@dimasanggayuda3966 Syria invaded Israel 3 times and constantly allowed itself to be a launchpad for rocket fire. Iraq hasn't stopped launching UAVs and Rockets. Some fantasy world you live in.
If isreal occupy Gaza again what will be gain of what hamas did on October 7? It almost looks like it was a bad decision, it resulted in the suffering of Gazans and the long term result will be more suffering so what did they actually gain ?
Yes I agree with you...and the international community can't do a thing about it even if Israel occupies Gaza. They were waiting for this moment and Hamas fell right into the trap because the Palestinians love violence and hate Israel more than they love their own children and freedom.
@@invadingomen6826 in ghetto warsaw they knew they were set for complete extermination. In Gaza they lived in a modern first world city, with malls, amusement park, zoo, cinemas, parks... life expectency was far above world median, and gdp was above world median too. There are neighborhoods in Cairo that had worse living conditions.
How is this any different than any other war throughout time. Here’s an idea: don’t start a war. The Gazans are lucky they have Israel as a neighbor instead of Russia.
Russia haven't killed 30.000 civilians In Ukraine, yet after 3 years No1 would like to have Israel next to them You never know What God promised them on Buddhist or Hinduist religions
Now that they're displaced they want to return to Gaza city... But when they were living there they wanted to return to Haifa... And basically that's palestinian identity in a nutshell: starting conflicts, getting displaced and dreaming about returning to the place they got kicked out
lol they keep trying to take over the whole land, everytime losing alittle more and more. they see the borders of Israel as their own, and respect the borders of neighboring arab nations lol..
Us Scots-Irish and English Americans will always have the backs of our brothers in Israel. Light will shine in the Middle East! God bless America 🇺🇸 ✝️Amen
Dont speak for us Irish and Scottish. We suffered from colonialism so we definitely do not support the stealing of land and the suffering of the innocent. Dont you have education in the US?
After october 7, the Palestinian state concept died. We, in Europe, always think about poor Palestinians (almost infantilizing their attitudes) Now, let’s just think only one minute about Israelis viewpoint too. Israel withdrew entirely from Gaza. Gave them a chance to try building a defacto state. Only one month later? Hamas and rockets fired at Israel instantly. Now imagine that West Bank/Judea and Samaria ? It would be simply suicidal for Israelis to repeat the same mistakes. Israelis even proposed 5-6 times peace agreements to Palestinians that were all rejected! Let’s open our minds to the fact that this Palestinian concept is dead already. A solution is to split sovereignty with Egypt / Israel in Gaza and Jordan / Israel in the West Bank.
Well we in Ireland respect international law and oppose the illegal occupation, ethnic cleansing and colonisation of Palestine. Palestine has to right to exist, the vast majority of the world recognises Palestinian statehood. The idea of dividing a country as you imply is illegal and violates international law arround territorial sovereignty. It is Israel that is in breech of international law, the only way there can be peace is if Israel stops invading Gaza, withdraws is occupation and illegal settlers from the West Bank and Jerusalem and to allow the international community to help the Palestinans build their own state in their own territory! 🇮🇪🇵🇸☘️🍉
depends... maybe that wall that stopped terror attacks is still occupation in your view.. anyhow that wont matter anymore, they will be inside gaza this time... the wall remains..
@@libistur You obviously don't follow their reporting. They are strong advocates for Israel's right for self defence. This said, they are not everything goes. But nobody of Israel's allies in Europe is everything goes.
The Palestinians have proven again and again and again. They are not able to be peaceful neighbors beside Israel no matter the territory. And therefore, any resolution that involves an independent Palestinian state is simply not possible. Everything else is wishful thinking
exactly.. people just dont know how states are created... they keep crying about international law when that does nothing for the creation of states.. just because something was given, does not mean something will remain, it is the people who must make it happen and the people decide at the end of the day.. not some entity in a rich area in europe..
@@the_grand_toureris he wrong though? The Syrians themselves (near the golan) have stated they prefer Israeli rule or whatever tyrannical regime will take over Syria.
