She Was Rejected With a 3.74 GPA and 515 MCAT. Why? | Application Renovation (S3 E10)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 155

  • @Jessi4Evr
    @Jessi4Evr 3 роки тому +166

    This is one of those applicants that I think would benefit most from doing things completely unrelated to medicine. She’s clearly dedicated and ready for med school but out of thousands of applicants with physician parents and EMT experience there has to be something that makes the application reviewer want to meet you in person.

  • @aabdi2001
    @aabdi2001 3 роки тому +118

    For her I think it all came down to her school list. She applied to too many public in state schools like dr ryan said. And the private ones were all top tier schools, leaving barely within her range

    • @aabdi2001
      @aabdi2001 3 роки тому +9

      @@J.W.-is8oj not if youre out of state

    • @BD-uo9po
      @BD-uo9po 3 роки тому +4

      @@J.W.-is8oj some public schools accept out of state students with sub 1% acceptance rate, much more competitive than even the top private schools (if we are only looking at acceptance rate)

  • @kparm23
    @kparm23 3 роки тому +32

    Thank you for showing the secondary as well! Learning and seeing more of the application definitely helps reduce the anxiety about the entire process.

    • @bissemgill475
      @bissemgill475 3 роки тому +7

      no part of this video reduced anxiety for me lol. Decent GPA and MCAT, school list that mostly matched stats, decent PS and ECs, but no acceptances. Starting to look like you need some sort of "X factor" to be admitted to any MD, not just T20

  • @starrailsunday
    @starrailsunday 3 роки тому +66

    Seeing people with good stats not get in makes me worried for myself 😭

    • @lilcluch1634
      @lilcluch1634 2 роки тому +8

      Ay you got it trust yourself you can do it fs

    • @Coconinga
      @Coconinga 2 роки тому +8

      you need to be careful with your school list, if its too top heavy you won't make it'. Need to have safeties and dream schools.

    • @robertison6773
      @robertison6773 2 роки тому +3

      @@lilcluch1634 this is what I needed to hear

    • @cocolina53348
      @cocolina53348 2 роки тому +2

      Youre taking away the wrong message. The lesson is to be a well-rounded applicant. There is more to getting into med school than having good grades and a high mcat. And know what schools your stats will get you into

    • @maraisfan4life517
      @maraisfan4life517 2 роки тому +2

      @@cocolina53348 that’s just picky. Why do you need to participate in sports and clubs just for universities to accept you? That’s stupid. What if you just desire to strive in academics?

  • @nightshockplayz5894
    @nightshockplayz5894 3 роки тому +30

    What I feel may have gotten this person comes down to:
    1) School List (The ones that were not advantageous).
    2) Personal Statement (Hardest part for many students).
    3) Possibly Letters Of Recommendation (Something hard for anyone to gauge why The apply struggled).

  • @mattp9076
    @mattp9076 3 роки тому +42

    Thank you for showing the secondaries. I think that's what killed her.

    • @karan_karan_karan
      @karan_karan_karan 3 роки тому +18

      that "i have an itch to be a doctor.. and I just CaNt StOp ScRaTcHiNg!!!" probably didn't help either omgggg

    • @stylewithme365
      @stylewithme365 2 роки тому +3

      @@karan_karan_karan that was cute tho

  • @yadiraplata4797
    @yadiraplata4797 3 роки тому +17

    This was super helpful as I'm writing my PS ! My observation is that I'm just not feeling a sense of passion? I could be completely off... I admire everything she has done and undoubtedly she could talk more about the many people she encountered that reinforced her decision of being a physician, which could maybe make her seem more personable and like a more caring future physician

    • @yadiraplata4797
      @yadiraplata4797 3 роки тому +5

      Also the second question in the secondary was like Dr. Gray mentioned, a little murky, this could've been an awesome response if the applicant had told us what she did to improve the societal inequality, it left me wondering why she didn't do something about the interpreting problem :/ I also think there's an overall neutral/negative tone throughout every essay, when I feel like a optimistic tone could transform this whole application. Wishing this future doc gets in this next cycle :)

    • @C3yl0
      @C3yl0 3 роки тому +1

      That’s the vibes I got about her application overall.

