Which Mora Knife Should You Buy? - Companion HD VS Bushcraft Black VS Garberg
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лип 2023
- Which Mora Should I buy
Garber VS Bushcraft Black VS Companion HD
Companion HD
www.canadianoutdoorequipment....
$32.00CAD
Specifications
Blade Length: 4.1” / 104 mm
Grip length 5” / 120 mm (includes protruding pommel)
Total Length: 8.8” / 224mm
Blade Thickness: 0.12” / 3.2 mm
Net Weight: 4.9oz / 139g with sheath
Steel Type: Carbon steel (1095 Equiv)
Hardness 57-58 HRC
Handle material ABS with soft overmold
Pro/Con
Least expensive
Best tip for carving
Spine comes unsharpened
Bushcraft Black
www.canadianoutdoorequipment....
$69.00CAD
Specifications
Blade Length: 4.3” / 109 mm
Grip length 5” / 120 mm (includes protruding pommel)
Total Length: 9.1” / 232mm
Blade Thickness: 0.12” / 3.2 mm
Net Weight: 5.6oz / 159g with sheath
Steel Type: Carbon steel (1095 Equiv) - DLC coating
Hardness 57-58 HRC
Handle material ABS with soft overmold
Pro/Con
Midrange price
Very well finished
Sharp spine
Wider blade than Companion
Tip not as fine
Mora Garberg (thanks Chuck from Texas)
www.canadianoutdoorequipment....
$136.00CAD
Specifications
Blade Length: 4.3” / 109 mm
Grip length 5” / 120 mm (includes protruding pommel)
Total Length: 9.3” / 229 mm
Blade Thickness: 0.12” / 3.2 mm
Net Weight: 7.3oz / 208g with sheath
Steel Type: Sandvik 14C28N stainless steel
Hardness 57-58 HRC
Handle material polypropylene
Pro/Con
Full tang construction
Sharp spine
Most expensive
Heaviest
Optional Multi-Mount Sheath
Less of a crafting knife, more of a general to survival knife
Not as grippy as other two
I have hundreds and hundreds of dollars in knives, that includes all the moras except the Black. Of all my collection, the only one my hand keeps reaching for is my carbon steel Companion, not even the heavy duty, just the regular Companion, reason being the blade thinness. I do batoning, food prep, carving and all general cuttig with this. I had a thought in my head for a while now that knives are getting thicker and thicker, but I don't really see the point to that if it's not a fuil on survival knife. Going to antique fairs, I saw hard used agricultural tools that are thinner than some of my knives, and if those stood the test of time when people didn't have modern metallurgy and materials, maybe I didn't need a sharpened prybar to split a branch or two for feathersticks but a change in prospective in how I use the tools I find comfortable.
I agree. Thinner knives carve so much better. Thanks for commenting
Mors Kochanski liked the Mora Classic for every task he needed to do in the woods (other than chopping I guess) as his ‘survival knife’ which is very similar to the more modern (but not necessarily better) Companion.
Why do you prefer the Companion over the Classic models?
Thanks for any suggestions
I’m jealous
Out of the ridiculous amount of moras I own, I tend to choose the eldris and companion the most. The spark would be next and then the garberg. I don’t regret buying the garberg But I don’t think I would buy it again. I can carve wood with the companion better and clean moose and rabbits with it better also. The garberg is a great knife but don’t do all those tasks better. The companion is my favourite knife by far. It is my go to knife. I have about 8 ss and 4 carbon. Lol. Absolutely love them. Cheers from Newfoundland!
The Companion is a winner for sure. Thanks for commenting
Love Mora knives. You can snag a Mora Robust for less than 20 bucks...fantastic knife!
Right on. Thanks for commenting
The button isn’t for connecting to pants, but is, as you also said, for adding another knife or knives with one point of attachment to the belt or pants by clip.
I think you will find it is both ua-cam.com/video/VGRnolrt7EM/v-deo.html Thanks for commenting
I've been using a regular companion for about 5 years now. The 2mm thickness has never bothered me, the knife has batoned, carved, prepared food and a lot of other things. I also own a HD and a bushcraft black but I still prefer to regular companion
The thinner blade is so much nicer to carve with. Thanks for commenting
Can’t go wrong with them,best value thing on the planet.
The Companion carbon , 2mm thickness is excellent. It's one of the best Mora's, price and function-wise.
Excellent handle ergo's also.
I like it much better than all those expensive knives.
Lots of info! Your attention to detail is appreciated. Thanks. I may have to watch twice. I love it. Thanks again.
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
Great review. For me the Kansbol works best. I have them all but since I do have little wood work in this part of the world, and the tasks I do is mostly outdoor food prep, field dressing, and butchering sometimes, Kansbol shines over all other beautiful Moras.
This is my choice as well. I have a lot of Moras, but this is the one I have multiples of and always take with me.
I now have the Kansbol and have a review coming. Thanks for commenting
@@Butch_Deezlsteak even if it was 5 bucks I prefer Kansbol. Ps. I have them both
I prefer the companion, bushcraft black, or kansbol over the garberg, because I think the price difference does not correspond with an equal increase in functionality, and in any case I always carry the Hultafors GK for heavy duty, cuz if it breaks it does not cost much, really almost nothing...
