How To Weld Sheet Metal With Flux Core Wire For Beginners | Flux Core Welding Tips And Tricks |

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 гру 2021
  • Today we will be going over some tricks to weld thin gauge sheet metal like body panels while avoiding wrapage. I go over 2 different techniques and several tips so make sure you watch til the end to get the full picture! Machine in question is my omnipro 220 welder set up with standard single phase 110v power. Wire size in the video is .035. settings were set to the lowest the machine could run, 90 IPM and 15v.
    #Fluxcorewelding #weldingforbeginners #howtoweld
    How To Weld Sheet Metal With Flux Core Wire | Flux Core Welding Tips And Tricks |
  • Авто та транспорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 163

  • @meta4282
    @meta4282 2 місяці тому +4

    With flux core i haad to weld a thin panel on a vw beetle. Placed a soaking wet rag behind the panel to act as heat sink to prevent burn through. 🔥 tshhh

  • @stephk5255
    @stephk5255 2 роки тому +54

    One of the best things I learned from welding sheet metal like this is patience. You can't rush it. Thanks for the video!

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +2

      Thanks for watching another one! I appreciate it 👍

  • @mpikas
    @mpikas 2 роки тому +63

    A few things that may be helpful:
    - the wire is mild steel, it will not harden. Trimming it works because when you cut it with a set of dykes or most other cutters you end up with a point which concentrates the electric potential making the arc jump much more easily than from the rounded glob you get at the end of the wire. The reason that the weld bead appears to harden is that modern automotive pannels are mostly made of "high strength steel," which will hardne somewhat and that is what you're heating/welding with the wire
    - welds shrink as they cool, when you put your first tack in it shrinks pulling that end together and the other end apart. Try putting your first tack in the middle and you should avoid that.
    - thinner wire puts less heat in the weld. Flux core is available in .030" which would make this easier.
    - aluminum or copper backing plates make it easier if you hold them against the weld. Even better if you can clamp to them.
    - lowering your gun angle decreases the heat you put in the weld and some welders do much better at low power settings than others. Once tacked, you skip around like you did on the second weld, but with the smaller wire, lower gun angle, backing the weld... you should be able to get away with running 1/2"-1" or so beads instead of tacks. That will prevent the gaps that you had and still control warp.

    • @ggazzara1115
      @ggazzara1115 Рік тому +5

      I'm going to attempt a repair on a separated 60 Chev. step-side tailgate. I like the idea of using .030 flux core wire. Thanks for the suggestion Mark!

    • @johnmeola1189
      @johnmeola1189 Рік тому +1

      Insightful comments thank you! I learned a few tips from your remarks and the video. You guys should be instructors add a technical school

    • @lawncuttingplusdelta
      @lawncuttingplusdelta 8 місяців тому +3

      @@ggazzara1115flux core works … best tip I got was thinnner the metal , more stick out …. You can stitch by barely striking and it will fuse without blowing holes ….. and it puts hardly any heat in the metal

  • @lihatkesini
    @lihatkesini Рік тому +14

    here in my country, almost every small shop just using MMA/stick to weld everything, even 0,8mm steel plate, or 0,6mm round/hollow bar.. they usually using 6013 with 2.0 mm, and practically tack-weld everything too.. it'll be provide enough penetration since it runs at higher amps, but with some good handling, we can control the heat distribution too..
    for welding thin plate, I usually start tack from the centre, and then tack at both end.. then tack it again at half distance between, half distance, half distance, until the distance between every tack just got approximately an inch.. brush every tack from any slag then continue to tack again to close the gap between every inch distance.. but keep the distance between your work, I usually skipped two-three gap when closing tack, and repeat it again after finishing a row.. for some work that doesn't need any plate to fully welded, some worker just leave those one inch distances tack with putty-work..
    still, we must consider that labour cost in my country was very cheap.. most small shop worker just got 10-12 usd per day here lol.. so that's why this methods only exist in third world countries.. otherwise, we should use other time-effective methods..
    anyway, you have a very good videos in your channel sir.. just subscribed
    #I'm sorry english wasn't my first language

  • @benbrowne3467
    @benbrowne3467 Рік тому +8

    Just came across your channel. Seriously- thanks for the tips. Brand new to welding, your videos are the most helpful I’ve seen. Appreciate your time.

