@@kaprelim8135 not a good exercise stretch position shoulder not good and u have to start with your bodyweight pulldowns better more control your brainwashed like so many thinking u have to do this and that exercises it's all a lie it was said to sell u something
They tend to fry the small muscles in my back, with little lats and traps. They aren't great for everyone, could be my crazy stupid barrel build body, but I don't get wide from them, at all. I get much more lat and rear delts from weights, and teres don't get fried like chernobyl
@trapps75 I mean rhomboids and teres are the main movers in pull ups. They work together, I don't get a great total back workout doing pull ups alone. Maybe you do? Good for you. Barbell rows, seated rows, seal rows all clear pull ups in terms of back growth.
@trapps75 and pull ups are almost inherently all teres/rhomboids from a full hang, not lats. Your losing lats towards the hang almost completely. The pull up is not ideal for back growth. Argue minor details all you want, nostalgic memories blah blah blah, we are talking about total back growth. Pull ups are not good for upper traps, lats (contrary to beliefs, the other exercises listed are BETTER for lats, I guess that's wrong too?) or progressive overloading. Nobody wants to buy a belt chain AND have a gym membership. It's just added tedious nuance lifting, that falls short of BB Rows and stiff leg deadlifting.
He’s a strongman, and a lot of strongmen are 300-350+ pounds. I think that pull-ups are A tier or higher, but for those who are much much higher in body weight, they aren’t necessarily the easiest
@@str1ker_eureka One of the reasons he gave is that it's hard to scale for people that can't do pull-ups or aren't able to rep them. But beginners can simply do jackknife/feet-assisted pull-ups and progress those until they can do regular pull-ups.
@irnbru22 I don't guess buddy. At the end of the day we should implement all the back exercises. Pull ups are on the top of the food chain in my opinion. Many can't do them and I understand
I like how someone realized that the letters on the tier list should change from light to dark to contrast with the background colours, but then seemingly forgot about it after the first one.
After watching a ton of your videos I must say you are a hell of a writer and commenter. I really appreciate your perspective in the middle of all the noise.
You all need to listen to this man, if you think he is wrong, you are thinking too much. When I started making my upper back a priority all of my lifts started going a lot smoother. If you are lacking an upper back weights can take you out of position too easily, and you won't know that's what's happening until you start bringing it up.
i completely agree, i neglected my upper back and my bench was hurt by it. once i started training it hard my bench skyrocketed 50lbs in 2 months to 265
There wasn't really a good reason given for that. "Harder to start with for some people" is fair, but there are ways around that like negatives. It is definitely S-tier, or at least A-tier. Easy exercise to perform, and easy to overload with a belt. (and has the variations like wide/narrow grip, or chinup for bicep focus)
just discovered this video as i'm recovering from rotator cuff surgery; hence all lower case type. in my early 20's i started entering bodybuilding contests. i have average genetics at best. and it took 7 years of weight training to even think about competing. barbell rows, weighted chins and cable rows were my staple lat exercises, also ez curl bent-arm pullovers finished the deal. i got great lats/serratus just from these four exercises; winning best back in one show. no dbl rows or lat bar pulldowns. just didn't do 'em. also want to say how much i appreciate the illustrations in all of these exercises. not sure who is the artist, but great work, and i don't usually say that...i was the main illustrator for MUSCULAR DEVELOPMENT MAGAZINE from 1994-2007 and am extremely critical.
Old-school greats like Leroy Colbert swore that wide grip pull-ups were the key to growing wing-like lats, especially the lower portion of lats. People dismissed this as pseudo-science, however. Well, I realized the other day that Wide Grip Pull-Ups, (done where your chin just clears the bar) are essentially long length partials (not extreme stretch, but that's been shown to have minimal difference.) Lengthened partials have been recently shown to emphasize growth in the distal portion of the muscle-in this case the lower lats. The Bro Science/old school wisdom was just waiting or the science to catch up once again...
I don’t think u understand what science means. It doesn’t come up with shit. It refines it. Ur going to find the most bullshit from old school. The shit that works in old school will continue on. Science doesn’t invent new ideas. It takes old ideas and simply puts them through the test saying whether it’s legit or not. There’s a reason someone like Alex doesn’t like sports science hypertrophy. Bcz to prove something works means it requires extremely rigorous testing which is hard. That’s why it’s so good at shifting the dogshit old school has given us already So if u wanna point fingers. Why not show the amount of dogshit old school has taught as well? Bcz a lot of people say a lot of different things then. Science tests them all and simply allows the correct one to follow through
Pull ups and chins ups is all you need to build a God like back ! This video is basically giving you the alternatives for people who cant do pulls up/chins ups. If you look at calisthenic athletes and streetlifters you can see clear evidence of the after effects of pulls ups. Therefore, it is an S tier excercise which is basically the father of all back excercises.
