Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Explaining Ghazali | A Response to Qaiser Ahmed Raja | Part 1 | Uzma Rumi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 чер 2024
- Last month, I made a video about Imam Ghazali. In that video, we discussed Ghazali's scientific concepts. In response to that video, Mr. Qaiser Ahmed Raja made a video in which he raised many objections to the content of my video. This video is a response to those objections.
Download link of Miskatul Anwaar:
archive.org/de...
If you like our content, please do like, share and subscribe to our channel.
Mr. Qaiser Raja (Front_Man of Molvis) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! !
Bhai aap rehne do.. 😂😂
This appreciation from my religious guide. Awesome feel !!
Ali Bhai , Qaiser Raja is a clown and a joker whose duty is to save his FIRQA and nothing else. So , Please Keep exposing Qaiser Raja and Tariq Masood and please DON'T stop because they will also NOT stop . Their agenda is that of Hitler's Goebbels and that is lie loudly and lie as many times and as many places as possible to convert lie into truth.
Oyyy mirza kuch to khuda ka khuf karo nafrat main iman se hath do betoge ek din ap ko to main sunta bhi nahi aj kal😢 qaiser raja zindabad❤❤
Awesome Uzma ❤ u have done owned him once again, demolished him, period !
Al-Ghazali basically tried to criticize the philosophers of his time, especially those influenced by Greek philosophy, such as Avicenna (Ibn Sina) and Al-Farabi. He argued that their views contradicted Islamic teachings and undermined religious faith.But it is important to recognize that the decline in scientific research was due to a combination of factors, including political instability, economic challenges, and changing cultural priorities.Scientific activity did not cease immediately after Al-Ghazali. Scholars like Ibn Rushd (Averroes) continued to engage in philosophical and scientific pursuits. So, Al-Ghazali's views on occasionalism and his critique of philosophy did shift the intellectual focus towards theology and mysticism, it is overly simplistic to say that they alone caused the decline of scientific inquiry in the Islamic world.
P.S. You saying 'In Shaa Allah' at the end of the video is actually promoting Ghazali's occasionalism. Because if you are so sure about yourself and firm on your view of causality, why then depend upon Allah’s intervention???
👏👏👏👌👌👌💯💯💯
@@ssabbassi888 Yeh jahil lady khud keh rahi hay k Mazhab k baray mai isko kuch khas pata nahi hay phir bhi Hujjat ul Islam Imam Ghazali k baary may Apni Jahilana Approach say baat kar rahi hay .
In jahilon ko lagta hay koi Task diya gaya hay jiski funding kahin or say ho rahi hay k Islam k baray mai Shak paidah karo ..
I love this debate coming from both sides. But please, both sides need to be respectful and not hate others.
Great Comment
impossible bcz of conjervatives hate towards rationalists. Cancer Raja ko uski zaban main samjha chaiye jo wo samjhta hai
Qaiser can't remain respectful he is fitratan badtameez
Qaisar jahil should mind only Mullah affairs and propaganda videos. 😂😂😂
Knowledge ❌ hate speech ✅
Voluntary ignorance spotted
@@Photon-1927thank you for your response about video
No, it's actually a Bollywood movie where you stand in front of a bullet, fired on someone else, in a dramatic manner and then cry, victim. He made that video in that language for Engineer sahab not for her, the video made for her was different and she didn't respond to it, funny part is she showed that video's thumbnail in her thumbnail, that means she was aware of that video.
Lums ki pajeet
@@Axhar1 seems you are fan of raja (former taxi driver). Good for you
Behen maine aapki video suni aur durst lagi thi lekin Qaiser sahab ka response dekh kar laga aap ko Ghazali samjhne mein ghalti hogayi. Mazrat bura mat maniyega. ALLAH SWT SAB KO DURST CHEEZ SAMJHNE KI TOUFEEQ DEIN AMEEN ❤
اس لو انجنئر پمپ کر رہا ہے وہ خود روز ذلیل ہوتا ہے راجہ صاحب سے اب اس کو ذلیل کروا رہا ہے
Ap on ka jwab tu sunein wo jhoot bol raha ha
@@Thinkoutsidethebox1840 Kon juth bol rha ha
Beautifully rebutted
Qasir Raja proved himself to be an Andbakt, without rationale and logic
@@Eesa029 she didn't answer any points. She just raised new ones. this isn't even a rebuttal but I guess believe whatever suits your worldview
lol dumb guy, state what has she rebuted?
Qaiser Ahmad Raja has invited to debate. why do you not come in front to front?
You cooked Mr Dutch intellect.😂. ❤
😂😅😅😅
So creative bro ❤❤❤
Ruko zara sabar karo
Bro. This is the first time I've ever heard this as a criticism of Al Ghazali. I don't know why this translation is the way it is but plz read the English translation. Al Ghazali doesn't say that the most merciful (Ar-rahman ) and the king (maalik) are eparate entities from God. What he actually says is they are attributes of God that are distinct from each other. His knowledge is not his hearing, his hearing is not his sight/seeing, his kingship is not his mercy, his mercy is not his wrath etc. I don't know why she presented it as if he's saying they're all different entities implying different Gods...
Go and see how Mr Dutch recooked within few days the video which took mis Uzma one month to prepare. She should bang her head elsewhere.
Religion is not a personal thing. Its linked with God and whole society's stability.
F off.
It is personal matter.
Keep your Islamist Views in your pocket.
Islamism is not Islam.
Maza aya.... Quality debunking lecture
First few minutes of this video really shocking. How can ghazali call "LA ILAHA IL'LAL'LAAH" as kalma of common people and bring his new kalma instead? How dare he change it?
I wonder how easy it is to manipulate people like you.why don't you yourself go and research on this .?.
No one can change it. Neither did he.
