I just don't understand why you are ignoring me when I am commenting the same thing almost every time. 1upbinge, PLEASE do, Nintendo heroes: Good to most Good Nintendo villains: Dumb to Brilliant I just wish you aren't ignoring me anymore. PLEASE listen to me. I love you and you are one of the best youtubers. So please return the favour.
@@naoyukiyoneyama5222 they dont read EVERY SINGLE COMMENT adding the fact that would be to much work, and your not the only person here who gets ignored by them edit:does it even count as ignoring? they probably didnt even read it
You know that extra life box for Rouge you couldn't get? You can reach it by rotating the control stick to use her Screw Kick, or Knuckles to Uppercut.
Sonic Adventures 1 and 2 have got to be one of the best 3D Sonic games out there. Here's a suggestion: Mortal Kombat weak to strong or Mortal Kombat heroes good to most good.
He may evil but Eggman still has some good in him. He just gets carry away at times. We can’t forget the fact that Eggman did help Sonic & them to save to Earth from Biolizard & the Ark Meteor.
Both of the Sonic Adventure Games are one of the best 3D Games ever! Especially when we got introduced to Shadow and Rouge in Sonic Adventure 2! Plus I definitely would love to see the morality of these characters, I believe Amy should be on the good side because she protected a Flicky and gets Sonic out of prison.😁👍
I disagree with Amy, partly. In my opinion, she should be one more step higher on the good tier. It's true that Amy was upset when Tails and Sonic kept leaving her behind. But then again, how could she not be? They left Amy behind in three terrible spots. ( The G.U.N island, Near the police, and on the colony ARK where she could be attacked by anybody.) In her defense, Tails and Sonic should be at fault there. Also, for the whole "marry me, Sonic" thing, in this game, you can tell she was just joking.
See?! I'm glad you agreed that Amy shouldn't be left behind! But people keep thinking she's annoying plus I can definitely tell she's joking about the "marry me" thing.😥😅
True, but outside of that, pretty much everyone in Sonic Adventure 2 was in character compared to in the 2010s games where they would become one-dimensional Karma Houdinis (which means no matter what bad things they do, they are made to be consequence-free no matter what. Plus while Sonic, Tails, Amy Rose and Knuckles are epic characters at heart and UA-camrs like Characters-in-Depth, The PJ Show, etc, there's no denying that Amy Rose was beyond flanderized in Sonic Free Riders regardless of the game itself being fixed because it now has actual controls, Tails was also beyond flanderized in Sonic Forces with his cowardice, Knuckles in the Sonci games of that decade because of how dumb he pretended to be, etc)
I have some ideas from more sonic games goot to evil: Classic sonic characters Sonic heroes and shadow the hedgehog Sonic boom characters Sonic Advance trilogy+Sonic Battle Sonic rush and Rivals Sonic 2006 Sonic Riders trilogy Sonic Chronicles Sonic storybook series Sonic Unleashed And for the last option Sonic Colors-Generations-Lost World-Forces
Sonic Adventure 1 & 2 Characters: Good to Evil THE GOOD 1) Maria Robotnik 2) Big the Cat 3) Tikal the Echidna 4) Miles "Tails" Prower 5) Sonic the Hedgehog 6) Amy Rose 7) Knuckles the Echidna 8) Rouge the Bat 9) Shadow the Hedgehog 10) E-102 Gamma THE GREY AREA 11) Chaos 12) Prof. Gerald Robotnik BAD TO EVIL 13) ZERO 14) Chief Pachacamac 15) Dr. Ivo "Eggman" Robotnik
For Sin Medals: Lust: Amy. Funny how the sexualized antiheroine isn't given this. But you can probably see why. Wrath: Gerald. Again, really surprising it isn't Knuckles, but Knuckles didn't try to pulverize a planet in anger. Darwin: Biolizard. It only exists to make sure Gerald's scheme is completed and doesn't seem to mind it would result in its death. Greed: Poca... Paha... That Echidna Chief! At least Rouge doesn't hurt Chao over her greed. Pride: Shadow. "Hmh... I'm the coolest." Gluttony: Eggman. We don't see him eat a whole lot but he does have the girth. That and potentially an insatiable hunger for power. Sloth: BiG tHe CaT! Envy: Beta. We don't hear anything from him but it seemed like he envied Gamma's temporary place as top robot. But in Sonic X he does speak, and seemed desperate to prove himself to Eggman.
