Mr. Qaiser Raja (Front_Man of Molvis) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! !
Ali Bhai , Qaiser Raja is a clown and a joker whose duty is to save his FIRQA and nothing else. So , Please Keep exposing Qaiser Raja and Tariq Masood and please DON'T stop because they will also NOT stop . Their agenda is that of Hitler's Goebbels and that is lie loudly and lie as many times and as many places as possible to convert lie into truth.
دنیا میں ہر دور میں کچھ نہ کچھ افراد انتے گندے ھوتے ہیں ان کا کام صرف اور صرف اہل حق اور مقبول شخصیات کے عیوب کے ٹوھ میں ھوتے ہیں لیکن اللہ تعالیٰ نے اپنے محبت کے پیاسوں کو ان کے فیوض سے مالا مال کیا اور وہ دن بہ دن اللہ تعالی کی معارفت میں ترقی کرتے رہتے ہیں جو کہ ابدی زندگی میں کام آنے والی سب سے افضل چیز ہے ان اھل حق میں سے ایک موجودہ دور میں سے قیصر احمد راجا صاحب بھی ہیں جو بھی دل کے کانوں کو کھول کر صرف ایک بار اس کو سنتا ہے اسے حق ضرور سمجھ میں آتی ہے اور مفتی ندیم الواجدی صاحب بھی ہیں اور ابھی تو ڈاکٹر ذاکر نائیک نے واضح کردیا۔
Behen maine aapki video suni aur durst lagi thi lekin Qaiser sahab ka response dekh kar laga aap ko Ghazali samjhne mein ghalti hogayi. Mazrat bura mat maniyega. ALLAH SWT SAB KO DURST CHEEZ SAMJHNE KI TOUFEEQ DEIN AMEEN ❤
Al-Ghazali basically tried to criticize the philosophers of his time, especially those influenced by Greek philosophy, such as Avicenna (Ibn Sina) and Al-Farabi. He argued that their views contradicted Islamic teachings and undermined religious faith.But it is important to recognize that the decline in scientific research was due to a combination of factors, including political instability, economic challenges, and changing cultural priorities.Scientific activity did not cease immediately after Al-Ghazali. Scholars like Ibn Rushd (Averroes) continued to engage in philosophical and scientific pursuits. So, Al-Ghazali's views on occasionalism and his critique of philosophy did shift the intellectual focus towards theology and mysticism, it is overly simplistic to say that they alone caused the decline of scientific inquiry in the Islamic world. P.S. You saying 'In Shaa Allah' at the end of the video is actually promoting Ghazali's occasionalism. Because if you are so sure about yourself and firm on your view of causality, why then depend upon Allah’s intervention???
@@ssabbassi888 Yeh jahil lady khud keh rahi hay k Mazhab k baray mai isko kuch khas pata nahi hay phir bhi Hujjat ul Islam Imam Ghazali k baary may Apni Jahilana Approach say baat kar rahi hay . In jahilon ko lagta hay koi Task diya gaya hay jiski funding kahin or say ho rahi hay k Islam k baray mai Shak paidah karo ..
Brother, no one says that Allah does not hold power to intervene(Naoozbillah) but we dont believe that Allah intervenes for everyone like Sufi's do and nor do we have the power to invoke it directly or indirectly. Also even if you believe that 2nd contingency is responsible for everything in our lives that we can observe does not mean that its totally random or without Allah's design. Well I can give two potential reasons that would justify it. 1) First impact or seed value (if you're familiar with programming, you would know what is a seed value in randomness). We humans can stack dominos and cause a chain reaction which is controlled. But if we try it with billiard balls, it goes out of our control, we might be able to predict and control one or two balls but we wont be able to control every ball, but with computers you can predict every ball by simulating the limited number of balls. Next to go above it, if even computers try to simulate everything e.g. air, water, solid objects etc, even they cant and lack computing power. Now, we know Allah is all powerful, if we expand the same logic of action and reaction chains to every single atom in the universe and for the period of start of the universe till end of the universe. Now, would any Muslim disagree with me when I say that Allah is capable of starting this universe by saying Kun-faya-kun and later everything happened in a chain of events based on what he wanted it controlled as. This means if Allah wanted to make life through evolution he can, this also means if we say Inshallah then it is possible that Allah created us to say that and whether something happens or not is still his choice even if he does not immediately intervene. 2) Compatibilism as compared to both free will or determinism. There is another important philosophical debate that if Allah knows exactly what we will do and created us as such(determinism), then what sense does it make that he will judge us and put us in hell fire for our actions since we were made to do it? On the other hand if we have absolute free will, then (Naoozbillah) does Allah not know what we will do, and so it means we have free will and we will be responsible for our actions and rightly be judged? I havent seen any molvi give a slightly decent answer to this. The answer to this seems to be Compatibilism, a mixture of both free will and determinism. Physics even supports it, if you read up quantum super position or Schrodinger's cat thought experiment, you would understand that our interaction(or in physics term, observation) with the universe makes sub-atomic particles fall into a state(the equation about either knowing a particle's momentum or knowing its position, cant know both), we're basically setting reality into a state by interacting with it. This has lead scientists hypothesize a theory of infinite universes, where we are in a reality one for every state was possible to achieve for every sub atomic particle at every time. So if Allah has created our reality such so that we are able to influence it like that and with our actions choose which reality we move on to, then that means we are given free will in a deterministic universe. And if we can choose which path to take from our actions, then surely Allah is infinitely more times capable than us to command every things on how their subatomic particles should collapse and how reality should turn out and still keep everything under cause and effect. So saying Inshallah and then if Allah wills it to happen, it will not take away from 2nd contingency since the action still happened in a deterministic reality. Anyway i dont claim that these two potential reasons are completely correct or absolute truth, Allah knows best and i might be partially wrong about some of it or completely wrong, but to me for now, they answer a lot of question about reality that is otherwise unanswered, specially by the molvi tabqa. Allah knows best, may he guide us.
Bro she cannot handle this, this is too much for her, people say that Pakistan is bankrupt but in reality people here are intellectually bankrupt like this lady here 😂😂
No, it's actually a Bollywood movie where you stand in front of a bullet, fired on someone else, in a dramatic manner and then cry, victim. He made that video in that language for Engineer sahab not for her, the video made for her was different and she didn't respond to it, funny part is she showed that video's thumbnail in her thumbnail, that means she was aware of that video.
Thanks God I hav found at least one person who really loves and has the courage and method to express the truth. اللہ آپ کو دور حاضر کی جہالت کے شر سے محفوظ رکھے. آمین
Well Needed CLIP. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Keep on preaching ISLAM without any Secularism & Mangolism. May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!! My Salute for all the ULAMA Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! ! ❤️🤭
Alhamdullilah Qaiser Ahmed Raja bahi nay barayy zabardasttt jawabaat diyee hain aap kay eik eik point ka. He debunked each and every point that you have raised in this video and the previous one. 😂😂❤❤😊 ap dono ke ilmii behas sun akr kafee kuch seekhnay ko milta hai and maza bhee ata hai sunnay mai. Leep it up guys. 👍 May Allah give more strength and courage to Qaiser Ahmed Raja bahi so that he keeps exposing desi khooni liberalalists and leftists just like that. 🙌🙌❤
السلام علیکم، بہن سب سے پہلے تو آپ کا شکریہ کہ زیادہ دیر نہیں لگائی پچھلی ویڈیو کے بعد یہ ویڈیو بنانے میں، ویسے معذرت کے ساتھ عرض ہے کہ اس ویڈیو کے بعد امام غزالی عالمِ ارواح میں قیصر احمد راجہ پر لعنتیں بھیج رہے ہوں گے 🙏😂، جزاک اللہ خیرا
if You Have Any Question About Islam VS atheism & other Religion You Can Ask Questions By Joining The Live Stream 👇👇👇 Mufti Yasir Nadeem Al Wajdi youtube.com/@YasirNadeemalWajidi LIVE ON EVERY SATURDAY/SUNDAY :- INDIA TIME 9:30 pM Aamir Haq youtube.com/@AwazEHaqUncensored LIVE ON EVERY WEDNESDAY & FRIDAY:- INDIA TIME 9:30PM Aasim Iftekhar youtube.com/@AasimIftekhar LIVE ON India Time 9:30PM QAISAR AHMED RAJA youtube.com/@QaiserAhmedRaja LIVE ON Every Saturday :- INDIA TIME 9:30PM ISLAMIC AWAKENING youtube.com/@IslamicAwakening LIVE ON EVERYDAY:- INDIA TIME 9:30PM
مس عظمی رومی فلسفے کو سمجھنے کے لیے غالب کمال کے یوٹیوب چینل پر تشریف لاین وہان قیصر احمد راجہ,ساحل عدیم,یاسر ندیم واجدی,غامدی جیسے سارے مذہبی چورن بیچنے والون کو عقلی و منطقی بنیادون پر دیا جاتا ہے
Bro. This is the first time I've ever heard this as a criticism of Al Ghazali. I don't know why this translation is the way it is but plz read the English translation. Al Ghazali doesn't say that the most merciful (Ar-rahman ) and the king (maalik) are eparate entities from God. What he actually says is they are attributes of God that are distinct from each other. His knowledge is not his hearing, his hearing is not his sight/seeing, his kingship is not his mercy, his mercy is not his wrath etc. I don't know why she presented it as if he's saying they're all different entities implying different Gods...
Apka andaz bht bahtreen aur shandar ha halaky Qaiser Raja aysa style deserve nhe krta wo usi style main jawab deserve krta js main is jysy log dyty han.... Meri request hugi ap sy ky second part main is Netherland ky motivational speaker ko batahe ky Ghazali pr sb sy phly yh rad Ibn Rushd ny kya tha naky Renan ny...