@@MS-HussainBhai video main refrence h ap khud parh lo ya research kr lo imam ghazali ne khud likha h
@@MS-HussainVideo ghor se dekho jaha refrence h note down karo or phr khud tasdeeq karo easy h
He is Talking about Tauheed .. not changing the Kalimah .. Read Surah Hashr .. last ayah .. HuAllah ulLazi .. Its very common most of the Imam recite in Namaz ..
Hello Miss.... I have written this for you after spending substantial amount of time kindly have a read....
Let me break it down for you miss, irrespective of what Qaiser Ahmed Raja said, the contention of Imam Ghazali for which he(ghazali) gave the example of cotton and fire was as follows, to understand that lets go beyond the cotton and fire's knowledge available at his time, the chemical reactions occur in nature due to certain fundamental tendencies of the atoms and energy, like when cotton touch the fire the that initiate a process of equalibrium in atom where it tent to have electrons in proportion that stables it, and when the atoms get stable at the given system, the reaction stops and the cotton become ashe, ghazali contended that these tendencies of atom are not necessities and can be in any other way but they are not, because God allowed them in that manner. He said "they call it a necessity because they have no proof beyond observation."
The problem is when he says "it's not because of fire but by will of God" you reckon he denied the relationship between cotton and fire, but in reality he defined the relation, that it happens not because of necessity, It can happen in any other way but God allowed to be as it happens before our eyes.
Now coming back to what Qaiser ahmed Raja said "ghazali ne essa kabhi nhi kaha ki rui nhi jalegi" he was referring to views of ghazali on general conduct of fire on cotton, and that doesn't negate his initial position that fire won't "necessarily" burn cotton if come in contact.
Miss you showed the video in the thumbnail is different then you reacted. In fact the video you showed in thumbnail clarify problem you presented. The video uploaded by QAR on the response to your video was "Defending Ghazali | A Response to @uzmarumi256" on 27 April 2024, he never called you "Desi secular" or "don't get into contingency argument", you reacted different video, he was very respectful to you....
Hopefully you came this far.....
Now the video he created in you response, he said in that video at 3:25 "Ghazali is not deny causality rather provided a framework for it, for its true nature.....neither fire decides that it will burn not cotton decided that it will get brunt, then these are contingent things and there is something other nessecery existence that give base to this causation."
Thank you
Great effort ❤
Bht khoob sir may khud yehi dekh raha hon Kay log kitnay jahil Hain Jo in madam ki baton ko sun kar sensible samajh rahay hain , ye bechari to sedhi saadhi kitab ko nahi samajh sakteen jab tak koi inhay na samjhai , ye philosophical or mistical sence ko Kahan samjhain geen
Inho nay ghazali ki kitab ki bas translation parh li sidhi sidhi Jo line samajh aai out of context chaap di ,😂 aur sir ko samjha raheen Hain , galti maan nahi raheen
😎☝🏼best
Qaiser belongs to same mentality who doesn't know what are they doing. Good work Rumi.
Aah librandu😂
I think both sides know what they are doing
@@theenigma4234 ua-cam.com/video/tOjT52JIPzw/v-deo.htmlsi=sH1AWDTv4gryzwBh
Tumhre ami ko jawab de dia
Tu kafir hai kya
What are the credentials of Qaiser Ahmad Raja?He is not a public intellectual and/or an accredited research scholar of any repute.Why is he wasting precious time of the general populace and under what Authority.
He was taxi driver in uk , ask him
یہ سوال تو پہلے آپ کو عظمیٰ رومی صاحبہ سے نہیں پوچھنا چاہیے؟
@@Mutahhar just for record , qaisar raja was taxi driver . Got deported and now become revivalist
@@Photon-1927what is your point exactly? A taxi driver can not talk but a engineer and this lady can?
What are the credentials of his opponents?
Waiting for Qaiser bhai response ❤
Aagaya
I am deeply impressed ma'am. More power and best wishes.
Qaiser ahmed raja ajeeb insan hai jb deobandi molvi ne bachy j sth ziadti ki thi recently uspr na koi iski video aai
Apky comment se apki ignorance ka pata chal geya .. ap k andar serf bughz hai ... Topic kia hai or ap kia keh rhe hain.😂😂
@@passionbasit991 Bhai meny video pr comment sirf Ali Bhai ki wajha se kia hai wesy tum hee dikhado video koi iski us hawaly se
@@passionbasit991 i already have these type of expectations from hazrat iron dome hafizullah gang and their members
Bahi apke sath b jis deobandi molvi ne zyadati ki hy ap hamy bata do hum action le laingy tension na lo bro
you will soon get refuted on this too
Aur yaha bat Fik ki nahi science ki hai Espar Ap Qaisar Ahmad raja Sahab se Live Discussion kare Please Mam😅😅
Live debate karenge to qaiser Ahmed Raza sirf point ko divert karega. Aur uske blind followers usiko defend karenge kyuki unhone kabhi jargons nahi sune
Madam g apk aur mirza g k pass koi solid argument hai ee ni. Wsy hee jalan main a kr logo ka wqt barbad kr rhy ho ap dono. Janab koi solod argument ly kr ayen. Yeh koi argument ni hota k main aur itny youtuber ni manty ! Really 😂 ?
Hoping million subscribers for you very soon. Keep making such an amazing content
@UzmaRumi
Qaiser Raja ne aap ki video ka response bohat respectful way main kia hai.
Aap jo clips cut kr k lga rahi hain wo QAR ne Engineer Mirza ko respond kia hai.
Is liay kindly mix-up na karein.
