'We Can Be Enemies, But We Can Still Trade' |
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
- Staying out of Ukraine, despite immense pressure from the US and the EU, was one of the two best things that India did in terms of foreign policy during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s last term, says Amit Gupta, senior adviser, Forum of Federations in Ottawa.
The advantages of that go beyond getting cheap oil from Russia. It also gave India the leeway to navigate its own foreign policy.
“The second one, which I am very proud of, is vaccine maitri,” says Gupta, who’s a former faculty of the US Air Force Air War College, and works mostly on international security, pop culture, and politics. He’s also coached the War College soccer team.
“Because if you look at that, while the US and the west were hoarding vaccine supplies and raw materials, India went out an gave it to people as far away as Antigua, and neighbours like Bangladesh,” he says. The fact that India did this for free in many cases is very very creditable, he asserts. Until it stopped because the US cut off the supply of raw materials, he adds.
The two areas where India didn’t do so well include dealing with China and having too many expectations from the United States, believes Gupta.
“There’s no sense of imagination left on how to deal with China. The positions are very rigid, and we are losing out, because China’s the behemoth in Asia,” he says.
Rattling off figures, he notes that China has 870 odd billion dollars of trade with ASEAN, 780 billion with the EU, 670 billion with the U.S., and about 300 billion with the Japanese and the Koreans.
‘And the Japanese and the Chinese and the Koreans hate each other. But the one thing they say is that nothing gives us greater joy than to make money off our enemies,” says Gupta. “India’s trade with China is about a 130 billion or so.”
All these countries say they have valid territorial disputes with China, but that doesn’t mean we can’t have a trading arrangement with it.”
Another “minor miss,” he says, “is that you still have an unruly neighbourhood.”
If you take out Bangladesh and to some extent Sri Lanka, India does not have a sense of amity in the region, which would allow you to expand your foreign policy and encourage greater economic cooperation, he feels.
How does the huge trade deficit with China, which applies not just to India but to almost every nation that China deals with, impact relations?
“The problem is that India (and the US) talk about greater reciprocity and soon, but when I talk to Indian manufacturers, they say the problem isn’t China, the problem is India,” he says.
“Because until your goods leave the gate of the factory, you are competitive with China. But they minute they go out and all the state and national taxes get slapped on, you suddenly non-competitive with the Chinese.”
The main issue? The Chinese think big, India doesn’t. They have reached out where other people don’t want to go,’ says Gupta, noting how a tiny place like Tierra Del Fuego has only two car dealerships, Chery, which is Chinese, and Hyundai, which is korean. And how Brazil is awash with Chinese cars.
“Another major issue is that the Chinese have put a huge emphasis on education, while India as pushed education into a downward spiral,” he adds. Apart from scaling up top notch Universities, the three countries which are filing the most patents each year in the world are China, Japan and South Korea, he notes.
The conversation then moves on to India-US relations, the insignificance of the QUAD when compared to AUKUS. “Why is it that three White Countries (US, UK, Australia) are determining the security architecture of the Indo Pacific?” asks Gupta.
Watch the full interview to know the answer to that question, as well as get intriguing and unconventional takes on India’s relationship with the US, UK and Russia, the issues plaguing the Indian diaspora, the American (and Canadian) hypocrisy over the Khalistanis, why India should under no circumstances ease its liability laws to allow American companies like Westinghouse sell it nuclear reactors, and finally, can China and India kiss and make up?
Join Nitin Gokhale's Strategic Group WhatsApp Channel to get the latest updates from articles on our website and videos on our UA-cam Channel: www.whatsapp.c...
Since many of our well-wishers requested a UPI payment id to contribute and support us, here’s the link, which gives us 100% of what you choose: stratnewsgloba...
You can also click and buy a UA-cam Super Thanks(the heart icon where you liked this video), which directly supports StratNewsGlobal, with 70% of your chosen amount.
Leave your comments, questions, and feedback. Like and share our videos. Subscribe to our UA-cam channel. Click on the 🔔icon to get notified of our latest uploads.
To get instant updates join our telegram circle - t.me/stratnews...
A great guest...a true patriotic Indian with an objective views on truth and pragmatism for India to do the right things. If India can take the views of this guest in dealing with its neighbors, especially with China, the world would be a better place without the US creating havoc around the world.
@@Allkongar ❤️❤️
India can be a far better country if it doesn't take orders from America!
@@Allkongar but jealousy and ego wouldn't let the Indians forget their humiliation of the 1962 war where they got a terrible beating from a much weaker China of today. If they were to fight another hot war India may not exist after that.
@@Sian-v2o Did you forget what happened in 1967? Why isn't China able to take back the so called Southern Tibet🤧
@alonewarrior7612 they could if they had wanted to since Delhi was in the retreat and could fall anytime Beijing decided to withdraw and let India breathe again. Do not rouse the dragon it may not go well the next time around.
'THE PROBLEM ISN'T CHINA. IT'S INDIA' - Absolutely agree
From : Singapore 🇸🇬
We neither believe China nor USA. The problem isn't India , it's China. It is stupid to believe ur enemy. It is as good as a butcher saying believe me. The funny part is u all believe the world as an order. If someone is economically mighty we just have to believe them because they are number 1 despite killing our soldiers in borders , occupying our land. Despite being poor we object to it. So you are saying that India don't have right to say as it's poor. India is much pratical than projected here. We banned tiktok which is so useless, there is no use of it except time waste. We banned shein, no use of it as we have large textile industry same as China banned UA-cam and google. We banned some chinese cars to protect our industry. What is wrong in that. These all videos are just a propoganda to make india stutter and further help chinese agenda and jobs
VERY VERY TRUE. ABSOLUTELY 💯 AGREE
INDIA IS THE PROBLEM.
CHINA IS THE SOLUTION.
