IAS vs. MBA (HARSH Reality NO ONE Knows) ft.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лип 2022
- 100X Your Chances to get in:
-Management Consulting & Product Management: www.globalgovernanceinitiative.org/impact-fellowship
-Public Policy: www.globalgovernanceinitiativ...
New Cohort starting soon.
______________
Our Future Tech School for AI roles- www.globaltechinitiative.org/
_______
Employment Report: www.globalgovernanceinitiative.org/reviews
-Get your free case study here: www.schrodingerbyggi.org/
On a totally related note, 100X your chances to get in Management & Policy Consulting where you get mentorship by BCG, Mckinsey Consultants, Join Global Network and Get Hired at GGI Impact Fellowship -www.globalgovernanceinitiative.org/
Mam which degree of India bcom , bba is considered more valuable in abroad..if we want to go abroad after graduation..what should be chosen???please reply🙏🙏🙏🙏
I know one of transport commisioner IAS from maharastra shout on OLA CEO and CEO just Try to down his anger & continuosly say sorry to him.. Not everyone become Ambani but yes 8 out of 10 ias become secratery of state or GOI. Success rate is more in IAS to bring change in society or stay in power. And also offcourse top businessman totally relay on Particular political party gov came in power then They think pol. Party or top officers favour them by some tender then there business will benefited and for that matter they run behind officers like nothing. Mark my word no comparison b/w IAS and MBA or Entrprenaur
hundred eyes to weep...hmm maharaj...
your name...reminds me of someone i lost to time...
take care and Stay blessed : )
@@TRA Vaibhav Hulk is that u from Mumbai?
@@TRA what's the career after economics hons? Why did u suggested this course ,can we go abroad if we perform wel in ug n can we get scholarship for foreign studies,what is the career in economics in India n abroad?
Pls reply i really need it
I had a wonderful time chatting with you on this important topic, Shatakshi!
Like your talk very much ..very down to earth...and quite knowledgeable
Sir please reply me
If one wants to go abroad after graduation and wanna good job there then which of the degree bcom or bba is considered valuable in US
@@ankurxarma5261 I m just at the same scenario I want to prepare for upsc during college but also need a good backup
@@MandeepKaur-is1nb take some time yourself to figure out what you would be really passionate about... also get some experience so that it can be useful... later after experience you will know and u may try abroad
Do you need to learn and understand all how govt governance , international relations to perform, guide ,..
With my experience, if a middle class student wants to become an IAS officer . First he should earn money by working in corporate sector. If he feels everything okay in terms of money. Then go and prepare for civil services.
As a middle class boy. I started my preparation in college days and still not get into the rank, surviving without money in hands is highly challenging. So, don't do mistake that I did.
If your parents well settled then go for preparation after graduation itself.
True
Very true. The syllabus and exam is so archaic that if one fails and invests in a few years, he/she becomes worthless in the job market.
Can you please tell ur story
Like which clg ,which grad you did
What rank u got
@@anitirks4439 I agree with you.
True
Real rulers of the society are undiscoverable...~laski.
Power is a Myth.
Everyone is subjugated by other...no need to feel Awe!
This is the debate that happens every month in my family, parents want me to become IAS but I am more inclined to corporate sector.
Highly recommend you to listen to your parents if you are confident to crack IAS
then you should not go into civil services as you will not be able to do justice to the service
It's about materialism or inner soul .
@@aditya37315 you literally summarised all that was said so far...thank you
can you please comment this under abhinav mishras comment
The question shouldn't be who is earning more, as a NASA scientist in America or a government scientist at CERN will never earn a million $ a month or even a year and their wealth won't be comparable to that of a business manager or CEO of a mid-size multi-million firm. the question should be who has more power and opportunity to change human life by their understanding of political, economic, and social information they acquire during their preparation.
True
Well said.
I agree with your point completely.
And now there arises another question that is - why those who contribute to humanity/ human life like Scientists and Socio Economic workers are paid less when they clearly deserve more.