I like to think of these games as the true introduction of the Sonic the Hedgehog saga, leading up to Sonic Frontiers, even though the saga really began in the 2D games instead of the 3D games. I like the old Sonic cartoons, the anime Sonic X, and the latest series Sonic Prime. The beginning of Shadow’s story reminds me of Jibanyan from Yo-Kai Watch.
7 місяців тому
Shadow is in heroes and stuff. And mentioned in a lot of other games.
Your reason for Big being second is because of something not enjoyed by the player OUTSIDE OF THE GAME'S UNIVERSE? A better reason would be because while he doesn't any bad, he doesn't do much good deeds to make an impact in the story either.
The Knuckles Clan was ALWAYS a warrior tribe. Their warrior ways had nothing to do with why they were smoked by (Perfect) Chaos. I don't even think that them attempting to seize the Chaos Emeralds was the cause of their death(s). What messed them over is when they started screwing with the Chao (and possibly Tikal).
Darwin Medal: Big for losing Froggy every freaking time Lust Medal: Amy for obvious reasons being her crush on Sonic Greed and Wrath Medal: Eggman for wanting the people to surrender so he could build his eggman empire Envy Medal: Chaos for his hatred for the echidna tribe for wiping out the chao Pride Medal: Shadow come on, saying I'm the ultimate life form how could we not give this medal to anyone else
There is a script written for that. It just needs to be made into a video. I don't know when it will come out, but rest assured it's been in the works for a while just like this video was.
Rouge and Shadow have absolutely zero reasons to be in the good territory. Rouge should at least be the first grey area character since she is a jewel thief. Not sure how that classifies as a good trait at all. Yes, she is a spy and isn't really all that antagonistic, but her entire arc in Knuckles' and her own story was to steal the Master Emerald and have it for herself since greed was one of her characters trait at the time. Also, Shadow shouldn't even be in the good territory at all. Shadow's entire motive was to destroy the world because her friend died(because that's somehow good writing to everyone?). Shadow has zero justification for trying to destroy the world. Losing someone isn't a good way to justify someone being a good person when they're trying to destroy the Earth. You know what, I'll even be generous and say that he should be put in the bottom of the grey area due to his heroic act in the final story but the fact that he's in the good territory boggles my mind. Another thing, I love how this video mentions that they would only include the characters exclusively to Adventure 1 and 2 and Sonic X to some extent, when Shadow the Hedgehog was partly why Gerald was given the bottom of the grey area. Take out the Shadow the Hedgehog story to Gerald's reason why he is at the bottom of the grey area while things may not be different, but it'll at least tell us that they're at least listening to their own rules.
The implication of putting him into good territory is that Shadow's revenge plot is because: 1)He is basically brainwashed into carrying out Gerald's will through the conditioning of a false memory about Maria's last wish 2)There is no evidence in Shadow's mind at least until Amy tries to reach out to him of there being any "good" people left after the ARK incident. Especially after Eggman, the first human he meets after being released from stasis basically wants to use him as a weapon exactly like GUN's Project Shadow. Although, yes I agree Shadow is grey at best because he done both a lot of good and bad with endangering and then saving Earth.
Can you please do a good to evil and sentence for crimes for the bully? I think Peter would be gold metal of good because he helps Jimmy Hawkins and Russell bring peace in the school but doesn't fight anyone. Silver metal good would be Zoey because she barely seen, but since meet Jimmy Hawkins breaking townie based. Bronze metal good, I would say principle Doctor cravelsnitch Because he might harsh to his students but he likes principle pickles from Reese which just cared about there students. Bronze metal of evil I give to Lola and lust metal because she date boy like Johnny Vincent and gorde and townie to create a massive rumble in the town. Silver metal of evil would Mr.burton for having Jimmy Hawkins steal panties from girls dorm,accusing Jimmy of starting a fire in gym and hitting on his students. I would give gold metal of evil and the wrath metal to Gary Smith, who cause the massive battle in school and kidnapping doctor cravelsnitch and tricking everyone to do his work. I would give sloth metal to mr.Gallaway, who was mostly drunk until Jimmy fixed his problems, and greed metal goes to mr.hattrick, who takes bribes from the preps,jocks and greaser. Evny metal I would give to Edgar as he help Jimmy Hawkins after beating up but start burning the trophies of Dorby and setting the gym on fire and send rats to the library and putting Johnny Vincent in crazy hospital just because Edgar hates Bullworth Academy because he never had enough money to go the school and because Gary Smith told him to do it.