India and China must cooperate for the future of both people. Do not allow foreign powers to divide and rule over you like in the past. Good neighbours is the only option
India can not be friends. Very loud mouth, arrogant, and very boastful. Every where they go very noisy.
yeah that means China dictates the rules....the solution is India develops with America or be lost. China used America, why can't India do that. India should cut off China from all trade period.
Tell that to Modi and his government..... twisted facts dun hold water!
@@ahkoy973 we do what is good for us and us only. We don't care about China or Asia.
Twisted facts and anti China propaganda is important to democratic government to score points. They need to cover up their failures.
When you want something said, ask India, and when you want something done, ask China..
Well said
Back then I heard of "India Superpower 2020", then it moved to "India Superpower 2025", and now it got changed again to "India Superpower 2030" slogan. 😪
India is alreay a mega power(new status for India) .. Forget superpower
@@oceanwave4502as legend puts i "abn aspiring super wannabe"
stupid comment..india does a lot, and china talks a lot too.
100% TRUTH. WISH INDIAN POLITICIANS, MEDIA AND INFLUENCERS LISTEN TO THIS PROGRAM.
EXCELLENT, THANKS
I'm 100% believe u make friends with China everybody happy and rich. I'm a Filipino they want to fight with China talk to China make friends maybe Philippines us rich and no fighting.china is ur neighbor make friends with ur neighbor
A filipino guy doesnt speak worst english like this so stop pretendin to be a filipino coz you are a chinese guy trying hard to speak english.
Your corrupt Marcos took US bribes. It cannot happened. Paid for Job to cause trouble knowing it suicidal for Filipinos
so far u the only Filipino that talk sense
Your president still has billions of corruption money that his late father has stashed in the US. So he has to obey his US master in order to get back the billions of corruption money
Philippines will become a friend of China if it stays away from the US and is not manipulated by the US.
Imagine if India and China can work together. The Asia will be rising.
应该合作，但是印度领导人显然更喜欢抱西方大腿，中国很希望跟印度合作！
@@曾林-k7q跟印度合作就算了，不要被印度背后捅刀就谢天谢地了，他发展他的，我们发展我们的，最好互不打扰。
India will not be used by China. India would be more propserous if they attach on the US and the west. They are so many Indians on US and West and that will benefit the country. India is a neutral country but if a country do dirty things on them ofcourse India will never back down. China showing bad things on the borders makes Indians pissed off.
It's not possible in the near future...... there are many smart Indians who become not smart once they become top politicians, ..
@@bertronix182 继续被你的印度媒体洗脑吧。如果你们想要战争，中国就会给你们战争。我们才不在乎印度要做美国的狗，美国的狗儿子够多了，再多一个印度也无所谓。我们要先把美国打败，然后再收拾美国的狗儿子们。
iMO, if India considers China as enemy, in most likelyhood, china will stop buying from India. Why? because there are no Indian products/services that China can not acquire somewhere else. Not sure if India can replace Chinese products with the same price and quality from somewhere else. Just an opinion.
To be honest, the Chinese people don't know how to boycott Indian goods because.... People can't even find Indian goods anywhere，Perhaps there are still some things like crispy fried balls, but almost... No one will buy it
India makes its own
What is China buying from India, right now, that they will stop ? China is trying to dump its own cheap goods on Indian market, while restricting market access for Indian goods.
@@rajx7120 China is trying to dump its own cheap goods on Indian market?? it is the Indian merchants who go to china, buy these cheap goods and send them to India. It is regular Indians who willingly buy them. I don't see China forcefully sells them to India. IMO. you are blaming the wrong people.
@@tompell3032 if China stop supplying India with raw materials for their pharmaceutical industry India would loose a huge chunk of the medical market. They import about 70% of raw materials from China. Not to forget the electronics where they import 60+% from China too. So India is not on the position to boast about anything .
This is one of the more objective and sensible discussion about China. Usually on Indian media, China is demonized as the cause of all things wrong in India. Bravo for getting a fair-minded realist guest.
Twisted facts and anti China propaganda is important to democratic government to score points. They need to cover up their failures.
@@simonooi2544CCP does the exact same thing you describe…blame everyone else for CCP failures.
@raevj
China is AHEAD of most, if not ALL countries!!!
Not perfect, but what failures are you referring to?
@@raevj At this era of information age you are still living in the lies of western media. Please visit China to see for yourself and research from alternative sources.
@@raevj it's easy to pinpoint but please verify your fact from reliable source. Don't try to point to some western media anymore , everyone already knows their anti china jealousy propaganda.
so much wisdom from these two gentlemen enjoyed the whole 46 minutes. thank you
People around the world's still cannot understand that China is growing in the region. This is something that we must accept the reality. Hopefully that this must change their mindset and move forward to the future. Look at China today that more and more countries looking for China to work together.
有些美国政客每天不提一句中国，那么他就不会写出漂亮的提案。
This was old news. US is delinking with China. They won't allow europe to trade with China. China is going down fast. Worlds factory is shifting to india. Why we need China? That China has ended
Just cannot trust our neighbours intentions, when they shake their head for yes it's means no.
If china grows then there is a great threat to regional countries which we have been watching
Indian head bobble? Lol
We will never forget that the United States watched tens of thousands of Indians die from Covid-19 every day but insisted on banning the export of vaccines and various anti-Covid materials to India. At the same time, China has repeatedly expressed, behind the door or in public, its willingness to provide India with its own vaccines free of charge.
In Phillippine, they just found out secret documents of US military spreading anti-vax propaganda to tell everyone don't use China vaccine through lies and other misinformation.
true
It's ego problem
We can't trust China with anything😂 free vaccines for the disease they themselves created?? Oh no.....never
China never provide anything free of cost. Also I heard that Chinese vaccines were a failure. So I thank God that Modi Government didn't permit Chinese Vaccines into India. And eventually our Indian Government came out of this crisis without much damage.
