I make a lot of theories, and sometimes, I never finish them, either because of lack of evidence, because of length or because of other reasons. Regardless, here's five of them.
I always saw Alex & Lisa as the gays in the group, I never thought they were together, but yeah. And then Alex’s new model came out & she’s literally textbook lesbian, like beanie & a flannel???
@@eleanornightwalker Yeah. I remember doing that quest when I was like, lvl 16 and now I am lvl 20 but I was on my starter and he be like "YUMMY CARAMELKISS!!! MABYE AN APPLE IN THE MOUTH AND ON A SILVER PLATTER?!" That freaked me out and I emedeantly logged off. xD
@@hlshdl6653 come to think of it, a teacher of mine said once that horse meat is a delicacy, and I remember being like THIS IS NEW TO ME But still, you don't look at a living horse and say "yummy, this one would make a nice meal!". You don't do that with ANY animals 🙈🙈🙈
@@eleanornightwalker But many people sadly do that with pigs and cows. MANY people joke about beating cows and pigs to death, and imagine eating them even while still suffering. It's a sad reality.
Theory: Mrs Holdsworth is an important character to the storyline. I think she's some kind of druid under cover. Proof: 1. She helped us quite a lot troughout the story 2. She knows how to make some kind of posions, like when James was having nightmares. 2. Somewhere in a main quests, around the end of the current main quests, there was a discussion about whitches. If I'm not mistaken, our character said that there is no such a thing as whitches and then Meteor says "should we tell her about Mrs Holdsworth?" So maybe she's a whitch, who is part of the Keepers of Aideen
During the winter wishes' quests last year there was a quest with Mrs. Holdsworth trying to think of a gift for Pi, and it was stated that she is a fellow witch. So yeah, Pi and Mrs. Holdsworth are like the opposites on the spectrum in the beginning - one being an evil green witch living in a swamp and the other being a cute granny bee-loving witch. Nic Stoneground once said that witches usually go through phases throughout their lives, exploring both pure and dark magic. I guess Mrs. Holdsworth went through this already and settled for a peaceful retirement in Moorland, while Pi is more like a baby-witch, still exploring what the world of magic has to offer.
What if Buck is really Garnok but Garnok can't leave the body he's taking on until the dark riders complete the ritual and stuff, but instead of being stuck under the sea what if it was a metaphor for him being stuck somewhere he didn't want to be for example a teenage boys body. lol
I've thought that he might be mind controlled, but that doesn't explain why he's portrayed in the book. He would probably also have that blue thing above his head like James when he's being mind controlled Another thought I considered was whether or not he could be a creation of Garnok/Dark Core. Like he was never human... but then that doesn't make sense because he has no abilities and acts just like a bully Seriously, this one is bugging me so much 🙈
@@eleanornightwalker He never takes his glove off and he's always looking at his hand and hitting it like it's not part of him...Maybe something's up with his hand?
i know this might sound stupid but what if buck and darko are brothers? this would explain why both of them are able to controll garnok and why they look similar..🤔
i've been thinking about how rania lost her eyesight ever since the mistfall series came out, and i taught it had something to do with the incident with blaze
In the series that might be the case, but Skye is not in the game so idk 🤔 I'm just overall very confused about how the Mistfall series translates to the game 🙈
@@eleanornightwalker I'm pretty sure that sometime in the future the Mistfall characters, especially Skye, will return I don't think SSO would create such a complex character just to never use I think that if they will put her in game, which I'm pretty sure they will, that putting her backstory into a series is actually quite a good way to show the character stuff kinda behind the scenes
Regarding the Glue Man riddle: Glue used to be made out of dead horses. So the Glue Man probably wants to make our horses into glue - that's what he'd do. I can't know IF Igor is a metaphorical Glue Man, but at least that explains the riddle itself.