Right on. I agree with your thinking. Thanks for commenting
I totally agree. I've owned a bushcraft black for some time now. And I still think mora is king in the bushcraft world. Keep on keeping on.
I am fortunate in that I have quite a few knives but the truth is, my Mora Bushcraft Black is as good as any of them. Thanks for commenting
Another informative video, Mark. Thank you so much. Best wishes from the San Francisco Bay Area. - Tim
Glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for commenting
I love this video it's helpful very much when some rookie people (including me) that looking for a new bushcraft knife.
Thank you very much.
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
The garberg was always my choice. Mostly because of the full tang design with part of it sticking out the butt, which has a lot of uses for crushing and scraping. Honestly not sure I would buy a garberg now, as there are better choices now that are more affordable and just as capable for less than ~110USD/135CAD. I think Mora has forgotten that its popularity was because they were inexpensive knives that are good quality.
I agree. Joker makes some great alternatives. Thanks for commenting
"Part of it sticking out the butt" had me chuckle, ahhh yes...the knife that poops 😂
if you're on a budget a Kansbol will do everything you need unless you use your knives for batoning. I wouldn't baton with any scandi grind though considering how much material you have to remove to sharpen, and if you dent or chip the blade on a knot it's a nightmare to fix
I have another video coming featuring the Kansbol. Thanks for commenting
Thank you for comparing the Mora knives. These types of videos are so helpful. I like the Buschcraft Black, primarily because of the pronounced guard- for beginners, this looks like a good safety feature. All the best, Mark.
The Bushcraft Black is my top choice as well. Thanks for commenting
Excellent job. I own lots of Moras and have my own thoughts, but this was a fun comparison.
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for commenting
My first bushcraft knife, and still used in rotation, Companion HD. And like you I sharpened the spine! Cheers Mark.
Right on. Thanks for commenting
Thanks for the extensive review! My brother gifted me with the Kansbol a few years ago, and it's done a good job for me. I don't do much wood carving, so that doesn't really enter into the equation for me. And since it was a gift, the price was spot-on!
Glad you enjoyed the video. I have a review of the Kansbol coming soon. Thanks for commenting
Great Comparisons & Thanks For Your Thoughts On These, Mark ! ATB T God Bless
Thanks for watching Terry
I own the Bushcraft model in ss its definitely the one i would choose as well. I own probably about 6 or 7 moras and its my favorite as well. Great knife. Good video. ✝️🇺🇸✝️
Glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for commenting
Hi! Mark: Another great video. Knives are like hiking staffs. To each his own.
My first pocket knife was a TL-29. My dad gave it to me as a kid. I wasn't dressed if my TL-29 wasn't in my pocket. I still had a TL-29 in my pocket when I was in the Army and sent to Germany. I was in Supply. I kept that TL-29 sharp. As many electronics came packed in two and three boxes one tight inside the other. I could cut through all three layers with one steady push of the TL-29. People said they had never seen a knife that sharp.
More onto your subject, the first knife I bought myself was one of the first Mora knives. It had a wooden handle, and a full tang laminated blade. That blade was advertised to be able to be bent 90 degrees in a vice and straightened without any damage. I only tried it once. That was proof enough for me.
But that laminated blade could sure be honed sharp! But I wanted a longer blade. In time I bought another Mora, and removed the handle and made my own wooden handle to my likes, and installed a metal finger guard at the hilt.
I did buy another blade, five inches. But it was not laminated either. I did make another handle, and finger guard hilt. But I didn't like the first handle, and years later made a new handle I like a lot.
Mora seemed to quit making the laminated blade, but I did find two Mora 6 inch full tang blades in a knife supply catalog. But they were not laminated. I bought two. I've had them for years, but I have not decided what I want to make in handles for either one.
You mentioned in another video, the Grohmann knife you bought. I prefer the design of what they call the #1 Original. I love the oval blade and nice flowing handle. But I refuse to pay what they are asking for the knife. I have found Cold Steel makes a nice inexpensive copy of that knife. I bought three. Later I did buy the Grohmann folding model of that knife. I knew waiting to buy it later would only cost that much more. I got it for under $80.
My grandfather gave me his knife collection, which included some blades from around the world.
It also included his personal Marble 6 inch hunting knife, which I had seen him wearing many times as a kid. I always loved that Marble knife. The stories it could have told.
I like working with leather as well, scabbards and holsters. Functional only. I don't do leather carving.
Once I moved here to the eastern Sierra desert area of California, I became friends with a Native American. He collected knives. A saddle maker had made two knife scabbards for him. But the single stitching had failed. And the saddle maker would not repair them. I had overheard the conversation, and when the Native American went to leave, I stopped him. I told him I could repair his scabbards for him, with double stitching. That was the beginning of a life long friendship. He was a telephone repairman. He often bought knives with no scabbard, or he did not like the scabbard that came with some knives. He had me fabricate what he wanted in scabbards. Many were nothing like I had never made before. He was always satisfied with my work. But he said I never charged him what I should have. He knew of my grandfather's Marble knife, and we both liked Marble knives. He liked the shorter blades. I liked the longer blades. One day he brought me a gift. It was a brand new Marble knife, the same model as my grandfather's, but with a 7 inch blade. Wow! What a beautiful blade! He said it was to make up for all the times I didn't charge him enough for all the scabbards I made for him. He came down with cancer and died a short time later. I'll always cherish that knife the rest of my life.