India need tons of money to build infrastructure to catch up with China. Who still invest money in infrastructure today? China and Japan, but China can offer much cheaper arrangement, something that India with its lack of money, need the most. India also need machinery to build its industry, and China is one of the producers for it, and also the cheapest one, something again, that India with its lack of capital, will benefit the most from it. More importantly, India need investment, and China has plenty of money to invest, and certainly China is or maybe was interested in India. But after how India government treated several Chinese companies that heavily invested in India, I doubt more Chinese companies will follow suit.
China looked at Japan tried to build high speed rail in India. By the time China finished building High speed rail in Indonesia, Japan still stuck in bureaucracy within Indian corrupt gov. China walked away as they escaped from Indian trap.
印度对待我们企业的事情在我们这边传开了，估计很少有企业再敢过去投资了！你们的领导只看眼前利益，失去信誉才是最可怕的
And get into debt trap.... Good idea mate 👌🏾
@@hemantachandra6962anyone says "debt trap" is insulting the intelligence of the borrowing countries.
India is too arrogant & delusional for its own good.
India needs to cooperate with China to accelerate its transformation into a global manufacturing power, with seamless integration with global supply chain.
It has long been China's stance that "Put the border disputes aside, let us cooperate on everything else. "
An emerging power like India cannot let its development be kidnapped by border disputes.
Look at Japan and S. Korea. These two East Asia neighbors can sit down for negotiations and cooperations, despite of their long time disputes over the sovereignty of the Liancourt Rocks in the sea between them. That is political wisdom and diplomatic maturity on full display.
Other countries such as China and India can definitely learn from S. Korea and Japan to manage their difference on borders, LAC, or whatever, and develop their relationship for the benefit of the economy and people.
The US, with its dirty "divide and conquer" tricks, doesn't want to see BRICS countries developing fast together. They'd rather see the two neighboring Asian giants fighting, hurting and weakening each other, to maintain their domination in Indo-Pacific for their own geopolitical interests.
A sane voice.
India had no specific strike forces on the northern border, and the posture was completely defensive, patrolled mostly by the Indo-Tibetan Border Police or ITBP. Things can still be kept calm on a disputed border if the place and timing of patrols around that border is known to both sides. If things are kept calm for a few years, then mutual confidence can build up and perhaps a more permanent agreement could be reached in time. One can see a lot of mutually beneficial things on the plate, including trade and investment.
There's one problem - salami slicing. When it suits them, like when Xi Jinping last visited India, the Chinese patrol forward and then refuse to leave, which is basically occupying new land. Then it seems that they are talking out of both sides of their mouth. That's when fatal clashes occur on the border.
_There is no way forward if the Chinese continue to do this_. India has not yet gotten into a common defensive pact with other nations on China's periphery and had not fully committed to the QUAD which is why AUKUS happened.
Now, we may have to align with other nations for a defensive alliance.
Not going to happen. Indian politicians need China as a convenient enemy for domestic politics.
Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
It has been China's policy: trade with us, we will take only a few acres of land a year. India cannot trade with China ever. India's solution is the same solution China, use America. India must allow US military bases in India and create refueling stations. China is against America only when other nations want to do business with America. It was fine for China but not for India
A smart and pragmatic Indian.
Patent applications are one thing; patent *grants* are another.
In 2023, China was granted more technological patents than the United States and Japan combined!!! This tells you everything you need to know.
As a Chinese, I think India is a superpower, and that's what I see being said on social media. China values India and considers it a friend.
As a Chinese I think india is a joke
india is not a superpower .
No china is a super power.
India is a superpower only in a Bollywood movie.🦉
hahaahaha
The gentleman on Indja siding with the US is a joke. Being is a friend of the US is the worst any country can do for itself, so said Henry Kissinger.
How do you think China got to be rich. By being the US's friend against the USSR. This man is a weak woman/man and his ilk ran India for much of its independence.
Great examples are Japan, South Korea, Israel, UK - you want to add...
They are not friends. They are vassal states. @@adityabanerjee7145
@@adityabanerjee7145u can't put Uk in that group... UK is a happy country , determinedly happy to reverse roles to play slave to their master Uncle Sam...
@@adityabanerjee7145 The most infamous example is Pakistan
Thanks!
🙏🏾
this speaker is amazing. he is an Indian treasure. he speaks the Truth about the evil and hypocrisy of the US, especially when it comes to Israel. India needs this man for India to improve and advance forward. He sees the truth! He should run for political office
As if China is not hypocrite. Atleast US imports from us. China restricts market access to Indian goods.
Not gonna happen
@@rajx7120I don't think Indian products have restricted access to Chinese market. Why don't Indian companies setup shops in China, bring their products to sell there on their own and see how they will do?
@@johnting4302 They did before 2020.
Now chinese companies are restricted in India unless the do JV and transfer of tech to local company
Once in the past the British colonizer stole the land from China. But India doesn't get to keep it. This is a common sense.
Not only land. Then you have to read about the authentic history of China during the colonial era.
The Indians think they're the next "great Britain empire". 😁😁
tibbat is not china
@@AmitSangwan123 Sikkim is not a part of India
@@titanxie5579Sikkim is a part of India because most of the Sikkimese people love being a part of India whereas not the same with Tibet.
India is a muti ethnic country
2 China is also a Multiethnic country but China is 90% Han chinese
India should partner China and China will help India improve its infrastructure.
no thanks
@@jeya9139... Good for you duh!
India should never trust China lol....that is a path towards failure.
Too young too naive!!!
I dont understand why the Indian always talk about china. I dont see china talk bad about india. Fellow indian get your priorities right or else you will forever talking.
China talks less,does more. They have a policy of nibbling. We must copy them with Pakistan . Nibble. Dont do war. China is land hungry.
Plain Jealousies n western tool to discredit China thru Lies.
Ask your PLA, why they intrude our borders, and violate border agreements.
