Israelis: Is Israel committing a genocide in Gaza?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Filmed November 29 2023
HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
Corey, I think you should let people know that Palestinians who speak against Israel are also threatened by jail time and fines and charges of terrorism. Some of them might be afraid to tell you their actual opinion for that reason.
AND Israelis too. A teacher got shoved around by police while being told to shut up about 🔻
They aren’t though…
@@mr.person5209 They literally are. You can't even bear the flag of Palestine in Israel without the police raiding your neighorhood and forcibly removing it by all physical means necessary. Palestinians have gone to jail for expressing support/condolensces for Palestine on WhatsApp.
@@eyeballpapercut4400 what? Lol
@@danielbiton9859 If you think that's bad, there's also Breaking The Silence Israel, an organisation of ex-idf personnel who are against the occupation, who a few yeara ago got depopularised by the government, calling them terrorist sympathisers.
"To a rocket, it doesn't matter if you are Jew or an Arab." Wise words.
Are you brainwashed?
only because it’s not guided
the rocket doesnt fly by itself
Hamas doesn't care either, on Oct. 7th they've murdered quite a few Muslims who identified themselves as such.
Read the Holy t errorism Bible:
*Joshua **6:21*
*Samuel 15:3*
*Numbers **31:17**-18*
*Ezekiel 9:5-6*
*Jeremiah 48:10*
*Matthew 10:34-35*
The first guy asking "Is it genocide? From our side or theirs??" broke my heart and mind into pieces.
Well, Hamas are the ones that aim at the total annihilation of the other side and target civilians while Israel works to reduce harm to the Gazan civilians.
So, yes, in a sense the 7.10 massacre was a botched genocide attempt.
He's a friend of mine in real life and I was surprised to see him in Corey's video!
Dang your friend is trash @dbulat
Is he really this biased @@dbulat
@@shayanbehlim we all are biased by our information bubble we sit in, but what did he say biased in your opinion? The fact that he believes that killing civilians is "sad but heh, what you gonna do?" Is a mindset of anyone in a hot zone, it's not like Palestinians think otherwise, considering the latest polls showing 70+% approval of hamas actions. It's wrong, but understandable why both sides think this way. Plus you don't know personal stories, maybe his uncle\dad\brother\friend\whoever suffered somewhere along the latest decades of mutual hate
The fact that some of the Arabs were too afraid to show their face on their cameras out of fear of persecution speaks volumes.
Yeah, they feared persecution from Arab communities. lmao
Theres freedom of speech In Israel, 🇮🇱
Not all of them. It's their choice not to show their faces. If you say things like Israel should be dismantled or that "war was going to happen anyway" -after years of peace, what do you expect?
These people feel shame because they have vengeance and resentment in their minds. Hamas poisons the minds of innocent Palestinian school children and then they grow up to be radical adults who want to kill.
They feel shame because they know that their thoughts are shameful.
I think Netanyahu is a tyrant and I think he's gone too far. I agree with many people who have said that, but I don't think Israelis want to genocide innocent Palestinians. Israelis just want to live in peace and Hamas keeps disrupting that peace for the sake of vengeance killings.
Palestinians are being manipulated into this by Hamas. Hamas wants to genocide all Jews and Christians. Israelis just want to live in peace. They're not starting wars with anyone. They're being attacked by multiple terrorists groups all around them. These are terrorists and not freedom fighters. These terrorists would kill innocent men, women and children in a heartbeat if they ever won this battle. They would kill anyone who does not adhere to their very strict fundamentalist view of Islam. Their battle is an ideological one and it started with the mufti Amin al-Husseini who only wanted a Pan Arab state. His desire to kill Jews was so strong that he aligned himself with Adolf Hitler and recruited soldiers to fight for the third Reich.
It sucks that Palestinians are being brainwashed in this manner by Hamas and I don't think Israeli can really do anything to sway them anymore. Their thirst for blood is too strong.
At some point, you need to let go of your need and desire for vengeance. 1948 was 76 years ago. These people are never getting their land back. It's gone forever. Get over it and move on with your lives. Did the Armenians ever get their land back? No one ever talks about the Armenians or the Armenian genocide. No one cares. For some reason we seem to care more about Palestinians than any other group of people and you have to wonder why. It's because we are all being brainwashed by propaganda from Hamas.
Not a single person in this video would even bother to acknowledge any other genocide going on around the world. This cause fills the empty void in their soul that modern consumerism has created. Hamas knows this and they utilize this. They gladly accept the deaths of 20,000 innocent people because it makes them look good. They instigate this violence because they're manipulative. When will people realize this?
Palestinians had every chance and opportunity to make Gaza a successful place. They choose not to. They choose to waste all of their money and resources on killing Israelis. This is what happens in those circumstances. It's sad and I feel empathy for them, but you are not helping their cause.
Persecution from other Muslims .
@@lilymaisiealso to protect them . ... they hv relatives in other Arab country... unlike most non-arab
“They voted for Hamas, they need to live with the results.”
Does that not apply to Israeli civilians then, given that they voted for Netanyahu?
Honestly, the hypocrisy is astounding.
Oh, but Israeli live with it, don't they? And defend themselves when it's necessary.
Most of them were born after the elections... These izraelis know it but they are bloodthirsty
And then they complain about Netanyahu being a fascist, as if it wasn’t them who elected him about a year ago for the fifth time.
It applies to any country. Besides which, before Oct 7 the country was literally on the brink of civil war because of the bullshit moves Bibi was making, and there were mass protests on both sides. So Israelis not only live with the results but try to do something about them.
Now compare that to the 85% support for Hamas in the west bank and 65% in Gaza.
@@cavannaro1 We are not crying? Palestinians however...
To be fair, this is kind of like asking Americans why we went into Iraq.
Yeah exactly. If you asked nowadays you would get a range of answers, but back at the time people just repeated talking points from the government, because that is all the media were putting out.
Iraq didnt invade the US kidnapping and killing children
* afgan alqaeda, or Imperial Japan
Or like German under Nazi rule why they invade the rest of the Europe
And Americans know about the same thing: what we were told. Anything else is basically guesswork.
I think an important aspect that wasn't discussed is the blocking of food + water + electricity + fuel, the collapse of the healthcare system, the situation becoming so dangerous that humanitarian aid can't effectively get in, and the fact that about 90% of the people in Gaza are without adequate shelter. Millions of Gazans are at risk of starvation, death by dehydration, unable to get medical care, sicknesses are starting to spread... the entire population is at risk of death from starvation and disease, not just bombing.
Tell me a war in this world that were no scarcity of food, water and modern amenities.
That's the tragic reality of war, I wish they could get international support without Hamas taking those resources
Then use provided money to build fucking power stations instead of making rockets and tunnels it’s that simple. Before they invaded Israel all of that have been provided by Israel for free. Why the fck would Britain or USSR supply water, gas or electricity to germany in 39-45
Billions of dollars only from USA which palestines and pro-palestines activists blame and shit on.
@@MillennialJesus its war crimes that Israel is commiting for sure, blocking access to food and water and electricity. That level of control is not typical.
30 sec into the video “this is the price of what they have done” is all you need to know. If not genocide it is at least collective punishment, which is a clear war crime that seemingly most Israeli citizens are supportive of….
So when hamas applied collective punishment on october the 7th and excused it as the price to pay for ocupation was valid though?
@@JustYetAnotherUser ok so by comparing my point to what Hamas did, you literally just agreed that what Israel is doing is the same, but 10x worse. I’m not even saying that what Israel did is worse than Hamas (but you are) - they are very different things. My point is that what Israel is doing is still wrong (war crimes) and it’s clear that they and many of their citizens don’t realize it.
@@ysong00 Ok, dont come with interpolations on what i said. I dont agree with how the israeli government is conducting this (in fact I despise that gov), however the whole "war crime" and "genocide" accusations are a sort of innacurate, at least for now.