its funny cuz your buttergood vampire theory was confirmed in recent quests XD in the newest wildwoods questline they call him "blood sucker" and make other vampire puns
Me too! And i'm glad cause bisexuality erasure is sadly strong these days :'( you're either gay, straight or confused, which is very offensive to me cause i'm bi myself :(
I love the first and last theory. Honestly wish you were the one who called the shots in Starstable because you'd make the best story quests and game quests in general. It pains me where sso is headed and i just wish they did better than now. The starshine legacy games were THOUSAND times better than Starstable in that sense. I also have to say i think you seem like such an incredible and unique person. Never stop being you. Like i could just listen to your videos even if they weren't about sso. You are such an interesting and mature person to listen to which is awesome! Thank you for today's video ☺️
The theory of aideen being pandorian has been in my thoughts for a while. We are the 5th soulrider and the reincarnation of aideen herself? Or atleast reincarnation of catherine. I dont remember if catherine was aideen's reincarnation but if she was then this next thing im gonna say would make more sense. So we have the ability to go to pandoria whenever we want to and we have not had any weird side effects whatsoever (or i have missed those if there were any) also i have seriously forgotten if we are aideen herself as the 5th soulrider but if we were and she was originally a pandorian, then so are we! Visiting pandoria frequently has not affected us and it makes it weird that we can have the access to pandoria even when there is nothing to do. Why would sso put the portals up and going if there was such a risk as to get lost, sick and die from the curse of pandoria? Aideen being a pandorian sure has no problem there since the curse of pandoria does not affect her nor us since we are aideen. Epic.
During one of the Fort Pinta Beach Festivals we could talk to Buck. I don't remember his exact words but he said he was actually hunting for James Cloudmill. He heard that James was doing business in some fort near the sea so Buck went there but couldn't get in. He apparently mistook Fort Maria for Fort Pinta.
(I haven’t finished the story quests yet so this may be wrong) but if Buck had tentacle legs, it means he can change form to have human legs. What if something happened to his hand, like it’s stuck in a tentacle form, which is why he always wears a glove, and the dark riders said they could fix it if he works with them? Idk, like I said, I haven’t even met buck in game, he might’ve taken off the glove before 🤧
I've been theorizing for MONTHS that aideen is actually pandorian. In addition to what you said, the fact that the magic the Druids use is the same/similar shade of pink as most of pandoria and Ydris' magic was always a bit suspicious in my opinion. If magic in the game was generally pink, shouldn't Pi's/Galloper Thompson's cauldron and the magic the Singing Yew used while performing the Whispering Cry be pink, too, instead of green? I know sometimes the symbols that appear while the Soul Riders use their magic are blue, but since there are, at least in the SSO version, blue tunnels in Pandoria that could still fit. I mean, color usually is pretty important when it comes to magic, and the ones the Druids use has generally always been pink. Also, the only green portals in game are the ones connecting the portal in Dino Valley with the one in Epona, so what if "natural" magic is the one the witches and galloper (who is immortal because of witches) use while the druids use pandorian magic? Idk probably just me putting too much thought into colors
I've been thinking about the last one, with Buck. We know from the books that Dark Riders aren't human. I think that they aren't anything, they were just created by Garnok to portray some level of normalness. The Dark Riders may not exist at all. And if they don't exist, or are just some imitation of a real person, Buck could be the same way. At this point in the game, we know that Katja, Jessica, and Sabine are bad news, but we know nothing about Buck. Maybe he's a spy, someone the Soul Riders wouldn't think twice about looking for, and reports back to the Dark Riders, which could be why he hangs around Katja in Starshine Legacy.
My favourite theory that isn’t really to do with quests but more with the horses sso are releasing is we’ve entered gen4. The BREED_CROSSBREED_breed glitch on starters could mean they are being updated soon, and there’s more reasoning. The jf, Gotland pony and finnhorses can wear a special bridle, and we know older generations cannot wear newer tack. Therefore, it would be logical to call them gen4. I know sso calls them gen3, but I feel like the theory with the special bridles is probably real and we’re getting updated starters soon. Eventually sso will probably drop the gen3 tag and go with gen4, or perhaps gen3.5. That’s my reasoning, again it isn’t much evidence but I like the theory.
No, they never say they're siblings 🤔 are you thinking of when he says "oooh, here comes big sister!"? Cause he's referring to Alex sticking up foe James, not Katja
There's a video on SSO's UA-cam channel, where GM Ylva, Matilda and Stacy (I'm not sure about her) were talking about spooky stories, involving the Glue Man one. If I remember correctly, it was stated that Glue Man turned your horses hooves into glue and than turn the rest of them..? I'm not really sure on the second part of it, so I recommend watching the video! I must say, that the idea, that Aideen is from Pandoria is really, really creative and fun to think about! I like to write fanfictions based on Jorvik universe, and this theory really help me to create new ideas, so, thank you :D
Rania is one of my favourite characters in the game and I've often wondered about who her father is, but never linked it with who her father is. This was really interesting. Also, I wondered if Blaze could be a Starbreed. She is a Jorvik Wild, but she doesn't fit in with the Warriors, Foresters or Mystics and clearly has magical powers. Like Nightdust and Starshine, she also has unusual colouring. One more thing I was thinking about is that in the recent Gary Goldtooth quest, Willow had a vision which told us that Cedar was in danger. This made me think could the Mystics be associated with the Moon Circle? Although it seems like the Mistfall series doesn't really seem to link up with the main story, I think it will be able too, with the help of the newer part of Wildwoods. Maybe there is some sort of magic that even the Keepere of Aideen don't know about. Edit: 3 weeks later I looked back at this comment and realised I said "I've often wondered about who her father is, but never linked it with who her father is" which makes no sense. I meant to say "I've often wondered about who her father is, but never linked it with how she lost her eyesight".
