❤ NICE to see both of you. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
I generally dont comment but taimur sahab words could stop me syaing that he is the most powerful and speaker that talk so much sense. He is an extra ordinary scholar
WOW WOW WOW ... Haven't seen someone privileged like Taimur Bhai to be so vocal about how things can be in real Poverty life & how Elites have a head start.
@@Sam-kd2dc every human being can play a certain role in the problem's solution. Atleast he has made Mazdoor Kisaan party and trying to take steps in a direction which gives the non-privelaged some direction. Also he spent time teaching and propogating Socialist ideas. He is doing his bit in my view.
Very good and impressive podcast and I enjoyed to listen Dr Taimoor Sahib and in Lastly he gave me great hope that there would be change in the Pakistani society through social media and status quo would be defeated in a few years.
Real issue in our system is injustice. A person can have his opinion however archaic it happens to be. Such opinions essentially are detrimental to his own life. One must work to eradicate injustice in society. Let people find their own ways to find peace and prosperity in their own life.
میرے خیال سے پاکستان بننے میں ہی غلطی تھی جس کی وجہ سے آج ہم 80 سال بعد اس مقام پر کھڑے ہیے جہاں جہالت غربت افلاس ہمارے اندر بھرا ہوا ہیے پہلے دن سے ہی نعرہ ہی غلط لگایا گیا تھا ہزاروں سال سے وادی سندھ کے لوگ ایک ساتھ رہ رہے تھے پھر ایک دم سے دو قومی نظریہ کہاں سے آ گیا ۔چند سالوں میں اتنی نفرت کہاں سے آ گی کہ 10 لاکھ معصوم انسانوں کو قتل کر دیا گیا ۔پہلے دن سے پاکستان پر جنرلز جاگیردار اور سرمایادار قابض ہو گے تھے اور یہ پاکستان بنایا ہی ان لوگوں کے لیے تھااور جاہل لوگوں کو اسلام کے پیچھے لگا دیا گیا ۔
Sawal yeh hai k Yeh Sara kuch kaisay change hoga society kaisay change hogi aur dusra sawal keya society amali tor change honay k liey keya kar rahi hai ?
I do not understand why what is said by Lums knowledgeable Prof is not told to the General Public, in Pakistan about the freedom movement, how was it shaped , & the negative role of British & Jinnah
Can you explain/include the effect of 2nd World war independance. I think if after war situation remained good independance was not possible. England left instead we earned?
To say Tata Birla were aligned with British is not totally correct. Yes, they had to work with power that mattered. But in those days, India exported nothing more than raw materials. Tata’s set up the steel mill despite strong opposition of British steel interests. The cotton mills were set up and developed despite opposition from Manchester interests. Obviously, British capitalism was the biggest player and all businesses had to work with them. But were they British interests like the landed gentry / princely states who supported British in 1857. I would dare say that businesses were pro India whereas landed interests were pro British.
بہت زبردست لیکن آپ کے پورے تجزیئے میں جس سسٹم کی یا جس نظامِ تعلیم کی یا جس اشرافیہ کا ذکر کیا ھے آپ نے اُنہی کو مخاطب کیا ھے مطلب زیادہ تر انگریزی میں الفاظوں کا استعمال کرکے اُس عام اور غریب آدمی کو اپنی معلومات سے محروم کردیا
روٹی بندا کھا جاندی اے۔ Moral decline is natural after sustained poverty… It’s obvious, without assurance of basic human necessities, no society can thrive. Pakistani Civilians r the one who hv always been neglected. It’s awful… No one has true empathy for them.
اشرافیہ سے اللہ تعالیٰ اس کے حرام کھانے کے بارے میں پوچھے گا اور ان لوگوں سے بھی سے بھی پوچھے گا جو یہ بات جانتا تھا اور اس نظام کو ختم کرنے کیخلاف کو کوشش ہی نہیں کی۔ I'm Nabeel. This is the argument............
