Update 12/20 This video is blowing up right now. thank you all so much! I know we all miss Jonghyun so much but he is always in our hearts and he watches over SHINee and Shawols. Thank you everyone for the comments and the views. I appreciate it a lot. The categories like “sexy” and “cute” are completely subjective in my opinion lol. I tried to be more objective with vocal and the others. I am heavily biased towards Taemin’s although ever member is beautiful and perfect and unique. Taemin’s vocals keep impressing me in his new albums. Everyone stream Idea :) Also I didn’t make a “bias” category for my ranking because it’s too hard to rank them individually and I don’t like ties. But it would look something like. 1. JongTae 2. Key 3. OnHo Thanks again everyone. 💖 Also Jjong and Taemin need to be switched in rapping.
See, the problem is Minho has his flaming charisma meanwhile Tae is death staring everyone and Jong is giving people illegal thoughts so any sexiness ranking is almost impossible.
technically speaking key and taemin are.not interchangeable taemin is above avarage vocalist and key weak-to average taemin has better technique and support it's just key's voice is more loud than taemin'.
Taemin's voice is breathy that's why his sexy songs hit different 😂 But they are legends in Kpop and the fact each person owns very unique color thanks to which we can separate easily from other groups are just enough
I definitely agree with many aspects of this ranking. When it comes to vocals, Jonghyun and Onew definitely take the top 2 spots. Taemin and Key are almost equal in terms of technique, it just comes down to their vocal color and stylistic choices which are both based on preferences. Those two would be equally placed in 3rd for me. Minho may not have been added to the group as a vocalist, but you can definitely see how much he’s improved over the past 13 years, he’d easily be a lead vocal in any other group with his current vocal skills. In terms of dance, I think Taemin in definitely ranked first in terms of technique. He has so much body control and at the same time, he is so fluid with his movements. Key is also an awesome dancer, I think he definitely expresses his movements well and is great at emphasizing during certain movements. Of course, there are subjective opinions as well regarding different dance styles. The rest of the members are also great dancers, again, they’ve improved so much over the years, it’s crazy to think that some of them hadn’t danced at all prior to being in Shinee. In terms of rap, I really don’t know where I’d place Onew, Taemin, and Jonghyun. Minho and Key are definitely the rappers of the group but since Shinee’s music in general doesn’t focus much on rap, it’s hard to place them on clear, definitive ranks since they don’t seriously rap in many of their songs and it’s hard to have consistent comparisons. I’d honestly just place those 3 in 3rd after Minho and Key. The 5 of them all rank 1st in terms of visuals... if you think so otherwise you’re wrong. 🤷🏻♀️ All in all, the 5 of them all contribute something special to the group. Each one of them is irreplaceable and without one of them, Shinee ceases to still exist as Shinee. That’s what makes this group so great and special, the fact that everyone excels in something different yet are all exceptional in every aspect.
I prefer Taemin’s vocal color over Key. Also a lot of people have said Jonghyun should rank ahead of Taemin in rap. Also minho’s vocals are really pretty I forget the song but they covered IU song recently and I love his vocal tone.
I agree they are all good dancers and visual is based on preference but they all bring something unique to the table with their visual and are always bias wrecking me 🤣.
Tbh, taemin improves a lot. And he actually support his vocal and resonate it. While key, his support is shallow and bcs shinee's songs are high for tenor and key is not tenor, it's a disadvantage for him, makes him strain a lot and tension happened.
Key's last two comebacks have placed him very high in all categories, in my opinion. He has called himself a chicken among swans, but he's totally a swan now. I prefer Taemin's vocal tone, but Key can do whatever he wants to with his voice, and he's very consistent from low to high. Onew's latest comeback (Dice) has proved his versatility. Can't wait for Minho's album and Taemin's return.
For me even minho is soo amazing? Why? Minho being scouted by SM on the street because of his visual. He was supposed to be the face of the group an his position supposed to be rapper and dancer. He didnt born with amazing singing skill like jonghyun or maybe onew. What we heard from minho now is 70% came from his effort and hard work and 30% from his originally skill. From debut until now in 2021 he never stucked he got better and better.
Even jonghyun was scouted by his looks,not knowing that he is a vocal god..anyway minho is improved so much and yeah he is amazing,they are all amazing♥️
I just love to see how they covers each other’s weak sides and also how much they’ve put their efforts in to improve themselves. That makes shinee be more shinee.
Every members are talented n have their own charm..n our super talented jonghyun,he can put soul into his music n his voice suitable fr every kind of songs..lets keep supporting this dorks....
Onew Key Jonghyun and Taemin, each of them can be main vocal in any kpop group, even better than some actual main vocal in some of group (since Jjong already be main vocal in SHINee and be king of vocal). Change my mind
I understand why Minho was number 5 for vocals. Someone had to be, right? We all know this is a group of amazing singers, dancers, and rappers. They are the definition of iconic. I’ll be a Shawol forever!
Taemin is just so impressive, man... When they debuted, he wasn't the best at dancing (Kibum was better) and was the worst/second worst at singing. Through his hard work and determination he became one of the all-rounded best idols (if not the best) in the industry, a role model and living legend. And he's only 27!
He wasn’t best at dancing? He only got added to SHINee because of his dance skill. They thought he wasn’t a good singer but he was such a great dancer they added him.
@@riahlexington Yeah, Kibum is 2 years older and it made a difference when they were teenagers. You can find a few videos of his predebut popping on youtube, it's really impressive.
They are different people and each bring their own shine, talent and uniqueness to the group. Otherwise, they wouldn't be a part of it. In addition, if they had the same qualities and style, the group would actually be dull and stiff. They blend well together and are also able to carry out solo activities well.
My ranking! Vocals #1 Jonghyun #2 Onew #3 Key #4 Taemin #5 MinHo Dance #1 Taemin #2 Jonghyun (she was amazing dancer even when he carried most of the dificult vocal lines he danced awesome, always manly and powerful) #3 Key #4 MinHo #5 Onew Visual #1 MinHo #2 Jonghyun #3 Taemin #4 Onew #5 Key Rap #1 Key #2 MinHo #3 Jonghyun #4 Taemin #5 Onew All rounder #1 SHINee haha About solo albums, it's unfair the ranking because the other members have not had the same oportunities that Taemin had. Cuteness I agree Sexy #1Jonghyun #2 MinHo #3 Taemin #4 Key #5 Onew ( he is so cute Even when he tries to be sexy)
If I have to rank them in vocals objectively, this would be my list - 1. Jonghyun 2. Onew 3. TaeKey 4. Minho Vocal ranking based on preference. 1. Taemin (he pulled me into KPop with his vocals). 2. Onew 3. Jonghyun 4. Minkey Dance Ranking (Objectively) 1. Taemin 2. Key 3. OnJongHo Dance Ranking (Preference) 1. Taemin 2. Jonghyun 3. OhHoKey Love all of them! They each bring something special to SHINee.