QAR ne apni video pr Uzma Rumi k barey main negative comments karney se bhi mana kia tha. How respectful is QAR and how ignorant you are 😮
@@huzaifashaheer724 wtf bro your qasir is lying and all proofs are in front of you but still you wont belive because you are a blind cult follower
Video send karo
@@shoebkhann307 would've sent but unfortunately UA-cam comments main koi bug hai. Links send nhi ho rhy. Plz aap Qaisar raja ke official channel pe jaa ke video check Kar Len. It's quite recent
I watched Mr Qaiser raja video and your too.
He responded in a very polite way while miss Uzma really doesn't know how to respond a person with a opposite perspective in a good way..... she is so rude
She is rebuttaling really well with her references that's why there is passion.
@@abdulhafeez-ob3vurebuttal ? 😂
What Gazali said is based on Sofi Ism that the Gazali has studied by his own practice after leaving all his luxurious life of State Wayiz. His brother was always taunting him that his sermons are leaving his audience with weeping eyes . Have he delivered such a sermon to his own person. Since you or your criticizers are not students of Sofi Ism therefore you can not understand the secrets of the knowledge stores of Allah. If you are so keen to know the fact you can leave your luxurious life and study the Sofi Ism, otherwise it is very difficult to know the reality of Sofi Ism. Muslim scholars always pose their nose in the subjects which they have never studied at their own as compared with Western scholars who never pose their nose in the subjects which they have not studied.
Engineer sahab aapa ka to samajh me aata hai magar aap inn aayaton ko kaise bhul gaye??
الله الصمد
Har cheez absolutely Allah per har lamha dependent hai apne existence ke liye.. fir ye physical laws Allah se independent kaise kaam kar sakte hai???
لله الامر من قبل ومن بعد
Allah hi ka akele command/hukm/faisla/decree hai (har cheez) se qabl bhi aur (har cheez) ke ba'ad bhi...
Matlab kis cause ke baad kya effect niklega aur jo effect nikla hai uska cause kya hoga...
"الا له الخلق و الأمر"
"كل يوم هوا في شأن"
Aur kaise bhool gaye ki Jo kuch dunya me aur universe me ho rha hai Allah uski nisbat apni taraf kart hai wo bhi fa'il ki haisiyat se jaise
"يقلب الله الليل و النهار"
"انزل من السماء ماء"
"يولج اليل في النهار.."
"و جعل الشمس سراجا"
"لنخرج به حبا و نباتا"
Wagaira wagaira aur bhi beshumar aayaat hai..
Sabhi aayaton me Allah فعل ke sath khudko فاعل bata rha hai.. fir aap seculars ki tarah ye mante ho ki Allah ne universe aur uske laws to create kar diye machine ki tarah magar ye unverse Allah ki mansha ke mutabik khud hi chal rha hai jaise koi machine engineer ki mansha ke mutabik chalti hai matlab "فاعل" wo machine khud hui..
Kya ye aqeedah Qur'an aur sunnat ke khilaf nhi hai???
Ghazali sirf aik sofi tha 👎👎👎
apni zuban sanbal kameeney ......
@@IrfanAli-kp8ys Bhai ghizali jesay pagal ko pagal hi bolain gay na. Is main ghalat kiya hai ?
@@rahil320🤡quiet liberall first check the work of imam ghazali ....
Jo oliya Allah ki gustakhi karta hai uska imam salamat nhi rehta@@rahil320
Dear Ms. Uzma,
I wanted to provide constructive feedback on your recent presentation. It seems your rebuttals were biased towards Islam, citing sources that lack academic credibility ( 😂😂hoodboy😂mistary mirza😂 taimur laala😂😂 come onnnnn.... ).
It's crucial to avoid allowing pseudo-appreciation to steer your work towards entertainment. Instead, strive for a neutral stance in your research to maintain professionalism and credibility. This approach will ensure your presentations are taken seriously and contribute meaningfully to your field.
Best regards,
IQBAL ka tarana baangh e dara hai goya
Hota hai ja wa paiman phir qaarwan hamara
appreciation comment to Miss Uzma Rumi, the voice of the sane.
Good or Bad will be decided after contrary reply by anyone
@@albaengineering
whatever
@@Maryam-Fatmathat sense of intellect you have, creating opinion without listening both side🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱
## gang of ilmi kitabi(don't even know Arabic literature)
@@zakku1232
whatever
Contingency argument was in fact originally framed by ibn Sina
Thanks for the effort. Great work , MashaAllah. Keep it up.
This is a difficult subject and lot of people get tangled. Great job in explaining
Very wrong interpretation by you miss uszma....may be to rebutal qaisar raja...
السلام علیکم، بہن سب سے پہلے تو آپ کا شکریہ کہ زیادہ دیر نہیں لگائی پچھلی ویڈیو کے بعد یہ ویڈیو بنانے میں، ویسے معذرت کے ساتھ عرض ہے کہ اس ویڈیو کے بعد امام غزالی عالمِ ارواح میں قیصر احمد راجہ پر لعنتیں بھیج رہے ہوں گے 🙏😂، جزاک اللہ خیرا
Sir setting main ja k subtitles off kr dain ...its simple. Video k neecha jo setting button hota ha wahan sa
واہ کیا علم غیب ہے😮
Shame on You. U r being called an engineer waaah Kia bat hei... Ignorant Dark face you r
G o mirzay k gandoo😂😂
Apnay Mirzay ko bahir nikal bill sy mufti Tariq Masood intizaar kar Rahay hai 😂
Mirza comments here is proof that , the damage has been done to mirza😂😂 Qaisar Raja is a legend.❤
You're right that's why everyone is discussing Ali Mirza. ❤
Syed Muzammil ❤🔥
@@minha_sheikh107 Syed Muzamil has very good knowledge. But he is not familiar with the ups and downs of Islamic knowledge. As he prefers the words of non-Muslim philosophers, he seems to be unfamiliar with Islamic literature. It will be much better if he learns Islamic literature instead of his own opinion.
