How Gacha Games Keep You Playing

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 чер 2024
  • "One does not play gacha games. Gacha games play you." I'm someone that's deeply fascinated with gacha games. There's a reason I review them, and why I started out this channel covering one in particular. Today, I want to cover the stuff I never had the chance to say, and give a brief heads up about the games that we all enjoy. Hopefully with the lessons I explain in this video, you can better prepare yourself when trying out these games.
    Join the Discord server!
    / discord
    Timestamps:
    0:00 - Intro
    0:50 - Setting expectations
    4:13 - Timegating progression
    6:01 - Grind/content updates
    8:00 - Monetization tactics
    13:08 - System 1 and 2
    14:41 - F.O.M.O
    15:54 - Sunk-cost fallacy
    17:35 - Habit formation
    19:32 - A way out
    21:10 - Closing words
    Music used:
    pastebin.com/qt7pNRA1
    Outro music:
    • Special Record Vol.2 -...
    References:
    Sys 1 and 2 Article:
    thedecisionlab.com/reference-...
    ToF Club Footage:
    • Mirroria City Night Cl...
    ToF Concert Footage:
    • Tower of Fantasy - Lin...
    FNV slot machine footage:
    • Fallout New Vegas - Go...
    Shenmue Gachapon machine footage:
    • Shenmue 1: Sonic Capsu...
    #gacha #gachagame
    v1.0
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 709

  • @RockanoYT
    @RockanoYT 7 днів тому +878

    You forgot the part where the game runs out of content and the players do pvp among themselves on a certain website

    • @hornetsilksong
      @hornetsilksong 7 днів тому +204

      Amazes me how chronically online twitter users found a way to conduct pvp when genshin has not implemented pvp at all

    • @aryanugraha6965
      @aryanugraha6965 7 днів тому +34

      If me when the “game runs out” I just install more gacha games cuz of waifu marketing I don’t care which one is on the top charts and play that I find it fun but still regrets cuz making more fomo on the min maxing doing multiple dalies, grinds and financial decisions

    • @arominized
      @arominized 7 днів тому +17

      when I got more invested on drama lore rather than in-game lore XD

    • @reed3863
      @reed3863 7 днів тому +6

      True. No pvp in game? Take that pvp outside the game 😂

    • @Andrew-st6fe
      @Andrew-st6fe 7 днів тому +20

      Genshin v.s Wuwa PVP
      Being insufferable to each other when both games plays like the same shit

  • @BlazeLibra
    @BlazeLibra 5 днів тому +127

    Events that dont come back is definitely one of my biggest gripes with gacha games. I'm glad something like Star Rail actually makes most of their major events permanent

    • @Keirnoth
      @Keirnoth День тому +1

      Nikke started it first.

    • @kuroha231
      @kuroha231 День тому

      ​@@Keirnoth Arknights did it first

    • @c-046ramadhan8
      @c-046ramadhan8 9 годин тому

      ​@@Keirnothseems like someone haven't read the history books yet

  • @Cats777
    @Cats777 7 днів тому +193

    It's not the "wait a minute, why am I doing this" question that makes me stop playing games. It's more like, "am I actually having fun?"

    • @adoroselatte
      @adoroselatte 7 днів тому +34

      For me, it's not a question. It's more of a "urgh,why do I feel dragged" kind of feeling and that's when I know that I need to quit playing gacha.

    • @Neuvillete4.6
      @Neuvillete4.6 2 дні тому

      Same

    • @divineroomba5013
      @divineroomba5013 День тому +2

      Same, I stop playing a game once I start feeling bored of the game or if it feels like a chore. Thats why I quit Genshin, the combat became super repetitive since there only like 5 different common enemies across the whole game and the story was so incredibly boring I couldn’t stand it.

  • @Rose00781
    @Rose00781 7 днів тому +329

    "Wait a minute, why am I doing this?' hits me hard, I don't even enjoy some of the game anymore, thanks for this video, and I'll definitely do the don't login challenge, really appreciate you man

    • @nicolas._.2294
      @nicolas._.2294 7 днів тому +10

      Ye, fr, I feel the same sometimes

    • @lil-army2120
      @lil-army2120 7 днів тому +28

      That's how I ended up not playing genshin for a while year, and it was the best decision ever made me realise it wasn't as fun anymore

    • @SetariM
      @SetariM 7 днів тому +9

      If you don't know why you're doing something, your heart was never in it to begin with

    • @simonshura9144
      @simonshura9144 6 днів тому +3

      ​@@SetariMsome of us are just collectors 😂 so obviously its hard to part from our waifus

    • @kylone1
      @kylone1 5 днів тому +1

      Yep, when I thought this about Genshin Impact, that's when I stopped playing.

  • @Emerald-kun
    @Emerald-kun 7 днів тому +185

    the best way to play gacha games is to not own a credit card

  • @Mx64MaxyImpress
    @Mx64MaxyImpress 7 днів тому +350

    One simple answer for me is with their characters that keeps appear to serve your addiction to them, one day you like that character, then another one come to replace it

    • @LucyKosaki
      @LucyKosaki 7 днів тому +53

      Some games like genshin for example do very well on characterization, so when a new character comes out, they appear in the story, there are quests focussed about them that make you feel attached to them, there are web events and incentive events, that encourage people to discuss and show off those characters on social media, the current endgame modes will all benefit that characters playstyle or artificially boost that characters damage types to make it feel stronger that it actually is. All to make the character feel like the most important and crucial new thing to get. Only to be replaced by the next character 3-6 weeks later.

    • @MrWilliGaming
      @MrWilliGaming 7 днів тому +41

      @@LucyKosaki except that doesn't really work that well anymore. old community favorites like the archons, hutao or ayaya stil get about as much community attention as the new hot characters. with the exeption of neuvillette,furina and arle no new fontaine character was really that hyped and the overall exitement around clorinde is best described as lukewarm.

    • @HeliumIsBack
      @HeliumIsBack 7 днів тому +4

      smth like power creep?

    • @TwilightAdvance
      @TwilightAdvance 7 днів тому +9

      Nope. Nikke already gave old characters progression to gain more power. Skins also keep alive older characters, it is sad to see how many gacha games rely only on power creep meta, forcing people to choose character based on meta instead of aesthetics or what you like to play most.

    • @abrahammesrajecorrea2349
      @abrahammesrajecorrea2349 6 днів тому +1

      Or in my case, one day you love X character... and then the game either kills them or makes them disappear. It has already happened to me in FGO with Musashi, Castoria and Jalter. Only Castoria came back and I'm glad...but I feel like I'm in a hostage situation where I want my favorite characters back, safe and sound. That's part of why I keep playing... to make sure they come back again.

  • @LucyKosaki
    @LucyKosaki 7 днів тому +179

    I have a friend, who plays multiple gacha games, but he isn't really phased by any of those retention tactics. He usually logs in when there is a new update, plays the new story, tries new game mode updates, does some exploration, tries current events while trying to get one of the current banner characters with the free resources he get through that. Then after a week or so when he experienced most of the new content in game A he moves on to one of the other games if there is a new update or collab event or anything in game B and completely stops playing game A for a month or two until there is something new and exciting, even if it means missing out on alot of daily resources and some minor events. Sometimes when he doesnt feel like it, he also just doesnt play gacha and instead plays something like elden ring or persona 5 instead. Of course his gacha accounts will never be stacked with gacha characters or equip, but he values his time and doesn't see the point in playing if there's nothing interesting. He also never spends on gacha currency, not even the 5 dollar month packs, but he does consider spending if there is a low cost direct purchase pack, for example an outfit for 5 dollars flat or a 5 star selection box for 5 dollars.
    Sometimes I envy him.

    • @stego-
      @stego- 7 днів тому +56

      its actually really easy.
      just like how your first purchase leads to you buying more things
      the first skipped day, leads to more after

    • @MrWilliGaming
      @MrWilliGaming 7 днів тому +52

      honestly its not that hard. the good content (story,events) is usually really easy and the endgame content usually really boring so whales can clear it. thats why you always go waifu >>> meta in any and all gacha. endgame sucks anyway so why would you grind for it?

