Exploring why Lady GaGa Scrapped the original LG5 album Concept
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
- Exploring the story behind the beginning stages of Lady gaga fifth studio 2016 album Joanne that had a different sound and concept staring in 2015, and even a song called Frankenstein that was rumor to be on the album that got scrapped
- Social Media
TikTok: / playlistpop
Twitter: / seeber_edward
Instagram: / edwardseeber
TikTok: vm.tiktok.com/...
UA-cam: / @edwardseeber
-Music used in video
Daily - lukrembo
Tower - lukrembo
boba tea - lukrembo
I Dont Need U 2 Say Anything - le gang
#ladygaga #lg #joanne #frankenstein
Hear me out. LG7 IS ORIGINAL LG5 UNDERCOVER.
YES.
Bet.
Rumors are that some of the scrapped OG LG5 tracks are being updated for LG7.
@@inmyrestlessdreams. that would be elite, artists should do that more often to test their comeback before their album release ;)
@@leftermihai9637 if so i am readyyyy 🙏✨
I think that Gaga figured out that the earlier RedOne stuff wouldn't fit the Joanne theme anymore. Joanne might not be the pop, electronic dance album we expected, buuut it is a really sweet humble moment in her catalogue, and it really showed a different side of her, and tied in very well with ASIB era, and kind of rebranded her as a more serious artist with a musical range.
Absolutely!
Actually, I think that Perfect Illusion, John Wayne, Diamond Heart & Dancin' In Circles could've been considered for original LG5 because they have that dark not country sound, but we never know how it really was but the fact that they're stand out from the rest of the album is definitely a fact.
@@dragonicelv exactly, and even though it was sonically different it still had those songs like "dancin in circles" & "john wayne" that had the gaga we loved from her pop, electronic dance albums
Honestly i believe a-yo couldve been one too like energy wise and replace the guitar with synths similar to the ones one money honey
I don't agree with this at all. She already had plenty of musical range, and her voice from an overall performance standpoint PEAKED* during ARTPOP. She was doing other things like that insane Sting tribute in 2015 or w/e and singing Imagine. She didn't need to prove to anybody that she was vocally talented at that point. 🙂↔️ Just the basic bitches and bible grannies who couldn't appreciate her amazing pop music because it wasn't 'normie' enough or heteronormative enough for them.. If we're being really fuckin so fuckin real here. 💯
we got robbed!! but the LG7 snippets ARE THE SH*T!!!
Abracadabra is
@@liam4590 i cant wait for LG7 🎶✨
I've Become A Zombie/Notorious Being sounds like it will be the new Mary Jane Holland
And Girlfriend reminds me of G.U.Y.
I think at the end, Joanne was the best choice for Gaga's career, as it was completely out of her comfort zone, and so different from her previous material...and even if people say that it "flopped" or that "it is her worst", I think it was a necessary record to move on into new phases of her artistry and career. Because, as much as I love pop, I understand that a star like Gaga needs to evolve and explore different sounds, concepts, ideas, genres and elements, just like she did in Joanne with the incorporation of a more folk vibe, 60s pop and rock and country. I think at the end she made the right decision, because otherwise her career wouldn't have moved onto the AISB soundtrack and Gucci and Joker and Jazz/Cabaret, and she would've stayed stagnant in plastic pop sounds, just like her fellow contemporary whose name starts with a K and ends in a y.
@@MsElectricLover that is a good point, it's important to keep growing and evolving we already do as people so why not artist, sure its scary to try new things but it's trying those new things that lead to growth and new inspirations to create new things, if she didnt do joanne some ppl wouldve said she doing the same thing, she not growing & etc and there already ppl saying they miss the old gaga (another comment we see happen to artist as time continues) so may as well try something new and follow what feels right for you in the moment, although not many fans liked the direction she went into it was perfect for going into AISB and with doing that she become a successful actress that opened more doors for her along with new fans and old fans who came around to her new direction, you are right if she didnt do joanne this may have not happened
The shade
I'm glad Gaga did Joanne the way it is! That album solidified her as an artist that deserves respect across different generations and it paved the way for the huge success of A Star Is Born era!
It cleaned her saturated image after ARTPOP. Depriving the public of "original Gaga" for a while eventually made people enjoy Chromatica more than they would if every single album was dance pop.
@@RenatoPereira95 THIS!!
‘2025’? Wow, her vision…
@@jeremifrancisco1 oops, my mistake 😅😭
Bloodpop really ruined ‘free woman’ I’ve been scared since.