@@Qaisrani922 Islamic literature is also someone's own opinion as well.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc No bro, no one gives their opinion. Islamic scholars used to spend their lives telling the Qur'an and the Sunnah, whatever the meaning is hidden in the depths, and which is consistent with the Qur'an and the Hadith.
wah wah wah. Maza aa gya. Keep it up brave lady. Thankyou.
Ay aqal ky andey
Well I didn’t understand are you trying to say that Allah created all things with certain laws and now Allah is not interfering?? He created world and left over ???
That's what they are trying to inject, still claiming themselves to be muslim. According to them, Allah is sleeping after creating the universe
صوفیا کے کندھے پر بندوق رکھ کر نشانہ قرآنی عقائد کو بنا رہی ہے
She just made Statements and did not gave proof.Wohi wala kaam kia hai "Rana nay jo keh dita keh dita" By the way Contingency Argument Ibn Sina nay frame kia tha pahlay.
No allah creating laws every thing working under the law if allah interfare its own laws its also againts laws allah has created except nabi.
@@usmanm9267 صرف نبی کے لئے اللہ تعالٰی اپنے قوانین کو خلاف کرتا ہے اس کی کوئی دلیل؟
@@Abu-hasnain nabuwat khatam ho gai uss ki nishaniya khatam hogai ab sirf hain mubashrat yani k sachy khawab. Jab nabowat he khatam ho gai to pher nashani kes baat ki.
If u read refutation of philosophers , reading first few page is clear. Man was genius…….his kalam cosmological argument still puts fear in hearts of godless heathens.
MashaAllah !!! Tabahi pher dii meri behn !!! JazakAllah ....Allah paak iss Raja ko Hidayt Dey Ameeeeen
Yar ab ap ni ke rhe is ko perda kerna chahye laila baji ke bar to aik he rat lgai hote he ap ne
Apni bar nazrya change hoja ta he ap ka
@@waqaskhan-jr7gx tum apna kaam karo
Woh karlegi parda
@@sanyaakurd-bd9wg syeda laila ki bar ap ku chelate ho is se to behter he wo
دعوت گئی بھاڑ میں
آپ لوگ یہاں اپنا لچ فرائی کرو
کوئی شرم ہوتی ہے
کوئی حیا ہوتی ہے
QAR's latest response titled " Sister Uzma Rumi is Arguably The best Ghazalian Yet". He schooled her again academically, great job QAR. I'm afraid his response will suspend the rest of the parts of her argument.😊
@@muhammadanas8107 mein to fan ho gya hu Raja Sahab ka 1 to videos dekhi hn Kya cool admi ha yar
Others abuse is wrong thing, but for a dishonest person like qaisar raja, I would say Qaisar baja,😂😂
All he do is
1) Take points in others like in a child way, not genuine points.
2) Discuss his silly logic in a serios way.
3) Appeal to emotions.
4) Use every logical fallacy.
An advise for him...
Beta tum masoom Pakistanio ku doka krsakthe wuh😂😂
Your totally wrong k her Muslim k dill ma k zahri asbab Nazar k dokha hai bus ya bola jata hai k AP UN zahir isbab pay emaan na rakho Apne mahanat karo us ke jaza Allah pak day ga. With due All respect AP ke Muslim k nazaryat ma Apne luch na talay please
صوفیا کے کندھے پر بندوق رکھ کر نشانہ قرآنی عقائد کو بنا رہی ہے
Front man of molvis is better than front man of anti islamisms and iron dom hafiza......... mirza sahib kisi or hi trf chal pry hain ... unsubscribed him
Again emotional rant instead on any logical argument. Really you molbis are beyond repair.
Let us have live debate
Contingency Argument was exposited by Ibn Sina originally, not Aquinas.
Abhi Qaiser Ahmed Raja bolega k live debate krlen to ye saray aen baen shaen krengy Engineer ki trah
Engineer ki batoo ka jawaab tery Qaisar jesy hazaroo bhi nahi dy skty beta badi hoo ky aao😂
@@i8xbabluxysxmrjay648 han thek keh rha hy khush reh 🤣
You have not given answer to main question yet, according to you after imam Ghazali the scientific temperament in the muslim world went down yet we see many Muslim scientists after Ghazali namely, Al Nafis, Al Tusi, Al Shatir, Ulugh Beg, Omar Khayyam (yes he worked on Algerba apart from poetry), Ibn Rushd, etc. How did they managed to work if Muslims developed an anti scientific mindset? Also, Al Ghazali's own view on science,
“As for the praiseworthy disciplines such as medicine and mathematics, they are associated with worldly benefit. And that category is divided into those that become a communal obligation and those that are of great merit but are not an obligation"
Kindly don't deviate from topic.
We are getting benefitted in terms of knowledge because of the exchange of dialogue between You and Qaisar Ahmad Raja
Mr. Junior Mirza (Front_Man of Liberandus) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen!!! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH
! ! ! عزوجل
Qaiser raja destroyed your references in his response...
video time
8:01 to 11:00
Apka andaz bht bahtreen aur shandar ha halaky Qaiser Raja aysa style deserve nhe krta wo usi style main jawab deserve krta js main is jysy log dyty han.... Meri request hugi ap sy ky second part main is Netherland ky motivational speaker ko batahe ky Ghazali pr sb sy phly yh rad Ibn Rushd ny kya tha naky Renan ny...
Imam Ghazali k tum loag paon k dhool k braber b nai ho. Jitni us nay books likhi hayn utni tumhari umar nai hogi. Besharmi ikhtalaf ka ye matlb nai hay k kisi insan ki har achi khoobi ka bhi inkaar kr do.
@@AbdullahJaved-kw8dl Ghazali pr mainy kuch nhe kaha apny comment main... Mainy srf Netherland ky fraud QAR code par bat ki ha.... Ghussa Q arha ha itna🤣🤣🤣.... Kahe aysa tu nhe Qaiser Fraudi ky chamchy ko ap😁😁....