    • @Kazuki_22
      @Kazuki_22 6 днів тому +11

      That also is another healthy way of coming to terms with playing gacha games.
      Just don't give in to the FOMO daily/weekly grind system.
      After all, it's a free game that just has the extra psychological effect for player retention and gacha monetization system wherein that supports the GaaS (Games as a service) model or the live free-to-play experience.

    • @Kyumifun
      @Kyumifun 6 днів тому +2

      That's how i play Guardian Tales. Idfk what "co-op expedition" is, i don't care about pvp, colloseum etc. i just play for the story (main story and side quests).
      It's more fun that way.

    • @IkarusFD
      @IkarusFD 6 днів тому +1

      Your friend same as me.

  • @baka_monogatari3389
    @baka_monogatari3389 7 днів тому +100

    If you think HI3 has too many currencies now, this is actually a streamlined version. It took years for them to implement. You should have seen it before lmao.

    • @sunglassfrog89
      @sunglassfrog89 7 днів тому +18

      Yeah new players sometimes dont know or forget HI3 is an 7 year old game

    • @Romashka_Sov
      @Romashka_Sov 6 днів тому +18

      ​@@sunglassfrog89being a 7 years old game is not an excuse to have too many currencies, you know?

    • @Jetsetlemming
      @Jetsetlemming 3 дні тому +1

      @@Romashka_Sov It's not a matter of it being an "excuse," it's just an explanation. HI3 was designed in the style of the time when it came out. Seven years is multiple generations of different games, the same company's released like four new ones since HI3 first came out and made the company what it is today. You gotta approach it as a retro game to really understand why it is the way it is. They've updated it a bunch over the years, only in the last year did they finally give it a proper PC version that isn't just an android emulator, but the core is still retro. Unlike many other old gacha games like Fate: Grand Order, at least HI3 is fully playable to experience what's unique about it while just ignoring the gacha elements. You can easily treat it as an offline freeware action game and have a great time with it.

    • @Romashka_Sov
      @Romashka_Sov 3 дні тому

      @@Jetsetlemming now sorry, but the whole second part of your message really sounds like an excuse. Late PC port has nothing to do with an amount of in-game currencies, as well as ignoring gacha elements, or being fully playable. And i didn't play FGO, but i thought its main story and farming modes also fully playable? Either this or i misunderstood you, sorry for my bad english then
      Also, being old is hardly an explanation. Maplestory is 9 years old and convoluted on purpose, but it still has less despite being older and much more predatory. Bleach: Brave Souls is an 8 years old game, but it has like, ten currencies including event ones and gacha summons? Somehow HI3rd has the most amount i've ever seen, and to be frank, at least some of these devs can remove entirely, turning them into Asterite

    • @The_CodFish69
      @The_CodFish69 2 дні тому

      @@Romashka_Sovsounds like a Gen Z compliant ya have the attention span of a ADHD gold fish.
      Who care about like 5 different currencies it take a a whole 2 min to understand how it works and what gives what.

  • @byeguyssry
    @byeguyssry 7 днів тому +163

    I'd like to add a few more notes.
    Personally, I don't care much for pity, but I think soft pity is pretty devious. For those who do not know of its existence, they feel like they're getting lucky and therefore makes them want to continue playing (sunk cost fallacy: "Oh I got so lucky in this game, never hitting pity once, all my luck is wasted if I quit"). For those who do know of it, it can be a bait. Say there's 10 minutes left on a banner and you're already in soft pity. Would you buy more premium currency to try to get the character? Say you buy the monthly pass and get 2 pulls upfront. You use those 2 pulls and still don't get the character. You're even deeper into soft pity. Surely now you must get it if you just get 2 more pulls (Gambler's Fallacy). So you buy another two more pulls and still don't get it. Now (Sunk Cost Fallacy) it would be a waste if you don't spend more money to get it.
    (I'd also like to note, some casinos do have a kind of pity; it's just that, of course, unlike gacha games where you could technically say "I value this character at $2000 so I don't mind spending $2000 to guarantee it", obviously no one is gonna say "I value this thousand dollar payout at $2000, so I don't mind spending $2000 to guarantee it". Casinos are controlled to usually rigged to ensure that the house doesn't get too unlucky, nor too lucky, and make sure that someone wins big every so often so as to entice the winner to continue gambling without realizing he's spent $2000 on that thousand dollar payout)
    For "Beginner Packs", most games also do this so that, once you purchase just one thing, you usually won't have to re-enter your credit card details again, which is a lot of time that can be spent deciding if you really want that thing. It also breaks people away from the "F2P" mindset since they've already spent, which breaks down any inhibitions about spending. Also, I'd like to note Project Neural Cloud's Beginner Pack, because it's pretty unique. For 99c (ah, good ol' $0.99 pricing that's everywhere), you get the character Angela, one pull, as well as a "Monthly Supply Voucher Discount Coupon" that lasts for 60 days. This reduces the price of the Monthly Pass from $4.99 to $3.99. And, yes, you can purchase Monthly Passes even when you already have one. I have no idea how effective this actually is; because you're incentivized to buy the Monthly Pass, but at the same time you probably won't buy the Beginner Pack without also buying the Monthly Pass, making it essentially a $5 investment, which is not what beginner packs are meant to do.
    FOMO in gacha games is pretty funny. They run a balancing act of trying to make sure that new players don't feel any FOMO for old stuff (or they might quit knowing that they can't get said old stuff), but only for the new stuff.
    Also, there are some games that don't really care about you logging in every day, just enough days each week. Tower of Fantasy is an example, as you only get Standard Pulls from doing dailies so you mainly care about the weeklies (though, they are time-gated so you do have to log in multiple days each week). Honkai Impact is another example. You can log in only twice each week and still get 87% as much pulls (though, more likely you're logging in thrice each week to get another important currency, which would net you 91.5% as much pulls. These calculations assume there are no events, so realistically, the percentage of pulls you get is higher), provided you do your weeklies. These still drive players to log in as much as possible, but has the benefit of not driving away players who are unable to log in every day.
    Also also, as a Honkai Impact player, mandatory What do you mean there are too many currencies in HI3? There are only Crystals, B-Chips, Asterites, AE Imaginons, Rusted Insignia, Ancient Willpower, Ancient Legacy, Time Structures, Ether Fuel, Ranger Creds, School Inspector Emblems, Weapon Resonance, Stigmata Resonance, Work Points Cards, Witch Orbs, Pure Witch Orbs, Pure ELF Orbs, Stardust Shards and Coins. Back in MY day, we had stuff like Mithril too, you know. Tsk tsk tsk, young people these days, unable to handle only 19 currencies.
    (Okay but for real though, I never had a problem figuring out what currency does what)

    • @coldfrost5
      @coldfrost5 7 днів тому +28

      no offence to you but that's just show you have a lot of free time or play for a long period when you understand the many currencies in a lot of gacha game and already invested so much time and money(if you spend).

    • @danielsurvivor1372
      @danielsurvivor1372 7 днів тому +9

      It's a double edged sword. On one hand, no pity system means there's virtually no cap besides irl wallet cap on how much someone can gamble so it means that there's more chances someone can theoretically waste more of their money. But on the other hand, pity systems also make the gamble more accessible, meaning that player might unknowingly get addicted to the gacha harder because there's no hard wall of "Well the chance is 1% who am I to beat the odds?"
      I personally not sure which one I prefer, sure if pity system existed in say TF2 I might have had a bit more cash(since the way I stopped opening cases or doing mvm for loot was, by getting lucky and getting 2nd aussie before 10 tours and getting slightly lucky on case openings as well(unusual war paint instead of unusual hat) and going "That's ENOUGH, I'll never beat those odds again, just stop gambling while the goings are good" with pity system I might have reached that point sooned, so stopped spending money on Gaben sooner so less harm... Or it could've normalised it in my mind so I spend more in a long run.
      It's a tough call but either way those system suck and hopefully thing will get better

    • @danielsurvivor1372
      @danielsurvivor1372 7 днів тому +5

      Nah dawg that's WILD, 19 currencies? Y'all eatin' gud, back in yee olden days it was 30 in some games!

