Lord Peter Wimsey - Five Red Herrings 3

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 76

  • @sarahknight5249
    @sarahknight5249 2 роки тому +21

    Thank you for these! I'm really enjoying them in our world gone mad! xx

  • @uhlijohn
    @uhlijohn 11 місяців тому +4

    Love the way Wimsey drops his "gs" and in other episodes he actually uses the contraction "ain't"!

    • @cruisepaige
      @cruisepaige 6 місяців тому

      Trendy talk. He died that what? At the end of sentences. Today the kids would say he has “rizz.”

    • @bethwaltz2607
      @bethwaltz2607 6 місяців тому +3

      Son of a duke, public school education, born 1890 -- Wimsey's style of speech is well suited to his station.

    • @johannaholmgren8088
      @johannaholmgren8088 27 днів тому

      It's how he spoke in the books. That was pretty much the norm for young men of his class in that time frame. And Sayers knew that quite well.
      Mind you, Ian Carmichael is very much older than the Peter Wimsey in the books.

  • @willowwobble
    @willowwobble Рік тому +7

    Look out for the beautiful examples of Art Nouveau design in the style of Scotish artist Charles Rennie Mackintosh that can be seen during the series, especially in some of the interiors...doors, fireplace, window, balcony handrail etc.

  • @joanhyde1745
    @joanhyde1745 3 роки тому +19

    Bunteris indeed a hero, trying to keep his service to such high standard when they are renting in a situation without inside running water.

  • @censusgary
    @censusgary 5 років тому +33

    Bunter is a superhero. He knows everything, and can do anything.

    • @cruisepaige
      @cruisepaige 6 місяців тому

      He’s an early model of Jeeves.

    • @censusgary
      @censusgary 6 місяців тому

      @@cruisepaigeActually, it’s the other way around. The first Jeeves and Wooster story was published in 1915; Lord Peter Wimsey did not appear until 1923. In at least a couple of the Wimsey books, there are sly comments about Wimsey and Bunter being like Wooster and Jeeves, indicating that Dorothy Sayers knew the Jeeves stories, and acknowledged their influence. There are similar mentions of Sherlock Holmes.

  • @carmenfurrell9759
    @carmenfurrell9759 2 роки тому +7

    I love the comrades between Lord Peter and Bunter.

  • @patriciajrs46
    @patriciajrs46 2 роки тому +6

    I like how Lord Wimsey keeps making Alice in Wonderland references. Ha. Bit funny. Love this. Ms. Sayers sure puts twists in her tails. Ha.

  • @billybogg3602
    @billybogg3602 Рік тому +1

    thanks for posting.

  • @colinglass1342
    @colinglass1342 Рік тому +1

    MON 6 MARCH 2023 Lord Peter whimsy Thanks for this series it makes my brain think. Clear out the mind fog watching this series on my smart phone you tube is the best of the best better for downloading almost any films tv series available countless audio books to download . Better then net flix virgin media sky etc.

  • @richardcleveland8549
    @richardcleveland8549 2 роки тому +11

    Wimsey's piano choices are interesting - Bach, Chopin, and around 34:00 either Ravel or Debussy - and then right into the "Italian Concerto" - my favorite Bach! Wonder who made the musical choices . . . .

    • @rosiesalas938
      @rosiesalas938 2 роки тому

      Debussy Fille aux cheveux de lin

    • @iglika.a
      @iglika.a Рік тому +1

      Debussy - The Girl with the Flaxen Hair. I don't know if I'm placing the caps correctly though...

  • @235hank
    @235hank 7 років тому +10

    Thanks much for the posting!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Horace O.

    • @mfjdv2020
      @mfjdv2020 7 років тому +2

      Second that! I especially like all the humour in this particular story, I've been chuckling ever since part 1. That bit at the police station is hilarious (starts at 7:08). Poor Inspector MacPherson!

  • @cidchase2689
    @cidchase2689 2 роки тому +5

    ...and the delightful quoting of Shakespeare from MacBeth! One should always quote Shakespeare!! Note the only slightly veiled reference from dialogue in the Petherbridge series, specifically "Gaudy Night" and specifically referring to Aristotle rather than Shakespeare. Would not be my preference.

