How to end homelessness | Marybeth Shinn | TEDxNashvilleSalon

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @matthewdancz9152
    @matthewdancz9152 10 місяців тому +12

    You know, you could just CAP rental prices. This will force all these private equity investing companies from jacking rental rates through the roof, and they will begin looking at other parts of the economy to destroy with over investment.

    • @matthewdancz9152
      @matthewdancz9152 10 місяців тому +7

      I can also point out that 30% of $0.00 is $0.00. Gaining employment, which seems to be increasingly rare in the AI dominated world is becoming harder and harder. Autistic individuals are the most impacted. Homelessness will never be ended as long as bad actors seek to make money through rental payments on properties they don't own. The problem is over priced rental units, but this problem will never go aways as the demand for rentals is always increasing and there is little economic incentive for the private sector to build more units to make prices come down. It isn't about political will, as most of our political elite make their money using the current free market incentives.
      They don't fix the problem, because they have every personal interest reason to not fix it, and no genuine reason to fix the problem. Their children are set for life.

    • @RuneValken
      @RuneValken 9 місяців тому +2

      Let's say they cap rents at 1000/month. Mortgages, property taxes, utilities, repair costs, and insurance keep going up. When those costs exceed the rents no one would keep rentals. They'd sell them to owner occupants or at best be slumlords, because they can't afford repairs. For rents to go down you have to make it cheaper to buy or build a house or apartments.

    • @Gamingetic
      @Gamingetic 6 місяців тому +3

      @@RuneValken And where landlords shirk their duties, the government should come in and 'alleviate' them of the 'burden' of being a renter. Then institute a rent-to-buy scheme in all public housing to allow renters to become homeowners and to prevent the need for the government to provide long-term services such as providing repairs.

    • @mollyprysunka7741
      @mollyprysunka7741 4 місяці тому

      @@RuneValkenhow about you can’t rent to anyone until you own out right? And then put hella regulations on owning multiple homes and price gouging. There’s no way they don’t know how to fix this

  • @SpeedOfNorris
    @SpeedOfNorris Рік тому +2

    Great TedXTalk Marybeth Shinn!
    I agree with your steps to take on improving the lives of unhoused people.

  • @martinbrousseau2560
    @martinbrousseau2560 Рік тому +7

    Unfortunately housing is the quick n easier answer.
    The long answer also requires looking at mental health care, community, hobbies, learning new skills.

    • @Paul-Meister-999
      @Paul-Meister-999 7 місяців тому +1

      And drug and alcohol addiction. Mental hospitals for those who need them. So much funding is needed, then when you get some funding it is often wasted.

  • @gplunk
    @gplunk Рік тому +8

    The real issue with the Sec. 8 voucher system is the difficulty in finding a landlord who will accept one. Even though there are many HUD properties out there; they typically have long wait lists for an actual unit. Other non gov't assisted properties will covertly deny voucher tenants; simply by not responding to their query, or stating that there are no current vacancies....

    • @jamesphillips5073
      @jamesphillips5073 7 місяців тому +2

      Here in Tucson, landlords are no longer allowed to decline Section 8 vouchers.

    • @mollyprysunka7741
      @mollyprysunka7741 4 місяці тому +1

      That’s crazy. Can you imagine if hospitals could decline to accept and treat Medicare patients?

    • @gplunk
      @gplunk 4 місяці тому

      Lack of housing is not viewed as a potential life threatening emergency....

  • @gloricaaxox
    @gloricaaxox 2 роки тому +18

    Wow, this is really powerful and so well put. I hope more people continue to think like this and share this message. Coming from Colombia and living in Canada now, I have seen a lot and it has always broke my heart to see the injustice in the world. Thank you for sharing this message.

  • @kevinharrison3265
    @kevinharrison3265 Рік тому +1

    Amen Sister! ❤

  • @GiselleReviews
    @GiselleReviews Рік тому +2

    Wonderfully, stated and thanks for the Ted talk. ❤❤❤💯

  • @alexisabercrombie133
    @alexisabercrombie133 2 роки тому +2

    Put in the resources.

  • @AntonioGracia-bl2mu
    @AntonioGracia-bl2mu 7 місяців тому +2

    Even though i might unrecognizable I'm still alive.

  • @joerobi2652
    @joerobi2652 Рік тому +19

    Nothing is going to change, the video is a year old and homeless just keeps getting worse. I've been homeless for three years. I don't even dream of living in a home again. Homes are a luxury like private jets and yachts. We need to start teaching children how to survive without a home in schools because this problem is never going to get better.

    • @talesin7070
      @talesin7070 9 місяців тому +3

      Look I didn't know your story, but I've been homeless for a year and a half. It's tough and getting tougher. Keep looking until you find a program that can help you is all I can say. One day we'll fix this.