Maybe each herd ties in to a circle, and maybe one herd is missing, causing the imbalence? The foresters would probably be the sun circle, taking care of the living things and plants in the forest. The Mystics probably would be the moon circle with their prophetic visions. The warriors are probably the lightning circle, strong defenders. That leaves the missing herd to be the Star circle perhaps? Like how Lisa was the last soulrider to show up in Jorvik, maybe the imbalance has to do with finding the missing herd.
@@sparxmaiden841 That's kind of what I was thinking, but further developed. I could kind of see the relationship between the Warriors and the Lightning Circle, and there are even a few similarities between Ash and Alex's personalities as I think deep down, Ash also wants to protect her younger sibling, but I never considered there could be a herd missing. That's a really interesting idea.
@@sparxmaiden841 I think honestly foresters fit more with the star circle, natural healers and helpers. The “heart” of the forest if you will. That leaves us with out the sun circle, the leader, the one who keeps the other circles in line. Could that be embermane? Perhaps there only being one or very few could be the reason of the imbalance. Maybe Gary Goldtooth will have something to do with this later on? There was the whole embermane we saw when we first went on the ride in the mist fall area. (Later on to be replaced with a forester model)
I feel as if my constant talk of Pandoria is rubbing off on you...finally, the Pandorians can take over the earth-I mean, it's nothing, you don't need to worry about it. But yeah, number 2 definitely makes me wonder a lot. Mostly about if Pandoria is actually a planet, since it seems you can get there in a spaceship, like Fripp did. It would make sense, but there's not a lot of things backing it due to Aideen still being a mystery.
You may or may not have rubbed off on me, yeah 😂😂😂 but I mean, all the soul riders got their powers from her, and the battle is always about Pandoria. Surely there's a reason why she gave us these powers? 🤔 Omg what if she used to be the queen of Pandoria or something, and that's why she was so powerful and graceful and seen as a goddess. And maybe that's why Pandoria is all pink - because Garnok invaded and altered it. Maybe it wasn't always like that 👀 (Okay yes, you DEFINITELY are rubbing off on me)
I could see Aideen being some sort of queen of Pandoria. After all, someone's got to rule the other Pandorians. Unless Garnok wiped most of them out...now I have an idea. If some Pandorians went to Earth before Garnok turned everything pink, they wouldn't of been wiped out. But if most stayed in their homeland, I can see how Garnok would wipe them out. Maybe in some sort of vain attempt to take it over for himself? Either way, it would make sense why we know so few Pandorians. And if there are more, maybe they just want to blend in with the humans so Garnok doesn't find them.
Pandoria mostly has purple-pink theme here. Though the issue I have with this theory that we are Aideen's reincarnation. When we turn into a horse, we pick up a gold theme and not pink cracks or purple ones. There is no hint on how did Aideen actually looked like beside the statue in Aideen's Plaza. Or at least haave no clue what she actually looks like with colors, you know. I would imagine that perhaps Aideen is just an alter ego of a powerful pandorian creature. (Also purple and yellow/gold are complimenter colors, so that is also possible)
I've heard some other people saying that too, but I think that's a misconception. I can't find anywhere in the game or elsewhere where it says that they are, and they don't look alike... it may come from when he says "oooh, here comes big sister!", and then Katja shows up behind them. He's referring to Alex in this moment 🤔
Eleanor Nightwalker tru tru. here’s an idea tho, maybe he has some sort of shape shifting ability? if he really is that tentacle thing and he really is a magical being, maybe he uses a more human form so he’s not as..well, sus? idk just an idea that came to my mind
In one of a Star Stable magazines (2017) was comic it was shown that Ranja lost her eyesight from when she run to forest to find some berries. She was just picking up berries, and then an animal (or other thing i don't clearly remember) has scared her, she begin panic, tripped and lost her eyesight.