🦔 SONIC FRONTIERS Characters: Good to Evil --- bit.ly/3vQ1W3w
I just don't understand why you are ignoring me when I am commenting the same thing almost every time. 1upbinge, PLEASE do,
Nintendo heroes: Good to most Good
Nintendo villains: Dumb to Brilliant
I just wish you aren't ignoring me anymore. PLEASE listen to me. I love you and you are one of the best youtubers. So please return the favour.
@@naoyukiyoneyama5222 it's not that deep
@@naoyukiyoneyama5222 they dont read EVERY SINGLE COMMENT adding the fact that would be to much work, and your not the only person here who gets ignored by them
edit:does it even count as ignoring? they probably didnt even read it
You know that extra life box for Rouge you couldn't get? You can reach it by rotating the control stick to use her Screw Kick, or Knuckles to Uppercut.
Haven’t played Sonic The Hedgehog in YEARS. Can you get it for the Switch? Planning to get one eventually.
I'm glad that Rouge, Shadow and Gamma are in the good tier.
Shadow is my favorite character in the Sonic series
@@shadowredstroke1255 mine too!
I loved Sonic X sooo much when I was younger, it's the first time I was introduced to many of the wider Sonic cast
Good
1:07 🥇Maria Robtnik
1:56 🥈Big
3:09 🥉Tikal
4:56 Tails
6:20 Sonic
7:46 Amy
9:00 Knuckles
10:23 Rouge the Bat
11:51 Shadow
13:25 Gamma
Gray Area
15:02 Chaos
16:00 Gerold Robtnik
Bad and Evil
17:25 Zero
18:05 🥈Pachacamac
19:10 🥇 Dr. Eggman
"He came to make an announcement"
Oh yes he did.
Nice to see Shadow in the good!
Ratchet & Clank! Weak to Powerful! Good to Evil! Dumb to Brilliant! Healthy to Toxic!
The Adventure games will always hold a special place in my heart.
4:46
Here’s my plan: Seal Chaos back in, but take drastic measures to make sure that no one can get Chaos back out unless he’s calm
Sonic Adventures 1 and 2 have got to be one of the best 3D Sonic games out there.
Here's a suggestion: Mortal Kombat weak to strong or Mortal Kombat heroes good to most good.
8:46 she didn't actually want Sonic to marry her, she was just screwing with him, that's how teens are like, they screw with each other.
I like how he called the echidnas the "knuckles clan"
Street Fighter! Weak to Powerful! Good to Evil! Dumb to Brilliant! Healthy to Toxic!
Kid Icarus Characters! Weak to Powerful! Good to Evil! Dumb to Brilliant! Healthy to Toxic!
Never realized how evil Eggman actually is.
Same
Remember when eggman forced sonic to kill his own "child?" (according to Amy at least)
Hopefully people get this reference...
@@bluekel615Wait , are you talking about Sonic Battle ?
He may evil but Eggman still has some good in him. He just gets carry away at times. We can’t forget the fact that Eggman did help Sonic & them to save to Earth from Biolizard & the Ark Meteor.
The Legend of Spyro Characters: Good to Evil.
Skylanders! Weak to Powerful! Dumb to Brilliant! Good to Evil! Healthy to Toxic!
Mega Man Characters! Weak to Powerful! Good to Evil! Dumb to Brilliant!
Jak And Daxter: Good to Evil
19:30 perfect moment
I was hoping people would catch that if I wrote that in :)
I thought the Biolizard would have been here to get the gold medal of evil.
1Upbinge: In Sonic Adventure 2, Eggman came to make an announcement.