    • @sakurakaslana8716
      @sakurakaslana8716 7 днів тому +3

      Yeah back then when our suspicious grey liquid item were Sakura flowers item lol
      But yeah although HI3 has too many, somehow it's pretty easy to figured them out
      But I can understand it still overwhelming for farming even for me

    • @muszy281
      @muszy281 5 днів тому +1

      ​@@coldfrost5or else like me who has school and work, but knows that types of currency because Hi3 is typically playable for a short amount of time like when if the resin is depleted you can't play any more quest related activities and it takes for a 15-20mins of the time spent playing on it. In my experience

  • @prismapsychosis8545
    @prismapsychosis8545 7 днів тому +130

    "The wait a minute... why am I doing this" feeling you described at 19:42 is EXACTLY how I quit genshin.

    • @starcilio4962
      @starcilio4962 7 днів тому +26

      Every time i quit a gacha is because i missed a day or two and it didnt felt like it was a big deal so might as well skips some more? By the time i noticed, several weeks to months has already pass.

    • @Kyrmana
      @Kyrmana 7 днів тому +8

      I quit genshin because the events were always a bit too much. The things they made you do weren't bad, but just a bit over what I'd feel comfortable grinding out and I'd feel exhausted.
      Also grinding stat items felt bad bc it's always the same dmn environment.

    • @vampire5183
      @vampire5183 7 днів тому +10

      It's also why I just quit HSR lol. Hadn't been having any fun with it for some time now, then I just decided to delete.

    • @danielsurvivor1372
      @danielsurvivor1372 7 днів тому +2

      And that's how I quit PvZ2, Penny Pursuit(apparently in the beginning it was more fair before making grinding plants important) broke me and made me lose all hope that the game can get better

    • @sakurakaslana8716
      @sakurakaslana8716 7 днів тому

      ​@@danielsurvivor1372for PVZ 2 you might want to try it's mods instead
      Mostly it's stripped away all the love service elements to be more like an offline game
      But be cautious since some levels are targeted for experienced PVZ players

  • @princessochka3690
    @princessochka3690 6 днів тому +71

    You actually only scratched the surface. If you research gacha gamedesign and currency economy deeper, you d realise that every single gamedisign decision they made was intentional and has a purpose, especially bad ones (for example, artifact grinding in Genshin is tedious for a reason; and there is a reason why Genshin lacks end-game too). If you delve deep enough, youll find out that gacha is actually a donation sifting mechanism that only cares about player influx being higher than outflux, and where "game" part exists solely to start this machine ON (as a "hook") by getting people inside the sifting process. It is quite admirable how genius gachas are, considering how cheap they are to produce/maintain (gachas recoup their cost within months, and get 100-1000% profits when most businesses in the world work for 15-20%). Seriously, gachas should be heavily regulated/monitored by international laws or banned.

    • @MegafanX123
      @MegafanX123 4 дні тому +13

      That. That's what I'm talking about. If only more people saw this comment...
      That's why I have a motto: If it's gacha, don't play it (And unfortunately my sister does the opposite. She doesn't spend money, but she spends something much more important: Time)

    • @JustSomeGuyWithAMug
      @JustSomeGuyWithAMug 4 дні тому +3

      I love the fact that they're not 100% regulated, keeping the market so free that I can get addicted to any gacha and still not spend any money

    • @Charalyn0010
      @Charalyn0010 2 дні тому +2

      No, they shouldn't be more regulated than they already are. I'm tired of people messing with my hobbies...

    • @princessochka3690
      @princessochka3690 2 дні тому +6

      @@Charalyn0010 And i'm tired of folk getting scammed. Gachas should be 18+. All psychological and manipulative tactics should be reviewed and prohibited. Gacha algorithm and rates should be certified and monitored by regulatory authority. Current gachas aren't regulated by anything, and are no different from a fraud scheme (simpliest analogue would be a phonecall scam, where scammer calls 1000 people to find 1 who pays).

    • @Charalyn0010
      @Charalyn0010 2 дні тому +2

      ​@@princessochka3690 Oh would somebody please think of the children? Yeah...I don't think so. Their parents give them money, their parents buy their smartphones and PCs, then you're worried about these people? Let's keep protecting the idiots then wonder why we're speedruning to Idiocracy... Nope, one should suffer the consequences of their actions, whatever that entails :)

  • @shrimp.thursday
    @shrimp.thursday 7 днів тому +69

    I quit genshin a couple of months ago, and that first day of missing dailies was really difficult. After about a week I've never felt so relieved before. It was so nice to not log on. Although, I still can't fully let it go (thanks to some characters, hell look at my profile picture) and I thought about returning for natlan but man even the thought of logging on genshin is really overwhelming where I'm at right now

    • @noinfoprovided5247
      @noinfoprovided5247 7 днів тому +10

      I feel that so hard, but i was never a consistent player anyways since college is very time consuming lol, but taking breaks is what has kept me coming back tbh. It feels better this way, if i play for too long the grind sinks in and i start to hate the game. But i dont know how some ppl say theyve completed everything in the game in just 2 weeks (yes ive seen someone argue that before as in all quests, 100% exploration, all collectibles, etc.) and i find that hard to believe considering ive been playing for years and i have soooo much catching up to do, its so overwhelming. I see theres a constant debate between ppl who say theres not enough content vs ppl who say theres too much that its scary and personally thats where i fall, but i just figure ill do what i find fun and that will be that, and i appreciate the game a lot more when i follow this mindset

    • @cat6th363
      @cat6th363 7 днів тому +5

      I got burnout around 1.4, quit gen and other gatchas I was playing around that time, it felt like a paid job (a low paid one)
      After cleaning myself from the need to get gatcha currency I returned to gen and two other gatchas I played at that' moment.
      This time it felt different, now I play gen just to rest from work. If I feel to I play other games and if the events are fun I play for lomger periods.
      I hope you get to that point. Games should be fun.

    • @p3sV1
      @p3sV1 7 днів тому +5

      i can relate! i used to play genshin on ps4 and during some circumstances i left my home and didn’t take ps4 with me. next year or so i didn’t have an access to it so i couldn’t play and for the first time i felt awful. i didn’t even like the story, i just loved the world and a few selected characters. but now i’m so happy i don’t play anymore even though still every time i see something about new character i think about how much fun builds you can create and stuff
      also i started to appreciate games that you buy for once so much more now. it feels so nice to have all the context in one purchase without gacha

    • @moredinorno
      @moredinorno 7 днів тому +2

      account deletion cetrainly helps, and i am not even kidding.

    • @shrimp.thursday
      @shrimp.thursday 7 днів тому +3

      @@moredinorno I don't want to go that far. I'd rather let my account sit unused than delete all that money and time spent on it

  • @hipunpun
    @hipunpun 6 днів тому +16

    Thank you for this video
    I struggle with gacha addiction, playing 6 gacha games daily is a massive time sink
    I really needed this wake up call, this video hit me like a splash of cold water to the face.

  • @kirovreporting3573
    @kirovreporting3573 5 днів тому +5

    I feel most mainstream gacha games are aiming for older people (like 25+ maybe 30+) because this age group used to enjoy video games in the past but they currently have responsibilities and little to no time to keep up with games for long times, most games require certain time and skill investment so you can enjoy them but gacha games are casual and require far less time, it is good for them to have a game where you can log in just for 10 minutes if you are short on time and also be able login for a couple of hours whenever you have time because the game still has content... if people has lots of time to play games regularly and spend this time grinding and playing gacha games i believe theses games will look far less addictive than they look.

  • @juicylebron1094
    @juicylebron1094 7 днів тому +19

    I thank god for making me a casual player and not too attached to video games because I have families and friends

    • @bonk6561
      @bonk6561 6 днів тому +6

      It really is a blessing. Growing up with just video games and no social interaction is one of the worst things that can happen to you, at some point, you become dissociated from the real world

  • @yournerdking218
    @yournerdking218 7 днів тому +24

    Not me breaking my gacha habits beacuse I'm so fucking tired of genshin not letting me skip NPC dialogue

    • @simonshura9144
      @simonshura9144 6 днів тому +4

      This sounds like torture especially if you dont give a dam bout it 😂

  • @KingKrouch
    @KingKrouch 6 днів тому +8

    The "not logging in for a day" challenge reminds me that I've done this at several points with something like Blue Archive because it's designed in a way where it's not going to eat up your time, and if you do spend time with the game, it's probably going to only be a few hours at the absolute most. I got burned out by it's gacha system, but the majority of people play that as F2P players, because they still get quite a bit out of it. If they sold merch, I would rather buy that instead.
    I think YoshiP (the director for Final Fantasy XIV) saying that people don't have to log into the game every day and treat it like a job is more in touch than any of the current higher ups at Mihoyo. Between the time-gated events that hide crucial story info and the grind to get anywhere, I haven't really bothered playing Genshin Impact in a while because much like open world games in general, it feels like a waste of time to me. While Star Rail has the same grind issue, I think that Mihoyo going for a combat system more down their lane (They can't do engaging action gameplay from my time playing Genshin and Honkai Impact 3rd) and going more towards a closed-off world design more in line with a JRPG really helps things out a bit.