Imam Ghazali k tum loag paon k dhool k braber b nai ho. Jitni us nay books likhi hayn utni tumhari umar nai hogi. Besharmi ikhtalaf ka ye matlb nai hay k kisi insan ki har achi khoobi ka bhi inkaar kr do.
@@AbdullahJaved-kw8dl Ghazali pr mainy kuch nhe kaha apny comment main... Mainy srf Netherland ky fraud QAR code par bat ki ha.... Ghussa Q arha ha itna🤣🤣🤣.... Kahe aysa tu nhe Qaiser Fraudi ky chamchy ko ap😁😁....
IMAN KAY DARJAT AUR MUTA'LIQA KALIMAT: Anbya aur deegar bari hastyon say het ker am insanon kay hawalay say bat ki jay, to Ghazali nay theek kaha aur yea hi ehl-e-tasawuf ka kulya hay. Imani lehaz say bunyadi darjat kuch yea hain: Pashu ka iman: La Ilaha Ilellah. Ashiq-e-Ilahi ka iman: La-Maqsood Ilellah. Fana fil-Lah ka iman: La Mojud Ilellah. Ghazali imani aur spiritual experience kay lehaz say bohet buland darjay per faez thay, lehaza unhain kisi Pashu kay imani koozay main bend kernay ki saee la-hasil hay. In imani kaifyat ko yea maya kay jal main uljhay dunya-parest secular log, jo imani, spiritual, intellectual and above all consciousness kay lehaz say Pashu hain, bhala kaisay samajh sektay hain?
Live debate karenge to qaiser Ahmed Raza sirf point ko divert karega. Aur uske blind followers usiko defend karenge kyuki unhone kabhi jargons nahi sune
What are the credentials of Qaiser Ahmad Raja?He is not a public intellectual and/or an accredited research scholar of any repute.Why is he wasting precious time of the general populace and under what Authority.
I watched Mr Qaiser raja video and your too. He responded in a very polite way while miss Uzma really doesn't know how to respond a person with a opposite perspective in a good way..... she is so rude
محترمہ لگتا آپ نے ٹھیک طریقے سے نہیں پڑھا۔جملے میں بھی (ALSO) کا استعمال ہوا ہے۔ جس کا مطلب ہے کہ روئ کا جلنا بھی ممکن ہے اور نہ بھی۔ جو کچھ بھی ہو گا اللہ پاک کے حکم سے ہوگا۔ قیصر صاحب نے آپ کو یہی سمجھایا تھا۔ کسی اردو زبان کے ماہر سے اپنی اصلاح ضرور کروائیں۔
تو ٹھیک ہے نا، محترمہ بھی یہی کہ رہی ہیں۔ کہ غزالی کے مطابق جو کچھ بھی ہو گا اللہ پاک کے حکم سے ہوگا نا کہ کسی قانون (فزکس، کمسٹری وغیرہ) کے۔ لہٰذا آگ دکھانے پر کبھی روئی جلے گی کبھی نہیں اور کبھی بغیر آگ کے بھی جلے گی۔ جبکہ سائنسدانوں کے مطابق جو کچھ بھی ہوگا اللہ کے بنائے ہوئے قوانین (فزکس، کمسٹری وغیرہ) کے مطابق ہوگا۔ تو آگ دکھانے پر روِئی ((لازماً)) جلے گی۔ اس میں کسی اردو زبان کے ماہر سے اپنی اصلاح کروانے کی کیا ضرورت ہے۔
@@sheralam920btw, the consistency in the natural phenomenon (i.e. physics, chemistry) is sunnat or adat of Allah. He is capable of changing the observable patterns in nature which is called miracle. So, either nature operates in normal way or it operates in unconventional way is dependent on will of Allah. Allah is not depend or bound by laws of nature but laws are dependent on Him. Do you agree? If not then which part of my explanation do you disagree with?
@@Osama-Anwar Nature, Its the nature which is bound by the laws of physics etc. And Allah do not interfer in these laws except for miracles. And Prophet (PBUH) is the last of all the prophets. So no more prophets means no more miracles. Scientest have been studying the nature and so far nothing has gone against the natura's laws.
100% Agreed with your rational and islamic approach. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen!!! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!!
@@moawiztaimur I don't know what translation she was using but that seems to be a very misleading translation. Plz just read the English translation of incoherence of the philosophers. Most of the points raised in the video would be cleared up as I believe there's huge misinterpretation happening here due to either bad translation or her not understanding Urdu philosophical language (I don't know how that goes, but I reckon it to be different from normal Urdu since most English used in philosophy is also in ways different from standard understanding of the same words)
@@aashirali2172 Al-Ghazali on Occasionalism is a philosophical doctrine that attributes all causal power to God. According to occasionalism, created substances cannot be efficient causes of events. Instead, God is the only true cause, and what we perceive as causes and effects in the world are merely occasions for God to exert His will. Al-Ghazali was a strong proponent of occasionalism. He argued that natural causes and effects do not have intrinsic causal powers. Instead, every event that occurs in the world is directly caused by God. For instance, fire does not burn cotton because of some inherent power in the fire, but because God wills the burning to occur whenever fire and cotton come into contact. Furthermore, Al-Ghazali's occasionalism is rooted in his theological views that emphasize God's omnipotence and continuous involvement in the world. He believed that attributing causal power to created things undermines the doctrine of God’s absolute sovereignty and omnipotence.
@@Marym-Zafarthat sense of intellect you have, creating opinion without listening both side🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱 ## gang of ilmi kitabi(don't even know Arabic literature)
Miss Uzma you said nothing wondering can happen after prophets. what's your take on karamat of non anbia mentioned in Quran like takhe bilqees. And what about karamat of Sahaba mentioned in Bukhari Muslim.
جی نہیں، پہلے عظمہ ٹھیک لکھو، پھر غزالی بھی سمجھ آئے گا۔ ، قیصر راجہ صاحب نے جو بھی اعتراض اٹھائے، اس میں سے عظمیٰ صاحبہ نے صرف دو چیزوں کو ٹچ کیا ھے،اور وہ بھی عظمیٰ صاحبہ جو سمجھ رھی اور جو سوچ رہی ھیں۔ ضروری نہیں کہ وہ حرف آخر ھے۔ اور قیصر صاحب نے عظمیٰ صاحبہ کو جھوٹا نہیں کہا ۔ عظمیٰ صاحبہ تو یہ بھی نہیں سمجھ رہی ھیں۔ تو باقی ان کا جواب آنے کا انتظار کریں۔ قیصر راجہ صاحب کی باتیں عظمیٰ صاحبہ کے کچھ پلے نہیں پڑیں۔😊
@@Qaisrani922 The problem is not about the facts, but Mr qaiser always go with the populous narrative that people want to hear. He knows that his audience isn't good at fact-checking. So he just interpretes the facts with his own way, and make jalebis. People think he is the only one who attack the progressives. So he earns money.
@@Qaisrani922 جی بلکل یہی حقیقت ہے ، اگر ایسا نہ ہوتا تو خدا نے گناہ نہ کرنے کی تنبیہ کیوں کی؟ جب سب کچھ گھڑی کی طرح ہے تو ہدایت اور گمراہی کا راستے پر انسان کا اختیار کیسے؟ اللہ نے فزکس کے قوانین بنائے اور کائنات انکے بلبوتے پر چل رہی ہے میرے بھائی ۔ اور انھی فزکس کے قوانین کی بدولت آپ اس سائنسی دنیا میں رہ رہے ہو۔
@@FaisalQureshiofficial2اور قرآن جو کہ رہا وہ؟ کہ اللہ کی شان یہ ھے کہ ہر وقت کام میں مصروف رہتا ھے؟ اس کے بغیر، کوئی پتہ نہیں گرتا، نہ کوئی دانہ پھوٹتا، قرآن پڑھو بھائی ۔
@@minha_sheikh107 Syed Muzamil has very good knowledge. But he is not familiar with the ups and downs of Islamic knowledge. As he prefers the words of non-Muslim philosophers, he seems to be unfamiliar with Islamic literature. It will be much better if he learns Islamic literature instead of his own opinion.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc No bro, no one gives their opinion. Islamic scholars used to spend their lives telling the Qur'an and the Sunnah, whatever the meaning is hidden in the depths, and which is consistent with the Qur'an and the Hadith.
That wonderful and clear argument.....great Uzma Sahiba......I am waiting for further such kind of videos. this man (Qsar sab) misguides the mind very cleverly and beautifully... really you are a blessing for a young rationalist mind.
Dear Ms. Uzma, I wanted to provide constructive feedback on your recent presentation. It seems your rebuttals were biased towards Islam, citing sources that lack academic credibility ( 😂😂hoodboy😂mistary mirza😂 taimur laala😂😂 come onnnnn.... ). It's crucial to avoid allowing pseudo-appreciation to steer your work towards entertainment. Instead, strive for a neutral stance in your research to maintain professionalism and credibility. This approach will ensure your presentations are taken seriously and contribute meaningfully to your field. Best regards, IQBAL ka tarana baangh e dara hai goya Hota hai ja wa paiman phir qaarwan hamara
First few minutes of this video really shocking. How can ghazali call "LA ILAHA IL'LAL'LAAH" as kalma of common people and bring his new kalma instead? How dare he change it?
He is Talking about Tauheed .. not changing the Kalimah .. Read Surah Hashr .. last ayah .. HuAllah ulLazi .. Its very common most of the Imam recite in Namaz ..
@UzmaRumi Qaiser Raja ne aap ki video ka response bohat respectful way main kia hai. Aap jo clips cut kr k lga rahi hain wo QAR ne Engineer Mirza ko respond kia hai. Is liay kindly mix-up na karein.
