Servo Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2019
- Please watch my updated video instead, for a much better testing procedure. The results are pretty interesting • Servo Test - 7 popular...
Here is a quick comparative test showing the relative speeds and centring between the "towerpro"/Racerstar MG90S, EMAX ES08MA II, EMAX ES3352, and Corona DS939HV.
TL;DW go for the EMAX servos.
The MG90S was the fastest of the servos, but was jittery at 6V
The EMAX ES08MA II is a decent all round servo and is shallow if you’re short on space.
The EMAX ES3352 is a great servo and thin, so can fit in thinner wings and tails.
The Corona DS939HV is a total let down. At 6V is works fine, but has lower specs than the other servos on test. At 7.4V, the range of the servo is great reduced. Corona are supposed to be the next step up from EMAX level servos, but in this test it was completely out classed.
If you found my videos useful, and would like to leave me a little tip, you could always buy me a Coffee at www.mrd-rc.com/go/ko-fi/
Really useful information, I have been using the EMAX ES08MD and Tower Pro MG90D's and found them both to be pretty good so far.
I’ll be doing another test soon, which will be a bit more scientific. Both those servos will be in the new test. I’ve used the ES08MA II servos quite a lot, and they’ve been really reliable. The video will pop up here and in the Fixed Wing RC Rebels Facebook group.
I'm glad I watched this before ordering. If you look at the specs between the two emax servos the only difference in size on paper is the thickness. But seeing them side by side the digital is not only thinner, but also quite longer. Now I understand why everyone who upgrades their axial scx24 uses the analog and not the digital.
The digital EMAX servo in this video is for slightly different purposes than the ES08MA II. However, there is also an ES08MD II which has an identical case.
Hey my fellow rocker! Lol thanks for video 🤘🤘
Very helpful video, thanks. If i wanted to run 4 of the ES3352 servos what kind of battery pack should i use? Its for a glider. Ta.
Would be funny to see them with some load.
I've had a few of the towerpro mg90 lock up under load when reaching their endpoints, both on a smaller wing and when used on the tail of a Volantex Ranger EX.
Only running emax servos these days, have not had any accidents with them.
I’m planning another test soon with some other servos as well as these, minus the Corona. That will have a test to see how much it can pul. However, it will probably be different to being in use all the time. I tend to use the EMAX ES08MA II servos. I have the digital version of that servo coming for the test, and the digital version of the MG90S, which is supposed to be vastly better than the analogue.
do the emax servos only turn 90 degree or 180 degree
Thanks for sharing.
Do you recommend getting the ES3352 vs ES08MD ?
I have been using the ES08MAII but looking for upgrade to digital servos for fpv.
If you’re happy with the performance of the ES08MA II, I’d just go to the ES08MD II. The ES3352 are a bit more powerful, but are a different shape (taller and thinner). The ES08MD II would be a straight swap.
Another thingvto compare us resolution smoothness. A lot of cheap servos are geared higher to achieve higher speeds but the trade of with that is lower resolution and a gritty movement as well as poor centering
I am coming up with a new testing procedure. Smoothness would be hard to quantify I think. But resolution would be simpler.
Here’s what I have so far. I’d welcome feedback. www.mrd-rc.com/tutorials-tools-and-testing/methodologies/servo-testing-methodology/
6:12 ".... that's really scientific " hahahahaha
You've got to laugh at yourself sometimes xD
Thanks for testing. Do you think the Emax ES08MD digital is worth the extra money over the analog ES08MA servo on a 44" 3D profile foam airplane ?
If your receiver can output at the higher speed, it may be worth it. Especially if it has a stabiliser.
Great! But does MG90S servo work on 7.4v? thnx.
No, they are 5-6v. Worst servos in the test though, the MG90S.
I’m still planning my new tests. I have some laser sensors arriving soon to build a servo speed trap.
Hello, I am looking for a servo that can be used as an accurate pointer. I've tried digital servos, but they make a whining sound that is a non-starter for me. Will the MG90S work for my situation? I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank you!
I would not use the MG90S for anything. They are really terrible servos, and far from accurate. You would probably want to use a high end, digital servo for the accuracy. But these are a lot more pricey.
@@MrD Thanks for your reply. As I mentioned, the digital servos make a whining sound; therefore, those are non-starters for me. Are there any accurate analog servos?
