The Ultimate Sonic Colors comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 сер 2024
- In this video I took 4 games and made a comparison. Sonic Colors (Dolphin),
Sonic Forces, Sonic Generations and Sonic Colors Ultimate by Gamespot was also included.
Intro - 0:00
Tropical Resort act 1(Dolphin)- 0:20
Tropical Resort act 1(Ultimate)- 2:19
Tropical Resort act 1(Generations)- 4:27
Tropical Resort act 1(Forces)- 5:55
Mods Used:
Tropical Resort act 1(forces) www.nexusmods.com/sonicforces...
Tropical Resort (Generations): • Sonic Generations - Tr...
Sonic Colors Ultimate footage: • Sonic Colors: Ultimate...
Twitch ID: iconic_studios13
Join my discord server (13+ only):
/ discord
follow me on Twitter: @IconicStudiosyt
Like and Subscribe for 1000 days
#IconicStudios - Ігри
This is so well edited, why isnt it famous?
Thanks but I am still learning after effects and other Adobe stuff the quality will improve even more over time
Well now it's famous
6:57 the way that Sonic loses all his speed when falling is just painful to watch. 😖
Some mods fix it but I kept every thing vanilla
BTW did you like this video if yes please subscribe I am so close to 100 subs
Não e não
Forces game engine is so garbage
@@neb9625 no it isn't they just used it badly
WOAH Sonic forces is so DARK!!!
I know better than every other stage in which it feels like the sun is directly on top of the stage lol
people who made that custom level had no idea of cameras and lighting
I just don't like the lighting in Forces in general, so it's obviously a problem if you wanna make a level on it.
Ladies and gentlemen; The Hedgehog Engine 2
@@B0UB3RT I think it works well in the base game, just not in mods
You can tell Sega dropped the ball in forces when the games are compared, forces unfortunately falls flat on its face. However i will give them props for creating a lighting engine in 4 years and completing a fully functioning game in a year. Sad that forces isn't getting it's rushed face a chance to shine due to the horrible backlash, hope the next game is great! (Honestly I'm glad Sega is taking there time with this next game.)
correction the game engine was made in 3 years and the game was made in 1 year
BTW if you liked this video please subscribe and watch my other videos we are so close to 100 subs
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator no yeah, 3 years my bad, mixed up my math and numbers...
And sure, I'll sub. I enjoyed this vid so why not :3
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator i feel like that correction was a nick pick, but who am i to talk honestly lol
@@jimmysmomschannel NOO ONE ASKED U BUCKO!!!!
don’t be offended pls. I’m just being a J A on purpose.
Just imagine unleashed mods. Man these levels would look and play so well with unleashes controls and physics
There are many unleashed mods heck I made tutorials how to install them check those out they aren't anything too big yet...
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator I know thay exists but I mean like for pc. I want a pc remaster for unleashed like colours. For easier modification
@@mr0easy it's as easy as generations
BTW can you please subscribe if you liked the video
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator I’ll sub when it’s consistently good content
Personally I like how Colors Ultimate is darker, just feels a little more accurate to being in space. The bloom is definitely too high, but I like the darkness with the florescent lights
@TSG4 Finally someone understood this
BTW is this video worthy for your sub if it is please subscribe it helps me out a lot we are so close to 100 subs
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator sure man, I respect the hustle, I gotchu
@@nickname2239 yeah I agree, which is why I like how the lights are more florescent, but I just think the bloom is too high, especiallyon Sonic's model. If they did more natural lighting it could've looked even better than it does, but I still think it looks good as it is especially in person
@@nickname2239 yeah it is, but I personally prefer the darker look because honestly I kinda forget the original is in space
6:02 That timing tho
The boost? That was intentional
I tried the thing with almost all the versions of the stage
Sonic Generations is definitely the best
Yeah and I was planning to add reshade.
The reboosted mod is sure a lot better than the original, to bad SEGA didn't change the level designe of some levels for ultimate
@@shidac39 agreed, if ultimate had an option to have generations style levels and the rings filling the boost guage, that would have been AWESOME!