@@shoebkhann307 would've sent but unfortunately UA-cam comments main koi bug hai. Links send nhi ho rhy. Plz aap Qaisar raja ke official channel pe jaa ke video check Kar Len. It's quite recent
Hello Miss.... I have written this for you after spending substantial amount of time kindly have a read.... Let me break it down for you miss, irrespective of what Qaiser Ahmed Raja said, the contention of Imam Ghazali for which he(ghazali) gave the example of cotton and fire was as follows, to understand that lets go beyond the cotton and fire's knowledge available at his time, the chemical reactions occur in nature due to certain fundamental tendencies of the atoms and energy, like when cotton touch the fire the that initiate a process of equalibrium in atom where it tent to have electrons in proportion that stables it, and when the atoms get stable at the given system, the reaction stops and the cotton become ashe, ghazali contended that these tendencies of atom are not necessities and can be in any other way but they are not, because God allowed them in that manner. He said "they call it a necessity because they have no proof beyond observation." The problem is when he says "it's not because of fire but by will of God" you reckon he denied the relationship between cotton and fire, but in reality he defined the relation, that it happens not because of necessity, It can happen in any other way but God allowed to be as it happens before our eyes. Now coming back to what Qaiser ahmed Raja said "ghazali ne essa kabhi nhi kaha ki rui nhi jalegi" he was referring to views of ghazali on general conduct of fire on cotton, and that doesn't negate his initial position that fire won't "necessarily" burn cotton if come in contact. Miss you showed the video in the thumbnail is different then you reacted. In fact the video you showed in thumbnail clarify problem you presented. The video uploaded by QAR on the response to your video was "Defending Ghazali | A Response to @uzmarumi256" on 27 April 2024, he never called you "Desi secular" or "don't get into contingency argument", you reacted different video, he was very respectful to you.... Hopefully you came this far..... Now the video he created in you response, he said in that video at 3:25 "Ghazali is not deny causality rather provided a framework for it, for its true nature.....neither fire decides that it will burn not cotton decided that it will get brunt, then these are contingent things and there is something other nessecery existence that give base to this causation." Thank you
Bht khoob sir may khud yehi dekh raha hon Kay log kitnay jahil Hain Jo in madam ki baton ko sun kar sensible samajh rahay hain , ye bechari to sedhi saadhi kitab ko nahi samajh sakteen jab tak koi inhay na samjhai , ye philosophical or mistical sence ko Kahan samjhain geen
Inho nay ghazali ki kitab ki bas translation parh li sidhi sidhi Jo line samajh aai out of context chaap di ,😂 aur sir ko samjha raheen Hain , galti maan nahi raheen
Your words are really engraved on my mind. I heard Qaiser bhai also, but your way of speaking is too good, and this video really cleared my arguments Waiting for the next part......❤
Engineer sahab aapa ka to samajh me aata hai magar aap inn aayaton ko kaise bhul gaye?? الله الصمد Har cheez absolutely Allah per har lamha dependent hai apne existence ke liye.. fir ye physical laws Allah se independent kaise kaam kar sakte hai??? لله الامر من قبل ومن بعد Allah hi ka akele command/hukm/faisla/decree hai (har cheez) se qabl bhi aur (har cheez) ke ba'ad bhi... Matlab kis cause ke baad kya effect niklega aur jo effect nikla hai uska cause kya hoga... "الا له الخلق و الأمر" "كل يوم هوا في شأن" Aur kaise bhool gaye ki Jo kuch dunya me aur universe me ho rha hai Allah uski nisbat apni taraf kart hai wo bhi fa'il ki haisiyat se jaise "يقلب الله الليل و النهار" "انزل من السماء ماء" "يولج اليل في النهار.." "و جعل الشمس سراجا" "لنخرج به حبا و نباتا" Wagaira wagaira aur bhi beshumar aayaat hai.. Sabhi aayaton me Allah فعل ke sath khudko فاعل bata rha hai.. fir aap seculars ki tarah ye mante ho ki Allah ne universe aur uske laws to create kar diye machine ki tarah magar ye unverse Allah ki mansha ke mutabik khud hi chal rha hai jaise koi machine engineer ki mansha ke mutabik chalti hai matlab "فاعل" wo machine khud hui.. Kya ye aqeedah Qur'an aur sunnat ke khilaf nhi hai???
Bahot he kamaal ki video hai. Lakinn thumbnail itna eye catchy nahe hai. Qaiser raja ka muhn bra kar k lgana chahiya tha jistarah wo views kalia sabhka face lgata ha thumbnail pay😂😂😂.. Urdu font bhe samjhna mushkil ha. Aggar aap kahain to main 3,4 thumbnails bna k apko fb per bhaij sakta hun. Jo pasand ho use kr lijiya ga..because you deserve millions of views.... ❤
Mr. Muhammad Engineer Ali Mirza (Front_Man of the Qadyanis) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! !
You have not given answer to main question yet, according to you after imam Ghazali the scientific temperament in the muslim world went down yet we see many Muslim scientists after Ghazali namely, Al Nafis, Al Tusi, Al Shatir, Ulugh Beg, Omar Khayyam (yes he worked on Algerba apart from poetry), Ibn Rushd, etc. How did they managed to work if Muslims developed an anti scientific mindset? Also, Al Ghazali's own view on science, “As for the praiseworthy disciplines such as medicine and mathematics, they are associated with worldly benefit. And that category is divided into those that become a communal obligation and those that are of great merit but are not an obligation" Kindly don't deviate from topic.
QAR's latest response titled " Sister Uzma Rumi is Arguably The best Ghazalian Yet". He schooled her again academically, great job QAR. I'm afraid his response will suspend the rest of the parts of her argument.😊
Video k start may ap nay kaha k Mazhab meri domain nehi aur minay Gazali ki science pr aitraz kia aur Qaiser raja nay Gazali ki science pr reply kia.Phit ap Qazali k sufi thoughts pr tankeed krnay chal pari.What the hell is that?QAR pehlay hi keh chukay hai k Gazali k sufi thoughts pr ap nay tankeed krni hai to krain lakin us ko bunyad bana k ap Gazali ki Science ko galat nehi keh saktay.
Front man of molvis is better than front man of anti islamisms and iron dom hafiza......... mirza sahib kisi or hi trf chal pry hain ... unsubscribed him
So How Imam gazali thought can ruined the Islamic golden age and you didn't counter any Arguments related to fall of Golden age. And I'm not able to understand why so called liberal didn't able to understand that In the case of Cotton and fire, Fire didn't burn Cotton if ALLAH didn't allow. This is hypothetical situation which can explain the power of Almighty, that ALLAH have power to intervene in this world. If god didn't able to intervene so He is not GOD. Because God have absolute power. This is very simple, And Can you explain how this thought become reason of Islamic golden age fall.Why you didn't counter any Qaiser Sahab Fall of golden age Arguments. I'm waiting for your Prompt response.
Bhai kya hogya ha. Apna dimaag use kro jb logo ko ye btao gy ye universe bghair kisi law k chal rahi ha to kon science pe focus kry ga asan rasta to ye bun gya k sufi ho jao to universe tumharay qdmon me hogi. To is trah logo ne science ko dekhny or universe k laws ko smajhnay ki bjaye sirf Allah ho krny me lag gye. Or science k ilm ko kafir ka ilm smaj liya is trah Islamic golden age tbah hoa ye clear cut ha is video me or pichli video me bhi. Is sy koi Muslim inkar nahi kr raha ha k universe Allah Almighty ne create ki ha. Problem ye ha sufi is baat ko man'nay k liye tayyar nahi k Allah Almighty ne is universe ko scientific laws k mutabiq bnaya ha or chala raha ha. In laws ko sirf Prophets k liye Allah ne tora isi ko occasionalism kehty. is baat ko sufi nahi man'tay wo kehty hain k ye kisi bhi insaan k liye hoskta ha jb aesa nahi ha. Ye sirf Prophets k liye ha
You need explanation?, ok! See, when Ghazali's thoughts were reinforced, people stopped researching and critical thinking, free thoughts became blasphemy and that ultimately lead to downfall of Muslims in Arab and Persia. Free inquiry is the key to scientific development. Where there will be a religious suppression there will be a recession in scientific achievements.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc oh really After the death of Imam Gazali there is 8 biggest research laboratory build in Islamic empires, and at that time Many Sultan fund research institutes and laboratories. This is very chep understanding that one person who collapse entire golden age and at that time whare different sect of islam didn't agree on same Arguments and this man come and all muslim say we are now follow this person we build observatries for fun we build monument without the help of science we translate geek philosophical book we build world largest astronomy observatries but we stop thinking, this is funny. This type of Arguments that imam gazali collapse Science and thinking come from empty mind that type of people who is not aware about Islamic history.
@@uuy5865 Nah bro! that is not what I have said. Whatever Ghazali wrote had a significant impact over the minds of the people of that time and it slowly but surely damaged the scientific fabric of society and later on ofcourse many religious personality came and contributed in the destruction. I would agree that some khalifa was open minded & they invested heavily in science and technology but their thoughts, beliefs overshadowed by the belief of those who were against all these progress.
Uzma Rumi, hats 📴 to your immensely logically impressive videos full of info and knowledge. As far as QR's illogicality is concerned, it's certain, he's to lose on every ground untill and unless he embraces the TRUTH AND REALITY.
