Why Do Crystal Palace & Brighton Hate Each Other?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 115

  • @kevinalderton6278
    @kevinalderton6278 2 роки тому +7

    Excellent video- I am a 66 year old Brighton season ticket holder. I remember those matches so well. No fan ever called us the Dolphins- we didn’t have a nickname other than Albion. On a hot day at a Brighton v Palace match in the mid 70’s the Palace fans were chanting Eagles Eagles and the North Stand just responded with Seagulls Seagulls and it stuck. Numerous people claim the have started it but we will never know. UTA!

  • @notgaryhart1312
    @notgaryhart1312 Рік тому

    Sorry for earlier rant , which I stand by. But that was one of the best explanation of our rivalry I’ve ever heard. From someone who lived through it’s origins.

  • @JustClickApprove92
    @JustClickApprove92 2 роки тому +27

    Spot on Dan. I’m a Villa fan, but I hate it when people write off the M23 rivalry, when they simply don’t understand, the game is literally everything to both sets of fans, it doesn’t matter that they’re miles away from each other, it just comes off as ignorance

  • @upkaarbharadia
    @upkaarbharadia 2 роки тому +35

    Excellent behaviour. I'm a Palace ST-holder as I grew up in South Norwood but I wasn't raised by football fans, so I've never personally felt the rivalry and can't find it within myself to dislike a Brighton or Millwall fan who supports their local team, over people who gloryhunt big teams with no local or family connection to them. That said, our games with Brighton are huge occasions regardless, which have ironically become the source of ridicule due to the success of both clubs making it a regular PL fixture that previously uninformed PL fans now have to acknowledge. Meanwhile Sky and BT presenters and pundits awkwardly save face by pretending to have always known about the rivalry when broadcasting the games. All of them should be made to watch this video 👏🏾

  • @starratsbiting8066
    @starratsbiting8066 2 роки тому +13

    Good video mate, well done. I'm an Albion fan, and you're correct in saying that this fixture prompts more excitement and anxiety - it is the one that both sets of fans really want to win, and are desperate not to lose. I imagine it's the same for Palace, but there's often discussion about whether contemporary players and coaching staffs "get" the rivalry, and approval when it is evident that some do (eg Zaha, Dunk), because certainly it is driven by supporters now even though much of it was rooted in the competition between Mullers and El Tel. That said, I have a feeling that there is a growing, (still grudging) respect between Seagulls and Eagles supporters which is coming about through the shared acknowledgement that we are two similarly sized clubs - survivors through awful times, and rooted in their communities - who have to contend against the super-greedy, plasticky giants. May Gerry Ryan's busted leg forgive me, but I have recently, on occasion, found myself internally cheering Palace on when they're playing one of the ESL wannabes.
    Alright, good luck with the channel, and the worst possible luck for Palarse on Saturday.
    Seaweed 'til I die 🙂

    • @TomClarkSouthLondon
      @TomClarkSouthLondon 2 роки тому +2

      It has become a rivalry over the years, which is totally different from a same city derby. Our natural rivalry is mongwall and Charlieton.
      I actually like bha and the town, so when the rivalry grew, it actually pissed me off!😤

  • @simmo321
    @simmo321 2 роки тому +1

    Nice video, Brighton fan here, looking forward to the game later, hopefully we come away with 3 points! Enjoy the banter this is what football is all about

  • @R3fruity
    @R3fruity Рік тому

    Great vid, up the Palace.
    As a new palace fan, this is a perfect explanation of where it all started. I heard about the money throwing at Palace fans, but didn't understand the build up with the run of fixtures which caused it.
    Looking forward to 3 points Thursday

    • @thomas.69
      @thomas.69 10 місяців тому

      4-1 AHAHAHAH

  • @janet1844
    @janet1844 Рік тому

    Hi and great explanation of the reasonings behind the rivalry; I first saw Palace play Workington in 1957 as a twelve year old and a fan was born. Having seen all those games, o yes the blood pressure in us fans rose to new heights! Of course we had another hiccup with them with poo//gate in13/14 which I guess many younger fans may only hear that story but hopefully in time they will get the whole picture. I’m now 77 and live in West Yorkshire hence dont get to Selhurst very often but I do watch all games.that I can stream and I have Palace tv+ so am well into the u21s andunder18s. Great piece from you and I wish you the best for the future. As this is my wife’s iPad just to let you know im Pete👍