  • @briannaolson4391
    @briannaolson4391 3 роки тому +88

    With this applicant, maybe it could’ve been useful to ask about her letters of recommendation? Since it was hard to identify an obvious weakness

  • @Bejman13
    @Bejman13 3 роки тому +22

    Having to retake the MCAT? Brutal

  • @andersnelson6888
    @andersnelson6888 3 роки тому +12

    THIS CANNEL IS AMAZING. NOTHING LIKE IT. THANK YOU!!!!!

  • @atlantic7949
    @atlantic7949 3 роки тому +23

    Most times it's not about cut-offs and numbers. It's more about mission fit.

  • @devankumar8369
    @devankumar8369 3 роки тому +146

    Her school list was intense, that had to have been a factor

  • @kaleygregory2324
    @kaleygregory2324 3 роки тому +27

    Dr. Gray, could you do a video on the TMDSAS application? Specifically on how to format the activities section with the limited word count

    • @theactualparadox
      @theactualparadox 3 роки тому +1

      I’ve been having a ton of problems with this one!

    • @tANGERINEchan
      @tANGERINEchan 3 роки тому +1

      I think I remember one of his older videos being a TMDSAS one, cant remember which exactly tho

  • @jessicas6776
    @jessicas6776 3 роки тому +56

    Tbh I liked the pun at the end of her essay

  • @farhantejani8287
    @farhantejani8287 3 роки тому +16

    More secondary reviews please!

  • @Odinwain
    @Odinwain 3 роки тому +5

    good advice and sometimes the truth is hard to hear but its honest advice.

  • @ezdeanalkurdi6745
    @ezdeanalkurdi6745 3 роки тому +5

    These are so helpful for this upcoming cycle! Thank you so much!

  • @jackiele5019
    @jackiele5019 3 роки тому +13

    School wants diversity and school might find her application, while checking all boxes, is not anything special. That’s unfortunate. I hope she will spend more time outside of being a premed to enjoy the richness of life. Long school of medicine has a great video about what make a good application.

    • @iluhyuhswag
      @iluhyuhswag 2 роки тому +2

      so what can make your application special?

    • @stylewithme365
      @stylewithme365 2 роки тому

      Disadvantages is sexy

  • @SunSunSunn
    @SunSunSunn 3 роки тому +27

    Possibly also letter of recommendations. Thats a factor that people always forget about.

  • @spanishmamamia999
    @spanishmamamia999 3 роки тому +16

    In my experience, it was importance in my acceptance to my med school that I was exposed to clinics and hospitals since my sophomore year in Pre Med.

    • @abdoulmoukailou2604
      @abdoulmoukailou2604 3 роки тому +3

      How do you get clinical experience?

    • @雪底下
      @雪底下 Рік тому

      @@abdoulmoukailou2604 volunteering

    • @pragyaw
      @pragyaw Рік тому +1

      @@abdoulmoukailou2604either volunteer, or do some sort of job like CNA, PCA, EMT, etc. in a hospital setting

  • @Lulu-gb7xu
    @Lulu-gb7xu 3 роки тому +36

    If she didn’t get in I am screweddddd come June

    • @Bash2026
      @Bash2026 3 роки тому +2

      Sameeeee

    • @thatweirdscienceguy9880
      @thatweirdscienceguy9880 3 роки тому +1

      MOOD

    • @dawsonzentz2078
      @dawsonzentz2078 3 роки тому

      LMAO yeah I’m taking the MCAT next year and feel like I have NO experience outside of coursework. Which I have sort of a strange situation but still. I feel like it’s extremely competitive for no reason sometimes. Obviously it has to be competitive but damn

    • @tonywalkerYougotswaw
      @tonywalkerYougotswaw Рік тому

      Did you guys get in?