I think Minho is a multi-talented person and he sings-raps very good. Even though a lot of people say he is worst in singing, ı dont think like that. Heartbreak and I am home just explains us he is also good at singing. He isnt just the rapper boy! He can have both soft and cold voices. I just think we cannot compare him with Teamin or Onew or Key or anyone else. They are all diffrent. They are doing their bests. I mean just we cant say he is the weakest or he knows less. They are all trained for different thinks.And he is also a good actor, To the beautıfıl you was very good, he is very handsome, he can do sports... In my opinion, he is always triying to do his best, he tries hard, he never give up. He dances very good, dont you think like that? I can understand the feeling while he is dancing. And his voice, ı think you shold listen Heartbreak and I am home. You will see that he is not just doing rap, he has more. A lot of people says he isnt good at vocals like the others in group, but ı dont agree. Maybe for the first times(years ago) he wasnt very good but now he is really good. I just dont understand why his vocals are so underrated. He deserves soooo...oooo much better, doesnt he? Anyway thank you for reading! Please listen to heartbreak and ı am home from Mınho. Thats my opinion, you dont have to agree me. Goodbye!
It was a video I made almost two years ago for fun since no one had made a recent one of shinee. I totally agree minho is good, but relatively the weakest singer compared to the rest. I ranked him third in dance also.
Neither Jonghyun nor Taemin are rappers in SHINee and I don't think they had any rap lines in the group songs, but judging from their solos Jonghyun is definitely a better rapper, just check his songs like She Is, Cocktail, Inspiration, RED, he even perfectly covered Zion T and Iron rap parts in Deja Boo and Crazy many times. Back when I was just getting into SHINee honestly I was very surprised to hear him rapping, legend could do everything.
@@sashinirathnayake7352 well I wouldn't really call that rapping, it's just a quicker style of singing or rap-singing at best, but Jonghyun had actual rap verses in his songs, my point stands - he's the best rapper out of the non-rapper line of him, Onew and Taemin. Heck, santa Jonghyun even rivals Key and Minho! ua-cam.com/video/eNeg185RbMo/v-deo.html
Kim Jongwho? No, I only know KING JONGHYUN OMG I LOVE YOUUUU, he will always be the no. 1 in my heart ❤ My love forever ♾️ SHINee my one and only favorite boygroup 💎 They’re the best 🥰
I'm new to SHINee but would say: Jonghyun - awesome voice, you can feel the raw emotion when he sung. Onew - extraordinary voice and super cute. Taemin - extraordinary dancer. Key - Amazing stage presence. He was quite mesmerising to watch in the SHINee World concert 2018. Minho - awesome rapper, dancer and super hot. Put them all together and you get this beautiful harmony, extraordinary to watch show that proves they are a talent that cannot be denied. The fact that they work together without trying to upstage the other just makes the whole group more attractive in every way.
I would argue that while Taemin has become more popular internationally, and has some of the best choreos in kpop, I would say Jonghyun made better music, and wrote better songs
I believe that Jonghyun’s music can’t be compared to Taemin’s as they’re both so different in terms of genre and style. I love both of their music for different reasons and I listen to them when I’m in different moods. And Jonghyun had always been such a gifted lyricist and composer, while Taemin is still learning and improving. The songs he wrote and helped composed are beautiful, and I don’t doubt he’ll improve in the future.
Yes, Jonghyun was not only an Idol, he is a Poet | Artist, he has his own style and he wrote and composed his songs, even some of the best Taemin's songs. Maybe the person that Made this video doesn't know Jonghyun's discography well and it's not well informed about his songs
@@riahlexington you’re totally fine. Honestly you’re preference is whatever you feel, but I just feel JH has a better handle, but no need to apologize💕
Hmmm true. Im trying my best but I still didn’t dive much into JH discography. But I would have been willing to rank his first before NGDA came out. But with both albums Taemin’s is easily number 1
for me sm really did boycott key! he is the lead dancer yet he never had a dance break, he never had a dance practice, people barely know he's a good dancer and gets surprised because he dances so well on amazing saturday like HE IS THE LEAD DANCER FOR A REASON... and sm also boycott shinee as a group, if they did sub units in their early days for example jongyu sub unit, taekey, 2min etc the group would be even more sucessful. also debut with a "noona song" in kpop I mean... 95% of the fans are YOUNG GIRLS is very dumb i'm so sorry. somebody bring a time machine please to change somethings. and i'm sorry if i offended someone but thats the truth.
@@riahlexington i forgot in which performance of everybody, but he sometimes do improves near the end of the song, after key's part This improve mostly happen on concerts tho. But maybe this one can help: ua-cam.com/video/gMtyOudpm9o/v-deo.html
Minho has definitely even better vocals than shown here (like in From now on live...) But because he is in SHINee he would still ranking #5 tho. Jonghyun rap is way better than Taemin, just need to watch his Crazy live perfomance during GDA, also according to an sm professional during pre debute and debute, Jonghyun was also standing out for his dancing skills (Will post the links asap).
I agree about Jonghyun rap, I have replied to several other comments about it and I was uneducated at the time. Dance ranking is really hard because everyone is practically same level except Onew who is last and Taemin who is on another level
Was kind of disappointed that Onew was 2nd on vocals (he made it to the top on cuteness, though^^). Not saying Jonghyun was bad, just that Onew sounds the most natural to me, not only in Shinee, among the most singers in k-pop.
I respect your opinion but watching vocal coaches and the like, everyone agrees how good is Jonghyun. Onew is an amazing singer and he deserves more recognition for it absolutely, but Jonghyun is on a different level. Please understand.
I agree Onew sounds the most natural. His vocal tone remains the same no matter what song he is singing. His voice has tremendous power but can also sound so sweet. Jonghyun on the other hand had the highest and widest vocal range in SHINee. He's a vocal chameleon and an expert in vocal acrobatics. He changes his vocal tone depending on what type of song he is singing. From what I've observed, Taemin is doing the same but in a different way and in a smaller scale (for now. You never know with this kid. The way he keeps on improving). Suffice it to say, I love all their vocals, Key and Minho included. They all absolutely killed it within their own vocal range.