Your media doesn't show the border violations done your PLA. Start respecting borders.
Been an enemy since 1962
Thanks
appreciate your support @bhararat04 🙏🏾
Jut sum it up ..... INDIA is about 100 YRS behind China in almost every aspect. We lost our edge many yrs ago ...... Sad, but True.
Absolutely agree
Visited India more than 15 years ago when it reported growth of more than 12 % yearly catching up China. But what I saw then I know even if China stood still for the next 20 years India will never catch up with all the slump, sanitary, water and racist caste system treating dalits so inhumane.
India didn't lost its edge over China, it was forever all the way behind China ... that's why you see all the envy and jealousy. Nuff said!
@@stansony4885 Very true
@@genbond7459 Absolutely agree
Learning from China means making revolutionary changes in land policies, basic education, infrastructure construction, and many other aspects. This means confiscating a considerable portion of the cake belonging to interest groups and returning it to the people. You can imagine how much resistance India will encounter to make such changes, and that is what you will face. There is a Chinese saying: 功成不必在我，功成必定有我. The meaning is that great achievements do not necessarily have to be achieved by me in the end, but there must be my full effort in them. You may want to experience this collectivist spirit.By the way, watching Western media can greatly distort your observations of China. Who lives in an airtight cage.
Collectivist spirit? China? Who are you "collecting" for, your billionaires and dragon families?
Learning from others is ok but India has to chart its own course. It has an old soul and wisdom that it can lead the world in peace and harmony. It does not have to follow the west or China but chart its own. I hope India neither tries to emulate America or China but just be India. Others do not understand India just as you say about China by others.
@@striker44 I think what you said is correct. Apart from the dispute caused by the border drawn by the British, there is no major conflict between the two countries. As world powers, the two countries should make due contributions to the peaceful development of Asia.
in other words, India needs a cultural revolution.
How many land and nation did India took from its neighbor?! Go back and review before you question China. India as today don’t even exist before the British colonized it. Don’t blow yourself out of proportion.
Excellent, excellent interview. The best thing was about what we are doing about China than showing how China is bad. Usually we get chest thumping about how India is behaving proudly and independently, which takes us nowhere.
Very very serious and illuminating talk for a common man from a fine scholer. Also qudoes to the interviewer for asking very pointed questions with minimum of his own views while giving full freedom to the man.
Chinese roads and infrastructure are a decade ahead of the western world. I would ask INDIANS to visit and tour China .... maybe they will learn something 🤪 !!
no thank you we don't want your china advise , now you going to tell it was china invented road , we don't want your crook idea
Don't worry slow and study wins the case there's no need to indebt nation in a h 25:53 urry because of for that we don't have china like railway and roads at present but that debt become s a burden too for coming period I hope you understood the problem
@@ghanvedsingh8946 You need roads and infrastructures to develop and prosper, if you'r e satisfied using your donkeys or rickety vehicles to travel your potholed dirt roads and stay in the dark ages, then by all means don't build any infrastructures to have ZERO debt.
Just remember this, that debt will be paid multiple times with the ease and comfortable travel it gives to travelers, the ease you can transport your products , and the progress it will bring to the community
the least ccp nationalist
Don't ask Indian nationals to tour your China. It is a country they dislike the most. Instead they should all immigrate to USA or UK which they admire.
High respect for the guest educated world view and his truthful analysis. He said what it is with unbiased truth. He should be India's prime minister or at least a government advisor for India advancements. Salute ❤
Indian should realised that waiting for American to help will never Come. You have to stand on your own 2 feet.
They have a long tounge.
India has to build more and increase staff of its scam call centers.🤪
If there were more Indians like Gupta, the China /India border issue would be resolved amicably. Furthermore, India would’ve a greater chance of achieving its potential.
Not going to happen. Indian politicians need China as a convenient enemy. That's good for domestic politics.
India invaded China in 1962 through Nehru's forward policy when China was having a massive famine from 1958 to 1962 and during the Sino-Soviet split from 1960 to 1962. It was a once in a lifetime opportunity that India would never miss to grab more land from a weakened China. When India gets beaten up and lost the war that they had started despite all these advantages, not to mentioned military supplies from Israel and USA (Research on "Israel aid to India in the 1962 war" and "America's aid to India in the 1962 war" and "JFK’s Forgotten Crisis"), she cried to the entire world and plays the victim. Till now, India never dares to disclose the "Henderson Brooks and Neville Maxwell report on the 1962 war" even after 60+ years. And when the report was leaked into the internet momentarily in 2014, India demanded the report to be purged permanently from the internet citing "national security"....just like BBC's documentary on the 2002 Gujarat Massacre and Modi's involvement. You have to got to wonder why🤔🤥😏🥱A nation without integrity and honesty and a spawning ground for all the scam callers has no credibility on the Global Stage😏.
@@LandGrabbingIndia you've just rewritten history. It was China that invaded India and not the other way round . China would have marched into new Delhi if they had wanted to but chose to withdraw. So believe what you want the real facts are there for everyone to see. I know that Indians are well known for having big mouths but lying to this extend is a new low.
@@Sian-v2o No country rewrites history as good as India. During his visit to Nepal in 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi himself, addressing Nepal's Parliament said, “Nepal is the country where the apostle of peace in the world, Buddha, was born,”. However, Jaishankar, India's foreign minister said in year 2020 that "Buddha was a great Indian"? Tell me, who is lying? Buddha can't be an Indian and a Nepalese at the same time. Who's lying? Dishonest breed. Why did your FM apologized through a proxy spokesperson, Anurag Srivastava, and retracted his claim that "Buddha was an Indian" and amended his statement to "there is no doubt that Gautam Buddha was born in Lumbini, which is in Nepal"? ➡Article: "India dismisses controversy over Jaishankar's remarks on Buddha (Times of India)". 🔚
@@Sian-v2o Lying to this extend and denying the truth is a new low.