Yes, their fathers and grandfathers, instead of accepting existence of israel thought they would destroy it and return back. Unfortunately, the new generation thinks the same. Why i do not hear that some gazans want hamas to negotiate to release hostages
Make it the Worlds RESORT Beach ⛱️ front property. Each Nation gets REPRESENTED by thier Own Beach front property. Giving GAZANS taxable Revenue n JOBS...
@Transformers-oe5jj lol.. not sure what you definition of delusion is, but being able to see something throughout someones whole life definitely makes it reality.. the delusion sits on a bunch of people, now 3-4 generations down the line, who think they are the true owners of the land lol..
*Israel🇮🇱 must respect ICC & soveregnity territorial integrity of Palestine (Gaza strip, east Jerusalem, West Bank), Syria (Golan). end war & keep peace.*
Gaza is with ISRAEL, No one has any say may be Saudi or anyone else, had anyone done anything on kidnepped or 7oct then now they should stay at a distamce
You need self-determination to build a paradise on whatever you have left, or you need self-determination to keep attacking your more powerful opponent. Change your mentality and strive for peaceful coexistence. Learn from Jordan, Egypt, and very soon Saudi Arabia.
Was told this was a news article about Gaza. Ended up being some Arab Woman doing a hit piece on BiBi. YA WE GET THIS EVERY SINGLE DAY OF THE WEEK FROM YOU DW. WTF!
I wonder if some people even know what genocide means. Something that even ICC hasn't dared declare, yet the experts on UA-cam have become international prosecutors.
Self-Defense is not a "cause" so does not require "justification". That's a rule of law and a standard of justice. I don't believe the person whose life The Pianist was based on every said that in real life.
Palestinians are homeless.iranians are in enjoying their homes. Start seeing iran as your enemy.
Nice try projecting white coloniser
The consequences of War started by Hamas. Oh well they knew they will lose but they'd still foolishly attack the Bear and then played as the victim.
And there won't be a war for atleast 25 years atleast in Gaza they now know the costs are higher then they are willing to pay.
Their consequences, of course allows Israel to occupy more Syrian teritory today
Their consequences ofcourse
@@aj3314That’s how the world works !!
Syria and Iraq never started anything with Israel but they got bombarded, attacked, and invaded
@dimasanggayuda3966 Syria invaded Israel 3 times and constantly allowed itself to be a launchpad for rocket fire.
Iraq hasn't stopped launching UAVs and Rockets.
Some fantasy world you live in.
If isreal occupy Gaza again what will be gain of what hamas did on October 7?
It almost looks like it was a bad decision, it resulted in the suffering of Gazans and the long term result will be more suffering so what did they actually gain ?
What did European Jews gain during the Warsaw Ghetto surprising? Literally everything you just said applies to that situation
Yes I agree with you...and the international community can't do a thing about it even if Israel occupies Gaza. They were waiting for this moment and Hamas fell right into the trap because the Palestinians love violence and hate Israel more than they love their own children and freedom.
They were hoping to destroy Israel but they failed.
@@invadingomen6826 in ghetto warsaw they knew they were set for complete extermination. In Gaza they lived in a modern first world city, with malls, amusement park, zoo, cinemas, parks... life expectency was far above world median, and gdp was above world median too. There are neighborhoods in Cairo that had worse living conditions.
@@MrWorshipMe Source: trust me bro
No, it's too late for 2 state madness.
Arabs, after 20-30 years of re-education, could perhaps obtain some form of autonomy.
How is this any different than any other war throughout time. Here’s an idea: don’t start a war. The Gazans are lucky they have Israel as a neighbor instead of Russia.
Russia haven't killed 30.000 civilians In Ukraine, yet after 3 years
No1 would like to have Israel next to them
You never know What God promised them on Buddhist or Hinduist religions
Are you out of your mind? Attacked the occupiers? Ukrainians also have no right to fight the Russian army?