The scabbard that came with the 7 inch Marble fit rather sloppy. I used the same leather of the factory scabbard, and made a nice tight fitting scabbard, with a simple design for the safety loop. It is made of round leather lacing, and fits tightly in holes punched through the leather. It can be adjusted if it wears or stretches. And can be easily replaced if it ever breaks. I have advanced to the point I no longer use metal fasteners in my leather projects.
Best Wishes, Mark
Sounds like you made a friend for life by offering to help the guy out. I also am not happy with the retail price of Grohmann knives, considering how other makers are making some of their designs better for less money. Thanks for commenting
Great job on a difficult topic. I’ve owned all three blades and my favorite is the Mora Bushcraft Black. What does it for me is the comfort of the handle, hard to beat.
Of the three it is most comfortable for me as well. Thanks for commenting
Great video, thanks for sharing your knowledge.
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
I'm coming up on a year since I got my first Mora. I got the 27$ orange one. I have been so happy with it. As my first bushcraft knife it fit the bill perfectly. I carve with mine almost daily, use it in the woods for bushcraft and use it around the house. For 27$ you cannot go wrong. If they were free I would choose the Bushcraft Black but I wouldn't go buy it knowing how good the cheapest version is. Thank you for sharing Mark!
Great choice in knives Steve. I bet if you tried my Bushcraft Black you would be looking to save your allowance for one😉. Thanks for commenting
It's amusing to see the differences between hunter outdoorsmen and bushcrafters. Nice comparison video and thanks.
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for commenting
Excellent review. Thank you
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for commenting
What I use is a hair band threaded through the sheath and double looped around the handle totally locks it in and its stil rather easy to remove
Great mod. I had added a short piece of shock cord and made a drop loop but removed them for this video to focus on the knife. Thanks for commenting
Thanks for the video Mark. I have the Mora Bushcraft Black, and the Garberg. I had the Spark, but my grandson wanted it so I no longer have it. I like them all, but relied more on the Garberg and carry it most often. I don't think it is really any better, but feels more solid. I would rely on any of them as they are all great blades.
It does come down to what you feel most confident in. Thanks for commenting
I completely agree with you on these three knives.
I appreciate your take on these knives. My review of the Kansbol will be out soon. Thanks for commenting Rob
I have more mora knives than I thought, but my single most used is my mora h.d. companion.
Hard to beat the HD Companion. Thanks for commenting
Just ordered the Black after watching some of GB2's assessment videos. I know I won't be a heavy user, so partial tang will be OK. Your video has confirmed right choice for me. Thanks! Cheers!
The Black is my favourite Mora. It can take a good amount of hard use. Thanks for commenting
I’m not sure I agree with your assessment of the Garsberg. First, the current price on Amazon is $68 for the carbon Garberg with the simple sheath and $75 with the upgraded system. I agree with you about the utility of the simple sheath. Overall, the Garberg is a more robust and capable of more demanding bushcraft tasks than the Black. Additionally, the Garberg comes with a 90 degree spine for scraping and use with a ferro rod. All in all, the Garberg is a better bushcraft tool than the Black or the Companion. A $120 price tag is a bit much to deal with, but as I cited the current price on Amazon is only slightly more than the Black, not twice as much. Now as far as carving is concerned, I am unsure what carving tasks that you are requiring a fine tip for. Typical bushcraft tasks such as making tent pegs, or pot hangers, making notches for a hand bow, or even carving a fire board to use the bow with can easily be accomplished with the Garberg. For more detailed carving, I always carry a More 112 carving knife that was designed for carving tasks. (the right tool for the right job.) As you say, all of the Mora products are excellent choices and if price-point is a crucial factor, then the Companion is an excellent. But, as Mors Kochanski said once, the best knife for the job is the knife you have with you. He was a big fan of the Mora Eldridge that he dangled from his neck. So, based on Mors example, I have the Eldridge around my kneck, the Garberg on my belt, and a Swiss Army Forester in my pocket. For multi-day camping, I also pack the Becker BK-9 for chopping tasks and a Bacho folding saw for processing fire wood. Personally, I wouldn’t consider the Mora Companion for anything. But, I did get the Mora Black as a gift for my son. It’s a good knife, but the I think the Garberg is the best choice and for $68, why wouldn’t you get the most complete bushcraft choice? ….just saying.
So, I am not arguing that the Garberg is not a good knife but I do not feel it is as good at "bushcraft" tasks, which includes carving, as the Bushcraft Black or Companion HD are. The Garberg is a slightly more heavy duty knife but I don't feel that makes it better at bushcraft. My price comparison is based on what they were available for to me at the time the video is made. I still stand by my assessment. Thanks for commenting
I have the bushcraft black for about 4 years and love it. No reason to change. Its rock solid, even if the tang is only 3/4 but thats overrated in todays world anyway.
Amazing value for the money.
I agree totally. Thanks for commenting
Excellent presentation. Thank you.