The current ratio is 2 civilian deaths for 1 hamas fighter. Considering that ratio and the extremely complex area of gaza, that death toll is incredibly low. Genocide is what happened in manila, for example, where 100k people died in 1 single month. Of course, this doesn't make it less tragic tho.
War crimes is also a bit subjective when most of the images that are circulating around the media lack context. It's mostly "oh, look, israelis killed x number o palestinians", yeah, but why, where, who were these palestinians, etc. And the whole humanitarian help trucks etc are also a source of hipocrisy beause egypt could perfectly attend to all of the palestinian needs but they just refuse to.
So no, I do not agree israel is doing the same, at least not for now. Just because palestinians are the weaker side, that doesnt make them victims, considering their intentions are well known. What i meant to show is how claiming this is collective pnushiment is not really accurate for now as it's hypocritical when one doesn't claim the same for hamas and the arabs themselves over the years,
@@JustYetAnotherUser so Israel wants to use collective punishment while also claiming its wrong to be done to them and doing so makes hamas terrorists? Hypocrisy and double standards are not sound bases to build from...
@@ysong00 Sure it's wrong to punish other people but does that mean that Israel is not trying to minimaize casualties? you think fighting Urban warfare is easy? When an organization like Hamas embeds itself into the population like this you will get deaths no matter which millitary does it, and if you think your country is better in that regard then think again.
This is one of Corey's better videos.
If you are on this page, regardless of where you stand, you are likely a part of the small subset of people that can empathize enough with both people to be a bridge for a future peace.
Don't give up on it, it's the only way.
well said
As an Israeli Jew, I have to chill you down and unapologetically say: it will never happen.
Yes, two peoples coexisting in harmony is the only moral future. It is not the only possible future, however, and asking how we get from point A to point B is important. The obstacles can’t be overstated. Having looked at the settlements, I have lost faith that two states is possible unless either the United States or God Himself intervenes, and neither is likely. One democratic state feels like an even more insane proposal, so what could peace possibly look like?
But crazy times call from us courage and honesty. And so here is the frightening, honest truth: Empathy will not bring peace, not alone. It is but one tool in the peacemaker’s toolbelt. It is even possible to empathize with both Israelis and Palestinians and to still believe that the violence currently unfolding is nevertheless just, or inevitable, or actually a path to peace rather than a road to hell. In fact, I’d suspect that empty empathy is how your average Israeli is feeling right now, the sort of “I don’t wish for civilians to be hurt, but that is war” that we see repeated over and over again, here and elsewhere.
If we truly want peace, we need honesty. The current campaign in Gaza is deplorable and unjustifiable, as is what’s going on in the West Bank. We are fortunate that we, in the international community, can see our primary objectives clearly: Securing the release of the hostages, securing a durable ceasefire, and ending the outrageous and unjustifiable siege. These three things are unlikely to happen without US pressure, which is unlikely to come. Therefore, it is incumbent on us to pressure the Biden administration, including by talking with each other to build a consensus that that truly is the only path to peace.
@@sammosaurusrex I don’t think Biden is able to influence anything even if he wants to
peace cannot come to the Palestinian land from outside
I think that this channel is more useful than America (today they will sign one agreement and in a year the Republicans will come and refuse to implement it)
When you have one group who are rich and powerful and the other who rely on aid from the USA, the powerful group are able to control the information and the narrative.
"If your "safety" relies on my oppression, then neither of us are free. Instead it's trapping you in a cycle of violence that can't end until you stop the oppression." -X
Empty quotes with false accusations and no evidence or truth. Oppression? Do you know the history of the Jews? They have owned the land of Israel for thousands of years, Judaism existed before Islam and archeological evidence supports Israel is Jewish. Go claim false oppression to someone who’s as ignorant as you are about evidence and facts.
What oppression? Israel did not liberate Gaza, and Hamas terrorists entered Israel's house and murdered everyone they saw. What is the solution for Israelis to evacuate the south? Maybe also from the north? We do not apologize for existing or defending ourselves.
@dodorish what about Jerusalem
That wasn't even gives to them by British and the rest of the holy land Palestinians were exiled out of thier homes and that's where they're always lived for centuries
"Freedom" should be replaced by "safety".
@@dude8746 Thanks!
It seems like most Israelis have absolutely zero idea what daily life was like for Palestinians prior to the 7th
There is no excuse for Oct 7th.
@@Nevercash so there is no excuse for Israel’s response either
@@bmxney3143 Israel's reaction is because of what happened on October 7
@@user-cs8pq1re4l October 7th is a response to Israel’s mistreatment of their people for years
@@bmxney3143 Absolutely correct!
17:45 “sababa” in this context means “ok” as a sentence completer. Translating it as “terrific” gives the wrong impression that he is condoning the bombings.
stupid comment^@@dannysaratoga
Much respect to you Corey for asking this question..
And for being such an amazing interviewer. If we only had people like him in the mainstream media.
@@martiendejong8857
Absolutely. 💯
He should have explained to them that it is a genocide. Do they not have any brain cells???
ua-cam.com/video/ksnLom8OD9E/v-deo.htmlsi=zJGFzTSMXEIKQN0J
This is documenter from the guardian. How they could steal land and house from Palestinian
The first time the phrase “human animal” was recorded in history was by Himmler in WW2, 1943 he literally said “we have to be savages in a chapter that will never be written when treating human animals”, even their calculating of calories was also done
"
In the Tantura documentary there is a iTf man who says that they took a pregnant woman, made bets whether the baby is a boy or a girl, disemboweled and cut her stomach open to check who won, another one talking about school children who were raising their the hands, the same way kids do in a classroom, after he rounded them up. He then kept firing. Both laughing merrily and casually at the recollection. In another documentary '1948: Creation & Catastrophe', a survivor speaks about women getting violated infront of their family members by iTf. She was a child at the time and still wept as an elderly woman. For more recent atrocities, "Breaking the Silence" record statements by the iTf themselves, they recount the events witht he same casualty their forebears do.
The journalist Gideon Levy once was at a checkpoint in the west bank where the soldiers there force the ambulance to wait an hour before someone clears it through as part of a routine while they watch Tv. The journalist waited with the ambulance then got angry, confronted the iTf soldier asking him what if it were your mother in the ambulance, the soldier made the same face and pointed his weapon at him. This was many years ago, it had only gotten worse since. They simply dont see them as human, by ANY means want the world to see the same.
There were no No Attacks on civilians the 7th. Just collateral.
500/1200-1300 (they keep magically decreasing) were soldiers. Out of 769 names, 462 military (55 soldiers, 13 privates, 59 corporals, 200 sergeants of whom 45 are sergeants majors, 48 commanders, 32 lieutenants, 5 lieutenant colonels, 6 colonels, 13 captains, 37 officers, 10 inspectors, 6 intendents, 2 Lance Corp). It was a Military defeat, they are taking it out on the rest.
- analysis of datasheet from haaretz.
Shocking how "the same group" can go from persecuted to perpetrator in less than 100 years
You mean defenceless to armored ?
@@shellymanyevitch1302 no, from nazi victims to nazis
Funny how Nazis like you still exist after 80 years.
you don't really know what the nazis have done do you@@BackdoorBox
@@michelle2126 i do, which is why i say that israel is a nazi state
That was a wide range of responses, really insightful
Greetings from Egypt to our brothers and sisters in Israel and Palestine. I hope peace will prevail in the Middle East and the whole world. 🇪🇬❤🇮🇱❤🇵🇸
Eih ya Sameh? What are you doing?
Khalih@@mmmfahmy
With more people like you, God willing there will be peace. It begins with education. We have to stop the incitement.
Jesus Christ is the way the truth and the Life. Light of the world.
@sameharayes Thank you for your kind words.
I wonder if Israeli people see the same images we are seeing from Gaza.
😢
Even if theyll see it they still actually experiencing the war and they saw alot more horrible images from Israel, things that personally traumatized me.