Buck could be one of garnoks underlings but just not apart of DC? I remember I saw somewhere that while Garnok was being taken somewhere by Fripp, his generals were there too. Since we see Garnok as having tentacles maybe his generals had them too which explains why Buck had tentacles? Also I remember how you said Rhiannon was somehow connected to that new woman (forgot her name but she was mentioned in the new wild woods quests) and some kind of magic happened that messsed with Rania
Amazing video once again! I have some thoughts on this so here they are: 1#: Lisa screams gay with how she looks like. She definitely had a crush on Alex but it's just from the way they are almost always together. 2#: Aideen is definitely Pandorian for her being supernatural. She gives off that vibe but still feels like she isn't. Pandoria is full of dark magic so it doesn't make sense for her to be Pandorian yet have beautiful powers of life. 3#: I do think that Rania got her blindness from magic like you said. About her father, I have figured out that her mother is married/ dating the vet girl who helped us in quests (I forget the name). It's clear in the character book and hints the affection between the 3 of them. 4#: Igor is definitely the glue man for his weird "love" for horses. I don't have to say much as it explains for itself. 5#: Buck gives me "related to Darko" vibes because of his hair looking close to Darko's hair. He gives the Darko look off to me. Kind of want to throw him off that cliff now- So that was my thoughts on this. What do you think?
Glad you liked the video! I know that Sigry and Dr. Eiren are married, but I'm sure Rania used to have a father too.. she doesn't refer to Dr. Eiren as her mother, and there are similarities between her and Sigry, so I highly doubt she's adopted 🤔 I've also thought about Darko and Buck being related, but there's nothing that suggests it so idk 🤔 if you put them side by side they don't look that similar anymore either 😕
I think that Buck having tentacle legs could mean that he is associated with Garnok- if not maybe even BEING garnok? (i know that sounds crazy, but it would explain why he was associated with the dark riders?)
About the "Lisa is gay" theory. You said that Helena Dahlgren was only referring to the "new" Lisa. However in the books Lisa is described as being a red-head with green eyes (just like the old lisa used to be). So yeah ig this is more proof that Lisa has been gay since the starshine legacy games.
Actually talking about Igor he has always scared me when ever i have seen him in quest lines. Cause the look gives a creepy vibe and how he acts and talks. Also could you maybe make more videos about Igor cause i want to know more about him
2:07 this is brining me to a whole other theory of the ufo and doors. What if when she came to earth she fled and Darkcore came in the ufo to search for her. They might of made the underground doors to get to places faster and to keep her if they did find her. She could be the main power source of them if they do have her. Maybe in a later quest we go and save her from Darkcore
Hey , I know this has nothing to do about this video and you might already know this but it could be IMPORTANT so I was reading about Darko and it said this: FOR A MAN WHO HATES HORSES SO MUCH HE IS AWFULLY OBSESSED WITH THEM and it seemed like he is trying to get dark riders thery own horses ? I thought dark riders hated horses , do you think this could mean something, Eleanor ?
I think I heard that rania actually lost her eyesight when she was a kid picking berries in the forest. And about rania's father, I think I remember there was a piece of dialogue where rania states that she guessed people like the mayor guy and her dad kept telling her mom that she's too ambitious. I'm pretty sure this is literally the only time someone mentions rania's father, but from what I can deduce from that single piece of dialogue, rania's dad acts like the mayor. Which is pretty sad. What jerks.