Bloodpop made her turn her sad Chromatica ballads into dance songs. (Ik he was just trying to cheer her up from her depression) But imagine if we got a Chromatica EP with the original piano ballads of the songs?!? But no, we got Dawn of Chromatica
I blame bloodpop for both the orginal lg5 and lg6 being scrapped
delusional
The original Intel collab will forever be the biggest mystery to me. 😮
@@TheSkinnyZ same, it probably wouldve been such an iconic moment and a great way in taking us into the next era with a snippet
I'm anisko from gagadaily .. thank u for including my name in your amazing video i really appreciate that .
I shared many information about the original lg5 and i've so talkative about Frankensteined and i had the honor to listen to it from redone himself when he visited my country tunisia .. and trust me guys the song is better than any other song she released .. it's even better than bad romance .. it's literally the next level and it's nothing like any other song she released before .
@@rebelrebel2567 of course thank for sharing the information you know about LG5 it was helpful, i didnt even think they could outdo bad romance thats awesome you got a chance to hear frankensteined by redone what an honor, i hope gaga decides to release it one day
I liked chromatic album. It reminded me of her older albums. I'm so excited for lg7!!
@@rosies69 same it was a fun album to listen too especially at the time when the world was in lock down, i am ready for LG7!!
So glad we got Joanne - I needed that album.
@@zee3499 same, its a great album
I often felt LG5 was originally a more disco driven album and then she pivotted...just gut feeling
@@JakeCoasters it would be amazing to hear a full disco album from gaga
People and other Little Monsters are claiming that we got robbed during LG5 and shit but cant you see tho, if Gaga went back to RedOne and made LG5 another pop album, she would've taken the same route that Katy Perry is taking right now with her KP6 and look what that got her, minus the rapist issue of course. People are already getting tired of the crazy Gaga we knew after Artpop and making LG5 another Gaga-pop genre wouldnt save her, she needs to reinvent herself and thank God thats what she did. I know Joanne wasnt that big as her first four albums but still, it made millions and it even made the public know her better. Plus, it also didnt made us tired of her craziness, it even made us hunger of her craziness.
N the purest tea was served ❤❤❤❤❤❤,paws up monsters
@@jonrebalonzo8248 exactly, it’s good for artists to try new things and expand their horizons bc it brings new ideas. If she had done pop/dance again, things might not have played out the same way, especially since the general public had already grown bored of it at that point and as you said, we now hunger for her doing camp bc she put it aside for a while
mark ronson when i catch you
i blame david bowie and ryan murphy
fr
Cool.. "chills" has gone into pop music content now! Love it!... number 15 😂
I truly think this is where there was a fork in the timeline, and somehow I ended up on the Joanne timeline. I wished I was in the LG5 timeline
@@j797s25 you didnt have any favorites off joanne?
I really hope LG7 delivers in a way Joanne and Chromatica could only wish they did 😩
@@TylerBR97 what did you think of the snippet she shared? i automatically was thinking artpop from hearing it
@@Playlist_Pop it gave me hope but I’ve remained incredibly cautious. The CBT teaser reminds me of TFM, Abracadabra reminded me a bit of ARTPOP, and the Notorious Being reminded me of Born This Way. I really really hope she delivers 🙏
Thanks a lot for this tea , i became a little monster back in 2018 , since than i almost know everything until this moment but this tea i couldn't get anywhere, i subscribed u , thsnks , definitely looking forward to more tea ❤❤❤❤❤
Hipster
@@UMARISART im glad you enjoyed the video and thank you for the support I appreciate it 💙
This would have been a much better LG5
@@ParasiticCadaver you didnt have any favorite songs from joanne?
@@Playlist_Pop I do like Joanne. I just wish it was LG6 instead of LG5
I think Gaga was about to perform in space with the help of Intel 😆 LG5 is the new LG7 with Gesaffelstein, RedOne and other producers
i cant wait for LG7
what???!!! a video has posted in 1 hr and nobodyy is commenting??!!!
It’s been a day and ur the only comment on here with 8 likes
Wtf is going on 🔫
@@kenalexandremeridi girl whts ur problem like what do u want me to dooooo????? like what's the matter with it???? it's okay to have low likes or whatever i mean i srsly don't care if i'll become the most famous person on youtube like who gives a fck???
@@rmxni1 thank you for commenting and giving support to the video i appreciate it
@@Playlist_Pop ur welcomeeee❤️
Oh so we have Mark to blame
no ahs hotel stealing all the darkness
@@emrebakann No, the original LG5 came to life AFTER Gaga did AHS: Hotel, because she got inspired by her character The Countess and the show itself and THEN created the original LG5 concept. I really do blame Mark Ronson because he watered down Gaga so much and because of him the entire LG5 was scrapped. I do like Joanne the album but not compared to ARTPOP, The Fame Monster, The Fame, Born This Way or Chromatica. I'm glad that Gaga really does become the Gaga of those eras again!