And its people u know so its so much difficult to sympathize with people on the other side especially when civilians took apart in 10/7
Definitely none of them have seen the genocide being live streamed on the instagram accounts of Motaz Azaiza or Bisan
@@hanna319 exactly 💯
I wonder if Arabs saw the images of the 7th in October (no)...We also dont care
@Corey Gil-Shuster It would fascinating to do a version of this where you essentially get reactions to videos from the "other side". e.g., show this video to people in Ramallah and see what they think. A conversation of sorts that hopefully builds empathy and understanding where possible.
its much much more difficult to ask a random on the street to "watch this video on the conflict you are facing, and give me ur opinions on it" vs asking for their response/opinion on a question/statement. theres also to mention the obvious difficulties such as making sure the listener is going to sit for 3+ minutes to respond to a whole video. which part will they reply to? it certainly wont be most of the video, they will choose something that to most may seem unimportant but to them may have gravity. I agree with you that it would be fascinating, but i dont think its practical. its infinitely simpler and more bare bones to ask a question than to have a "watch and respond" session.
@tjmignardi fair point on the practicality.
You shouldn't expect a positive answer from people in Ramallah when they are under Palestinian authority control and have been brainwashed to think that Israel is always at fault. There's practically no point in interviewing Palestinian people
These people who say “war is a war”, I bet they wouldn’t be saying this if they were in gaza. It is easy to say that when you’re not in the war zone
It's easy to say this when it's not your nation being attacked and your people being murdered. Stfu.
These people have been through wars. They have run to bomb shelters, they were near suicide. Bombings, most of them served in the military.
Israelis know what war is. They hate it. They didn’t choose it. But they are willing to fight it.
Every Israeli is in the war zone …
Can you ask Israelis what they would do if in 1948 it had been their country and suddenly Palestinians started to arrive and were given an UN mandate to form their own state. Basically what the Jews would do if the situation was reversed? would they give their country up to the newcomers or resist?
I think it depends if the Arabs will give the Jews freedom which up until 48 wasn’t the case
can you elaborate? I don't quite get your point.
I would answer you, but your question is based on false assumptions and a horrific historical distortion.
It just didn't happen the way you describe.
1. There has never been a Palestinian state.
2. There has never been a Palestinian people.
3. Jews have always lived in the Land of Israel.
There wasn't a Palestinian state, the area was controlled by the UK at the time. No Arab left their home before the 1948 war. So it wasn't "their country", it was a land where Arabs and Jews lived. Had the UN partition plan of 47' been accepted by both sides we could had been living in peace with Israel and Palestine side by side for 76 years now.
Hopefully it's not too late. Hope that answers your question (it seems to have been based on inaccurate information)
The Jews started to arrive long before 1948. There was a small Jewish immigration for centuries, it intensified in 1882. In 1948 there was no sovereign Arab nation called Palestine, only a land called Palestine ruled by the British. Therefore this example of yours is false, it wasn't their country, from a political point of view (and what other point of view there is when talking about states and countries).
Many Arabs who now identify as Palestinian Arabs arrived there during the 1920s and 30s to work for the British and the Jews, who brought economic development to this land, which was neglected by the Ottomans for many years (you can look up the British statistic of immigration from this era). Yasser Arafat was born in Cairo, as well as nearly half of the people of modern-day Gaza. And some of the Arabs living in the West Bank arrived during the Jordanian rule over this territory between the years of 1948 to 1967, but they are, for some reason, considered "indigenous people", but Jews who arrived, for example, in the 1920s and 30s arent.
hearing the guy at 0:37 say ‘this is the price for what they’ve done’ made me physically retch. the babies? what they have done? the children? the mothers? the sisters? the innocents? what have they done???
1/2 the population voted for Hamas in 2006. Most everyone trapped in Gaza has never had an opportunity to vote. These people are gods chosen people MY AS*. Free Palestine 🇵🇸😭
What did your lovelies do to j e w i sh b a bies on the 7th of october?
alot of HAsbara comments and thinking on here sigh.. pathetic.@@jessiekatetheking
whiy don't you ask the IDF that shelled them or the tank drivers?? that shelled the homes and killed most?@@dogbert52
He’s so suck
“Do you personally want to k- Palestinians?” Is definitely not the question. How this person changed the entire question from one of a government doing something to one of a personal question totally distorts the entire point of the question. Then the interviewer goes and says ‘There are people outside that think that all Je- want to k- Palestini-“ which is definitely not what the majority are saying, the majority are saying that the Israeli govt and the Israeli army are the ones committing mass murders in Gaza through their widespread bombing campaigns. It’s like he doesn’t even try to educate people.
This is in stark contrast to him interviewing Palestinians, where he is sharply critical and starts to downplay their concerns. The guy is a Zionist shill
That was an Israeli who is not fluent in hebrew, both sides spoke a bit broken hebrew, he changed the phrasing multiple times because of it.
Absolutely we are not living in a time when religion should be ruling God bless that man and his words
Yes exactly, I wrote a comment just like this before I saw yours
Thanks for this video, good to hear from both sides and happy to see these Israeli Arabs also seeking peace just like us Israeli Jews and others.
No, they are NOT seeking peace, listen to them blaming the Palestinians for this Genocide. 🙄
@subversivelysurreal3645 who are they you speak of?
??? theyre justifying the genocide by saing that the palestinians voted for hamas when half the population were kids or werent fucking born yet theyre genocide enabling terrorists
I'm 74 and have Parkinson's. I can walk (slowly) only 2 miles, then I have to lie down and rest for the remainder of the day. Just wondering how many elderly people in northern Gaza have Parkinson's or other debilitating diseases.
Also, I've seen videos of IDF shooting at women and children who are running down an IDF-desgnated evacuation route. I can't run.
What? You saw no such videos of course. IDF is literally setting up evacuation routes, and protecting the Gazan civilians from Hamas. It is a crazy dystopian world, where the Gazan leadership wants as many Gazans and Israelis to die, while useful idiots like you encourage them and believe their propaganda. Hamas is worse than the Nazis, and you are eating their shit directly.
That video was Hamas. The amount of fake news and propaganda out there surrounding this war is unprecedented so I would fact check everything you see
They had weeks to evacuate. Even at 2 miles a day, that's plenty of time.
@@user-rg2wo4vj8q what is proved false? I said they had weeks to evacuate, not two days.
@@user-rg2wo4vj8q Yeah, crazy replies. Seems like it's normal for them to chase other people out of those people's own houses.. it's crazy how entitled they sound.. am i missing something here. it's totally insane
It’s wasn’t 1400 people, that was also a lie at 2:07, it was an Israeli media outlet that admitted the numbers to be 1,200. Hopefully this comment doesn’t get deleted.
Does that really make a difference? Would you be mad if I said 22000 Palestinians were killed in Gaza instead of 20000? Come on now...
if it hasnt been deleted yet I think its here to stay, when my comment was deleted it was within 1 min.
The actual figure accounted for to date is 1149 including 1 baby, 25 minors. It's also important to note that 300+ casualties were military personnel. Lastly there have been reporting that some of the casualties were the result of IDF "friendly fire".
@@andreafionda542 no, because that will likely be the figure tomorrow or the day after. But yes I will be frustrated if they say 1400 when it’s actually 1200… because they are proven nazis who use lies to justify a genocide.
@@saphire2214 only reporting by hate filled arabs.
If we could go back and ask the same question in 1940s Germany... what do you think people would tell us?
They would tell you they are being genocided by the jews.
And if we asked Americans the same question then? Before the atomic bombs on Japan?
@@Bnidb123 Did America occupy and brutalize Japan? Round the entire island up into one or two giant concentration camps? Did the Americans destroy the country of Japan, its history, deny the Japanese people even existed and claim they were 'just some Asians'?
That said, you'd be surprised how many Americans did not agree with the US joining the war against Germany. The sympathies of many Americans were much closer to the Third Reich than people today are willing to admit. The KKK had marched through Washington in 1926 and had the strongest membership in its history between the wars.