Lol god like back.... calisthenic athletes spend hours a day training. Like saying "do gymnastics to look like a gymnast!".... neat, 15 hours a week to have a meager amount of muscle
As a former Marine and being our upper body test on the PFT , Pull-ups are staple of back day for me. I just think it's bad ass to knock out a lot of pull ups and even more badass to knockout muscle ups. And dudes in prison have built great physiques from pull ups being their main back exercise. Anyone who knocks down pull-ups as an exercise, just suck at doing pull-ups
The reason pull up should be S 38:18 or at least less than a it's because you had to do full range of motion if you do pull-ups with your arms always standing and pulled apart to your neck or upper chest is a whole different ball game than people not getting their chin up to the bar or gooseneck i n g when you can bring your pull-ups all the way up to your upper chest or lower part of your neck you get a contraction on your all your back muscles
So just for the record, I agree with your stance on pull-ups. For me personally, weighted pull-ups/neutral grip pull-ups have always done more for me than anything else. But technically speaking, your reasoning is correct for why your placed them where your did
While i appreciate the shout out, i have to say, "pull ups are C-tier is Wild." Calesthenics guys get wide af! Also in regards to dumbell pullovers, if your use lying on the bench variation as in your illustration, the strength curve sucks. Do cross bench or hanging of the bench like someone who knows the movement and it radically improves.
Really? I just started doing them out of necessity d/t a bulging disc. Going really light until I get the form down and my back starts to feel better. Still can't figure out the best way to hold the bar. My wrists don't bend very well so I've been crossing my arms and the bar is pressing against my neck a bit. Not sure if that's normal or not?
@@Mrbobcat7 At first it may feel uncomfy, and may leave you out of breath. As when you first start back squatting and the bar feels awkward. Soon it will feel better (though the bar should be resting somewhere around your clavicle)
@@Mrbobcat7do overhand not under just hold the bar at your shoulders. Takes the focus off the wrists and im the same as you but my disc fully burst like a doughnut now i never back squat and my max atm is 100 that like 250kg on the back heavy asf and my backs 98% back after 18months. And quads are explosive also.
C Tier for Pullups is total ridiculous. It just puts into question everything else you say and there was absolutely no need for that. You are my favorite channel to listen to when it comes to strength training. I bought and read your book "Base Phase". This is unfortunate Mr Bromley as that is a time tested "late intermediate", lift you need to first work to "unlock", before you can program it of course. But the results they produce speak for themselves. Come one, just look at the Calisthenic community as they seem to produce the best backs in existence. (adding some heavy hinges for the spinal erectors is preferred)
Why would anyone look at the calisthenic community or gymnasts for info on how to train in a gym? Both those camps clock long hours doing exclusively variations that tax the upper back.... not the same as programming a few sets of pullups twice per week. If you want to go do gymnastics for 10 hours per week, great. You'll get jacked. Doesn't inform anything about general gym training. And calisthenic guys don't have the 'best backs'. They are aesthetic, absolutely, but if you have a 180lb guy who carries all of his mass in his back, yeah he's going to have a nasty v-taper. We're talking about absolute size and strength. You look to pro bodybuilders and elite strength athletes for that, and few of them use pullups.
I think a couple of S-tier movements are missing from the list. Snatch pulls will hit your upper back in a unique way. Upright pulls - like clean pulls but start from thighs and pull to chest height - are a great variation on upright rows. Much more explosive movement and you'll murder the traps slowing the bar down on the eccentric. Also, I've found both to help with building a bigger deadlift.
I think it's good as is, i've seen people doing tier lists on exercises they never done before and i think that's dumb at least i know a lot of the movements from this list he did and he didn't try to put in many movements he doesnt have may not have enough experience to talk about
@@bce6936 Fair enough, if he's not familiar with them he shouldn't endorse them. In that case it's a good idea to try them out for a while (and make a video about their awesomeness).
@@GIboy1990Don’t know if this is the case for you but common problems are starting too heavy and going too fast off the floor/not being smooth. You want the bar to move fast so only go as heavy as you can to maintain a good bar speed. It’s also important to gradually increase the rate of acceleration, then sort of full send around knee height. Another important thing is to not think of it as a deadlift. In fact, it’s closer to a squat as you start low and engage the legs. Start low and shoulders in line with your toes. With that said, lower back certainly gets a workout, but pain is obviously not good.
If you are very light, pullups / chin ups are probably one of the best. It was the only way for me to make my upper back bigger and thicker. I can see them being difficult for heavier people, but if you have a small frame they are easy to do. And then, you can add weight through a belt anyway for even more gains.
If doing a body part split I definitely like giving upper back it's own day. A regular core four split I like pairing rows with bench and vertical pulls with over head presses.
Same. Thickness day (bench+row) Width day (shoulders + lats) Arm day Leg/hip day Just have to make sure that you minimize anterior delt usage as much as possible during the thickness day. If you can’t it’s fine, anterior delts is secondary anyway since it gets trained a lot.
@@apeinto5637 I had crazy shoulder pains. So bad I thought I'd need surgery on both. Then Brian arslue said to get my rows up. And over a year I could finally row more than I can bench and I now have zero shoulder pain. It really saved me.