IMTAHANI GUIDES KA FALSAFA: Mohtarma nay na-janay kis Kabaryea kay thailay say koi guide pakar kay ret li hay, aur fart-e-jazbat main musalsal broken record ki terah bej rahi hain: occasionalism, causality, kherq-e-adet,... Ghazali nay kia ghalet kaha? Kia Mohtarma nay ankhain khaul kay is dunya ka mushahida nahin kia? Natural laws say het ker, Khuda kis qanoon kay tehat insan ki infaradi aur masherti zindagi - and more importantly, human history - chala raha hay? Western philosophy ka bhi yea aik fundamental asool hay, kay God works through history! Kia koi sahib-e-fehm-o-faraset yea keh sekta hay, kay yahan koi rationalism kar-ferma hay? Nahin, aur her ehl-e-danish yea kehnay per majboor ho ga, kay ik kaynati Toofan-e-bed-tameezi hay, kay thamnay ka nam nahin lay raha. Khuda nay her makhlooq ko apnay panja-e-istabdad main jakra huwa hay, yani THERE IS NO FREE WILL, jaisa kay Qur'an khud bhi batata hay: "And there is not a beast in the earth but the sustenance thereof dependeth on Allah. He knoweth its habitation and its repository. All is in a clear record." [Hud 11:6, Tr.: Pickthall] "Lo! I have put my trust in Allah, my Lord and your Lord. Not an animal but He doth grasp it by the forelock! Lo! my Lord is on a straight path." [Hud 11:56, Tr.: Pickthall] So, this God is holding every creature by its forelock (the part of the brain responsible for thinking/reasoning, social cognition, and executive functions), and with that our perception, reasoning and decisions, so HOW CAN THERE BE ANY FREE WILL? Islam kay SINGLE AUR LINEAR LIFE MODEL kay tehat to Khudai rationalism dhoondna abes hay, han Hindu philosophy, yani THEORY OF REINCARNATION, kay tehat aisa koi karmic rationalism divine kia ja sekta hay, laikin aisa kertay huway Islam ko aik jali deen bhi man-na paray ga. Kia Mohtarma is 'mathematical' truth ka samna kernay ko tayyar hain?
Well I didn’t understand are you trying to say that Allah created all things with certain laws and now Allah is not interfering?? He created world and left over ???
That's what they are trying to inject, still claiming themselves to be muslim. According to them, Allah is sleeping after creating the universe صوفیا کے کندھے پر بندوق رکھ کر نشانہ قرآنی عقائد کو بنا رہی ہے
She just made Statements and did not gave proof.Wohi wala kaam kia hai "Rana nay jo keh dita keh dita" By the way Contingency Argument Ibn Sina nay frame kia tha pahlay.
@@Abu-hasnain nabuwat khatam ho gai uss ki nishaniya khatam hogai ab sirf hain mubashrat yani k sachy khawab. Jab nabowat he khatam ho gai to pher nashani kes baat ki.
شاباش ! اتنی اچھی باتیں سننے کو ہماری سوسائٹی ترس گئی ہے ۔ کسی فرد واحد کے ہر اعتراض کا جواب دینا مستحسن نہیں ۔ اچھے کھلاڑی ہر بال نہیں کھیلتے ۔ لوگوں کے اعتراضات سے گریز کر کے بلکہ بلند و برتر ہوکر موضوعات و مسائل کو زیر بحث لائیں تو افادیت بڑھ جائے گی ۔ سلامت باشید !
You are doing an excellent work. Criminally underrated. Been a subscriber for a while and your content doesn’t disappoint; always well researched. As far as Caner Raja is concerned, he is just that, cancer.
Mr. Qaiser Raja (Front_Man of Molvis) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! !
Bhai aap rehne do.. 😂😂
This appreciation from my religious guide. Awesome feel !!
Ali Bhai , Qaiser Raja is a clown and a joker whose duty is to save his FIRQA and nothing else. So , Please Keep exposing Qaiser Raja and Tariq Masood and please DON'T stop because they will also NOT stop . Their agenda is that of Hitler's Goebbels and that is lie loudly and lie as many times and as many places as possible to convert lie into truth.
Oyyy mirza kuch to khuda ka khuf karo nafrat main iman se hath do betoge ek din ap ko to main sunta bhi nahi aj kal😢 qaiser raja zindabad❤❤
Awesome Uzma ❤ u have done owned him once again, demolished him, period !
دنیا میں ہر دور میں کچھ نہ کچھ افراد انتے گندے ھوتے ہیں ان کا کام صرف اور صرف اہل حق اور مقبول شخصیات کے عیوب کے ٹوھ میں ھوتے ہیں لیکن اللہ تعالیٰ نے اپنے محبت کے پیاسوں کو ان کے فیوض سے مالا مال کیا اور وہ دن بہ دن اللہ تعالی کی معارفت میں ترقی کرتے رہتے ہیں جو کہ ابدی زندگی میں کام آنے والی سب سے افضل چیز ہے
ان اھل حق میں سے ایک موجودہ دور میں سے قیصر احمد راجا صاحب بھی ہیں جو بھی دل کے کانوں کو کھول کر صرف ایک بار اس کو سنتا ہے اسے حق ضرور سمجھ میں آتی ہے
اور مفتی ندیم الواجدی صاحب بھی ہیں
اور ابھی تو ڈاکٹر ذاکر نائیک نے واضح کردیا۔
Thanks for the effort. Great work , MashaAllah. Keep it up.
This is a difficult subject and lot of people get tangled. Great job in explaining
Maza aya.... Quality debunking lecture
Behen maine aapki video suni aur durst lagi thi lekin Qaiser sahab ka response dekh kar laga aap ko Ghazali samjhne mein ghalti hogayi. Mazrat bura mat maniyega. ALLAH SWT SAB KO DURST CHEEZ SAMJHNE KI TOUFEEQ DEIN AMEEN ❤
اس لو انجنئر پمپ کر رہا ہے وہ خود روز ذلیل ہوتا ہے راجہ صاحب سے اب اس کو ذلیل کروا رہا ہے
Ap on ka jwab tu sunein wo jhoot bol raha ha
@@Thinkoutsidethebox1840 Kon juth bol rha ha
@@Thinkoutsidethebox1840جھوٹ کوئی بھی نہیں بول رہا ۔ اپنی اپنی سمجھ کی بات ہے ۔ قیصر احمد راجہ کی تشریح درست ہے ۔
لیکن بد بخت مرزا کو یہاں دیکھ کر میرا تو ایمان تازہ ہوگیا الحمداللہ
Al-Ghazali basically tried to criticize the philosophers of his time, especially those influenced by Greek philosophy, such as Avicenna (Ibn Sina) and Al-Farabi. He argued that their views contradicted Islamic teachings and undermined religious faith.But it is important to recognize that the decline in scientific research was due to a combination of factors, including political instability, economic challenges, and changing cultural priorities.Scientific activity did not cease immediately after Al-Ghazali. Scholars like Ibn Rushd (Averroes) continued to engage in philosophical and scientific pursuits. So, Al-Ghazali's views on occasionalism and his critique of philosophy did shift the intellectual focus towards theology and mysticism, it is overly simplistic to say that they alone caused the decline of scientific inquiry in the Islamic world.
P.S. You saying 'In Shaa Allah' at the end of the video is actually promoting Ghazali's occasionalism. Because if you are so sure about yourself and firm on your view of causality, why then depend upon Allah’s intervention???
👏👏👏👌👌👌💯💯💯
@@ssabbassi888 Yeh jahil lady khud keh rahi hay k Mazhab k baray mai isko kuch khas pata nahi hay phir bhi Hujjat ul Islam Imam Ghazali k baary may Apni Jahilana Approach say baat kar rahi hay .
In jahilon ko lagta hay koi Task diya gaya hay jiski funding kahin or say ho rahi hay k Islam k baray mai Shak paidah karo ..
Brother, no one says that Allah does not hold power to intervene(Naoozbillah) but we dont believe that Allah intervenes for everyone like Sufi's do and nor do we have the power to invoke it directly or indirectly. Also even if you believe that 2nd contingency is responsible for everything in our lives that we can observe does not mean that its totally random or without Allah's design. Well I can give two potential reasons that would justify it.
1) First impact or seed value (if you're familiar with programming, you would know what is a seed value in randomness). We humans can stack dominos and cause a chain reaction which is controlled. But if we try it with billiard balls, it goes out of our control, we might be able to predict and control one or two balls but we wont be able to control every ball, but with computers you can predict every ball by simulating the limited number of balls. Next to go above it, if even computers try to simulate everything e.g. air, water, solid objects etc, even they cant and lack computing power. Now, we know Allah is all powerful, if we expand the same logic of action and reaction chains to every single atom in the universe and for the period of start of the universe till end of the universe. Now, would any Muslim disagree with me when I say that Allah is capable of starting this universe by saying Kun-faya-kun and later everything happened in a chain of events based on what he wanted it controlled as. This means if Allah wanted to make life through evolution he can, this also means if we say Inshallah then it is possible that Allah created us to say that and whether something happens or not is still his choice even if he does not immediately intervene.
2) Compatibilism as compared to both free will or determinism. There is another important philosophical debate that if Allah knows exactly what we will do and created us as such(determinism), then what sense does it make that he will judge us and put us in hell fire for our actions since we were made to do it? On the other hand if we have absolute free will, then (Naoozbillah) does Allah not know what we will do, and so it means we have free will and we will be responsible for our actions and rightly be judged? I havent seen any molvi give a slightly decent answer to this. The answer to this seems to be Compatibilism, a mixture of both free will and determinism. Physics even supports it, if you read up quantum super position or Schrodinger's cat thought experiment, you would understand that our interaction(or in physics term, observation) with the universe makes sub-atomic particles fall into a state(the equation about either knowing a particle's momentum or knowing its position, cant know both), we're basically setting reality into a state by interacting with it. This has lead scientists hypothesize a theory of infinite universes, where we are in a reality one for every state was possible to achieve for every sub atomic particle at every time. So if Allah has created our reality such so that we are able to influence it like that and with our actions choose which reality we move on to, then that means we are given free will in a deterministic universe. And if we can choose which path to take from our actions, then surely Allah is infinitely more times capable than us to command every things on how their subatomic particles should collapse and how reality should turn out and still keep everything under cause and effect. So saying Inshallah and then if Allah wills it to happen, it will not take away from 2nd contingency since the action still happened in a deterministic reality.