Now that they're displaced they want to return to Gaza city... But when they were living there they wanted to return to Haifa... And basically that's palestinian identity in a nutshell: starting conflicts, getting displaced and dreaming about returning to the place they got kicked out
lol they keep trying to take over the whole land, everytime losing alittle more and more. they see the borders of Israel as their own, and respect the borders of neighboring arab nations lol..
Haifa is Palestinian land so he isn't wrong if he wants to return there
Kind of like Native Americans and Aborigines of Australia…
@@apiklala I don't care. Haifa looks much nicer under Israel.
Us Scots-Irish and English Americans will always have the backs of our brothers in Israel.
Light will shine in the Middle East!
God bless America 🇺🇸
✝️Amen
Dont speak for us Irish and Scottish. We suffered from colonialism so we definitely do not support the stealing of land and the suffering of the innocent. Dont you have education in the US?
Long live democracy in the middle east!
After october 7, the Palestinian state concept died.
We, in Europe, always think about poor Palestinians (almost infantilizing their attitudes)
Now, let’s just think only one minute about Israelis viewpoint too. Israel withdrew entirely from Gaza. Gave them a chance to try building a defacto state. Only one month later? Hamas and rockets fired at Israel instantly.
Now imagine that West Bank/Judea and Samaria ? It would be simply suicidal for Israelis to repeat the same mistakes.
Israelis even proposed 5-6 times peace agreements to Palestinians that were all rejected!
Let’s open our minds to the fact that this Palestinian concept is dead already. A solution is to split sovereignty with Egypt / Israel in Gaza and Jordan / Israel in the West Bank.
They left the place but closed it off making it a concentration camp. Of course peoole inside will be radicalised
@@abrakadavra3193 not true.
Well we in Ireland respect international law and oppose the illegal occupation, ethnic cleansing and colonisation of Palestine. Palestine has to right to exist, the vast majority of the world recognises Palestinian statehood. The idea of dividing a country as you imply is illegal and violates international law arround territorial sovereignty. It is Israel that is in breech of international law, the only way there can be peace is if Israel stops invading Gaza, withdraws is occupation and illegal settlers from the West Bank and Jerusalem and to allow the international community to help the Palestinans build their own state in their own territory! 🇮🇪🇵🇸☘️🍉
@@jaabaadaabaaadoo what part is not true?
the thief returning a bathroom doesn't mean he had returned the house .
Wait, what?! RE-occupy???
Isn't Israel already occupying Gaza?
depends... maybe that wall that stopped terror attacks is still occupation in your view.. anyhow that wont matter anymore, they will be inside gaza this time... the wall remains..
It is in reference to the previous formal occupation that lasted until 2005
Israel hasn’t been in Gaza since 2005. Where you been?
Before October 7, Gaza was free... no occupation... since 2005
@@Alex-vu6lt free from Israel maybe, not from Hamas...
An independent gaza after 2005 failed miserably. They need Israeli control to succeed.
How colonial of you…
@@Pou1gie1 but it's true. Gaza had the chance to be proof itself and it disproved itself horribly.
Here we go again.
Typical DW.
Biased reporting as usual.
And the Arab leaders is silent.. Isnt that wonderful.. 😂
@@samsmith2635 biased in which direction?
@@changedNameSorrybias in the sense because dw never reported how the war started, never brought up Hamas as terrorists, are they not?
@@libistur You obviously don't follow their reporting. They are strong advocates for Israel's right for self defence. This said, they are not everything goes. But nobody of Israel's allies in Europe is everything goes.
you started a War! now playing victim ... no sympathy here!
Doing what your fathers did in 1948 and expecting a different result is unwise to say the least 😢
The Palestinians have proven again and again and again. They are not able to be peaceful neighbors beside Israel no matter the territory. And therefore, any resolution that involves an independent Palestinian state is simply not possible. Everything else is wishful thinking
are you joking !! your reverse things, people without state who want them to be expelled and at risk of genocide doesn't remember you any people .....