Hello Daren what do you think of es08mdii to be fitted in the ranger 2400?
Being a medium plane but slow I would be aware in case they are underpowered
They should be fine. I have ES08MA II in my Phoenix 2000. They aren’t underpowered for that plane. But if you are worried, run them at 6v.
@@MrD I will sold my f765 the bridge of 6 v in my f765.
Does it affects anything to run it at 6?
If you set the Vx bridge to 6v, the servos will be at 6v. Which will be fine.
@@MrD thank you
Appreciate
@@MrD any strange behavior with digital servos and crossfire?
I'm new in the rc car world, The voltage refears to the voltage of the battery? If I put a battery of 7V will it work? Thanks
The voltage refers to the voltage the servo will operate at.
I’ve not used RC cars for a while. But when I did, the speed controller reduced the voltage for the servos and receiver to 5v. The battery connected directly to the speed controller. This was of course for electric cars. For nitro cars, I’d imagine there is some kind of BEC to reduce the power for the servo and receiver. To be honest though, this was back when you used NiCd batteries 🤣
With batteries, the voltage given is the nominal voltage. For example a 2S LiPo will have a nominal voltage of 7.4 volts. When fully charged it will be 8.4 volts, so the servo needs to be able to handle that upper voltage.
Thank you very much
So... Weird.. allready the 5th servo stopped working in flight :-(.Its the Emax ES09MD. Using it on a hacker Edge 540 v3 profile foamy.They just work great but after a while they fail.Maybe its has to do with the bec from the Hobbywong Flyfun V5 esc.Its on default output of 5,2 volts.Dunno... but it annoying, when it happens again.. and again inflight.Help will be much appreciated.
Those servos shouldn’t be failing on a profile foamy. What current is the BEC? If you’re moving the servos all the time in 3D flight, it could be that the servos aren’t getting enough power. I would have though a 5A BEC should be fine, but 3A may be pushing it. Also, where are you getting the servos. There are clones of EMAX servos out there. I wouldn’t trust places like eBay or Amazon.
@@MrD Its 5,2 volts at 3A.Should i set the bec then on 6 volts?Manual says it will output 7A on 6 volts.I was getting them on AliExpress at FeiYingRC store.Hopefull they're genuine.How can check when they are fake Thnx
@@rverdonk3 you can try 6V. The servos can take it, and will be quicker and have more torque. On the box, there should be a scratch panel. You can check the number on the EMAX site. If there’s no scratch panel, it’s fake.
@@MrD i will check them.. when im at home
theres a scratch panel on the bottom off the box.They look real to me.Servo can move free on the plane.. Well putted 2 new aileron servo in.. will see for how long they will hold up this time.
check those emax im sure they have one plastic gear in them.....missleading info from them
No, they’re full metal gears. The plastic gear version is the ES08A.
there was big talk a while ago about the one plastic gear inside them.....maybe there have changed them as I would not purchase them because of this
ua-cam.com/video/vVHgqjbYThY/v-deo.htmlm15s
1:27 corona over there!
Corona is everywhere :D Hopefully not for much longer though. Hope you're keeping safe.
@@MrD Yeah, all is well, hope its the same from your end :)
Yes, so far so good. Thank.
Try the Miuzei servos instead of the Tower Pro. They are under $2USD /ea and far better than the Tower Pro. Also, the Coronas can feed back into the receiver and cause all the servos to jitter. Someone found that adding a toroidal core solved that ua-cam.com/video/sEp4VT6NL6o/v-deo.html
I'll have a look at the Miuzei servos. To be honest, for the money I can't see anything beating the MG90D. Check out my better servo test video and you'll see what I mean.
ua-cam.com/video/w3VWWmJSKo4/v-deo.html
I also found that all the jitter and range issues in this video was because I was using a servo tester. Hooking them up to an actual receiver made a huge difference.
Low cost is better agresif
Not always. It depends what they are going in. I wouldn’t put cheap servos in something like a Mini Drak or Goblin just to save a few pennies and risk failure. For stuff like S800’s and AR Wings the EMAX ES08MA/D II servos are great. I wouldn’t use the TowerPro analogue servos in anything now.
Sorry I'm late 😎🤙