ہم مسلمان جنہیں معزز اور عالم دین سمجھتے تھے، چند لوگوں کے علاوہ اسلام اور سائنس دونوں کے دشمن نکلے۔افسوس کہ آج بھی بعض علماء کرام اس بات کو نہیں مانتے کہ زمین گول ہے۔اللہ ان کو ہدایت دے۔
Allah pak tum.jaisu galezo ko adyat dy
کونسے علماء زمین کو گول نہیں مانتے؟
AP Allah ko paband karny waly argument ko support kar rhy hai Allah hi Hafiz hai Apka
Zameen waqi gool nahi hai , Tum Zara research kar Kay dekh lo😂
زمین گول ہے ؟۔۔۔
اس پر کوئی دلیل یا ثبوت موجود ہے ؟۔۔۔
Imam Ghazali basically allowed the option that fire may not burn based on miracle of Ibrahim (A.S.). Quran has told us many other things which proved later in science. These things only tell us what's possible even more than what we know. Ghazali believes it is also possible through science that fire may not burn. It does not deny science, rather it forces you to expand your view of science and struggle to explore things that are unknown to traditional science. For example, In surah Kahf, it's mentioned that a sound struck on ears of ashab and they went into state of hibernation. Now the sound striking on ears is causing hibernation which at the moment is unscientific, but Islam is only telling you that it is possible, try to do it. Similarly, how the Ibrahim AS was not burnt, it is possible that fire may not burn. We should only expand our horizon of science and try to unlock more things.
آپ کی باتوں میں جو تضاد ہے تو بہن, بہت جلد قیصر بھائی آپ کی کلاس لینے آئیں گے
میں صرف ایک تضاد بتا دوں ؟
قیصر صاحب نے کہا کہ امام غزالی Phenomenal aspect of Cause and Effect کو رد نہیں کرتے تو آپ نے امام غزالی کی تحریر کا حوالہ دے کر کہا کہ قیصر صاحب جھوٹ بولتے ہیں
تو میری بہن, جو جملہ آپ نے پڑھ کر سنایا اس پر تھوڑی دیر غور کر لیا ہوتا تو آپ کو اتنی لمبی ویڈیو بنانے کی زحمت نہ کرنی پڑتی نا
امام غزالی لکھتے ہیں "ہم یہ بھی جائز رکھتے ہیں", یہاں لفظ 'بھی' کا اِستعمال قابل غور ہے بہن
یعنی امام غزالی قوانین فطرت کا صریح انکار نہیں کر رہے بلکہ یہ کہہ رہے ہیں کہ اگرچہ خدا کا تشکیل کردہ فطرت کا قانون ہے کہ آگ روئی کو جلائے گی لیکن اس واقعے کا سبب بننے والا Chief Cause اللہ خود ہیں جو کسی موقع پر دخل اندازی بھی کر سکتے ہیں
اب آپ کے ذمے ہے اس پر غور کرنا
I love Muhammad Ali Mirza bhai
🤦♂️ who asked?
Very good video. I appreciate you Miss Uzma Rumi. May Allah guide all of us to the right path.
The supporters of all Firqas are happy to have a new member in the form of Qaiser sahab, but there is no actual or logical reason behind their happiness. The thing is, Qaiser Sahab is talking about someone who has ruined all their Firqas ☺️☺️☺️
100% Agreed with your rational and islamic approach. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen!!! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!!
Qaiser Raja famous chawal toh warr gaya. 😂
@@Hazrat-e-Insaan when in Pakistan , profanity will be charged , shaid Isi terha is awam mein kuch tahzib a saky.
Kuch sharm honi chahiey insaan ko, ek insaan ho k apni lingo ko mulahiza kerein, how it sounds, how these third class words jo shaid ap ki subah sham k adat hey, kitni azziat ka bais hey, for readers. Ap k actions mein tau register ho hi rahi hey ye, just a reminder 🩵
Baji Ab Qaisar Ahmed raja ka bi response dekh lo ap ka sara weham door ho jay ga 😂
maine Tera baat ka tehkeek kiya to ye paaya ke Sikke ki ek side tune bayaan kiya aur dusre side ko kha gayi tune Imam gazali ke baare me kaha ke wo Reason the jo ummat e muslma ke bich se science khatm hua wo reject kiya Karte the lekin jab maine unka kitaab padha to dekha ke unhone likha hai wo unhi science ko maante the jo proved hai aur jo proved nahi hua uski andhi takhlid nahi Karte the ..tune kaha halaku khan ne science ki kitaabe ko burn kiya tha aur uske destroy karne ke 100 sal Bad hi science ka down fall aane laga muslim World se lekin jab maine tehqeeq kiya to paaya ke Imam ghazali se pehle jitne momin sciencedaan hue hai usse tin guna zyada sciencedaan Imam ghazali ke 100 sal 200 Saal 300 saal 400 Saal baad tak qaseer taadaat me dunya ke saamne Aaye...to kuch bolne se pehle tehkeek karke bola kar kisi ka ratta rataaya baat mat kar aur thoda books english me bhi padha kar
"I highly value your perspective and insights on this matter. Your thoughtful input would be greatly appreciated as we navigate through these important decisions."
O bai Dr Asad Q. Ahmad ko read kro Professor of Barkley university of university. Ye bndi jhot bol rhi.
اب جواب نہیں فتویٰ آئے گا میری بہن پر جیسے امام غزالی نے ابنِ سینا پر کفر کا فتویٰ لگایا تھا 😢
😂😂❤
You can't beat Qaisar seb, He is a legend.
You have to be strong.
QAR is a clown 🤡
Clown to tu hy jo locgic ky bina baat kr raha hy.