@@ahsuniverseslays perfectly said. if I had a Time Machine I would never have let them meet.
Lg7 is lg5 but modified, remade, modernized and more pop
Exactly!
@@EjNoahe if this is ture i cant wait!
@@Playlist_Pop Frankensteined returns….the concept returns along with some og songs on the album and deluxe …
I totally agree with this statement
you took me to a trip down memory lane ❤
LG7 IS GOING TO BE THE ORIGINAL LG5 HEAR ME OUT. !!!
La era Joanne fue muy necesaria en la carrera de Gaga, el piblico estaba saturado de ella en ese momento, la musica que estaba pegando en ese momento era trap/rap y nada de lo que Gaga hubiera hecho hubiera sido un hit, al ser Joanne un album personal y trabquilo, no exigia tener grandes hits ni revolucionar el mundo, para mi Joanne es como una pausa segura en su carrera donde se paro de pie a reflexionar sobre su futuro, no fue un total exitoz pero tampoco un fracas, ni pasó inadvertido
exactamente si gaga hubiera elegido el sonido dance/pop original para LG5, el público no lo habría recibido bien ya que en ese momento se cansaron de lo que ella ya había hecho, Joanne era la mejor dirección a seguir y se alineaba bien con gaga en Ese momento de su vida, especialmente cuando se preparaba para hacer Nace una estrella, lo que le abrió nuevas oportunidades, la ganó nuevamente entre el público y se convirtió en una actriz exitosa, si no hubiera hecho Joanne, es posible que las cosas no hubieran sido así también. Joanne mostró un lado diferente de su arte y creó, como usted mencionó, "una pausa segura en su carrera donde se puso de pie para reflexionar sobre su futuro", es lo que necesitaba hacer para seguir adelante
Sorry but I had to stop watching after “Dianna Warner”. Her name is Diane Warren. Then you said Gaga was touring in “2025”. I hope you’ll take this as constructive criticism because I love watching content like this but those kind of simple inaccuracies make me kind of doubt everything else you’re saying ya know ❤ saying this with love fr!
Imagine putting all the effort into making a UA-cam video like this and you slip up on two words and then some troll comes to correct them….they say when you can’t act you try to teach… it’s not landing. 🎉
Probably made by AI 😂
Ok snowflake
@@finalGirl1397 I was being nice, weird overreaction!
@@finalGirl1397 imagine putting all this effort into a youtube video thats pure fiction and presenting it as if its fact? there is literally next to NO actual concept leaks or evidence of what LG5 could have been in its early stages. None. Other than us knowing she was in the studio with redone, which he stated they worked on an early version of angel down and nothing more. this video is all fan delusion and the inaccuracies this person spoke on were only the tip of the iceberg and simply serve as evidence for how sloppy and irresponsible the creator is. Stop being so defensive and get real. If one makes content where they present fact or theory then they need to be as accurate as humanly possible. This is journalism for the modern age and its scary how inaccurate and sloppy everything always is. and you defend it.
Great video keep up the good work
@@finalGirl1397 thank you
Great video! ❤
@@funkwaves thank you for watching
i love ur gaga vids pls never stop
@@aesetrical thanks so much
My theory is once she got signed to ASIB, she scrapped the album so she could test out the stripped back sound
@@nathangurule8180 what did you think of joanne? did you have favorite songs from it?
@@Playlist_Pop I love Joanne :) it helped me enjoy other genres that aren’t pop/dance/synth. My favorite has to be Sinner’s Prayer because it reminds me of my favorite video game series, Red Dead Redemption 🤠
@@nathangurule8180 sinner's prayer dose give the feeling of dead redemption, though i only seen a friend play it i definitely do get that vibe from it
Diana Warner 😂
I gotta say, I hope when Diane Warren eventually wins her first competitive Oscar on her 19th or 20th nomination, I hope that’s how the presenter says her name.
plz noo 😭 my mistake should not be repeated ever again
we were robbed
@@guyroo9974 you didnt have any favorites from joanne?
another theory, the Dancing in Circles Remix is actually just Drivin in Circles. And they used her Dancing in Circles vocals over the original Divin in Circles instrumental, then called it a 'remix'
Gaga did say that Joanne's sound concept or the new changes for lg5 was also from her label decision to change her usual image and win the hearts of the general public again. Half thanks to that, Gaga would have a wide variety of music directions as we knew her today. Proving that she's the Chameleon artist of our generation. ❤❤🔥
@@cheehoegaga5751 it did work and it was a good direction to take while going into acting for asib, gaga is amazing at reinventing herself, what direction would you like for her to do next?