Based on what I've seen vocal coaches say - Onew and Jonghyun are both very good if we're talking technique. The difference is in how they choose to carry their voices. Onew chooses to stick to what's traditionally considered 'proper technique' more often than Jong, hence why he sounds so natural and is always so consistent in tone and delivery. Most idols could dream of being that consistent and with delivery that good. Jong on the other hand has the same capability but chooses to play with his technique and sound more. His ability to play with his vocal delivery so well is what makes him phenomenal. He understands vocal technique and his voice to the point that he can manipulate his voice to get whatever sound he wants. That ability is why he's usually considered 1st overall. I guess the overall point I'm trying to make is they're both very good in the end so you can like whoever you want lol
How they entered SM: Taemin- Dancing since 3rd grade. He joined an SM audition and got in. Onew- In High school, found loved in singing, decided he wanted to become a singer. Joined SM Academy. Key- Since kindergarten he wanted to become a singer. Joined SM audition and got in. Jonghyun- part of many school bands, joined many competition. One of those SM saw him and he was casted. Minho- He wanted to become a football player like his dad. But told he's not good enough, plus he has smaller frame so his dad was against it. Got scouted in a ski resort because of his good looks and height. Unlike the 4, he was never born to sing or dance. Ranking like this is always unfair to him. Minho is trained to sing and dance, and got better overtime. But can't be compared with his peers who are born to it. Our Minho is the best actor. Recently just won an acting award.
@@riahlexington I also think he's the best rapper but this position is rarely noticed. I remember that video from Weekly idol where MC Doni (I think it was him) who told Minho he was SM's hole and he's never ranked. This was after he made a mistake dancing. Maybe he was joking (who knows). Good thing Minho's a tough marine and continue to push on. All members excel on different areas, and when they do solo it reflects. Ranking is normal, i just made a comment also for new to SHINee World who don't know how they got casted. They probably would wonder why Minho lack the singing and dancing skills of others.
Honestly Doni and Coni are so problematic. Minho doesn’t deserve that. He can dance pretty well. Everybody makes mistakes. He’s not a hole, he is talented rapper and he can dance and sing only reason his vocals are last is he is in a group with 4 vocal legends. Put him in BTS or something he would be like lead vocal. Kind of like Lia in Itzy. Her dancing is just fine, but people say she is bad because she is in a group with 4 great dancers. And Minho is such an amazing person with a big heart I can’t imagine SHINee without him, they are all so precious to me.
Why is Minho being underrated because he does not have an album of his own? Must he go solo because other members are doing it, he also have other careers to concentrate on. It hurts me when people think he contributes less to the group and I hate it even more when he's been compared to other members. I mean they are all special in their own individual ways. God created Minho to be handsome and its not his fault that God made him more handsome, but that doesn't mean that he is not talented. And I also love watching him dance . He doesn't even make mistakes like other members do sometimes
I made this video months ago and never expected it to blow up. My intention was never to put Minho down. I love all of them. I ranked Minho #1 in rap. Saying he’s the weakest vocalist in a powerhouse group like SHINee is far from an insult. I’m sorry if it came off as insulting.
@@riahlexington I'm really sorry if I was being too harsh , but its not just about this post, I was a bit upset about how most people think he is not talented enough because he hasn't gone solo yet. But all the same I'm sorry for being harsh under your post okay
No offense but when did I ever say he wasn’t talented enough. He’s the weakest vocalist in the group but considering he isn’t trained in it and the others are really really good he is actually good singer for a rapper I ranked him middle for dance and 1st place in rap so I’m not sure what you’re talking about. Others have told my my Taemin bias is obvious and I’m aware, but again this video was made months ago and I never expected it to blow up , I’m honestly kind of tired of discussing it.
Great video! I would agree with most of your ranking opinions here besides dance. As a dancer and choreographer having over 100 credits in the dance industry that include Madison Square Garden and other places, here is how I would rank the dancers: 5. Minho (my husband, but still he ranks fifth) 4. Onew 3. Jonghyun 2. Key 1. Taemin
Sadly, that will never happen. The only kpop acts to touch the hot 100 have been BTS, BLACKPINK, Wonder Girls, CL, and PSY. Much larger and more popular groups like Twice and EXO haven’t even made it. SHINee reached their commercial peak around 2009-10 with their songs Ring Ding Dong and Lucifer. Those are still their most viewed music videos. Their recent fame isn’t even close. Good Evening has 30 million views next to Ring Ding Dong’s 130 million. They have a dedicated fan base, but it isn’t big enough to propel songs to hit status in the states with streaming now like BTS. Also a lot of the fans who were teenagers at debut have grown up now and have families and lives, and don’t have time to sit and stream. They have been on two years hiatus due to military enlistment for some of the members. They’re having a comeback soon, but again, it won’t come close to the hot 100. They were steadily losing hype in 2015-16 even though their songs were good. The group almost completely fell apart after that because of Onew’s scandal (which wasn’t a big deal, we forgive him) and Jonghyun’s passing in late 2017. They had an album in 2018 and that might have been the most people had noticed them in awhile, unfortunately due to recent events. But that wasn’t even close to the level of success needed. Your best shot for seeing any of them on the hot 100 is probably Taemin with SuperM. His solo work is amazing, please listen to his song Idea and support him. Also vote for him on MAMA if you can (I’ve been really bad about it lately because of depression .) so yeah.
It’s been three years. I think they are okay as I said they’re having a comebcak soon. They’ll never have a hot 100 hit unless they get together when they’re 80 and ring ding Dong charts hahahah.
My ranking/preference Vocals 1.Jonghyun 2.onew 3.key 4.taemin 5.minho Dancing 1.key/taemin 2.taemin/key 😅 3.jonghyun 4.minho 5.onew Sexiness 1.jonghyun(in excuse me miss and prism🤩) 2.key 3.taemin 4.minho 5.onew(but he so so so cute) But all of them of course has its own charm and charisma..and i love them all🥰
I would actually place Jjong over Taemin in terms of rapping. Remember when he effortlessly rapped zion.t's part in deja boo and ir*n's part in crazy live? Or the rap he did with Kibum with their christmas outfits? No shame to Taemin but I have never heard him rap seriously. I am not sure about the dancing placements either but that's debatable.