Me: Shadow the Hedgehog is a BI-
Both of the Sonic Adventure Games are one of the best 3D Games ever! Especially when we got introduced to Shadow and Rouge in Sonic Adventure 2! Plus I definitely would love to see the morality of these characters, I believe Amy should be on the good side because she protected a Flicky and gets Sonic out of prison.😁👍
Mario and rabbids sparks of hope good to evil
I disagree with Amy, partly. In my opinion, she should be one more step higher on the good tier. It's true that Amy was upset when Tails and Sonic kept leaving her behind. But then again, how could she not be? They left Amy behind in three terrible spots. ( The G.U.N island, Near the police, and on the colony ARK where she could be attacked by anybody.) In her defense, Tails and Sonic should be at fault there. Also, for the whole "marry me, Sonic" thing, in this game, you can tell she was just joking.
See?! I'm glad you agreed that Amy shouldn't be left behind! But people keep thinking she's annoying plus I can definitely tell she's joking about the "marry me" thing.😥😅
True, but outside of that, pretty much everyone in Sonic Adventure 2 was in character compared to in the 2010s games where they would become one-dimensional Karma Houdinis (which means no matter what bad things they do, they are made to be consequence-free no matter what. Plus while Sonic, Tails, Amy Rose and Knuckles are epic characters at heart and UA-camrs like Characters-in-Depth, The PJ Show, etc, there's no denying that Amy Rose was beyond flanderized in Sonic Free Riders regardless of the game itself being fixed because it now has actual controls, Tails was also beyond flanderized in Sonic Forces with his cowardice, Knuckles in the Sonci games of that decade because of how dumb he pretended to be, etc)
Rayman Characters: Good to Evil
Mega man X characters: Good to Evil
Alright it's been a while since we got a good to evil list in 1up binge.
I bet Maria is going to be in the 3rd Sonic Movie
Terraria characters. Good to Evil.
Good: Princess.
Grey Area: Duke Fishron.
Evil: Goblin Tinkerer.
I have some ideas from more sonic games goot to evil:
Classic sonic characters
Sonic heroes and shadow the hedgehog
Sonic boom characters
Sonic Advance trilogy+Sonic Battle
Sonic rush and Rivals
Sonic 2006
Sonic Riders trilogy
Sonic Chronicles
Sonic storybook series
Sonic Unleashed
And for the last option
Sonic Colors-Generations-Lost World-Forces
These games are so epic!
Seriously Sonic should have gotten the Gold medal of good
Nice, only you missed the Biolizard.
Sonic 06 good to evil
Halo Characters Good To Evil
Sonic satam characters good to evil
Dark pictures anthology series characters good to evil
Yes its been over a year and they didn't do the dark pictures anthology series and the worst part is that when you did them you got alot of views
My favorite sonic game ever is sonic adventure 2. I’d buy 3. So nostalgic. Love the music and chaos.
Mario and rabbids kingdom battle donkey kong good to evil
Hi 1upBinge I love this and I hope you have a good day and you are awesome
Do God of War: Ragnarök Characters - Good to Evil!
Sonic Adventure 1 & 2 Characters: Good to Evil
THE GOOD
1) Maria Robotnik
2) Big the Cat
3) Tikal the Echidna
4) Miles "Tails" Prower
5) Sonic the Hedgehog
6) Amy Rose
7) Knuckles the Echidna
8) Rouge the Bat
9) Shadow the Hedgehog
10) E-102 Gamma
THE GREY AREA
11) Chaos
12) Prof. Gerald Robotnik
BAD TO EVIL
13) ZERO
14) Chief Pachacamac
15) Dr. Ivo "Eggman" Robotnik
You should do a list like this for Sonic Battle and/or Sonic Chronicles.
I must be the only sonic fan here who loves Amy dearly 😊
No, you are not.
Nice try, pal.
No I do too 😂😭💖
No way! I love Amy Rose too, I have Amy Rose toys and a poster of her! I may have other Sonic Characters Merch, but Amy is the one I had the most.😁👍
We need a remaster of SA1 and 2.
I Absolutely Love Sonic Adventure and Adventure 2 Battle Games of Sonic from my Childhood Years, and that also includes the Sonic X Anime!