@@Sian-v2o The Chinese were having the "great Chinese famine" from 1958 to 1962. Would China pick a war with India when they are having a massive famine? Think, Indian, think.
@@Sian-v2o India had Israeli and American support in the form of supplies/weaponry. Research on "Israel aid to India in the 1962 war" and "America's aid to India in the 1962 war" and "JFK’s Forgotten Crisis". China had no support from Soviet and the West. The Sino-Soviet split from 1960 - 1962. China had nothing. Would China pick a war with India when they are having a massive famine and no support from either sides if one of the sides take sides with India? Think, Indian, think.
Mr. Gupta, India needs you.
I am a serious China supprter. I want to see India progress. not be so far behind China. It is pathetic.
Quite a smart gentleman...better than any politicians
Im really impressed by the guest he is spitting facts truly 🙏🙏
really? what kind of taxes are imposed on goods meant for exports?
Finally, someone I would listen to. Respect🙏🙏🙏
@sachair
Go ask jayant bhandani
He can tell you better.
They got paid by CAP to speak false facts. they speak like pro-china shills..
@@sachair2701he is not talking exports. He is talking goods competing with Chinese goods in Indian market
current foreign minister talks without understanding the real nuances inplay between india and china
Fix Corruption, Law and Election commission rest will fall in place..Cos if I go to court for any reason I should get justice..
This interview should've never ended.
China felt awe with technology, economy and social life in west back in 80s. Then they bow their head down, learn from the west and adapt it into Chinese society. Pick the best part, and discard the bad ones. After decades of adopting western system and knowledge, China becomes what today, the largest market, largest manufacturer, largest purchasing power, and largest technology innovator.
Meanwhile if you look at India medias, they are all filled with jealousy and blames. Brits took India gold. China took India market. USA took India freedom. etc. This kind of "I never wrong" mentality only hold Indians back from advancing ahead. Gov tried to spread illusion in Indian's mind that India is catching up with China and USA very soon is pretty hilarious. China economy alone is 12 times over than India, and US is even larger. When you look at the speed, China and USA is running even way faster for India to catch. Not to mention India embrace capitalism with monopoly which drives poor people to become poorer. In the end, India can be proud because they have 1 billionaires, while the rest of people can't afford to climb to middle class. Meanwhile China annual tourism was anticipated by US, EU and the rest of the World. EU even goes further to hire Chinese police in order to make Chinese tourists feel safe. Even back in 90s at peak height of US economy, you never see any country hiring US police to protect US tourists.
Never enrich an adversary who attack u. No human sense. Don't trade with them. The horrible Indian mentality of Delusions n Jealousies against China is evident. This ex British vassal state must obey her western masters to survive. It's a DEAD make up hybrid states of different language/ culture n religion. There can never ever be united as a nation.. The common language is English. Laughable n lack identity n credibility.
亲。你有聪明，却没有智慧。 建议你多去看看印地语他们的访谈，不然你看不到他们真正的想法，反而你圣母心泛滥地叫醒敌人。 蠢三才是好三。 别害了咱们和咱们国家。 好多西方政要曾经不怕得罪阿三，公开讲过阿三是内心中最排外的人。当它起来时，你我们都会遭殃的。 希望你能够深明大义把你的评论删掉。谢谢。 国人语言不过关才产生出警察在国外的事情，去看看泰国机场标识或者日韩东南亚，你就明白了我说的话了。 你用“bow their head down”并不妥，英语语境中不是这样表达的，而且这样形容国人的姿态过了头。
建议你多去看看印地语他们的访谈，不然你看不到他们真正的想法，反而你圣母心泛滥地叫醒di人。 chun三才是好三。 别害了咱们和咱们国家。 好多西方政要曾经不怕得罪阿三，公开讲过阿三是内心中最排外的人。当它起来时，你我们都会遭殃的。 希望你能够深明大义把你的评论删掉。谢谢。 你去看看那些在中国拿到很多福利并且娶到中国老婆的阿三，在油管这里做了多少抹黑诅咒造谣我们的视频。拜托你好好认清阿三，别再掏心掏肺了，他们永远不懂得你的善意或者明白你的用意，你又何苦这样？ 国人语言不过关才产生出警察在国外的事情，去看看泰国机场标识或者日韩东南亚，你就明白了我说的话了。 你用“bow their head down”并不妥，英语语境中不是这样表达的，而且这样形容国人的姿态过了头。
亲， 建议你多去看看印地语他们的访谈，不然你看不到他们真正的想法，反而你圣母心泛滥地叫醒di人。 蠢三才是hao三。 别害了咱们和咱们国家。 好多西方政要曾经不怕得罪阿三，公开讲过阿三是内心中最排外的人。当它起来时，你我们都会遭殃的。 希望你能够深明大义把你的评论删掉。谢谢。 你去看看那些在中国拿到很多福利并且娶到中国老婆的阿三，在油管这里做了多少抹黑诅咒造谣我们的视频。拜托你好好认清阿三，别再掏心掏肺了，他们永远不懂得你的善意或者明白你的用意，你又何苦这样？ 国人语言不过关才产生出警察在国外的事情，去看看泰国机场标识或者日韩东南亚，你就明白了我说的话了。 你用“bow their head down”并不妥，英语语境中不是这样表达的，而且这样形容国人的姿态过了头。
Why do you care
Indians are defeated by the Chinese in the 1962 war. It was the most humiliating defeat in history if you were to examine all the facts that were involved in the war. This is the ultimate proof that war tactics/strategy/determination/will power/bravery triumphs over superior weapons/technology/cowardice.
1) The Chinese were having the "great Chinese famine" from 1958 to 1962. China was too weak to defend itself.
2) India had Israeli and American support in the form of supplies/weaponry. Research on "Israel aid to India in the 1962 war" and "America's aid to India in the 1962 war" and "JFK’s Forgotten Crisis".