The concept of creator varies from human to human.
Yes u r right but it should not be against al Qur'an
@@Muslim-543216 billion people don’t believe in Quran or Islam
A well needed response ♥️♥️♥️
Yes by anyone not specifically QAR
22:52 misunderstanding... Kharqe aadat ka mahal hona batil hai ka matlab ye nhi hai ki kisi bhi insan including ambiya apni taqat se kharqe aadat koi kaam karte the.. iss ka matlab ye hai ki kharqe aadat ko ye kahna ki mahal hai iss liye batil aur gair islami aqeedah hai kyunki ye kaha ja raha hai ki Allah ne koi law bana diya to wo uss law ke khilaf koi kaam nhi kar sakta ... *Dr israr Ahmad r.a ne achi misal di thi ke ye kahna ki kharqe aadat mahal hai goya Allah ne ek cage (universe) banaya aur khud usi me kaid ho gaya.. subhan Allah aisa nhi hai* ....
Dusri baat : aap ne jo ref diye uske neeche ke passage me khud gazali kah rhe hai ki kharqe aadat kaam Allah kisi ke liye bhi kar sakta hai aur har waqt kar sakta hai magar wo aisa karega nhi verna agar insani mushahide me kharqe aadat kisi kaam ka hona ek aam cheez ban jayega to uski tahkeer ho jayegi matlab maujza nhi kah layega..
Matlab universe aur uske andar ki har cheez Allah ki sunnat ke mutabik hi kaam karegi ya'ne universe apne physical law ke mutabik hi kaam karegi jiska use Allah ne hukm diya hai apne amre kun se... Agar ye physical laws kuch aur hote to humara experiance bhi kuch aur hota... Magar Allah koi aisa khaliq nhi hai jo universe ko kisi ghadi banane wale ki tarah banaya ho.. usne khud farma diya hai ki usne universe ko " "Be" and it is " se banaya hai aur isi tarah iske laws bhi banaya hai aur isi tarah ise chala bhi rha hai.. as-samad ka yhi to matlab hai ki universe aur iske andar ki har cheez har aan aur lamhe Allah per dependent hai apne existence aur operation ke liye. Universe ke Physical laws khud se nhi kaam kar rhe hai balke har cause aur uska effect Allah ke total control me hai.. verna iss aayat ka kya matlab hai "كل يوم هوا في شأن"
Innocent People are dying in Gaza and you are arguing over strange things
کیا بکواس تبصرہ ہے تمہارا
مطلب جو کچھ غزہ میں ہورہا ہے، اُس کا تعلق اس ویڈیو سے کیسے ہے۔
Qaiser bhai zindabad..qaiser bhai ap logo ke lye doctor hai or aj kal mirza ko injection lga raha hai😂😂
Sorry agar aapko video samajh nahi aaya
@@saptarsi7868😅😅👍🏼
"abe dhakkan takla ahmed raja bol 🤔🤔🤔takle ke chamche 🤔🤔🤔
Dukh horha qaiser raja ap jese logon ko bewaqof bana sakta hai 😅😅
@@Huntmenoww jo QAR se bewakof banraha ho uska IQ lvl minus - me hoga😅
So How Imam gazali thought can ruined the Islamic golden age and you didn't counter any Arguments related to fall of Golden age. And I'm not able to understand why so called liberal didn't able to understand that In the case of Cotton and fire, Fire didn't burn Cotton if ALLAH didn't allow. This is hypothetical situation which can explain the power of Almighty, that ALLAH have power to intervene in this world. If god didn't able to intervene so He is not GOD. Because God have absolute power. This is very simple, And Can you explain how this thought become reason of Islamic golden age fall.Why you didn't counter any Qaiser Sahab Fall of golden age Arguments.
I'm waiting for your Prompt response.
Bhai kya hogya ha. Apna dimaag use kro jb logo ko ye btao gy ye universe bghair kisi law k chal rahi ha to kon science pe focus kry ga asan rasta to ye bun gya k sufi ho jao to universe tumharay qdmon me hogi. To is trah logo ne science ko dekhny or universe k laws ko smajhnay ki bjaye sirf Allah ho krny me lag gye. Or science k ilm ko kafir ka ilm smaj liya is trah Islamic golden age tbah hoa ye clear cut ha is video me or pichli video me bhi.
Is sy koi Muslim inkar nahi kr raha ha k universe Allah Almighty ne create ki ha. Problem ye ha sufi is baat ko man'nay k liye tayyar nahi k Allah Almighty ne is universe ko scientific laws k mutabiq bnaya ha or chala raha ha. In laws ko sirf Prophets k liye Allah ne tora isi ko occasionalism kehty. is baat ko sufi nahi man'tay wo kehty hain k ye kisi bhi insaan k liye hoskta ha jb aesa nahi ha. Ye sirf Prophets k liye ha
You need explanation?, ok! See, when Ghazali's thoughts were reinforced, people stopped researching and critical thinking, free thoughts became blasphemy and that ultimately lead to downfall of Muslims in Arab and Persia. Free inquiry is the key to scientific development. Where there will be a religious suppression there will be a recession in scientific achievements.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc oh really After the death of Imam Gazali there is 8 biggest research laboratory build in Islamic empires, and at that time Many Sultan fund research institutes and laboratories. This is very chep understanding that one person who collapse entire golden age and at that time whare different sect of islam didn't agree on same Arguments and this man come and all muslim say we are now follow this person we build observatries for fun we build monument without the help of science we translate geek philosophical book we build world largest astronomy observatries but we stop thinking, this is funny. This type of Arguments that imam gazali collapse Science and thinking come from empty mind that type of people who is not aware about Islamic history.
