Taliban and ISIS are very different religiously. Taliban is extremist but generally practices traditional Sunni Islam: Maturidi Theology, Hanafi Jurisprudence, Naqshabandi Sufism (Spirituality). ISIS isn't just extremist, it follows a modern religious sect called Salafism. They reject traditional Sunni Islam and consider them heretics and should be murdered. Their Theology is anthropomorphic and literalist; they follow no school in Jurisprudence and they interpret directly from the sources however they like; they reject Sufism in its entirety. That's why they hate each other as much as they hate Shiites. People keep called Al-Qaida and ISIS Sunni when they have been taking direct aim at Sunni establishments. They are far more insane, brutal and deviant.
Taliban: Who are you? ISIS-K: I’m you if you aren’t on drugs. Taliban: Well then, thank goodness for that sweet sweet freedom juice then (Opium and other drugs). (This is a reference on how most of the current ISIS-K recruits are Evil Reactionaries (Even more so than average) Taliban members that believe that The Taliban changed too quickly and The Taliban lost supposed “values” due to supposed changes.)
@@orrorsaness5942 When the Taliban took control in 2001 the opium production dropped under 1% because they said "either you plant another crop in the ground or we burry you in the ground with the opium" . You should be more worried about the drug abuse in your country.
@@TylerSolvestri Nah ISIS and ISIS K kills for fun, Taliban kills when they feel it’s justified to kill, So if you steel something then they cut you’re hands off, if you they feel you are lying when they ask you to say the truth then head off or when you break there rules, while ISIS is like, “oh you are a bit whiter then us guess torture time” a few weeks of torture then head off on live stream. Both bad but ISIS AND ISIS-K is worse much worse, Taliban just wants there way of what justices is and control and people to follow there rules,
Main reason is Taliban are content with just Afghanistan. They literally could ignore the complaints of the Uyghur Muslim population right next to the imaginary border and make deals with china. That is still secular therefore I think it’s going to be overthrown.
Actually no what they want is the United States off their land. That’s their explicit goal, that was bin Ladens stated goal in interviews and in what he wrote. A “caliphate” isn’t “the world” dumbass Lauren
@Anarcho Monarchist Facts! At least you can overdose on drugs if you want to forget about everything in Afghanistan under the modern Taliban. Who knows if you can do that under ISIS-K.
Thanks so much for the excellent material you've been putting out this last week on the situation in Afghanistan! If you were at all so inclined, it'd be awesome if you'd consider making some videos on the larger-scale history of the region. Say, going back at least to the Great Game. Be nice to have some perspective on the "Graveyard of Empires"...
@Ricardo Marín he’s from Medina and someone who doesn’t even understand Arabic saying that Quran isn’t articulate keep reading your English translation buddy
@@Omar-jk8ny He was born and died in Medina. He is a direct decedent of the Prophet threw his daughter Fatimah and Ali AS. He taught Malik ibn Anas and Abu Hanifa. So he knew Arabic to say the least.
Hi everyone! Thanks for tuning in for today's 5 Minute History video. If you enjoyed it let me know by giving me a thumbs up and let me know what your thoughts are regarding the future of Afghanistan in the comments below. If people are interested I might make a dedicated longer video to the rivalry between the Islamic State Khorasan Province and the Taliban within Afghanistan and the rivalry between ISIL and Al-Qaeda across the Muslim World more broadly. *Note: At **5:02** when describing the US service people killed I say 'servicemen' however two of the casualties were women so wanted to rectify that here.*
I enjoyed as always, good work. My only small point you might want to note would be that two of the dead US servicemen you referred to were female. Adding an on screen note possible post upload?
USA: I will “ally” (puppet) you and give you military assistance! UK: America WTF are you doing!!!?!?!??????? Taliban: God bless me… no you are not here to be an ally, but… I’m gonna need all the help I will get.
@@historywithhilbert I'm on my laptop and I've found that I typically don't get notifications from the website (for any video) until I refresh the page or open a new video. I don't know if you're both referring to the app or what though. Great video BTW!
If you notice in all the recent pictures of taliban they are following good trigger discipline. It's as if for the last 20 years US was training the taliban and not the afghan national army. The way those "terrorist" have efficiently defeated the afghan army reminded me of the US shock and awe in Iraq.
Lol so the Taliban actually strengthend their own biggest enemy by liberating all prisoners. But the Afghans still need to learn from the IRA, these are not enough subbranches and splinter groups
The Taliban is being assisted by America (America sending 1-5k in Afghanistan) in the fight against America’s current arch-enemy ISIS. Due to that, The Taliban is listening to America on military advice.
In my opinion it’s either that the Iraqi army got lucky and ISIS was poorly trained Or the Iraqi army is tough as nails and they beat them back On the other hand the ANA was terrible and the Taliban was too well led for them
@@ieatmice751 mix bag the actually Mosul Swat battalion were one of the few units that ISIS would kill on sight or even captured they have the chance to ‘repent’
@abdennour O Afghanistan only had one of the most retarded governments the modern world has ever seen. I doubt Iraq has been selling their hardware to ISIS like them.