I think their general singing ability is on a very similar level if not equal, but their voices are just completely different. At this point their ranking is more subjective than objective
Totally agree, Jonghyun should be #2, because even he carried with the group's hardest vocal lines while dancing and he did amazing, with well supported notes and powerful and manly movements
Ok..... I just have to speak up.....ranking these extremely talented and ever so sexy men is like asking a mother which child does she love more....there is not a ugly bone in any of them....I hate the fact that they are even listed like this...no I am sorry....I disagree STRONGLY with this assessment....
This was a video i made over a year ago for fun that inexplicably blew up. I was following a formula in kpop UA-cam where people rank the members of a group based on categories like dance, singing, rap, visuals, etc. SHINee was my favorite group and I didn’t see a recent one with them so I decided to make it. I love all the members and I thought the ranking was pretty balanced. All members shine in different areas and that is NOTMAL. i was never trying to put anyone down.
From this I khow that Taemin is surely your bias and that is just fine. Just that in these ranking, the effect of him being your bias is very noticable. 😂😂😂
@@riahlexington I find it funny and relateable. When we have a bias, I wonder how but everything they do looks extra beautiful. Sometimes when taeyeon just casually talk, I find her cute or I think about how pretty she is. Anyway thankyou for making this video, the clips are very complete and I love it. (I just can't help but laugh remembering how we are both two fangirls, we love all members but our bias is special to our heart so we cannot really rank them. Sorry if my comment hurts your feeling though 🙏🙏)
What’s sad? That I ranked them? Please. Just stop with the tragedy porn. We aren’t allowed to have a fucking video where someone doesn’t comment something sad? Just stop.
Update 12/20
This video is blowing up right now. thank you all so much! I know we all miss Jonghyun so much but he is always in our hearts and he watches over SHINee and Shawols.
Thank you everyone for the comments and the views. I appreciate it a lot. The categories like “sexy” and “cute” are completely subjective in my opinion lol. I tried to be more objective with vocal and the others. I am heavily biased towards Taemin’s although ever member is beautiful and perfect and unique. Taemin’s vocals keep impressing me in his new albums. Everyone stream Idea :)
Also I didn’t make a “bias” category for my ranking because it’s too hard to rank them individually and I don’t like ties. But it would look something like.
1. JongTae
2. Key
3. OnHo
Thanks again everyone. 💖
Also Jjong and Taemin need to be switched in rapping.
@Anders Kye why are y’all commenting this here?
Key #1 All rounder.
I agree
Yess
if key is 4th at sexiness ranking, then why i'm pregnant after watching his "born to shine" stage
Hahaha
Yes they are all too sexy!
See, the problem is Minho has his flaming charisma meanwhile Tae is death staring everyone and Jong is giving people illegal thoughts so any sexiness ranking is almost impossible.
Three year update: We now have waterbomb + rapper Jinki - so..... it's just impossible now
I think Key and Taemin can be interchangeable in the vocal category. They both have different strengths.
technically speaking key and taemin are.not interchangeable
taemin is above avarage vocalist and key weak-to average
taemin has better technique and support
it's just key's voice is more loud than taemin'.
Taemin's voice is breathy that's why his sexy songs hit different 😂 But they are legends in Kpop and the fact each person owns very unique color thanks to which we can separate easily from other groups are just enough
Yes he is amazing 🤩
There's nothing key cannot do trust me
Key is a God.
Yes theres 1
Be imperfect
I definitely agree with many aspects of this ranking. When it comes to vocals, Jonghyun and Onew definitely take the top 2 spots. Taemin and Key are almost equal in terms of technique, it just comes down to their vocal color and stylistic choices which are both based on preferences. Those two would be equally placed in 3rd for me. Minho may not have been added to the group as a vocalist, but you can definitely see how much he’s improved over the past 13 years, he’d easily be a lead vocal in any other group with his current vocal skills.
In terms of dance, I think Taemin in definitely ranked first in terms of technique. He has so much body control and at the same time, he is so fluid with his movements. Key is also an awesome dancer, I think he definitely expresses his movements well and is great at emphasizing during certain movements. Of course, there are subjective opinions as well regarding different dance styles. The rest of the members are also great dancers, again, they’ve improved so much over the years, it’s crazy to think that some of them hadn’t danced at all prior to being in Shinee.
In terms of rap, I really don’t know where I’d place Onew, Taemin, and Jonghyun. Minho and Key are definitely the rappers of the group but since Shinee’s music in general doesn’t focus much on rap, it’s hard to place them on clear, definitive ranks since they don’t seriously rap in many of their songs and it’s hard to have consistent comparisons. I’d honestly just place those 3 in 3rd after Minho and Key.
The 5 of them all rank 1st in terms of visuals... if you think so otherwise you’re wrong. 🤷🏻♀️
All in all, the 5 of them all contribute something special to the group. Each one of them is irreplaceable and without one of them, Shinee ceases to still exist as Shinee. That’s what makes this group so great and special, the fact that everyone excels in something different yet are all exceptional in every aspect.
I prefer Taemin’s vocal color over Key. Also a lot of people have said Jonghyun should rank ahead of Taemin in rap. Also minho’s vocals are really pretty I forget the song but they covered IU song recently and I love his vocal tone.
I agree they are all good dancers and visual is based on preference but they all bring something unique to the table with their visual and are always bias wrecking me 🤣.
The reason I didn’t tie Taemin and Key in vocals is just because I didn’t want a tie.
I agree with everything you wrote. I think the same.
In my case I like Key's vocal color better, that's why I prefer him over Taemin
Tbh, taemin improves a lot. And he actually support his vocal and resonate it. While key, his support is shallow and bcs shinee's songs are high for tenor and key is not tenor, it's a disadvantage for him, makes him strain a lot and tension happened.
Key's last two comebacks have placed him very high in all categories, in my opinion. He has called himself a chicken among swans, but he's totally a swan now. I prefer Taemin's vocal tone, but Key can do whatever he wants to with his voice, and he's very consistent from low to high. Onew's latest comeback (Dice) has proved his versatility. Can't wait for Minho's album and Taemin's return.
솔직히 한 팀 안에 아이돌 중 탑급 보컬 종현과 온유, 입담 개쩔고 패션 센스 개쩌는 키, 조각상 외모 최민호, 한국의 마이클 잭슨 이태민이 있다는 건 사기임...