@@uuy5865 Nah bro! that is not what I have said. Whatever Ghazali wrote had a significant impact over the minds of the people of that time and it slowly but surely damaged the scientific fabric of society and later on ofcourse many religious personality came and contributed in the destruction. I would agree that some khalifa was open minded & they invested heavily in science and technology but their thoughts, beliefs overshadowed by the belief of those who were against all these progress.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc ua-cam.com/video/tOjT52JIPzw/v-deo.htmlsi=ZwPb-6klU3ypN_wj
Brilliant reply to that clown raja..
You have exposed raja so badly.. He doesn't even know what he's saying , he has crammed few lines like, yeh aapki field nhi, woh desi secular hai woh falaan hai etc..
He's a clown...
thanks to qaisar ahmad raja for introducing you to me
you are a gem
Great dear sister. ❤❤❤❤Keep it up sister.
Mr. Muhammad Engineer Ali Mirza (Front_Man of the Qadyanis) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! !
ameen
shame on engineer
Qaiser is a gem and engineer is secular sh*t 😡
engineer is a danger to Islam 😢
Qaiser you beauty ❤
I think that all of us need to have humble attitude. As you criticised on Qaiser Sb and said that he is arrogant, you also did the same mistake in this video
Mam ab to subscribe krna paray ga AAP ko Engineer shb Kisi knowledgeable Real person ki vedios share krty Hain , Baki Molvi Agent Qaisar Raja ki wchi beezti ho Rahi ha 😂😂😂✌️
Well done sister ❤
Bahot he kamaal ki video hai. Lakinn thumbnail itna eye catchy nahe hai. Qaiser raja ka muhn bra kar k lgana chahiya tha jistarah wo views kalia sabhka face lgata ha thumbnail pay😂😂😂..
Urdu font bhe samjhna mushkil ha.
Aggar aap kahain to main 3,4 thumbnails bna k apko fb per bhaij sakta hun. Jo pasand ho use kr lijiya ga..because you deserve millions of views.... ❤
The pseudo intellect award goes to MR QIASER AHMED RAJA😂
محترمہ لگتا آپ نے ٹھیک طریقے سے نہیں پڑھا۔جملے میں بھی (ALSO) کا استعمال ہوا ہے۔
جس کا مطلب ہے کہ روئ کا جلنا بھی ممکن ہے اور نہ بھی۔
جو کچھ بھی ہو گا اللہ پاک کے حکم سے ہوگا۔
قیصر صاحب نے آپ کو یہی سمجھایا تھا۔ کسی اردو زبان کے ماہر سے اپنی اصلاح ضرور کروائیں۔
تو ٹھیک ہے نا، محترمہ بھی یہی کہ رہی ہیں۔ کہ غزالی کے مطابق جو کچھ بھی ہو گا اللہ پاک کے حکم سے ہوگا نا کہ کسی قانون (فزکس، کمسٹری وغیرہ) کے۔ لہٰذا آگ دکھانے پر کبھی روئی جلے گی کبھی نہیں اور کبھی بغیر آگ کے بھی جلے گی۔
جبکہ سائنسدانوں کے مطابق جو کچھ بھی ہوگا اللہ کے بنائے ہوئے قوانین (فزکس، کمسٹری وغیرہ) کے مطابق ہوگا۔ تو آگ دکھانے پر روِئی ((لازماً)) جلے گی۔
اس میں کسی اردو زبان کے ماہر سے اپنی اصلاح کروانے کی کیا ضرورت ہے۔
That lady always blame ulma and Islam now lecturing about Islam. Atheist have no right to talk about islam
andhbakht spotted
Your words are really engraved on my mind.
I heard Qaiser bhai also, but your way of speaking is too good, and this video really cleared my arguments
Waiting for the next part......❤
This debate has long been settled in the academic spheres! For people of knowledge and research have written books and papers discussing whether Imam Ghazali (RA) was responsible for decline in Islamic sciences, a point that orientalist tried very hard to prove. A request to all Muslims here is to listen to people like Humza Yousuf and visit intellectual channels like Paul William’s Blogging Theology we’re Professor Shuaib discusses Ghazali (RA) and this dispute in detail.
You have made so many infrences without giving their Rational.Contingency argument may Cause and effect may GOD ka alam na hona kahan say sabit kia aap nay?You just made a statement and thats it.This is not how you make your point.
She is not denying Allah as the first cause of this universe meaning Allah Almighty created this universe. Her point is this universe is govern through scientific laws and these laws are created by Allah Almighty and He suspends these laws only for Prophets. Whereas Sufis are against it.
You are doing an excellent work. Criminally underrated. Been a subscriber for a while and your content doesn’t disappoint; always well researched.
As far as Caner Raja is concerned, he is just that, cancer.
بہت موثراندازمیں بیان کیا ہے۔۔۔
Who is greater religion or human being??
religion exists if human beings exist whereas the opposite is not true😊
Now raja ko samjhe agai hogi laikin ana bahut hai is bandai mai. Ye baat ghuma daiga and will not respond
Qaisar Raja Ki Galti Nahi Hai,
Devband DimagBand 😂😂😂
confuse Mirza k confused students kuch to khuda ka khauf kru
secular culture promotion
@@yousufhussain7018
Aap ek aur suboot hain,
Devband DimagBand 😂😂😂
@@qarisohaibahmedspeeches bhai Dimag nahi 2no kan band kiye hue he in confused persons se Alhamdulilah apne emaan pe satisfied he Allah in confused aur secular culture k promoters se sab musalmano ku bachay ameen
@@yousufhussain7018Bhai satisfied to Barelwi bhi hain, Qadiyani bhi hain inko choriye,
Hindu bhi hain aur Christian bhi hain apne apne emaan se,
DimagBand Devband Wali Baat Kar Rahen Aap Phir
Nice explanation Uzma
Dear Uzma, Ghazali is not only recognised in Islam but his philosophical work is well known and widely respected in West, he's been taught in universities as well.