Anyway i dont claim that these two potential reasons are completely correct or absolute truth, Allah knows best and i might be partially wrong about some of it or completely wrong, but to me for now, they answer a lot of question about reality that is otherwise unanswered, specially by the molvi tabqa. Allah knows best, may he guide us.
درست
Bro she cannot handle this, this is too much for her, people say that Pakistan is bankrupt but in reality people here are intellectually bankrupt like this lady here 😂😂
Beautifully rebutted
Qasir Raja proved himself to be an Andbakt, without rationale and logic
@@Eesa029 she didn't answer any points. She just raised new ones. this isn't even a rebuttal but I guess believe whatever suits your worldview
lol dumb guy, state what has she rebuted?
After discussing with my brother Qaiser Ahmad Raja
Have a debate with Kaisar Ahmad Raja
I just discovered your channel- I like your work.
Knowledge ❌ hate speech ✅
Voluntary ignorance spotted
@@Photon-1927thank you for your response about video
No, it's actually a Bollywood movie where you stand in front of a bullet, fired on someone else, in a dramatic manner and then cry, victim. He made that video in that language for Engineer sahab not for her, the video made for her was different and she didn't respond to it, funny part is she showed that video's thumbnail in her thumbnail, that means she was aware of that video.
Lums ki pajeet
@@Azhar2612 seems you are fan of raja (former taxi driver). Good for you
Uzma ji aapko mera Salaam Bharat sey.
You are warming up the MINDS frozen in time.
Hoping million subscribers for you very soon. Keep making such an amazing content
Thanks God I hav found at least one person who really loves and has the courage and method to express the truth.
اللہ آپ کو دور حاضر کی جہالت کے شر سے محفوظ رکھے. آمین
Qaiser Raja ka reply dekhiye fir decide kijiye
It's very enlightening. Keep the good work up. Thank you
Thank Allah (swt) We have more people doing research and speaking the truth and sister you one of them. Keep up the good work.
Nangy sar badan bi saaf nazar Aa raha ap bi apni sister jaisi hun gi phir
@@babuarslan This is a modern era you stupid. Look around your own family you will find so many sister like her.
I m very surprised to listen u keep carry on very great confidence lovely speaking power God bless you
Waiting for Qaiser bhai response ❤
Aagaya
😂😂😂@@Shams_Tabrezii
Very good video. I appreciate you Miss Uzma Rumi. May Allah guide all of us to the right path.
MashaAllah !!! Tabahi pher dii meri behn !!! JazakAllah ....Allah paak iss Raja ko Hidayt Dey Ameeeeen
Yar ab ap ni ke rhe is ko perda kerna chahye laila baji ke bar to aik he rat lgai hote he ap ne
Apni bar nazrya change hoja ta he ap ka
@@waqaskhan-jr7gx tum apna kaam karo
Woh karlegi parda
@@sanyaakurd-bd9wg syeda laila ki bar ap ku chelate ho is se to behter he wo
دعوت گئی بھاڑ میں
آپ لوگ یہاں اپنا لچ فرائی کرو
کوئی شرم ہوتی ہے
کوئی حیا ہوتی ہے
I am deeply impressed ma'am. More power and best wishes.
Well Needed CLIP. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! Keep on preaching ISLAM without any Secularism & Mangolism. May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!! My Salute for all the ULAMA Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! ! ❤️🤭
wah wah wah. Maza aa gya. Keep it up brave lady. Thankyou.
Ay aqal ky andey
Alhamdullilah Qaiser Ahmed Raja bahi nay barayy zabardasttt jawabaat diyee hain aap kay eik eik point ka. He debunked each and every point that you have raised in this video and the previous one. 😂😂❤❤😊 ap dono ke ilmii behas sun akr kafee kuch seekhnay ko milta hai and maza bhee ata hai sunnay mai. Leep it up guys. 👍 May Allah give more strength and courage to Qaiser Ahmed Raja bahi so that he keeps exposing desi khooni liberalalists and leftists just like that. 🙌🙌❤
lmao ..
dimwitted retard spotted
We are getting benefitted in terms of knowledge because of the exchange of dialogue between You and Qaisar Ahmad Raja
Wao ,what a intellectual level... really impressed 👍..one new subscriber
I love this debate coming from both sides. But please, both sides need to be respectful and not hate others.
Great Comment
impossible bcz of conjervatives hate towards rationalists. Cancer Raja ko uski zaban main samjha chaiye jo wo samjhta hai
Qaiser can't remain respectful he is fitratan badtameez
Qaisar jahil should mind only Mullah affairs and propaganda videos. 😂😂😂
Qaiser raja destroyed your references in his response...
video time
8:01 to 11:00
السلام علیکم، بہن سب سے پہلے تو آپ کا شکریہ کہ زیادہ دیر نہیں لگائی پچھلی ویڈیو کے بعد یہ ویڈیو بنانے میں، ویسے معذرت کے ساتھ عرض ہے کہ اس ویڈیو کے بعد امام غزالی عالمِ ارواح میں قیصر احمد راجہ پر لعنتیں بھیج رہے ہوں گے 🙏😂، جزاک اللہ خیرا
Sir setting main ja k subtitles off kr dain ...its simple. Video k neecha jo setting button hota ha wahan sa
واہ کیا علم غیب ہے😮
Shame on You. U r being called an engineer waaah Kia bat hei... Ignorant Dark face you r
G o mirzay k gandoo😂😂
Apnay Mirzay ko bahir nikal bill sy mufti Tariq Masood intizaar kar Rahay hai 😂
Dear Madam, your style is very impressive, your voice is very vibrant. You have shattered the image of Qaiser Ahmed Raja. 👍👍👍👍
🤣🤣🤣
if You Have Any Question About Islam VS atheism & other Religion You Can Ask Questions By Joining The Live Stream 👇👇👇
Mufti Yasir Nadeem Al Wajdi
youtube.com/@YasirNadeemalWajidi
LIVE ON EVERY SATURDAY/SUNDAY :-
INDIA TIME 9:30 pM
Aamir Haq
youtube.com/@AwazEHaqUncensored
LIVE ON EVERY WEDNESDAY & FRIDAY:-
INDIA TIME 9:30PM
Aasim Iftekhar
youtube.com/@AasimIftekhar
LIVE ON India Time 9:30PM
QAISAR AHMED RAJA
youtube.com/@QaiserAhmedRaja
LIVE ON Every Saturday :-
INDIA TIME 9:30PM
ISLAMIC AWAKENING
youtube.com/@IslamicAwakening
LIVE ON EVERYDAY:-
INDIA TIME 9:30PM
#gang of ilmi kitabi, run like rat hide
مس عظمی رومی فلسفے کو سمجھنے کے لیے غالب کمال کے یوٹیوب چینل پر تشریف لاین وہان قیصر احمد راجہ,ساحل عدیم,یاسر ندیم واجدی,غامدی جیسے سارے مذہبی چورن بیچنے والون کو عقلی و منطقی بنیادون پر دیا جاتا ہے
Great work Uzma.... Presented your points and arguments very well... I don't know how Raja is going to counter this
Qaiser belongs to same mentality who doesn't know what are they doing. Good work Rumi.
Aah librandu😂
I think both sides know what they are doing
@@theenigma4234 ua-cam.com/video/tOjT52JIPzw/v-deo.htmlsi=sH1AWDTv4gryzwBh
Tumhre ami ko jawab de dia
Tu kafir hai kya
The way you explained with the references was amazing 👏
You cooked Mr Dutch intellect.😂. ❤
😂😅😅😅
So creative bro ❤❤❤
Ruko zara sabar karo
Bro. This is the first time I've ever heard this as a criticism of Al Ghazali. I don't know why this translation is the way it is but plz read the English translation. Al Ghazali doesn't say that the most merciful (Ar-rahman ) and the king (maalik) are eparate entities from God. What he actually says is they are attributes of God that are distinct from each other. His knowledge is not his hearing, his hearing is not his sight/seeing, his kingship is not his mercy, his mercy is not his wrath etc. I don't know why she presented it as if he's saying they're all different entities implying different Gods...
Go and see how Mr Dutch recooked within few days the video which took mis Uzma one month to prepare. She should bang her head elsewhere.
Glad to see such an enlightened and rational student of reason and philosophy ❤ keep it up 👍
Apka andaz bht bahtreen aur shandar ha halaky Qaiser Raja aysa style deserve nhe krta wo usi style main jawab deserve krta js main is jysy log dyty han.... Meri request hugi ap sy ky second part main is Netherland ky motivational speaker ko batahe ky Ghazali pr sb sy phly yh rad Ibn Rushd ny kya tha naky Renan ny...
Imam Ghazali k tum loag paon k dhool k braber b nai ho. Jitni us nay books likhi hayn utni tumhari umar nai hogi. Besharmi ikhtalaf ka ye matlb nai hay k kisi insan ki har achi khoobi ka bhi inkaar kr do.
@@AbdullahJaved-kw8dl Ghazali pr mainy kuch nhe kaha apny comment main... Mainy srf Netherland ky fraud QAR code par bat ki ha.... Ghussa Q arha ha itna🤣🤣🤣.... Kahe aysa tu nhe Qaiser Fraudi ky chamchy ko ap😁😁....
@@AbdullahJaved-kw8dl😂😂😂😂😂 chutiya tha tera gazali, burbad karkya rakha hai usne Muslims KO
IMAN KAY DARJAT AUR MUTA'LIQA KALIMAT: Anbya aur deegar bari hastyon say het ker am insanon kay hawalay say bat ki jay, to Ghazali nay theek kaha aur yea hi ehl-e-tasawuf ka kulya hay. Imani lehaz say bunyadi darjat kuch yea hain:
Pashu ka iman: La Ilaha Ilellah.