    • @Lulu-gb7xu
      @Lulu-gb7xu Рік тому

      @@tonywalkerYougotswaw I actually got my first acceptance two weeks ago and I have 3 more interviews ahead so far. Your story matters!! Thanks for asking btw, this made me smile

  • @Bash2026
    @Bash2026 3 роки тому +11

    Can’t believe she didn’t get in smh

  • @garrettludescher9588
    @garrettludescher9588 3 місяці тому +1

    Kind of an intense video😭😭 great learning vid tho

  • @sydneydevore4512
    @sydneydevore4512 3 роки тому +18

    If you have a physician parent, should you definitely plan on writing about that in your PS? I didn't feel like that was my "why", but I wouldn't want to raise any concerns.

    • @IM12111
      @IM12111 3 роки тому +1

      I believe it should be included as an influence. How much influence and the reasons behind that narrative, that’s what you’ll be judged on by the readers.

  • @sophiepellerin5517
    @sophiepellerin5517 3 роки тому +61

    I think the school list must have played a role, otherwise, it's hard to say

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +15

      ^ ^ This ^ ^ she would have been a shoe in at any DO school or lower tier MD school. Stats is 1/3 of your rubric score, interview is 1/3 and HoLiStIcs is 1/3 (your essays). Stand out in your essays!!! And not by researching for a year either, do some paid full-time work to build up your professionalism and communication skills.
      20 schools is the bare minimum anyone should be applying to, most should apply to more, especially anyone with a common story that doesn't really stand out (basically most traditional students are a dime a dozen and need to do something to make themselves seem more unique in some way).

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +9

      Lol obviously a bot account. ^^^^^ don't go to that website unless you like having viruses infect your computer

    • @danielavello4834
      @danielavello4834 3 роки тому

      @Zayn Forrest you’re right, no one cares 😂

  • @mike112693
    @mike112693 3 роки тому +2

    her school lists wasn't bad considering her stats. Many have gotten in with slightly lower stats. tough luck.

  • @richardking1561
    @richardking1561 6 місяців тому +1

    why does 3:00 am matter? Threy are busy pre-meds with a lot on their minds.

  • @Russianboyz95
    @Russianboyz95 3 роки тому +13

    Once again, it comes down to the school list.

  • @kansasmypie6466
    @kansasmypie6466 3 роки тому +51

    All that application money wasted. That’s really unfortunate.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +12

      It's an important lesson that trying to save money by *only* applying to 20 schools can cost you more in both time and money than applying to 35 the first time.

    • @devankumar8369
      @devankumar8369 3 роки тому +15

      @@alphaspartan lowkey that’s not the lesson, her school list was insane, like her stats are great don’t get me wrong, but she applied to some ungodly competitive schools, and if her extracurriculars and essays are not the most amazing things ever (which again they were great but not like unbelievably great), her stats don’t compete at those schools it’s an unfortunate reality of those private schools and applying to out of state public schools is always a bad idea. She’ll be fine tho she’ll get into med school she just has to apply to some lower tier private schools as well.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому

      @@devankumar8369 I completely agree with you. I was going to say she shouldn't have applied so top heavy but then I thought who am I to judge, she could have hedged her bets by adding 15 lower tier to her list to cover all her bases and never have to ask "what if"?

    • @alexwyler4570
      @alexwyler4570 3 роки тому

      @@alphaspartan Are you sarcastic? should i apply to 35 schools instead of 25 schools? I am going in with good stats but my mindset is that there is no such thing as a safety school. i was going to do 25 schools. My comment/question is not sarcastic. i think BEMO? or another cie on youtube says we should apply to 40 schools. i think they give you that directive to make sure you get into a school. i could be way wrong.

    • @alexwyler4570
      @alexwyler4570 3 роки тому +1

      @@alphaspartan After this episode, i think BEMO or the other cie might be right, you need to apply to 40 schools. Applying to medical school will be the same price ish as my yearly undergraduate tuition! i am thinking you are serious, we need to apply to 35 schools. That is a good racket for medical schools. Any other tips we should know? Thanks!