  • @matrix3509
    @matrix3509 7 днів тому +67

    All of these issues with gachas is precisely why its basically mandatory to only start playing gacha games as a F2P player and only spend money if you feel you've already gotten significant entertainment value out of the game for free.
    Its so easy to find yourself in the "why am I even doing this?" stage of the daily grind if you've yet to spend money. If fact, spending money incentivizes you to never have this thought since it forces you to grapple with the fact that you've wasted your money. On a related note, this is also why gacha developers try so hard to make dailies take as little time as possible.
    I've already burned myself out on plenty of gachas, and have no issue dropping them simply because I got tired of them long before I ever felt the desire to spend money. I was hyped for WuWa like so many other people, but I'm so insanely glad I stuck to being F2P, because the grind sucks and drove me away just like Genshin did.
    I'm probably going to skip Zenless Zone Zero unless they do something vastly different from the typical Hoyoverse garbage, because I'm already tired of the formula. The more gachas follow the Genshin model, the sooner into the grind cycle that "Why am I even doing this?" thought comes up for me.

    • @Nyxnik
      @Nyxnik 7 днів тому +1

      Same here

    • @zilloking_2002taylor
      @zilloking_2002taylor 7 днів тому +4

      Are there any gachas that you currently are playing and haven’t been turned away from playing them?

    • @matrix3509
      @matrix3509 7 днів тому +3

      @@zilloking_2002taylor Just Nikke, but that has more to do with the genre and the fact that nearly every chaacters goes on the standard banner after their event is over, than any specific monetization practices. The genre got me to stick around, and the lack of FOMO convinced me the devs were worth tossing some money to. Even then, I only buy Mission Passes and nothing else.

    • @xczv1237
      @xczv1237 6 днів тому +5

      ​@@zilloking_2002taylor if you're still up for suggestions, hope you'll be willing try Arknights for a while. Starting out a new account can be really tedious, but overall I can honestly say it's the only gacha game I play entirely for the gameplay. Which of course doesn't mean it doesn't have alot of interesting lore and characters either.
      Gacha follows the Nikke system of having most new ops added to standard after their banner ends, but even then you can clear most event stages with only the operators given to you for free. Since almost all events that give out premium currence gets added to the campaign menu after their rerun, complete with first clear rewards, its really F2P friendly I'd say.
      Gameplay itself I heard best described as a mix of tower defence and tcg strategy. The main objective is to not let any enemies get through to your 'blue box', and you do this by using operators you've collected, each with different mechanics that interact with each other and counter enemies in a variety of ways.
      There are literally hundreds of videos out there by talented, passionate creators who showcase the really interesting ways you can clear a stage. The community around the game itself is also really fun to be around if you wanna take a peek

    • @simonshura9144
      @simonshura9144 6 днів тому +2

      Pretty sure Pal world like Azur Promilia will make open world fun again for most if us, because atleast we can expect it to have more casual aspects to it hopefully as well hopium copium PLEASE~ 😂

  • @atomictoaster3393
    @atomictoaster3393 7 днів тому +48

    I hate it when i try to uninstall gacha in pc like genshin or wuwa, they put character with sad or crying face with text bubble like "are you leaving?"
    As someone who experience the feel of being left, it kinda hurt me mentally and i just hate it

    • @zSTALKn
      @zSTALKn 7 днів тому +12

      You must have not attempted to uninstall World of Warcraft back in its early days. Consider that you dodging a bullet without even knowing.

    • @atomictoaster3393
      @atomictoaster3393 7 днів тому +4

      @@zSTALKn i didnt play wow lol guess i really dodge a bullet

    • @adoroselatte
      @adoroselatte 7 днів тому +1

      ​@@zSTALKnthat is real bad

    • @Swagbastian
      @Swagbastian 5 днів тому +6

      Yup, that's just another psychologically manipulative tactic they use to keep people playing. Imagine your game sucking so much that you have to try and guilt people into continuing to play.

    • @wanderingsoul4103
      @wanderingsoul4103 4 дні тому

      ​@@zSTALKnwait why is it dodging a bullet what happens when you uninstall it im curious

  • @theMiaow
    @theMiaow 7 днів тому +28

    I was literally just recently curious about why gacha games are addictive and how it affects our brain, and here you are having uploaded a video abt it 🤣

  • @zylou8643
    @zylou8643 7 днів тому +242

    gacha games will inherently be evil in nature but I just can't stop playing them, I'm glad im good with money when it comes to these games but it will always suck when you wanna get someone into one of these games because they're just so time-consuming (at least over the course of months and years) and predatory at minimum due to luck based "power" in the form of characters

    • @Herschier_of_reality
      @Herschier_of_reality 7 днів тому +6

      Yes agree but I usually just barely play games never let it waste more time than it

    • @demonking-zm3rs
      @demonking-zm3rs 7 днів тому +15

      I mean low barrier of entry. Cost Effective (As in unless your prone to spending a huge portion of people don't actually spend money) there less demanding then regular games with an Imaginary Longevity
      And they usually have unique designs. Realistically Gacha is no more evil then going into the mall and having smells pumped into the air
      Or any basic business practices the big diffrent is that Food Alcohol Drugs your body has limit for the stimulus but "fun" doesn't although most people again don't have the dire issues
      At best Gacha make you form a routine around them. So they become instinctive and they desensitize you but again going to the supermarket and seeing Half Off or Two For One Macaroni does the same

    • @nik_senpai
      @nik_senpai 7 днів тому +15

      I always thought of myself when I play gacha games "Have I always been having fun playing these games?"

    • @nicolas._.2294
      @nicolas._.2294 7 днів тому +1

      ​@@demonking-zm3rsyou have a point

    • @nicolas._.2294
      @nicolas._.2294 7 днів тому +20

      ​@@nik_senpaiye same, like if I ain't having fun then it ain't worth it, just wasting the little time I have on this planet

  • @abhiss6705
    @abhiss6705 7 днів тому +116

    This is why I like games like Brown dust 2 and snowbreak who are very respectful of your time. 5 mins here and there and you can get most things done. They dont overstay their welcome with bloat.

    • @ktkace
      @ktkace 7 днів тому +11

      NGL, SB has too much system 2 stuff... it has become like a chore after the dailys esp after lvl 60 when the exp gets halved ...

    • @BlueAmerican26
      @BlueAmerican26 7 днів тому +2

      SB? Nah, not aat all.

    • @Hamorich
      @Hamorich 7 днів тому +7

      BD2 yea
      Uhh, idk about snowbreak tho

    • @ikoukuhn
      @ikoukuhn 7 днів тому +10

      Gotta agree on snowbreak. It just took 1-3 minutes for me to finish the daily quests

    • @Hamorich
      @Hamorich 7 днів тому +5

      @@ikoukuhn oh just the daily quest? Ok then it's pretty fast I'd say.

  • @covid19sama
    @covid19sama 7 днів тому +73

    As someone who's broken free of the gambling addiction of gachas, the fomo is absolutely the worst part. Luckily I still genuinely enjoy Genshin despite its downsides, Limbus Company has basically no fomo at all unless you count event rewards, and I haven't played WuWa long enough for fomo to even start but I'm still having fun with it regardless. One of the reasons I quit Destiny 2 was because of the fact that literally all seasonal content leaves the moment a new expansion comes out, but even worse is that I need to pay $100 just to keep access to my dailies

  • @HappyHaploid
    @HappyHaploid 7 днів тому +23

    How can I keep playing Limbus Company when the Developers had no experience making a Gacha Game

    • @angrypeperoni1239
      @angrypeperoni1239 7 днів тому +23

      Letting PM cook. Either they make a 5 star meal or we get 300 lunacy.