@@Playlist_Pop I love to see a brand new jazz and moulin rogue soundscape met pop album in the future of coz. As for LG7 I'm all ready to devour something futuristic yet brutalist or whatever she's baking. Praying it to be drop within this year😭❤️
@@cheehoegaga5751 i love that combination if there anyone who can bring that mix to life it would be gaga, same im excited for LG7 from the snippets it dose give futuristic i even thought it gave a little artpop, whatever she got planned i will be ready ^-^
Before perfect illusion I thought we would of got rock album but I guess it was country pop ugh I miss that era! Imo her best tour
@@Peterrdee a rock album from gaga would be amazing
LG7 is the SHITTT 🔥
Great video 😊
@@charisleon0716 thanks
Ok but like, the vampire stuff could have been a countess thing
@@MYSTERIOMUSIK it dose fit well with her character, so it is possible
1:04 2025?
I didn't know i'm living in the future
@@jjjchillsorry about that, that was my mistake
I think Joanne was good for her career overall as people may have gotten tired of crazy dance Gaga and she may have ended up like poor Katy Perry. Even though the album Joanne kinda sucks... it was good for her overall
@@romanarts6645 it was a good career move, it aligned so well where gaga was at the time in her life especially as she was going to start doing asib, which not only opened new opportunities for her but she also became a successful actress, if she didnt take the joanne route things may have not played out like they did, some would have probably said comments like "this isn't new", "she isn't growing" and like you mentioned ppl were getting tired of what she already did in past eras, so this change needed to happen in order for her to move forward in her life and career
You speak like you’re about to pass
Burger king foot lettuce
Joanne was a good album it was setting a tone down era for her, it was as personal as all her other work but lyrically it is her best, art pop for me is her worst. But I do keep hoping after she released the cure she would put an album out with that sort of sound. It worked and is an amazing track
@@BrookePage1992 joanne was a great album, it aligned perfectly where she was in her life and career as she was going to into asib, so it made sense to go in that direction, same i do love the cure though i think it was an outtake from asib, it has a similar vibe to hair body face and heal me two other tracks i also love ✨
I wish she would have done some different things like stick to the original lg5 and do a david bowie separate from the original performance planned . I think she has missed some amazing music opportunities by changing things to much .
@@daultonlitteral3143 i wouldnt say that, sure there were some missed opportunities, but look at how many more opportunities gaga got when she did ASIB, she became a successful actress and releasing joanne was good timing for her transition into acting, if she had done the original LG5, things might not have played out the same way, especially since the general public had grown tired of her camp & dance pop style during artpop, some might have said she was doing the same thing and not growing, so at that point, gaga needed to try something new for her career to evolve
We’re taking comments from fans on a forum as credible? lol. We know very little to nothing about the original LG5 other than the fact that she worked with Redone, and there is a song called Frankensteined. That’s it.
The only times Gagadaily is mentioned was as “fans speculating” and as “rumored.” It’s very obvious through Gaga’s teasing that the original LG5 was very different than the one we got, especially after that Oscars performance.
Who’s Diana Warner? 😂
@@TheSkinnyZ my mistake 😅 i meant to say diane warren
There is quite literally no evidence or spoken of concepts for what the album might have been. So idk what any of you are discussing or what this video could possibly present. This is nearly all pure fictional delusion lol
Lady Gaga was great when she first emerged on the scene. She was new, fresh and exciting. The Fame / FameMonster, Born This Way & ArtPop were Gaga at her crazy best and most creative. (Even though ArtPop kinda missed the mark at certain points in the album). Everything after ArtPop was garbage. Joanne was boring garbage. The Tony Bennett stuff was a pop career killer, which is exactly what happened, it killed her music career. She tried coming back to original crazy and creative Gaga with Chromatica but the sound of that entire album was dated and the production was yawn-inducing. The only hit on that album was Rain On Me, and the only reason that was a big hit, was because it featured Ariana Grande, who was super hot at that time. Grande was the one to propel that song to #1, not Gaga. Don’t believe me? Well, Gaga sang Stupid Love all herself, and the video was panned, and the song was classified as her one of her worst singles of her career, and certainly the worst choice for a lead off single. It was considered a flop in terms of Gaga’s past lead singles from her pop dance albums. I purchased Chromatica on the day of release and was excited because it was said to be a return to her pop/dance form. Yes it was an all dance album, but like I said, the production was incredibly dated and did NOT make me go gaga for Gaga. I think I listened to the full album twice and that was it. It wasn’t replayable at all. Now, since a week after I bought the CD years ago, it collects dust. I guess I should dust more. Her ultra famous pop star era ended a LOOOOONG time ago. Now she’s just incredibly boring and not relevant at all anymore. From the things I’ve heard about her new upcoming studio album, I don’t have much hope for it, let’s just say that shall we.
What about Alice from Chromatica?