@abdennour O They at least had the guts to fight wheras Afghanistan was like "why bother? The US got my back. They just took yet another rural community"
Thank you, as always, for this, and for giving your sources. It is, I fear, impossible to predict what will happen in Afghanistan because there are far too many unknowns: will the Afghans be left alone to decide their own fate, or, yet again, will some other state see a strategic interest in interfering-let us hope not, but I cannot see it taking less than 20 years to sort out, and whether Afghanistan survives as a nation or splits up must be anybody's guess.
It's not called ISIS-K, that's a weird name made up by the media which doesn't make much sense when you know what it means. They're called IS-KP which stands for Islamic State Khorasan Province.
Exactly, I’ve been hearing that every where on western media. If I remember ISIS doesn’t even exist in Syria unless it’s a small part of a town. Same with Iraq I believe. Then these guys in Afghanistan aren’t even the same guys but just have the same ideology so it’s just called IS-K or IS-KP.
@@DoubleBullet The idea that ISIS is non existent in Syria and Iraq is another misconception. They're still there, they've just retransitioned back into a guerilla army from a more conventional force. They hide in the desert between Syria and Iraq and among Bedouin communities that inhabit the area, most of whom hold sympathies to IS. They are have a significant presence in almost every Sunni majority governorate in Iraq, with a more limited presence in the predominantly Shia south. They also have a large presence in their former Syrian territories now occupied by Kurdish communist forces. With regards to IS-KP, IS as a group maintains consistent contact with their worldwide branches, or as they call them, Provinces. But they also allow a lot of autonomy for those branches too far from Iraq and Syria, such as IS-KP, ISWAP (Islamic State West Africa Province), ISCAP (Islamic State Central Africa Province), and many others.
Is the K like a stand in for the upgrade? Kinda like iPhone has the numbers. Edit: As a prior service Marine, I have to laugh at this in order to not cry.
The amazing job this channel with this situation has been top notch. I have an understanding of the culture, trial and ideologies on the ground and some historical context. Other then this channel, only 1 pundit Malcolm nance has been honest. Taliban and ISIS-k are mortal enemies. Believing Taliban are complicit. The idea of a shadow government isn't known in the United States. Dunno if NATO allies explained that negotiations with Taliban, is like negotiating with Labor and not even including Boris Johnson. Those bombing were to destroy Taliban credibility and draw recruits. So glad to find someone explain that not every group is the same. Cable news in the United States has been intellectually dishonest about most things.
Fun fact : In 1990's, the Talibans had jailed hundreds of ISISK members. And when the Taliban gov. was replaced by the Americans, the Americans released them all.
@@boygenius538_8 All those guys would be older by now. I imagine most members of the group, and what makes them so dangerous, is how they can recruit younger members.
@The Homie Nick Gurr Well, mountain warfare, suicide bombings, attacks on educational institutions deemed "un-Islamic", and bombings of infrastructure used to facilitate trade or cooperation with the international community. Yes, you can say that these tactics are general and that other groups carried out such acts before the Taliban existed but they are features of the Taliban's playbook that ISIS-K currently uses, for different objectives, of-course.
That's why I think the Taliban isn't that much of a concern to the world as long as it doesn't shelter terrorists with global aspirations: they seem to be fundamentally concerned with their Islamic state within their own borders. If that leads to the pacification of the country I think it is tolerable, as peace should bring slow modernization.
We want a global Islamic state though 🙂. Muslims world wide supported Taliban to be a province of a future Islamic state and to spread Islamic law and faith.
It would be nice if you could give equal focus to ISIS-K and US casualties, I just found it weird that you didn’t mention the Afghan children killed in the US drone strikes
@1:32 Lemme point this out. The ANA did not want us there. From the track record of green-on-blue to the consistent retreat of its forces, to the almost immediate surrender a couple weeks ago, you can see it. I was on the ground for maybe a day when i noticed it first. Half of them are former mujahedeen or their kids, and the other half are terrified. Also, this war is civil in nature to their eyes, so both sides wanted NATO gone. Every time a leader said so, he was conveniently replaced (except for Kuwait, which retained its monarchy). The only reason ISIS and the Taliban are fighting each other is political- which also makes them all the bad guys, as according to Sharia, you go to hell for killing outside of jihad. So, why they still fighting? Sorry, but its the same answer- money and power. And we have precisely zero place interfering with that, regardless of our interest in the matter. They didn't want us there, and the moment we left, they picked up and kept right on finishing their war.
@AJ Thomas Taliban are mujahids who fought for independence from American and NATO Occupation. They wanted a self governing Afghanistan and didn't wanted foreign soldiers and influence in their nation. They were resistance fighters who fought foreign imperialism for 20 years and now won!