ڈاکٹر تیمور صاحب نے فرمایا ہے کہ ابھی تک داس کیپٹال کا اردو ترجمہ نہیں ہوا۔ یہ بات درست نہیں ترجمہ بیس سال پہلے کا ہو چکا ہے اور انٹرنیٹ پر بھی میسّر ہے۔ اگر کسی کو درکار ہو تو پی ڈی ایف بھیجا جا سکتا ہے
😢 Unfortunately this man doesn't know that what is money ? However he is a good person. He might be a good sociologist but doesn't know the economical science.
ڈاکٹر تیمور کی سوچ واضح نہیں۔۔پہلے وہ معاشی عدم مساوات اور اسکے نتیجہ میں طبقاتی تفریق پہ بولتے چلے گئے۔۔پھر عباس بھائی کے سوال کہ غریب پسند بھی امیر کلچر کو کرتے'کی کوئی وضاحت نہیں کر سکے۔۔بس شغل مغل ۔۔دوسری بات انہوں نے ایلیٹ طبقے کی بجائے 'خود'کو یعنی فرد کو ڈسکس کیا۔۔تو پہلے پندرہ منٹ ڈیلیٹ کردیتے تو اچھا تھا
❤ NICE to see both of you. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! !
Sharm magar inko aati nhi, siding with liberals
salam sir i wana meet to you
I love Ali Bhai ❤❤❤
@@Iconoclast601sarm tumko aati nahi siding with chandakhor molvie
Engineer Sahib, Allah aap ko ISI ko chorr ke sach ke saath kharrey honey ka hosla de!
I generally dont comment but taimur sahab words could stop me syaing that he is the most powerful and speaker that talk so much sense. He is an extra ordinary scholar
Schollars are away from masses
Both of you guys are very sensible human beings. Appreciate your work. Respect from India.
Well done Taimur Sahib and thanks a lot Abbas for bringing up such a well balanced intellectual on the forum.
Ye sab bewkuf hai inn logo ki baaton pe na jana khud padho itna bongiya hai ...
Dr Taimur is a nice person, bhagwan aap dono ko khush rakhe❤
Two great personalities and scholars Love u both
Dr. Taimur Rahman is really Gem 💎. Lot's of love from india 🇮🇳.
Dude you have no idea how much I like these podcasts keep it up
Abbas bhai apko dekh kar insaniyat pe yaqeen aur badhh jata hai... salaamat rahen bhai❤
Love you both 💓 💗
Abbas Bhai! Excellent Great 👍
Taimur sb, I love your all analysis
Hadees E Rasool (SAW) hy Gurbat Ensan ko kufar tak pohncha deti hy😢😢
Human consciousness is irrepressible.Thankyou.
Very profound discussion
MashAllah Great Knowlage Shared with us.Thanks
Wonderful. As usual Taimoor Rahman is spot on. While Abbas is a very good host as usual
I love listening to Prof Taimur.. what a gem of a guy... Kbhi borr bhi ni hone dete..
Dr Taimur just hats off to you sir 👏👌 don’t have words to explain what you are doing for humanity
بہت اچھی،معلوماتی، پر اثر اور دلوں کو تحریک دینے والی گفتگو، ماشاءاللہ
م
Good intellectual debate. We need more of these debates to widen the horizon of thinking.
Meri age bhi 18 year hai aor main aap ki video bhut like karta hon Bhai Abbas haidar ❤
Meaningful debate. Thanks,
True! In Pakistan meritocracy is hinged with connections to the establishment.
Brilliant!
Keep up the good work Abbas.
Kia BAAT hai Dr shab zabardast
آپ کے مہمان اس بار بہت اچھے ہے 👍
Excellent
mulk gareeb nahi ha paise ki distribution unbalance ha 😭😭😭
@@shahabrao8995 thats is called capitalism, that what dr taimur had been fighting against since decades
WOW WOW WOW ... Haven't seen someone privileged like Taimur Bhai to be so vocal about how things can be in real Poverty life & how Elites have a head start.
So? What next? Has he told that? Can he do anything actually?
@@Sam-kd2dc every human being can play a certain role in the problem's solution. Atleast he has made Mazdoor Kisaan party and trying to take steps in a direction which gives the non-privelaged some direction. Also he spent time teaching and propogating Socialist ideas. He is doing his bit in my view.
Very nice.
What a beautiful awakening conversation
That you Dr Taimur and Abbass.👏🏻
Excellent!!!