3) The Sino-Soviet split from 1960 - 1962. China had nothing. No weapons, guns, artillery supplies from either Western and Soviet and no food (serious famine).
4) Despite all these advantages, India lost.
5) There are no excuses for such a humiliating defeat. That is why India is so desperate to have the "Henderson Brooks and Neville Maxwell report of the 1962 war" concealed forever and also to hide which country is the true aggressor of the war. When it was leaked into the internet momentarily in 2014, India demanded the report to be purged permanently from the internet citing "national security"....just like BBC's documentary on the 2002 Gujarat Massacre and Modi's involvement.
All lies not facts
@@kik1139 Says the Indian bot.
Verify point #1 to point #5 and you will that they are all facts. Fact denying Indian bot couldn't swallow the facts.
Chinese consider
INDIA AN ASSOCIAATE OF USA.
Good
Since you already consider us as such, we shall be one
More accurate --- India is a vassal of the U.S.
@@saleelkhetle9596 congratulation for your new status as USA's proxy TOOLS
@@saleelkhetle9596 😂
So it is that easy to influence India
😂
India is not Anglo-Saxon culturally rooted: the Anglo-Saxon culture was imposed on the country. Fortunately, we have a respectable wiseman Mr. Amit Gupta to show the way to those willing to listen. I love India and wish the country and its people all the best.
How was attacking Iraq justified for 9/11? Or killing so many in Afghanistan gor 9/11? Osama's presence should not have condemned a nation.
Osama is Saudi, and we attacked Iraq!!? Just got the country mixed up . Hahah
You are talking about America's "Rules Based Global Order" applying to all EXCEPT the U.S. ---- America's so-called EXCEPTIONALISM!
You are talking about America's "Rules Based Global Order" applying to all EXCEPT the U.S. --- America's so-called EXCEPTIONALISM
And Osama found in Pakistan land but nobody talked about this
@@Goku65027
Shshsh...🤫🤫🤫
America's Reality Preceptions don't care about your inconvenient truths...!!!🤓
30:00 Henry Kissinger Quote: “To be an enemy of America can be dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal.”
no politician in india is serious about education because he himself was never educated and became politician as a gunda
Spot on on not trading with China! There is a metro line outside my house which ordered Chinese trains that the government stopped- now we are waiting waiting and waiting…
Despite screaming for boycott, the trade deficits with China keep growing almost to 100 billions ...😅
And you will continue to wait and wait...😅😂🤣😭
Keep waiting. Good luck.
and it not just a China issue, the Japanese train project are also stalling because the government keep changing the law. the lack of policy stability make it impossible for foreigner to invest as they do not know if they will ever see their returns... China has a reputation of solving problem for businesses, while India has a reputation of creating problem for businesses, that's really want prevent India from capturing FDI like China...
21:58 you have to wonder, why US is willing to provide Australia submarine, when their other allies to the north JP and SK aren't even consider, and just as stated here, 22.48 , it's pretty obvious they want to keep it in the family they trust
Because they're ripping us off.
lol, you got it wrong. Both Japan and S Korea capable to build submarine of their own. Japan even offer to sell Australia nuclear submarine, but PM Tony Abbott was pressured by China with sanctions if Australia bought from Japan. After Wang Yi visit, Australia navy took the offer from France for Diesel submarine in JUST 2 DAYS!!! Who the hell review billion dollars proposal in just 2 days??? Then PM Scott Morrison got pressured by Biden to buy old submarine, so he tore the French contract and went a head with 1996 design nuclear submarine, which will arrive in Australia, assembled, and ready for testing as soon as 2050. China will be testing proton cannon at that time!
@@ericwong4213didn't know about Japan's offer, but I read the news on France's Macron being very PO when Australia did 360 on them and went with the US...which at the end of the day US gets what they want when anyone is an ally...I should know, since I'm Canadian, Canada does what US wants...like the latest EV sanction, or Huawei phones are banned in Canada from selling
One day, when India is closely behind US like China today, India will realize US will block India from getting stronger and better even though India doesn't steal and rob like Western countries did in the 19 century...
@@ericwong4213 china will not exist by that time
Smart man! If more of Indians like him, India would have a very bright future.
Like if you replace Xi pieng as Chinese president
@@sureshp.s.1410
Stupig irrelevant comment.
No wonder Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
From : Singapore 🇸🇬
Amit Gupta is a pleasure to listen to . I will subscribe if your guests are of the same calibre.
China has not only *cheap* labor, it has *skilled* labor. China is really big on education; India isn't.
China's economic policies have been very intelligent and far-sighted. That's why China owns all the critical supply chains and why China is the master of vertical integration. All this is what makes China the one and only global manufacturing superpower.
China's supply chain is both vertical and horizontal integration. That's why the next China is China.
China's supply chain is both vertical and horizontal integration. That's why the next China is China.
India sent the best educated to the USA to run their big companies. China keeps its best to build its own companies.
Certainly as a malaysian indian, i agree w amit.
If India and China can work together, both will get tremendous benefits. If only……
There are over 120 Million unemployed jobless Indians without a future.
China cannot help. China has to take care of its unemployed youths first. 🦋
One of the very very few Indian show I have seen that have their feet on the ground
👍
Wow, this is the first time hearing the rational people talking about foreign policy. Excellent view of world events.
It is even more naive if anyone who thinks India has the ability to take back those territories by military force.
India will always be the best option for all countries ho really want to work hard to see a better future for their country because this great leader of India show the west and partners that India help a lot of countries to get the vacation and then still take care of their own country and that is a great plus
India should get emotionally over the loss of the 1962 war first then can they get their mind cleared for some business.
Stop violating birder agreements and stop defending Pakistani terrorists at the UN.
😂 good point
and china should accept reality it will remain in the middle income trap and never reach the level of the USA
Yes India will take back the land we lost from Chinese cheaters
and the sooner or later you figure out the loss of china in 1965
Indian need more people like the guest, has very clear understanding of the world.