They are at war with both Pakistan and Afghanistan XD, Since the Taliban are now in power, they're now under threat lol And Pakistan.. they already beaten them up and kicked them away from the law-less Tribal Areas XD
@@randomtanker4355 yeap.. although we call them ISKP (Islamic State (of) Khorasan & Pakistan) They martyred two of our Pakistani forces personnel along the Durrand Border… Pakistan has closed many of the Border crossings and has ramped up Military presence along the Border.
Great video as always but you missed out on ISIS-K terrorism in Pakistan with alliance of former TTP members who fled to Afghanistan during Pakistanis militarily offense in Waziristan. ISISK are mostly targeting hazara shia community. In most recent attack they have brutally killed coal miners. ISIS-K fraction is the most brutal in the world. Hope new Taliban government will go after them unlike previous regime who made a deal with those terrorists.
@A Fels that's kinda funny actually. 😄 Anyway ask the democrats party in the U.S and members of the CIA who are democrats about the origins of the African Al-Qaeda
@AJ Thomas well look at India they just closed some churchs and hate crimes against Muslims and Christians minority in India had rise since the hindu centric government rise in India
@AJ Thomas Actually the French thing was due to the mocking of the prophet. Which wouldn't be accepted by any Muslim for that matter mate regardless if radicalization
Taliban and ISIS are very different religiously. Taliban is extremist but generally practices traditional Sunni Islam: Maturidi Theology, Hanafi Jurisprudence, Naqshabandi Sufism (Spirituality). ISIS isn't just extremist, it follows a modern religious sect called Salafism. They reject traditional Sunni Islam and consider them heretics and should be murdered. Their Theology is anthropomorphic and literalist; they follow no school in Jurisprudence and they interpret directly from the sources however they like; they reject Sufism in its entirety. That's why they hate each other as much as they hate Shiites. People keep called Al-Qaida and ISIS Sunni when they have been taking direct aim at Sunni establishments. They are far more insane, brutal and deviant.
They recently martyred two of our PAK-Soldiers along the Durrand line.. Pakistan has taken decisive action… closing alot of the Border crossings and ramped up Military Presence… Now only time will tell what will happen next…
Who they are seems less important than who funds them. Every underground punk kid in the 80s and 90s had a zine, but not all of them turned into Alternative Press. Longevity, power, influence all need to be subsidized by someone or some organization.
Welp at least the Taliban are armed to the teeth now, and they clearly want to fight for Afghanistan. I do know the Taliban were fighting ISIS a few years ago, I remember hearing about it.
@@reaperoftheyeari4481 It is the origins of the Aryans. Recently aryan history has become a trending topic. Croatian nationalists celebrate their Kurdish and Persian ancestry. So do some Irish and Scottish. Also it is the homeland of Sanskrit and Avestan languages, from which all Indo European languages stem from...
Not one presenter, not one, has presented the actual Hadith or Islamic texts !!! Not even it's actual historical Islamic context. I'm going to sit back and watch this world burn down to the ground!
For the record, their twin suicide attack on the airport didn't kill 182 people, most of the afghans killed were shot by panicking US soldiers and marines. The bombing killed probably 30-40 civilians plus the 13 service members
Will you make a video for ISIS West Africa province? They're hardly in the news even though they got Shekau killed and have taken large swathes of lands in recent years.
@@horatiuscocles8052 Yeah i did but quite frankly they want dominion over the whole country so they should be called ISIS-A. And secondly there not a new group at all there just old ISIS who retreated to Khorasan.
It's pretty incredible they were able to hold as much ground as they did with that few people. Sure, it isn't easy terrain but the Taliban appears far larger and well organized while being familiar with it
Russia, Iran, the Taliban and others have been complaining about the US transporting ISIS fighters to Afghanistan for years. No surprise they show up out of no where after the US lost
Sorry but northen alliemce has been defeated thankfully in just 5 DAYS now the taliban has full control of the country. and isis k have nothing on taliban
nothing scaryer then a sub branch of a sub branch
Basically a twig
it either gets water downed or crazier
What do you mean?
@Ricardo Marín based
ISIS isn’t a sub branch of anything. So it’s a branch of an organization. ISIS covers a large part of the globe. From the Philippines to Algeria.
The sequel we didn't want but the one we'll probably get
🟨 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
ROUND 2
Of course because Americans can only view things in terms of films they’ve seen. Every dipshit has to make some kind of clever comment
Let’s hope just like almost every other sequel, this sequel is also bad quality.
@@hopperthemarxist8533 you’re communist so you don’t have an opinion
ISIS: let's be guerrilla fighters in Afghanistan.
Taliban: nooooo, only we can do that.
It's going to be interesting to see how they fare against a guerilla enemy in the same terrain from which they waged a guerilla war for 20 years
how about no guerrilla fighters, that'd be great
If i was forced to pick one side, i would choose Taliban lol xd
Fair enough, it's their country, why should they want an American asset doing bombings and terrorism in their country?
@@lance-biggums American asset?
You mean by Afghan Government, NATO or ISIS? 😏😏😏
The sequel to the 2015s we didn’t want
lol aye totally agree
And there was so much to choose from..