I wish you could change it to unleashed/gens boost
@@Omen_SMK agreed
Honestly, I think the original still looks the best, technical stuff notwithstanding. I think ultimate might be my second favorite here, but it’s close with gens. Ultimate just looks a little slicker to me, probably because the game looks blown out instead of oversaturated. Forces doesn’t look like it was correctly ported
Here's where all of them win:
Colors: Music
Ultimate: Customization
Forces: Visuals
Generations: Fun
OMG you are THE sonic apocalypse gaming I am a huge fan thank you for watching this video.
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator oh np! I was meaning to make this kind of video myself but you did a splendid job, so I don't have to haha
@@SoniaSpectrum Thanks this was my first time using after effects and premiere pro I am glad you liked it
hey i was wondering would you like to join my discord server i mean if you want to link in the desc.
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator that's amazing! Especially for a first time! I wish I had those programs bc I have a few ideas for a physics swap video that would need precise editing with a menu, but until then I'll just keep doing what I'm doing lol. I look forward to seeing more videos from u though!
Here is the updated version of this video it has better graphics I didn't change much as I was in a hurry as my exams are going on. Here: ua-cam.com/video/bIsPuOAR4kU/v-deo.html
I legit thought the Generations one was real for a sec cuz i never played generations 😂
I don’t think the tropical resort mod is forces being bad, it’s more likely the mod creator’s fault, as other stages such as the space one in forces have a darker environment and can very easily make them look good, this is definitely on the mod creator, he didn’t put effort to make the stage look good, anyways uh normal colors wins in my opinion.
Visually i would pick generations, gameplay i would pick ultimate
@@jimmysmomschannel and for nostalgia I'd pick Sonic Colors.
@@roby4504 I'm not big on nostalgia, plus i'd still pick ultimate in that category.
Hello Ring 👁️👁️
Every Sonic Game have Sonic Colors Stages like Tropical Resort,Sweet Mountain,Starlight Carnival,Planet Wisp,Aguarium Park,Asteroid Coaster and Terminal Velocity!
Great comparison bro👍🏾
Glad you liked it!
Generations will always be the best, here is my ranking for each version!!! 1st place: Generations, 2nd place: Ultimate, 3rd place: Original, 4th place: forces, now to name each best thing about each game!!! Generations: Boosting and character/level design and effects/lighting, Ultimate: Customization and quality improvements/lighting, Original: lack of glitches on certain consoles and good quality for its time, Forces: Visuals [nothing more, that's how bad forces is and how good generations is].
Seeing Colors and Colors Ultimate back to back....god, what a horrible remaster.
Also, very nice editing! You're well on your way with getting good with Premiere Pro!
Well the menu was made in after effects but thx and also please subscribe if you liked this video.
Everyone is complaining about Sonic colours ultimate, and to be honest, I don't see how it's so bad.
The lighting is wayyyy better, and it looks good too.
@@MyNamesNoahIt may not seem like it but the game actually looks beautiful when you play it yourself i have both the pc and switch version and they both look beautiful
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator Yeah, I never said that the lighting was bad, I said that Sonic Colours Ultimate looks amazing.
@@MyNamesNoah colors ultimate is an underrated Emerald
6:49 me when someone tell me to volume up the music when im pissed off
for real its funny how the music gets louder with the boost XDD
Wow 7k views well we did it people you can enjoy more epic content like this by subscribing it's free and you don't wanna miss out a Collab with a certain youtuber that is coming out soon
The OG Sonic Colours is my favourite. I also love the visuals, aesthetics and vibrant lighting of it much more than the others.
Me too! I didn't apply the HD texture pack here but even with basic upscalling this games holds up amazingly!