Hitler's Germany took many of its trace laws from Jim Crow South.
Do you even know what was goin on in 1940s germany you muppet?
This is not comparable
it is shocking how is the level of ignorance about the fact from a lot of people here, some don't know islam, some are filled with miss-information that lack evidences, some are not aware of israel old - and current- acts against international law .. and all of these are just pure facts, that needed to be learned before even start a conversation, yet they don't know it .. what a sad situation
Does 'International law' allow to kidnapp a 9 months old baby?
@@yaronofry5111 no, not for children, and neither bombing them , nor imprisoning them for raising a flag or throwing a rock .. and that is what israel doing too
@@yaronofry5111you mean like israel does every day? they just call it „arresting“
@@yesmyninja6850You can try as hard as you can but there is no moral equivalence between Israel and Hamas. if there was, there would be no Gazans alive after 7th of October. and Israel does not kidnapp babies to tunnels, Hamas does.
@@yaronofry5111 What about keeping 2 million people in the world's largest open air prison after invading their land?
salam from ethiopia, as muslim please don't think we accept what they did , the killing, kidnapping and other things . we just think about the innocent children ,woman and man in gaza .as human we should have respectful discussion (not like debate but listen what the other side is saying) and found something we can agree with . hope there will be peace .
p.s don't come after me i am just 15
Thank you for your kind words.
Israel is working to end the genocidal Hamas regime while trying to minimize civilian casualties. It is hard as Hamas embeds it military presence in the civilian population under its control.
Most humans are on the same page. The problem is Hamas does not care about the deaths of Gazan women and children nor Israeli women and children.
In Khaybar they did exactly the same as Hamas did on october 7
@@orchidoclaste7298 brother or sister don't talk without knowing history please ,lets be respectful to each other.
@@eladnoy2547 I get what you are saying but it doesn't justify what israeli goverment are doing , if you watch what their news is saying , they try to justify it and bsasically saying collective punishment is their best resolution .
The first man interviewed said " this is the price for what they've done". Does anyone turn off the tv and think this is exactly what both sides think. Everyone agrees that horrific acts should not happen at all. But 20000 people killed the vast majority being civilians and children as a response. imagine the anger of the future generations. And they too will say their actions are justified.
It seems Israelis don’t see this at all, and I am dumbfounded. Their selective indifference to suffering and dying children is so upsetting.
They aren't identifying how many Hamas fighters are in that figure. It's not 20,000 civilians, the number at he moment according to Hamas (gazan ministry of health) is lower, and it's total casualties, and yes it's a war, a war that Israelis did not start nor want. Hamas fighters are young, average age in gaza is in their 20's. Hamas openly targeted civilans and kidnaped them in their 1,200+ person killing rampage and launch of this war, calling for and asking for all allies to attack israel... Thankfully they did no come with significant force... but Hamas & Islamic Jihad keeps going on fighting shooting aimless rockets, risking all their families, cousins and neibors lives. Hamas could have and still could surrender/lay down and and returned the kidnapped any-day and stopped the war.. Instead Hamas keeps fighting a clearly loosing battle at the expense of all civilians in Gaza just for the sake of fighting/martydom.
@@nathiekatzoff97 Hamas live in Occupied country, sure they will fight, why Israel not stopping of stealing homes in the west bank ? return to border of 67 ? why you wants just to accept theft and another people control even their water ? Hamas wanted to take hostages not really kill, to swap with prisoners Israel keeps take and toture. most the prisoners were kids and women like Israel hostages. Israel bomb everywhere instead of fighting normal, they wants to kill civilians, they bombed hospital, unro schools, church, houses ...etc.
According to Hamas, 20,000 people died. The same Hamas that burned children and beheaded people says this. Whoever does this has no problem lying about the number of victims.
It is naive to believe the data provided by Hamas.....
@@nathiekatzoff97 Israel did start this war, it's been ongoing since 1948. This is complicated issue, Israel isn't innocent and stop treating the situation as so. Hamas is what happens when you invade, oppress, and take away a peoples dignity. If you want thing's to change those factors need to be addressed.
Oct 7 constituted the actus reus and mens rea for genocide. The response can be argued to have the actus reus but not the mens rea. Because if Israel had that intent, the number of casualties would be far higher by now. Closer to those of Syria or Yemen.
Corey, thanks for your continued work. You've been able to give people insight into the mind of both Israelis and Palestinians in an invaluable way. I have been to Israel twice (and once to the WB), and have a lot of family in Israel... but much of what I see is mediated through facebook, what I hear from family, etc. Your work is far more "real".
This is never going to end.
Until Israel has all the land, including Syria, Lebanon and Egypt.
@@theredboneking
amen true promised borders of Israel are from the river Euphrates to edge of the Nile, to the red sea...
@@theredboneking Lol what when have they *ever* expressed any wanting to either of those countries.
They already had huge part of Egypt and completely gave it all up for peace with Arabs.
And they're the aggressive side preventing peace in the region?
Once the Muslim countries abandon all the foreign ideologies and unite upon Islam it will very quickly be over.
@@theredboneking Israel wants to steal those countries too???
The level of mis-information and wilful denial of evidence is really disheartening. I wanted to find a glimmer of hope by watching this.. but no 💔
Yeah the level of hamas propaganda is really frightening, makes you understand why so many people supported nazi germany the same way ppl now support hamas
theres jews like me who dont believe this, and many israelis who dont either. dont give up hope
@@sab5686Are you in Israel?
Im especially disgusted by the arab israelis. Totally cold persons towards Gaza and history their own country. Palestine is a lost cause it is so sad. Killing civilians especially thousands of children is a genocide. Just read the legal texts ruling the IPC
Denial of what? What evidence? You're delusional and brainwashed by Arab propaganda
corey why are you not pushing them on their lies? one of them said gaza was not in a blockade, what is the point of this channel?
Wow. Last man had so beautiful speech. More people like him.👍👍👍
Thank you, Guy.
Your work on UA-cam is very important. Very interesting videos
23:45 this assumption that Gaza could have been like Singapore or so with all that money is a bit wild. I mean Singapore has control of its air and sea borders, it can do business with the world. To assume that a refugee camp devoid of civil and proper political institutions and its own border control can be anything else than it is now, is very wild
To be fair, Singapore managed to make peace with her neighbours and even her sibling/frenemy Malaysia that gave her the boot due to racial tensions - who occasionally still threatens to switch off her water supply from time to time. It should also be noted that Singapore's neighbours could easily create a blockade in times of hostilities too.
well not if you didn't become a terrorist state.
So did Gaza between 2005 and 2007. Then they lost it to terrorism. That's how it works.
@@user-xs4mu8xm7d lol singapore's neighbours are not as crazy as that. singapore, malaysia, indonesia live in peace together with each other, visit each other often, work in each other's countries often. clearly not the same as palestine - israel relationship.
They would have gotten that if they had pledged to make peace but that was clearly never their intention
“This is a price for what they have done”
The most dangerous thing is an oppressor that pretends to be a victim.
Corey I love you and Salukie. The Work you do is soooo importantttt
Salukie is the epitome of a self hating Jew.
My thoughts!
Salukie is a good kid, but I'm worried he will bite off more than he can chew. He pushes the limits
in what sense? @@tbishop4961
@@tbishop4961 Salukie is off the rails it seems. I loved his previous content too. However I can see that as he grew his channel, he’s not making appropriate use of the money and donations. He started posting videos on objectionable content like “how to pull white chicks” or scoring drugs and gives airtime to Israeli who are happy with what is going on in Gaza. Very, very sad as his previous stuff was valuable, especially his chats with Palestinians which he did taking great personal risks
That Arab Israeli citizen was so balanced in his replies- God bless him!
He's afraid to speak what he really thinks, Israel is an apartheid state for Palestinians, so he's being careful what he says.