Israel is the least peaceful neighbor in the middle east
Israel has proven again and again that they are interested in the land and not peace. Apartheid and occupation is not peace
exactly.. people just dont know how states are created... they keep crying about international law when that does nothing for the creation of states.. just because something was given, does not mean something will remain, it is the people who must make it happen and the people decide at the end of the day.. not some entity in a rich area in europe..
@@AmonTheWitch "Israel is the least peaceful neighbor in the middle east" How many wars did Israel start and how often was Israel the victim?
Re occupy is the euphemism for re steal Palestine.
It was never theirs in the first place.
Sudan Nigeria Chad Syria Liberia Iraq Yemen Lybia Uganda are best places for peace
Onestate solution is the only way to permanent peace. Let all gazans and westbankers live in peace and enjoy the benefits of living in Israel.
Gaza under Israel is a peaceful Gaza.
That has to be the most crass and tasteless comment on this page.
Gaza was under Israel for the past decades...and it brings to 7 october
Its always been under Israel and look at what that led to.
@@the_grand_toureris he wrong though? The Syrians themselves (near the golan) have stated they prefer Israeli rule or whatever tyrannical regime will take over Syria.
@@Mandems973no it hasn’t. They were under Humuz rule for about 18 years.
I hope this world will always be peaceful 😢😢😢😢😢
Let them go to Iran or Lebanon.
Iran- not Lebanon
Let Israel go to Mongolia or Madagascar as was the original plan instead of stealing indigenous land
Why does the presenter look like he is suffering from acid reflux?
I wonder this every time I see him on this channel 😂
Yes, their fathers and grandfathers, instead of accepting existence of israel thought they would destroy it and return back. Unfortunately, the new generation thinks the same. Why i do not hear that some gazans want hamas to negotiate to release hostages
“Special Military Inhabitations” please. It isn’t annexation if your deity ordained it millennia ago, duh.
What deity said so? It's been told in a book written by mortals.
How is this fair journalism bringing an Israeli ex IDF soldier and presenting her to the audience as an unbiased Middle East analyst.
Thru have both sides calm down we know you can’t stand them callllmmm down
Make it the Worlds RESORT Beach ⛱️ front property. Each Nation gets REPRESENTED by thier Own Beach front property. Giving GAZANS taxable Revenue n JOBS...
One of the greatest plays of our time. Future historians will have grateful material.
God bless Israel
Are they running out of sand?
Now I know not to waste my time with DW.
Maybe Gazans can move to Syria, probably be better
They will feel clearly at home considering that Israel is also invading Syria. 😊
@ both believe in an apocalyptic version of islam
Maybe Isrealis can return back to Europe
maybe you can move to the moon?
@ wow you think syria is equivalent to an alien world… I’m scared what else you may be thinking
It will end like east prussia 🤷
It will end like all the crusades ended
@Transformers-oe5jj the First,second,third and fourth crusades were Victorious what are you talking about?
@@NicolasHaufe 😂 victorious 😂 that's why you are delusional about this one 😂
@Transformers-oe5jj Stop projecting yourself on me its creepy
@Transformers-oe5jj lol.. not sure what you definition of delusion is, but being able to see something throughout someones whole life definitely makes it reality.. the delusion sits on a bunch of people, now 3-4 generations down the line, who think they are the true owners of the land lol..
🇮🇱🇺🇲🇺🇦🇬🇪🇮🇳
No more dancing and cheering?
That's why this will never get solved. No one will make a deal that hurts each side. It's all or nothing for both sides.
*Israel🇮🇱 must respect ICC & soveregnity territorial integrity of Palestine (Gaza strip, east Jerusalem, West Bank), Syria (Golan). end war & keep peace.*
Palestine is fictional idea
Iran, Hamas, Hezbolla and Houtise must stop attacking Israel.
Palestina must recognize Israel's sovereignty.
When they leave you alone you follow them, what do you want?
Israel can build luxury seafront houses and beach bars there. Then, the handsome young men from Gaza can sell ice cream to tourists 😊
Making money is nice
And the German left party member girls can be served by them guys with the money from shutting down German Industry!