7:14 Actually this one was on tails for telling Eggman that the emerald was fake and letting eggman trick him
For Sin Medals:
Lust: Amy. Funny how the sexualized antiheroine isn't given this. But you can probably see why.
Wrath: Gerald. Again, really surprising it isn't Knuckles, but Knuckles didn't try to pulverize a planet in anger.
Darwin: Biolizard. It only exists to make sure Gerald's scheme is completed and doesn't seem to mind it would result in its death.
Greed: Poca... Paha... That Echidna Chief! At least Rouge doesn't hurt Chao over her greed.
Pride: Shadow. "Hmh... I'm the coolest."
Gluttony: Eggman. We don't see him eat a whole lot but he does have the girth. That and potentially an insatiable hunger for power.
Sloth: BiG tHe CaT!
Envy: Beta. We don't hear anything from him but it seemed like he envied Gamma's temporary place as top robot. But in Sonic X he does speak, and seemed desperate to prove himself to Eggman.
Either have adventure 3 or should be remake adventure 1 or 2. Subtract big story.
Sonic the hedgehog villains evil to most evil
Least Evil: Metal Sonic
Evil: Dr Eggman
Most Evil: Mephiles The Dark
@@elchido1874How is Metal Sonic the least evil?
@@rainbowtoyfunrandomess1982 because he is lack Of moral agency and normally Metal Sonic only obey Dr Eggman's orders
@@elchido1874 Oh yeah. I mean he is pretty emotionless except for being vengeful and being obsessed with beating his "loathsome copy."
I feel like robotnik semi redeemed himself at the end and the series ended here like it was supposed to then yeah he changed sides somewhat
Love this video
I like to think of these games as the true introduction of the Sonic the Hedgehog saga, leading up to Sonic Frontiers, even though the saga really began in the 2D games instead of the 3D games. I like the old Sonic cartoons, the anime Sonic X, and the latest series Sonic Prime. The beginning of Shadow’s story reminds me of Jibanyan from Yo-Kai Watch.
Shadow is in heroes and stuff. And mentioned in a lot of other games.
Your reason for Big being second is because of something not enjoyed by the player OUTSIDE OF THE GAME'S UNIVERSE?
A better reason would be because while he doesn't any bad, he doesn't do much good deeds to make an impact in the story either.
Really hoping for a Pokémon Scarlet and Violet good to evil with arven probably gold medal of good
The Knuckles Clan was ALWAYS a warrior tribe. Their warrior ways had nothing to do with why they were smoked by (Perfect) Chaos. I don't even think that them attempting to seize the Chaos Emeralds was the cause of their death(s).
What messed them over is when they started screwing with the Chao (and possibly Tikal).
Could you do injustice 1 and 2 characters good to evil
Castlevania good to evil
Multiversus good to evil
Sonic 06 Characters Good to Evil
*Can you make a scale between the good guys and the bad guys in Sans Rpg?*
Nintendo Princesses: Dumb to Brilliant
Can you do Sonic Rush and Sonic Rush Adventure Good to Evil
Attempt Number inf+1
Freedom Planet Good-to-Evil please
I recommend Playstation all stars for the Squid game format.
Darwin Medal: Big for losing Froggy every freaking time
Lust Medal: Amy for obvious reasons being her crush on Sonic
Greed and Wrath Medal: Eggman for wanting the people to surrender so he could build his eggman empire
Envy Medal: Chaos for his hatred for the echidna tribe for wiping out the chao
Pride Medal: Shadow come on, saying I'm the ultimate life form how could we not give this medal to anyone else
"I have an announcement"
Yo, do mk11 characters good to evil
Please do Terraria characters Good to Evil
Shadow should start grey area.
What about the Biolizard ?
The bio lizard would probably belong in the bad to evil category
Gta hd universe good to evil pls
When will everyone learn that Sonic Adventure 3 is not happening anytime soon? 😑
How about a Portal 1 and 2 good to evil? I would like to see that eventually.
Don’t know who would be the most good
@@liamtherobot9656 I think Doug Rattman is most good.
Need more Chao, Bell.