Shinee soloists and as a group have so much bops, that the playlist will be so long! Thank you for this video🙂❤️ wow 20 minutes, time pass so fast
💖💖
key the most underrated all rounder of all times. this fandom dont deserves him.
jonghyun himself ranked key as no.1 in 'most sexy on stage' and I agree.
You can see Onew rapping in Wishful Thinking live in the DxDxD concert at Tokyo Dome, by the way ^^
Thank you! 💖
For me even minho is soo amazing? Why? Minho being scouted by SM on the street because of his visual. He was supposed to be the face of the group an his position supposed to be rapper and dancer. He didnt born with amazing singing skill like jonghyun or maybe onew. What we heard from minho now is 70% came from his effort and hard work and 30% from his originally skill. From debut until now in 2021 he never stucked he got better and better.
Oh absolutely, I saw their livestream concert and he sounded really good!
Even jonghyun was scouted by his looks,not knowing that he is a vocal god..anyway minho is improved so much and yeah he is amazing,they are all amazing♥️
@@mayla787 noo jonghyun was scouted bcs of his vocal!! he was scouted when he's performing with his band
@@putriangelin6 really,but when he was scouted he was a bassist in a band,but passed the audition because of his vocals.
Their vocal totally unbeatable... I got chill 7 minutes straight!! They are too extra 😍
I just love to see how they covers each other’s weak sides and also how much they’ve put their efforts in to improve themselves. That makes shinee be more shinee.
Every members are talented n have their own charm..n our super talented jonghyun,he can put soul into his music n his voice suitable fr every kind of songs..lets keep supporting this dorks....
I love them yes 💗
Onew Key Jonghyun and Taemin, each of them can be main vocal in any kpop group, even better than some actual main vocal in some of group (since Jjong already be main vocal in SHINee and be king of vocal). Change my mind
I understand why Minho was number 5 for vocals. Someone had to be, right? We all know this is a group of amazing singers, dancers, and rappers. They are the definition of iconic. I’ll be a Shawol forever!
Taemin is just so impressive, man... When they debuted, he wasn't the best at dancing (Kibum was better) and was the worst/second worst at singing. Through his hard work and determination he became one of the all-rounded best idols (if not the best) in the industry, a role model and living legend. And he's only 27!
He wasn’t best at dancing? He only got added to SHINee because of his dance skill. They thought he wasn’t a good singer but he was such a great dancer they added him.
@@riahlexington Yeah, Kibum is 2 years older and it made a difference when they were teenagers. You can find a few videos of his predebut popping on youtube, it's really impressive.
Oh wow
Taemin debuted as the main dancer like....
@@eliana5000 yeah...that’s what I thought too
They are different people and each bring their own shine, talent and uniqueness to the group. Otherwise, they wouldn't be a part of it.
In addition, if they had the same qualities and style, the group would actually be dull and stiff. They blend well together and are also able to carry out solo activities well.
I agree absolutely
My ranking!
Vocals
#1 Jonghyun
#2 Onew
#3 Key
#4 Taemin
#5 MinHo
Dance
#1 Taemin
#2 Jonghyun (she was amazing dancer even when he carried most of the dificult vocal lines he danced awesome, always manly and powerful)
#3 Key
#4 MinHo
#5 Onew
Visual
#1 MinHo
#2 Jonghyun
#3 Taemin
#4 Onew
#5 Key
Rap
#1 Key
#2 MinHo
#3 Jonghyun
#4 Taemin
#5 Onew
All rounder
#1 SHINee haha
About solo albums, it's unfair the ranking because the other members have not had the same oportunities that Taemin had.
Cuteness I agree
Sexy
#1Jonghyun
#2 MinHo
#3 Taemin
#4 Key
#5 Onew ( he is so cute Even when he tries to be sexy)
Why Taemin had the opportunity? Cos he is qualify in all angles.
If I have to rank them in vocals objectively, this would be my list -
1. Jonghyun
2. Onew
3. TaeKey
4. Minho
Vocal ranking based on preference.
1. Taemin (he pulled me into KPop with his vocals).
2. Onew
3. Jonghyun
4. Minkey
Dance Ranking (Objectively)
1. Taemin
2. Key
3. OnJongHo
Dance Ranking (Preference)
1. Taemin
2. Jonghyun
3. OhHoKey
Love all of them! They each bring something special to SHINee.
Same here
I think Minho is a multi-talented person and he sings-raps very good. Even though a lot of people say he is worst in singing, ı dont think like that. Heartbreak and I am home just explains us he is also good at singing. He isnt just the rapper boy! He can have both soft and cold voices. I just think we cannot compare him with Teamin or Onew or Key or anyone else. They are all diffrent. They are doing their bests. I mean just we cant say he is the weakest or he knows less. They are all trained for different thinks.And he is also a good actor, To the beautıfıl you was very good, he is very handsome, he can do sports... In my opinion, he is always triying to do his best, he tries hard, he never give up. He dances very good, dont you think like that? I can understand the feeling while he is dancing.
And his voice, ı think you shold listen Heartbreak and I am home. You will see that he is not just doing rap, he has more. A lot of people says he isnt good at vocals like the others in group, but ı dont agree. Maybe for the first times(years ago) he wasnt very good but now he is really good. I just dont understand why his vocals are so underrated. He deserves soooo...oooo much better, doesnt he?
Anyway thank you for reading! Please listen to heartbreak and ı am home from Mınho. Thats my opinion, you dont have to agree me. Goodbye!
It was a video I made almost two years ago for fun since no one had made a recent one of shinee. I totally agree minho is good, but relatively the weakest singer compared to the rest. I ranked him third in dance also.
i agree they are all great in their own way
I can't judge anyone but I can rank 1 person LORD KIBUM #1 at everything 😌😌😌😌
It’s okay to have a bias haha. Some of the rankings are subjective anyway, but regardless let’s appreciate ALL the members.
Neither Jonghyun nor Taemin are rappers in SHINee and I don't think they had any rap lines in the group songs, but judging from their solos Jonghyun is definitely a better rapper, just check his songs like She Is, Cocktail, Inspiration, RED, he even perfectly covered Zion T and Iron rap parts in Deja Boo and Crazy many times. Back when I was just getting into SHINee honestly I was very surprised to hear him rapping, legend could do everything.
This video is old, and I agree.
