That performance was one of the high points of my career as a hornist. This larger ensemble loses some ot the immediacy and intricacy of the composition. Schoenberg knew what he wanted!
It's not Op. 9b, as in that version Schoenberg added trombones and trumpets. This is Op. 9 with expanded strings, an alternative sanctioned by the composer but very rarely heard.
Google amca özür dilerim bir daha din muhabbeti yapmıycağım telefonumu koru lütfen dünyadaki bütün dinlere saygı duymalı ben taksın ben yazmadım haçlı da yazmak istemedim dikkatsizliğmden
@@philzmusic8098 the Berg violin concerto is beautiful. but mostly for that bit when the Bach chorale emerges out of the atonality in the woodwinds) and works so well against it).
Fabulous performance of this forever-young piece of music. Can't get enough of that harmonic and polyphonic overabundance with that substrate of romantic expression. What a genious Schoenberg was! Thanks for the upload!
Thank you for your kind words!
Nice performance! Wonderful to hear an expressive, unobstructed sound!
Thank you! We're glad that you like it 😊
I’ve always wished that this style of composition had lasted longer before eventually moving on to the atonal masterpieces. I also love what came next , particular Pierrot Lunaire, the violin and piano concertos, the string trio, etc. but this frantic ‘on the edge’ of tonality was fantastic.
Thank you ( and not only because it’s International Thank You Day ) for Descriptions. Life makes corrections. Cristian Macelaru and WDR Symphony have proved it again.
2. Stelle: 9:20
3. Stelle: 11:14
Unglaublich schön 💫
I looked for the longest performance online and it payed off handsomely. Wonderful playing and conducting. My only objection is the pull-up at the very end!
This isn’t the original version for 15 instruments. But they are playing so skillfully and tight that it has the clarity of the chamber piece. I often find this piece, one of my favourites,sounds muddy with larger forces. This is fiery!
Thanks!
Fantastic performance of one of the 20th century greats. Weird rit in the final 2 seconds though, but the rest was the best I've ever heard the piece played.
4:37
Thanks a lot. Need this for an audition right now.
Hektisch...
aufregend
Perfect performance
Impressed with this conductor, nothing faked.
Thank you 🥰
Звучит как Малер в квадрате , которого сжали до камерного состава. Потрясающе
Awesome!!!
Thank you! 🤗
I played first horn in this wonderul piece of music many times with the Ensemble Modern on tour. There were several conductors, notably Ernest Bour, and Friedrich Cerha. We did the original version with 15 instruments which I find much better. One of the best performances was in the Kölner Philharmonie - with its fantastic acoustic. That performance was one of the high points of my career as a hornist. This larger ensemble loses some ot the immediacy and intricacy of the composition. Schoenberg knew what he wanted!
Amazing! Greetings from Cologne!
L'onestà intellettuale nella composizione musicale, fu per Schonberg talmente primaria da fargli rischiare di arrivare allo "spartito bianco".
Is that conductor Brendan Frasier?
No, it is our chief conductor Cristian Măcelaru.
18:50 oh no ...
12:52 the a-clarinettist should have waited the high natural b the violinist plays.
Vielleicht opus 9b, führ Gr orchster. Urfassung ist für 15 musikanten. Macelaru ist toll
It's not Op. 9b, as in that version Schoenberg added trombones and trumpets. This is Op. 9 with expanded strings, an alternative sanctioned by the composer but very rarely heard.
nicht ganz 9b, trotzdem schön
16:37 das Horn-Thema soll mehr espressivo klingen, meiner Meinung nach.
To me the summation and high water mark of symphonic art, the too little known key piece of classical music
Google amca özür dilerim bir daha din muhabbeti yapmıycağım telefonumu koru lütfen dünyadaki bütün dinlere saygı duymalı ben taksın ben yazmadım haçlı da yazmak istemedim dikkatsizliğmden
When an artist strives to be "expressive" all the time, it comes out as mud. Even Mahler and Tchaiikovsky are not so shameless.
Your comment is extremely opinionated, incompetent nonsense
Something like YT commenters.
there's just no architecture here. just an endless sonic goo.
@@petermerelis D'accord. From his tonal works, such as Gurrelieder, you can see that Schoenberg was simply not a very good composer. Berg was.
@@philzmusic8098 the Berg violin concerto is beautiful. but mostly for that bit when the Bach chorale emerges out of the atonality in the woodwinds) and works so well against it).