  • @chrisgitter3265
    @chrisgitter3265 2 роки тому +5

    Brilliantly put. I'm from the US and I remember having to dig when I became a Palace fan about why exactly we hated Brighton so much. I think a twitter thread of yours is how I learned a good chunk of it, and this video will be great for new fans and neutrals alike

  • @jakeleatherland
    @jakeleatherland 2 роки тому +4

    Great video 👍 I'm a Leicester fan and have watched and read about the rivalry before. But it's great to hear it explained so well from a supporter of one of the clubs

  • @louisbarron9688
    @louisbarron9688 2 роки тому +2

    Cracking explainer video fella, respect. I won’t wish you luck for the game on Saturday, but go well anyway

  • @Duke46283
    @Duke46283 2 роки тому +3

    This was really informative, I never really understood the rivalry but it just shows that rivalry doesn’t always have to be a geographical thing. Good luck to both teams on the weekend but I have to say “El Gatwicko” is genius 😂

  • @anthonyallan5281
    @anthonyallan5281 2 роки тому +1

    Holy crap I new parts of this story but you just clarified alot more than I ever could have ever known, been a Palace fan since 1981 when I was 4 years old and got told some of the reasons by my dad and his mates..!! Been following you on twitter for about a year now and now on UA-cam.. Bluddy well done, keep going, you're on a roll..!! 😎😁😀

  • @MrSteed13
    @MrSteed13 2 роки тому

    Glad to see you take the plunge. It's nice to put a face to the voice.

  • @sharonstevens7592
    @sharonstevens7592 2 роки тому +2

    That was such a fascinating explanation of why BHA and Palace are rivals. As a Brighton fan this is something that I have never really thought about too much. I didn't start watching them until much later than the 70s :)

  • @derosabike
    @derosabike 2 роки тому +2

    Great video Dan. I remember the beginnings of the rivalry between Brighton and Palace in 1970's as a young lad who was too naive to understand at the time, why wearing a red and blue scarf round my wrist would offend a grown man at the Goldstone 🔴🔵
    Some people who don't understand, criticise the rivalry due to its distance, but I've never heard anything said about Ipswich vs Norwich and they are further apart than us and as you said Chelsea vs Leeds. It's not always down to geography.

  • @timbeyers58
    @timbeyers58 2 роки тому +2

    Great work, Dan. Thank you. Really appreciate these videos and your commentary for how it helps me keep up with CPFC from here in the States. Keep at it, mate.

  • @seanforbes3937
    @seanforbes3937 2 роки тому

    Went to uni in Brighton and started following the side as a sort of second club and I remember being so confused about this rivalry. Appreciate this

  • @WHUCallum97_
    @WHUCallum97_ 2 роки тому +2

    Good vid mate but icl 'El Gatwicko' is a slander name i've never heard of before but it made me crease😂

  • @TomG1901
    @TomG1901 2 роки тому +3

    Really great video mate, I’m a young brighton fan and this has helped improve my knowledge on the rivalry, I’m going up to Selhurst park for the first time at the weekend and I think it’s our best chance ever to smash you, but knowing us we’ll lose 1-0 haha. Good luck for then mate

  • @gottabigmouth1079
    @gottabigmouth1079 Рік тому

    Excellent summary Dan. Really clear and well explained. The rivalry in the 2013 season play offs were certainly made more spicy when someone in the Brighton side shat in our changing room. Plus can forget when Steve Coppell managed Brighton and we spanked them 5-0. The club made t-shirts to celebrate.

  • @ckablackie
    @ckablackie 2 роки тому +1

    Great explanation Dan. I attended two of those 76/77 fixtures at the Goldstone ground. Unlike most BHA fans I have a soft spot for Palace .... just not when we play each other 😄 May the best team win on Saturday😉

  • @arrontrevor7086
    @arrontrevor7086 2 роки тому +4

    It's also quite a thing that the rivalry survived over the period in the 90s when Brighton fell down the leagues and we hardly played each other, especially as it was a relatively recent one.