Actually both Jonghyun and Onew did rap in DxDxD, one of Shinee’s Japanese songs.SHINee - ua-cam.com/video/OTZMso8njbo/v-deo.html
@@sashinirathnayake7352 well I wouldn't really call that rapping, it's just a quicker style of singing or rap-singing at best, but Jonghyun had actual rap verses in his songs, my point stands - he's the best rapper out of the non-rapper line of him, Onew and Taemin. Heck, santa Jonghyun even rivals Key and Minho! ua-cam.com/video/eNeg185RbMo/v-deo.html
Thank u so much for more details
❤
MinHo is cute toooo😍
It's crazy how they have been improving tremendously over the years. They were already top tier talented when they were teenagers and just debuting ❤
SHINee is and ICON, this group is so talented in general.
Kim Jongwho? No, I only know KING JONGHYUN OMG I LOVE YOUUUU, he will always be the no. 1 in my heart ❤
My love forever ♾️
SHINee my one and only favorite boygroup 💎
They’re the best 🥰
I'm new to SHINee but would say:
Jonghyun - awesome voice, you can feel the raw emotion when he sung.
Onew - extraordinary voice and super cute.
Taemin - extraordinary dancer.
Key - Amazing stage presence. He was quite mesmerising to watch in the SHINee World concert 2018.
Minho - awesome rapper, dancer and super hot.
Put them all together and you get this beautiful harmony, extraordinary to watch show that proves they are a talent that cannot be denied. The fact that they work together without trying to upstage the other just makes the whole group more attractive in every way.
I love this video! Keep up the great work :)
I would argue that while Taemin has become more popular internationally, and has some of the best choreos in kpop, I would say Jonghyun made better music, and wrote better songs
I love both of them.
I believe that Jonghyun’s music can’t be compared to Taemin’s as they’re both so different in terms of genre and style. I love both of their music for different reasons and I listen to them when I’m in different moods. And Jonghyun had always been such a gifted lyricist and composer, while Taemin is still learning and improving. The songs he wrote and helped composed are beautiful, and I don’t doubt he’ll improve in the future.
@@Lena-zn4re I used to be very deep into the fandom and my feelings and I couldn’t really listen to Jjong’s stuff so
Yes, Jonghyun was not only an Idol, he is a Poet | Artist, he has his own style and he wrote and composed his songs, even some of the best Taemin's songs. Maybe the person that Made this video doesn't know Jonghyun's discography well and it's not well informed about his songs
I love Jonghyun , can be a better composer or better vocal but I love to listen to Taemin songs that's what counts in music.
Idk, I think Jonghyun is definitely a better rapper than Taemin
You’re absolutely right and I was uninformed at the time of making this. I’m sorry.
@@riahlexington you’re totally fine. Honestly you’re preference is whatever you feel, but I just feel JH has a better handle, but no need to apologize💕
Love my shining 5hinee forever😍😍😍
Discography makes sense because it's in the order from smallest to largest discography lol
Hmmm true. Im trying my best but I still didn’t dive much into JH discography. But I would have been willing to rank his first before NGDA came out. But with both albums Taemin’s is easily number 1
@@riahlexington personal preference and that's okay. I would rate Jonghyun first but this is your video lol
@@thekeytomyheart_ it’s not an issue of preference. Saying I can’t listen to his discography makes me sound like an idiot. I’m sorry.
@@riahlexington What? I never said you can't listen to his discography. I think there's a misunderstanding here. I'm not angry or upset at you
For me JONGHYUN should be first because he wrote and produced most of the songs of his discography
My boys are just talented perfect 💗
Missing my Jonghyun the king vocalist
all in all i love that i’m a fan of such a talented group.
REASONS TO LOVE SHINEE:
for me sm really did boycott key! he is the lead dancer yet he never had a dance break, he never had a dance practice, people barely know he's a good dancer and gets surprised because he dances so well on amazing saturday like HE IS THE LEAD DANCER FOR A REASON... and sm also boycott shinee as a group, if they did sub units in their early days for example jongyu sub unit, taekey, 2min etc the group would be even more sucessful. also debut with a "noona song" in kpop I mean... 95% of the fans are YOUNG GIRLS is very dumb i'm so sorry. somebody bring a time machine please to change somethings. and i'm sorry if i offended someone but thats the truth.
‘move’ is a bit harder for males because of the way the male body works so props to taemin
I mean he is the one who did it originally yes props to him he is a dancing God.
Sexy ranking i think 1st: Jonghyun watch moon video
Yes haha it’s all up to personal preference that’s very much a subjective category
You could also add a video of Onew's improvisation in Everybody, damnnnn that was my favorite
Where can I watch it?
@@riahlexington i forgot in which performance of everybody, but he sometimes do improves near the end of the song, after key's part
This improve mostly happen on concerts tho. But maybe this one can help:
ua-cam.com/video/gMtyOudpm9o/v-deo.html
Its on 3:46, but supposed to be higher than that
Minho has definitely even better vocals than shown here (like in From now on live...) But because he is in SHINee he would still ranking #5 tho.
Jonghyun rap is way better than Taemin, just need to watch his Crazy live perfomance during GDA, also according to an sm professional during pre debute and debute, Jonghyun was also standing out for his dancing skills (Will post the links asap).
I agree about Jonghyun rap, I have replied to several other comments about it and I was uneducated at the time. Dance ranking is really hard because everyone is practically same level except Onew who is last and Taemin who is on another level
@@riahlexington sorry, I haven't read other comments but I did see you mentioning it at the end of your comment after I left mine... 5HINee Forever 💚💎
I might switch jonghyun and minho in dance ranking
Fair enough, idk how I would change the ranking these days but I’m probably never gonna remake it.
Was kind of disappointed that Onew was 2nd on vocals (he made it to the top on cuteness, though^^). Not saying Jonghyun was bad, just that Onew sounds the most natural to me, not only in Shinee, among the most singers in k-pop.
I respect your opinion but watching vocal coaches and the like, everyone agrees how good is Jonghyun. Onew is an amazing singer and he deserves more recognition for it absolutely, but Jonghyun is on a different level. Please understand.
I agree Onew sounds the most natural. His vocal tone remains the same no matter what song he is singing. His voice has tremendous power but can also sound so sweet. Jonghyun on the other hand had the highest and widest vocal range in SHINee. He's a vocal chameleon and an expert in vocal acrobatics. He changes his vocal tone depending on what type of song he is singing. From what I've observed, Taemin is doing the same but in a different way and in a smaller scale (for now. You never know with this kid. The way he keeps on improving). Suffice it to say, I love all their vocals, Key and Minho included. They all absolutely killed it within their own vocal range.