Most of this agreed but teh bodyweight being C tier don't think is right.... weighted chins / pulls in various grips are pretty much the S tier. Weighted inverted rows can be done with vest (including front bolt plates) or with a weight belt set around hip level. Front lever pulls or even band assisted versions of it, stradle levers, ice cream makers.....probably does for width what the strong man stuff does for erectors...adding that "unique" development of all those fibers underneath teh primer movers etc.
On pull-ups might want to check out dudes who progress to doing them with plates hanging off a dip belt or do super wide pull-ups with weight. Progressing into being able to do any pull-ups can be a challenge but not an impossible task. Pull-ups are more challenging the more a person weighs of course. On inverted rows you can load them with a vest. I have a plate loadable vest I'll use for weight rows or weighted pushups no spotter needed. Setup for inverted rows can be done fairly easily off a pull-up bar with rings and maybe some kind of box to elevate the feet a bit. Progressing into it as a beginner here is much easier as you can just be more up right until it's doable. I like using free weights too. I did weighted pulls ups and single arm rows last upper day. I do think you are missing some aspects of calisthenics movements. Particularly when it comes to the idea of lat growth and pullups.
All you said is "you CAN do it this way". My point is its a pain in the ass and there aren't benefits compared to other rows or pulldowns. Most really good lifters and IFBB pros aren't glued to pull-ups. Its a fixation of calisthenic nerds.
@@AlexanderBromley Pull ups are fine unless you're fat. If you are fat, they are also good, if you can do them, but they are an advanced movement. In the U.S, where it sounds like you are from (correct me if I am wrong), most people are obese, but where I live, that's not the case, so I don't agree with your assertion that the skill floor is high. I was doing pull ups during my first year of training, and chin ups during my first few months.
Great video Alexander. I love free barbell weights because they work and you get stronger. When I do cables and some machines I have noticed that i get weaker in free weight. The best in my opinion is 3:1 free weight cables ratio
@@GIboy1990 Easier to fuck up barbell rows though. I agree on rows being above pullups, as they hit more of the back, but it is much harder to do, and progress(It it so easy to add slightly more body english each workout, and think your becoming stronger), than pullups.
Yes, yes, I am a week late, but I feel like I need to put in a good word for pull ups. I am a tall guy and at my gym I can't use pull down machines, because I get absolutely no stretch - however the pull down movement is the one I feel the most. That makes pull ups an excellent option for me and others like me in particular. There is also a certain kind of prestige that comes with doing pull ups, which just feels great to boast with in front of anyone who can't do pull ups :^)
I’ve been doing these heavy with a snatch grip and it hits everything on my backside. Spinal erectors, hamstrings, lats, mid/lower trap, upper back etc
@@zerrodefex true. I have done those too. Definitely felt different compared to the banded db pullover. The hypertrophy coach shows a bench version that I haven’t tried. But it wasn’t that hard to set up after the first time. Even easier if you have a training partner to hold the band vs rigging it up.
I have used these prior to finding out about John's book. Very solid exercise and indeed a total pain in the ass to setup. But once I had it going I powered out 8-10 sets because of how it felt.
Great list with good explanations. For the seal row, the erectors work because when you pull, you will realize that your spine squize at the top of the movement. It's not huge but that one of the few exercices that make them work in a concentric way. But no way pull ups are C tier. They are S tier without any doubt. When you can add weigth, believe that it will grow your back like nothing. You put your lats and teres major in such a weak position that if you can lift let's say 30 more kilos than your body, it will mean that you are really a strong dude. There is no better exercice for the lower trapezius and the middle trap works quite a lot too. Also, the erectors work. You have studies showing the difference between lat pull down and pull ups and it's insane. The hardest exercice to master but when you do, it's worth diamond.