LOOK TURK
@Ricardo Marín 🟡 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
I'd love to see a video about the Panjshir Resistance in Afghanistan.
That video should be out on Friday ;)
It won't be very long.
I dunno man, but it seems the Panjshir resistance seems to be doomed
@Ricardo Marín 🏮SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
the brits love them a handsome lad whose a chip off the old block
Taliban: Who are you?
ISIS-K: I'm you but even more radical
Taliban and ISIS are very different religiously. Taliban is extremist but generally practices traditional Sunni Islam: Maturidi Theology, Hanafi Jurisprudence, Naqshabandi Sufism (Spirituality). ISIS isn't just extremist, it follows a modern religious sect called Salafism. They reject traditional Sunni Islam and consider them heretics and should be murdered. Their Theology is anthropomorphic and literalist; they follow no school in Jurisprudence and they interpret directly from the sources however they like; they reject Sufism in its entirety. That's why they hate each other as much as they hate Shiites. People keep called Al-Qaida and ISIS Sunni when they have been taking direct aim at Sunni establishments. They are far more insane, brutal and deviant.
Taliban: Who are you?
ISIS-K: I’m you if you aren’t on drugs.
Taliban: Well then, thank goodness for that sweet sweet freedom juice then (Opium and other drugs).
(This is a reference on how most of the current ISIS-K recruits are Evil Reactionaries (Even more so than average) Taliban members that believe that The Taliban changed too quickly and The Taliban lost supposed “values” due to supposed changes.)
@@dinomar7818 They are both similarly violent. The difference one is way more organized and populous
@@orrorsaness5942 When the Taliban took control in 2001 the opium production dropped under 1% because they said "either you plant another crop in the ground or we burry you in the ground with the opium" . You should be more worried about the drug abuse in your country.
@@TylerSolvestri Nah ISIS and ISIS K kills for fun, Taliban kills when they feel it’s justified to kill, So if you steel something then they cut you’re hands off, if you they feel you are lying when they ask you to say the truth then head off or when you break there rules, while ISIS is like, “oh you are a bit whiter then us guess torture time” a few weeks of torture then head off on live stream.
Both bad but ISIS AND ISIS-K is worse much worse, Taliban just wants there way of what justices is and control and people to follow there rules,
ISIS-K when the Taliban just isn’t enough.
they invented another taliban after this war
ISIS-K is just Modern Taliban not overdosed in Opium.
Main reason is Taliban are content with just Afghanistan. They literally could ignore the complaints of the Uyghur Muslim population right next to the imaginary border and make deals with china. That is still secular therefore I think it’s going to be overthrown.
@RedPill Crusader crusaders were useless, Saladin made them his bitch.
Taliban: Look, we took back Afghanistan what else could you want?
ISIS-K: What do I want? I want the world!
Actually no what they want is the United States off their land. That’s their explicit goal, that was bin Ladens stated goal in interviews and in what he wrote. A “caliphate” isn’t “the world” dumbass Lauren
@@hopperthemarxist8533 its a joke! Lol
@@hopperthemarxist8533
Damn it, dude.
You’re overthinking it.
@@hopperthemarxist8533 ISIS wants to conquer the world though
@@hopperthemarxist8533 A caliphate strives to be the world😅.
ISIS literally aims to convert the whole world...by force.
Lesson: don't use the Arabic equivalent of comic sans on your flag if you want to gain power in Afghanistan.
🟣SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
@@natashagupta4691 lame
This kinda makes the Taliban look like the good guys lmao.
Because ISIS-K is even more bad guy than Taliban.
🔺SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
I mean, ISIS literally just bombed Kabul so yeah, monsters like them make the Taliban seem like better people.
@@TaikaviittaX ISIS-K’s just The Taliban if The Taliban literally never changed.
@Anarcho Monarchist Facts! At least you can overdose on drugs if you want to forget about everything in Afghanistan under the modern Taliban. Who knows if you can do that under ISIS-K.
Thanks so much for the excellent material you've been putting out this last week on the situation in Afghanistan! If you were at all so inclined, it'd be awesome if you'd consider making some videos on the larger-scale history of the region. Say, going back at least to the Great Game.
Be nice to have some perspective on the "Graveyard of Empires"...
I feel sad, when will the Afghans catch a break? When will the 60s come back for them?
They don't want it clearly.
I sincerely hope it's sooner rather than later.
@@MasonBryant the ignorance in your comment is astounding.
When will the sixties come back for all of us. I want the sixties back in LatAm as well, but pre-1964
not soon enough
The book about the Afghan papers was realeased on the 31st of august. Anyone who wants read the mess in Afghanistan. Good place to start.
"There are four things of which little is much: Fire, enmity, poverty, and illness"
- Ja'far as Sadiq (جعفر الصادق الإمام)
@Ricardo Marín enmity means hatred or a hostile feeling towards someone.
@Ricardo Marín he is descendent of the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)
🛑SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
@Ricardo Marín he’s from Medina and someone who doesn’t even understand Arabic saying that Quran isn’t articulate keep reading your English translation buddy
@@Omar-jk8ny He was born and died in Medina. He is a direct decedent of the Prophet threw his daughter Fatimah and Ali AS.