Ashiq-e-Ilahi ka iman: La-Maqsood Ilellah.
Fana fil-Lah ka iman: La Mojud Ilellah.
Ghazali imani aur spiritual experience kay lehaz say bohet buland darjay per faez thay, lehaza unhain kisi Pashu kay imani koozay main bend kernay ki saee la-hasil hay. In imani kaifyat ko yea maya kay jal main uljhay dunya-parest secular log, jo imani, spiritual, intellectual and above all consciousness kay lehaz say Pashu hain, bhala kaisay samajh sektay hain?
Aur yaha bat Fik ki nahi science ki hai Espar Ap Qaisar Ahmad raja Sahab se Live Discussion kare Please Mam😅😅
Live debate karenge to qaiser Ahmed Raza sirf point ko divert karega. Aur uske blind followers usiko defend karenge kyuki unhone kabhi jargons nahi sune
Kia hi explanation he maza agia, You are hidden Start of Pakistan ❤
What are the credentials of Qaiser Ahmad Raja?He is not a public intellectual and/or an accredited research scholar of any repute.Why is he wasting precious time of the general populace and under what Authority.
He was taxi driver in uk , ask him
یہ سوال تو پہلے آپ کو عظمیٰ رومی صاحبہ سے نہیں پوچھنا چاہیے؟
@@Mutahhar just for record , qaisar raja was taxi driver . Got deported and now become revivalist
@@Photon-1927what is your point exactly? A taxi driver can not talk but a engineer and this lady can?
What are the credentials of his opponents?
Pakistan me b itni intelligent female h yakeen nai hota.... Keep it on mem❤... Thank you
Aap indian muslim ho?
Abay Sadah-loh, yea imtahani guides ka retta hay.
I watched Mr Qaiser raja video and your too.
He responded in a very polite way while miss Uzma really doesn't know how to respond a person with a opposite perspective in a good way..... she is so rude
She is rebuttaling really well with her references that's why there is passion.
@@abdulhafeez-ob3vurebuttal ? 😂
Molvio ke tatto ko kuch jayada hi izzat chayea 😂
Acha or polite hain to apny Ghar ley k jao
Great video, this is how we break down false ideas, by real study and references. You have earned a sub
محترمہ لگتا آپ نے ٹھیک طریقے سے نہیں پڑھا۔جملے میں بھی (ALSO) کا استعمال ہوا ہے۔
جس کا مطلب ہے کہ روئ کا جلنا بھی ممکن ہے اور نہ بھی۔
جو کچھ بھی ہو گا اللہ پاک کے حکم سے ہوگا۔
قیصر صاحب نے آپ کو یہی سمجھایا تھا۔ کسی اردو زبان کے ماہر سے اپنی اصلاح ضرور کروائیں۔
تو ٹھیک ہے نا، محترمہ بھی یہی کہ رہی ہیں۔ کہ غزالی کے مطابق جو کچھ بھی ہو گا اللہ پاک کے حکم سے ہوگا نا کہ کسی قانون (فزکس، کمسٹری وغیرہ) کے۔ لہٰذا آگ دکھانے پر کبھی روئی جلے گی کبھی نہیں اور کبھی بغیر آگ کے بھی جلے گی۔
جبکہ سائنسدانوں کے مطابق جو کچھ بھی ہوگا اللہ کے بنائے ہوئے قوانین (فزکس، کمسٹری وغیرہ) کے مطابق ہوگا۔ تو آگ دکھانے پر روِئی ((لازماً)) جلے گی۔
اس میں کسی اردو زبان کے ماہر سے اپنی اصلاح کروانے کی کیا ضرورت ہے۔
@@sheralam920 So you are saying that Allah is bound by Physics Chemistry to run this universe?
@@sheralam920btw, the consistency in the natural phenomenon (i.e. physics, chemistry) is sunnat or adat of Allah. He is capable of changing the observable patterns in nature which is called miracle. So, either nature operates in normal way or it operates in unconventional way is dependent on will of Allah. Allah is not depend or bound by laws of nature but laws are dependent on Him. Do you agree? If not then which part of my explanation do you disagree with?
@@sheralam920I am assuming that you are Muslim and not some ex Muslim or atheist. Right?
@@Osama-Anwar Nature, Its the nature which is bound by the laws of physics etc. And Allah do not interfer in these laws except for miracles. And Prophet (PBUH) is the last of all the prophets. So no more prophets means no more miracles. Scientest have been studying the nature and so far nothing has gone against the natura's laws.
Who is greater religion or human being??
religion exists if human beings exist whereas the opposite is not true😊
100% Agreed with your rational and islamic approach. Ma-Shaa-ALLAH عزوجل ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen!!! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen!!!
Could you please provide reference for the writings of Imam Ghazali you referred in your video? Thanks
@@moawiztaimur I don't know what translation she was using but that seems to be a very misleading translation. Plz just read the English translation of incoherence of the philosophers. Most of the points raised in the video would be cleared up as I believe there's huge misinterpretation happening here due to either bad translation or her not understanding Urdu philosophical language (I don't know how that goes, but I reckon it to be different from normal Urdu since most English used in philosophy is also in ways different from standard understanding of the same words)
@@aashirali2172 Al-Ghazali on Occasionalism is a philosophical doctrine that attributes all causal power to God. According to occasionalism, created substances cannot be efficient causes of events. Instead, God is the only true cause, and what we perceive as causes and effects in the world are merely occasions for God to exert His will.
Al-Ghazali was a strong proponent of occasionalism. He argued that natural causes and effects do not have intrinsic causal powers. Instead, every event that occurs in the world is directly caused by God. For instance, fire does not burn cotton because of some inherent power in the fire, but because God wills the burning to occur whenever fire and cotton come into contact. Furthermore, Al-Ghazali's occasionalism is rooted in his theological views that emphasize God's omnipotence and continuous involvement in the world. He believed that attributing causal power to created things undermines the doctrine of God’s absolute sovereignty and omnipotence.
appreciation comment to Miss Uzma Rumi, the voice of the sane.
Good or Bad will be decided after contrary reply by anyone
@@albaengineering
whatever
@@Marym-Zafarthat sense of intellect you have, creating opinion without listening both side🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱
## gang of ilmi kitabi(don't even know Arabic literature)
@@zakku1232
whatever
Miss Uzma you said nothing wondering can happen after prophets. what's your take on karamat of non anbia mentioned in Quran like takhe bilqees. And what about karamat of Sahaba mentioned in Bukhari Muslim.
Sister is braindead
A well needed response ♥️♥️♥️
Yes by anyone not specifically QAR
Very nice explanation. There are many Qaisers around, and you don't need to respond them but just explain the truth.
Stay blessed!
اتنے علمی اور ادبی انداز میں قیصر راجے کو کسی نے پہلے دھویا ہو، نہیں دیکھا میں نے،😂😂😅😅😂 زبردست عظمیٰ
جی نہیں، پہلے عظمہ ٹھیک لکھو، پھر غزالی بھی سمجھ آئے گا۔ ، قیصر راجہ صاحب نے جو بھی اعتراض اٹھائے، اس میں سے عظمیٰ صاحبہ نے صرف دو چیزوں کو ٹچ کیا ھے،اور وہ بھی عظمیٰ صاحبہ جو سمجھ رھی اور جو سوچ رہی ھیں۔ ضروری نہیں کہ وہ حرف آخر ھے۔
اور قیصر صاحب نے عظمیٰ صاحبہ کو جھوٹا نہیں کہا ۔ عظمیٰ صاحبہ تو یہ بھی نہیں سمجھ رہی ھیں۔ تو باقی ان کا جواب آنے کا انتظار کریں۔ قیصر راجہ صاحب کی باتیں عظمیٰ صاحبہ کے کچھ پلے نہیں پڑیں۔😊
@@Qaisrani922 The problem is not about the facts, but Mr qaiser always go with the populous narrative that people want to hear. He knows that his audience isn't good at fact-checking. So he just interpretes the facts with his own way, and make jalebis. People think he is the only one who attack the progressives. So he earns money.
اور عظمیٰ صاحبہ یہ ثابت کرنا چا رہی ھیں کہ اللہ کائنات کو ڈائریکٹ نہیں چلا رہا۔ گھڑی کی طرح کائنات بنا دی اب وہ چلتی جا رہی؟ کیا تم۔مانتے ہو یہ سب؟
@@Qaisrani922 جی بلکل یہی حقیقت ہے ، اگر ایسا نہ ہوتا تو خدا نے گناہ نہ کرنے کی تنبیہ کیوں کی؟ جب سب کچھ گھڑی کی طرح ہے تو ہدایت اور گمراہی کا راستے پر انسان کا اختیار کیسے؟ اللہ نے فزکس کے قوانین بنائے اور کائنات انکے بلبوتے پر چل رہی ہے میرے بھائی ۔ اور انھی فزکس کے قوانین کی بدولت آپ اس سائنسی دنیا میں رہ رہے ہو۔
@@FaisalQureshiofficial2اور قرآن جو کہ رہا وہ؟ کہ اللہ کی شان یہ ھے کہ ہر وقت کام میں مصروف رہتا ھے؟
اس کے بغیر، کوئی پتہ نہیں گرتا، نہ کوئی دانہ پھوٹتا،
قرآن پڑھو بھائی ۔
Dear Uzma, would you please be kind to provide scholarly reference for your take on Ghazali?
She mentioned books.😅
Qaiser Ahmad Raja has invited to debate. why do you not come in front to front?