Whereas it took you almost a month to respond to QAR and you brought two critics Molvi so and so , I'm sure like all of us you yourself haven't have heard of these two unknown critics before.
The man with Ghazalis stature deserves a critic with some authenticity, next time bring someone we know instead of bringing some Tom, Dick and Harry to strengthen your case.
Qaiser raja can be called " confident lier '. So confident in speaking lies I never s 34:57 een such a astonishing person who speaks lie with such confident. And degrade those who most of time speak truth. What shameful personality raja is
Pura maheena laga k video banai aur aitraz dekho😂😂🤣 congratulations 🎉 sahil adeem ki 95% jahil aurton mein ap bhi ati ho😅😅
Teri mavi aayi h jahil ki aulaad, Adeem ne tujhe vi gaali di h aur tu usko defend krne me laga h
5% men spotted 😅
Nice 👍
Qaiser saib please become front man of truth not mullah!!!!!😊
Miss Rumi , I think you don't quite understand the occasionalism argument. Are you claiming that Allah is bound by his Laws and even he can't change them like the philosophers believed?
You are absolutely wrong, miss rumi never said that Allah can't change his own created laws. Allah can, but Allah already decided not to change except for his prophets whenever He desired to do so.. I think you some sort of pain has disabled you to understand the open fact.
@@shehryarkhan1808 "Allah had decided not to"
Bro from where are you getting this information? Do you have any special connection route ?
Please understand the argument. The Philosophers like Ibne Rush and Ibne Sina argued that things don't change their nature since if they did knowledge of things is impossible. But Ghazali argued that what means here nature of things is just the will of Allah which he can change any second to alter the laws of physics. Of course the philosophers were in disagreement. According to them Allah created the universe with specific laws and he can't change them.
اتنے علمی اور ادبی انداز میں قیصر راجے کو کسی نے پہلے دھویا ہو، نہیں دیکھا میں نے،😂😂😅😅😂 زبردست عظمیٰ
جی نہیں، پہلے عظمہ ٹھیک لکھو، پھر غزالی بھی سمجھ آئے گا۔ ، قیصر راجہ صاحب نے جو بھی اعتراض اٹھائے، اس میں سے عظمیٰ صاحبہ نے صرف دو چیزوں کو ٹچ کیا ھے،اور وہ بھی عظمیٰ صاحبہ جو سمجھ رھی اور جو سوچ رہی ھیں۔ ضروری نہیں کہ وہ حرف آخر ھے۔
اور قیصر صاحب نے عظمیٰ صاحبہ کو جھوٹا نہیں کہا ۔ عظمیٰ صاحبہ تو یہ بھی نہیں سمجھ رہی ھیں۔ تو باقی ان کا جواب آنے کا انتظار کریں۔ قیصر راجہ صاحب کی باتیں عظمیٰ صاحبہ کے کچھ پلے نہیں پڑیں۔😊
@@Qaisrani922 The problem is not about the facts, but Mr qaiser always go with the populous narrative that people want to hear. He knows that his audience isn't good at fact-checking. So he just interpretes the facts with his own way, and make jalebis. People think he is the only one who attack the progressives. So he earns money.
اور عظمیٰ صاحبہ یہ ثابت کرنا چا رہی ھیں کہ اللہ کائنات کو ڈائریکٹ نہیں چلا رہا۔ گھڑی کی طرح کائنات بنا دی اب وہ چلتی جا رہی؟ کیا تم۔مانتے ہو یہ سب؟
@@Qaisrani922 جی بلکل یہی حقیقت ہے ، اگر ایسا نہ ہوتا تو خدا نے گناہ نہ کرنے کی تنبیہ کیوں کی؟ جب سب کچھ گھڑی کی طرح ہے تو ہدایت اور گمراہی کا راستے پر انسان کا اختیار کیسے؟ اللہ نے فزکس کے قوانین بنائے اور کائنات انکے بلبوتے پر چل رہی ہے میرے بھائی ۔ اور انھی فزکس کے قوانین کی بدولت آپ اس سائنسی دنیا میں رہ رہے ہو۔
@@FaisalQureshiofficial2اور قرآن جو کہ رہا وہ؟ کہ اللہ کی شان یہ ھے کہ ہر وقت کام میں مصروف رہتا ھے؟
اس کے بغیر، کوئی پتہ نہیں گرتا، نہ کوئی دانہ پھوٹتا،
قرآن پڑھو بھائی ۔
O sister ye ap Kis bewaqoof ko samjha rahi ho wo to intehai jahil admi ha usky zehen me itni baty kaisy samjh I gi. Chaly usko samjh ay ya na ay hmy bht kuch sekhny ko Mila thank you so much.
Excellent. In my humble opinion ,Ghazali was confused on issue of Causality. Ghazali while keeping aside the Ontological causal necessity, he accepted the logical one. H. A. Wolfsin ( sorry if not correctly written) maintains that Ghazzali did nor accept causality. E. J Courteney however believes that Ghazzali has been misinterpreted on Causality. In my evaluation, based on the above authors, Ghazzali tried to reconcile between Kalam and philosophy on topic of Causality. This seems to be owing to rising Scholasticism his era has witnessed. He did the same to causality issue as Ghazzali had done to Orthodoxy and Sufism. Interestingly , Avi Cena was ghazali teacher in philosophy. Regards. Asar ahmadzay
Miss Uzma you said nothing wondering can happen after prophets. what's your take on karamat of non anbia mentioned in Quran like takhe bilqees. And what about karamat of Sahaba mentioned in Bukhari Muslim.
Sister is braindead
Qaiser to Gazaali : Hum to Dooby hen Sanam Tmko bhi ly doobyn gy