    • @KRobinson-ko1ne
      @KRobinson-ko1ne 5 місяців тому

      You seriously believe we need to teach that to children?
      This is outrageous! We need rent assistance programs, affordable housing and safety nets

    • @mollyprysunka7741
      @mollyprysunka7741 4 місяці тому

      @@KRobinson-ko1nemean while they’ve know we need that funding and assistance and they aren’t interested in helping people who need it. Need ≠ demand. The govt should have protected us

    • @Sam-c7y9d
      @Sam-c7y9d 24 дні тому

      Get a job, one already knows how to live below you means, save money by using all the secices out there, food, showers, etc. above all change your attitude and perspective, don't make it harder than it really is...speaking from exspirience

  • @ivanpadilla1936
    @ivanpadilla1936 7 місяців тому +3

    Another factor is giving the homeless purpose in life. If someone is used to living on the streets and doing whatever they want, then assimilating into the “normal world” will be close to impossible.

    • @gplunk
      @gplunk 4 місяці тому +2

      Yep; it's very hard to get back into the 'swing', when you've been down and out for so long....

    • @KRobinson-ko1ne
      @KRobinson-ko1ne 4 місяці тому +1

      They still need a base of operations and a place to sleep indoors at all times
      The shelters, women’s centers, halfway houses etc

    • @Sam-c7y9d
      @Sam-c7y9d 24 дні тому

      Exactly

  • @matieurod752
    @matieurod752 Рік тому +1

    Some valuable points made here by her certainly. But her simply stating , Oh and the solution is housing , when I’m the beginning stating that’s all she hears from people In meetings she attends . Nice Ted talk though mam !

  • @EliStettner
    @EliStettner Рік тому +3

    Y'all should add some subtitles

    • @FirstNameLastName-m3e
      @FirstNameLastName-m3e Місяць тому

      You can choose ' Captions" from the menu in the upper right.

    • @EliStettner
      @EliStettner Місяць тому +2

      @@FirstNameLastName-m3e I don't remember if they had captions disabled when I first posted this. I might have been referring to them using auto-generated captions instead of paying for human captioning.

  • @michaelsantangelo6192
    @michaelsantangelo6192 Рік тому +14

    Rich people simply don't care about homeless people at all.

    • @georgewagner7787
      @georgewagner7787 Рік тому +1

      Untrue. My bil is wealthy and is on the board of a nonprofit that trains young men for employment

    • @PurpleDemonZombie
      @PurpleDemonZombie Рік тому +2

      @@georgewagner7787 what happens when people who aren't
      Young becomes homeless

  • @hippieJOSH420
    @hippieJOSH420 Рік тому +9

    Raising the minimum wage actually creates more homelessness. The answer is to reduce the cost of living

    • @claytonmorada
      @claytonmorada 9 місяців тому +2

      The research I have read says the opposite of this statement. Where are your citations?

    • @hippieJOSH420
      @hippieJOSH420 9 місяців тому

      @@claytonmorada My citations are the history since we've 've been raising minimum wage since the late '80s. Every time. Minimum wage hikes the homeless population hikes. If you're going to double what the federal momentum wage is then you're going to eat up the middle class. The guy making $11 an hour now is going to make the same amount as the guy that was making 7.25. The guy that is making $16 an hour which was more than double of minimum wage will not only be making a dollar more than minimum wage. You can't keep raising minimum wage and not expecting prices to increase which hurts everybody. The only thing that benefits everybody is lowering the cost of living and that can be done the same way as raising the minimum wage, through legislation

    • @talesin7070
      @talesin7070 9 місяців тому +1

      So incredibly wrong. Cost of living is always going to increase because of inflation. Minimum wage should at least increase at the speed of inflation.

    • @KRobinson-ko1ne
      @KRobinson-ko1ne 27 днів тому

      There’s a LOT of different necessities
      Trying to put a cap on prices is a start but we all the assistance programs we can get: everyone needs to be guaranteed food and shelter of some source. And I don’t mean under a bridge or an opportunity to work which is just a removal of even more taxes and more government regulations for business owners!

  • @svtjones
    @svtjones Рік тому +6

    She is only has book knowledge in regards to homelessness and drug abuse. She obviously walked the streets, interacted with the people and seen what really goes on. That’s the problem with people like her. They make plans for fixes that aren’t based in reality. Her “fixes” work for some on the streets, but don’t work for the majority. I’d can talk about this for hours.

    • @Gamingetic
      @Gamingetic 6 місяців тому +4

      You should share what you believe the real solutions are, then

    • @mollyprysunka7741
      @mollyprysunka7741 4 місяці тому +1

      Then what is your perfect plan that’s both based on reality and solution focused?

  • @billyoumans1784
    @billyoumans1784 4 місяці тому +2

    The conservative movement stands directly in the way of funding any of this, even as its constituents gain billions.