Theory: The Dark Riders are animals. Okay, hear me out here. I've been reading the SSO books (I haven't read the third one yet though it's coming in the mail) and I must say, there is sooooo much lore in them. Now, to my theory, there is so much proof to back me up. Sabine is a tiger or a lion. For one, her personality shows this a lot, as she can be tame and calm until tampered with, then she goes full rage mode. Two, at one point in the first book, it says (spoilers for the SSO books) 'She finished her convocation with the pale driver, and seemingly slinked towards the bushes where Lisa, Alex, Linda and Anne were hiding. She walked around the bush edge, sniffing the air like the tiger Lisa had seen in a zoo when her mum had taken her when she was little. She eventually walked away, grunting like some sort of animal.' UHH HELLO!?! If THAT doesnt scream tiger or lion I don't know what does! Katja is a arctic fox. This one was a bit harder and took a lot more research, but it's kinda obvious now. I was stuck between the idea of her being a snow wolf or arctic fox, but fox seems more likely. At one point in the second book, it reads: 'I knew I would find you here, coming to rescue your poor precious pony. What a shame, you can't do anything to help him!" A voice echoed across the room. She looked up. A bright white girl sat above her in a loft. They met each other's eyes. Lisa couldn't look away, stuck staring into Katja's lifeless white eyes. She eventually looked away, then disappeared into the darkness.' Okay, sure, maybe not that alone, but after researching, I found this: 'One way to describe a fox's attack towards animals like chickens is they will stare into they're eyes, causing them to freeze in fear. The fox will then pounce, killing the animal.' Like that sounds like a fox when you put them side by side. Jessica is a spider. This you kinda went over in one of your videos, but not in detail. I think you have read the bit where Jessica crawled into the car with Mr. Sands like a spider, so I won't really explain that since I think you know. We don't know about the fourth general, but I'm hoping the third book will answer some of questions about that. Feel free to make this into a video, and yes, basically all I do in my free time is draw, write and theorize. I've basically figured out the whole story line for Minecraft haha. Thank you for reading if you had made this far, and remember to drink some water, eat healthy food, and get the rest you need for tomorrow's great day. You're all amazing
*I wonder who the very first soulriders were, in a quest, it said that Linda, Alex, Lisa, and Anne, weren't the first soul riders. I was very confused when it said that.*
I wanted to point out how the cover of Glueman's song is blackish/grayish and how the weird man's(forgot his name) outfit is those same blackish/grayish color. And for Eideen's theory... I think you can make a wgole video on this if you search for every single time Eideen was mentioned. I am sure if it's sso world h1ve gave us more hints.
I know this is late but whatever. I found it weird that Buck was portrayed with tentacles because the only other character that I know of that has been associated with tentacles was Garnock. Since Buck hangs out with the Dark Riders, what if he only bullies James because he knows that his sister (Alex) is a soul rider whose life mission is to stop Dark Core's plans. He can use James to get information or to spy on the soul riders. THINK ABOUT THAT!
The Buck thing has been driving me crazy as well. I'm POSITIVE there was some canon content of him standing in front of the Fort Maria with tentacles coming out of the ocean behind him (the ones we saw when Darko used Garnok to attack us) but I can't find it anywhere for the life of me. I'm 100% sure either HE'S Garnok himself or at least he's very closely tied to it.
Abot Aideen being pandorian: YES! i always thought about it, it makes sense in my head. Why would her powers and the seals from each one of them be in Pandoria if she wasn't one of them? In my headcanon I always thought she was kinda like an ideal rather than a goddess to pandorias, a girl that from nothing came to be really powerful, showing the strongest bond between rider and horse. Also, how else would you explain Fripp's existance? he too is pandorian, just as old as Aideen herself, when Garnok ended on earth they had to search for someone to be able to destroy it and save the planet, they neede to find somene willling to do it, that would porbably be a pandorian
I think buck might be garnock, or somehow related to him. If he was portrayed in a history book with tenticles, and put up against a soul rider, he defiently can't be a normal bully like we're lead to believe. No evidence for this though, just my thoughts
To me Buck is like a "host" body. Maybe they need someone with enough bad feelings/energy to use it for carrying Garnok's soul and reach us in an easier way ? It would be like a possession. And Buck is probably unaware of this, he could simply be happy that some of the dark riders want to hang out with him as Katja is quite pretty and can easily manipulate people. His interaction with Rin shown us that he's ready to change his mind for a pretty girl. He would be a good choice as he's close to James ( not in a good way I have to admit ) , one of the soul riders' siblings. It'd be a perfect way to spy on them and hit a the right moment.
Watching these makes me think SSO is a much deeper game than I think... And I'm so addicted to your channel! I can't wait to see all of these theories finished! I'm so exited! ❤️
So... You know how Garnok has tentacles? Maybe he doesn't live in Devil's Gap... At this moment. It seems like a leap but... MAYBE BUCK IS GARNOK! I don't know much about that history book but I just thought "GARNOK" once I saw it.
Wow. Okay. Lots of theories! So. . .first of all. . .I think the Igor theory is perfect. Even before I had heard of Igor, any time the song Glue Man mentioned. . .Well. . .The glue man, I've always pictured someone like him. About the Buck theory. . .Wow! I think that is possible. And as one of the comments down there said, I think Buck may very well be Garnok. I mean, his arms and legs are unrealistically oversized, especially for a bully in school. I think that may be because he is just wearing a disguise to cover his tentacles.