YOU CANT REWARD COLONISERS WITH LANDS
Arabs Colonisers are not being rewarded.
The extreme right IS right.
Gaza is with ISRAEL, No one has any say may be Saudi or anyone else, had anyone done anything on kidnepped or 7oct then now they should stay at a distamce
These lands belong to Israel before now they take it back
You need self-determination to build a paradise on whatever you have left, or you need self-determination to keep attacking your more powerful opponent. Change your mentality and strive for peaceful coexistence. Learn from Jordan, Egypt, and very soon Saudi Arabia.
Was told this was a news article about Gaza. Ended up being some Arab Woman doing a hit piece on BiBi.
YA WE GET THIS EVERY SINGLE DAY OF THE WEEK FROM YOU DW. WTF!
Look at the presenter! Does he reflect German culture?
@@LawpickingLocksmith wasn't the one presenting the information so I couldn't give a hoot.
Did you actually want to respond to what I said?
76 year long apartheid, 17 year long blockade of Gaza and now committing genocide. PURE EVIL
Pure ignorant comment
Purely ignorant indeed
@philus012 You are the liar. He wrote the truth.
Hahahahahha
@@dave84111nope add the numbers up
Civilian in gaza wants peace but their government wants a war😅
nope.. they elected a terror governmnet..
@@jfern6673 20 years ago.
It's not conflict!! It's genocide and it's still happening 😢😢😢
No it's not. repeating a lie doesn't make it true
I wonder if some people even know what genocide means. Something that even ICC hasn't dared declare, yet the experts on UA-cam have become international prosecutors.
Didn't we say it from the beginning?
The Israeli were legally living in Gaza just as in Judea and Samaria.
You dont understand law lol
😢
Free palestine 🇵🇸
❤🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻❤️
They need to get out, they need to leave. They've been told to leave and they don't listen.
Israel buffering themselves a new country 😂
Justice & Independence for Palestine🇵🇸
Soo the comments were always right😂😂 maybe let peopel comment more.
Leave Palestsnian land only then there can be permanent peace otherwise more sleepless nights for both sides.
Liar. That's not what Hamas said about their goal.
They even want to conquer Rome and America.
They said that. Do you want proof?.
Liar. That's not what Hamas said about their goal.
They even want to conquer Rome and America.
They said that. Do you want proof?.
Liar. That's not what Hamas said about their goal.
They even want to conquer Rome and America.
They said that. Do you want proof?.
Which land? The West of Israel or the east?
Does that include Tel-Aviv?
There was a sentence in the movie The Pianist: "No cause in which people die is justified."
very true... that is why the deliberate and targeted massacre on innocent civlians by the palestinians on oct 7 was inhumane and brutal.
What about the cause of Greater Israel...
I strongly disagree.
Self-Defense is not a "cause" so does not require "justification". That's a rule of law and a standard of justice. I don't believe the person whose life The Pianist was based on every said that in real life.
Very one sided report , tatally ignored collective evil and hate of Palestinians
The current Lebensraum doctrine.
JFC read a history book.
His trial had been ongoing during the war - it was not a factor.
This is a genocide
No it's not
No
no,its a self defense
there should be a jail term of 20 years for anyone is says this. Its a crime of stupidity.
No. Words have meaning.
I think it's like they traded crimeria for Gaza strip maybe 😅 lol
OFCOURSE THEY WILL STAY.
Settlement is illegal according to your law and you supporting them build and settle 😮
Is Tel-Aviv a "settlement"? The al-Aksa Mosque was a "settlement" of Marwan 1.
@@nuqwestr
(2. continuing)
Specially as you make your play on religion.
@@nuqwestr
(3. continuing)
Then you claim “they want wipeout us” while exactly the opposite is happening right now.
YT is censoring rational posts, no insults no hate speech.
This discussion thread is being shaped by YT
Free Palestine
Free it from the world
deutch land is complicit in another…
No
no
The Greater Israel Project...?
dw still calling it a «conflict » 🤬
India is peacedul national