Bhira angreji ni andhi te apni zuban wich gal kr le
What a btfl channel i just subscribed ... Btfl content keep i lt up ❤
Mirza comments here is proof that , the damage has been done to mirza😂😂 Qaisar Raja is a legend.❤
You're right that's why everyone is discussing Ali Mirza. ❤
Syed Muzammil ❤🔥
@@minha_sheikh107 Syed Muzamil has very good knowledge. But he is not familiar with the ups and downs of Islamic knowledge. As he prefers the words of non-Muslim philosophers, he seems to be unfamiliar with Islamic literature. It will be much better if he learns Islamic literature instead of his own opinion.
@@Qaisrani922 Islamic literature is also someone's own opinion as well.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc No bro, no one gives their opinion. Islamic scholars used to spend their lives telling the Qur'an and the Sunnah, whatever the meaning is hidden in the depths, and which is consistent with the Qur'an and the Hadith.
That wonderful and clear argument.....great Uzma Sahiba......I am waiting for further such kind of videos. this man (Qsar sab) misguides the mind very cleverly and beautifully... really you are a blessing for a young rationalist mind.
Dear Ms. Uzma,
I wanted to provide constructive feedback on your recent presentation. It seems your rebuttals were biased towards Islam, citing sources that lack academic credibility ( 😂😂hoodboy😂mistary mirza😂 taimur laala😂😂 come onnnnn.... ).
It's crucial to avoid allowing pseudo-appreciation to steer your work towards entertainment. Instead, strive for a neutral stance in your research to maintain professionalism and credibility. This approach will ensure your presentations are taken seriously and contribute meaningfully to your field.
Best regards,
IQBAL ka tarana baangh e dara hai goya
Hota hai ja wa paiman phir qaarwan hamara
Great , mera bhut bara confusion khtum kia. Thank you
Secondary causality
Nice explanation Uzma
Because of associative eating, I find it very interesting. Please continue. The next video is a must-listen while I have dinner
First few minutes of this video really shocking. How can ghazali call "LA ILAHA IL'LAL'LAAH" as kalma of common people and bring his new kalma instead? How dare he change it?
I wonder how easy it is to manipulate people like you.why don't you yourself go and research on this .?.
No one can change it. Neither did he.
@@MS-HussainBhai video main refrence h ap khud parh lo ya research kr lo imam ghazali ne khud likha h
@@MS-HussainVideo ghor se dekho jaha refrence h note down karo or phr khud tasdeeq karo easy h
He is Talking about Tauheed .. not changing the Kalimah .. Read Surah Hashr .. last ayah .. HuAllah ulLazi .. Its very common most of the Imam recite in Namaz ..
It is still possible if we add something to cotton it will not burn.
@UzmaRumi
Qaiser Raja ne aap ki video ka response bohat respectful way main kia hai.
Aap jo clips cut kr k lga rahi hain wo QAR ne Engineer Mirza ko respond kia hai.
Is liay kindly mix-up na karein.
QAR ne apni video pr Uzma Rumi k barey main negative comments karney se bhi mana kia tha. How respectful is QAR and how ignorant you are 😮
@@huzaifashaheer724 wtf bro your qasir is lying and all proofs are in front of you but still you wont belive because you are a blind cult follower
Video send karo
@@shoebkhann307 would've sent but unfortunately UA-cam comments main koi bug hai. Links send nhi ho rhy. Plz aap Qaisar raja ke official channel pe jaa ke video check Kar Len. It's quite recent
Great keep it up 👍
Hello Miss.... I have written this for you after spending substantial amount of time kindly have a read....
Let me break it down for you miss, irrespective of what Qaiser Ahmed Raja said, the contention of Imam Ghazali for which he(ghazali) gave the example of cotton and fire was as follows, to understand that lets go beyond the cotton and fire's knowledge available at his time, the chemical reactions occur in nature due to certain fundamental tendencies of the atoms and energy, like when cotton touch the fire the that initiate a process of equalibrium in atom where it tent to have electrons in proportion that stables it, and when the atoms get stable at the given system, the reaction stops and the cotton become ashe, ghazali contended that these tendencies of atom are not necessities and can be in any other way but they are not, because God allowed them in that manner. He said "they call it a necessity because they have no proof beyond observation."
The problem is when he says "it's not because of fire but by will of God" you reckon he denied the relationship between cotton and fire, but in reality he defined the relation, that it happens not because of necessity, It can happen in any other way but God allowed to be as it happens before our eyes.
Now coming back to what Qaiser ahmed Raja said "ghazali ne essa kabhi nhi kaha ki rui nhi jalegi" he was referring to views of ghazali on general conduct of fire on cotton, and that doesn't negate his initial position that fire won't "necessarily" burn cotton if come in contact.
Miss you showed the video in the thumbnail is different then you reacted. In fact the video you showed in thumbnail clarify problem you presented. The video uploaded by QAR on the response to your video was "Defending Ghazali | A Response to @uzmarumi256" on 27 April 2024, he never called you "Desi secular" or "don't get into contingency argument", you reacted different video, he was very respectful to you....
Hopefully you came this far.....
Now the video he created in you response, he said in that video at 3:25 "Ghazali is not deny causality rather provided a framework for it, for its true nature.....neither fire decides that it will burn not cotton decided that it will get brunt, then these are contingent things and there is something other nessecery existence that give base to this causation."
Thank you
Great effort ❤
Bht khoob sir may khud yehi dekh raha hon Kay log kitnay jahil Hain Jo in madam ki baton ko sun kar sensible samajh rahay hain , ye bechari to sedhi saadhi kitab ko nahi samajh sakteen jab tak koi inhay na samjhai , ye philosophical or mistical sence ko Kahan samjhain geen
Inho nay ghazali ki kitab ki bas translation parh li sidhi sidhi Jo line samajh aai out of context chaap di ,😂 aur sir ko samjha raheen Hain , galti maan nahi raheen
😎☝🏼best
Excellent video ........... Just love your content
Your words are really engraved on my mind.
I heard Qaiser bhai also, but your way of speaking is too good, and this video really cleared my arguments
Waiting for the next part......❤
Mashaa Allah beautifully explained ❤ God bless you
Excellent research. We need more ppl like you who break the so called AZEEEM BUZURQ myth and thats automatically guide us towards Quran and Sunnat
Well done Maim 👍 Your style of explaining things is so neat.
Engineer sahab aapa ka to samajh me aata hai magar aap inn aayaton ko kaise bhul gaye??
الله الصمد
Har cheez absolutely Allah per har lamha dependent hai apne existence ke liye.. fir ye physical laws Allah se independent kaise kaam kar sakte hai???
لله الامر من قبل ومن بعد
Allah hi ka akele command/hukm/faisla/decree hai (har cheez) se qabl bhi aur (har cheez) ke ba'ad bhi...
Matlab kis cause ke baad kya effect niklega aur jo effect nikla hai uska cause kya hoga...
"الا له الخلق و الأمر"
"كل يوم هوا في شأن"
Aur kaise bhool gaye ki Jo kuch dunya me aur universe me ho rha hai Allah uski nisbat apni taraf kart hai wo bhi fa'il ki haisiyat se jaise
"يقلب الله الليل و النهار"
"انزل من السماء ماء"
"يولج اليل في النهار.."
"و جعل الشمس سراجا"
"لنخرج به حبا و نباتا"
Wagaira wagaira aur bhi beshumar aayaat hai..
Sabhi aayaton me Allah فعل ke sath khudko فاعل bata rha hai.. fir aap seculars ki tarah ye mante ho ki Allah ne universe aur uske laws to create kar diye machine ki tarah magar ye unverse Allah ki mansha ke mutabik khud hi chal rha hai jaise koi machine engineer ki mansha ke mutabik chalti hai matlab "فاعل" wo machine khud hui..
Kya ye aqeedah Qur'an aur sunnat ke khilaf nhi hai???
Uzma Qadiani...not Rumi....
Contingency argument was in fact originally framed by ibn Sina
Buht information thi vedio ma well done mam.buht koch new sikhna ko mila.
Bahot he kamaal ki video hai. Lakinn thumbnail itna eye catchy nahe hai. Qaiser raja ka muhn bra kar k lgana chahiya tha jistarah wo views kalia sabhka face lgata ha thumbnail pay😂😂😂..
Urdu font bhe samjhna mushkil ha.
Aggar aap kahain to main 3,4 thumbnails bna k apko fb per bhaij sakta hun. Jo pasand ho use kr lijiya ga..because you deserve millions of views.... ❤
Part 2?
Mr. Muhammad Engineer Ali Mirza (Front_Man of the Qadyanis) is beyond repair. May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! My Salute for all the TRUTH Lovers. Al-hamduLILLAH عزوجل ! ! !
ameen
shame on engineer
Qaiser is a gem and engineer is secular sh*t 😡
engineer is a danger to Islam 😢
Qaiser you beauty ❤
Ghizali aur Qaisar sahab to warr gaye ! Hahahaha :D :D Well done Ms Uzma!
Ye waqat bty ga Kon wara hi😂
You have not given answer to main question yet, according to you after imam Ghazali the scientific temperament in the muslim world went down yet we see many Muslim scientists after Ghazali namely, Al Nafis, Al Tusi, Al Shatir, Ulugh Beg, Omar Khayyam (yes he worked on Algerba apart from poetry), Ibn Rushd, etc. How did they managed to work if Muslims developed an anti scientific mindset? Also, Al Ghazali's own view on science,
“As for the praiseworthy disciplines such as medicine and mathematics, they are associated with worldly benefit. And that category is divided into those that become a communal obligation and those that are of great merit but are not an obligation"
Kindly don't deviate from topic.
Who are the "Higher or Highest Personalities of Religion" in your Opinion Uzma?