Thank you both of you gentleman.
Good👍🇮🇳❤❤❤
Waiting for part 2 👍🏻
Excellent guest and very helpful discussion 👏👏
Will wait for part 2
Dr Sahb is love
Brilliant discourse🎉
Very enlightening
Very good and impressive podcast and I enjoyed to listen Dr Taimoor Sahib and in Lastly he gave me great hope that there would be change in the Pakistani society through social media and status quo would be defeated in a few years.
Great presentation.
Good anayalsis ❤by Sr taymor
Very good perspective. Specially cultural capital
Amazing please make part 2
amazing
Thanks
بھت صاف سچ کہ رہے ہیں
Brainstorming session ❤❤❤
Love you 💕 sir thank you
Nice ❤
Dr sb good to watch the interview,,,,,, you should do some social work
Three solutions to solve the crisis
First one Education
Second Education
Third Education
Real issue in our system is injustice. A person can have his opinion however archaic it happens to be. Such opinions essentially are detrimental to his own life. One must work to eradicate injustice in society. Let people find their own ways to find peace and prosperity in their own life.
we all need to build internal individual character within ourselves even before being muslim or pakistani we need to be human.
Interesting debate. Most questions were not well addressed. The title of the video is also not covered
If you print too much money, it would lead to hyperinflation like Zimbabwe. So the solution is not feasible.
جہالت سب سے بڑا ظلم ھے جو مسلمانوں نے اختیار رکھا ھے چاہیے پاکستان کے بننے سے پہلے یا بعد مایوسی کی وجہ بھی غیر سنجیدگی اور عدم اخلاص ھے
میرے خیال سے پاکستان بننے میں ہی غلطی تھی جس کی وجہ سے آج ہم 80 سال بعد اس مقام پر کھڑے ہیے جہاں جہالت غربت افلاس ہمارے اندر بھرا ہوا ہیے
پہلے دن سے ہی نعرہ ہی غلط لگایا گیا تھا ہزاروں سال سے وادی سندھ کے لوگ ایک ساتھ رہ رہے تھے پھر ایک دم سے دو قومی نظریہ کہاں سے آ گیا ۔چند سالوں میں اتنی نفرت کہاں سے آ گی کہ 10 لاکھ معصوم انسانوں کو قتل کر دیا گیا ۔پہلے دن سے پاکستان پر جنرلز جاگیردار اور سرمایادار قابض ہو گے تھے اور یہ پاکستان بنایا ہی ان لوگوں کے لیے تھااور جاہل لوگوں کو اسلام کے پیچھے لگا دیا گیا ۔
Munafiq wo hai jo sach jaante hue hi sach na bole
Matlab Musalman😅😅
Sirs, some latest statistics show 35% of pakistan population living under extreme poverty.
Real Democracy RD is the only solution
State to ensure education to everyone
❤
mango can' b expected 4m a banana tree same wise tranquility is not possible in the country formed on the basis of hatred.
آپ بھاڑ میں جائیں😂 ۔
بہترین باۓ دی وے ♥️
True islam
ڈاکٹر صاحب ایک معمولی سا سوال ہے کہ اگر ان بائیس کڑوڑ گدھوں کو کچھ انسان بنانے کے لئے آپکو مقرر کر دیا جائے تو--
Allah ka khoof karoDr ko bih Ghaha bana ny ki koshish Na karo😂😂😂😂😂
Sawal yeh hai k Yeh Sara kuch kaisay change hoga society kaisay change hogi aur dusra sawal keya society amali tor change honay k liey keya kar rahi hai ?
I do not understand why what is said by Lums knowledgeable Prof is not told to the General Public, in Pakistan about the freedom movement, how was it shaped , & the negative role of British & Jinnah
پم خیال لوگوں کا اچھا یہ سنگم ہے
وگرنہ سماجی رابطہ کاری کا ہجوم بےہنگم ہے
ڈاکٹر صاحب داس کیپٹل تو ترجمہء کر دیں پلیز
💯🤌🏼
59:00
Sir middle class ki definition kren plz ?
Can you explain/include the effect of 2nd World war independance. I think if after war situation remained good independance was not possible. England left instead we earned?