Hey, About your Buck theory, I have something to add: 1. At fashion week 2018, you could speak to a lot of different Npc's, including Buck. He says a lot of things, but this dialogue in particular caught my attention: „Devil's Gap? Yeah, the rumours are true. Place is totally haunted. Something about which is from, like, a thousand years ago. I hoped the fence once and shot some sick video. Weird lights, freaky people in hoods, talking horses... it was total cult stuff. I posted it all to jortube but someone took 'em down. It's a conspiracy, I'm telling you!" I find it odd that Buck seems to have no memory of what happened in Devil's Gap, maybe an easter egg from the developers, since it seems that what happened in Starshine Legacy is no longer canon. Or maybe was Buck controled/hypnotized by Katja and now doesn't remember anything. 2. Again, at the 2018 fashion week, he says this: „James thinks he's so smart, holing up in Fort Maria. You heard me - FORT MARIA. I know that's where he's hiding, and I'm gonna stay camped outside the gates until he shows his pimple face. We'll see who gets the last laugh!" That explains why he is in front of Fort Maria. 3. Some people in the comments suggested that he might be related to Darko somehow. Here's what Buck had to say about him (Again, at the fashion week 2018): „"Darko"? Is that dude for real? He's trying way too hard. Sweet cane, though. (Here is a link to a video where you can read most of the Npc's dialogue, and they all have something interesting to say: ua-cam.com/video/rAGYJCcuisI/v-deo.html )
Actually, I think this is a detail that not a lot of people saw, but today I logged on sso and I was standing next to Fort Maria's entrance when I saw Buck, ironically I wanted to take a screenshot with him but then I noticed that his animation is not the same one in this video!! I know the video is already old but the fact that they changed his iddle animation, might mean they're working on him, I don't think a developer would take their time just casually checking Buck's files and changing his iddle animation, this is just a theory but I think in the upcoming main story quests we will get to see him with the dark riders and the arrival of the new dark rider. (This was just a fun detail but it might mean something :) )
WAIT , NO WAY. I LEFT THE AREA AND I CAME BACK, HE NO LONGER HAS THE DIFFERENT ANIMATION. . . It might have been just a mistake but it's curious, I took a couple of screenshots of his mysterious other iddle animation tho, it's a little bit of my proof (I was so happy that it was a possibility to see him in new quests but my hopes are almost gone)
Hey I Hope you read this but my theory with buck is that he may be the son of garnok and we will fight him before garnok that could be why he hangs around the dark riders and why he is portraits with tentacles in that history book, because garnok also has these tentacles
Technically Skye from the mist fall series is in the game, even if we have never met her. Don’t you remember that at the New Years party for 2021 Rania and the rangers mentioned Skye and that she was new to Mistfall and kind of a fish out of water we still have not met her but we know that she actually exists.
Yeah I recently finished playing the starshine legacy series. I’m sure that buck is a warrior for garnok, sent to act as katja’s ‘champion’ as depicted in the last episode. He does not seem to possess any magical properties though, so he’s probably just some muscled body guard for katja.
I have a theory about Rania's father. As we all know and as it was being said, we do not know him. However in the Mistfall's series we can observe in one of the last episodes that she can see magic-linked things (she saw her friend and her horse, both using magic). Maybe her dad is a druid and that druids are special people, meaning that they cannot "become" but are born with special abilities such as controlling magic and seeing it. And again, maybe some types of druids are forbidden to have children like priests. And if her father is a druid, there's obviously a moment where her abilities awaken and maybe the awakening happened in her early ages and that process shouldn't be interfered with, however maybe her mom did interfer as she was clueless about all of this druid thing which led to her blindness. This theory may explain her abilities in the series, her blindness as well and the unknown identity of her father. :)
There is also a legend from Starshine Legacy that can prove your theory about Aideen roots. When we enter Pandoria Throught "path of winds" we can find horse statues, pretty similar to this located in Epona. Moreover There are Stone tablets with pictures on it and they tell story of Pandoria's origins. If we Pay attentoion to all elements on Stone tablets, we can see human-like character in few pictures. In my opinion this might be Aideen But I am not 100% sure...
i have a small thing to add to the rania theory. sso actually released a comic about her in one of their magazines and it sort-of-kinda touches on the topic of her blindness and confirms that her father left them. i translated the comic to english a while ago, so i can send the link to anyone who’s interested. (youtube keeps deleting my comment with the link so that’s a bummer)
If the legend says Aideen came from a falling star (outer space) then isn’t it possible the secret spaceship location is how she got here and where she landed?