Lol he is afraid to speak his mind. They cant even post on social media for risk of facing the consequences.
He’ll go to jail if he speaks against them
@@samodamirits not only "they" if u post something that shows bad interest u will get arrested it happened to jews as well.
And theres Palestinians at the cneset that deny 10/7 and they still have their place there which i personally think is insane.
@@deplorable2767 Please try and talk to some Israeli Arabs, I think they might tell a different story. I don't know if you have already but if you haven't I think it's better if you had the chance of really seeing what they think about the state. Not the Palestinians that unfortunately do not have the same freedoms as the Israeli citizens. Talk to Arabs in Kfar Qasem and of their relationships with the jewish people.
They killed 18.000 civilian by far and still saying it's not genocide they have no shame.
There are 1.7 million Arab Muslims israeli citizens currently living in Israel majority Palestinians.Genocide ?
That's not even close to a genocide.
@hey_adorable At this moment the count is 50.000, 18.000 children not just civilians. You have no shame all of you, the whole world hate zionists right now because what you did was so not human
@@Gretathunbergsfart Genocide is about intent not number, Question isn`t how many died is WHY they died and were they targeted intentionally, When Hamas shoots RPG`s at soldiers behind a child, Sadly the soldier has to shoot to defend his life, When Hamas sends little children with explosives to attach them on APC`s or Tanks, Sadly that child will be shot, That`s what evil Hamas is doing, Can`t blame it on Israel.
If they think that this is a war, then they must stop speaking about holocoste at ww2. Because it was also a war, not genocide then. Shame on all people who don't accept this as a genocide. If this is not genocide, what is it then?
The holocaust wasn’t a war because the jews were not fighting back and didn’t harm anyone one. THIS IS A WAR because hamas attacked Israel, have Israeli hostages and fire rockets into israel many times a day
They re evils all of them, except few, everyone says it started on 7 october, and don't care about the other side.
atalayayberk5747 This is not a genocide . Gaza open a war with Israel, they did a war crime attack against innocent civilians in Israel. The response of Israel is very different and Israel is not trying to wipe Gaza they fight against the Palestinians government. If you don’t understand the difference next time tell them not to start a war they can’t win.
Because it was done by the west .
🎉in ww2 nazis (the governing body of Germany) were slaughtering Jews who were German citizens. How can a country be at war with itself?
They literally don’t care, no humanity, no empathy
That's with a camera recording them... one can only imagine what they believe and say in their private lives. Indeed no hope for peace.
I have a hunch as to what your reaction to 10/7 was, dear peace loving soul
I’m sorry did you have people you know slaughtered by people who vow to do it “again & again” and say “it’s just the rehearsal” until all of your people are murdered? Does your country have 500k people waiting to be able to return home when they no longer have to live in fear of what Hamas will do? Every person here clearly said they don’t want to hurt civilians, I’d like to see a single Gazan say this about Israelis.
@@Ariel-jq1if fear of hamas will do?? more like palestinian fear what israel forces (aka real terrorist) will do, civil say don't want hurt civill my ass even the first interviewer didnt match with ur statement, i even seen amny israelis says they want to flatten every palestinians, better shut up if you know nothing
@@aragog0559 I have a hunch as to what your reaction to before 10/7 75 years occupation attack of israeli to palestinians, dear peace of knowing everything
Please ask to Israelities people : If there are 1000 Hamas running and hiding in Tel Aviv, would IDF bombs Tel Aviv with the same reason in Gaza, namely "eliminating Hamas"
They wouldn't have access to tunnels in Tel Aviv and it would be near impossible to hide amongst the population in Tel-Aviv so your comparison is flawed!
@@Dazza0187
What if they did have access to tunnels in tel aviv?
Its very simple, if you control the surrounding buildings and area you use a different type to force to when you don't, it's how every war works!
The point of bombing campaigns is so they don’t have to send Israeli troops in and risk their lives, if Israeli citizens lives were in danger in a bombing campaign than Israel would be willing to risk the lives of their troops. I don’t see how this is a gotcha question.
What an idiotic analogy.
1. Israel would evacuate as many civilians from the area as possible before or concurrently with any military operation. Hamas encourages civilians to stay, sometimes at gunpoint.
2. There is no need to bomb when your soldiers can freely move around and deploy in the area. This is impossible in Gaza with terrorists and hostile civilians everywhere.
3. Why do Palestinian supporters resort to useless analogies that have no grounding in reality? Such as apartheid, genocide, and the nonsense you put forth. Speak the facts if you have an actual argument.
Protecting our selves from babies.
The man at 2.50 says we didn’t do anything, it’s Hamas fault . Well occupation is what you did and 75 brutal years of it
Interesting-and chilling-video but I don't think you understand the definition of "genocide," Corey. For a genocide to occur there doesn't even have to be killing. Under Article II of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, a legally binding global treaty, "genocide" is defined as "any of the following acts committed with
intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such":
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its
physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
Why do marxists and izlumists always change definitions of words?
No way that’s a direct quote, considering “ethnical” is not a word. Generally the term is “ethnic”.
@@Altafan21 Yes way it's a direct quote and yes "ethnical" is a word. (I am a professional writer). Here's the original document. www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/documents/atrocity-crimes/Doc.1_Convention%20on%20the%20Prevention%20and%20Punishment%20of%20the%20Crime%20of%20Genocide.pdf
@@Altafan21Yet it is, as a simple google search would prove you. “Ethnical” is, by the way, a perfectly valid word, as a rarer synonym of “ethnic”. Anyway weak attempt at dismissing the content based on a minor lexical detail.
I’ve said this hundreds of times lol what frustrates me is that genocide isn’t something that you can just discuss. If certain conditions are present then it’s a genocide. You can’t just decide it’s not or try to give your opinion on it
What truly boggles my mind is how Israeli settlers are free to roam their streets in peace, sleep in their beds without the fear of their homes being flattened and finding their children buried under the rubble. The privilege they have is ASTOUNDING. To have billions pumped into your military and economy must be wonderful. They all seem so brainwashed, the propaganda is insanely powerful. They seem completely aloof to what's happening to their neighbours. I feel sorry for them...
@bobrzycapolathe jig is up the whole world sees it
@bobrzycapolaevery Zionist accusation is a confession
Are you stupid? They are in fear too. Thousands of rockets fired at them every hour too. You know what’s the difference? Their government cares for their people and invests billions to protect their civilians that’s why many of them or not dying either. If you don't know the full scale of what is going on please keep quiet. Hamas is using its people as human shields
Agree, well said.
Your Islamist friends in Gaza received BILLIONS of dollars to get yourself good lives and sleep in golden beds.
What did they do with this money? built tunnels shot rockets at Israeli CIVILIANS (in your words "settlers")
and educated their kids to be terrorists.
Now they started a war against Israel and you are whining because they are losing? there is no more PRIVILEGED group in this world than the palestinians
That one Arab guy was so grateful for the life he lives in Israel
Mass psychosis is alive and well
So what would be the normal equivalent of this video?
To the guy who said all problems come from religion, when you look around the world, you actualy find out that it is far from true. Look at Stalin, look at Hitler, China... and so on. Religion can be a tool for war but not source in my opinion.
Yes Even WW1 & 2 were not initiated because of religion!
Well religion set up Israel and religion fights against Israel
Religion play a big role in dis particular conflict to be sincere
Religion...Greed...and Communism.
Religion is an ideology - ideologies are excuses for war
"we didn't start it".... are you sure?
it did not start on Oct. 7, Human Rights Watch and many organizations have reported on the apartheid for decades, and decades.....
They are living on bloody earth
Who declared war on who in 1948? And ever since then?
Adolf/achmet
yes but unfortunately most people that defend israel don't care about truth or human life, its about routin for your team.
There living in their warped reality were the series of events throughout history benefit them
So you justify the kidnapping of a 9 months old baby and gang-rape of girls simply because the Arabs were pissed off at the Jews?