I think inverted rows are more stable than barbell or dumbbell rows, despite their other limitations. They have fewer degrees of freedom, as your hands can only move in a specific path relative to the torso, like a smith machine
Inverted rows are amazing, great for lats or upper back depending on your hand placement. It saves your lower back too, the only downside is loading them once you can do 20+ reps
For anyone who wants to add strongman loading but lacks access to atlas stones and sandbags: Fill a cheap yoga ball like 80% with water. It's a pain to fill up but once you're done it's one of the most brutal odd objects you can lift! Slap some flex tape over the hole to keep it sealed and you're good to go. Shockingly durable in my experience so far
Water weighs 8lbs per gallon. How many gallons could you possibly fit in there'? Because I'd need 150lbs bare minimum to get anything out of it even with the awkwardness of it, which is why I lowered the minimum to 150lbs out if good faith
Tried strapping in for 1 drop set of frame carry 2 weeks ago. Made it 150ft and was sore for 4 days. Today I repeated the workout and made it 200ft. Highly recommend giving it a whirl, it's terrible
honestly, Sumo Deadlifts can work wonders for your knee health if you already overcooked the RDLs for a week and you need to do something whacky for your knees, but other from that, they're pretty nieche, can still be nice though! (I haven't done them in 2 years)
I don't wanna fight @Alexander Bromley IRL, he'd pick up my heavy, awkward butt up and slam dunk me for stone loading practice. But since we're in the comments... UA-cam friends, enemies, trolls, or sociopaths, if you're a big-un, this is for you. Find an assisted pullup machine, use the weights to offset your perma-bulk, slightly arch and pull your chest up for multiple sets of somewhere about 8-10 or even 10-12. Close, medium, wide grip, they ain't pulldowns, they really do hit different. Seriously, for us heavier dudes, assisted pullups are always working with high poundages. You have a disadvantaged movement, adjustable angles and width of pull, high total load, stabilization reduces unnecessary fatigue, progression, and you can cheat them a little for eccentric focus. So, duh, they will make you grow. Program them in your high pull slot or one of your heavy lat work slots and work them like a job. Sure, it may not be your particular go-to, and you may have decided to Kroc row your way to super powers, but don't sleep on them. At least A-tier for us hefties, unless you are already pulling down your bodyweight for your age in reps.
Some of the weighted pullup fans need to be strict barbell or T-bar rowing, and some of y'all barbell fans need to see the science and the gains for weighted wide pullups. My sorry butt needs to program in some odd object lifts and some loading next year.
Trapless Goldberg is heresy of the highest order 😂😂😂
Who wins in a fight?
Trapless Goldberg vs High Altitude Cain?
Weighted pull ups - S tier
@@kaprelim8135 not a good exercise stretch position shoulder not good and u have to start with your bodyweight pulldowns better more control your brainwashed like so many thinking u have to do this and that exercises it's all a lie it was said to sell u something
They tend to fry the small muscles in my back, with little lats and traps. They aren't great for everyone, could be my crazy stupid barrel build body, but I don't get wide from them, at all. I get much more lat and rear delts from weights, and teres don't get fried like chernobyl
It's impossible to work the small muscles in your back without working the major ones physically impossible
@trapps75 I mean rhomboids and teres are the main movers in pull ups. They work together, I don't get a great total back workout doing pull ups alone. Maybe you do? Good for you. Barbell rows, seated rows, seal rows all clear pull ups in terms of back growth.
@trapps75 and pull ups are almost inherently all teres/rhomboids from a full hang, not lats. Your losing lats towards the hang almost completely. The pull up is not ideal for back growth. Argue minor details all you want, nostalgic memories blah blah blah, we are talking about total back growth. Pull ups are not good for upper traps, lats (contrary to beliefs, the other exercises listed are BETTER for lats, I guess that's wrong too?) or progressive overloading. Nobody wants to buy a belt chain AND have a gym membership. It's just added tedious nuance lifting, that falls short of BB Rows and stiff leg deadlifting.
pull ups c tier? come on...
💪💪 Amen
Inverted rows in D tier is crazy as well.
I would understand if it was just an upper back tier list, but since he’s including the lats I don’t understand that decision at all lol
He’s a strongman, and a lot of strongmen are 300-350+ pounds. I think that pull-ups are A tier or higher, but for those who are much much higher in body weight, they aren’t necessarily the easiest
@@str1ker_eureka One of the reasons he gave is that it's hard to scale for people that can't do pull-ups or aren't able to rep them. But beginners can simply do jackknife/feet-assisted pull-ups and progress those until they can do regular pull-ups.
I back. Trust me I back
-Your back
Not a lot of UFC fans here but I got your back!
Hespect!
A man of taste and refinement with the Spider reference.
~Laterson Silva
20:35 that's the kind of very clear advice I appreciate sometimes! "If you're not at 80s for 10, you're not there yet".
Pull ups. Top top top. Numebr 1. If you cant do them cause you're "too heavy" . Stop the excuses start working on them.
Im guessing your small but thinks hes big 😂 pull up will NOT give you a monster back
@irnbru22 I don't guess buddy.
At the end of the day we should implement all the back exercises. Pull ups are on the top of the food chain in my opinion. Many can't do them and I understand
@@irnbru22weighted pull ups will
@irnbru22 You're just telling me that you've never done weighted pullups before.
I like how someone realized that the letters on the tier list should change from light to dark to contrast with the background colours, but then seemingly forgot about it after the first one.
Bro really triggered me with the pull-up rating😂
You are probably
@@itooflemma 81kg, but I do them with 24kg added, so that's 105kg.
@@itooflemma not being able to pull or push your own body weight makes you a relatively weak 200 pounder
@@Ruthlessaggression93 bet @itooflemma is stronger than you . . . and neither of you are as strong as an ant - relatively speaking
I'm still recovering from it (the triggering, not the pullup).
After watching a ton of your videos I must say you are a hell of a writer and commenter. I really appreciate your perspective in the middle of all the noise.