  • @campion05
    @campion05 2 роки тому +14

    Agreed the opposite tacks end to end do work well, add a bit of compressed air immediately after the tack and this helps against warping. More time consuming but if its worth welding like a car body panel its worth taking the extra step. Also I keep the wire waste at a minimum by not breaking off after each tack, keep a fine metal file on near by and scratch the tip of the wire on the file which opens up the tip again for the next tack. This trick has saved me a bunch of wire. I do the same when I'm stick welding. I'm not a pro. Just a regular Joe.

  • @austinpfoster
    @austinpfoster 2 роки тому +5

    Thank You! This is the EXACT video I needed!

  • @gingersquatch9844
    @gingersquatch9844 2 роки тому +1

    I was taught to do a single continuous weld between the tack welds... this makes much more sense!!!

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому

      Depends on the situation but stich welding warps the panels less for sure 👍

  • @jw11432
    @jw11432 2 роки тому +13

    I was able to do 26ga sheet metal with my Titanium 125. It was incredibly tedious and forced me to turn my amps all the way down, but it worked for my purposes.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      Its really difficult, especially for newer guys

  • @dawargames8798
    @dawargames8798 2 роки тому +19

    Just wanted to say thanks for the effort 👌. I usually don't respond, but I wanted to let you know that it is helpful, especially for us amateurs, every little bit counts !!!

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому

      Thank you! I do have more videos on welding for beginners in a playlist here on the channel so feel free to check it out if you need more help!

    • @jackhertzler8402
      @jackhertzler8402 2 роки тому

      73-87 and the truck 9th

  • @aros007z
    @aros007z 2 роки тому +7

    Awesome explanation, pure pro here, thanks!

  • @BearBudgetTurbine
    @BearBudgetTurbine 2 роки тому

    Did some patch panels with my cheap flux core, with results that were not great, but I did it. But now I have more rusty projects, so I ordered a small mig unit. Should make life a bit easier...

  • @evan24v71
    @evan24v71 2 роки тому +5

    That anti spatter spay is amazing!!!

  • @thisismypickle5164
    @thisismypickle5164 2 роки тому +14

    If possible, depends on the situation, you can clamp aluminum blocks on both sides of the weld leaving enough room for the weld torch then weld all the way from one end to the next. Let the affected area and heat sinks cool then unclamp the sinks and the warpage should be minimal or non existent. I realize this is not always possible but when it is it will save a lot of hassle.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому

      Very interesting! I hadnt throught of that!

  • @hvymax
    @hvymax 2 роки тому +5

    Just do 1/4" at a time and move around to minimize warpage. The easiest way to stack dimes is one at a time. Pulse makes things stupid easy. I was stick welding 1/4 panels 40 years ago.

  • @mrhow2712
    @mrhow2712 Рік тому

    Thank you for the amazing info man!!

  • @jameswallace7351
    @jameswallace7351 2 роки тому +2

    Great video it's a big help because I want to start trying to weld sheet metal with flux core

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      Its not hard once you start to figure it out! Just go low and slow and dont try to rush it by trying to weld across. Panels take a lot of time and a lot of tack welds.

    • @jameswallace7351
      @jameswallace7351 2 роки тому +2

      @@NightWrencher thank you I've mig welded before with gas I just want to learn it with flux core I'll keep watching your videos

  • @wangofree
    @wangofree 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks bro for all your welding videos.

  • @keithm.9062
    @keithm.9062 2 роки тому

    Great video, again.