He taught Malik ibn Anas and Abu Hanifa. So he knew Arabic to say the least.
Hi everyone! Thanks for tuning in for today's 5 Minute History video. If you enjoyed it let me know by giving me a thumbs up and let me know what your thoughts are regarding the future of Afghanistan in the comments below. If people are interested I might make a dedicated longer video to the rivalry between the Islamic State Khorasan Province and the Taliban within Afghanistan and the rivalry between ISIL and Al-Qaeda across the Muslim World more broadly.
*Note: At **5:02** when describing the US service people killed I say 'servicemen' however two of the casualties were women so wanted to rectify that here.*
I enjoyed as always, good work. My only small point you might want to note would be that two of the dead US servicemen you referred to were female. Adding an on screen note possible post upload?
Yes, longer video please
Hou nou eens op met dat neppe geforceerde accent.
@@ally_crawford Thanks for letting me know I'll add that into the description as a correction!
Yes PLEASE!!!
ISIS K is like regular ISIS but you can get it to go faster if you tweak the BIOS
@Karl Marx no doubt ISIS is puppet of Israel
When your cheat code gets used against you...
Taliban: We did it! We reconquered our land from US!
Isis-K: allow us to introduce ourselves...
USA: I will “ally” (puppet) you and give you military assistance!
UK: America WTF are you doing!!!?!?!???????
Taliban: God bless me… no you are not here to be an ally, but… I’m gonna need all the help I will get.
actually taliban are 10 x as poweful as isis k
isis k are just foreign fighters. they will be caught soon
@@SherKhan-rd9uw Is that why most of ISIS-K’s recruits are mostly those disillusioned by The Taliban changing with the times?
@@orrorsaness5942 i dont understand what u mean lol
@@SherKhan-rd9uw Watch the video again. The video stated that ISIS-K’s recruits are mostly those disillusioned with current Taliban.
I didn't get the notification for this video for almost an hour.
That's strange, it was instantly demonetised which may have something to do with it..
@@historywithhilbert I'm on my laptop and I've found that I typically don't get notifications from the website (for any video) until I refresh the page or open a new video. I don't know if you're both referring to the app or what though. Great video BTW!
As a wise man once said
Let them fight
Ahh what a classic Godzilla reference
Your 5 min videos rock, Hilbert.
a good idea for a video would be the Colombian conflict and its guerrillas
The FARC is certainly on my list of 5 Minute History videos to be made.
@@historywithhilbert FARC and ELN
Love your well-researched videos! Keep up the great work
How do you know they are base in fact. Are you there?
If you notice in all the recent pictures of taliban they are following good trigger discipline. It's as if for the last 20 years US was training the taliban and not the afghan national army. The way those "terrorist" have efficiently defeated the afghan army reminded me of the US shock and awe in Iraq.
Nothing like the shock and awe campaign. Resistance wasn’t crushed. Provincial governors handed entire swaths of Afghanistan over to the Taliban
US army trained afghan soldiers, who joined taliban laterm
Trigger discipline isn’t something exclusive to Americans. It’s not hard to figure out that if you don’t want to shoot finger off the trigger.
There is also so many cases of the Afghan army just not being good even either US training
Less history with Hilbert more present with Hilbert
🟢SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
So happy to see your video
"Real Gs move in silence. Like Lasagna"- ISIS-K, maybe
The most random of a comment ive seen
Lol so the Taliban actually strengthend their own biggest enemy by liberating all prisoners. But the Afghans still need to learn from the IRA, these are not enough subbranches and splinter groups
The Taliban is being assisted by America (America sending 1-5k in Afghanistan) in the fight against America’s current arch-enemy ISIS. Due to that, The Taliban is listening to America on military advice.
Isis makes the Taliban look like girl scouts.
The Taliban gave them a good hiding though. Guess we'll see how it pans out.
In my opinion it’s either that the Iraqi army got lucky and ISIS was poorly trained
Or the Iraqi army is tough as nails and they beat them back
On the other hand the ANA was terrible and the Taliban was too well led for them
@@ieatmice751 mix bag the actually Mosul Swat battalion were one of the few units that ISIS would kill on sight or even captured they have the chance to ‘repent’
@abdennour O Afghanistan only had one of the most retarded governments the modern world has ever seen. I doubt Iraq has been selling their hardware to ISIS like them.
@abdennour O They at least had the guts to fight wheras Afghanistan was like "why bother? The US got my back. They just took yet another rural community"
Thank you, as always, for this, and for giving your sources. It is, I fear, impossible to predict what will happen in Afghanistan because there are far too many unknowns: will the Afghans be left alone to decide their own fate, or, yet again, will some other state see a strategic interest in interfering-let us hope not, but I cannot see it taking less than 20 years to sort out, and whether Afghanistan survives as a nation or splits up must be anybody's guess.