Glad you enjoyed it!. Thanks for commenting
Hi Mark. My first knife from 1967 is hand crafted with classic wooden handle. The sheath is r/deer stitched and riveted. It has fur and teardrop facing and simple l / straps to tie to pants. Also have 50 mm with matching sheath and antler handle with inlays. Only newish one is very early BLACK in carbon. Lars from down under. Haven’t been to Sweden since 69. First post since collander cooking suggestion. Still enjoy your posts though !! Many thanks
Your knife sounds like a true old-school puukko. Thanks for commenting
Love those Mora knives! I’ve never had the Garberg, but I’ve always been a fan of the simple 510 in carbon steel and the wood handle Laminated steel ones. I prefer the simpler handles that don’t have the finger grooves.
I need to add a No1 or No2 to my collection. Thanks for commenting
Hello Mark! Just bougt a classic Mora with wood handel and finger stopp for my husband, during your revue! It is for carving! Hope he use it! I love carving in wood! Barbro 🇸🇪🕊
Great choice. I am sure he will love it. Thanks for commenting
Good comparison video Mark , thanks for sharing , God bless !
Glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for commenting
As always, a great thumbs up review. My favorite Mora has been the Robust pro carbon. I carry that knife literally everyday and use at least briefly everyday and have had it for 7 years. One just can't argue about the tremendous Mora value to cost ratio.
I share the same option. I love the Mora Robust! I don't understand why the Robust is not so popular as the other Mora models. Greetings from the woods in Sweden.
Hi Lonnie. Good to hear from you. I was thinking of you when I made this video knowing that the Robust is whet you carry. I may have bought mine because of you. Thanks for commenting
Oooh I've got that same robust, bought it 10 years ago - that was my first bushcraft knife as well
A real keeper and user. Thanks for commenting
Picked up a Kansbol awhile ago & really like it. But my older companion has been great over the years. Also have the Eldris for playing around camp. So if I’m out it’s a SAK in my pocket, a Companion or the new Kansbol on my belt & an Eldris as a neck knife if I’m in camp & want to have it on.
I have reviews of the Kansbol and Eldris coming. Thanks for commenting
Great video, sir. As one viewer commented, "a difficult topic." We are fortunate to have so many choices and can have them delivered to our doorsteps. Knife choices can be highly personalized. I have a few Mora's and recently added a Garberg after finding a stainless version with basic sheath for $55.00 USD. Excellent comment about crossing over to a survival knife. I hope I never have to find out.
I agree, so many knives to choose from. Hard to decide which is my favourite. Great buy on the Garberg. Thanks for commenting
ua-cam.com/video/5DrP4we4yJQ/v-deo.html
Bruce Zawalsky used the Basic 511 for 20 years and now has the Mora Pro C.
Canadian Wilderness Survival.
Should say enough I think.
Narrow tangs are fine, have always been fine. History has proven this.
I wish the Garberg came with the Bushcraft handle.
That would be cool. I would buy one. Thanks for commenting
Nice Video Sir!
Glad you liked it. Thanks for commenting
Hi Mark, 😊 thanks for another interesting video, your choice of companion HD, and bushcraft black , would be my choice also. The price of the companion knives makes them cheap enough to buy several to keep in various kits, and if you want low maintenance buy the S/S HD version, I use both types and achieve excellent results from them both, their cheap, easy to sharpen, and will do all anyone needs to do whith a cutting tool, and should you be unfortunate to lose one it's not as heart wrenching as losing a high end knife. Best whish's Mark to you and your's, Stuart UK.
Glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for commenting Sturat
First class review 👍. A lot of good personal comments from you.
Glad you liked it. Thanks for commenting
The Kansbol is the most versatile Mora in my opinion. It’s a great bushcraft knife as long as you don’t do any heavy batoning. It can handle light batoning for splitting kindling no problem. It’s also the best Mora for food prep making it great for camping. It’s a great hunting knife as well. I used my Kansbol on a recent elk hunt and it did a great job skinning and processing my bull.
My review of the Kansbol is coming shortly. Thanks for commenting
Looking forward to your review of the Kansbol and comparison
The blade shape is very similar to the Garberg with a blunter point not as good fit fine work
The handle is coated and better
The blade profile is very sympathetic to food prep and fine work
The thinner blade is very easy to carve
And the spine is razor sharp for scraping and fire starting
An excellent knife for the price point
The best choice is the Condor Terrassur which combines the blade shape of the Companion and the strength of the Garberg at 1/2 the price
Please buy and review this knife
I have been thinking about the Terrasaur. Will consider. Thanks for commenting
I always have 2 answers for most asked knife questions.
Want a knife for a friend who is into outdoors.. any Moira
Want a knife as a gift for my husband.
Buck 110.
Ah yes, the Buck 110. Glad I own one but does not see a lot of use. Thanks for commenting
I was hesitating back and forth but I now replaced my Garberg with the new Mora Lok from the Ash series ... after I got a nice discount from my dealer and I have to say I prefer it over any other Mora I have used. Yes it is expensive but the slghtly better blade geometry, handle shape and better finger guard made it my favorite Mora now.
The new Mora Ash series do look nice. They look more like a real bushcraft knife than the Garberg. I trying hard to talk myself into getting one. Thanks for commenting
Those are ten times more expensive for the same steel…. That’s a tough sell. For that price, you can get some fine knives with much higher quality steel.
Great comparison Mark. Have you ever or would you ever consider an episode on knife sharpening/maintenance ?