  • @theskyblueview7400
    @theskyblueview7400 2 роки тому +1

    Nice one for clearing this up mate. We (Coventry) have a bit of weird relationship/rivalry with Sunderland going back to 1977 which a lot of fans don’t seem to understand. Happy to explain further if you wanted

    • @professionalman1960
      @professionalman1960 Рік тому

      Yea you and Jimmy Hill cheated

    • @theskyblueview7400
      @theskyblueview7400 Рік тому

      @@professionalman1960 😂😂😂😂😂😂 I forgot that relegation is decided by 1 game a season. You lot should have played better across the season and not left yourself in that position

  • @wavydavy64
    @wavydavy64 2 роки тому +13

    Oh Andy Johnson he wears a magic hat...

  • @T0FFII
    @T0FFII 2 роки тому +1

    Brilliant an insightful video for a neutral perspective on the rivalry! Always enjoy matches where the atmosphere is frosty, derby or not!

  • @korma9732
    @korma9732 Рік тому

    Not a bad upload for a Palace fan! My first home and away games were against Palace in '75. We were the best.two teams in that league and then the second division and fans, managers and players just wanted to win. I don't remember fans being segregated either.

  • @gooner7768
    @gooner7768 2 роки тому +1

    Didn’t know this. Was interesting. Keep it up Dan.

  • @id70b40
    @id70b40 Рік тому +2

    As a Brighton fan, the first games I look for a the start of each season are the Brighton / Palace fixtures. Whilst there is the rivalry, we supporters do have a ceasefire each year for the REMF games.

  • @malhar94
    @malhar94 Рік тому

    Very informative and interesting!

  • @derek9676
    @derek9676 2 роки тому +2

    Cheers for that. Good to know the back story to the rivalry. As the geographical one never made any sense

  • @Tdr-jv2nc
    @Tdr-jv2nc 2 роки тому +3

    As a Brighton fan I love the rivalry we share with palace

  • @mattthornton1997
    @mattthornton1997 2 роки тому +1

    Great content mate. Keep smashing it

  • @thestartingxi5522
    @thestartingxi5522 2 роки тому

    Good video mate
    Feel like there should be more on the recent fixtures aswell tho
    “Poo gate” for playoff final
    The animosity with that first game in the Prem
    Palace fans painted over Bruno’s mural and bringing bangers to the game
    Brighton fans spraying “cpfc die “ near Selhurst etc
    Feel like the rivalry has been re-enlightened recently

  • @paddygladman9923
    @paddygladman9923 Рік тому +1

    As far as I'm concerned, it started when you lot came down mob handed in a preseason friendly. This was before the game at Chelsea

    • @paddygladman9923
      @paddygladman9923 2 місяці тому

      That's true but this slap head doesn't know about that

  • @brtscafsma77
    @brtscafsma77 2 роки тому

    Love the palace content hero bro:)

  • @benjaminherbert8569
    @benjaminherbert8569 2 роки тому

    Well written and well put Dan.

  • @SeagullsSocial
    @SeagullsSocial 2 роки тому

    Great video Dan 🙌

  • @terryplows2807
    @terryplows2807 2 роки тому

    Thanks for sharing this mate.i used to live in Norwood and ever understood the rivalry unto now..I'm a spurs fan a us vs Woolwich is a naughty rivalry

  • @LilywhiteLane
    @LilywhiteLane Рік тому

    As an opposition fan this was very interesting to hear👍

  • @BrinscallEagle
    @BrinscallEagle 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting that at one point Dan you commented that at 39 years of age your were not around when the start of the rivalry began yet feel strongly the rivalry because of the events at that time. Interesting enough from my point of view I started watching Palace at the age of 17 in 1958 and to me the rivalry is with Millwall or Charlton. I understand the location difference but I guess it is an era thing and to me the incidents back then were just two managers who had a dislike for one another which spilled over to the teams. Whilst I desperately want us to beat Brighton it is no more or less than any other team we are currently playing in the Premiership. As I said it is probably a generation thing.
    I thoroughly enjoyed the broadcast. COYP

  • @amiritelads2404
    @amiritelads2404 2 роки тому

    Great video mate, keep them coming!