Intact these should be some highest paying jobs.
@@ACE-uo2mn cause of capitalism, private firms increases their productivity from overwork underpaid workers, labor exploitation, tax evasion, market manipulation, and lobbing the democratic government laws for maintaining their own monopolies over the market and destroying actual potential competition early on.
Most innovations and inventions were done by government scientists all over the world, from computers to microchips to touch screens and so ON AND on with public/taxpayer money, and most of these were in the socialist era but In today's imperialist society, once one figure out the solution to the masses' misery and the way to monetize it. we as a society make them invincible lords, "innovators" and even some are self-proclaimed scientists calling themself, entrepreneurs of a new age.
Capitalists don't acknowledge the privileges they were in and I refuse to acknowledge their "so-called risk for reward narrative" too. Capitalist media manipulation had made sure that exploitation by these corporates goes unchecked, no matter what the public interest is will only churn for-profit weather that costs social dismay they won't care, cause after all they can control the narrative.
As rightly said "Mr. Wilford's train must go on" - Snowpiercer
Don't go for UPSC more than two attempts without solid plan B.. because my life already been ruined.. Started in 2013 but failed in last attempt..
I can understand ur disappointment dear brother, hope life works in ur favour in the near future…. U have done ur best … 👍👍
How many years u gave yo upsc
Then you can go for state govt exams like group 1 or 2,it will be easy for you
@@BlaCK_HaT. from 2013 to 2018 then june 2021 to June 22..total 6 to 7 years..
Humm may I ask what are you doing now?
There's no comparison between IAS and other Grade A civil services let alone private sector. I respect everyone's choice but let's get real. Beyond a point it's beyond money and power. That's where Armed forces and Civil services come in and in this there is nothing more dynamic than IAS. They run a country of a billion+ and its every mechanism that should sum it up.
Keep your opinion to urself.
If u really think ias runs the country, i am really impressed with ur knowledge of reality👏👏👏
load of bs
Really you believe in this fiction....A country is running because of a lot of factors...
@@Theactualstoic only for 3 years please correct yourself, The starting point DC and it can act as a judge some criminal cases.But to higher end there is no restriction you will atleast become secretary if not more than that.And since I have done MBA from tier 1 college I can assure you not every one becomes consultant or gets heavy package, plus life of consultant is a hell no work life Balance
Very debatable. I feel a bureaucrat is so engaged in the daily grind of policy implementation and the dictat of higher ups, that to change anything he has to really go out of his way. That level of motivation to bring change against the will of your superiors and working at a payscale much less than private sector, is very rare.
its a service and not a job stop comparing them
Corruption bhi karte h ye log
@@shiva1619 right ✅
Policy implementation itself is so satisfying and innovative if done correctly
This is a talk that broadened my perspective! Thank you Satakshi and Naman❤️❤️
Just no words to say how much helpful this video is for me ...please continue making such videos ...as a 12 grader It helped me so much
I think Top Services in UPSC CSE(IAS,IPS,IFS) is any day better than any other job in India, There are few reasons for that-
1. Diversity of work
2. Direct Impact on masses
3. Work life balance
4. Financial stability, if you want to earn in crore there is also path in that.
5. Social status
6. Power to create impact
7. Range of people with one you are working, one day you are working with 'Top Intellectual' of the specific domain another some day you are working with 'Under privileged' section of a society.
I think that gives more satisfaction to someone else. But no one have to forget that probability to get in Civil Services is very low, so always have PlanB, that's the pragmatic approach.
भाई लास्ट में जाके आईएएस या आईपीएस का कैरियर मंत्री के हाथ में ही होता है वो सिर्फ़ कठपुतली है सिस्टम का. उसको जब बोले उठो उठो, बैठो बैठो. अगर बदलाव करना है तो एमएलए या एमपी बनना पड़ेगा तब जाकर कुछ होगा. वो लॉ बनाते है ये कठपुतली सिर्फ उसका पालन करते है 😆
Nothing is better than a public servant.