About the glue man one I think it it is true because in one star stables weekly videos they posted something about the glue man, but i cant remember which video. :/ I love your video by the way ( the video was about 3 girls talking about haunted stuff and specially the glue man )
I think Buck is a remnant of the old backstory to ssl and sso, now that they've changed the main storyline he is not relevant anymore which is why he has had little to none part of quests or stoey line and probably wont have any in the future either.
Omg guys.... So you showed the picture about the History book. I can see the 4 soulrider, and GARNOK. With a hockey stuff and EXACTLY look like that bully boy except the legs. Garnok's legs. Doing the quest with Missisippi Jones in Epona he said it was a library. But why someone guard in front of a library?! That place is just a mistery. But he can be Garnok.
the buck one i think that hes like some sort of recreation of garnok and only darkcore knows just like how were the recreation of aieeden but he does not know but he knows magic is real and that's why he was with katja when james was stolen. not sure buttt yeah
At Rania, in jorvikpedia it said that she lost her eyesight collecting berries and she wasn t careful. Still,she saw Skye with Blaze At Buck: he might be katja`s brother,because in ssl at ep 4 is about and James,Alex`s BROTHER.So,yeah
YES, WHY IS BUCK STANDING THERE??? I'm sorry for that. But finally somebody said it. :-D It is in my head for months. I believe Buck have powers like dark riders. And I think he is alien too. And even he looks young, I think he is not. And I have very crazy theory, but unfinished too. It starts with Avalon. I found about him on Jorvikipedia that he worked at Fort Maria's library as a librarian, until an unknown incident. This info is from some holidays in game. I saw pictures with it on some web too. WARNING!!! There is ending info from game. And I didn't read books or comics so I don't know if we have more info about this. Now is just my crazy theory a no facts. :-D I think maybe Buck and Katja have to do something with that incident. I think maybe they wanted steal something from that library? Because I think there are very interesting and dangerous books. Maybe some of them are full of magic. But Avalon defended and something go very wrong there. Maybe they hit in fight some magic books or something. So now nobody can go inside. And I always wonder, what if Avalon started hide his face after that incident? He didn't hide when he was young. And no, because became druid is no explanation! And now Buck is watch Fort Maria. For right moment when Katja will know how enter library. And Buck watch to be sure nobody else will enter than Katja or somebody from Dark Core. Sorry for comment long like eternity. :-D
4:15 maybe the father turned into a horse when she was little, since she could see him despite being blind, maybe they're related in some way, I don't have any proof tho so it's just a thought lol
I know this video was made over 2 years ago, but i'll say it anyway. What if Buck is Garnok, but he uses "Buck" as a disguise so that no one will not that it's him. That would explain why he is hanging out with the dark riders/katja in starshine legacy and why he is standing near Fort Maria. But the reason his powers in starshine legacy are not as strong as Garnoks powers normally are could be "the benefits" from his disguise (being a teenage boy). The reason why he is using a disguise could possibly be for spying on the soul riders with them thinking he's just a normal bully who plays hockey. This would also explain why he has tentacles in that one picture, and why he is "fighting" all four soulriders in it. That means that they are lying about Garnok lying on the bottom of the oceon, and that the real reason they want something from the soul riders is because they need it to get Garnok into his normal self, with his powers and everything so that they can end the world or whatever it is that they want to do. Cause maybe it's a curse, maybe Garnok can't turn himself back bc of the lack of powers he has. But who knows? I mean Buck literally having tentacles in the book/picture really makes me belive that he is Garnok in disguise. Btw, I love your theories, they makle me so much more intressted in the game and it's a lot more fun getting to know things that aren't said in Starstable Online, like from the comics, legacy games and just mainly lore/mysteries that I have never heard of before. :)
I think that rania 's dad was a druid and there was some sort of accident that caused rania being blind like an expiriment going wrong and rania being caught in the middle of it
The glue man story is a reference to some factories supposedly using horse hooves to make glue. There is no glue "man" it's just a metaphor for the corperations.
Ok so I am wondering: Who is Mrs. Holdsworth's husband? I mean, if she did not have a husband, she would be adressed as Ms. Holdsworth. BUT MRS. HOLDSWORTH! I was thinking, bc she does some magic, could it be Gary Goldtooth?