I was just scrolling through my YT feed today thinking "I wish Bromley would put out a new video!"
these drawings are awesome
Ah an intelligent tier list with categories and no bullshit f-tiers. Thank you!
'Pull ups too hard, so I dont see the benefit' - loool
This is the best back lecture I’ve ever listened to. Gives a clear path forward for priorities and secondary/tertiary in programming. Bravo!
You all need to listen to this man, if you think he is wrong, you are thinking too much.
When I started making my upper back a priority all of my lifts started going a lot smoother.
If you are lacking an upper back weights can take you out of position too easily, and you won't know that's what's happening until you start bringing it up.
i completely agree, i neglected my upper back and my bench was hurt by it. once i started training it hard my bench skyrocketed 50lbs in 2 months to 265
When i saw pull-ups in C tier i knew there would be a lot of ruffled feathers 😂
Anyways, great video, fantastic artwork.
There wasn't really a good reason given for that.
"Harder to start with for some people" is fair, but there are ways around that like negatives.
It is definitely S-tier, or at least A-tier. Easy exercise to perform, and easy to overload with a belt. (and has the variations like wide/narrow grip, or chinup for bicep focus)
just discovered this video as i'm recovering from rotator cuff surgery; hence all lower case type. in my early 20's i started entering bodybuilding contests. i have average genetics at best. and it took 7 years of weight training to even think about competing. barbell rows, weighted chins and cable rows were my staple lat exercises, also ez curl bent-arm pullovers finished the deal. i got great lats/serratus just from these four exercises; winning best back in one show. no dbl rows or lat bar pulldowns. just didn't do 'em. also want to say how much i appreciate the illustrations in all of these exercises. not sure who is the artist, but great work, and i don't usually say that...i was the main illustrator for MUSCULAR DEVELOPMENT MAGAZINE from 1994-2007 and am extremely critical.
Old-school greats like Leroy Colbert swore that wide grip pull-ups were the key to growing wing-like lats, especially the lower portion of lats. People dismissed this as pseudo-science, however.
Well, I realized the other day that Wide Grip Pull-Ups, (done where your chin just clears the bar) are essentially long length partials (not extreme stretch, but that's been shown to have minimal difference.) Lengthened partials have been recently shown to emphasize growth in the distal portion of the muscle-in this case the lower lats.
The Bro Science/old school wisdom was just waiting or the science to catch up once again...
I don’t think u understand what science means. It doesn’t come up with shit. It refines it. Ur going to find the most bullshit from old school. The shit that works in old school will continue on. Science doesn’t invent new ideas. It takes old ideas and simply puts them through the test saying whether it’s legit or not. There’s a reason someone like Alex doesn’t like sports science hypertrophy. Bcz to prove something works means it requires extremely rigorous testing which is hard. That’s why it’s so good at shifting the dogshit old school has given us already
So if u wanna point fingers. Why not show the amount of dogshit old school has taught as well? Bcz a lot of people say a lot of different things then. Science tests them all and simply allows the correct one to follow through
the visuals getting way better recently, bromley putting the work in
Love the art
Incorporating wide grip pullups has added to my wideness more than anything else.
BeCaUsE tHeY'rE wIdE
@@cheeks7050😂
that's actually weird and shouldn't happen
@@etilpoh😅😅
@@cheeks7050 Ahahahahahaa
Pull ups and chins ups is all you need to build a God like back ! This video is basically giving you the alternatives for people who cant do pulls up/chins ups. If you look at calisthenic athletes and streetlifters you can see clear evidence of the after effects of pulls ups. Therefore, it is an S tier excercise which is basically the father of all back excercises.
Lol god like back.... calisthenic athletes spend hours a day training. Like saying "do gymnastics to look like a gymnast!".... neat, 15 hours a week to have a meager amount of muscle
U r just weak at pull ups @@AlexanderBromley
As a former Marine and being our upper body test on the PFT , Pull-ups are staple of back day for me. I just think it's bad ass to knock out a lot of pull ups and even more badass to knockout muscle ups. And dudes in prison have built great physiques from pull ups being their main back exercise. Anyone who knocks down pull-ups as an exercise, just suck at doing pull-ups
Farmer walks it is. “Easy to recover from and they’re fun as shit”
I love that a big back can either mean being extremely unhealthy or extremely jacked. After this video I plan on going from one to the other.
No stay jacked
Why not both
Unhealthy either way tbh
Do you actually “love it” tho???
@@hugodogobobhow
Watching your channel just constantly reaffirms that I need to sign up at strongman gym
Or atleast get some shit for the home. A pair of farmer handles and a sandbag cost you 200 bucks tops.
I really missed the Zercher Deadlifts in the Deadlifts category. Doing heavy high rep work with them has blown my back up like nothing else.
I'll keep building up my pullups. Currently at 4x7 supersets with medium weight squats.