I have been asked and may do that yet. Can be very involved type of video. Thanks for commenting
I've used all three
All of the above. All three are good users
Right on. Thanks for commenting
Great video. Not many guys mention the tip problem of the garberg. From the time the Garberg came out on the market I wondered why they shaped a bushcraft knife more like a hunting knife. This less sharp tip and the wide belly is an absolute no go for a primaly woodworking knife to me. Talking stability, because they are dirt cheap, I abused Mora basic 511 knives to splitt and crosscut with a baton through all kind of things, not only wood. I never managed to break them or get the handle loose. When it cames to Moras, maybe the full tang dactrine is overrated. When I go outdoors, I mostly even wear a Mora classic No 2. And I do light betoning with it too ( I know I shouldn`t).
I agree. I see the Garberg as more of a light survival knife than a bushcraft knife. Thanks for commenting
Its crazy but i have to admit that out of all my expensive knives i choose the most my Mora companion 😅
I would recommend anyone a Companion with a Axe and Saw for Bushcraft 😊
I know what your saying. Picking up a Mora feels like meeting up with an old friend. Thanks for commenting
It really boils down to what you use your knife for and the price you pay. If you can get a Garberg on a deep discount then go with that as it's simply better built.
Thanks for commenting
For carving and small precision tasks the best is really the classic red wood handle mora. It just allows for a wider range of grips for different jobs. And it’s probably the cheapest mora available. It’s not a “survival knife” or a do-it-all tool, but for carving, it’s a mainstay …
Totally agree. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft I have the No.3 Classic. It is superb for carving, especially hardwoods even with tough knots. Makes short work of them and great for detail. Great no-nonsense channel!👍
The Bushcraft black is such a great knife, the orange if you're out near the ocean, great handle, very strong. The Garberg is one of the strongest knives ever made, the Companion is one of the nicest little outdoor knives money can buy but...the 2000 and/or the Kansbol are the undisputed winners for me. Great knives, lovely steel, very comfortable handles and both have excellent sheaths. Love my Moras.
My review of the 2000/Kansbol is coming soon. Thanks for commenting
Hi Mark! Excellent comparison vid on the 3 knives! Over the years I’ve had a few moras, from the original Clipper to the first generation of the “Black” and I think you have hit the nail right on the head, the Black is probably the best all round Mora for a bushcraft knife! The Garberg on the hand is a move away from bushcraft to a “hunting” style knife, in my humble opinion of course😂 As for battening, no knife is designed for that, a knife is for cutting an axe is for splitting!! Right tool for right job😂
I actually have a few knives that are purposely designed for batoning (the terava skrama would be one example). I've also used my Garberg for light to moderate batoning jobs (no more than 2-3 inches in diameter) for over a decade without ill effect. Sometimes it is easier to carry a knife and a saw (or a big and a small knife), rather than a knife and a hatchet/axe. I also personally would rate the garberg as a general bushcraft/survival knife due to the shape and grind of the blade, Mora has other more hunting focused designs such as the 2000.
Glad you liked the video. We will need to agree to disagree on batoning though. Thanks for commenting
Great review! Just adding (I'm sure most of you know) that all three of these models are available in both carbon steel and stainless. I have Bushcraft Black and Companion HD both in carbon, so I am thinking my next one will be either a stainless Kansbol or Bushcraft orange, just so I have one stainless blade in the mix.
Thanks for commenting
The companion is perfect (cost, simplicity, design)
Right on. Thanks for commenting
I often hear Mora Knives consider as beginners knives and have to wonder how much better other knives truly are. I do not see the value in a $300 dollar Bush Craft knife that is three times the price of Mora Garberg either. You are paying for the pride of saying or showing your interest in knives. That is a high price to pay standing alone in the woods for what you get.
Leather sheaths, super steels, beautiful woods and famous brands do not make you a better Bush Crafter. You may look better in a mirror and that is about it. I like Mora knives because they work. I would look at the Mora Axe Outdoor Kit in Orange and add an orange Eldris to the kit and you do not need adding an orange lanyard. 🤔🙂
I agree. For me, the reason I own a custom knife is to better fit my hand than most production knives. However, I would be happy to own just a Mora. Thanks for commenting
G'day mate, certainly a fair point. And equally fair to say IMO, if you happen to be a "knife dude" you're inevitably gonna mess around with an array of variables ; )
Besides, if you're one to get right out in the sticks, we can be talkin life or death, so if your tools aint up to scratch, I'd hope you'd agree, that's a bad thing.
Having said all that I'm with ya, you dont need to spend huge bucks to stay well equipped. Mind you I'm not going to be betting my life on a Mora, in isolation anyway, I'm much more comfortable with them as either back up to something else significantly bigger and more capable on the trail, or as great utility in a car camping scenario for example.
Btw; I dont know the Mora Axe kit, but I will look it up, thanks for mentioning it. I can tell you the Fiskars X7 hatchet is pretty much bomb proof, wouldn't surprise me if it actually is bomb proof, lol, and gets a lotta work done for a small, ergo friendly, light, (I think arond 700 grams if memory serves), package and for not much moolah, (think I paid 50 -60-ish AUD), orange on the lower handle too; their whole range is at least worth a look IMO, your use case and personal taste will ultimately decide. Cheers Duke.