  • @mgs8747
    @mgs8747 2 роки тому +1

    great info. thank you for posting this.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому

      Thank you! There are more videos like this coming out soon so make sure to check back

  • @rbuell1121
    @rbuell1121 2 роки тому +1

    Excellent video, thanks
    GRACIAS

  • @bobbyfischer7028
    @bobbyfischer7028 Рік тому

    Thanks for the tip

  • @Happymacer_P
    @Happymacer_P 4 місяці тому +1

    For comparison it might be worth having a look at what “Bondobilly’ (might be ‘Bondo Billy’ on UA-cam) has to say about flux core welding car body panels. Similar stitching technique but 1” stick out and really hot welds.

  • @f100unibody9
    @f100unibody9 2 роки тому +2

    Great video. Keep up the good work

  • @cuervojones4889
    @cuervojones4889 2 роки тому +1

    That was very helpful!

  • @brentsmith5647
    @brentsmith5647 Рік тому +4

    Brilliant video thank you 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @CMC328
    @CMC328 Рік тому +1

    Good info and thanks!

  • @drizler
    @drizler 3 місяці тому +1

    A piece of scrap copper, I use 3/4” copper flattened with one end left like a handle as a backer if I can. That helps dissipate the heat . Works great as long as you can get at the back.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  3 місяці тому

      I have a little adjustible magnetic copper plate that I like to use as well. Works pretty good 👍

  • @charlespartak2435
    @charlespartak2435 2 роки тому +1

    I started out my project with flux core on 18 and 16 gauge. Lots of heat warping . Once i went to mild steel wire and c25 it went much better .

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +3

      Gas welders are much better for sheetmetal because of the thinner wire. If I was trying to do a profesional job, I would use gas. But for a hobby welder flux core will get the job done

  • @edwardjayfix
    @edwardjayfix 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks!!

  • @shamyjiran
    @shamyjiran Рік тому

    you are the best.

  • @billarroo1
    @billarroo1 Рік тому

    As you progress with the weld bead, use hammer and dolly to flatten it out, as you go, or if you try straighten it at the end you'll have a lot harder time trying to straighten it.

  • @nealart
    @nealart Рік тому

    Thanks!

  • @NerveLindsay4187
    @NerveLindsay4187 2 роки тому +1

    WoW - your a very good Teacher - I subscribed - be checking out all your video's - thanks

  • @master886786
    @master886786 2 роки тому +1

    Vary vary helpful

  • @Literature-ft8ru
    @Literature-ft8ru Місяць тому +1

    How can you weld with fcaw when it's so hard to see your what your welding with a spatter cloud vs. a mig weld which is easy to see

  • @johnverdin6600
    @johnverdin6600 4 місяці тому

    What did you set your wire speed and your voltage to on your machine for flex core welding exhaust pipe????????????

  • @richardritter6025
    @richardritter6025 12 днів тому

    Question for you!
    You say to break of the point… ok
    But do you tack break point tack break etcéteras.. or
    Break only the first one?

  • @ronaldsmith2043
    @ronaldsmith2043 9 місяців тому

    Super genius

  • @BlondieSL
    @BlondieSL 14 днів тому

    I'm not a "welder" but I do weld things as needed. And no, I'm not great at it. LOL
    But I now have a MIG, so it should be easier for me.
    I never liked my stick welder. Too hard to spark up without sticking rod to work.
    Anyway, I wonder, to avoid warping, would it be a good idea to use 2 clamps (or vice grips), one at each end to hold the pieces together, then tack close to, but not touching the clamps and one tack dead center?
    Then once the tacks are done, remove the clamps/vice grips and continue with your back and forth idea?
    Would that help to reduce warping?

  • @kenadams3951
    @kenadams3951 Рік тому +1

    Good video

  • @robertclymer6948
    @robertclymer6948 Рік тому +1

    Hello Again NightWrencher!!! Love and blessings from Michigan. Thanks again for your tutorial and tips. It means a lot to us beginners. I'am in the process of choosing a machine. Thinking of a dual setup that can do Mig fluxcore or (gas) and Tig for aluminum welding. Is that a good choice? Thanks

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  Рік тому

      There are a lot of multi process machines out there. Usually the tig welding attachments are sold seperate so it gets expensive really quick. I would get a basic simple mig machine and start with flux, then move on to gas welding. You can get really nice results with gas welding 👍

  • @TheProchargedmopar
    @TheProchargedmopar 2 роки тому +2

    Ever try a torch? Think Dulcich uses old school method. I love torch welding.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +4

      Its more expensive and less convenient than a little flux core box. There are places where thats the best thing to use but in the majority of situations a cheapy welder works better and easier to use.