🔸SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
This isn't 5 minutes history. This is 5 minutes 32 seconds history! Disregard everything.
:31 seconds
Short answer: Islamic State - Khorason Province
ISKP is this the K-pop army people are talking about
Someone I went to school with was one of the soldiers that got blown up by this group. He was two years younger than me
Damn that’s tough
I can only hope that some good comes out of all this in the long term.. because the short term is looking very grim indeed.
Are you married, do you have kids and a sustainable future, because the invaded countries don't have those.
Really respect the effort put into pronunciation :)
It's not called ISIS-K, that's a weird name made up by the media which doesn't make much sense when you know what it means. They're called IS-KP which stands for Islamic State Khorasan Province.
Exactly, I’ve been hearing that every where on western media. If I remember ISIS doesn’t even exist in Syria unless it’s a small part of a town. Same with Iraq I believe. Then these guys in Afghanistan aren’t even the same guys but just have the same ideology so it’s just called IS-K or IS-KP.
@@DoubleBullet The idea that ISIS is non existent in Syria and Iraq is another misconception. They're still there, they've just retransitioned back into a guerilla army from a more conventional force. They hide in the desert between Syria and Iraq and among Bedouin communities that inhabit the area, most of whom hold sympathies to IS. They are have a significant presence in almost every Sunni majority governorate in Iraq, with a more limited presence in the predominantly Shia south. They also have a large presence in their former Syrian territories now occupied by Kurdish communist forces. With regards to IS-KP, IS as a group maintains consistent contact with their worldwide branches, or as they call them, Provinces. But they also allow a lot of autonomy for those branches too far from Iraq and Syria, such as IS-KP, ISWAP (Islamic State West Africa Province), ISCAP (Islamic State Central Africa Province), and many others.
I can’t wait for the new history textbooks
Is the K like a stand in for the upgrade? Kinda like iPhone has the numbers.
Edit: As a prior service Marine, I have to laugh at this in order to not cry.
Bruh don’t cry lmao just accept it
@@refrainfromevil1377 That's all we can do at this point.
The "K" in ISIS-K stands for Khorasan, which was a name for various Persian and Turkic kingdoms in Central Asia before and after the Muslim conquest
K stands for kindergarden cuties
Very interesting. This area will never be peaceful, as it seems. Thumbs up for the good explanation of this chaos!
Short answer: CIA
Long answer: Central Intelligence Agency
Democrats actually
@@kaljamaha22 the entire russia
Short answer: the NWO
Long answer: THE NEW WORLD ORDER
No proof
The amazing job this channel with this situation has been top notch. I have an understanding of the culture, trial and ideologies on the ground and some historical context.
Other then this channel, only 1 pundit Malcolm nance has been honest.
Taliban and ISIS-k are mortal enemies. Believing Taliban are complicit. The idea of a shadow government isn't known in the United States. Dunno if NATO allies explained that negotiations with Taliban, is like negotiating with Labor and not even including Boris Johnson. Those bombing were to destroy Taliban credibility and draw recruits.
So glad to find someone explain that not every group is the same. Cable news in the United States has been intellectually dishonest about most things.
Fun fact :
In 1990's, the Talibans had jailed hundreds of ISISK members.
And when the Taliban gov. was replaced by the Americans, the Americans released them all.
ISISK didn’t exist in the 90s…
@@zetazimmer4769 Hell that's more than a decade before ISIS even became a thing
@@zetazimmer4769 perhaps the people who eventually formed the group is what he’s referring to
@@boygenius538_8 All those guys would be older by now. I imagine most members of the group, and what makes them so dangerous, is how they can recruit younger members.
Power vacuums suck
Great job herbert.
Thanks Hilbert
Taliban: “ ISIS-K, where did you learn all this terror, guerrilla warfare, and suicide bombing ?”
ISIS K: “ I ..I learned it from you !”.
So you are saying ISIS-k is trained by Taliban
@The Homie Nick Gurr ISIS certainly picked up several tactics from the Taliban.
@@KingshukMonsur No, but their tactics are partly inspired by that of the Taliban.
@The Homie Nick Gurr Well, mountain warfare, suicide bombings, attacks on educational institutions deemed "un-Islamic", and bombings of infrastructure used to facilitate trade or cooperation with the international community. Yes, you can say that these tactics are general and that other groups carried out such acts before the Taliban existed but they are features of the Taliban's playbook that ISIS-K currently uses, for different objectives, of-course.
@@Derzto Lol, I was making a joke .
The media created that Isis-k name the actual name is ISKP (Islamic state of khorasan province.
Yup, even the original ISIS does not refer to themselves as ISIS
Next video: al-Qaeda on the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS).
😂😂😂
@@ok00001 Yes indeed.
That's why I think the Taliban isn't that much of a concern to the world as long as it doesn't shelter terrorists with global aspirations: they seem to be fundamentally concerned with their Islamic state within their own borders. If that leads to the pacification of the country I think it is tolerable, as peace should bring slow modernization.
We want a global Islamic state though 🙂.