  • @anneroy4560
    @anneroy4560 3 роки тому +6

    a lot of the Columbo 'ah, just one thing' as he is leaving ... can be very effective ...

    • @mfjdv2020
      @mfjdv2020 3 роки тому +2

      But nobody does it like Columbo :-)

    • @Muck006
      @Muck006 3 роки тому

      It is effective because many people have let their guard down at that time ... after seeing the back of the inquisitive inspector in charge of the case.

  • @harmoniabalanza
    @harmoniabalanza 4 роки тому +7

    at 27:05 Wimsey looks affectionately at the girl. I think it is the actor recognizing a small flub in the young actress and knowing she has great potential he looks fonder. So dear!

    • @mfjdv2020
      @mfjdv2020 3 роки тому +1

      If you mean the woman who plays Fenella Strachan, she's an appallingly and abominably bad actress. And what on earth is a 'flub'?

    • @glen7318
      @glen7318 3 роки тому

      @@mfjdv2020 Mistake

    • @texasred2702
      @texasred2702 2 роки тому +10

      @@mfjdv2020 she's affected. A girl like that would have been considered a scandalous Kardashian type, or at least trying very hard to be. I thought the actress did a fine job of portraying a type that's been lost to history.

    • @steveg8322
      @steveg8322 2 роки тому

      @@texasred2702 Damn straight,she’s great.Pulls off the adolescent aching for adulthood very admirably.🍹A Horse’s neck for the young lady!

    • @VLind-uk6mb
      @VLind-uk6mb Рік тому +1

      @@texasred2702 I agree. She was a young girl trying to act older -- not an unknown phenomenon, especially when faced with an attractive older man! Of course she is very naive, and essentially innocent -- she's all talk. Lady Rose in Downton is a variation of the type. It's teenage rebellion of a sort, bucking at the restrictions placed upon them.

  • @mollyjonesreacts
    @mollyjonesreacts Рік тому +1

    29:52 After just screaming (to her) “Don’t touch lass!” & all the while she was wearing 🧤- next the policeman takes the item, holds it & wait for Wimsey to REMOVE his gloves 🧤 before handing over that particular item 😂 - I’m waiting for the police 👮‍♀️ to go down for mishandling evidence.

  • @user-xu3fs6gr5p
    @user-xu3fs6gr5p 3 роки тому +7

    No serious bible student would suggest that there is anything queer about II Samuel 1:26. Even though Jonathan knew that David would eventually have the crown; Jonathan was ever loyal to David. There were several times where Jonathan could have ratted David out..

    • @coloraturaElise
      @coloraturaElise Рік тому +1

      Yes, and that lovely little hint Mrs. Farren gives is not in the book.

    • @user-xu3fs6gr5p
      @user-xu3fs6gr5p Рік тому +1

      Thanks for that bit of info. I will have my bookseller get me a copy of the book. It will be a great read methinks.

    • @user-xu3fs6gr5p
      @user-xu3fs6gr5p Рік тому

      Thanks for that bit of info. I will have my bookseller get me a copy of the book. It will be a great read methinks.

  • @kateleblanc604
    @kateleblanc604 2 роки тому +3

    Not much of a "vacation" for Bunter what with all the toting and carrying of water.