  • @alanandrews8098
    @alanandrews8098 Рік тому +1

    I was at the replay in question,the ref's name was Ron Challis thereafter always known as Challis of the Palace.
    I have work mates who are Palace fans who I get on with really well but come the derby week things get a little tense.
    As grown men in our 60s we should know better but football rivalry trump's common sense every time.

  • @stevenmeachin21
    @stevenmeachin21 2 роки тому

    Really good video (Brighton fan) and I can confirm I’m shitting myself for the game today and the rivalry is as big as any

  • @topdrivinginstructor
    @topdrivinginstructor 2 роки тому +4

    If you knew your history you would know the rivalry started back in 1973/4 at a pre season friendly at the Goldstone when Palace fans took over the entire town before the game and ran Brighton fans all over the ground during and after the game! The next game in the League at the Goldstone was a different story with even handed fights everywhere and the animosity between the 2 sets of fans was well and truly established then, well before the 75/76 season!

    • @rebekahleech5354
      @rebekahleech5354 2 роки тому +2

      I went to that game with my dad and uncles n Cousions as we would say a sea of red n blue

    • @TomClarkSouthLondon
      @TomClarkSouthLondon 2 роки тому +3

      Agreed, I remember pre season “friendly” matches long before mullery and venables when there was always violence between the *CRYSTAL PALACE* football club, and . . . .bha.

    • @TomClarkSouthLondon
      @TomClarkSouthLondon 2 роки тому

      Just pointing out I think it was “Phil” Holder, not “Paul” 🤔

  • @QuillonPottinger
    @QuillonPottinger 2 роки тому

    Really good, needs a follow up though to frame the intensity of the last few decades.

  • @Palaceman17
    @Palaceman17 Рік тому +1

    As a palace fan I’ve always felt that Brighton are our rivals and that Millwall is the derby.

  • @richardslater677
    @richardslater677 2 роки тому +1

    Brilliant video.

  • @timphillips9954
    @timphillips9954 2 роки тому

    As a Brigthton fan from 1974 me and all of my fello Albion fans see this game as a derby. Palace were our nearest football league club untill Crawley entered the top for leagues. Btw the Goldstone ground was a fantastic place to watch football from from which I watched a number of great games in front of around 35000 in the lower leagues. BHAFC.

  • @richtyrrell3823
    @richtyrrell3823 2 роки тому +1

    Love your videos dan

  • @oscarc1165
    @oscarc1165 2 роки тому +1

    As a Brighton fan, this was a great video, Well explained deep dive into our rivalry. We all know Brighton are better but annoyingly we will lose or draw like we do every year! Great video though

  • @peterburry2531
    @peterburry2531 Рік тому

    There's a similar rivalry between Swindon and Gillingham, which dates back to the late 1970's and violent grudges between the two sets of players that spread from the pitch to the terraces.

  • @Kacperslyfe
    @Kacperslyfe 2 роки тому +1

    Hey mate I'd really Appreciate time stamps on a video like this ! ❤️💙

  • @TomClarkSouthLondon
    @TomClarkSouthLondon 2 роки тому +3

    It is just a fierce rivalry between the two clubs and supporters. NOT a derby.
    We share one important thing in common with the Tesco bag shirty’s and that is love for our *local* clubs.
    I actually like bha and the town, so the rivalry really pisses me off!
    They and us have come close to extinction on occasions, so we know each other’s determination to not let that happen, makes supporting your nearest football club special, true, and with integrity.
    Bha have been an inspiration for all clubs, showing that it is possible in the modern game to grow into a formidable force without Arab blood money Asian betting gangs and Americans obsession with ruining a soccer club.
    I wish bha all the success they deserve and respect their fans for standing by them through thick and thin, just as the *CRYSTAL PALACE* football club supporters have been doing since *1861*

    • @TheSeafordian
      @TheSeafordian Рік тому

      Leeds call their games with Man U a derby but they are further apart than Brighton / Palace. As is Norwich / Ipswich.