The mora bushcrafts, black and orange are awesome and worth the upgrade over the companions IMO. The garberg is way too close in price to many other finer knives with better materials. Love your videos btw, keep up the good work!
Glad you liked the video. Thanks for commenting
Best alternative to the garberg is a 110 Jaakaaripuukko. It’s awesome.
I have a review of that knife. Thanks for commenting
I can buy a similar knife at Walmart fishing department for $3. I can buy 40 of these throw-away knives. No brainer. I bought the bushcraft black for $45. Never would buy a Garber overpriced. Bingo we agree.
Thanks for commenting
Thank you, I also have begun collecting knives and love the Mora brand.
What is your opinion between Mora Bushcraft Black or Terava Jaakaripuuko 110 from Finland.
If you asking about a choice between the two knives, the Jaakaripuuko is a tougher more all round outdoors knife and the Bushcraft Black is more of a crafting knife. Having said that, both are great choices. Thanks for commenting
The Kansbol might be between the Companion and the Bushcrafter. Personally I have found that the 2mm thick Moras carve much better than their HD ones. I keep going back to the Basic with a sanded off guard. Good video. Thank you.
I have a review of the Kansbol coming. Thanks for commenting
Companion HD was my first knife and is great for the price. The Bushcraft black handle is superb. I prefer the Condor Terrasaur over the Garberg.
I need to try a Terrasaur. Thanks for commenting
Oh and I forgot to mention. On the most Mora knives the edge goes right up to the grip no ricasso what so ever. Its harder to sharpen, yes. But when carving you have more power because of the better leverage. and that is what counts for me.
I agree. Thanks for commenting
Had a similar thought about the Companion vs Kansbol. The Kansbol is a good knife but not 2,5 times better, prefer the handle and tip/bladeshape of the companion.
I prefer the Companion of Bushcraft Black for general bushcraft but the Kansbol is a better cooking knife. Thanks for commenting
Part of the price of a knife is the cost of manufacturing. I suspect the Garberg has greater manufacturing costs due to its different design from all the other Moras. I have a Garberg and I Iike it but I use a Martini fishing knife the most.
Yes, I agree. Manufacturing and material costs do play a part in price. Thanks for commenting
Yes. And if you want something for carving, mora companion carbon!(no hd, no stainless)
Right on! Thanks for commenting
The tang of the companion is about a quarter inch wide. The Bushcraft Black is three quarters of an inch wide.
Good to know. Thanks for commenting
Really? I own an HD Comp and Bushcraft Black. Hoping you’re right that would be awesome
Hi Mark, I just looked on there site and this one jumped out at me; MORA COMPANION HI-VIS ORANGE KNIFE $24.95, I don't need another knife but I am very tempted with this one.. If I was still doing a lot of canoeing and wilderness camping I would go for this one MORA BUSHCRAFT SURVIVAL ORANGE $96.95.
Yes, I almost bought both😅😅. Thanks for commenting
The regular Companion knife that I have has a rubber grip section in the middle - the new HD version looks just like the one I have but with a thicker blade - but your Companion HD looks like it has a completely different handle. You might want to pick up the new version of the companion to compare since it is so cheap - I purchased my Companion a few weeks ago on sale for $14.95 USD which is an incredible value.
Yes, I did mention that mine is not the true companion but the older style Robust HD. The same except for the handle colour. I agree, the companion may be the best value Mora available. Thanks for commenting
Enjoyed the video!
I have the garberg in carbon, the companion HD carbon, the mora robust hd carbon also. I really enjoy them all.
Is it true that the garberg uses a better quality carbon steel than in the other Mora's?
Thanks again for your video
Glad you liked the video. To my knowledge, the Garberg uses the same carbon steel as all Moras which is similar to 1095. Thanks for commenting
Could you use one of these for “food preparation while traveling/camping?”
For sure, as long as you keep them clean. The Mora Kansbol would be better. I have a review on that as well. Thanks for commenting
The big downside to those mora the companion and the black is the sheath is right hand only. I bought the Garberg when they were on Amazon for $55. With the multi mount. I like the knife but the sheath isn’t my favorite. Really to tell you the truth I use the BPS adventurer more. I really love the grind. The Garberg has the potential but I haven’t felt like reprofiling the whole blade. Everyone says it’s a different animal once it’s convexed.
Another thing I’ve learned is for my use which is camping an fishing the kansbol is probably the best choice or the Eldris.
I love big knives but really 3-4 in is all the knife anyone needs. Another really great knife I carry a good bit is the mini Pendleton hunter. The AUS10 version is in $30 range really useful knife.
Good thoughts on the Garberg, BPS, Kansbol and Eldris. Thanks for commenting
This might be a little late however both the Garberg and the Kansbol will fit in their sheath in both directions, making the sheath ambitious dexterous (at least the simple plastic one) Maybe the leather sheath is different though for the garberg
@@J.sh_CDN I have the Garberg because of that exactly. 99% of knives are made for right-handed. Most of my knives are kydex or coldsteel they can be revised.
@richardhenry1969 oh! I misread your above comment! I understand now what you mean.