  • @greenman6141
    @greenman6141 5 місяців тому +1

    I loved the outrage of David Rintoul's character.
    Be suspected of murder.
    vs.
    Be thought not just a greasy gigolo, but a greasy gigolo with NO TASTE.
    He doesn't want to be thought a greasy gigolo with such want of standards.
    A painting gigolo should have taste! Doesn't want that stain on his prospects. Character be damned.
    Think Gauguin - who made such a career out of abusing and infecting the beautiful and guileless.
    I'd have been 100% sympathetic to Rintoul's character if he'd have helped the widow to have some later life fun. Yes, she was unbearable to listen to. But - well, let's just say, I don't think it was accidental that the "beautiful" woman was always weaving and spinning - the REAL man eating creature was that Mackintosh mad one. She's even described as "sucking the life" out of her victim.
    The widow has some love of life left in her. Good for her.
    The murder "mystery" is all a matter of cross referencing timetables. More trainspotting than detecting. Though that's not meant as a criticism. All those lovely unBeechinged branch lines. One could weep.
    The real meat is, of course, the characters.
    The married couple who claim their marriage is strong because they allow each other "freedom", both of whom turn out to be profoundly jealous and really rather nasty.
    The successful painter whose head servants describe their domestic set-up as being "like a family". Yup, an unkind, controlling, gas lighting, lying, cruel family. They're right...just like a real family.
    The locals, Scottish locals, who make money from the English tourist incomers, and can't stand them. That's 100% correct in two ways.
    I've an American relative, who, when he traveled from Ireland to Scotland, said that he really enjoyed Scotland, as people there were too busy hating the English to get around to hating Americans.
    Plus, anyone who has ever lived in a place that has a tourism economy, will recognize the loathing that locals have for their source livelihood.
    Sayers did all that stuff so well, and with affection and dry humour, but never blind to reality..
    It's one of the reasons I liked Gaudy Night so much. She lived in the academic world, but she didn't let it off the hook. She pointed out the cruelty in the intellectual and social snobbery, the deliberate, relished cruelty. My daughter is currently at uni and she describes very well that world of difference between professors who can critique students' work in a manner which encourages and improves them and their work, and professors who just want to flex & inflate their own egos and do so by humiliating and crushing those young people they're meant to be enlightening and guiding.
    Sayers was good at seeing the dark and light and not being overly judgmental.
    That's a real quality when writing about murders.

  • @235hank
    @235hank 7 років тому +6

    Jolly good!!!!!!
    Horace Ovid

  • @mfjdv2020
    @mfjdv2020 3 роки тому +4

    Peter's car is beautiful, but how on earth can anyone drive anything like that? With that huge long bonnet and no power steering either. And the rear part of the car's almost as long as the bonnet!

    • @gwenethgrieve4023
      @gwenethgrieve4023 3 роки тому +2

      What the older cars do have is better visibility as generally the driver was sitting higher than we do in modern vehicles.

    • @Muck006
      @Muck006 3 роки тому +1

      The giant steering wheel has the purpose of making it possible to turn the wheel ... in addition to the rather narrow tyres and low speed.

    • @richardcleveland8549
      @richardcleveland8549 2 роки тому +2

      Interesting that the Bentley is maroon; I've only ever seen the 'teens and 'twenties cars in British racing green. I ran into a flock of them (I should say encountered!) several years in the wilds of my home state, mostly of the vintage of LPW's, and all in green . . . except for a one-off late-model with power everything driven by a member of the club who was no longer strong enough to manage one of the Blowers. All (except the recent model) were drop-tops, and all tops were down - bracing in late October or early November. Wotta sight! I'll never forget it!

    • @eshaibraheem4218
      @eshaibraheem4218 2 місяці тому

      Oh, the good old days! Magnificent motor car, and wonderful colour.

  • @richardcleveland8549
    @richardcleveland8549 2 роки тому +2

    Hmmm . . . when Bunter reels off the quote from the bible about Jonathan and David, LPW seems somewhat taken aback . . . or, at least very thoughtful.

    • @rosiesalas938
      @rosiesalas938 2 роки тому

      Batman and officer relationship. LIke Frodo and Sam. BFF

    • @VLind-uk6mb
      @VLind-uk6mb Рік тому

      @@rosiesalas938 Bromance, as they say nowadays. Devoted, but non-sexual, friendship -- enjoyed by many men.

    • @coloraturaElise
      @coloraturaElise Рік тому +1

      Peter's taken aback because he knows it's not in the book, and wonders at the producers of this series for making such a suggestion.

  • @greenman6141
    @greenman6141 5 місяців тому

    Playing some of Debussy's Children's Corner at 34:36.

  • @dmisso42
    @dmisso42 2 роки тому +4

    Sayer was not only revelling in the satirical representation of English Society but was not averse to taking a swipe at contemporary and popular authors of her time.
    Wilkey Collins was a novelist who wrote Crime Fiction (24:53) who Sayer probably did not respect. Haha.