Muslims world wide supported Taliban to be a province of a future Islamic state and to spread Islamic law and faith.
In a way it reminds me of how Vietnam had it's own "Vietnam" as soon as we left
respect for being unbiased
It would be nice if you could give equal focus to ISIS-K and US casualties, I just found it weird that you didn’t mention the Afghan children killed in the US drone strikes
Because that's not what this video was about
@@nodnoc he mentions the US soldier casualties but not the afghan children that also died, that is weird
The new boogeyman of the times. That's who.
Taliban to ISIS: GET OUT OF MY SWAMP!
Where are you sourcing this information?
I've got sources in the description
@1:32
Lemme point this out.
The ANA did not want us there. From the track record of green-on-blue to the consistent retreat of its forces, to the almost immediate surrender a couple weeks ago, you can see it. I was on the ground for maybe a day when i noticed it first. Half of them are former mujahedeen or their kids, and the other half are terrified. Also, this war is civil in nature to their eyes, so both sides wanted NATO gone. Every time a leader said so, he was conveniently replaced (except for Kuwait, which retained its monarchy).
The only reason ISIS and the Taliban are fighting each other is political- which also makes them all the bad guys, as according to Sharia, you go to hell for killing outside of jihad.
So, why they still fighting? Sorry, but its the same answer- money and power. And we have precisely zero place interfering with that, regardless of our interest in the matter. They didn't want us there, and the moment we left, they picked up and kept right on finishing their war.
could you do a video on the panjshir region and the northen allinence in afghanistsan?
I suddenly respect the Taliban slightly more knowing that they *don't* want to take over the world
@AJ Thomas Taliban are mujahids who fought for independence from American and NATO Occupation. They wanted a self governing Afghanistan and didn't wanted foreign soldiers and influence in their nation. They were resistance fighters who fought foreign imperialism for 20 years and now won!
No, but Taliban’s ally, Al-Qaeda does.
ISIS can barely take over Syria let alone the world
Why would you even think they want to take over the world? What an american mindset.
@@Xfighter000 Sometimes people think that due to the fact that Al Qaeda wants to in the future and Taliban is their ally.
Hello Hilbert.
I would be interested in a video on connection between ISIS and its variants and Pakistan
They are at war with both Pakistan and Afghanistan XD,
Since the Taliban are now in power, they're now under threat lol
And Pakistan.. they already beaten them up and kicked them away from the law-less Tribal Areas XD
@@randomtanker4355 yeap.. although we call them ISKP (Islamic State (of) Khorasan & Pakistan)
They martyred two of our Pakistani forces personnel along the Durrand Border…
Pakistan has closed many of the Border crossings and has ramped up Military presence along the Border.
Shhhh we don't talk about Pakistan's support of terrorist groups.. Lol
Great video as always but you missed out on ISIS-K terrorism in Pakistan with alliance of former TTP members who fled to Afghanistan during Pakistanis militarily offense in Waziristan.
ISISK are mostly targeting hazara shia community. In most recent attack they have brutally killed coal miners.
ISIS-K fraction is the most brutal in the world. Hope new Taliban government will go after them unlike previous regime who made a deal with those terrorists.
I would be asking a better question how far ISIS reached beyond Iraq & Syria?
Considering the timing of these recent events.
@A Fels that's kinda funny actually. 😄
Anyway ask the democrats party in the U.S and members of the CIA who are democrats about the origins of the African Al-Qaeda
@AJ Thomas well look at India they just closed some churchs and hate crimes against Muslims and Christians minority in India had rise since the hindu centric government rise in India
@AJ Thomas
Actually the French thing was due to the mocking of the prophet. Which wouldn't be accepted by any Muslim for that matter mate regardless if radicalization
These guys legit went to ISIS occupied territory and just were like ''Yeah this is cool, we should do this''
Ah thanks for clear that up so it's just Special-K
Qorasani Daesh is in Kolkata as well they killed 2 people in my aunt’s neighborhood a few years ago
All these Muslims fighting eachother.... Religion of peace
Taliban and ISIS are very different religiously. Taliban is extremist but generally practices traditional Sunni Islam: Maturidi Theology, Hanafi Jurisprudence, Naqshabandi Sufism (Spirituality). ISIS isn't just extremist, it follows a modern religious sect called Salafism. They reject traditional Sunni Islam and consider them heretics and should be murdered. Their Theology is anthropomorphic and literalist; they follow no school in Jurisprudence and they interpret directly from the sources however they like; they reject Sufism in its entirety. That's why they hate each other as much as they hate Shiites. People keep called Al-Qaida and ISIS Sunni when they have been taking direct aim at Sunni establishments. They are far more insane, brutal and deviant.
They recently martyred two of our PAK-Soldiers along the Durrand line..