Remember that the German population during the Shoah had absolutely no knowledge the camps existed. Asking civilians is just going to reflect what the propaganda tells them is happenning.
Also it's sad to see it's always Israeli women or are the most brainwashed people by the IDF...
I have never seen a genocide where the population tripled itself
"We give them territory..". That's like someone forcing me out of my house and then thinking they're being benevolent in giving me a shed in the garden 🤦🏽♀
*UN given land :)
I’ve never seen footage of the UN forcibly oust families from their homes. I have seen footage of Zionist forces doing this. I’m not religious in any way but I’ll pray that no one gives your home away on someone else’s behalf
You're very narrow minded if you're taking this literally. What "we gave them territory" means is "we withdrew from Gaza so that they could establish their own governance, and they instead elected Hamas who became the monster it is today, so we have no reason to believe that giving any more territory will make things better for us". I hope you did not need this explanation.
@@arielweinbergerThere is a bigger and more ruthless "monster" taking action right now and you are supporting it
if the people being "forcefully removed" from your territory were squatters i think its not only an act of benevolence to offer them another space to live in but, as we are learning for decades now, also incredibly foolish. let the jordanians and egyptians and syrians calling themselves palestinians go back to their own territories if they cannot accept their own defeat, the so called nakba when they collaborated with arab armies that sold them the lie that if they only leave for a couple weeks they will annihilate the jews and they will be able to come back. turns out they lost, and that is their nakba, a failed attempt at jewish genocide which started long before 48. :)
Most of these people don't have humanity nor opinion just IDF talking points, I wan to say sad but it is actually disgusting.
They have access to the internet, there’s no excuse for this apathy and ignorance.
@@jessiekatetheking agreed
Maybe you should move to Gaza they will welcome your moronic opinion...Its not about Killing Palestinians if Isreal wanted them gone it would have been done years or decades ago do you not think there army could have erased the hole lot. its about getting rid of Hamas and its supporters and yes people will die like in any and all wars...
"No humanity"? Really? That's the angle you're going for? Well thank god they have their country then
@@aragog0559 taking the death of Palestinians as oh what can you do about it or as they deserve it or in a childish way like they started it is a lack of humanity, that is what i meant.
What I don’t understand: leaders of hamas proclaim that it is glory to dye like martyr, so they definitely must be happy now((( They just made it happend
Never in my life would have I imagined that people would ever refer to an army as "moral" what's moral about war? What's moral about little boys and girls having to give up on their futures because they know they'll never grow up.
I've only seen two vids and glanced at your catalogue here, but I already LOVE your valuable channel! THIS is what is needed! SUBSCRIBED, thanks!
This is the price for what they've done? Serious, what did a small child do to help Hamas?
Apparently 1400 is equal to 18000 and a fair price to pay.
i dont know, ask hamas who is turning them into martyrs
The adults around them screwed up.
The children are innocent
Ask his parents why they start a war instead of rasing happy child in peace
The numbers of people killed in Gaza includes Hamas as far as I know
To the man at 10:25. Incorrect. Its not religion that is the problem. It is solely Islamic religion.
I never want to have such people as a neighbour
They're only your neighbor for a short amount of time. Very quickly they just steal your home and now you have new neighbors
And is Hamas okay as neighbors?
@@dodorishchildish
@@itzelouise8714 It's better to be childish and not want to cut off children's heads
@@dodorish you are starving children lady, dude or whatever you are, are you proud of it?
I'm not even watching the vid and the answer to the question is: Yes Israel is committing Genocide in Gaza. Anyone with a speck of moral fibre would also say the same thing
so the palestinians are Arabs.There are 475 million Arabs in the world. There are 15 million Jews in the world. This is not even close to a genocide. Clearly you don't know what the word means.
"I don't care what you say, I know the truth" - A Really Dumb Person
yep, same here, the whole world already knows the answer, so I didn't watch the video too. It doesn't matter what they say.. Actions speak louder than words!
@@janetannerevans2320lol that makes no sense what you just said. Lmaoo your logic is absurd
ok, when you attacked Sina in Egypt it was also a self defense and when you attack Jurdean and Lebanon it was also a self defence . stop laying
"Jews and the Arabs
Semitic pawns in the master game.
The player who controls the board
Sees them ALL as the same.
Basically, cannon fodder."
-Eugene McDaniels, _Headless Heroes of the Apocalypse_
Who controls the board? The Anglo Saxons?
No Arab Israeli will be comfortable enough to say what they really think
no you are just not comfortable with their answers
Trust me, there is nothing in the world that would bring me more joy than knowing that Arabs in Israel are safe. During my travels i’ve seen and witnessed quite the opposite. So forgive me if I have a healthy level of skepticism
@@miadia3387 i don't just 'trust' people on the internet who say stuff, cause frankly anyone on the internet can say anything. If you claim that arab israelis are so oppressed, that they cannot speak their minds on this issue freely, please give a source from any credible news organization that confirms it. So far i have only read of cases where people within israel who sympathize with hamas actions on 7 oct. have been arrested.
I don't doubt there is racism against arabs in israel, but you are also kind of direspecting the arab israelis who speak in this video by claiming that they cannot have come up with their opinions on their own.
@@miadia3387 maybe because they sympathize with the Palestinians and Israel’s government treatment towards them is not always fair, also the Palestinian matter is deranged in Israeli discussions. But they still get better opportunities and are treated better in Israeli territories more than any Palestinian under Hamas’s rule. And that’s a fact
I just want the murdering to stop. How can people not have compassion for 20,000 dead? Are they saying no Palestinians have compassion for 1,400 dead? Killing begets killing. Children are raised to believe that fighting is the only answer. None of them should take the word God into their mouth, whether it is Israel or Hamas they are all murderers. I still thank you for asking questions calmly, so we can learn what people think.
Babe, that’s the reality of war, that’s why we avoid them as much as possible
Those are Hamas numbers. Israel targets Hamas and unfortunately many civilians do get caught in the way. But let me ask you this; If you were Hamas and you would have lost 3,000 fighters in combat, along with 6,000 more civilians... What would you do? As a Hamas leader? If I was a Hamas Leader... I would lie and say that 20,000 civilians were killed.
@@ordro107 No, the numbers are probably accurate. Even though they have every incentive to want more deaths, I do think that Hamas is accurately reporting the numbers, in so far as is possible. Didn’t Israel also corroborate those numbers in one of their reports?
@@ordro107 Like people not using their critical thinking skills
@@Adam-326 lol are you seriously believing a terrorist organization? lol The same one that lied about how many was killed in the hospital bombing that they did BTW and was saying it was irsreal. Which was the barking lot btw not the hospital
Under UN’s Genocide Convention charter, it’s a textbook genocide.
I remember one video I watched of yours and you asked a Palestinian, “What’s the difference between a Israeli-Arab and a Palestinian” and he looked sad before weakly smiling and saying “They’re free.”
I look forward to the day Israel ends its occupation and Palestine has the Right of self-determination.
it is not a genocide. If it was there wouldn't be 20,000 casualties in 2 months there would be 2 million within 2 hours as Israel has nuclear bombs. The population of Palestinians has increased consistently since 1948 when Israel was established as a political state. Hamas, in it's own constitution does not want self determination they want all Jews worldwide dead. Read the Hamas charter, quit pretending Palestinians want anything other than a complete and total annihilation of non Palestinians. Don't believe me, believe your own eyes when you read their stated intention.
This is not true.
Genocide is defined as trying to destroy an ethnic, national, etc. group.
Israel actively works to minimize civilian casualties.
This is not a genocide.
This is not a war crime.
This is simply war.
I like that your channel is showing both sides form regular people.
"We didnt start it" LOL delusional
yes, indeed. A sign of not having a brain, but being brainwashed
How so?
