This is fun! I may be on some of those Europea and budget planes soon--and Perrie alluded to my fav semi-legal hack the airlines will NEVER ADMIT to, but usually do: if you have flexible, squishy bags, you’re far more likely to keep yours that that hard shell somebody else also wants space for. The crew will send a half-dozen hard shell luggage’s down to be gate checked, all while ignoring your soft bag, or maybe folding it tighter to make more space, . If space is truly limited (not talking overhead bins here) those soft malleable bags really save people, by being wadded in, in all kinds of ways. Hard shells go down below. Don’t ask, or make a thing out of it. But soft squishy bag stays with owner 90 %, while hard bag goes away. As for pockets in bags, I’m not a fan. 2-3 are useful, but more means more time digging through them trying to recall whats where, while grumbling from the ever- expanding line behind you gets meaner and louder! To organize in those bags, I use clear plastic bags of all sizes, to see fast and easy what’s inside. Some of those silicon bags with sealing tops are perfect for me. But I do need a personal bag like this (well covered on Carry-on big bags and pack packs, but not a. Bag of this size, pretty sure I’m getting one soon, thanks to Perrie and her great style and presentation!
HI @bettyparker3317 You go girl! You get it! The squishy bags can be such a lifesaver. There are some of on YT who are even considering going to soft traditional open on one side bag, although I would argue to still use a clamshell bag, but think about going soft-sided to keep everything more organized. But the bottom line is this. It has to work for you. There are no rights or wrongs other than resisting the need to over-pack. Thank you so much for this great post!
@PerriesPassport I definitely am a pocket person so definitely leaning bygreen. The blue color is so neutral it can go with lots of outfits if needed for a day bag and the laptop part is very helpfulll
Love your content! I fly to NL in a week and a half 😊 I'm excited to try your front pocket pouch hack this trip. I only fly in to AMS and home from LHR, so I'm on domestic airline. The rest of my travel is on trains, so the underseat size restrictions aren't an issue me. I've whittled away at the liquids I carry (primarily solid toiletries now) so my baggie is smaller. I packed my checked bag over a week ago (mostly camping gear) to make sure the weight is good. I'm so looking forward to being in some cooler weather! Oh yeah, and new subscriber now 😊 I just love your simple, no-frills, straight to the point videos. We're just simple people that don't need fancy stuff.
Hi @peggywoods4327 I'm so glad you like my vids!! Sounds like you have everything really under control. My last trip to LHR in June was a breeze (you can never tell with them). I'm so happy you subscribed. And I don't need fancy stuff. Just stuff that functions well and is useful, so I'm glad that I found an audience that I appeal to.
There is a Levi's backpack (Standard issue L backpack) that checks all the size requirement boxes - it fits a laptop (you can squeeze in a macbook pro), it has a water bottle pocket and the rectangular shape fits a lot. Pretty much no organization inside or outside, no luggage passthrough (you can sew on a strap easily) , but it is the secret weapon to beat those ridiculous size requirements!
Hi @mapleleafbassinc That is a very nice bag, but it is too deep for international airlines. It's great for most of our national ones, so thanks for that tip!
I bought the bag in your intro after seeing it in another UA-camr's video on what she takes to Europe. It's 1.5" wider than my airline's size, but i hope of i don't over pack it, it'll be okay!!
Hi @TracyKMainwaring It really depends on the airline.. I have taken it on BA flights without any issues but SAS gave me a problem with it. Don't try it on EasyJet or Ryanair. YIKES!!
We're traveling United the end of October. Personal size is 9x10x17 :(? None of my personal under seaters are 10"...they are typically 9x12x17 .... Dang!
Hi @vonniebench, typically they are 18X14X8. But in your range I would suggest the Cabin Max bags. Check out my videos on them. I think you'll like one of them (one is a 3-in-one) It's very close to your size needs ua-cam.com/video/kMgmR4SN23g/v-deo.html
I know what the manufactures say the bag size is. However, at airport the gate, they measure the packed size. You should complete your video by remeasuring the packed bag. It would give viewers more confidence
Hi @richardcarey1233 I do usually do usually show that, and I did do it, but I didn't include it in the video, since the bags measured in exactly as they should. But you are right, I should have at least said something, but I thought the video was getting too long. Advice taken! Thank for your comment.
I love all your videos! Do you have any suggestions for a personal item/go under the seat in front of you bag that is not a backpack, and does not have a specific padded compartment for a laptop, as I never carry a laptop with me on vacation. And I don’t need a backpack. I’m probably in the minority with this request. 😊. Thank you very much!