  • @mohay583
    @mohay583 Рік тому

    Hi nice video. I am a welding learner and english learner. English is not my mother tongue and i was able to understand 90% of what you said. Where is your accent from ? Thanks dude

  • @johnmacmillan627
    @johnmacmillan627 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks

  • @kenswitzer4133
    @kenswitzer4133 2 роки тому +2

    If you weld this flat on a welding table doesn't it act as a heat sync that helps decrease warpage? Thanks for the informative videos👍👍👍✌️✌️🤙🏻🙏🏻😁👌

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      Yes, that could work but you could avoid all of that by not welding for extended periods of time on sheet metal. The preffered way would be to just go around with tack welds until its fully welded in.

    • @darkshadowsx5949
      @darkshadowsx5949 2 роки тому

      if you can afford the table. also if you can weld flat on the table and not weld your piece to the expensive table.
      it also wont work if your panel is curved and your piece has minimal contact surface with the table.

  • @TheProchargedmopar
    @TheProchargedmopar 2 роки тому +2

    11 views and I'm the first 👍,
    Man, this youtube a tough crowd. 😆💪

  • @bassdaze
    @bassdaze Місяць тому +2

    you warped it by pushing the panels together after you first weld in which you never clamped....

  • @shademe
    @shademe 2 роки тому +1

    I'm a bit lost here, so it seemed as if both ways were a fail if I understand correctly? The 1st was warped and 2nd didn't penetrate correct? Thank you for your time

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      It penetrated enough to hold the panel where it needed to be. Good tack welds are incredibly strong and they dont need to go all the way through

  • @NitrousFTW871
    @NitrousFTW871 Рік тому +1

    All your videos are well explained!You should advertise welding lessons for beginners and make a little $$$

  • @brianmurphy2382
    @brianmurphy2382 2 роки тому +2

    Planisher it flat when you are done

  • @mikeskoczylas1571
    @mikeskoczylas1571 2 роки тому +2

    quick question, i cant remember the specifics, but i thought i read somewhere that some wire (or certain situations maybe?) you cannot weld over your previous weld. is there truth behind that? can you explain?
    thanks

    • @zacharygalliher609
      @zacharygalliher609 2 роки тому

      dont weld over top of slag. he should have knocked to slag off before making the next weld.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +3

      It depends on the situation, for 99% of DIY stuff you can make multiple passes no problem as long as you clean it before starting the next pass

    • @andrewep2816
      @andrewep2816 2 роки тому

      @@zacharygalliher609 Zach - I am a beginner and have been wondering on the point you made. It would seem slag would be a contaminant on top of the metal and interfere with good conductivity, good arc and weld. I have been thinking that as I tack along a sheet metal seam it is best to continuously wire off the slag to shiny metal. Is that the proper way?

  • @timbartley5678
    @timbartley5678 2 роки тому +1

    I. Been welder on a truck cab that was choped and the person had just taken weld holden tighter I got a harbor freight welder cheap on I can't figure it out on low or hi heat keep maken it worse on welder it burned bigger holes haven a heck of a time

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      When in doubt turn all the settings down and work the weld slower. increase wirespeed if it pauses too much.

    • @MegaTapdog
      @MegaTapdog 2 роки тому +1

      Is your polarity set correctly?
      do you have it set to tip negative?
      As in your tip is negative and your clamp is positive? I made the mistake of assuming that tip would be positive and my first welds were like that until a buddy educated me.