The Chinese, Japanese, and Koreans do not hate each other. They have a long history. There are disputes as with any neighbor. They do disagree with the way the Japanese recognize what they did in WWII.
the new generations, perhaps. but not my generation.
Oh boy I have got some bad news for you, we hate each other to the bone alright😂
抱歉，我恨🇯🇵和南朝鲜。🧐
They do. Japan is scared of China or why the quad? Who needs quad? All hate china
Koreans hate the Japanese deeply, because they have been pillaging the peninsula a long time.
I think India should think about India people and country not try to copy America
Modi is an American idolizing poodle and pitch Hindus against other racial minorities to win elections
Why copy China, whose real estate companies are collapsing under debt, and scores of apartment complexes destroyed for lack of demand.
HOWDY 🤠 MODI is an “ADMIRER” 🤩 of AMERICA 🇺🇸
Apologies but India has clearly proven that it is independent
@@arsalanmirza3411 ---- Modi is an American idolizing poodle!
I say hello to the speaker, a man who is intellectually honest and an excellent analyst ! If 1.4 billion Indians are as competent as he is, India and China's relationship will again Chini Chini Bhai Bhai !To grow rich as India thinks she is on track to over take China by 2040 (what dreams are made off, as impossible as coming back from the dead!); India needs China to grow rich, China does not need India at all; China is already the richest nation on earth. Finally one simple question will answer everything. THE DAY THAT INDIA BECOMES LEADER OF BRICS IS THE DAY INDIA OVER TAKES CHINA.
Bollywood movies?
India don't need china , China desperately need India because china benefits the most in trade between the two countries . Look out the trade deficit of India with China. We will not discuss trade unless china stays away from our borders and stop claiming other country's territories. Instead We are happy to develop slower as it happening for last decades. India showed a brother gesture back then when we didn't raise objection on tibet , Taiwan, didn't take UNSC seat and china has given nothing to us , CCP is just a shit government.
We have our own brics
Very nice and educative conversation
Dude is right about no one takes India seriously
They do. They want to use india against Chinese. Thats their only intrest. They want to push india to do their dirty work of killing Chinese and bringing them down. Their policy is opening up Tibet, xingjiang
They will give free weapons. Free money. Everything. Provided we fight for them. They hate modi for not being their zelensky
They wanted modi to grab their money like musharaff. We are suddenly on every forum
They want to give us feeling of self importance. We are not impressed by that. Addressing their parliament doesnot fill our stomach. We are not moved by dramas like that. We are focussed on right things. Modiji is doing fine. After 5 trillion,our only aim would be to double it fast. Faster,fastest. 10 trillion economy would truely look great. Very great. Congress never had such ambitions. Congress never talked of gdp, per capita
Great video 👍🏻👍🏼
Keep it up !!
From : Singapore 🇸🇬
Amir Gupta is the only few sane Indian that can see through the whites dirty politics in being India friendly. Modi should have him as an advisor in geopolitics
he doesn't see through the yellow propaganda...pig eating yellow terror
Good luck to India. Thank you Amit Gupta for your analysis and opinions.
Amit is brilliant.
Nice discussion....
He is a smart person. Smarter than 99% of the people in charge of the nations.
India became independent from the British in 1947 (it was ruled by the British for 98 years). From 1948 to 2010, for 62 years, it could not do anything but talk big words! They really have to thank the British, otherwise the country still does not know how to do it. What language should be used to communicate?
Ok he is the only indian guy that made sense kudos to him😊
Every country has unresolved issues with their neighbors. It is the leadership's wisdom to prioritize issues. However, I do argue that India's top priority must be economic development and large scale job creation. A country with a lot of unemployed young people is sitting on a volcano. India also needs to build water works and infrastructure to protect their farmers from global warming.
Logic tells us that when your economy is stronger, you have more leverage dealing with your neighbors.
If India wants to solve the border dispute with China before economic relations can improve, they are doing it backwards.
Exactly！India’s biggest enemy is not China, but AI and robots. India must complete industrialization before automation technology becomes popular, otherwise, India will never be able to build its own industrial system. Africa still has abundant resources to feed its own population, what does India have? !
Modi has been trying to unite India through extreme nationalism and religion, as in Hinduism.
It's impossible for India to both be extreme nationalist and do business with China.
@@xiwang9560 modi forgot that there are some 200+ millions of muslims who are legally indian citizens . Ethnically they are all the same just their believes are different. Favouring one and discriminating another is just being morally wrong and stupid.
@@Sian-v2o modi is from rss, they kill indian muslims as their job.
Excellent interview with a very impressive guest and a good moderator....thanks
Brilliant interview
This gentleman is a gem! Wouldn't mind hearing him speak again and again!
India pays Russian with indian rupees for Russian oil but restricts Russian from using Indian rupees to buy Indian products. What a great nation India is! No wonder no one wants to keep their money.
India is paying with Russian currency, Russia won't except Indian currency
India is allowing both Russian and Indian currency and AFAIK Indian docks are building a number of ships for the Russkis, among other things both official and unofficial.
@@kabzaify
Grammar Police WARNING:
-except- ❌
*accept* ✅
Please learn the difference.
Gordon Chang should be able to tell India when it will become a Super Power! .... Hey Gordon where are you, I've got a customer for you!
Excellent interaction 👍👍Thank you so much! Please invite him again. 🙏
Indian politicians need some real strategic wisdom. Every neighbors have borders issues, but can not afford to become enemies
The way you described the neighbors as unruly as if they are your colony. You think you have amity with Bangladesh? When shit hits the fan like Maldives, you will know. You made each and every neighbor your enemy. You should be ashamed of the foreign policy you maintain. China will never say their neighbors are unruly. WTF! It's an insult and Maldives dealt with that pretty well. Hope the same happens in BD. A sovereign nation is an equal entity. Talk with respect. Sorry for the language.