You all are so good at making these statements without any reasoning behind any of you stupid claims. They did start it. And you are the one which is delusional if you think israel is not going to respond to a terror attacks which killed raped and burned alive 1400 people, the same people whose dead bodys was celebrated with at gaza by the same "innocent civilians" which now victimize theirselves. Just how israel did start it tell us??
Lol read some history, we indeed didn't start it.
If the Arabs had accepted the Peel Commission or the UN Partition Plan rather than declaring war on the Jews and trying to wipe them off the map, there would never have been the 1948 Nakba. So no, the Jews didn't start it
how irony they know a lot of innocent civilians died but they still can’t convince themselves that they’re committed genocide 😂
Yeah, crazy. It's insane.. i can't fathom.
Genocide has a specific definition, there could be millions killed and it not be a genocide, and there could be a few hundred killed and it be a genocide. Intent matters in the definition. By Israel warning the residents to flee, there is NO intention on killing them.
*Genocide?*
*_"The systematic and widespread extermination or attempted extermination of a national, racial, religious, or ethnic group"_*
There has Never been a genocide by Israel on anyone. The Palestinians killed as the result of wars that they started, are not victims of genocide. The millions killed in Japan when the US dropped atomic bombs in WW2 ars victims of genocide. The 1 million Armenian Christians murdered by the Turks are a genocide. The 800,000 Tutsi murdered in Rwanda are a genocide.
People who were killed in wartime by warfare are not victims of genocide, unless specifically targeted for destruction, which Israel has never done.
*Please buy a dictionary! Google is free!*
😂what did your cu ltists do on 7th of october? 😂
@@dogbert52 so what did you do then? innocent civilians in Palestine had been oppressed by the Israeli for decades. I ask you, WHAT WILL YOU DO IF SOMEONE TOOK YOUR HOME AND KICKED YOU OUT FROM THEIR LAND? and 20,000 innocent civilians in Palestine had died because of the bombing by the Israeli and most of them are children? 5 years old kids are terrorist? You don’t bomb hospitals or schools. You don’t starve people and cut all the water and electricity supply . This is obviously a genocide.
Did the US perform a Genocide in Germany?
Many more innocent civilians died there.
I think you should first aim to understand the meaning of words before using them.
"Irony" included.
I feel bad for the Palestinians that had to answer. They were probably afraid to answer freely
There were no Palestinians asked.
Racists Israelis do not call the people in Israel, Palestinian, they are called Arabs, so that their culture is erased.
@@shainazion4073 there's arabs that still identify themselves as Palestinians in israel.
i think you are right about the couple in the car
@@scriptaman2888i think they israeli arab not palestinians
That clown said, "We gave them territory" 5:16
You literally stole their land
Как украли?
They won it in a war so it’s not really “stealing” at least if we’re talking about Gaza
I find their responses too nauseating to listen to.
Why you don’t like hearing the truth?
Sad to watch. Most Israelis think it’s ok what’s going on. With this mindset it’s unlikely the peace can be achieved.
BOTH sides think they are justified in what ever action they take.
most israelis have no idea whats going on in there own country (just like in america and everywhere else) they just watch the biggest news outlet and believe everything they say without discernment. the truth will get out eventually
Peace has never been and can never be achieved during ongoing active warfare. It comes after.
Right so the Israelis who unlike the Palestinians are Not being taught in schools to become terrorists when they grow up & to blow up & kill the other for their God - are the ones that need to bend over backwards & handle Hama with kids gloves? Give me a break.
mad respect to the guy who said all the problems in the world come from religion including his own
In reality it's the people riding religion as their way to gain materialistic desire
religion is just their excuse
No ,he doesn't know anything about any religion
Religion is to unite people not divide . It's people who misuse religion to justify crimes.
Am I wrong for thanking that some of the arab israelis are and should be scared of actually saying their opinion?
Yes you're wrong.
Why?
@@MayaRaz-rx8eg ty for explaining
@@khaledassaf6356 because there is a massive crackdown going on where even posting a Palestinian flag could get you jailed
@@haroun5937 That's not true, there's a clear difference between supporting terror and empathizing with Palestinians, and Israel makes that distinction.
I love what you do Corey. Keep the good work.
Please ask them this question next time: What does it mean "peace" (between Israelis and Palestinians) for you?
Every israeli knows exactly what "peace" means with a r a b m u z li n z......
"Houdaybia peace"
Peace to Israelis means Palestinians living under their rule and accepting it without any resistance. Shame on them.
@@jessiekatetheking The only reason Israel controls Gaza and the West bank is for security. All we want is for Palestinians to live their life freely and leave us alone, but if we just stop the occupation in the west bank, It will turn into Gaza. In the end, the root of the problem is that they don't believe Israel has a right to exist (in any boundaries), and they aren't willing to comprise at all. They will continue to commit terror attacks until 100% of Israel is their's. If you watch Corey's videos you should have caught on to that by now. What is Israel supposed to do in this situation?
@@jessiekatethekingyou cleansed your 22 a r a b countries out of j e w s , you can go colonize those countries habibi
@@jessiekatetheking true.. occupier mentality. hmm hope they realize what's wrong with occupier mentality..
Disgusting answer from the first jew. Stopped watching after that.
I'm a Filipino and I never even knew that there was a war between Israel and Palestine. As an outsider to this tragedy who don't support Israel or Palestine(as I've seen both countries have done attrocities, it's not like one has been pure with their actions), I still put most of the blame on Hamas because their incredibly lacking military strategy of taking hostages and killing civilians in a nation ten to a hundred times more powerful than them was similar to a scenario where North Korea nukes the US, or Taiwan performing a ground invasion of mainland China. The only outcome was their own destruction, and they brought down the lives of the children, the families of their fellow Gazans. Had they not attack last October, all of those buildings would have still been standing to this day, the children wouldn't have lost their parents, and 30,000 people might still be living right now.
I guess the definition of genocide has been altered so much that literally every war is now a genocide. Cool
No it's been altered to make jews not be allowed to defend themselves
Ma’am Israel has dropped 18,000 tons of bombs on the Gaza Strip ( a small piece of land) if u had any education you’ll know that’s about 1.5 times the explosive force of the bomb dropped on Hiroshima
People love buzzwords
I guess the definition of war has been altered so much that literal genocide is referred to as war. Cool
2 million unhoused people 70000 buildings destroyed 20000 killed 100000 wounded what do you call it a skirmish??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? snail
After watching so many videos on Corey's channel I can say without a doubt that Israeli society is one of the most closeted I've ever come across. The level of delusion in some of these people's answers is horrifying.
Other multimedia people who have a lot of people following them have said that they were offered money to speak highly of Israel.
Let’s hear examples?
Yep
Strange, in Israel they review media, BBC, Al Jazeera, etc. in the news release. It seems that you only know one narrative...
the fact noone knows whats going on on the other sides of the separation barrier. 100 years of occupation, this shit starting before 1920.. someone needs to read some history books. like everyone in the country, bunch of back water hillibillies if they all lived in florida@@solvingpolitics3172
The guy at 10:30 is on the right track when he says""all the problems of the world comes from religion".....AMEN!!
Not true Palestinian we’re all religions .. it’s about colonization etc
@@goldmo2427 zionist colonization through religion
Listening to those two women near the end was infuriating, just blindly regurgitating the propaganda they’ve been fed.
it will never cease to shock me that a population whose ancestors experienced the most shameful, evil, repugnant genocide are so comfortable condemning a group of people to mass annihilation. is this an example of "hurt people hurt people"? what is happening? for Israeli citizens to see Oct 7 as the start of these attrocities -- as a US citizen who wasnt fully aware of our crimes in the middle east -- you would hope there was some reckoning. there just isn't.
Wow congrats an American learned about war. Also none of them voiced their support for mass annihilation. What video did you watch?
You murdered tens of millions of innocent people in the 20th century, all that blood is on your hands.