Hi @susana.2631. Thank you so much! Are you taking only domestic carriers or other ones because that matters? Most of the better bags do have a place for a computer, but some of them can be used for other purposes. If you give me some more info, I might be able to guide you, better.
@@susana.2631 My bad, I should have been more specific. Do you use international airlines? The reason I am asking is because they use smaller bags. And if you do, which ones do you use the most?
@@susana.2631 OK, so my two go-to's do have a computer compartment Which can be used for paperwork since they are on the inside of the bag on the side, but hold a ton and have good organization and are crossbody bags with handles. One is my Beis bag and I bought a cheaper version on Amazon, which I also love. It has a huge shoe compartment, which I use as a packing cube for my clothing and then there is plenty of room on the inside of the bag for another packing cube and all my other stuff, and it fits under the seat. If you want to see me pack the cheaper version of this bag, go to this video: ua-cam.com/video/lteRR9EJLL0/v-deo.html If you want to use this bag for just all your odds and sods you can do that too. Hope that helps.
Most majority of European, Asian, Australian and NZ airlines got with 40x30x20cm (16”x12x8”) Budget airlines go with 40x25x20cm What you opened up with right at the beginning is just way too small just one or two a.hole European and Chinese airlines (5” depth)
Hi @RyanKry! There is no industry standard (yet) for personal items. For instance, yes, if I am taking a European budget airline, Ryanair only allows 40 cm x 20 cm x 25 cm, but Easu Jet is more generous with 45 x 36 x 20 cm. On the other hand, BA only allows 40cm x 30cm x 15cm, which translates into 15.75 inches x 11.81 inches x 5.91, which is what these bags are. I do have another video for bags that are compliant for the budget airlines here: ua-cam.com/video/kMgmR4SN23g/v-deo.html Thank you for your comment!!
@@PerriesPassport Just checked it, good review. Thanks. I know cabin zero and cabin max are the only two backpack manufacturers I know who are specifically producing backpacks taking account of budget airlines, while all the big name brands like Aer, Tortuga, Peak Design etc. geniunly don't care at all when it comes to personal item size bags, most of their products do not fit into the sizer bins of the more generous North American airlines coming in 21-21inches in length. Such a shame really, I have a Tortuga 40L, Peak Desing 45L and a large Aer Travel backpack but when it comes to personal item bags the option is to go for a budget bag. I am yet to come across one that I can go for from a reputable name brand. Thank you for your time though, appreciated. Happy holidays, cheers.
@@RyanKryYou are 100% right that none of the big brands have tried to make a backpack personal item for European/ Asian airlines. It is a shame! Happy Holidays to you, too!
Hi @erinf4712 The My Green bag has a place to put the backpack straps. You can watch how on the Amazon video. They really didn't bother me when I used it as a crossbody, but it is an option. With the CYUREAY bag you can tuck the backstraps behind the trolly passthrough.
I bought the 15.6 laptop lookvook bag It's dimensions are 17 H x 5 W x 7.2 deep. So according to your dimensions this will not fit. Will they let you squish it in there. Or are they super strict. If it's to big do they make you check it?
@@christinestarr8192 So KLM personal item size is 16 x 12 x 6 in. Both those bags should fit into their sizers, since the bags are soft and have a lot of give. What I might suggest a trying one that you like and checking them out at the airport after doing a test pack.
Hi @ginamills5597...I never heard of that bag until just now, so I checked out the specs (and the price... which is about 3 times the Mygreen bag and the Sherpani bag is 1 inch less in depth and 1.5 inches less in width, than both of the bags that I showed. Otherwise, I think it's more comparable to the Mygreen bag, but this is all from me reading the specs and knowing what the bags I showed looked like.
@@PerriesPassport thanks. that's helpful. it did remind me of the mygreen bag. it is pricey but i've seen it here & there...unfortunately, i have yet to see a review besides those on the websites. ( i like to see real people reviews...ie. youtubers like you, etc.)
@@PerriesPassport i have a feeling based on the pics that it's about the same. and that sherpani is more of a brand name so the price is higher. i personally live on a budget like most people so if something from amazon works then I don't need the name brand.