But have a good plan B before running behind that.
Well how'd a civil servant earn in crores tho?
@@swathy782 By teaching, content creation and an illegal way of earning( दो नंबर का पैसा)
Good episode. If given another chance i would groom myself to be a religious guru. Most prospective career in India.
Yea . Or a politician both are same these days anyway. Haha
hahaha good one!
Such an amazing conversation! Hope it reaches out to millions of people who are wasting their 20s!
We need more of Naman..He was outstanding.. precise and crisp answers
IAS definitely has more power but this power is only for implementing laws. Using those power for your personal reasons is misuse of power which can lead to punishment.
is this power transferable to next life?
@@prasantakumarpadhi9716 they are king of their district 💪🏼, but they should be selfless with their work
@@Theactualstoic mla mp power only for limited time, after losing election he has no power, but even chief minister cannot remove ias from power
@@aadiliqbalkhan8216 IAS kuch nahi hai sab pisa me nachte hai
IAS is slave of all uneducated and criminal mp mlas....also many ias misuse their power like the couple who got caught for roaming their dog in stadium. All this patriotism is a joke.... everyone only wants money and power for their own advantage.
I liked the way how Naman explained things so neutral and precises with structure answers
I don’t know why but I felt this discussion is tooooooo Elite ! Like kaafi Elite….
In my perspective not everyone becomes ias officer... So with good b school degree I can able to make more money and I will be happy with that..
The middle class is so generalised nowadays that everyone except Ambani and Adani is middle class. There should be a subdivision of the middle class like the lower middle class, the middle middle class and the upper middle class.
Very relatable topic... Question on who holds more power was so well answered by Shatakshi. Naman and your conversation was so informative. Make more of such videos.
*only those who have tasted OR have felt POWER knows the worth of IAS*
or MLA?
@@Hannibal_Lcter😂😂 or CEO
One of the most informative and motivating video I've ever watched on this channel
Thanks
I have watched lots of vedios on career advice but this is what I was trying to find you made my mind thank you so much both of you ❤️.
There is no comparison between upsc vs any service ..it is national service.. money is not everything..at all..
Is it so,Abhinav? Then why they take so much bribe while in service?
@@shreeparna777 you cannot generalise
you are right ias ips has way more respect than any MBA grad earning crores
@@anayasa6103 same applies for the statement given above. It's not about comparison. Either national or not. :-)
@@shreeparna777 it is not but for service which are not frontline.....for any person in armed forces and equivalent has way more respect in society you believ3 it or not
MBA vs IAS? I thought one is a course and other is a job? Sounds like comparing apples to oranges
Thank you for the insightful discussion.
Very mature answers by him, all the best wishes for him
What a power couple. 💕
IAS is not a job; It is a service.
That is why people quit big investment banking jobs to pursue civil service.
I've never heard anyone going from investment banking to IAS
Also people quit UPSC preparation to pursue investment banking because you learn your calling eventually
Loved your content Shatakshi pls keep enlightening 👏👏👏👏
Someone who funds the political party is more powerful than the person who has won the public mandate.
🤫
That's a secret that no one wants to talk including these people.
Actually there is no debate..
Being is Public sector you service the nation and people..
Being in Corporate sector you service your company owner and make him/her more rich and nothing else and my question is where's the satisfaction in that..?
If not IAS pursue your career in academics.. be architect of the next Gen..
You serve an European or American firm and can't compare it with public sector jobs..
he talks very similar like akshat shrivastava as in very clear, logical and intelligent. enjoyed the discussion very much
There should be no comparison to any corporate job with the prestigious charm of IAS, it gives more power to bring change to citizens of the country. These management jobs are self-oriented and money-making jobs. People switch to these jobs only when they couldn't get into government jobs just to survive and earn their livelihood. Group A & Group B government jobs in PSUs, offer the highest package equivalent to their counterparts in the Pvt sector. Also, the Pvt sector has ZERO job security, laying off and reducing the salary, and a toxic environment, which are quite normal in corporate jobs. Any time, one should study diligently and smartly to get into the elite services of IAS/IFS/IRS/IPS
Ur views r to the point n very true
Thanks,@@mayankmishra1615
Civil service is also toxic in the sense that you have to work according to the whims and fancies of politicians. They have little or no power on their own.