Right didn't even watch the video and just commented 😂 these people all said they don't want complete annihilation of Palestinians. They were attacked by terrorists, responded 10x times as harsh and are fully accepting of the consequences to achieve peace especially for them. Obviously
If israeli's wanted genocide there would be... They are clearly military much stronger. There are currently 50,000 buildings destroyed by the war effort... and only 15,000 people dead (including fighters)... do the math? thaats not even 1 person per building... Genocide is clearly not the goal, or israel is really bad at genocide... warning people to evacuate, etc. They have a 1-3 ratiio which is the highest human standard in war. The US in Afghanistan/iraq had aa 1-9 ratio for protocal.
50,000 buildings destroyed. So many displaced without homes to go back to. Tell me what the plan is for all those displaced people? If Israel controls everything that goes in or out, how does a common civilian (not a Hamas member. I know it's hard for you to think of a common Palestinian civilian, but try) live their life? Tell me how it is not easy for them to become an extremist when what little they had was destroyed by this insanely disproportionate response? You present the case of US/Afghanistan as a great study in how wars should be fought. It is literally a failed war that has created irreversible damage. Stop with the mental gymnastics. Israel has a track record of lying and occupying.@@nathiekatzoff97
Genocide is defined as the deliberate and systematic extermination of a national, racial, political or cultural group. 17000 Hamas reported deaths equate to 0.073%. It is a human tragedy but not genocide. There are still 2.3 million in Gaza and 2 million on the West Bank. No one discusses the 650,000 Jews expelled from Arab countries where there are now virtually no Jews anymore. I would argue that is genocide committed by most of Israels neighbours.
that 650k jews dead now? they bomb them? put them in gas chamber? who decide to take the palestinian land first? why most jews in israel got european ancestors? what did you guys did to get kick out from europe? why your politician keep on calling for a genocide publicly? why israel keep on getting caught lying again and again. Are you sure your worship God? or satan? are you blind?
Good point! Try and say that to Tik Tok’s pro Palestinians
Then you should know according to humanitarian organisations that this has been defined as genocide. You should also mention the 6 million Palestinians that were expelled from Palestine in 1948 by Israel. Kicked out of their homes (literally) or shot and killed indiscriminately so Israel could take their land. They also raped many women and killed many babies. Don't believe me? Watch Tantura. It's an interview by an Israeli documentary maker of the soldiers that committed the Nakba. They were laughing and enjoying telling about how they raped and killed innocent people.
What's more important than getting sucked into trying to define "genocide" is to understand that this has been made into a political argument. People think or say they are supporting human rights by claiming genocide but are really only politicizing human rights for rhetorical gain. The result of this is polarization and radicalized views like the woman at the end of this video or the people shouting "gas the Jews" in Australia. It's important we can hold Israel accountable for any war crimes committed, unfortunately given history they likely won't be, but the main focus should be on implementing a long term solution. Polarizing rhetoric like this does the exact opposite and in the end will not affect Israel's response next time this happens.
The guy @ 1:36 (which I assume to be Arab) is afraid to say it's genocide because he's clearly living in Israel territories and knows what will happen if he speaks negatively...
The guy at the end was spot on, peace and love 🙏
So many people live in their own little bubbles. The survey participants remind me of "Allegory of the Cave". These people have never seen the sun, afraid of mere shadows, and probably never will.
The overwhelming majority of Israelis and Palestinians encounter each other physically and metaphorically only in military checkpoints and fighting zones. Never allowed to leave the physical or metaphorical "cave", namely: Israel's separation wall and the propaganda.
Actually just explaining to yourself that people who have a different opinion have never 'seen the sun' seems a pretty bubble-y statement to me, as it gives you a justification for not having to engage with the content of what they say. I don't think you are doing the allergory of the cave any justice by assuming that you are beyond the bubble and can therefor tell who has and who hasn't seen the light.
Not the westerner watchin YT videos from his safe little bubble saying that the ACTUAL people from the video who LITERALLY live here and experience this every day live in a f***ing bubble, this has GOT to be satire
I wonder if God will accept the defence of ‘human shields’ when he asks them about the 7000 dead children on the day of judgement
If it's the same God that flooded the whole planet because some people were bad I wouldn't be surprised
@TrueHebrews 😂😂😂😂
I'm sure he'll forgive the unannounced raping and kidnapping of terrified civilians in the name of "resistance"...
Religion is just evil.
@TrueHebrewsI’m not sure if you’re being funny or not. How bad is that?
@TrueHebrews 1 Timothy 1:4 -
Neither give heed to fables and endless genealogies, which minister questions, rather than godly edifying which is in faith: so do. 4 nor to devote themselves to myths and endless genealogies, which promote speculations rather than the stewardship from God that is by faith.
thank you for the work you do corey. the only way peace can be attained is asking these questions and hopefully, even if its just one person, can change their mind for peace rather than not peace.
24:32 abu omri is such a good person, he only seeks peace!❤
Just one thing to the cr1me of genocide It is not necessarily the completely anhilation of a certain group.
The popular understanding of what constitutes genocide tends to be broader than the content of the norm under international law. Article II of the Genocide Convention contains a narrow definition of the crime of genocide, which includes two main elements:
A mental element: the "intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such"; and
A physical element, which includes the following five acts, enumerated exhaustively:
Killing members of the group
Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group
Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part
Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group
Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
10 Stages of Genocide
1. Classification: People are divided into "us and them".
2. Symbolization: People are forced to identify themselves.
3. Discrimination: People begin to face systematic discrimination.
4. Dehumanization: People equated with animals, vermin, or diseases.
5. Organization: The government creates special groups
(police/military) to enforce the policies.
6. Polarization: The government broadcasts propaganda to turn the populace against the group.
7. Preparation: Official action to remove/relocate people begins. 8. Persecution: Beginning of murders, theft of property, trial
massacres.
9. Extermination: Wholesale elimination of the group. It is "extermination" and not murder because the people are not considered human.
10. Denial: The government denies that it is or has committed any crime.
Stanton, Gregory (2012); 10 Stages of Genocide, Genocide Watch
They have taken all those stages, and right genocide don’t mean the complete cleansing of a group. Cause if that was the case than that would mean now genocide was done against Jews.
Yup, and this is why it isn’t a genocide.
@@emmettdonkeydoodle6230 disagree, there is many stages that has occurred alredy
A Muslim who blames others for committing genocide... Oh the irony@@dalila3398
@@dani-ks9cg I'm atheist
Thank you Corey for this video. Please share the speech of the last guy everywhere: Salam/shalom for everyone.
He was so phony with no opinion.
Don't know don't care. Israel can do whatever it wants.
I think if you phrased the definition of "genocide" differently you would've gotten different answers. I don't know if you agree it is a genocide or not so that might influence the point of the video, but phrasing genocide as "Israel *wants* to kill all Palestinians" obviously sounds bad, and nobody who is tied to Israel will admit that it's a genocide when it's put like that because no, not all the Palestinians should die and the Israeli government probably won't kill *ALL* Palestinians because the supposed goal of this war is to apparently eliminate Hamas. It's not a matter of if they want to kill all Palestinians or not, it's if they are killing many innocent Palestinian civilians -and they are.
that is what genocide literally is.
"the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group."
To put it in perspective if we believe the Hamas numbers of 20000 people. that would be 1 percent of the population of Gaza, not all Palestine, just Gaza.
In comparison in 1933 in Europe the Jewish population was 9.5 million give or take and the Nazis killed over 6 million, that is 2/3 of the population of ALL JEWS in europe.
Hence Holocaust is genocide.
supposedly 20000 people dead from a population of over 6 million in war is NOT genocide by any metrics.
There could be an argument of Ethnic cleansing of a population from a specific region but even that has not taken place.
"In the Middle East, they understand force. You show kindness, and they see it as weakness." Gosh, it sounds like Greece is in the Middle East.
Come live here for a bit, then talk
It's true ,they genuinely see kindness as weakness
@@Lateralmove Live where?
@@Србомбоница86 Hi
@@user-yc3pb1ij7gMiddle east, Israel