@@PerriesPassport ps, i like a convertible bag but when i first started looking for one, the only one i could find was the sherpani or lug which were a bit pricey for me at that time. I think the concept is becoming more popular so I'm seeing many other choices now. I believe it's b/c many of us use a backpack or crossbody for our travel (as in on a tour) and many museums now won't allow backpacks or larger crossbody so having the option as a tote helps.
Hi @241JMJRAir Lingus allows a bag that is 10 in x 13 in x 8 in, which is a bag far bigger than this in depth and 2 inches shorter, which in my experience with them has not been an issue. The problem is always with the depth with the European carriers. That being said, if you are nervous, in 2 weeks I have 2 more bags that also meet this exact requirement. Hope this helps.
You do realize that after you packed these bags you showed us that they were no longer 5 inches in depth. If you measure with all that you put in the front section of the bag, you will see what I mean. Just thought you'd want to know.
Hi @michelinebeattie7789 Actually only the My Gren bag had a pocket that came out about a 1/4 inch, but that bag remained a bit more "squishy" than the other bag did and it did meet airline complie4nce when I used it. The other bag was not as squishy so I guess you would have to be careful and not overpack it.
HI @JD-zt3nr. Which bag? Only the Mygreen bag got a bit wider but it was still squishy enough to get into the sizer. Also I stuffed the bag, so if you didn't do that, there wouldn't be an issue.
So here is one of the two videos I promised about 2 personal item bags that work for almost all airlines. I hope you find it informative!
This is fun! I may be on some of those Europea and budget planes soon--and Perrie alluded
to my fav semi-legal hack the airlines will NEVER ADMIT to, but usually do: if you have flexible, squishy bags, you’re far more likely to keep yours that that hard shell somebody else also wants space for. The crew will send a half-dozen hard shell luggage’s down to be gate checked, all while ignoring your soft bag, or maybe folding it tighter to make more space,
. If space is truly limited (not talking overhead bins here) those soft malleable bags really save people, by being wadded in, in all kinds of ways. Hard shells go down below. Don’t ask, or make a thing out of it. But soft squishy bag stays with owner 90 %, while hard bag goes away.
As for pockets in bags, I’m not a fan. 2-3 are useful, but more means more time digging through them trying to recall whats where, while grumbling from the ever- expanding line behind you gets meaner and louder! To organize in those bags, I use clear plastic bags of all sizes, to see fast and easy what’s inside. Some of those silicon bags with sealing tops are perfect for me.
But I do need a personal bag like this (well covered on Carry-on big bags and pack packs, but not a. Bag of this size, pretty sure I’m getting one soon, thanks to Perrie and her great style and presentation!
HI @bettyparker3317 You go girl! You get it! The squishy bags can be such a lifesaver. There are some of on YT who are even considering going to soft traditional open on one side bag, although I would argue to still use a clamshell bag, but think about going soft-sided to keep everything more organized. But the bottom line is this. It has to work for you. There are no rights or wrongs other than resisting the need to over-pack. Thank you so much for this great post!
This is the exact video I needed right now! I'm researching for my first international trip and have been searching for the best underseat bag!
Hi @StarlahMutiny ! Glad that it was a help. Which one are you leaning towards?
@PerriesPassport I definitely am a pocket person so definitely leaning bygreen. The blue color is so neutral it can go with lots of outfits if needed for a day bag and the laptop part is very helpfulll
@@StarlahMutiny The same for me, too, on all accounts.
Love your content! I fly to NL in a week and a half 😊 I'm excited to try your front pocket pouch hack this trip. I only fly in to AMS and home from LHR, so I'm on domestic airline. The rest of my travel is on trains, so the underseat size restrictions aren't an issue me. I've whittled away at the liquids I carry (primarily solid toiletries now) so my baggie is smaller. I packed my checked bag over a week ago (mostly camping gear) to make sure the weight is good. I'm so looking forward to being in some cooler weather!
Oh yeah, and new subscriber now 😊 I just love your simple, no-frills, straight to the point videos. We're just simple people that don't need fancy stuff.
Hi @peggywoods4327 I'm so glad you like my vids!! Sounds like you have everything really under control. My last trip to LHR in June was a breeze (you can never tell with them). I'm so happy you subscribed. And I don't need fancy stuff. Just stuff that functions well and is useful, so I'm glad that I found an audience that I appeal to.
Great video 👍🏼 Thanks so much for sharing options for those of us who don’t like backpacks.
Hi @noemimatias3729 I was really impressed with these two bags. I mean they do it all! I tried to find something that would fit all needs.