Based on what I've seen vocal coaches say - Onew and Jonghyun are both very good if we're talking technique. The difference is in how they choose to carry their voices. Onew chooses to stick to what's traditionally considered 'proper technique' more often than Jong, hence why he sounds so natural and is always so consistent in tone and delivery. Most idols could dream of being that consistent and with delivery that good. Jong on the other hand has the same capability but chooses to play with his technique and sound more. His ability to play with his vocal delivery so well is what makes him phenomenal. He understands vocal technique and his voice to the point that he can manipulate his voice to get whatever sound he wants. That ability is why he's usually considered 1st overall.
I guess the overall point I'm trying to make is they're both very good in the end so you can like whoever you want lol
@@YuKaKariyu Exactly! They are both amazing.
I absolutely prefer onew’s voice but jonghyun’s everything is a bit better.
taem has a quality to his dancing that really does remind me of michael jackson. i bet he would love to hear that lol!
every shinee ranking:
Dance:
No. 1 Taemin
No. 4 jonghyun
No. 5 onew
Vocal:
No. 1 jonghyun
No. 2 onew
No. 5 minho
Rap:
No. 1-2 key/minho (changeble)
No. 3-5 others (changeble)
Visual:
No. 1 minho
others changable
Sexy (imho shinee doesn’t have sexy image)
No. 5 onew
I think Jonghyun is ranked higher in sexiness than Taemin. The same with airport fashion, I think he is ranked higher than both Taemin and Minho.
It’s a subjective opinion.
How they entered SM:
Taemin- Dancing since 3rd grade. He joined an SM audition and got in.
Onew- In High school, found loved in singing, decided he wanted to become a singer. Joined SM Academy.
Key- Since kindergarten he wanted to become a singer. Joined SM audition and got in.
Jonghyun- part of many school bands, joined many competition. One of those SM saw him and he was casted.
Minho- He wanted to become a football player like his dad. But told he's not good enough, plus he has smaller frame so his dad was against it. Got scouted in a ski resort because of his good looks and height. Unlike the 4, he was never born to sing or dance. Ranking like this is always unfair to him. Minho is trained to sing and dance, and got better overtime. But can't be compared with his peers who are born to it. Our Minho is the best actor. Recently just won an acting award.
I ranked him first in rap and he is a good dancer and his voice is pretty just not as good as the others, also he is beautiful and kind-hearted.
@@riahlexington I also think he's the best rapper but this position is rarely noticed. I remember that video from Weekly idol where MC Doni (I think it was him) who told Minho he was SM's hole and he's never ranked. This was after he made a mistake dancing. Maybe he was joking (who knows). Good thing Minho's a tough marine and continue to push on.
All members excel on different areas, and when they do solo it reflects. Ranking is normal, i just made a comment also for new to SHINee World who don't know how they got casted. They probably would wonder why Minho lack the singing and dancing skills of others.
Honestly Doni and Coni are so problematic. Minho doesn’t deserve that. He can dance pretty well. Everybody makes mistakes. He’s not a hole, he is talented rapper and he can dance and sing only reason his vocals are last is he is in a group with 4 vocal legends. Put him in BTS or something he would be like lead vocal. Kind of like Lia in Itzy. Her dancing is just fine, but people say she is bad because she is in a group with 4 great dancers. And Minho is such an amazing person with a big heart I can’t imagine SHINee without him, they are all so precious to me.
Key was selected for dance.
Watching this video makes me realise how much i want Taemin to be back of the military already❤ 💎💎💎💎💎
Help a girl out, what’s the nct energy rap song please
Alive
@@riahlexington thx babe
I think you didn't include enough clips about Minho's rap, in alive it is very good
I love Minho. I didn’t think this video would blow up. But thank you.
sorry I think in
Rapp
1.Minho
2.Key
3.Jonghyun
4.Taemin
5.Onew
Airport Fashion
1. Key
2.Jonghyun
3.Taemin
4.Minho
5.Onew
Sexiest
1.Minho
2.Jonghyun
3.Taemin
4.Key
5.Onew
in my opinion 🙏
Why is Minho being underrated because he does not have an album of his own? Must he go solo because other members are doing it, he also have other careers to concentrate on. It hurts me when people think he contributes less to the group and I hate it even more when he's been compared to other members. I mean they are all special in their own individual ways. God created Minho to be handsome and its not his fault that God made him more handsome, but that doesn't mean that he is not talented. And I also love watching him dance . He doesn't even make mistakes like other members do sometimes
I made this video months ago and never expected it to blow up. My intention was never to put Minho down. I love all of them. I ranked Minho #1 in rap. Saying he’s the weakest vocalist in a powerhouse group like SHINee is far from an insult. I’m sorry if it came off as insulting.
@@riahlexington I'm really sorry if I was being too harsh , but its not just about this post, I was a bit upset about how most people think he is not talented enough because he hasn't gone solo yet. But all the same I'm sorry for being harsh under your post okay
No offense but when did I ever say he wasn’t talented enough. He’s the weakest vocalist in the group but considering he isn’t trained in it and the others are really really good he is actually good singer for a rapper I ranked him middle for dance and 1st place in rap so I’m not sure what you’re talking about. Others have told my my Taemin bias is obvious and I’m aware, but again this video was made months ago and I never expected it to blow up , I’m honestly kind of tired of discussing it.
Vocals
1. Onew
2. Jonghyun
3. Key
4. Taemin
5. Minho
Dance
1. Taemin
2. Key
3. Minho
4. Jonghyun
5. Onew
Rap
1. Minho
2. Key
3. Jonghyun
4. Taemin
5. Onew
Stage Presence
1. Jonghyun
2. Taemin
3. Key
4. Minho
5. Onew
Visual
1. Minho
2. Taemin
3. Key
4. Onew
5. Jonghyun
Wrong vocal 3.taemin 4. Key
People are allowed to have a different opinion!
Great video! I would agree with most of your ranking opinions here besides dance. As a dancer and choreographer having over 100 credits in the dance industry that include Madison Square Garden and other places, here is how I would rank the dancers:
5. Minho (my husband, but still he ranks fifth)
4. Onew
3. Jonghyun
2. Key
1. Taemin
I certainly didn’t see it from watching. But of course you would know best. I’ve seen people say Minho is second, lol.