Police and government service sucks big time
That's your view
IAS actually sucks for a moral person
The amount of corruption that he has to see in his workplace
Naman sir is in UN & Foreign services- which is comparatively better.
Each town & city has it's Politican Gunda & those who go against him get transferred or worst killed.
IAS ki ecosystem m toh crores apne aap girte h😅😅
Relevant subject great discussion amazing perspectives 💐👌👍
Awesome content 👍🔥
A very insightful session!!!
Definitely no need to debate IAS is IAS.....
Ias is boss of himself,not slaver of corporates
But a slaver of politicians.
You got idea how politicians handle IAS officers?
I got my answer in first 5 minutes. Thanks
Such type of quality conversation and quality content Indian youth need. Thank you maam. It doesn't matter where you work but always try to give back to society by whatever means you can that's what makes us humans
:))
Clearly both Management Consultant or IAS earn enough to buy personal podcast Mic
The man with money is most powerful.
The dark side of this comparison is that people compare it with top tier people (0.1%) of that field , I mean if You did MBA or started a startup that doesn't mean you will become Jeff Bezos , Elon Musk or Ambani or Adani , there are many MBA graduate who doesn't get good post/position that they have imagined and their are many startup that failed/bankrupt even if they had good ideas, so we should count them too !
scientists gets no.1 position , they need to study 35 years just to get postdoctoral experience(PhD, postdoctoral) and forevery One publication in top journals they get good pay you let's say 2.5k dollars , if it has high impact factor then one publication pays 3.5k USD .
But the amount of dedication is mind boggling can just become GM in some company and earn equivalent and try jobs abroad which would pay 100k and upwards
My aim is to give trampoline for my coming generations through IAS/IPS
I literally needed this video
Your voice is very clear and crunchy, what is secret behind this 😅 my pitch is good but voice sounds very unfiltered which affect the quality of communication
You both make sense.
Great content, very informative.
This was a great chat!
Didi, can I get into business consultancy after my undergraduate. I am going to get my BBA-Finance from an university in USA. Please make a dedicated video on this topic. There are many members in my circle who need this information.
Mam just one question.
I want to leave civil & study MBA in the US.
Will I be able to land a job in the US (IN THE NON CIVIL FIELD)?
Or is it not a good career move altogether?
Will I struggle to find jobs?
It is a good career move provided you keep moving and you keep yourself motivated. 👍
Great Conversation !!
I think both of them have power on their own Sector but both of those personal are just earning money. No one of them is seeking for the betterment of agriculture sector. That's why India is loosing young generation of farmers and all those beurocrates and politicians are directly responsible for this damage of our country.
Inqilab Jindabad 🇮🇳
Really well crafted video
Before jumping into prep for upsc do analyse your family financial condition
Hello Mam! Hope you're doing well. I have 3.5 years of experience in operations & did MBA from Tier 3 College. Now, I am struggling to grow and have stable career path because of not doing MBA from a good B-School. Should I go for ISB, IIMA one year program for career growth ? Thanks in Advance 🙂
Go for ISB
Go for IIM, reputed ones, nothing comes close
I am from tier 1 B school tbh honest it won't help better take 1 or 2 year experience more than go to elite colleges outside India, Rest is your decision.
U can do one year MBA from abroad.My friend did one year MBA from Ireland.now he is working with a reputed Australian govt. Bank.
Lovely content shatakshi...loved the insightful discussion between you and Naman 😊
Please do keep bringing such discussions with Naman:)
Apple vs orange, those two jobs are world apart, choose better comp topics.