    • @Happyheretic2308
      @Happyheretic2308 2 роки тому +6

      Wilkie Collins wrote what is accepted as the first detective novel “The Moonstone” in the mid-19th century.

    • @glen7318
      @glen7318 2 роки тому +8

      What are you talking about? Sayers wrote crime fiction herself and she greatly admired Wilkie Collins and spent a lot of time writing a biography of him....

  • @harmoniabalanza
    @harmoniabalanza 4 роки тому +5

    Poor Bunter in love with Betty and she in love with him. Sniff.

    • @glen7318
      @glen7318 3 роки тому +4

      Bunter isn't a falling in love type of guy....

    • @mfjdv2020
      @mfjdv2020 3 роки тому +6

      Bunter isn't in love with Betty!

    • @Muck006
      @Muck006 3 роки тому +3

      At best Bunter is in a "bromance" with Lord Peter ... but his first "love" would be his PRIDE in BEING RATHER GOOD AT HIS JOB! The amount of skills he has is rather amazing ... camerawork, painting, the usual FULL knowledge of food and drink and all the domestic skills too ... while having sharp eyes almost like Sherlock Holmes.

    • @glen7318
      @glen7318 3 роки тому +4

      Bunter is quite a lady's man....

    • @VLind-uk6mb
      @VLind-uk6mb Рік тому +1

      @@glen7318 That is mentioned throughout the books. There's a reference in The Nine Tailors to some young servant who caught Bunter's eye and Peter says she is too young for him, to which Bunter wistfully concurs.

  • @glen7318
    @glen7318 4 роки тому +4

    You have a woman's hair my lord!!

  • @Steve_Marsden
    @Steve_Marsden 2 роки тому

    9:19 20:24

  • @mfjdv2020
    @mfjdv2020 7 років тому +5

    Extraordinary attitudes in those days, if the poor widow lady had such difficulty in revealing a perfectly natural circumstance. Nowadays nobody would think anything of it.

    • @Muck006
      @Muck006 6 років тому +13

      Nowadays we are informed of far too much stuff we DON'T want or need to hear instead AND - due to the lack of honour/consequences - people lie a lot. Just look at the media or politicians.

    • @mfjdv2020
      @mfjdv2020 6 років тому +2

      Agree entirely about politicians and journalists, but both these reprehensible groups have been behaving like that for decades. It's nothing new.

    • @censusgary
      @censusgary 5 років тому +8

      Apparently her modesty was due, at least in part, to the fact that her story wasn’t true.

    • @glen7318
      @glen7318 3 роки тому +2

      Its not that extraordinary, people did have sexual affairs outside marriage but they kept them discreet... Look at the Duke of Denver's keeping silent about his affair with the farmer's wife...... He did not wnat to damage her reputation as her husband would problaby slit her throat for her if he found out....

    • @Happyheretic2308
      @Happyheretic2308 2 роки тому

      Not all change is a positive thing. Decency seems to have disappeared from society, and that’s not a good thing at all.

  • @sabineeins2651
    @sabineeins2651 2 роки тому +1

    Terrible voice, that Mrs.Farran

    • @st0rmforce
      @st0rmforce 2 роки тому

      I generally like all the performances in this film, even the slightly hammy ones... but bloody hell, the actress playing Mrs Farran is really jarring. Like she thinks she's in a solo performance

    • @VLind-uk6mb
      @VLind-uk6mb Рік тому +1

      @@st0rmforce She's meant to be an unappealing person: pretentious, affected, prideful. "Our pale Pre-Raphaelite ghost...not our cup of tea!" She is jealous of her husband's friendship with Henry Strachan, which is just the post-pulic-school sort of devoted friendship that seems to have gone out of fashion. She demanded total worship of herself. (Rather puts me in mind of the Duchess of Netflix...)

    • @coloraturaElise
      @coloraturaElise Рік тому

      @@VLind-uk6mb Yes, Farren had to have a reason for running away from her.

  • @edwardromana
    @edwardromana 2 роки тому

    LOL Bible Gay Panic