Weighted pull ups and bend over barbell rows
The reason pull up should be S 38:18 or at least less than a it's because you had to do full range of motion if you do pull-ups with your arms always standing and pulled apart to your neck or upper chest is a whole different ball game than people not getting their chin up to the bar or gooseneck i n g when you can bring your pull-ups all the way up to your upper chest or lower part of your neck you get a contraction on your all your back muscles
So just for the record, I agree with your stance on pull-ups. For me personally, weighted pull-ups/neutral grip pull-ups have always done more for me than anything else. But technically speaking, your reasoning is correct for why your placed them where your did
While i appreciate the shout out, i have to say, "pull ups are C-tier is Wild." Calesthenics guys get wide af!
Also in regards to dumbell pullovers, if your use lying on the bench variation as in your illustration, the strength curve sucks. Do cross bench or hanging of the bench like someone who knows the movement and it radically improves.
Weighted Pull Ups are S++ tier
Just wanna say Front squats exploded my barbell row and back strength in general
Really? I just started doing them out of necessity d/t a bulging disc. Going really light until I get the form down and my back starts to feel better. Still can't figure out the best way to hold the bar. My wrists don't bend very well so I've been crossing my arms and the bar is pressing against my neck a bit. Not sure if that's normal or not?
@@Mrbobcat7 At first it may feel uncomfy, and may leave you out of breath. As when you first start back squatting and the bar feels awkward. Soon it will feel better (though the bar should be resting somewhere around your clavicle)
@@Mrbobcat7do overhand not under just hold the bar at your shoulders. Takes the focus off the wrists and im the same as you but my disc fully burst like a doughnut now i never back squat and my max atm is 100 that like 250kg on the back heavy asf and my backs 98% back after 18months. And quads are explosive also.
C Tier for Pullups is total ridiculous. It just puts into question everything else you say and there was absolutely no need for that. You are my favorite channel to listen to when it comes to strength training. I bought and read your book "Base Phase". This is unfortunate Mr Bromley as that is a time tested "late intermediate", lift you need to first work to "unlock", before you can program it of course. But the results they produce speak for themselves. Come one, just look at the Calisthenic community as they seem to produce the best backs in existence. (adding some heavy hinges for the spinal erectors is preferred)
Why would anyone look at the calisthenic community or gymnasts for info on how to train in a gym? Both those camps clock long hours doing exclusively variations that tax the upper back.... not the same as programming a few sets of pullups twice per week. If you want to go do gymnastics for 10 hours per week, great. You'll get jacked. Doesn't inform anything about general gym training.
And calisthenic guys don't have the 'best backs'. They are aesthetic, absolutely, but if you have a 180lb guy who carries all of his mass in his back, yeah he's going to have a nasty v-taper. We're talking about absolute size and strength. You look to pro bodybuilders and elite strength athletes for that, and few of them use pullups.
Block,rack pulls are S+ tier
I think a couple of S-tier movements are missing from the list. Snatch pulls will hit your upper back in a unique way. Upright pulls - like clean pulls but start from thighs and pull to chest height - are a great variation on upright rows. Much more explosive movement and you'll murder the traps slowing the bar down on the eccentric. Also, I've found both to help with building a bigger deadlift.
I think it's good as is, i've seen people doing tier lists on exercises they never done before and i think that's dumb at least i know a lot of the movements from this list he did and he didn't try to put in many movements he doesnt have may not have enough experience to talk about
@@bce6936 Fair enough, if he's not familiar with them he shouldn't endorse them. In that case it's a good idea to try them out for a while (and make a video about their awesomeness).
Snatch pulls are pretty awesome. Though I've always got LBP from it
@@GIboy1990Don’t know if this is the case for you but common problems are starting too heavy and going too fast off the floor/not being smooth. You want the bar to move fast so only go as heavy as you can to maintain a good bar speed. It’s also important to gradually increase the rate of acceleration, then sort of full send around knee height.
Another important thing is to not think of it as a deadlift. In fact, it’s closer to a squat as you start low and engage the legs. Start low and shoulders in line with your toes.
With that said, lower back certainly gets a workout, but pain is obviously not good.
Been waiting two years for this one. The secret ending to your tier-list run
If you are very light, pullups / chin ups are probably one of the best. It was the only way for me to make my upper back bigger and thicker. I can see them being difficult for heavier people, but if you have a small frame they are easy to do. And then, you can add weight through a belt anyway for even more gains.
My team mate Sean Brady dominated burn last night, and his back looks like a ninja turtle.
Team Gracie 😊 ... and yeah his back is wild
If doing a body part split I definitely like giving upper back it's own day. A regular core four split I like pairing rows with bench and vertical pulls with over head presses.
Same.
Thickness day (bench+row)
Width day (shoulders + lats)
Arm day
Leg/hip day
Just have to make sure that you minimize anterior delt usage as much as possible during the thickness day. If you can’t it’s fine, anterior delts is secondary anyway since it gets trained a lot.
@@apeinto5637 I had crazy shoulder pains. So bad I thought I'd need surgery on both. Then Brian arslue said to get my rows up. And over a year I could finally row more than I can bench and I now have zero shoulder pain. It really saved me.
