The sound of the lightsabers coming from these worn audio tapes almost scares me. It has a really creepy feel to it that I've never experienced before. Also the music sounds like it comes straight from the 30s.
35 and 16 mm have that rustic May 21, 1980 feel to it. As someone who born at the end of the summer of 1980 and raised as a first generation fan. I absolutely love the Puggo 16mm aspect.
In terms of the lightsaber colours,Puggo is better,it is darker and isn't white in the middle finished with a blue/red glow.In terms of the backgrounds,Grindhouse wins,its lighter and looks more modern than Puggo Strikes Back.
@timewarpdrive7764 No, that was fake. You can tell by the moment where Vader says in this fake "luke" for second time, it's basically taken from the moment he was saying "You do not yet realize your importance" and audience's reaction was straight up taken audio from Infinity War audience reaction
The lighting and image quality is a lot better on the 35mm one, while the lightsaber color and oranges at the start are better on the 16mm. Also, at the end of the scene on the top platform, on the 35mm one, there’s a reel change. Damn you Fight Club, I can’t not see it!
ExtremePlayGames I still recommend harmys Despecialized it’s the best quality out of the 3 I take video and audio quality more and it’s a near perfect recreation
I only ever watched the original VHS recording once, so I had no idea the first ignition sound when Luke draws his lightsaber was changed for whatever reason in later editions
Plus Grindhouse isn't as zoomed in and that makes Puggo Strikes Back look super weird in the scene where Luke gets his hand chopped off along with its dark colours imo.TBH Puggo looks weird in every way possible except the first part of the battle,when Luke is sliding down that mega-slide-that-leads-to-certain-death-without-plot-armour and its lightsaber colours.
Oh my gosh, I never realized the soundtracks sounded not clear in this, it sounded like very very old while on DVDs it sound like it was new and clear, how strange.
Okay, but I find it cool and fun to hear how that sounds as it is a bit synthesized to me, do you too, I am not sure what is the grind house is, but tear over the years just makes me feel bad about it, but I don't know how they made them sound clean and modern sort of on DVDs?
Fan's Madness Fetishes Imagine being so much of a moron that you think people dislike the special editions specifically for being in 1080p. Get out of here, mate. This is no place for you.
@@philipdoesit6098 why would you expect a kid to know how a technology that probably wasnt around anymore when they were growing up worked? digital projectors started being common place around 2010. if a kid was 5 years old when that happened he would be in high school now
@@youngbutretro4228 yes but not everyone does. i will tell you for a fact (because I am in LA for film school) that I didn't know how film reels being changed worked until I saw fight club when I was 15 or 16.
![ORIGINAL Luke vs Darth Vader | The Empire Strikes Back (1980) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, Renegade]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jRBFyob112c/mqdefault.jpg)
![ORIGINAL Luke vs Darth Vader | The Empire Strikes Back (1980) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, Renegade]](/img/tr.png)
![ORIGINAL Luke vs Darth Vader & The Emperor | Return of the Jedi (1983) [DeEd, Blu-ray, GOUT, LPP]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ouv-JDzgQOA/mqdefault.jpg)
![REVISITED Battle of Yavin | A New Hope (1977) [Revisited, DeEd, Blu-ray, Puggo]](/img/n.gif)
The sound of the lightsabers coming from these worn audio tapes almost scares me. It has a really creepy feel to it that I've never experienced before. Also the music sounds like it comes straight from the 30s.
Mono mix from Puggo.
@@StarWarsComparison empire strikes back
The empire strikes back
6:45 hearing the crunch from Vader’s gloves
35 and 16 mm have that rustic May 21, 1980 feel to it. As someone who born at the end of the summer of 1980 and raised as a first generation fan. I absolutely love the Puggo 16mm aspect.
What a beautiful image. That's the way a movie is supposed to look.
No Blu-Ray, just the classics.
Which one?
Good to see quality in our parents time
yup it looks different on the vcr compared to later versions on dvd etc. as well
But the remastered versions on DVD have more fixed errors
@@flyte707 that not vhs thats a film scan
Actually no; It looked much better in the cinema. This stuff is just worn.
This is nothing like the quality back then. Old age damaged, discoloured prints... Seeing stuff in the cinema was mint. Excellent pictures.
In terms of the lightsaber colours,Puggo is better,it is darker and isn't white in the middle finished with a blue/red glow.In terms of the backgrounds,Grindhouse wins,its lighter and looks more modern than Puggo Strikes Back.