1k views OMG this means the world to me please check out my other videos and please subscribe
5K VIEWS OMG. Never thought I'd hit this many anyway please check out my other videos and please subscribe ✌️
I am reuploding this video except all games will be pushed to their limits. Also subscribe if you wanna see that
Even if 10% of you guys subscribed i can get about 2k subs so pls subscribe it's free and helps me out alot
i did
@@jadz120 thank you soo much
np!
ok, me inscrevi 🙂👍
im gona sub to! NICE WORK! 😄😄@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator 😄😀😆
Huh 6k views I don't know what to say if you can just subscribe and check out my other videos it would me Happy
WE DID IT!!! 3k Views Wow this video really blew up if you would subscribe i will be very happy you will make my day by just pressing a button
I actually started learning premier pro for my channel and college just waiting to get a MacBook now
It has a steep learning curve. I am still learning the basics but good luck
You can see the struggle in the forces gameplay. Lol
Fr 😭
16k views I am quite surprised well please subscribe and like the video
In sonic forces i feel like running slow while boosting in 2d sections
Ok 12k this is crazy please subscribe.
Some things of note about the Forces version:
1. Why’s Sonic’s voice different?
2. How is the lighting WORSE than Ultimate’s?
3. Why’s the boosted music sound so awful?
1. It's the Japanese voice for sonic.
2. Either the mod creator screwed something up or that type of lighting is not supported by he2
3. Idk lol
With the lightning it's because the creator of the mod just ported the geometry and every other aspects of the Gens mod and since Gens has a nerfed lighting system unlike Forces or even Unleashed it looks this amateur
Answering to the 2nd question:
FOR REAL! Even Ultimate looks awesome compared to Forces! Either the creator screwed up something or tried to be the most close possible to Forces' visuals lol
If you want to join my discord server the link is in the description
*Slides Into Wisp Container*
Me: NANI?!
What if Eggman actually rebuilt the Tropical Resort during the war in Sonic Forces?
For instance; He builds a smaller version of it near Mystic Jungle.
Well then in his og plan after taking over the world he would rule the world and run an amusement park lmao
subtitles: epic
Lol idk why I added that I guess I was experimenting
To break everything down
Hedgehog Engine 1: An absolute banger engine when it comes to technical ambitions and gorgeous effects, lighting, and animation.
Hedgehog Engine 2: A decent engine with Higher Quality Texture work, better lighting, nice screen spaces reflections, and massive stages that stretch out way off into the distance.
I messed up in the level select a sound is supposed to be played but if you enjoyed the video please subscribe
Edit: 2.5K VIEWS OMG please subscribe and check out my other videos
seeing this and the time of events by any chance did you see my comparison video and took inspiration or was this a coincidence?
Well I don't remember seeing your video at that time.. it was something I wanted to do once the GameSpot footage rolled out 😅
Still I saw the video you are referring to and yea that's a strange coincidence lol
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator lol
why are you not using higher resolution footage of Sonic Colors Footage from dolphin? .. also, theres a discord notification at 0:52
I am using 1440p sonic colors upscaled and I know I have a discord notification on 0:52
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator you should probably upload a fixed version where you dont have that notification, and turn on anti aliasing on dolphin too, the settings you choose to represent the game with, i do not consider to be either optimal or fair, since all other versions have antialisasing enabled. i hope your channel has a bright future.
Colors ultimate because it actually looks like a remake not like generations, tho generations is way better than forces
hey did you like the video? if yes please subscribe 9 more subs then we will be at 100 subs
is the sonic generations one modded? i've never seen that in game before.
Yeah it's modded
Roses are red
Containers have lids
Why don't people close discord
When they record vids
I forgor 💀
Both Generations and Forces play fine. But the thing is, Generations physics make quite a difference when playing Colors on it. It isn't as natural. Forces is also super weird. Sonic while boosting, goes faster in the 3D sections, and slower in the 2D sections. And some more stuff, too. Sorry, but i have to give it to Colors Ultimate.
Yeah I agree.. colors ultimate is a great choice!
epic
Imagine if I hit 30k views on this video before I hit 200 subs
If only they just modified Generations for the Colors remaster...
It’s just a shame they couldn’t combine both act 1 & 2 like how it was originally *BIG SAD
Did u know there's a fifth Tropical Resort? Is on the 3DS version of Sonic Generations but almost nobody knows about it...
If you are getting technical there is the ds version too
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator yeah...