    • @FirstNameLastName-m3e
      @FirstNameLastName-m3e Місяць тому

      False. Homelessness is lower in red states. Compare SF , NYC or L.A
      to other states. Conservatives are hardly all, nor majority wealthy.

    • @Sam-c7y9d
      @Sam-c7y9d 24 дні тому

      Wrong the democrats created and support it with their polocies. Teaching one morals , work skills, responsibility, paying their own way, etc. is the conservative way. Democrats do none of this, there way is to give handouts and encourage homeless to rely on them and government.

  • @MarySchipke-dg7dg
    @MarySchipke-dg7dg 7 місяців тому

    Homelessness is "Big Business" and the Homeless Industrial Complex will always profit from the misery of the homeless. Cut these thieves and frauds out of the homeless equation and homelessness will disappear. Issue gov't homeless benefits to the homeless - like disability checks to the disabled or unemployment checks to the unemployed.

  • @brianhay4024
    @brianhay4024 Рік тому +3

    Her ideas seem aspirational at best and not grounded in reality.

    • @mollyprysunka7741
      @mollyprysunka7741 4 місяці тому +2

      Then what is the solution for real? So tired of “well that won’t work! Idk what will, but we sure shouldn’t try THAT person’s plan. What’s my plan? I don’t have one.”

  • @bryanrusth338
    @bryanrusth338 11 місяців тому +2

    Clearly this lady has never interacted with a homeless person

  • @kevinspangler4907
    @kevinspangler4907 Рік тому

    Resentment is the root

  • @georgewagner7787
    @georgewagner7787 Рік тому +3

    In new york, shelters are the only affordable housing now.

  • @nazlozcelik255
    @nazlozcelik255 2 роки тому +4

    Why humans only thinking own. This' s looking world and world economic problems but if thinking everything we saw it.. people dead peole cry ...

  • @georgewagner7787
    @georgewagner7787 Рік тому

    Not also. Instead. Build affordable housing now. Don't throw money down the toilet by subsidizing People's rent for years on end. Build them housing

  • @GroMoe
    @GroMoe Рік тому

    Ha....They will never end homeless....people wake up! Homelessness is used as leverage. Not to mention all the people getting rich helping the homeless. Basically it's like this. Homeless people are worth more homeless than they are in houses. Wake up.

    • @masondrip42
      @masondrip42 9 місяців тому

      damn

    • @RuneValken
      @RuneValken 9 місяців тому +1

      I can think of very few people who could profit off of homelessness. But very many who profit off of you owning a home. Every plumber, roofer, electrician, landscaper, etc. Every Home Depot or Lowes or home decorating store benefits from you having a home.

    • @masondrip42
      @masondrip42 9 місяців тому

      both realities are true. the homeless are a leveraging tool for the rich, middle class and lower middle class. while simultaneously every home owner is sucked dry while told her happy you’re in the home owners club. the homeless doesn’t gain anything from its perceptional power; and the homeowner never quites gets the feeling of being in power over anything but it’s right to be enslaved by agenda politics, western culture and american greed.

    • @FirstNameLastName-m3e
      @FirstNameLastName-m3e Місяць тому

      ​@@RuneValkenPeople who own companies providing help, assistance to the homeless who do business with state government to that effect.

    • @KRobinson-ko1ne
      @KRobinson-ko1ne 27 днів тому

      I admit: at a younger age I’d think you were being tin foil headed. It took Donald trump becoming president and modern day plague to confirm this

  • @AntonioGracia-bl2mu
    @AntonioGracia-bl2mu 7 місяців тому

    No I didn't still alive.

  • @KoreyThatcher
    @KoreyThatcher Рік тому

    Why don’t we just get rid of paying rent and have the federal government buy the rental homes and give them to the renters? Also get rid of mortgages. Everyone has already been paid. Nobody loses anything

    • @masondrip42
      @masondrip42 9 місяців тому

      the most hippie thing i’ve heard in my life. i don’t agree with the government daddy paying for everyone’s house.

    • @leahp1765
      @leahp1765 6 місяців тому

      ​@aco762poor Cuba?

    • @FirstNameLastName-m3e
      @FirstNameLastName-m3e Місяць тому

      Wasn't that what they tried to do with Fannie and Freddie that brought the economy to its knees?

  • @the_yungchubbz
    @the_yungchubbz 2 роки тому +2

    If you close your eyes, this lady sounds like an intellectual Kermit. 😂

  • @AntonioGracia-bl2mu
    @AntonioGracia-bl2mu 7 місяців тому

    No I'm white actually,but I'm alive

  • @Str8Lace211
    @Str8Lace211 Рік тому +1

    omg that is all cap

  • @jordanmensah3116
    @jordanmensah3116 2 роки тому +7

    She sounds like kermit the frog

  • @Str8Lace211
    @Str8Lace211 Рік тому

    cap