Pakistan has taken decisive action… closing alot of the Border crossings and ramped up Military Presence…
Now only time will tell what will happen next…
Although Note, we Pakistani’s call them
ISKP (Islamic State ,of, Khorasan-Pakistan)
🌓SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
@@natashagupta4691 no…
Stop copy pasting this stuff everywhere…
Who they are seems less important than who funds them. Every underground punk kid in the 80s and 90s had a zine, but not all of them turned into Alternative Press. Longevity, power, influence all need to be subsidized by someone or some organization.
They got lots of money from looting Iraq and its oil reserves(ironic)
Never heard of them before the recent events
Welp at least the Taliban are armed to the teeth now, and they clearly want to fight for Afghanistan. I do know the Taliban were fighting ISIS a few years ago, I remember hearing about it.
🌕SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE HILBERT
It’s actually IS-K, not Isis-K which would make no sense. IS-K is trying to restore the former state of Khorashan .
Khorasan, Samarkand... Historically very important, ancient Aryanam, origin of European culture and language...
They are important in Persian culture how ever I'm not sure if They are the origin of European culture
@@reaperoftheyeari4481 It is the origins of the Aryans. Recently aryan history has become a trending topic. Croatian nationalists celebrate their Kurdish and Persian ancestry. So do some Irish and Scottish. Also it is the homeland of Sanskrit and Avestan languages, from which all Indo European languages stem from...
Not one presenter, not one, has presented the actual Hadith or Islamic texts !!! Not even it's actual historical Islamic context. I'm going to sit back and watch this world burn down to the ground!
I was hoping the K stood for "Killas", like "Isis killas". I thought a small band of brothers was uniting to take on the tyranny together.
Funded by CIA Corporation Ltd
For the record, their twin suicide attack on the airport didn't kill 182 people, most of the afghans killed were shot by panicking US soldiers and marines. The bombing killed probably 30-40 civilians plus the 13 service members
Holy Christ this is as complicated as a Spanish soap opera
You should rename your channel to Reading Wikipedia with Hilbert.
It is bad I only know khorasan because EU4?
It's actually ISKP Islamic State in Khorasan Province, ISIS K makes it sound like a ceral brand
I know guerilla is a word of Spanish origin, but in English it's pronounced gorilla 😎
🦍
A global caliphate? Fuck that and a bag of chips!
🇺🇸 1970s: let’s create extremists to fight the USSR.
🇺🇸2021: let’s create extremists to fight the extremists that deafened both the USA and USSR.
Dont forget Pakistan
Sounds like healthy cereal
Egyptian gods- the sequel
ISIS-K sound like a brand of Kellogs Cereal.
Why did you include the flag of Nepal ?
Influence never reached Nepal.
Will you make a video for ISIS West Africa province? They're hardly in the news even though they got Shekau killed and have taken large swathes of lands in recent years.
“They kilt my dawg Biggie”
Anyone who trying to instill power through fear is a coward imo. I’d rather lead people through hope.
interesting alignments. who's who. who's in my sights will do.
Flash Backs to Mini Vietnam 🇻🇳…
Now Afghanistan gonna have their version of Taliban vs Mini Taliban
😂
dumb thing to say
Taliban and isis are 2 whole diffrent people and taliban can easily defeat those isis losers
Karma is a bitch, ain’t it? Taliban now fighting insurgents. I’m definitely living in a parallel universe.
Adding the K seems cheesy, To be honest there just plain old ISIS still or at least be ISIS-A to make more sense.
did you even watch the video? the k stands for khorasan
@@horatiuscocles8052 Yeah i did but quite frankly they want dominion over the whole country so they should be called ISIS-A. And secondly there not a new group at all there just old ISIS who retreated to Khorasan.
@@RomanHistoryFan476AD ISIS-K is there since before the fall of ISIL
@@horatiuscocles8052 IISL, ISIS, ISIS-K how many names are there for these clowns.
@@RomanHistoryFan476AD Only a spoonful
It's pretty incredible they were able to hold as much ground as they did with that few people. Sure, it isn't easy terrain but the Taliban appears far larger and well organized while being familiar with it
If history has taught anything it’s that war in Afghanistan seldom goes how you expect on paper
Just came to say that without my glasses on this thumbnail picture looked like abunch of roblox terrorists.
Here's the thing, if this group has people from Lashkar E Khurasan, then the entire world is in trouble, cause those bastards have no heart, no mercy!
Something aint adding up, so why would the taliban release them?
They probably just escaped.
@@davidesparza3637 now that would make sense
Imagine the see eye hey was involved and you'll see the bigger picture
Russia, Iran, the Taliban and others have been complaining about the US transporting ISIS fighters to Afghanistan for years. No surprise they show up out of no where after the US lost
The Taliban listened To US advice and released them “By the grace of Allah” I bet.
Maybe the US shouldn’t have transported ISIS fighters from Syria to Afghanistan?
Why not? Sit back and enjoy the show. 🔥
Let the Taliban and ISIS-K fight each other while the National Resistance Front (aka Northern Alliance 2.0) continues to hold out in Panjshir Valley.
Sorry but northen alliemce has been defeated thankfully in just 5 DAYS
now the taliban has full control of the country.
and isis k have nothing on taliban