If you ever feel like trying the BPS Adventure knife, they actually make a Left handed sheath for it, that is also marketed for use with Garberg sized blades and such. Pretty cheap price too, I've bought a right handed one in anticipation for buying a Terava puukko 110 without sheath
For a beginner and if your money is precious then instead of buying a garberg but a stainless steel companion together with a stainless steel companion HD. Bring two knives with you outdoors and 99.9% of the things you do will be satisfied with both knives. And they won't rust.
Right on. Great assessment. Thanks for commenting
I got a Bushcraft Black years ago when I was a beginner in the bushcraft field. It has been used and abused, with all the mistakes that could possibly occur.
Never had a problem with it! The coating and the mini-bevel are long gone on the scandi grind :)) Very good and easy to sharpen steel.
I recently got a Garberg black with the mini-survival kit (a ferro and a diamond sharpener) and I am testing that and abusing that as well.
In my opinion, if you are doing bushcraft, you need more than one knife. The Garberg is a better primary knife than the others at least because of that crossover to the survival part.
If you want to do fine crafting you better get a specific tool for that like a Mora120, 106, or even 162S it will be way over the companion!
Right on. Well thought out based on experience. Thanks for commenting
Your videos are exceptional and we're extremely appreciative of your efforts. Keep up the fantastic work!
Best wishes,
Team Theta
Thank you for your kind words. I have two other Mora knife videos if interested and my review of the Kansbol is coming soon
I have Mora MG Companion Carbon and for myself is10/10. I use it whenever I get a chance 😂..Great knives without question...
Right on.Thanks for commenting
Great video!
Have you any experience with the Mora Kansbol?
I do now as I received one after making this video. I did own the Mora 2000 but wanted to wait until I had the Kansbol. Review coming shortly. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft I have been using three Mora 2000 for almost 2å years and I am looking to upgrade to Kansbol in the near future. Looking forward to your review!
I still prefer the Bushcraft Black. I like the edge geometry better.
I like it as well. Thanks for commenting
Some might call it sacrilege.. But I have filed down the clip point on my garberg..
It was a big risk on such an expensive Mora, but I am happy with the result..
Its now a kind of cross between a bushcraft black and a companion HD..
I lost a little bit of length, but its still about 2 mm longer than a HD
I also removed the protruding tang..I hate them and it was uncomfortable in my palm..
In my opinion they should have just made the HD in a full tang version..
I don't know about it being sacrilege but I would make the modifications if I felt I would enjoy using it more. I will look at my Garberg and give this some thought. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft
I have since noticed the BPS version of a Mora..
@@CJ-bb2gs I have just made a review video of that knife to be released soon
In the states the prices are a lot cheaper. Bushcraft black interests me. I have a Garberg which I like.
Thanks for commenting
Mark, are you planning to affix some bright coloured paracord to your Mora Black?
Possibly, just trying to decide if I want to drill a hole in it. Thanks for commenting
Two quick points. Firstly, as others have already said, you should have , ideally, included the Kansbol.
Secondly , why or why do Mora not put a lanyard hole in all their sheath knives at the factory stage ?
PS the multi-mount kit with the Garberg/Kansbol is great for wearing over thick winter clothes so you can access your belt knife very quickly without fumbling through layers of over garments to reach your blade.
I now have the Kansbol with a review coming. I see the tiny bit of cord I put through lanyard holes as more of a way of finding them if I drop them rather than something to help me hold on to the knife. Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thank you for your reply, looking forward to watching your review of the Kansbol .
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Just to add another comment. I find lanyards invaluable for retaining vital equipment , especially when on a prolonged expedition or "in the field" for a long time and tiredness, minor injury and forgetfulness start to affect your actions and behaviour.
The Companion SS with the 2.5mm blade is the one people should really be looking at.
Thanks for commenting
Hello from British Columbia Canada
🇨🇦🖐👍❤🌳🌲🚐🌳🌲🖌🎨🛶🤳😎
Thanks for commenting
You know your stuff. Indeed the Clipper had a broad but short tang and not too much plastic handle to support it when batoning. They also came if different blade shapes. The old companions had the same handle but a standard blade shape and thinner but much longer tang. Later they changed to the new handle ans we know the Companion today. The one you're showing is from the 'Craftline' I think it was called and no longer in production as far as I know. They had the normal version in carbon and stainless and this Robust version.
Almost identical to the Mora Companion and Companion HD.
Never bought the Bushcraft Black but have the same handle shape on the 'Forester'. For my hand great in hammer grip and sucks in reverse grip.
The Garberg is stronger maybe but not a good slicer or carver in fine spots. Besides that it's heavier but most of all overpriced. For that price you have a whole lot of other options already.
For people just starting out or children I advice the Basic 511 or 546 or the Robust if you want a thicker spine. The reason is price and the hand guard for protection. But the best buy even for experienced people is the Companion or Companion HD in my opinion.
Thanks for adding to the details. I agree, the Companion is the all round best knife
Hi Mark. I think that this comparison is not complete without the Kansbol. As it provides next to garberg robustness a some would argue better precision then eider the HD od Garberg (my favorite camp cook knife paired with a opinell 8 slim)
Agreed. I now have the Kansbol and have a review coming. Thanks for commenting
Companion HD is way more robust though.
I've seen the destruction tests of Joe X on UA-cam.