This video is S tier. Awesome job.
Most of this agreed but teh bodyweight being C tier don't think is right....
weighted chins / pulls in various grips are pretty much the S tier. Weighted inverted rows can be done with vest (including front bolt plates) or with a weight belt set around hip level. Front lever pulls or even band assisted versions of it, stradle levers, ice cream makers.....probably does for width what the strong man stuff does for erectors...adding that "unique" development of all those fibers underneath teh primer movers etc.
Yoooooooo, the animation is super cool. Please keep that in your videos
Back day is tomorrow, your timing is impeccable sir 💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽
New Goals, Seeing my back from the front! 💪
On pull-ups might want to check out dudes who progress to doing them with plates hanging off a dip belt or do super wide pull-ups with weight. Progressing into being able to do any pull-ups can be a challenge but not an impossible task. Pull-ups are more challenging the more a person weighs of course.
On inverted rows you can load them with a vest. I have a plate loadable vest I'll use for weight rows or weighted pushups no spotter needed. Setup for inverted rows can be done fairly easily off a pull-up bar with rings and maybe some kind of box to elevate the feet a bit. Progressing into it as a beginner here is much easier as you can just be more up right until it's doable.
I like using free weights too. I did weighted pulls ups and single arm rows last upper day. I do think you are missing some aspects of calisthenics movements. Particularly when it comes to the idea of lat growth and pullups.
All you said is "you CAN do it this way". My point is its a pain in the ass and there aren't benefits compared to other rows or pulldowns. Most really good lifters and IFBB pros aren't glued to pull-ups. Its a fixation of calisthenic nerds.
@@AlexanderBromley IFBB pros aren't glued to pullups because they're too overweight to do them.
@@AlexanderBromley Pull ups are fine unless you're fat. If you are fat, they are also good, if you can do them, but they are an advanced movement.
In the U.S, where it sounds like you are from (correct me if I am wrong), most people are obese, but where I live, that's not the case, so I don't agree with your assertion that the skill floor is high.
I was doing pull ups during my first year of training, and chin ups during my first few months.
Nice Haviland thumbnail
It's back
I see what you did there.
Never hit subscribe so fast
fatigue management is the top priority for me so i stick to the later exercises
It's back!
Get it 😏
Alex, great content and thought out explanation as usual. Cheers for the download.
You always put out the best info brotha 👍🏼
I agree
Dumbbell pullovers are definitely hit the tri-cep long head than the back. Also, pro-tip, instead of using a dumbbell, use an upside down kettle-bell
Kettlebells are highly underrated. I tried using them and now they are my favorite tool by far. So versatile.
Already love this
Great video Alexander. I love free barbell weights because they work and you get stronger. When I do cables and some machines I have noticed that i get weaker in free weight. The best in my opinion is 3:1 free weight cables ratio
3:06 Goldberg without this traps can’t hurt you.
Ya, of course he can’t
BIG BACK BIG BACK song is playing rent free right now
More of these please! Particularly, one about shoulders would be much appreciated!
Nice drawings and graphics accompaying the explanation, it's a cool touch
Man, yahll are hurt by the c tier pullups. 😂
Pull-ups are good. But they're too temperamental and easy to fuck up honestly.
Bro there's nothing to do except go up, they're some of the easiest exercises to do, no wondwr people are confused@@GIboy1990
@@GIboy1990 Easier to fuck up barbell rows though. I agree on rows being above pullups, as they hit more of the back, but it is much harder to do, and progress(It it so easy to add slightly more body english each workout, and think your becoming stronger), than pullups.
Pull-ups are great..... if performed correctly and with discipline! Which 98% of the average bro has neither.
@@Tyler-gc9zq the average gym bro doesn't squat correctly either buts that's no fault of the movement
Thease videos keep getting better and better, are you doing OSG in december, you are not on the website list i thought you were ?
Yes, yes, I am a week late, but I feel like I need to put in a good word for pull ups.
I am a tall guy and at my gym I can't use pull down machines, because I get absolutely no stretch - however the pull down movement is the one I feel the most. That makes pull ups an excellent option for me and others like me in particular.
There is also a certain kind of prestige that comes with doing pull ups, which just feels great to boast with in front of anyone who can't do pull ups :^)
Almost a sin not to put the Jefferson Curl on here, and as an S too.
Funny thing is he showed a clip of AtlasPowerShrugged doing the Jefferson Curl but I never heard the name mentioned.
I’ve been doing these heavy with a snatch grip and it hits everything on my backside. Spinal erectors, hamstrings, lats, mid/lower trap, upper back etc
I only do Deadlift, Pull up and chest support row for back exercises.
In John Meadows Unity program he had banded dumbbell pullovers. While a bit of a pain to set up. I felt it in the lats throughout the whole movement.
I feel that with all the setup just do a cable pullover. May be a bit less optimal but easier and quicker to set up.