    • @thora8624
      @thora8624 2 місяці тому

      If he's using a harbor freight flux core welder it's actually probably running in AC. Don't ask me why but that's how they sell em... a little bit of diy mod work, adding a bridge rectifier, capacitor bank, and possibly a choke, can actually turn a nearly un-usable piece of junk into a pretty sweet little flux core machine. That's what I did, you can look up instructions for the modifications here on UA-cam. I 100% suggest you do it. I absolutely love using mine now.

  • @garytango
    @garytango 5 місяців тому +1

    👍

  • @mebcool
    @mebcool 2 роки тому +1

    Hello and thank you for the video.
    Great explanation throughout.
    Question though, regarding the second method... "You've got to pick your poison" you said, @ 9:15 you can clearly see the crevice between the two sheets on the back side, won't this be a perfect spot for moisture to hide thus starting a premature failure... in other words, on a body panel this welding technique will fail in a short time, will it not ?

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      Yes and no, if you cant reach the back of the panel, it doesnt matter what technique you use, it will eventually rust over because it will stay exposed on the back side. If you can reach the back of the panel, you can quickly sand down the back and apply body filler to paint right over it for a sealed finish.

  • @jack902902
    @jack902902 7 місяців тому +1

    How about intentionally gapping slightly, then spot weld?

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  7 місяців тому

      I don't do that for sheet metal. For thicker metals where you need more penetration, I would say go for it.

  • @AutodidactEngineer
    @AutodidactEngineer 9 місяців тому

    1mm E6013 works well also

  • @Dfchainsaws
    @Dfchainsaws 2 роки тому +2

    What brand wire are you using

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      For this video I used innershield wire by lincoln. Ive used different brands of wire but I like lincoln wire the best.

  • @nat15.9
    @nat15.9 Рік тому +1

    Any recommendation on Voltage, Wire speed and Current for flux core welding on thin metal(1mm-1.5mm)? , what’s your settings on this demonstration?

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  Рік тому

      Sheet metal I try to go as low of heat as possible with the slowest wire speed that it'll take. Each machine is different and sheet metal is tricky but to avoid warpage and to avoid making big welds, slow it down and take it easy. Spot weld in circles quickly also helps

    • @nat15.9
      @nat15.9 Рік тому +1

      @@NightWrencher thank you so much, l have posted some short videos on my channel - it was terrible to weld flux core on thin metal as I still have no idea on settings, if you may have a look and give me some advice, it’d be really appreciated🥹 it’s very confusing to adjust whether voltage or wire speed.

    • @nat15.9
      @nat15.9 Рік тому

      @@NightWrencher ua-cam.com/video/pZLasPUr3eo/v-deo.html

    • @nat15.9
      @nat15.9 Рік тому

      @@NightWrencher ua-cam.com/video/YBHLznlXMDE/v-deo.html

    • @nat15.9
      @nat15.9 Рік тому

      @@NightWrencher ua-cam.com/video/3FkrSqEHtn8/v-deo.html

  • @robwells5753
    @robwells5753 2 роки тому +3

    You dont need to break any wire off just give the tip/wire a rub on your work piece is all thats needed it works every time

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      I do that sometimes, even tapping it a little works too. But for sheet metal, I'll either keep tacking while its still red, or break off the tip. The weld strikes easier and you're in and out faster.

    • @robwells5753
      @robwells5753 2 роки тому +1

      @@NightWrencheriv never tried that bc i learned to tap/scratch the rod before there was mig welders but im gona try it i could use a good habit. Thanks mate

  • @walleyeye
    @walleyeye 3 місяці тому +1

    What guage wire are you using?

  • @arphaxand3494
    @arphaxand3494 Рік тому +1

    What's the name of the circular gadget you put on the sheet metal?

  • @shabadoo24
    @shabadoo24 2 роки тому +1

    A regular Joe explaining how a regular Joe should do it.

  • @JesusTorruella-mn9tg
    @JesusTorruella-mn9tg Рік тому

    😊

  • @hopefilledsinner3911
    @hopefilledsinner3911 2 роки тому +1

    Take the tip off the wire was new to me.