1 MONTH LATE SQUAD WHERE YOU AT?!?!?!?!!!!!?!!!!!!!?!??!?!?!?
I just watched this vid but I don't wanna subscribe right now(69 subs)
As soon as that goes up tho then you'll have an guaranteed subscriber
Nice
OMG did they really not change the level at all for generations????? I had never noticed this before😂
They merged act 1 and 2 but I stopped at the end of act 1
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator But still, it was beat for beat the exact same level geometry. And then I had no idea it was in forces because I never bought forces. It doesn't surprise me knowing the way they made that game lol
@@P8NPrivTV well I bought forces when it was on sale for about 300 rupees or around 2.56$
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator righteous bucks. great purchase
You probably didn't notice because it isn't actually in the game. This video shows off a Tropical Resort level mod that recreates the level exactly in generations, as well as a similar mod for forces.
Just a reminder that the original name of sonic generations was sonic colors 2
Damn I didn't knew that.. thx for the info lol
Source?
Actually sonic colors was originally a will port of generations they just made a different game for the wii when they realised that generations would have been impossible to port to it.
I think u mixed up colors with 06..
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator 06 was going on the will but ultimately became sonic and the secret rings
Really sad that the fanmade port on a game about 10 years older looks so much better than the remake...
I liked generations style and ultimate style
100 subs!!! wow check out my latest 100 sub collab with sonic apocalypse gaming its just like this one but better ua-cam.com/video/Eaycyt_kzrQ/v-deo.html. Also subscribe!!
The Forces and Generations ones are mods?
yup
0:52 discord alert is crazy
I forgot to put it on do not disturb lol
Na minha opinião eu gostei mais do generations, tem um tom de cor mais vivo as iluminações mais claras etc. Realmente gostei do Mod. Agora o Sonic Forces a fase parece não estar muito viva (é apenas minha opinião)
Forces looked TO dark
Now that Colors ultimate exists, I just want unleashed ultimate.
Yeah me too
its not needed tho
@@jimmysmomschannel it's DESPERATELY needed. Have you SEEN how unleashed runs? And besides, it's stranded on Xbox 360 and PS3. And neither of them is the Definitive version. I think it's about time for a current gen release.
@@thefollower2933 Ara ara, get with the times my guy. The game is on PSnow (its ass but its there) and it's on Series X through backwards compatibility which runs the game 4k60, also Xbox one also got an update for 4k (no 60fps tho).
No the game is NOT in 60fps on xbox series x
How to make Sonic Forces a good game: make it a different game
True frr 🤣
DS?
generation is the best +1like
glad you enjoyed it would mean the world to me if you subscribed too
i guess 19.6k people think otherwise
5:57
see this is what i hate abt forces
sonic doesnt gain his speed consistently like in older games, he just instantly goes from fairly slow to fast like how do u mess that up in a PLATFORMER
Well a basic answer is.. it's forces.. a more complex answer is.. they use a modified character controller of lost world in forces.. the run button stuff didn't translate properly in forces so we get this janky mess lol
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator also the weird turning from lost world where he basically moves slower when going left an right
LIKE WHYYY
It kinda made sense in lost world bc of the curved terrain BUT NOT HERE 😭
@@bubblebuddy1 well it's the same answer... the character controller of lost world is used here lol
What about Sonic Unleashed? It introduced the Hedgehog Engine and in my opinion it's better than any of these 3 games. Although I love all 4 of them :)
Man i dont think there is a tropical resort mod for su
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator I would like to watch it. Cuz this was a very interesting video. Liked it.
Now how in the hell does Forces look better than Colors Ultimate??????
In my opinion it doesn't look better lol Forces lacks proper lighting and just the visual polish of SCU
Sonic forces lighting looks really bad.
The stage just really isn't meant for the engine.
That isn't true, the mod creator literally didn't add lighting, they just copy & pasted the geometry and textures from the generations mod.
How does forces simultaneously look the best and worst
Because it's forces
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator Its because none of the lighting objects were imported. Any stage would look bad in any lighting engine if you remove the lighting, its nothing to do with forces.