Not everyone's taste. But it shows the differences really well.
Sideway pressure is not something the Kansbol handles well. It snaps rather easy.
But for camp/cooking it is totally fine ofcourse.
@@Ve-suvius I can confirm that HD is tough - i have both of them and i used my HD to take down door frames and parts of a brick wall (i would never try that with the kansbol so i cant say if it would mach up)
@@m0riss
Cool, yeah, it is a tough cookie for sure. Nice to hear your experience.
I would like the Kansbol to see it in carbon.
I'm really a carbon fanboy so to speak.
I understand the choice for stainless Morakniv made, for slicing tomatoes and veggies and meat. The stainless is nice. Then again. Many Japanese Chef's knives are made of carbon also. So I see no problem there really.
Btw, the Kansbol did plunge nicely through the car roof. It did way better than man so called combat knives he tested.
But that sideway tip test was no good for the Kansbol, it was break after break, like a snap off utility knife.
There's always a trade-off. The Mora Pro C is a much better slicer than its thicker brother the Pro Robust. But the Pro Robust has its robustness going for it, you can easily pry your way out of a cut with it. No problem.
which Mora for "bushcraft"?
I'm rather partiial to my Mora Number 1.
I suppose any but the Eldris, and the curved ones for carving a spoon would get the job done.
I have a few of the spoon carving Moras but need to add a No 1 to my collection. Thanks for commenting
Nice
Thanks for commenting
Great video! For bushcraft, would you recommend stainless steel or carbon?
The answer, as with most things is, it depends. Generally, I would suggest a good quality stainless steel. As afar as the Mora knives are concerned, either steel would a good choice, provided you take car of them in terms of sharpening and preventing rust, especially on the carbon steel knives. After that, steel choice varies greatly. Hope this helps
@@MarkYoungBushcraft Thanks so much! I appreciate it!
The Bushcraft Black is excellent.
The Companion's also.
I don't like the slick grip of the Garberg, no guard either. A little guard is preferred by me.
Slick handle and no guard= no thanks.
Wide tip on the Garberg. Not preferred either.
Thanks for commenting
@@MarkYoungBushcraft
The Mora Pro C and Pro Robust are also great little knives.
If money were absolutely removed from the equation, would you still choose the others over the Garberg?
Ove been looking for a good knife that sort of fits all the requirements. I'm a bit fixated on a full tang knife where the tang termination is exposed, and better yet if it has a striking surface at the butt to drive stakes as I do a good bit of camping and CO ground is pretty hard.
There is almost always something handy (rocks mostly) to drive stakes, and a knife is admittedly not perfect for that task, but it is something failing all else beong available. Its also a less-lethal means of deterrence.
I have several knives, but my Buck and K-Bar are the closest comparable tools. Both have a striking surface but both leave me wanting. The Buck is too short for much batttoning and the K-Bar is heavy and I've seen questionable durability issues.
The Gerber Ultimate Survival knife had my attention but it appears a bit fragile, and so I took it off the list. My Helle is beautiful and sharp but is not full tang and I i think limited in what I'd use it for.
The Gerberg seems to fit most of my requirements though I wish it had more of an intentional striking area. I don't tend to use a knife as a pry, but sometimes it can't be avoided.
I really like the bushcraft black but not being full tang worrries me, which brings me back to the Garberg.
Money is not an issue for any of these knives, though I'm reluctant to take anything much over $100 into the wild as they are at risk of being lost and I never have seen a truly justifiable leap in performance or durability above those prices, particularly for knives intended for these uses.
Thoughts?
For me and the way I use a knife of this size, the Bushcraft Black makes more sense. If I need more robustness I go with a larger knife like one the Terava or Work Tuff gear knives. From what you describe, it sounds like the Garber might be a good choice. Hope this helps
Hi Mark! I would like you to answer!
which is the better choice? Mora Bushcraft Orange or Bushcraft Black? I would like you to give reasons!!!
Thanks!
It depends on where you will use your knife. The stainless steel (12C27) is very good but very basic. Best used in environments that are mostly wet or around salt water. The carbon steel (1095 equivalent) has better edge retention and overall toughness than the stainless steel but requires more maintenance to prevent rust. Personally, I am happy with the Bushcraft Black. Thanks for commenting
For someone just starting buy the normal Companion to begin with,it’s mostly all you’ll ever need anyway.Heck buy a spare one they’re so cheap.
Agreed. Thanks for commenting
I am I guess pretty weird when it comes to knife use. Usually if I go out I take a knife roll. I may only use one of them but I have close to a dozen to chose from. I will say that I am fond of the thin blade knifes.
One is none. If you can take the weight then why not!
Not weird at all. I often have multiple knives with me as well. Thanks for commenting
If you compare these knifes knives by price you would have to lose/break 4 Companions or 2 Bushcraft Blacks to justify the Garberg price. I tend to carry a backup knife and a separate food prep knife so perhaps an argument can be made for owning all 3.
Good way of looking at it. Thanks for commenting
The Garberg will struggle in today's market, better knives for 3/4 and even half the price. I'm a Companion fan, HD or not, and perfectly satisfied with what I have, and the Garberg at 60 USD🙂 might compete, but not so much at anything above that
I agree, the Companion is still the best value Mora available. Thanks for commenting