  • @stylewithme365
    @stylewithme365 2 роки тому +5

    Does everything. Gets rejected 😷

  • @frostassassin7265
    @frostassassin7265 3 роки тому +3

    She needs a better school list. Pretty top-heavy list

  • @mikell.6064
    @mikell.6064 3 роки тому +25

    HOWW?!!!

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +20

      She got too cocky with that 515. Never assume a lower ranked MD school or even applying DO is beneath you. Good schools have 20 515 students applying for one seat, you gotta stand out some other way. That low tier MD school or DO school would kill for one student who scored a 515 on the MCAT to apply, lol.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +6

      @@assassinruler1483 that's tough to be honest. Yes you'll stand out as an 18 year old, but maybe not in a good way. You'll have to fight to prove you're mature enough to handle med school and the responsibility of being a doctor and having patients trust you when you're so darn young compared to most other med students. Prove you know what you're getting yourself into through shadowing and clinical exeperiences. Actions speak louder than your own words though, go get leadership experience and get your letters of recommendation writers talk about how mature you are for your age and how you're a leader. And of course in your interviews you'll need to come across as a mature and experienced person. Life experience is the biggest differentiator between applicants I feel like, it's stuff you can write about in your essays and make you a better doctor because you know what your patients are going through. The avg age of medical students keeps getting older and older.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому

      @Juki Mars how do they control yield by not allowing high score students in

  • @skyllarkuppinger6751
    @skyllarkuppinger6751 3 місяці тому

    I don’t like the comments about her father. My father is a psychiatrist so I had to put “physician” on there. But he’s not in my life whatsoever. In fact when I was born my parents were already split up and my father did not even pay child support. Now I am worried that they are gonna see that my dad is a doctor and have the same concerns as dr gray.

    • @abiroberts3409
      @abiroberts3409 2 місяці тому

      Maybe in your “other experiences” essay you could talk about your Dad being absent if you feel that has impacted your journey

  • @cooperholland5502
    @cooperholland5502 3 роки тому +5

    disagree that comment at the end of the PS was sick

  • @Maddawg31415
    @Maddawg31415 3 роки тому +6

    I wonder how the secondaries went for the schools she got rejections

  • @sergiootero5904
    @sergiootero5904 3 роки тому +24

    What a bunch of bologna. How did she not get in?

    • @devankumar8369
      @devankumar8369 3 роки тому +17

      Her private school list was intense

    • @theactualparadox
      @theactualparadox 3 роки тому

      @C B how do you know it was 72%?

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +13

      She applied to competitive schools. You need more than good stats to get into a top ranking school. If she'd applied to low ranking schools or DO with these stats, she would have 100% gotten in. Don't get cocky (most med students are at least a little arrogant, it just comes with the territory).

    • @centeenarose6994
      @centeenarose6994 3 роки тому +2

      @@alphaspartan how do u know which ones are high tier vs mid tier vs low tier? Is there a list somewhere?

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +4

      @@centeenarose6994 yeah US World News ranks colleges, including medical, and the MSAR shows GPA and MCAT averages for each school. You'll notice a correlation between stats and school rankings. So just use that as a rule of thumb. You're more likely to get into a school where you're at or above average stat wise than a school where you're hopelessly outgunned by your fellow interviewees who (on paper) make you look like a lower achieving student. Dr. Gray is right about tailoring your app to the schools mission as well, and you're going to have a better chance getting into an individual school if your essays resemble what the school stands for, e.g. prove you're interested or connected in some way to rural communities if you're applying to a rural school or do some research if you're applying to a research heavy school.

  • @dogtags45
    @dogtags45 Рік тому

    In the most meaningful remarks, the story starts by talking about Pat, and a sentence in the middle mentions Jim. Just a heads up.

  • @thebeatles9
    @thebeatles9 2 роки тому +1

    Why was this applicant rejected? Applying too high?

  • @blaby4ever
    @blaby4ever 3 роки тому +24

    These medical schools should have accepted her. It's they're their damn fault we're short on doctors.