35mm quality is obviously better, I would only color correct it like the 16mm
6:16 Proof that the line has always been "No. I AM your father!" and not " Luke, I AM your father! " as many have infamously thought it was.
Theres a pirated video tape from 1980 where he says "No. Luke, I AM your father!" Perhaps some cinemas were sent an alternate version?
@timewarpdrive7764 No, that was fake. You can tell by the moment where Vader says in this fake "luke" for second time, it's basically taken from the moment he was saying "You do not yet realize your importance" and audience's reaction was straight up taken audio from Infinity War audience reaction
@@timewarpdrive77it's fake
The lighting and image quality is a lot better on the 35mm one, while the lightsaber color and oranges at the start are better on the 16mm. Also, at the end of the scene on the top platform, on the 35mm one, there’s a reel change. Damn you Fight Club, I can’t not see it!
7:48 Clouds looks different
(No hateful replies)
Nintendorak Yamato that is due to the colours, I suspect.
You’re right
Hateful replies
Which version are most close to original gout, Puggo, grindhouse or Harmy Despecialized Edition ?
Aside from color, Grindhouse.
ExtremePlayGames I still recommend harmys Despecialized it’s the best quality out of the 3 I take video and audio quality more and it’s a near perfect recreation
Harmy’s is the most accurate and well put together. The Grindhouse edition shown above is very off in terms of its color.
can i watch the whole puggo version somewhere? all I found at the link is that he doesn't distribute his work
archive.org/details/ESB16mm
They’re the mono mix of the film.
5:24 What a slash
Lot of dust grains on both
The best look!
Jump to 6:05 to the "I am your father" scene, thank me later.
@Gmail com ha
Sounds like a mix between the 1980 and 1997 version, I can barely hear an echo.
I only ever watched the original VHS recording once, so I had no idea the first ignition sound when Luke draws his lightsaber was changed for whatever reason in later editions
I can't find Puggo's ESB.
Check description.
The Puggo is how the movie looked. IDK wtf the blurays look so far off. The DVDs were p good.
The 16mm looks like kind of like the Laserdisc
I have the Grindhouse version, 4K77 and 4K83 and they are beautiful!!
can anyone help me get the 35mm dreamastered ed on blu ray?
Where can I download this 16mm Puggo Strikes Back version?
It got removed from the Internet Archive for unknown reasons.
Still a great scene(s)
Such a charming version
Darth Vader wins! 🏆
I like the bottom one better, crisper.
sorry but i like puggo's best.
1:44 All too easy
C’est trop facile
Plus Grindhouse isn't as zoomed in and that makes Puggo Strikes Back look super weird in the scene where Luke gets his hand chopped off along with its dark colours imo.TBH Puggo looks weird in every way possible except the first part of the battle,when Luke is sliding down that mega-slide-that-leads-to-certain-death-without-plot-armour and its lightsaber colours.
Oh my gosh, I never realized the soundtracks sounded not clear in this, it sounded like very very old while on DVDs it sound like it was new and clear, how strange.
This video uses the audio that accompanied the film reel of the grind house, which has received wear and tear over the years.
Okay, but I find it cool and fun to hear how that sounds as it is a bit synthesized to me, do you too, I am not sure what is the grind house is, but tear over the years just makes me feel bad about it, but I don't know how they made them sound clean and modern sort of on DVDs?
Blackout Despecialized so couldn’t you download harmys version and open a editing software and put harmys audio over it and export it
+ anime dude 9000
Yeah, sort of, it's maybe they keep the special tape to not make it early 80-ish sounding.
Fan's Madness Fetishes
Imagine being so much of a moron that you think people dislike the special editions specifically for being in 1080p.
Get out of here, mate. This is no place for you.
4:44-4:54-Maniac Vader.
2:43 With remastered version, there’s no glitch like that when going to next scene
That's not a glitch, that's a film reel being changed
@@philipdoesit6098 Luckily enough I do. A lot of people my age don't know how film works and it's sad
@@philipdoesit6098 why would you expect a kid to know how a technology that probably wasnt around anymore when they were growing up worked? digital projectors started being common place around 2010. if a kid was 5 years old when that happened he would be in high school now
@@sebcubille I'm 15 even i know how film works
@@youngbutretro4228 yes but not everyone does. i will tell you for a fact (because I am in LA for film school) that I didn't know how film reels being changed worked until I saw fight club when I was 15 or 16.
1:57-2:02 My thoughts on Rise of Skywalker. Lol
Said no one ever
@@Nebulasecura 6:36 My reaction to the Sequels
@@YourInternetHistory676 same but when the expanded universe was halted
@@Nebulasecura I agree