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому +1

      It helps that the weld and avoids unessesary heat from being added to the panel

  • @onetonpun
    @onetonpun Рік тому +2

    Will an aluminum heat sink help prevent warpage?

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  Рік тому

      I've heard that it does but I have not tried it personally

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  14 днів тому

      @@BlondieSL Aluminum is awesome as a table. Cools off quickly and slag doesnt stick to it.

  • @bobd.fletcherjr4912
    @bobd.fletcherjr4912 Рік тому

    👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🙋‍♂️🙋‍♂️🙋‍♂️

  • @horatiohornbie7395
    @horatiohornbie7395 2 роки тому +27

    welded sheet metal for 15 years.... if you can, avoid flux core, it goes way too deep. MIG or TIG is the way to go.

    • @mikejohn3265
      @mikejohn3265 2 роки тому +2

      Clever. I did flux in school on steel. Had issues with it "punching" especially on open root and ceramic.

    • @alexandrobrin2891
      @alexandrobrin2891 Рік тому +16

      I ONLY HAVE A FLUX CORE

    • @nicloewenhagen5557
      @nicloewenhagen5557 Рік тому +19

      ​@alexandrobrin2891 same here why watch it if you have 15 years of experience? Some people...

    • @creativestudio4873
      @creativestudio4873 9 місяців тому

      ​@@jaytodd5809flux core has flux in the center of the wire mig is solid wire...no flux and needs a gas for shielding. So no its not the same. And with mig you can weld thinner metal.

    • @AviationAngler
      @AviationAngler 9 місяців тому

      ​@@jaytodd5809it stands for metal inert gas the guys right mig means it needs gas normally argon CO2 mix

  • @Colin-Fenix
    @Colin-Fenix 2 роки тому +1

    Actually?

  • @tennentssuppa
    @tennentssuppa 2 роки тому +1

    why did you go over the old weld? It made that side thicker and full of rubbish. It should be ground back ffs.

  • @johnbaptist7476
    @johnbaptist7476 2 роки тому +1

    Hello friend
    Where U buy your jacket & what do U call it . Thank you for sharing your knowledge . GOD bless 😇 + 🕯♾️ 👏👍󾓦 ✟✟✟✡✟✟✟ 󾓦 4/17/ 22

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  2 роки тому

      Hello! I just use denim or leather jackets like dickies or levis. A welding apron can also be used. Stay away from anything made of nylon, polyester or any other plastics, they will melt.

  • @davidsmall6914
    @davidsmall6914 Рік тому

    Please take " go ahead" out of you vocabulary, but very good.

  • @toodjackson4438
    @toodjackson4438 5 місяців тому

    Don't do it like this unless you want your body panels to look like the ocean

  • @ochayethegnu2915
    @ochayethegnu2915 5 місяців тому +1

    Why do Americans say “gonna go ahead and…” all the time. PLEASE STOP!

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  5 місяців тому +4

      Sorry to be a bloke govna, dinnit mean ta get ya knackered. Its my fault innit? This might make you chuffed, I'll switch it to "about to stroll on over this area and..."

    • @ochayethegnu2915
      @ochayethegnu2915 5 місяців тому +1

      What I should have said is “gonnae no dae that? Jist, gonnae no?”

    • @NightWrencher
      @NightWrencher  5 місяців тому

      @@ochayethegnu2915 😂

  • @tombrady9385
    @tombrady9385 2 роки тому +3

    If you can’t weld a straight beat in one pass on 24-20 gauge you shouldn’t be doing video educating others. Tacking a beat is not a strong bond on the metal. Unless you wire brush each tac before putting another. That would be dumb. But that would assure the weld fuse together better. You can check out my uncle at weld tips and tricks channel on UA-cam. You might learn something and do a video.

    • @HarryJarrell
      @HarryJarrell 9 місяців тому

      You can weld a bead continuously with mig, but it is nearly impossible with flux core, on such thin metal.

  • @ash5.0
    @ash5.0 2 роки тому +1

    That was one of the worst beads I have ever seen