To say Tata Birla were aligned with British is not totally correct. Yes, they had to work with power that mattered. But in those days, India exported nothing more than raw materials. Tata’s set up the steel mill despite strong opposition of British steel interests. The cotton mills were set up and developed despite opposition from Manchester interests.
Obviously, British capitalism was the biggest player and all businesses had to work with them. But were they British interests like the landed gentry / princely states who supported British in 1857. I would dare say that businesses were pro India whereas landed interests were pro British.
بہت زبردست لیکن آپ کے پورے تجزیئے میں جس سسٹم کی یا جس نظامِ تعلیم کی یا جس اشرافیہ کا ذکر کیا ھے آپ نے اُنہی کو مخاطب کیا ھے مطلب زیادہ تر انگریزی میں الفاظوں کا استعمال کرکے اُس عام اور غریب آدمی کو اپنی معلومات سے محروم کردیا
What is the contribution of trillions of Zakaat
Love pakistan from Nepal 🇳🇵. Aap log India mai reunited hojao 😊
Aap log bhi saath aa jao
@@amitgoyal9816 Nepal toh hamesh India ka hai. Aaj vi 30 thousand Nepali indian army mai hai ❤️🇳🇵
روٹی بندا کھا جاندی اے۔
Moral decline is natural after sustained poverty…
It’s obvious, without assurance of basic human necessities, no society can thrive.
Pakistani Civilians r the one who hv always been neglected.
It’s awful…
No one has true empathy for them.
اشرافیہ سے اللہ تعالیٰ اس کے حرام کھانے کے بارے میں پوچھے گا اور ان لوگوں سے بھی سے بھی پوچھے گا جو یہ بات جانتا تھا اور اس نظام کو ختم کرنے کیخلاف کو کوشش ہی نہیں کی۔ I'm Nabeel. This is the argument............
ڈاکٹر تیمور صاحب نے فرمایا ہے کہ ابھی تک داس کیپٹال کا اردو ترجمہ نہیں ہوا۔ یہ بات درست نہیں ترجمہ بیس سال پہلے کا ہو چکا ہے اور انٹرنیٹ پر بھی میسّر ہے۔ اگر کسی کو درکار ہو تو پی ڈی ایف بھیجا جا سکتا ہے
Share it pl.
aray sir by the way English is more easy then Urdu.
Poverty leades a man to kufer
Shah waliullah ny b gurbat ko masail ki jr kaha ha. Phr ap SAW ny b kaha k ghurbat kufr tk ly kr ja skte ha
Abbas aapki aankhon mein neend bhari hui lag rahi hai😊
🙈🙈
Sara masala chanda Ka ha is liya har firqa chata ha mara gro bada hojay
😢 Unfortunately this man doesn't know that what is money ? However he is a good person. He might be a good sociologist but doesn't know the economical science.
Can you kindly enlighten us what is money and what the intrinsic value of paper money please.
Please explain what MONEY is?
Ocean of knowledge
They were afraid of Gandhi, they wanted to save their lands. 😔 la illah illalah was fraud for laity's.
Qaiser Ahmad Raja ❤Only
Zombie
Communism is also dogmatic which Taimoor represents 😢
👍
भारत में कुछ हद तक गरीबों के हक में काम सभीं ने किया है मोदी जी बढिया काम गरीबों के लिए किया है और कर रहे हैं।
😂😂😂
Kuch bhi bakchodi karo.
main problem of pakistan is pakistan army
ڈاکٹر تیمور کی سوچ واضح نہیں۔۔پہلے وہ معاشی عدم مساوات اور اسکے نتیجہ میں طبقاتی تفریق پہ بولتے چلے گئے۔۔پھر عباس بھائی کے سوال کہ غریب پسند بھی امیر کلچر کو کرتے'کی کوئی وضاحت نہیں کر سکے۔۔بس شغل مغل ۔۔دوسری بات انہوں نے ایلیٹ طبقے کی بجائے 'خود'کو یعنی فرد کو ڈسکس کیا۔۔تو پہلے پندرہ منٹ ڈیلیٹ کردیتے تو اچھا تھا
Abbas bhai excellent
tamaam
This gentleman is totally utter nonsense. He totally failed to get the root cause