  • @BenFleury
    @BenFleury 2 роки тому +9

    I remember ringing up Adrian Durham on Talksport in 2017 to explain the origin of the Palace-Brighton rivalry and him being fascinated by it.
    Eagles 🔴🔵

  • @rebekahleech5354
    @rebekahleech5354 2 роки тому

    Nice vid Dan injoyed it love the passion in palace n Brighton games don’t go much now but look forward in watching this fixture palace till I die middle crew homesdale ❤️💙

  • @georgedalepayne
    @georgedalepayne 2 роки тому +5

    I'm sure I speak for most Albion fans when I say this fixture always fills me with dread 😂 Brighton always find a way to royally fuck it up every year, hopefully this years different

    • @georgedalepayne
      @georgedalepayne 2 роки тому +2

      Either way, at least we can both say we support our local teams, which goes a long way these days

    • @tombha23
      @tombha23 2 роки тому +1

      @@georgedalepayne absolutely, support ur local. come on seagulls!!!

  • @steveluckhurst2350
    @steveluckhurst2350 2 роки тому

    No mention of Gerry Ryan?

  • @icanmakeitsnow
    @icanmakeitsnow 2 роки тому +1

    Never knew this thanks

  • @arthurmorganempire
    @arthurmorganempire 8 місяців тому +1

    Have seen it after twitter

  • @rajnirvan3336
    @rajnirvan3336 Рік тому

    I also heard Alan Mullery barged into the Palace changing room and threw 5 one pound notes and said your teams not worth that

  • @rhino7735
    @rhino7735 2 роки тому

    Yeah spot on mate I'm a Liverpool fan and while Utd and Everton are our biggest rival i actually hate Chelsea the most both sets of fans dont have any respect for each other where as I do have a level of respect for Utd cause like Liverpool Man Utd are a successful club and have a big history so the Palace/Brighton rivalry is very similar to the Liverpool/Chelsea rivalry

    • @peterburry2531
      @peterburry2531 Рік тому +1

      Would I be right in thinking that there is a deep cultural and ideological divide between the two sets of fans; Liverpool historically being a left wing city and Chelsea being, well.. we all know what they are

  • @captvimes
    @captvimes 2 роки тому

    We were called the shrimps. That is why we wanted to change it and many clubs rebranded at that time. There was a brief flirtation that we might use Dolphins. But it was never officially adopted and many in the town hated the dolphinarium and didnt want it associated with the club.Dolphina are only on Brightons town crest not Hoves another contention. We did copy Eagles and it quickly became popular and adopted as our new badge. The biggest catalyst in my memory was Henry Hughton breaking Gerry Ryans leg in three places and ending his career. While palace fans cheered.

    • @sharonstevens7592
      @sharonstevens7592 2 роки тому +1

      Oh Lord! I remember that day so vividly! I hadn't yet graduated out of the south east corner! My mate was in tears as he was her favourite player.

  • @dellaanniehughes4533
    @dellaanniehughes4533 2 роки тому +1

    I'm a seagirl and my partner supports palace. Mostly a friendly rivalry. We just don't discuss football.

  • @markcallaghan369
    @markcallaghan369 2 роки тому

    Goes back before the Venables/Mullery era

  • @fraserhyldon
    @fraserhyldon 2 роки тому +3

    We scored 3, they scored 1...

  • @williamkanegateshead
    @williamkanegateshead 2 роки тому +1

    I didn't know about Brighton being known as The Dolphins before. That's what they are for me from now on then. Just like Crystal Palace will always remain The Glaziers. 😃

  • @seanforbes3937
    @seanforbes3937 2 роки тому

    I'm baffled some discredit the rivalry due to the lack of a geographical connection. Surely such venom and passion existing despite no adjacency is testament in and of itself to the strength of the dislike the fans feel for eachother.