    • @stylewithme365
      @stylewithme365 2 роки тому +6

      Then blame NPs/PAs for taking their jobs 🤡

    • @blaby4ever
      @blaby4ever 2 роки тому +1

      @@stylewithme365 i'd be more inclined to blame the government for shoveling money to these medical institutions and hospitals than other fields.

    • @robwes9227
      @robwes9227 Рік тому

      It isn’t their fault. They filled all of their seats. What more can you ask of them?

    • @JimMilton-gp9op
      @JimMilton-gp9op Рік тому +3

      @@robwes9227they should have more seats and be able to train more people.

  • @jennvan126
    @jennvan126 3 роки тому +4

    I noticed that her only non-science letter was only assigned to one school. Could that have been a problem? A lot of schools require at least one non science LOR

    • @japjeetmehton9921
      @japjeetmehton9921 3 роки тому

      Do you mean she had only one non-science letter of reference? Could you elaborate your point?

    • @jennvan126
      @jennvan126 3 роки тому

      There is a box on the right that says “number of schools assigned” that says 1 for the non science letter. I might be mistaken but it seems like she only sent her non-science letter to one school? Just curious how that would factor into this process if true.

  • @zachvrobel2478
    @zachvrobel2478 3 роки тому +3

    Regarding the statement that late June is good for taking the MCAT, I graduate with my BS in early May 2021 and was planning to take the MCAT closer to August/ September 2021. Is that way too far out for 2022 application cycle?

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +2

      That's late but if you do well it's not too late. Worse situation would be to take it in June with only one month of studying and bombing the exam!

    • @zachvrobel2478
      @zachvrobel2478 3 роки тому +2

      @@alphaspartan my thoughts exactly, however I think the July 17th date is what I'm going to register for. Give me time to study prior and time on the back end for processing. I won't be working so I'll have a solid 2.5 months to study.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +2

      @@zachvrobel2478 I took my exam with about the same time table as your describing and I did good enough. Don't be afraid to push the date back if you're not ready based on your practice exam scores. I had a friend that studied with me for the exact same amount of time with the same materials and she got a 487 while I scored well above 500. It's crazy how much variance there can be with this test!

    • @zachvrobel2478
      @zachvrobel2478 3 роки тому

      @@alphaspartan Thank you for the information, that is very reassuring. I plan to do just that. I have heard about the variances but thats the first real life example I've seen. I don't have anyone following my same timeline so I am going to invest in an online test prep to help with fine tuning the areas I need the most work on. I work better on my own in these situation too.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +1

      @@zachvrobel2478 good luck friend. Just make yourself a plan and stick to it. Adapt when necessary. That's how med school will be too! I bought the Kaplan 7 book review set and UWorld plus the AAMC MCAT materials directly from their website. I would suggest you buy the AAMC materials, UWorld and use Khan Academy which is free. Anything else is too expensive and I'd only recommend it if you have more money than you know what to do with.

  • @C3yl0
    @C3yl0 3 роки тому

    In my opinion it was the personal statement. She needs to step back and think the reasons of why.

  • @TheMrSSS
    @TheMrSSS 3 роки тому +11

    Canada type shit

  • @toughntiny
    @toughntiny 3 роки тому +9

    Is it actually less competitive to get into a DO program?

    • @burnt.norton
      @burnt.norton 3 роки тому +19

      short and simple answer: yes.

    • @erindanner9173
      @erindanner9173 2 роки тому

      No more… they’re less programs

    • @prescriptionbateman
      @prescriptionbateman 2 місяці тому

      With her application I can't imagine her not getting into almost every DO school she applied to. TBH she probably could've gotten in if she applied to more reasonable schools, more pvt schools or public schools in FL NY MI

  • @Maddawg31415
    @Maddawg31415 3 роки тому +7

    Rochester is not public

  • @alexwyler4570
    @alexwyler4570 3 роки тому +6

    Dr Gray, should she have applied to a DO school? just a thought, what do i know.