    • @Aedlmonrl
      @Aedlmonrl 7 днів тому +3

      Every single major bug is either 300 Lunacy, or 1300 Lunacy
      Its really good in itself, so trust in the plAn

    • @lhobang
      @lhobang 7 днів тому +1

      ​@@Aedlmonrl1300 lunacy if kjh fucks up badly. Though it's nice, I don't want PM to crumble

    • @Xanthopathy
      @Xanthopathy 3 дні тому

      Exactly. They're much less likely to pull egregious shit.

  • @khathecleric
    @khathecleric 7 днів тому +25

    Nikke managed to strike the right balance for me, along with a art style and a story i enjoy.

    • @servbotz
      @servbotz 7 днів тому +12

      Nikke's art and story are the only reasons I keep playing. I hate the dailies. Out of all the gachas I play, it feels the least rewarding to do dailies for and the most like a chore. I keep debating on dropping it but god damn it, the art/story/waifus go damn hard.

    • @BlindedMan
      @BlindedMan 7 днів тому +2

      ​@@servbotzReally? I feel the opposite. Genshin and Starrail I stopped for the same reason you said but Nikke I had no problem with it.

    • @servbotz
      @servbotz 7 днів тому

      @@BlindedMan For Gen, you literally play the game now and that completes dailies. So now I can actually do side quests, explore, main campaign, or just do the events. For HSR, you literally just let it auto on another screen. Done in

    • @michaelantonius321
      @michaelantonius321 7 днів тому +3

      @@servbotz NIKKE's daily is by far the easiest among all gacha game beside BA. Either you do this wrong or the method you approach daily mission is wrong, imo.

    • @servbotz
      @servbotz 7 днів тому +8

      @@michaelantonius321 I strongly disagree. Especially if you've played a lot of gachas. Re1999, BD2, and Snowbreak dailies are done in fraction of time with sweep and minimal user input. That's just 3 right there. Majority of Nikke dailies are chores. Be real. Do you actually enjoy doing Simu. room every day? Is it fun? Or killing same interception ex boss? Even HSR you can just set to auto and do something else. There is way too much friction in Nikke menu loading screens and transitions. You can enjoy doing the Nikke dailies if that's your cup of tea. But I can confidently say it's not the "easiest" daily in terms of time spent, user attention required, loading interruptions etc.

  • @Goncalo_Paulino
    @Goncalo_Paulino 7 днів тому +37

    Already knew 90% of it but it still was a great video
    I recommend this every gacha player and people trying to get into gacha games
    I spent a 50% of last summer playing Genshin Impact and when I stopped having fun I stopped immediately
    I currently play 3 gachas and might try out some new gachas but I'll stick with this 3 and that's it (btw 3 gachas is already insane)

    • @servbotz
      @servbotz 7 днів тому +5

      Really depends on the games. BD2, Snowbreak, and HSR have insanely fast dailies. That's like 15 mins total. BD2 events are done in

  • @thegamerfe8751
    @thegamerfe8751 День тому +2

    The whole "why am I doing this?" hits really hard specifically with Genshin, I just log in, start doing my commissions then go "I'm just going to do brain dead farming for months to reach the 5 star pity only for me to have to repeat it again cause I lost the 50/50 or, I get the character then I'll literally have no content to use them in other than brain dead abyss" and I just log out. Idk why I haven't uninstalled the game yet but I probably will in a few days.

  • @CruelViper88
    @CruelViper88 7 днів тому +10

    I love playing Nikke because of the world building and stories, but main story, and side bits of the Nikkes.
    The world is quite tragic and blessed for Nikkes....I'm to invested in the lore of the game... I wana know more

    • @TwilightAdvance
      @TwilightAdvance 7 днів тому +1

      I play NIKKE for the story, i've skipped majority of the smaller banners/events. This summer i log in because there is Maiden swimsuit and she's my fave.

    • @jojomicheldu59
      @jojomicheldu59 День тому +1

      I hear a lot of good things about nikke but the gameplay made me drop it within a week. There's barely any

  • @ilovehoneyberryfromarknights
    @ilovehoneyberryfromarknights 7 днів тому +30

    That's why i left most gacha games and sticked to limbus company
    You don't even need to pull to get a character you want
    And the battle pass on limbus has wayyy so much value than other gacha games
    Which makes a person like me still get alot of stuff even if i can only play for a while
    The main thing why i bought the bp is to support project moon so that they can fund their new game. They almost went bankrupt.
    Canto 4 was peak ideal

    • @jackmeher1512
      @jackmeher1512 6 днів тому +1

      Sleeper agents, activated?! Red.........gaze.

  • @real_Hinoe
    @real_Hinoe 6 днів тому +18

    I started playing Honkai Star Rail when it's released and I haven't missed a day not logging in. After Wuthering Waves came out and I saw all the hype about it how it's very good, I was very tempted to start playing it. It is very exciting to be a day one player without any FOMO. I've been playing non-stop for the last two weeks.
    However, as a completionist, I love getting every reward, every achievement a game can offer me (even if it's a gacha). I realized I just don't have much time to play TWO gacha games with that attitude. It is indeed hard to quit a game even if you just bought battlepass and one monthly supply and have been playing for only two weeks. So this expirience taught me that I propably never start another gacha game and there is no point in trying to do that. I felt kinda bad about it because I really love the gameplay in WuWa but your video reassured me my decision is correct.

    • @EyesDontCry
      @EyesDontCry 5 днів тому +10

      I played genshin for a few months in January last year before hsr dropped and got the characters I wanted, at some point logging in just sucked so I stopped playing.
      Hsr then releases and I'm able to play it on my phone, and I haven't really stopped. Not because of FOMO or whatever, but I genuinely enjoy what the game has to offer, logging in takes no longer than 10 minutes to do everything I need, and any time extra I play some simulated universe or try some new team comps in MoC.
      It's just so different going from genshin which ended up feeling like a chore, to hsr where I'm happy to just let the auto battle do the work for a couple of minutes and log off. And if I miss some days who cares, you get reserve energy and so many reward from new patches and events that it doesn't matter.
      Genshins daily loop just sucked the life out of it, combined with its lacking story and tedious dialogue, whereas I genuinely like the story and characters of hsr, and never really get bored of the gameplay loop, building new teams all the time to mess around with.
      I'm still having fun over a year later and have no plans to stop 👍

  • @anshin8923
    @anshin8923 6 днів тому +4

    Thank you for this video. After hearing your explanation about the sunk cost fallacy i realized that i made the right decision to leave tower of fantasy.
    At that time i was contemplating whether to quit the game or not since I've spent money to buy several battle passes. And yanuo banner pissed me off so much that i kept sighing every time i opened the game, UNTIL one major update locked me out of the game since i don't have enough storage.
    That update needed more than twice the game's size which was 69GB, heck i dont even know if it actually needed thrice that amount.
    So i uninstalled the game thinking that i should get back once i buy new ssd.
    However, this video made me realize that i don't need to, it feels like some burdens have been lifted off of my shoulders. Thank you 😇

  • @skyeunknown8076
    @skyeunknown8076 2 дні тому +2

    Very informative nice vid. I think the reason I drop gacha games so fast (my most played is genshin and I threw in the towel around 20 hours in) is because the f2p experience by design sucks and instead of getting motivated to spend money I just get discouraged and leave

  • @imhotalk
    @imhotalk 7 днів тому +9

    Sending this to my friend who is stuck in the game they came to hate, that makes them do abyss-type events at 3 am because of time zone, who is upset about new shitty characters but doesn't want to stop because they've already played for 10 years and "it's a pity to waste the effort"
    I've myself learned the hard way when I reached vip10 in a game and dropped it few months later. I felt so bad I spent so much money. But at least I stopped and never spent money in gacha again.
    Also, deleted HSR yesterday and feel so relieved not to mechanically do dailies anymore.

  • @Captnspork
    @Captnspork 7 днів тому +5

    Recently got burned out from playing Blue Archive. Taking a break for now and feeling better for it. Definitely will play more when the anniversary comes up, til then it's not going anywhere.

  • @unlockablecharacter8134
    @unlockablecharacter8134 7 днів тому +5

    The absolutely insane thing is the quality of these gacha games are so much higher than many triple A titles that I'm willing to give their predatory practices a pass. I will absolutely 100% call it out everytime I see it and I won't ever encourage my friends to play these games, but when they play better than most games on the market then I'm playing it.