There is a Levi's backpack (Standard issue L backpack) that checks all the size requirement boxes - it fits a laptop (you can squeeze in a macbook pro), it has a water bottle pocket and the rectangular shape fits a lot. Pretty much no organization inside or outside, no luggage passthrough (you can sew on a strap easily) , but it is the secret weapon to beat those ridiculous size requirements!
Hi @mapleleafbassinc That is a very nice bag, but it is too deep for international airlines. It's great for most of our national ones, so thanks for that tip!
Happy Saturday Perrie! Great video!❤
Hey Deborah @deborahconkle6822 Happy Saturday to you, too and thanks! ❤
Hi friend. I just subscribed. Great video. I love to travel.
Hi @noemimatias3729 Hi Friend right back at you. Glad you found the video helpful... I love to travel, too!
I bought the bag in your intro after seeing it in another UA-camr's video on what she takes to Europe. It's 1.5" wider than my airline's size, but i hope of i don't over pack it, it'll be okay!!
Hi @TracyKMainwaring It really depends on the airline.. I have taken it on BA flights without any issues but SAS gave me a problem with it. Don't try it on EasyJet or Ryanair. YIKES!!
We're traveling United the end of October. Personal size is 9x10x17 :(? None of my personal under seaters are 10"...they are typically 9x12x17 .... Dang!
Hi @vonniebench, typically they are 18X14X8. But in your range I would suggest the Cabin Max bags. Check out my videos on them. I think you'll like one of them (one is a 3-in-one) It's very close to your size needs ua-cam.com/video/kMgmR4SN23g/v-deo.html
What did the bags weigh after you’ve packed them?
Hi @juliehamburger8232 ! Honestly I don't remember, but I didn't have a hard time carrying either of them fully packed.
How thick are the bags after they are packed?
I know what the manufactures say the bag size is. However, at airport the gate, they measure the packed size. You should complete your video by remeasuring the packed bag. It would give viewers more confidence
Hi @richardcarey1233 I do usually do usually show that, and I did do it, but I didn't include it in the video, since the bags measured in exactly as they should. But you are right, I should have at least said something, but I thought the video was getting too long. Advice taken! Thank for your comment.
I love all your videos! Do you have any suggestions for a personal item/go under the seat in front of you bag that is not a backpack, and does not have a specific padded compartment for a laptop, as I never carry a laptop with me on vacation. And I don’t need a backpack. I’m probably in the minority with this request. 😊. Thank you very much!
Hi @susana.2631. Thank you so much! Are you taking only domestic carriers or other ones because that matters? Most of the better bags do have a place for a computer, but some of them can be used for other purposes. If you give me some more info, I might be able to guide you, better.
@@PerriesPassport only international flights. About an 8 hour trip. Thank you very much!
@@susana.2631 My bad, I should have been more specific. Do you use international airlines? The reason I am asking is because they use smaller bags. And if you do, which ones do you use the most?
@@PerriesPassport I only use Delta. They’re not nearly as picky as everyone else. 😄
@@susana.2631 OK, so my two go-to's do have a computer compartment Which can be used for paperwork since they are on the inside of the bag on the side, but hold a ton and have good organization and are crossbody bags with handles. One is my Beis bag and I bought a cheaper version on Amazon, which I also love. It has a huge shoe compartment, which I use as a packing cube for my clothing and then there is plenty of room on the inside of the bag for another packing cube and all my other stuff, and it fits under the seat. If you want to see me pack the cheaper version of this bag, go to this video: ua-cam.com/video/lteRR9EJLL0/v-deo.html If you want to use this bag for just all your odds and sods you can do that too. Hope that helps.
Most majority of European, Asian, Australian and NZ airlines got with
40x30x20cm (16”x12x8”)
Budget airlines go with
40x25x20cm
What you opened up with right at the beginning is just way too small just one or two a.hole European and Chinese airlines (5” depth)
Hi @RyanKry! There is no industry standard (yet) for personal items. For instance, yes, if I am taking a European budget airline, Ryanair only allows 40 cm x 20 cm x 25 cm, but Easu Jet is more generous with 45 x 36 x 20 cm. On the other hand, BA only allows 40cm x 30cm x 15cm, which translates into 15.75 inches x 11.81 inches x 5.91, which is what these bags are. I do have another video for bags that are compliant for the budget airlines here: ua-cam.com/video/kMgmR4SN23g/v-deo.html Thank you for your comment!!