During the time of Mao, Zhou Enlai offered to exchange Arunachal Pradesh for Aksai Chin to reach a peaceful and lasting settlement of the border dispute. But Nehru rejected the offer. Fast forward to today, Xi is still making the same offer but what about Modi? It is pointless to argue who owns Aksai Chin(AC) and who owns Arunachal Pradesh(AP) historically but to accept the reality that AC(38,000sq km) is now under China control while AP(84,000 sq km) under India. While China can claim that AP was part of Southern Tibet annexed by the British who ruled India when the the Qing Dynasty was in mortal decline and so was AC, this is now "water under the bridge..." It will not change the reality on the ground...Personally I am more inclined to the Chinese claim as the population and ethnicity of the people living in both AC and AP are Tibetan. But for the sake of a lasting peace and good neighbourhood, China should make some concession..
Great discussion and intellectually sound. Amit Gupta is rational and frank. India can do well and will do well when it can improve on the livelihood of the Indians and raise the living standard of the vast majority of those in the rural areas. I agree with Amit that India must increase the education of the poor and rural Indians. Hope India will increase the GDP of its citizen
India is around 500 years behind china in overall development specially people's mindest for discipline hardwork honesty punctuality
Brilliant speakers!!!!
Absolutely brilliant!!!
Ghanta brilliant
@@Muneerkhan-y3l maybe you didn’t understand it lol
@@DominicAlmeida-no4pf i know what m saying I know my country very well I don't need to read some Chinese propagandalist to know the reality of my country and it geopolitical world
Amit Gupta sees it realistically.He’s not deluding anyone.
To all those who actually watched the entire interview before commenting, Thank You.
To all the haters who believe abuse is also an opinion, bless you too.
Excellent episode , straight talk by Mr. Amit Gupta
A genuine and a practical guest. He should hold a position in the Indian government
Just to promote Chinese propoganda
Joke. Anti modi rant
Such a comprehensive coverage of international relations for India.. very nicely articulated n thoughtful... Thanks for sharing
India China and Pakistan need to get together and work out their birder disputes peacefully understanding each other's positions. Keeping these land disputes alive only serves the outside powers who exploit it for their own interests. The future prosperity belongs to Asian countries.
India is still thinking like during the colonial times.
Such a rational & crystal clear minded Amit Gupta, India 🇮🇳 needs someone like him instead of wasting time battling competing with China & anti-China, should leverage on China by working close with its better industrial production (Mock up product design, etc.) in order for Indian young people to be able to realise its ideas & devise even better Indian commercial products to market worldwide !
Another is to have China Mega Infrastructure construction companies to build infrastructure (High Speed train, etc.) for India whereby they are the leader for building infrastructure with better advancement, lower cost & shorter construction time.
We can do it. Our education system is archaic. Marks oriented not learning oriented. We teach too much. No time to discuss, understand, experiment, research, do science. Such student don't have habit of thinking,problem solving. Science needs change. Reflection. Atmosphere to do new. Marks crushes creativity. We must copy uk, Japan, even Russia. How they teach science. We are doing it absolutely wrong. Our student with 100 / 100 is not able to do anything with his information
Cramped ,memorized. Noone teaches him to think for himself.
A people's revolution will change all things. Its impossible
Vote counted, so hard to change, unless there is a revolution taking place or the rich/privilege one won't let it happens.
I see many anti-Indian comments, sadly. The border disputes have fostered nationalism on both sides.
Gupta wisely said that these disputes should not deter collaboration in other areas. China said it too. As two most populous neighbours, it's inevitable that sooner or later, the need for markets for their growing manufacturing industry will be overwhelming.
It was the same for Japan, as the first wave, spawning SK, Taiwan and Singapore in the second wave, which in turn catalyses China next.
India is next and it could be explosive if it collaborates with China. It's through investments from these countries that you develop a manufacturing base and an ecosystem of supply chains.
It's really not about India vs China but India + China that will be a big part of the Eurasia miracle.
One of brilliant and knowledgeable man, Mr. Amit Gupta. Good discussion
Well done..
An absolutely enlightening interview with probably the most sensible Indian commentator I've heard in a long time...👍👍
He is factually wrong. There are no taxes being slapped on goods meant for export. In fact, one is entitled to credit of input taxes paid when goods are exported.
Export of goods and services are zero rated under GST. Exporters can claim refund of input tax credit (ITC) of inputs/input services used in export of goods/services, subject to fulfilment of prescribed conditions. 6:20
I think the issue is how long does it take to get it back without any hassle?
yes, gov doesn't tax export
but gov officials demand tax for export, otherwise ur goods will never leave the port.
@@ericwong4213 --- that, my friend, is bribery & corruption
That tax is called BRIBERY. I ran two foreign investment companies in Chennai and Delhi for over 5 years. We eventually folded n left because of corruption. Meanwhile our investments in China is booming and rewarded. India needs to stem its corruption that runs through its entire country.
@@daniellee8720 Bribery. If we don't fix this, we'll be left with table scraps. Or perhaps we'd be toast. But I digress. You're absolutely right.
I do think the OP should be commended for pointing out a pretty big booboo from the guest of the interview, it should've been about the endemic corruption, a holdover from our Socialist past with a 90+ % tax rate, where everyone had to get dirty or die.
24:00 Indian in India should one self, which group has India benefit most from: QUAD or BRICS+
You are right when you said nobody takes India seriously.
Guest is absolutely right
Except you both and two gentlemen in the program everyone takes India seriously 😮😮😮
Well, if your girlfriend or wife start to play both sides then you should understand better? 🤣 🤣 🤣
Is there that much division between Indians? Gugurat vs Bengalis?
@@SuryakalaShiramshettythe whole world laughs about India and the peacock Modiji, except you and other brainwashed indians😂😢😮😢😂