@@riahlexington well everyone is entitled to their own opinion for sure. Just glad folks are loving our boys!
sexy and cute, I think the no1 is Taemin
5:30 whats the song
Stranger
I would like to see one of there songs make the hot 100. They're good!
Sadly, that will never happen. The only kpop acts to touch the hot 100 have been BTS, BLACKPINK, Wonder Girls, CL, and PSY. Much larger and more popular groups like Twice and EXO haven’t even made it. SHINee reached their commercial peak around 2009-10 with their songs Ring Ding Dong and Lucifer. Those are still their most viewed music videos. Their recent fame isn’t even close. Good Evening has 30 million views next to Ring Ding Dong’s 130 million. They have a dedicated fan base, but it isn’t big enough to propel songs to hit status in the states with streaming now like BTS. Also a lot of the fans who were teenagers at debut have grown up now and have families and lives, and don’t have time to sit and stream. They have been on two years hiatus due to military enlistment for some of the members. They’re having a comeback soon, but again, it won’t come close to the hot 100. They were steadily losing hype in 2015-16 even though their songs were good. The group almost completely fell apart after that because of Onew’s scandal (which wasn’t a big deal, we forgive him) and Jonghyun’s passing in late 2017. They had an album in 2018 and that might have been the most people had noticed them in awhile, unfortunately due to recent events. But that wasn’t even close to the level of success needed. Your best shot for seeing any of them on the hot 100 is probably Taemin with SuperM. His solo work is amazing, please listen to his song Idea and support him. Also vote for him on MAMA if you can (I’ve been really bad about it lately because of depression .) so yeah.
Oh sorry to hear about that. I hope things get better.
For me or SHINee? Haha.
Both
It’s been three years. I think they are okay as I said they’re having a comebcak soon. They’ll never have a hot 100 hit unless they get together when they’re 80 and ring ding Dong charts hahahah.
omg onew such a cute papa
4:22 whats the song name?
Shadow by Taemin
@@riahlexington thank u ❤️
My ranking/preference
Vocals
1.Jonghyun
2.onew
3.key
4.taemin
5.minho
Dancing
1.key/taemin
2.taemin/key 😅
3.jonghyun
4.minho
5.onew
Sexiness
1.jonghyun(in excuse me miss and prism🤩)
2.key
3.taemin
4.minho
5.onew(but he so so so cute)
But all of them of course has its own charm and charisma..and i love them all🥰
I have said what I think about Minho, but let me also add that if we round everything up, Key should be number 1. This is coming from a Minho bias
I don’t remember doing an all around ranking, but I do think Key is the best all-rounder.
샤이니🩵
I would actually place Jjong over Taemin in terms of rapping. Remember when he effortlessly rapped zion.t's part in deja boo and ir*n's part in crazy live? Or the rap he did with Kibum with their christmas outfits? No shame to Taemin but I have never heard him rap seriously. I am not sure about the dancing placements either but that's debatable.
Fair enough I really wasn’t sure what to do with the raps. I couldn’t find any good clips of Jjong rapping , sorry.
Yes, I also think that Jonghyun's rap is better 😊 also JONGHYUN should be higher in dance.
@@serendipity3135 I get it ur a solo stan ok
I agreed about the rap I wasn’t well informed.
@@riahlexington no, I'm shawol. I love all the boys. I admire them all.
SM may know what they have....but they don’t get paid enough....none of them especially Taemin
I don't think minho is weak at vocals. Just watch IU palette
No he isn’t.
KJH ❤️
SOMEONE TELL WHAT SONG WAS KEY RAP PART!?
Which rap part? Time stamp?
@@riahlexington it's on 9:54😊
“Alive”
I honestly like key's vocals over Taemin's 😬
I think their general singing ability is on a very similar level if not equal, but their voices are just completely different. At this point their ranking is more subjective than objective
Thank you for saying it. Of course I love them both.
I love both. Yeah they are close. I saw someone who knew about vocal say so too.
@@riahlexington I like Taemins voice more but Keys singing sounds more natural to me 😅
@@sweetmask5276 your comment was subjective anyway. You said you like it more not he is better.
there really is no group like shinee
Los reyes del kpop
Taemin el rey solista del kpop
9:55 what song
Alive
song at 8:12 ???
Symptoms
I LOVE SHADOW TOO!!
Great song
7:40 song?
Also stranger 😊
@@riahlexington thank you 🥺
😘💎😇🤗
but minho fab in dancing💯
For me jonghyun's dance ranked 2nd...😉
I watched them all dance. I stand by my ranking
@@riahlexington yh..... its up to u dr...but i already agree to ur choice... 😇
Totally agree, Jonghyun should be #2, because even he carried with the group's hardest vocal lines while dancing and he did amazing, with well supported notes and powerful and manly movements
@@serendipity3135 if I put him there a whole bunch of people would get mad lol also I love him but again no
@@riahlexington why people would get mad?
Ok..... I just have to speak up.....ranking these extremely talented and ever so sexy men is like asking a mother which child does she love more....there is not a ugly bone in any of them....I hate the fact that they are even listed like this...no I am sorry....I disagree STRONGLY with this assessment....
This was a video i made over a year ago for fun that inexplicably blew up. I was following a formula in kpop UA-cam where people rank the members of a group based on categories like dance, singing, rap, visuals, etc. SHINee was my favorite group and I didn’t see a recent one with them so I decided to make it. I love all the members and I thought the ranking was pretty balanced. All members shine in different areas and that is NOTMAL. i was never trying to put anyone down.
From this I khow that Taemin is surely your bias and that is just fine. Just that in these ranking, the effect of him being your bias is very noticable. 😂😂😂
Okay?
@@riahlexington I find it funny and relateable. When we have a bias, I wonder how but everything they do looks extra beautiful. Sometimes when taeyeon just casually talk, I find her cute or I think about how pretty she is. Anyway thankyou for making this video, the clips are very complete and I love it. (I just can't help but laugh remembering how we are both two fangirls, we love all members but our bias is special to our heart so we cannot really rank them. Sorry if my comment hurts your feeling though 🙏🙏)
It’s okay.
everyone in shine is no1
Sad...
What’s sad? That I ranked them? Please. Just stop with the tragedy porn. We aren’t allowed to have a fucking video where someone doesn’t comment something sad? Just stop.
Key>taemin vocals
I think they’re about equal but I was a big Taemin bias lol