  • @ShuffleSwitcher
    @ShuffleSwitcher Рік тому

    This video is not quite correct. The rivalry began before 1976. Try three years before when Palace smashed up the town of Brighton and Hove in a pre-season friendly. When Brighton fans saw the fixture list the following 1974/75 season, pitting the Albion in an opening day clash with Palace, they saw a chance to avenge matters as well as a rare chance to put one over a recent Division One side. The local Evening Argus paper wrote of the intensity of the games between the sides both in 1974/75 and 1975/76.

  • @petertrott2483
    @petertrott2483 Рік тому

    The encroachment was caused by a Palace player pushing a Brighton player into the box

  • @99_sam
    @99_sam 2 роки тому +1

    Great content Dan, just remember to blink every once in a while

    • @HLTCOMEDIA
      @HLTCOMEDIA  2 роки тому +12

      Trust me, staring at a camera, with a ring-light on whilst focussing on what you want to say without stumbling over your words, your brain is on such a state of alert that I think blinking goes out of the window.

  • @shmiqqy
    @shmiqqy 2 роки тому

    stupid that it's even called the m23 derby, brighton doesn't get the m23, we don't even have a motorway here for about 15 or 20 miles
    just another attempt at trying to make croydon/brighton seem local to each other but they're not

  • @randombanter8872
    @randombanter8872 2 роки тому

    Up the Albion! ✊

  • @indiekid19872
    @indiekid19872 2 роки тому +1

    Great Vid 👍. Still feel like it's not the same as a city rivalry where offices / families / friendship groups will be divided. I guess both teams are searching for a rival where they don't really have a traditional rivalry (especially in Brighton's case)

    • @PHTV11
      @PHTV11 2 роки тому +1

      We don't like Millwall neither. Charlton care about us but we don't give a shit.

    • @TomClarkSouthLondon
      @TomClarkSouthLondon 2 роки тому +1

      Same city derby games are a no choice rivalry, the *CRYSTAL PALACE* football club and bha are rivals because of a long history of violence and hostility between club and fans. A rivalry is totally different to a derby, both clubs know it, other fans will never get, what they don’t have!💁🏼‍♂️

    • @TomClarkSouthLondon
      @TomClarkSouthLondon 2 роки тому

      @@PHTV11no one likes them, they don’t care😂

    • @peterburry2531
      @peterburry2531 Рік тому

      @@TomClarkSouthLondon There's a similar rivalry between Swindon and Gillingham that dates from the 70's... It means more to The Gills than it does to us, as we're preoccupied with Oxford and the Bristol clubs, whereas they have nothing better to concern theirselves with..

  • @krshoreham7634
    @krshoreham7634 2 роки тому +1

    Watched both games at The Goldstone Ground and the one at Stamford Bridge …Ron Challis was the ref in question …awful!

  • @MrAndyrevell
    @MrAndyrevell 2 роки тому

    You forgot to mention the sickening challenge on Ryan by Hughton. He should have been arrested for GBH

  • @lukewainwright3212
    @lukewainwright3212 2 роки тому

    Come on you Seagulls

  • @mindcrap7472
    @mindcrap7472 2 роки тому +1

    Poogate?

  • @timphillips9954
    @timphillips9954 2 роки тому

    Think about Man Utd and Liverpool or Man Utd and Leeeds Utd

  • @thomas.69
    @thomas.69 10 місяців тому

    SEAGULLLSSSSS

  • @paddygladman9923
    @paddygladman9923 2 місяці тому

    It started before what your going on about. It started when you mugs got in the northstand in a preseason friendly. It kicked off then, your talking shite mate

  • @mash83
    @mash83 2 роки тому

    It's always a greatly anticipated/dreaded fixture but it's mostly a bit of pantomime spiciness. When it goes beyond that it tends to get a little pathetic but I can't remember any real incidents for some time. From both sides it always adds a cherry on top, getting one over the other especially with bit of late drama (why did you let it bounce!)
    Here's to many more 🍻
    I reckon you'd do well in this by the way, you really should enter 👍
    ua-cam.com/video/SWgg20IqibM/v-deo.html
    UTA

  • @rebekahleech5354
    @rebekahleech5354 2 роки тому

    Red n blue you no it’s true I remember palace v Brighton games the fights so I’ve got hate in me palace for life ❤️💙