    • @The_Rum
      @The_Rum 4 дні тому

      Dude seriously. I felt the same seeing the quality and production in star rail.
      Makes current non-gacha turn based rpg into shame honestly.

  • @lucifermorningstar8387
    @lucifermorningstar8387 7 днів тому +4

    “Have fun out there!" I realized that the day I was doing my dailies for the umpteenth time. I logged out to do my job, only to take a break and log in again... I couldn't resist the urge to get my next shiny 5 stars (I was at 70 pityish). SO, I opened interactive map and went on complete autopilot mode, running around the map for primos.
    Half an hour later, something came over me. Perhaps it was stress that piled up or some sort of anxiety, I had no idea what happened. I just stopped in motion and stared at the scene. Something finally hit me.
    "Am I having fun?" I whispered in my head. "Is logging in daily, doing the same boring quest, and the same shit over and over fun?"
    No, it wasn't. I was just chasing the highs I had when I first played genshin. Some of the most fun I ever had in games was early genshin exploration. But now... now everything had become a chore in-game.
    I alt f4'd and quit gaming for a month. The game to bring me back was a little gem of a game my friend recommended to me. What Remains of Edith Finch. It got me hooked into single player games with good stories.
    Like you said Gacha games fun are fun, and can definitely provide your time's worth. But NEVER EVER continue playing a game if you feel like it isn't fun anymore.

  • @haruzaya9529
    @haruzaya9529 7 днів тому +5

    wow I play like around 10 games right now and this speaks to me so much. Great video!

  • @jaadc
    @jaadc 6 днів тому +1

    my guy. i truly love your content. keep it up man

  • @kanata_harumi
    @kanata_harumi 7 днів тому +4

    In reality. Dropping games for me is easy since I only have limited free time in me. I dont think I can drop all the gacha games I am playing right now but I am sure that in time, when I get bored or when I got too busy, the gacha games will have to go as well...

  • @frutolerant
    @frutolerant 7 днів тому

    Thank you for this video!! It'll always keep it in mind when I enter my gachas

  • @AgressivePigeon
    @AgressivePigeon 7 днів тому +7

    One my "new game trying habits" is to find what I enjoy playing in it, and just ignore everything else as long as that thing is enough. Events and battle passes will always have goodies and materials you could never get at the same speed as a F2P, but are they worth more than actually feeling a connection to the game/story? Games like Nikke do it right, by archiving events and allowing you to experience their stories without that FOMO.

  • @icehollow8704
    @icehollow8704 7 днів тому +1

    Hey, i'm getting more and more involved in the gacha game ecosystem since i started Gen on realease, today i play Gen, Nikke, HSR, Brown Dust II actively and some games that i kinda stopped playing. I'm really interested in this part of the gaming community and i'm happy that there is some interesting channels like yours that go over it. Keep the good job !

  • @caelussss
    @caelussss 5 днів тому +3

    What makes me keep playing Gacha games tbh is when it doesn't feel so bad to keep playing because there's convenience to it. The reason I quit Genshin and went to WuWa is because of how convenient it is to play it. I don't have to go to a goddamn statue just to change my character's element, exploring doesn't feel so tedious because I can run without consuming stamina and I can run on walls and do a backflip on edges, and there's just so much convenience that I don't feel bad having to go to play it because it doesn't feel like a tedious activity. With Star Rail, I can literally play another game while it goes on auto. I may not be able to skip dialogues but at least there's an actual tracker of how many chests there are in one place and I don't have to craft a freaking compass just to get them. I came play to relieve myself of stress, not to get more stress.

  • @gabreil12yt49
    @gabreil12yt49 7 днів тому +5

    Play limbus company, that way you wont have your time fucked. Thats the one gacha game that respects your time.

  • @weirded1948
    @weirded1948 7 днів тому +3

    Dude, you have the best content when it comes to gacha games in general. May sound funny, but when im looking for a video to watch while eating i always check if i havent watched a vid from yours lol. Keep up the good work man.

  • @matteo7641
    @matteo7641 7 днів тому +1

    Hi Pseychie, I just wanted to thank you for this video. I love that the videos you post are thought through really well and actually increase my knowledge as well, even though the content is fully about gacha games.
    I personally played almost every gacha game that is currently on the market and have a love-hate relationship with them. Right now though I stopped and actually hope to not pick one up in the nearer future. I‘ll start my first real job in a couple of weeks and want to begin that chapter without any games.
    I love the real gameplay aspect of games like Honkai Impact 3rd, Honkai Star Rail, Genshin and PGR though.
    I wish everyone in this community a lot of fun with the games they play but please follow the consensus of this video and don’t overdo it!

  • @RickAltair
    @RickAltair 4 дні тому

    Very well made and explained video. Good job.

  • @slayertwix5491
    @slayertwix5491 6 днів тому

    First video I've seen from your channel and it's enough for me to subscribe, this is what I call great content.

  • @spotlessmind9263
    @spotlessmind9263 7 днів тому +2

    I started playing Brown Dust II after your video.Good recommendation👍

  • @HonkaiHistory
    @HonkaiHistory 7 днів тому +6

    The thing about honkai impact, they are aware of it and already streamlined their resources multiple times. The craftting system was much more convoluted in the past too. Though with new updates, for example when we got Part 2 launch, they wanted to make the new gear system not compatible with the old system, because resource management was too different and they wanted to not get in a situation where for example new gacha-only gear from the end of Part 1 people potentially paid real money for suddenly becomes farmable one patch later.
    It is expected that legacy currencies for Part 1 systems slowly get more and more streamlined and phased out as time passes.

  • @ShinoHanamisa901
    @ShinoHanamisa901 7 днів тому

    Thank you for the advice.
    I will think carefully what to do for my games.

  • @hammayor9815
    @hammayor9815 День тому

    Thanks for making this video, it really got me reflecting on which gacha games i should stop playing that aren't fun to me anymore and spend my time and money on other things that are actually fun

  • @luandourado7249
    @luandourado7249 7 днів тому

    Thanks for the vid. Nice work

  • @markextint3024
    @markextint3024 7 днів тому

    This is my new favorite channel

  • @Francisco.Guimaraes
    @Francisco.Guimaraes 7 днів тому

    Thanks. I really liked the final part where you explain and remind me that I should play to have fun and not be forced to for any other reason.
    I Have fun with your video.

  • @chaschas
    @chaschas 7 днів тому +2

    solid video. i'm personally juggling 5 games right now and it's way too much. the problem is, i don't know which game to quit/drop because i'm still having fun in all of them. a struggle for sure that i need to figure out lol

  • @zenpai8539
    @zenpai8539 7 днів тому +1

    i love these kind of videos please keep it up

  • @MrWilliGaming
    @MrWilliGaming 7 днів тому +2

    this video shows very well why there is a growing need for stricter regulation in the gaming and especially the gacha gaming space.

  • @DefinitelyNotAFerret
    @DefinitelyNotAFerret 7 днів тому +8

    14:17 I doubt you've played this... but this happens in Nu Carnival 🙃they'll dangle seemingly valuable limited time packs, some even with SSR characters (though standard characters) and give you like a week to decide if you want to spend like $80 on that pack, plus the limited time event packs that come out with each event

  • @originalrealzer2314
    @originalrealzer2314 День тому +2

    Ironically genshin's fomo was so bad that I quit the game and I am not affected by fomo anymore. If I don't feel like playing a game I can just not play it until I feel like it again whether it is for a day, a week or even months.

  • @theprotagonist6969
    @theprotagonist6969 6 днів тому +4

    Damn
    Didn't expect this video to pop up in my algorithm and just made me realize that I've been wasting my time, money and life 😞

    • @YoshikageKira101
      @YoshikageKira101 6 днів тому

      Well
      That is what we call gambling addiction my friend

    • @theprotagonist6969
      @theprotagonist6969 6 днів тому

      ​@@YoshikageKira101 Yeah
      I know this games are great and popular
      But I didn't realize that I'm wasting my valuable time and money 😭

    • @guardiansoulblade2673
      @guardiansoulblade2673 5 днів тому

      @@theprotagonist6969 I'm F2P on most of my gachas so all I invested in is time, except for two gachas that I want to put some money into because it means I can get more characters.