@@zerrodefex true. I have done those too. Definitely felt different compared to the banded db pullover. The hypertrophy coach shows a bench version that I haven’t tried.
But it wasn’t that hard to set up after the first time. Even easier if you have a training partner to hold the band vs rigging it up.
I have used these prior to finding out about John's book. Very solid exercise and indeed a total pain in the ass to setup. But once I had it going I powered out 8-10 sets because of how it felt.
I love doing bendover rows on the Smith. AS the bar can't move towards you, you can contract your Lats against the bar through the whole Motion.
Love the visuals on this video!
These drawings look so cool
Here again
Straight arm Pulldowns/Pullovers laying on the floor and using a floor height Pulley eliminates the stability issues.
Great list with good explanations.
For the seal row, the erectors work because when you pull, you will realize that your spine squize at the top of the movement. It's not huge but that one of the few exercices that make them work in a concentric way.
But no way pull ups are C tier. They are S tier without any doubt. When you can add weigth, believe that it will grow your back like nothing. You put your lats and teres major in such a weak position that if you can lift let's say 30 more kilos than your body, it will mean that you are really a strong dude. There is no better exercice for the lower trapezius and the middle trap works quite a lot too. Also, the erectors work. You have studies showing the difference between lat pull down and pull ups and it's insane. The hardest exercice to master but when you do, it's worth diamond.
I think inverted rows are more stable than barbell or dumbbell rows, despite their other limitations. They have fewer degrees of freedom, as your hands can only move in a specific path relative to the torso, like a smith machine
Inverted rows are amazing, great for lats or upper back depending on your hand placement. It saves your lower back too, the only downside is loading them once you can do 20+ reps
@@corenkothats what we have chains, weight west and other fun equipment for😊
YES A NEW TIER LIST
For anyone who wants to add strongman loading but lacks access to atlas stones and sandbags: Fill a cheap yoga ball like 80% with water. It's a pain to fill up but once you're done it's one of the most brutal odd objects you can lift! Slap some flex tape over the hole to keep it sealed and you're good to go. Shockingly durable in my experience so far
Water weighs 8lbs per gallon. How many gallons could you possibly fit in there'? Because I'd need 150lbs bare minimum to get anything out of it even with the awkwardness of it, which is why I lowered the minimum to 150lbs out if good faith
Bromley, if you are doing these drawings, we've come a long way from the white board of old. Bravo sir! Also, love the content!
wish i could take credit lol.
Pull ups should be the bread and butter of any back program.. No matter what
30:40 You can load an inverted row like you load squats or dips. Put on a weight vest and add weight.
As always, great quality
We need Rick Tobagen Bugenhagen on this one
Tried strapping in for 1 drop set of frame carry 2 weeks ago. Made it 150ft and was sore for 4 days.
Today I repeated the workout and made it 200ft. Highly recommend giving it a whirl, it's terrible
Face pulls D tier. AthleanX in shambles.
Pull up variations, row variations, deadlift variations, good mornings, and just stop the paralysis by analysis from there
Cool animations man!
honestly, Sumo Deadlifts can work wonders for your knee health if you already overcooked the RDLs for a week and you need to do something whacky for your knees, but other from that, they're pretty nieche, can still be nice though! (I haven't done them in 2 years)
Now do the front chest and abs
I don't wanna fight @Alexander Bromley IRL, he'd pick up my heavy, awkward butt up and slam dunk me for stone loading practice. But since we're in the comments...
UA-cam friends, enemies, trolls, or sociopaths, if you're a big-un, this is for you. Find an assisted pullup machine, use the weights to offset your perma-bulk, slightly arch and pull your chest up for multiple sets of somewhere about 8-10 or even 10-12. Close, medium, wide grip, they ain't pulldowns, they really do hit different. Seriously, for us heavier dudes, assisted pullups are always working with high poundages. You have a disadvantaged movement, adjustable angles and width of pull, high total load, stabilization reduces unnecessary fatigue, progression, and you can cheat them a little for eccentric focus. So, duh, they will make you grow.
Program them in your high pull slot or one of your heavy lat work slots and work them like a job. Sure, it may not be your particular go-to, and you may have decided to Kroc row your way to super powers, but don't sleep on them. At least A-tier for us hefties, unless you are already pulling down your bodyweight for your age in reps.
30:45 they are possible to load, either use a vest or different body positions. Otherwise there wouldn't be people that could do front lever rows
Hey loved the artstyle, also great video as always.
that pic of goldberg without traps is funny
great inputs thank you
You better watch out ranking my pullup so low! Weighted pullups are best, like pulldown is not even comparable,
Much better without the music!
Wow brilliant! You forgot Meadows rows...
If we do lengthened partials, a lot of these lower rated exercises become much better
Some of the weighted pullup fans need to be strict barbell or T-bar rowing, and some of y'all barbell fans need to see the science and the gains for weighted wide pullups. My sorry butt needs to program in some odd object lifts and some loading next year.
Legendary !!!
I got big dreams and bad genes
Interesting new visual style :)