@@PerriesPassport Just checked it, good review. Thanks. I know cabin zero and cabin max are the only two backpack manufacturers I know who are specifically producing backpacks taking account of budget airlines, while all the big name brands like Aer, Tortuga, Peak Design etc. geniunly don't care at all when it comes to personal item size bags, most of their products do not fit into the sizer bins of the more generous North American airlines coming in 21-21inches in length. Such a shame really, I have a Tortuga 40L, Peak Desing 45L and a large Aer Travel backpack but when it comes to personal item bags the option is to go for a budget bag. I am yet to come across one that I can go for from a reputable name brand.
Thank you for your time though, appreciated. Happy holidays, cheers.
@@RyanKryYou are 100% right that none of the big brands have tried to make a backpack personal item for European/ Asian airlines. It is a shame! Happy Holidays to you, too!
Great video. Are the back pack straps removable on either bag?
Hi @erinf4712 The My Green bag has a place to put the backpack straps. You can watch how on the Amazon video. They really didn't bother me when I used it as a crossbody, but it is an option. With the CYUREAY bag you can tuck the backstraps behind the trolly passthrough.
How much do these bags weigh when packed?
HI @DebbieFautt-ch5hh The CYUREAY bag weights 1 lbs and the Mygreen bag weighs 2 lbs. Hope that helps!
I bought the 15.6 laptop lookvook bag
It's dimensions are 17 H x 5 W x 7.2 deep. So according to your dimensions this will not fit. Will they let you squish it in there. Or are they super strict. If it's to big do they make you check it?
Hi @christinestarr8192 which airline are you going with?
@@PerriesPassport klm
@@christinestarr8192 So KLM personal item size is 16 x 12 x 6 in. Both those bags should fit into their sizers, since the bags are soft and have a lot of give. What I might suggest a trying one that you like and checking them out at the airport after doing a test pack.
Do u know these compare to the convertible bag by Sherpani?
Hi @ginamills5597...I never heard of that bag until just now, so I checked out the specs (and the price... which is about 3 times the Mygreen bag and the Sherpani bag is 1 inch less in depth and 1.5 inches less in width, than both of the bags that I showed. Otherwise, I think it's more comparable to the Mygreen bag, but this is all from me reading the specs and knowing what the bags I showed looked like.
@@PerriesPassport thanks. that's helpful. it did remind me of the mygreen bag. it is pricey but i've seen it here & there...unfortunately, i have yet to see a review besides those on the websites. ( i like to see real people reviews...ie. youtubers like you, etc.)
Hi @@ginamills5597 I might consider reviewing it, although it would have to be amazing to beat out that Mygreen Bag. I just love it.
@@PerriesPassport i have a feeling based on the pics that it's about the same. and that sherpani is more of a brand name so the price is higher. i personally live on a budget like most people so if something from amazon works then I don't need the name brand.
@@PerriesPassport ps, i like a convertible bag but when i first started looking for one, the only one i could find was the sherpani or lug which were a bit pricey for me at that time. I think the concept is becoming more popular so I'm seeing many other choices now. I believe it's b/c many of us use a backpack or crossbody for our travel (as in on a tour) and many museums now won't allow backpacks or larger crossbody so having the option as a tote helps.
FYI…Will not work as a personal item on Aer Lingus.
Hi @241JMJRAir Lingus allows a bag that is 10 in x 13 in x 8 in, which is a bag far bigger than this in depth and 2 inches shorter, which in my experience with them has not been an issue. The problem is always with the depth with the European carriers. That being said, if you are nervous, in 2 weeks I have 2 more bags that also meet this exact requirement. Hope this helps.
I just wondering about the weight
Hi @user-qr5og5gg6i Empty, the My Green bag weighs 2 lbs and the CYUREAY is 1 lb
You do realize that after you packed these bags you showed us that they were no longer 5 inches in depth. If you measure with all that you put in the front section of the bag, you will see what I mean. Just thought you'd want to know.
Hi @michelinebeattie7789 Actually only the My Gren bag had a pocket that came out about a 1/4 inch, but that bag remained a bit more "squishy" than the other bag did and it did meet airline complie4nce when I used it. The other bag was not as squishy so I guess you would have to be careful and not overpack it.
Now that you've packed your bag, it's not 5" deep any more.
HI @JD-zt3nr. Which bag? Only the Mygreen bag got a bit wider but it was still squishy enough to get into the sizer. Also I stuffed the bag, so if you didn't do that, there wouldn't be an issue.