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +4

      Yes! She would have def. been accepted. They expect high stat people to get into MD schools, so they accept them and take their tuition deposit with the expectation that they will drop the seat and the school pockets the money. Works 60% of the time, every time.

    • @andrescorona7044
      @andrescorona7044 3 роки тому +1

      @@alphaspartan I disagree. No need to have applied DO had she had a better list. She’s very competitive for MD schools and I don’t think it was necessary applying DO the first time around. Now as a reapplicant she should apply top tier DO to not have to have to apply a third time

    • @alphaspartan
      @alphaspartan 3 роки тому +1

      @@andrescorona7044 actually I think we do agree. I don't think she "needed" to apply DO either if she'd done a better school list the first time, but if she had applied DO the first time without a solid school list, she wouldn't be reapplying now and wasting another year of her life. It sounds like you agree with me by saying she should apply DO for her 2nd cycle as well. 😅

  • @theTSAguy
    @theTSAguy 3 роки тому +3

    GO GATORS!!!!!!!

  • @hillarycrigler1033
    @hillarycrigler1033 3 роки тому

    Love your videos, also go gators

  • @dom6783
    @dom6783 3 роки тому +21

    Probably ORM

    • @UsRUncharted
      @UsRUncharted 3 роки тому

      Orm?

    • @daveyjones3016
      @daveyjones3016 3 роки тому +6

      Statistically she had over a 75 percent change of getting in. Not 100 percent, just unlucky or interview problems.

    • @matthewlee4834
      @matthewlee4834 3 роки тому +2

      @@UsRUncharted It stands for "overrepresented minority/majority." Honestly the girl's annunciation sounds like she's White or Asian-American, so I wouldn't entirely doubt if she was ORM

    • @theactualparadox
      @theactualparadox 3 роки тому

      @@daveyjones3016 how do you know she had a 75% chance?

    • @pk6010
      @pk6010 3 роки тому

      @@theactualparadox I believe someone said above that AAMC does have a guide of who is urm and orm and their avg mcat/gpa

  • @CXY96
    @CXY96 3 роки тому +14

    Probably Asian/White. Classic.

    • @thesneakygamer4343
      @thesneakygamer4343 3 роки тому +20

      I am middle eastern/white, also an over represented minority and got into plenty of schools with similar stats. Her school list wasn’t good that’s pretty much it. She fixes that and she is good to go

    • @CXY96
      @CXY96 3 роки тому +4

      @@thesneakygamer4343 You're Middle Eastern? My friend, no, you're not an ORM. You are exactly what medical schools want to make their class more "diverse." I'm sorry bro. I'm sure you did well in school and on exams but you are by no means an ORM.

    • @thesneakygamer4343
      @thesneakygamer4343 3 роки тому +10

      @@CXY96 Iranian/middle eastern are considered over-represented. Proportionally they are actually more represented in medicine than any other group. I have talked to ad-coms that consider us over-represented. Also in the AMCAS app, middle eastern is white so they can’t distinguish anyway.

    • @thesneakygamer4343
      @thesneakygamer4343 3 роки тому +4

      Also it sucks to see but I am an MS1 and I have gone through a tone of all reviews and interviewed plenty of applicants. I would consider her application pretty average, she struck me as a standard med school applicant and she didn’t stand out. If she diversified her school list a bit she still would have gotten in somewhere good though.

    • @CXY96
      @CXY96 3 роки тому +1

      @@thesneakygamer4343 Oh for sure, I didn't think her application was particularly unique. But it seemed like she had the drive to go into medicine and good enough stats.
      Regarding your heritage, although adcoms may consider you to be "over-represented," let me say this. Your name doesn't evoke the same time of aversion compared to a "Chang, Wang, Zhang." Racism against Asians is accepted, especially among higher academia. Racism against Middle Easterns is a no-go, career-ending move for higher education.

  • @goldielocks8231
    @goldielocks8231 3 роки тому +3

    Go to st george in grenada produces great dr.s in business 40 years

    • @IM12111
      @IM12111 3 роки тому +7

      Not a high recommend of this, too risky with many caveats.