Well Money>Businessmen>Politicians>Government
I know one of transport commisioner IAS from maharastra shout on OLA CEO and CEO just Try to down his anger & continuosly say sorry to him.. Not everyone become Ambani but yes 8 out of 10 ias become secratery of state or GOI. Success rate is more in IAS to bring change in society or stay in power. And also offcourse businessman totally relay on Particular political party gov came in power then They think pol. Party or top officers favour them by some tender then there business will benefited and for that matter they run behind officers like nothing. Mark my word no comparison b/w IAS and MBA or Entrprenaur
Subscribed!!
At the end of the day, SDE end up earning the most xD
Could you please, let us know what is prerequisite and Procedures to join GGI. Please
I'm not even watching the video but know that IAS is IAS. 1000s of candidates leave their well paying jobs after MBA and write the exam. I know of people who had crores of packages, left the job and came to the services
Many left ias to do mba too
Exactly it's their prospective , some bureaucrats leave for MBA some prepare after doing MBA , but it craze is all over, I myself IIMer left corporate world for upsc.
In my perspective if we look on the the society IAS has the more power in every aspect of field . you can examine the power of an IAS officer when a minister come to a particular are he had to take permission from by IAS of that area while in the case of private sector organization the big hunk like Jeff Bezos ,elon ,ambani have the power in upper level or mainly you can say they have the power of Monopoly .......
Thanks sis
Hello mam how can I connect with you ? I want to learn more from you on this topic ?
You people please don't prepare for IAS , it's good to have low competition . 👌
Target IFS.Indian embassy in Berlin,Germany 🇩🇪.
Thank you ma'am.
Who cares which has more power just do what you like and earn money
How can you even thought of comparing IAS with MBA?
I think it was balanced podcast. Shataskhi was in favour of MBA while Naman was in favour of UPSC.
No match with ias,ips ,ifs....
Rbi governor to foreign secretery to pm advisor.....simply
#mba run company ...but ias run country.....#ias is the initial post.....not the last...(i hope you would google)
Example....you run a multi company or ceo of that company but he is obliged to follow the rules of #IRS
That guy is definitely a sigma
18:56 Absolutely brilliant!
Part 2 please ☺️
mam ...i am a software engineer .........m preparing for upsc.....i want to know am i doing right?
I would like to know about the undergrad degree's relevance in corporate sectors, especially who come from the law background.
Ca karo saath mein
@@Nishantpatale9423 if one is pol sci graduate
Ias ips no doubt more powerful person than any mba guy though from wealth perspective they earn less but the job satisfaction is ultimately high... Plus the power to serve poor it's a service not a job...
And indeed a respectable work . But the problem is many MISFITS got the post and for their own selfish desires diluted the true essence of bureaucracy.
How can one compare with upsc🤣
Yaha asha koi hai jo IAS bankar desh badlna chata hai
I think the most powerful are the conglomerates like Google, Facebook, Amazon and Tata. The people heading these organisations also weird immense power.
For example, Mukesh Ambani can initiate policy changes for the betterment of his business interests.
The decisions taken by these MNCs alter the world for better or worse.
Second are the politicians and last are the IAS/IPS
hey what you did after your graduation to get that govt job
Great content. Thank you
What are your sources of learning
how about IFS ....best of both world pritave + public
I know the secret bro and that is 95% hard work and 5% luck. And do you that only 95 % of the India has this 5% of luck.
i got my ANSWEr IN 5 MINUTES
IAS se koi compare nhi ...job of the das
A Corrupt IAS can fool people 😂😂
Hi Shatakshi, can you please make a video on, MBAs working in Private equity vs MBAs working in Big Tech, thx in advance
har kirana shop owner mba se jyada skilful h
no one knows, then how do u know?
नमन सर आप अच्छे family background से हो और आपने MBA भी कर रखा है पर मैं एक लड़की हूं सामान्य परिवार से मेरे तो parents मुझे पढ़ाना भी ठीक नहीं समझते और न ही पैसा खर्चा करना चाहते हैं।
💐💐👌👍
Us moment