@@radio6sussex823 i get that but I was just trying to make a forces joke lol
Rip Sonic Colors DS edition nobody talks about it :(
i was first considering including that but I wanted the 3d version of tropical resort so i left it out
Ey chief your missing the DS version
Yeaaa ik.. I honestly couldn't get my ds emulator working and I could have fixed it.. but I needed to get the video out.. atleast that's what I remember.. I could redo this video soon with My better skills if u want me to. I don't have a problem with that
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator nah it's fine it's just the DS version may not be the best version but it's a damn fine good 2D adaptation
0:51 someone forgot to turn off Discord
haha
Generations is the definitive winner
Yeah sure it's your opinion I love ultimate personally
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator I have no problem with that, still I liked the generations one
Should I be surprised the Sonic Forces version looks so terrible?
No, but if you like my videos consider subscribing
Generations looks beyond amazing
Forces just looks utter garbage
Sonic generations 3ds where???
Well... I didn't have it at that time lol😅😅
Why is Unleashed not involved
Because there is no tropical resort mod for unleashed..
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator thanks
*sonic colors DS has left the chat*
It's 2D and I forgot!! 😭
How did SEGA butcher such a good song so badly?
It's fine my main issue is the piano it feels out of place
Why does SCU ost lack energy???
I don't know sound good to me
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator not saying it's bad or anything, the original soundtrack just sounds better imo...
I mean yeah some parts of the ost are better in the og version
@@fanerplay9468 I think some point In the future they’ll make a better tropical remix
Maybe there is a 0.00001% chance they would do that
Imagine sonic generations having a colors dlc
That would be great
Tropical resort was in Sonic Generations
@@t0biascze644 no it wasn't it is a mod not an original DLC
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator Its in the Nintendo 3DS version of Generations
IDK about other versions
@@t0biascze644 well technically it was the DS version of the game and not the wii version
yikes, just when you think ultimate is bad, here comes forces.
The lighting is awful I was too focused on getting a "good run" I didn't notice it that much but when explored the stage with free cam I noticed many missing materials and lighting effects.
Sonic colors is 14 years old colors ultimate is 3 years old sonic forces is 7 years old Sonic generations is 13 years old
Colors Ultimate is definitely the best!!
Unpopular opinion but eh I mean it's definitely better than forces
Sonic colors ultimate is fun
it sure is
Forces is so painful to watch
Y el de Ds?
non nous je n'ai fait que les jeux 3d
g a m e s t o p
What?
hey if you liked this video please subscribe we are soo close to 100 subs
how is it forces still looks the worst
tbh my ranking from best to worst is
the original
generations
ultimate
forces.
(the original and generations are at a tie.)
I will switch up original and ultimate
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator sorry those 2 are not interchangeable on this list.
@@ZUnknownFox well its your opinion and i respect it but i love ultimate
why did you say "still" its the modder's fault the lighting doesn't exist not the engine
ah 8k views if only some of the people subscribed
I will bro 👍
When at 0:52 has discord?
@@arrafinoferdian1326 i know i know i forgot to put it on do not disturb
Tell you what, the people that watched this think it’s great video but are to lazy to move a muscle and push the subscribe button
@Agoti that is true but one more sub and we will be at 100 and I will release a video on par or even better than this
Sonic Colors 10/10
Sonic generations 10/10
Ultimeit 10/10
Forces8/10
9:40a.m. 10/10/2021
umm
@@IconicStudiosTheAnimator YEAHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!
Sonic forces they didn’t even try
Forces always looks so stiff to play ugh.
Me gusto mas el de generations
Seguro que me encantan los colores por excelencia aunque
Me gusta mucho los colores
Bro its crazy how bad forces looks, the lighting looks like a generic sonic roblox fan games lighting 💀
Yea... problem is with the mod tho... it doesn't have proper light maps baked in
The forces acceleration is awful🤮
İ dont know how but generations looking best and most fun to play.
My game sonic foces game. Ps4
Sonic Forces continues to dissapoint.
Sonic *Forces* you to be disappointed