  • @NeroAtlas
    @NeroAtlas День тому

    I've been wanting to make a video like that for a long time. You did, and you did awesomely! I covered the video by reacting to it, and I'd be extremely happy to foster discussion about those themes, as a gacha game creator.
    Thank you for all the dedication you put into it - psychology is not that useless after all ;D - I'll definitely tell everyone from the community go check out your channel! It's good to see things analyzed, and dangerous practices exposed without the need of hating the genre altogether. In fact, I think you have really nice taste on gacha ;D

  • @sparvinator
    @sparvinator 6 днів тому +1

    Hey, never seen your content before but wanted to say good video, your last remarks helped me quit hsr and the whole video was very informative, thanks for the good time.

  • @JOHNRED663
    @JOHNRED663 7 днів тому +3

    How to beat a gacha game: Never enter your credit card 😂

  • @kjelliWWW
    @kjelliWWW 7 днів тому

    bruh your content is so good

  • @coral_7712
    @coral_7712 4 дні тому +1

    You should review The Battle Cats (if you haven't already).
    While the game is old and it is a gacha game, it offers nothing but it's unique and phenomenal gameplay and amazing use of strategy - Ive played it for years and only really ever had 1 burnout because I played practically every day. In fact, you can actually beat the entire game without ever laying a finger on any gacha mechanic in the game (since theres alot of free story units).
    A good part about this game is that its extremely forgiving. Its easy to get rare units, you lose virtually nothing by taking a break (maybe a few units, but you can always just use strategy to compensate your losses, which is great).
    People dont really talk about it because its an old game + its not a completely unique and groundbreaking game, but its damn good at what it does for sure. I think you'll like it.

  • @dragonbloo10
    @dragonbloo10 7 днів тому +1

    This is a good discussion , for my side games i usually have a goal and once i met that goal i try to weigh if theres another goal or consider dropping the game, that goal can either be a pulling a character mostly, investing and using that character or beating the story

  • @arumicyak
    @arumicyak 3 години тому

    Thank you for this video. Now, I don't feel bad to the games that I've quitted just because I spent time, money, and effort on it. At the end of the day, I've already had fun.

  • @Nervi121
    @Nervi121 5 днів тому

    this video should be in the main page of youtube for everyone to watch, u make really good stuff and you know ur shit man, good freaking job

  • @narius_jaden215
    @narius_jaden215 7 днів тому +1

    For me, it's the fact that characters I build up will have future content to do. In my favourite single player games, I can only train my characters so much; eventually you hit the end and that's it.

  • @chinyang1200
    @chinyang1200 7 днів тому +3

    I think he missed one part of Gacha games where they already have something for if you quit for long periods of time . They implemented Return reward if you stop for more than 30 days of playing .

    • @malcovich_games
      @malcovich_games 4 дні тому

      "I can't be bothered to come back because I'm behind already" is why lapsed players never come back to a gacha. The comeback bonus helps ease this a bit.

  • @contextualnightmare
    @contextualnightmare 7 днів тому +10

    LimbusCompany - makes you keep playing because we want to know the story, without being predatory

    • @user-garnet
      @user-garnet 7 днів тому +10

      Eh, its still predatory time-wise, it still wants you to grind a ton.
      But yeah, the monetization is much, much less predatory. The fact that it outright says the Bp cost alone puts it’s above a lot of gacha games

    • @Aedlmonrl
      @Aedlmonrl 7 днів тому +2

      @@user-garnet MDs are atleast fun to do, much more than most other games I've played, getting lunacy after doing mds is an extra plus while doing random stuff with ego gifts, but yeah, it is the leAst predatory gacha I've ever played

    • @buh507
      @buh507 7 днів тому +1

      ​@@user-garnet1 MD per week isn't really "predatory time-wise" tbh

    • @simplyeyeronic1443
      @simplyeyeronic1443 6 днів тому

      ​@buh507 I mean I think 1 MD a week will mostly just make you break even on crates for the season. You'll be getting new content but the budget for old stuff will be a lot tighter.
      Thar said, it's still far more forgiving of a system and the fact that spending lunacy, the gacha currency, on enkaphalin, an energy currency, is considered to be a viable if not optimal playstyle by many is impressive.

    • @user-garnet
      @user-garnet День тому

      @@Aedlmonrl not to mention the fact that the grind is for new units and not to build units you already have - this lets you build multiple teams and change your play style, giving a variation to grinding I don’t experience in a lot of gachas without paying or playing for a long while

  • @Ugotsomemilk
    @Ugotsomemilk 7 днів тому +3

    What also many forget, regarding the first purchase with extremely valuable packs: You now have your payment method saved and its WAAY easier to spend money now. A Gacha, that forces you to reenter your payment information, is a bad gacha (regarding monetization for the devs)

  • @BlackBow86
    @BlackBow86 5 днів тому +1

    Chad Limbus Company respecting player time, and lets u stack enkephalin modules to spend them another time. Also, 1 frame of Carmen to send the playerbase into a frenzy.

  • @danielehartmann2787
    @danielehartmann2787 7 днів тому +1

    I might forsee a Review-video for honkai Impact 3rd at this point. :D
    Nice video, enjoyed it although I knew all the stuff already. 35 Years old, grewing up the last years with Josh Strife Hayes. Very good and for gacha games orientated recap of his words. Like your style, too.
    Also: I see P5R-footage, I press like!

  • @davidsabillon5182
    @davidsabillon5182 7 днів тому

    I like this style of video. Like commented and subscribed 👍

  • @Lyfe
    @Lyfe 3 дні тому

    Great video! The key certainly is to have fun with the video games you play and if you aren't having fun... You're missing out on the main point of video games

    • @simonshura9144
      @simonshura9144 4 години тому

      If your an grown adult, then fun is longer a thing & just a concept of the past ^^
      Games nowdays are all about money, cust sunk fallacy and Fomo 😌👌

  • @darknessinc.5360
    @darknessinc.5360 3 дні тому +1

    About Gachas....i have always hated how they are so painfully slow, i also hate the fact that you have to pull the same character to power it up, things i never tolerated...also, they take too much time, and i think they need a way to have "artifacts" be less random, like craftable items that boosts drop rates for certain modifiers, and i would like the progression to not get so frustratingly impossible overtime...wonder why nobody did any of this.
    Luckily, Star Rail specifically, has super quick dailies, fast events, and a more casual approach, those companies need to realize that today we don't have anymore so much time to throw away...we want to enjoy a game, not feel forced to play it.

  • @AdamJorgensen
    @AdamJorgensen 5 днів тому +1

    Nice video, I practise a lot of you advice, having learned by experience being an HI3 player sinxe 2018 😅
    I quit Genshin due to not enjoying it.
    Quit PGR because i was just going through the motions.
    Messing around in WuW with no intention of sticking with it (even despote having spent a bit on it).
    At the end of the day, if I'm not having fun or not happy with the direction if the game I'll drop it (HSR and HI3 are heading in this direction 😊)

  • @matthewjordan8956
    @matthewjordan8956 6 днів тому

    I agree with what you are saying as far as the manipulation of Gachas. I play a few as time wasters, I travel for work and usually can't bring a game system with me. Honestly, I manage gachas by doing my dailies on each, only pull on gachas that will grant me a lot of progression and/or long term effectiveness. Thankfully there are so many content creators like you that do those kind of reviews. What has helped with spending is using google rewards, if i want currency i just do some surveys or upload receipts. Have fun with your games dude!

  • @edhikurniawan
    @edhikurniawan 5 днів тому +1

    My playstyle with gacha games are. I break when i want to break. I could go on very long hiatus playing them. Like 2 years at GFL, 4 years at world of warships, 6 months at Arknights. Not once, even multiple times.
    Playing multiple gacha games are actually one of my tactic to divert the gambling addiction. Like If 1 game gives me 10 pulls, i do have 40 pulls by playing 4 games. Although, it doesn't works simply like that.
    Remember you're telling the pity system? What I'm doing is scraping the freebies to get that pity. It takes months right? By playing multiple games, that number went down, like from 4-6 months to every 1 or 2 months.
    Also, i love games that doesn't FORCE you to complete all of its content. Arknights is always my example. Every event at Arknights, you can literally farm the event by only doing the easiest, the noob friendly stage 1 or 2 of the event. Because the Sanity cost per reward point is always the same 1:1. That game also has Roguelike wich IMHO offers quite decent reward. Which usually I don't play because it took much time.
    Do I enjoy the game even without completely doing that? I'd say yes.
    But on the coin flip, IF i do have an urge to play the game even longer, it also feels rewarding.
    I'm playing gachas, but I'm still PC master race person. Means i still playing END-able games. It is why i could switch playing them (gachas) ON or OFF.
    I also do not monetically restricted so i do have to do whatever the game told me to do, even for a rewards, if i don't enjoy it. But also since I'm playing multiple gacha games, it also give me a rationale not to overspend. Feeding 4 kids is Expensive.