Please next do call of duty black ops 1 2 3 4 zombies characters good to evil
Request: Which sonic adventure 1 & 2 character would win the squid games?
I’m more of a Mario person, but I still respect enemies
Do sentenceing sonic vilans for there crimes
There is a script written for that. It just needs to be made into a video. I don't know when it will come out, but rest assured it's been in the works for a while just like this video was.
Sonic 06: good to evil
Good: Sonic
Neutral: Silver
Evil: Mephiles
Rouge and Shadow have absolutely zero reasons to be in the good territory. Rouge should at least be the first grey area character since she is a jewel thief. Not sure how that classifies as a good trait at all. Yes, she is a spy and isn't really all that antagonistic, but her entire arc in Knuckles' and her own story was to steal the Master Emerald and have it for herself since greed was one of her characters trait at the time.
Also, Shadow shouldn't even be in the good territory at all. Shadow's entire motive was to destroy the world because her friend died(because that's somehow good writing to everyone?). Shadow has zero justification for trying to destroy the world. Losing someone isn't a good way to justify someone being a good person when they're trying to destroy the Earth. You know what, I'll even be generous and say that he should be put in the bottom of the grey area due to his heroic act in the final story but the fact that he's in the good territory boggles my mind.
Another thing, I love how this video mentions that they would only include the characters exclusively to Adventure 1 and 2 and Sonic X to some extent, when Shadow the Hedgehog was partly why Gerald was given the bottom of the grey area. Take out the Shadow the Hedgehog story to Gerald's reason why he is at the bottom of the grey area while things may not be different, but it'll at least tell us that they're at least listening to their own rules.
The implication of putting him into good territory is that Shadow's revenge plot is because:
1)He is basically brainwashed into carrying out Gerald's will through the conditioning of a false memory about Maria's last wish
2)There is no evidence in Shadow's mind at least until Amy tries to reach out to him of there being any "good" people left after the ARK incident. Especially after Eggman, the first human he meets after being released from stasis basically wants to use him as a weapon exactly like GUN's Project Shadow.
Although, yes I agree Shadow is grey at best because he done both a lot of good and bad with endangering and then saving Earth.
Please do a Squid Games for My Hero Academia
I was actually here before 1k likes
Destroying government property is not by any means a 100% morally negative thing lol
do minecraft mobs good to evil
I did have a hunch that Maria would be the most good.
How about sentencing heroes and and good characters from films and games
I would love to see one on Sonic X
Can you please do a good to evil and sentence for crimes for the bully? I think Peter would be gold metal of good because he helps Jimmy Hawkins and Russell bring peace in the school but doesn't fight anyone. Silver metal good would be Zoey because she barely seen, but since meet Jimmy Hawkins breaking townie based. Bronze metal good, I would say principle Doctor cravelsnitch Because he might harsh to his students but he likes principle pickles from Reese which just cared about there students. Bronze metal of evil I give to Lola and lust metal because she date boy like Johnny Vincent and gorde and townie to create a massive rumble in the town. Silver metal of evil would Mr.burton for having Jimmy Hawkins steal panties from girls dorm,accusing Jimmy of starting a fire in gym and hitting on his students. I would give gold metal of evil and the wrath metal to Gary Smith, who cause the massive battle in school and kidnapping doctor cravelsnitch and tricking everyone to do his work. I would give sloth metal to mr.Gallaway, who was mostly drunk until Jimmy fixed his problems, and greed metal goes to mr.hattrick, who takes bribes from the preps,jocks and greaser. Evny metal I would give to Edgar as he help Jimmy Hawkins after beating up but start burning the trophies of Dorby and setting the gym on fire and send rats to the library and putting Johnny Vincent in crazy hospital just because Edgar hates Bullworth Academy because he never had enough money to go the school and because Gary Smith told him to do it.
Nice
Do Sonic X Characters: Good To Evil!
Where are beta and the bio lizard?
Do Hunie pop good to evil
Hunie pop Squid game
Sonic adventure 1 rules
Shadow is in other games..
1up binge sonic Adventures 1 and 2 video GOOD TO EVIL
19:30 you know what you did 😏
Sonic villains bad to evil