Qaiser ahmed raja ajeeb insan hai jb deobandi molvi ne bachy j sth ziadti ki thi recently uspr na koi iski video aai
Apky comment se apki ignorance ka pata chal geya .. ap k andar serf bughz hai ... Topic kia hai or ap kia keh rhe hain.😂😂
@@passionbasit991 Bhai meny video pr comment sirf Ali Bhai ki wajha se kia hai wesy tum hee dikhado video koi iski us hawaly se
@@passionbasit991 i already have these type of expectations from hazrat iron dome hafizullah gang and their members
Bahi apke sath b jis deobandi molvi ne zyadati ki hy ap hamy bata do hum action le laingy tension na lo bro
Amazing Uzma... You totally nailed it.
Nice 👍
Excellent Uzma, very well explained.
QAR's latest response titled " Sister Uzma Rumi is Arguably The best Ghazalian Yet". He schooled her again academically, great job QAR. I'm afraid his response will suspend the rest of the parts of her argument.😊
@@muhammadanas8107 mein to fan ho gya hu Raja Sahab ka 1 to videos dekhi hn Kya cool admi ha yar
Video k start may ap nay kaha k Mazhab meri domain nehi aur minay Gazali ki science pr aitraz kia aur Qaiser raja nay Gazali ki science pr reply kia.Phit ap Qazali k sufi thoughts pr tankeed krnay chal pari.What the hell is that?QAR pehlay hi keh chukay hai k Gazali k sufi thoughts pr ap nay tankeed krni hai to krain lakin us ko bunyad bana k ap Gazali ki Science ko galat nehi keh saktay.
Sufism is a portal to mystism and magic
The greatest black magician Alcester Crowley traveled and learnt magic from sufis
ua-cam.com/video/k3_R9y0hfFQ/v-deo.htmlsi=V3VzlXgAdW86QfUV
Is ki wajah bhi isi vidoe main bata di hay.
Well done sister ❤
Front man of molvis is better than front man of anti islamisms and iron dom hafiza......... mirza sahib kisi or hi trf chal pry hain ... unsubscribed him
Again emotional rant instead on any logical argument. Really you molbis are beyond repair.
Watching you first time. I Found it very informative video. Good
بہت موثراندازمیں بیان کیا ہے۔۔۔
I usually have no comments on any UA-cam videos but few that force me to do so, and your video is one of them
More power to you 🙌🏼
So How Imam gazali thought can ruined the Islamic golden age and you didn't counter any Arguments related to fall of Golden age. And I'm not able to understand why so called liberal didn't able to understand that In the case of Cotton and fire, Fire didn't burn Cotton if ALLAH didn't allow. This is hypothetical situation which can explain the power of Almighty, that ALLAH have power to intervene in this world. If god didn't able to intervene so He is not GOD. Because God have absolute power. This is very simple, And Can you explain how this thought become reason of Islamic golden age fall.Why you didn't counter any Qaiser Sahab Fall of golden age Arguments.
I'm waiting for your Prompt response.
Bhai kya hogya ha. Apna dimaag use kro jb logo ko ye btao gy ye universe bghair kisi law k chal rahi ha to kon science pe focus kry ga asan rasta to ye bun gya k sufi ho jao to universe tumharay qdmon me hogi. To is trah logo ne science ko dekhny or universe k laws ko smajhnay ki bjaye sirf Allah ho krny me lag gye. Or science k ilm ko kafir ka ilm smaj liya is trah Islamic golden age tbah hoa ye clear cut ha is video me or pichli video me bhi.
Is sy koi Muslim inkar nahi kr raha ha k universe Allah Almighty ne create ki ha. Problem ye ha sufi is baat ko man'nay k liye tayyar nahi k Allah Almighty ne is universe ko scientific laws k mutabiq bnaya ha or chala raha ha. In laws ko sirf Prophets k liye Allah ne tora isi ko occasionalism kehty. is baat ko sufi nahi man'tay wo kehty hain k ye kisi bhi insaan k liye hoskta ha jb aesa nahi ha. Ye sirf Prophets k liye ha
You need explanation?, ok! See, when Ghazali's thoughts were reinforced, people stopped researching and critical thinking, free thoughts became blasphemy and that ultimately lead to downfall of Muslims in Arab and Persia. Free inquiry is the key to scientific development. Where there will be a religious suppression there will be a recession in scientific achievements.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc oh really After the death of Imam Gazali there is 8 biggest research laboratory build in Islamic empires, and at that time Many Sultan fund research institutes and laboratories. This is very chep understanding that one person who collapse entire golden age and at that time whare different sect of islam didn't agree on same Arguments and this man come and all muslim say we are now follow this person we build observatries for fun we build monument without the help of science we translate geek philosophical book we build world largest astronomy observatries but we stop thinking, this is funny. This type of Arguments that imam gazali collapse Science and thinking come from empty mind that type of people who is not aware about Islamic history.
@@uuy5865 Nah bro! that is not what I have said. Whatever Ghazali wrote had a significant impact over the minds of the people of that time and it slowly but surely damaged the scientific fabric of society and later on ofcourse many religious personality came and contributed in the destruction. I would agree that some khalifa was open minded & they invested heavily in science and technology but their thoughts, beliefs overshadowed by the belief of those who were against all these progress.
@@HamzaKhan-dc4nc ua-cam.com/video/tOjT52JIPzw/v-deo.htmlsi=ZwPb-6klU3ypN_wj
Uzma Rumi, hats 📴 to your immensely logically impressive videos full of info and knowledge. As far as QR's illogicality is concerned, it's certain, he's to lose on every ground untill and unless he embraces the TRUTH AND REALITY.
Qaiser bhai zindabad..qaiser bhai ap logo ke lye doctor hai or aj kal mirza ko injection lga raha hai😂😂
Sorry agar aapko video samajh nahi aaya
@@saptarsi7868😅😅👍🏼
"abe dhakkan takla ahmed raja bol 🤔🤔🤔takle ke chamche 🤔🤔🤔
Dukh horha qaiser raja ap jese logon ko bewaqof bana sakta hai 😅😅
@@Huntmenoww jo QAR se bewakof banraha ho uska IQ lvl minus - me hoga😅
IMTAHANI GUIDES KA FALSAFA: Mohtarma nay na-janay kis Kabaryea kay thailay say koi guide pakar kay ret li hay, aur fart-e-jazbat main musalsal broken record ki terah bej rahi hain: occasionalism, causality, kherq-e-adet,... Ghazali nay kia ghalet kaha? Kia Mohtarma nay ankhain khaul kay is dunya ka mushahida nahin kia? Natural laws say het ker, Khuda kis qanoon kay tehat insan ki infaradi aur masherti zindagi - and more importantly, human history - chala raha hay? Western philosophy ka bhi yea aik fundamental asool hay, kay God works through history!
Kia koi sahib-e-fehm-o-faraset yea keh sekta hay, kay yahan koi rationalism kar-ferma hay? Nahin, aur her ehl-e-danish yea kehnay per majboor ho ga, kay ik kaynati Toofan-e-bed-tameezi hay, kay thamnay ka nam nahin lay raha. Khuda nay her makhlooq ko apnay panja-e-istabdad main jakra huwa hay, yani THERE IS NO FREE WILL, jaisa kay Qur'an khud bhi batata hay:
"And there is not a beast in the earth but the sustenance thereof dependeth on Allah. He knoweth its habitation and its repository. All is in a clear record." [Hud 11:6, Tr.: Pickthall]
"Lo! I have put my trust in Allah, my Lord and your Lord. Not an animal but He doth grasp it by the forelock! Lo! my Lord is on a straight path." [Hud 11:56, Tr.: Pickthall]
So, this God is holding every creature by its forelock (the part of the brain responsible for thinking/reasoning, social cognition, and executive functions), and with that our perception, reasoning and decisions, so HOW CAN THERE BE ANY FREE WILL?
Islam kay SINGLE AUR LINEAR LIFE MODEL kay tehat to Khudai rationalism dhoondna abes hay, han Hindu philosophy, yani THEORY OF REINCARNATION, kay tehat aisa koi karmic rationalism divine kia ja sekta hay, laikin aisa kertay huway Islam ko aik jali deen bhi man-na paray ga. Kia Mohtarma is 'mathematical' truth ka samna kernay ko tayyar hain?
Let us have live debate
Well I didn’t understand are you trying to say that Allah created all things with certain laws and now Allah is not interfering?? He created world and left over ???
That's what they are trying to inject, still claiming themselves to be muslim. According to them, Allah is sleeping after creating the universe
صوفیا کے کندھے پر بندوق رکھ کر نشانہ قرآنی عقائد کو بنا رہی ہے
She just made Statements and did not gave proof.Wohi wala kaam kia hai "Rana nay jo keh dita keh dita" By the way Contingency Argument Ibn Sina nay frame kia tha pahlay.
No allah creating laws every thing working under the law if allah interfare its own laws its also againts laws allah has created except nabi.
@@usmanm9267 صرف نبی کے لئے اللہ تعالٰی اپنے قوانین کو خلاف کرتا ہے اس کی کوئی دلیل؟
@@Abu-hasnain nabuwat khatam ho gai uss ki nishaniya khatam hogai ab sirf hain mubashrat yani k sachy khawab. Jab nabowat he khatam ho gai to pher nashani kes baat ki.
I love Muhammad Ali Mirza bhai
🤦♂️ who asked?
I did
شاباش ! اتنی اچھی باتیں سننے کو ہماری سوسائٹی ترس گئی ہے ۔
کسی فرد واحد کے ہر اعتراض کا جواب دینا مستحسن نہیں ۔ اچھے کھلاڑی ہر بال نہیں کھیلتے ۔ لوگوں کے اعتراضات سے گریز کر کے بلکہ بلند و برتر ہوکر موضوعات و مسائل کو زیر بحث لائیں تو افادیت بڑھ جائے گی ۔ سلامت باشید !
You are doing an excellent work. Criminally underrated. Been a subscriber for a while and your content doesn’t disappoint; always well researched.
As far as Caner Raja is concerned, he is just that, cancer.