  • @Boricosa
    @Boricosa 7 днів тому +1

    I think this is the best video u ever made

  • @Qazxsth
    @Qazxsth 3 дні тому

    Great video!
    The only gacha I actively play is Granblue Fantasy

  • @henryeng0903
    @henryeng0903 7 днів тому +2

    Just some personal stuff, I played Genshin for 3+ years since the third day it launch and blue archive for sometime, that is my only 2 games and gacha games. BA I remain F2P while Genshin I spent RM160 in total. Genshin did manage to keep me playing for 3 years but once Wuthering Waves released, the quality of life that it provide actually make me never feel bad for quiting Genshin. So yea, now I am playing WuWa and BA, no regrets on dropping Genshin even if invested some sunk cost into it.

  • @Nyxnik
    @Nyxnik 7 днів тому +2

    I consider myself lucky in that these systems actually make me want to play the game (and spend money on it) less.
    Once the daily grind and resource starving starts, I begin to hear a voice in my head telling me "you could just play something more interesting instead of doing these dailies" and then I just alt+f4 and uninstall.
    Same with spending money, especially for battle passes. I just think to myself "they want me to enter this loop of doing boring dailies AND give them money for it?" No thanks.
    I guess my brain is immune to this type of conditioning (luckily) since I have played games my whole life and remember the times before all these practices (and that there are games like Baldur's Gate 3 which still provide a full experience without them). But I can see how this can brick a person's mind, especially if they condition you since you are young.

  • @fallengarden
    @fallengarden 7 днів тому +3

    The correct title is "how gacha games want you to keep playing but they cant", cause they are way too lazy to steal enough stuff from MMO's to get enough end game content which would justify the "please play for years" live service model. Some crappy tower system alongside daily 15 minute of player retention data boosting repeat sh1et is far from enough to keep a serious gamers attention long term.
    The first real gacha game will be the one which implements raid content alongside a Diablo 2-like infinitely randomized dungeon content which you can grind for however long you want, anytime you want. If we get a gacha like this, i will play it long term. At the moment, gachas are only good for to wait for their story to finish completely, finish it in a month and forget it for ever. Take it as a free story game and move on.

  • @danielsurvivor1372
    @danielsurvivor1372 7 днів тому +1

    11:15 Fun fact about FNV Slots and blackjack are affected by Luck stat(the higher the better odds of winning)but roulette isn't.
    And there was one FNV challenge run where someone tried to win roulette with different luck variants, from 1 to 10 and lemme tell ya FNV surprisingly seems like a good anti casino ad in this way, seeing player character lose so many times(even with high luck) is wild but also realistic to irl casinos.

  • @wailmerpail
    @wailmerpail 3 дні тому

    The moment i realise logging in feels like a chore rather then something i want to do i stop playing

  • @ericraululyeetusdelyeetus5028
    @ericraululyeetusdelyeetus5028 7 днів тому +5

    As is customary, I must comment one thing.
    *LIMBUS COMPANY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*

  • @YoshikageKira101
    @YoshikageKira101 6 днів тому +2

    When you got that juicy salary and you said you wouldn't gamble
    But look at it now
    Your spending all your hard earn to a game that will forget on you

  • @Romanian901
    @Romanian901 7 днів тому

    im saving this video to my playlist of videos

  • @leestefan2999
    @leestefan2999 День тому +1

    I can never understand why some players would feel so compelled to whale in gachas. I felt season / annual pass was fair and square which I would feel more justifiable to pay for, but it looks like these days, such passes still can't grab money fast enough, so some brilliant minds came up with a blatant turbo money grab system... gachas.
    Thousands of bucks spent on a single digital character, not even some kind of NFT... I didn't think gachas would flourish when I first heard about it. Clearly, I was wrong, and this may degenerate into a rather unhealthy society problem in the coming future when everything essential to living is becoming more expensive over time.
    Casinos would love such a system because there's only money coming in from the gamblers and none flowing back out to them.

  • @simonshura9144
    @simonshura9144 11 годин тому

    Spending big money and not getting the unit is probably the worst thing in some gachas without a pity 😂

  • @Fir3Soul
    @Fir3Soul 7 днів тому

    This was a cool video to listen/watch along as I did some of my dailies and felt like "hmm he speaks to me " but Yeah in these couple of years I learned to only play 2 max 3 gachas that are actually fun . I played I think almost all of them and spent money , but now I only play WuWa due to it's combat being fun (will try ZZZ and compare and see who tops then) HSR cause that's super chill and i'm somewhat lucky and invested in the Main story , and always have one I hardly login(or spend money) and just I dunno..it's there as a "I got 30 mins to spend, let's play X " . Still great video !

  • @kawaii3075
    @kawaii3075 3 дні тому

    This why I love star rail, the only thing you miss out on if you don’t login is stellerjade. Which isn’t problematic for star rail because the devs love giving pulls away each update. I never feel like I’m forced to login everyday I login everyday because I enjoying building characters/ gameplay loop. Fomo barely ever happens specially with events that have story tied to them, the devs make that story part of the main story/ put it in a tab where everyone can get access to it whenever they want do it. The only fomo thing is getting free four stars that’s about it, but those events stay for most of the patch anyways

  • @ValtenBG
    @ValtenBG 5 днів тому +1

    I used to play HI3 for a quite a while but I quit the game little before HSR's release. Little before I quit I was feeling a heavy burn out and the only reason I continued to log in was the story and characters. Those were the things that brought me and kept me playing but also the reason I quit. I no longer had fun with it. The direction and quality took a nosedive at 1 point. I stuck around a little more to see if the story will pick itself up and go back to what made me love the game. It didn't and one day I just didn't login. That day became 2, then 3 and so on. I haven't really touched hi3 in more than 14 months and I am not sure if I want to ever go back to it, because the game already disappointed me once.
    I was mostly f2p in hi3 but in HSR I am low spender and I have spent quite a lot money in total over the cource of the time(I am day 1 player). Right now I enjoy the game and the direction it is taking and don't feel like my money went for a "bad cause". But in no way will I hesitate to quit the game if it goes downhill, similarly to its predecessor.

  • @eoezxeoezx9728
    @eoezxeoezx9728 7 днів тому

    Finally someone who talks about gacha game as a whole and not just comparing wuwa vs genshin

  • @DinnyForst
    @DinnyForst 7 днів тому +1

    Always know your limitation and worst case scenario while playing. This is how I enjoy most of gacha based video games and avoid predatory tactics to entice spending money.

  • @MikeJXWT
    @MikeJXWT 5 днів тому

    Good video, its important to keep these things in mind while playing gacha games, let alone any games. I've made this mistake with FPS and Rhythm games in my youth and thankfully grew out of it.
    Luckily I haven't had the issue with being super tied to a gacha. I'f I'm enjoying my time, I will spend some money on it if I see it fit. Currently doing that for only HSR. Everything else I just play whenever new story comes out.
    I've made it a goal to myself to follow a few rules playing gacha:
    - Never use a credit card, I only use my tip money from work and only top up via gift car ds with tip money.
    - If the game starts getting to the point where it's now become a chore to just log in only for dailies and never touch the game at all for a week or two it's time to stop.
    Especially when I begin thinking "oh man, i still have to log into x game for dailies" with a mentality of dragging your feet towards a chore you hate doing.
    - If I begin to feel frustrated over the mentality of "there's nothing to do" and it begins to effect my mood, then its time to put the game down
    It's made it easy for me to balance work, life and gaming while allowing me to play regular games and not stressing out about it.

  • @astreakaito5625
    @astreakaito5625 7 днів тому

    great video, better hope more will see it :)