I didn't know Alex was gay until I did that one winter wishes quest where I found Alex and Maya under the mistletoe
those two are definitely frooty !! as a lesbian i’m super glad that sso has some LGBTQ characters
This quest was for the gays 😔✊
I always saw Alex & Lisa as the gays in the group, I never thought they were together, but yeah. And then Alex’s new model came out & she’s literally textbook lesbian, like beanie & a flannel???
@@cat-bu5ky yaasss gay gang
LITERALLY ME TOO!! I was like “:0” TOO BAD THEY DIDN'T KISS THAT WOULD'VE BEEN SO CUTEE
"Dont let yourself be fooled by his innocent freckled face-"
Literally never thought he was any sort of innocent. Not once.
Girl I have to agree with you there
Also, James is hiding in the library because Buck (I think that’s his name) bullies him. So he’s definitely not a nice kid
Star Stable Office writing down the theories and make it into the game:
Star stable scrapping these amazing theories to make new, horribly made horses instead: 🤔😀🤑🤑👌😏
Actually the whole Glue Man thing is based on how glue used to be made out of horse hooves.
Maybe Igor does that too 👀
No but for real, why does he wanna eat horses 😅 what a creep
@@eleanornightwalker Yeah. I remember doing that quest when I was like, lvl 16 and now I am lvl 20 but I was on my starter and he be like "YUMMY CARAMELKISS!!! MABYE AN APPLE IN THE MOUTH AND ON A SILVER PLATTER?!" That freaked me out and I emedeantly logged off. xD
@@eleanornightwalker He definitely is creepy, but it's not so uncommon for horses to be eaten.
@@hlshdl6653 come to think of it, a teacher of mine said once that horse meat is a delicacy, and I remember being like THIS IS NEW TO ME
But still, you don't look at a living horse and say "yummy, this one would make a nice meal!". You don't do that with ANY animals 🙈🙈🙈
@@eleanornightwalker But many people sadly do that with pigs and cows. MANY people joke about beating cows and pigs to death, and imagine eating them even while still suffering. It's a sad reality.
Theory: Mrs Holdsworth is an important character to the storyline. I think she's some kind of druid under cover. Proof:
1. She helped us quite a lot troughout the story
2. She knows how to make some kind of posions, like when James was having nightmares.
2. Somewhere in a main quests, around the end of the current main quests, there was a discussion about whitches. If I'm not mistaken, our character said that there is no such a thing as whitches and then Meteor says "should we tell her about Mrs Holdsworth?"
So maybe she's a whitch, who is part of the Keepers of Aideen
Hmm, if I remember correctly she is actually a friend of the keepers of Aideen, but I have no idea if she's a retired druid or something 🤔🤔🤔
I always felt like she was a retired witch???
During the winter wishes' quests last year there was a quest with Mrs. Holdsworth trying to think of a gift for Pi, and it was stated that she is a fellow witch. So yeah, Pi and Mrs. Holdsworth are like the opposites on the spectrum in the beginning - one being an evil green witch living in a swamp and the other being a cute granny bee-loving witch. Nic Stoneground once said that witches usually go through phases throughout their lives, exploring both pure and dark magic. I guess Mrs. Holdsworth went through this already and settled for a peaceful retirement in Moorland, while Pi is more like a baby-witch, still exploring what the world of magic has to offer.
@@eleanornightwalker If I remember correctly, she was a friend of Elizabeth too. She came to her funeral to say goodbye.
Yayy it's confirmed now :D
I just wish Star Stable started focusing on the mainstory again. So many questions..
What if Buck is really Garnok but Garnok can't leave the body he's taking on until the dark riders complete the ritual and stuff, but instead of being stuck under the sea what if it was a metaphor for him being stuck somewhere he didn't want to be for example a teenage boys body. lol
I've thought that he might be mind controlled, but that doesn't explain why he's portrayed in the book. He would probably also have that blue thing above his head like James when he's being mind controlled
Another thought I considered was whether or not he could be a creation of Garnok/Dark Core. Like he was never human... but then that doesn't make sense because he has no abilities and acts just like a bully
Seriously, this one is bugging me so much 🙈
@@eleanornightwalker He never takes his glove off and he's always looking at his hand and hitting it like it's not part of him...Maybe something's up with his hand?
Buck: ,,This human body is limiting"
@@lisafarforest2442 or maybe the gloves conceal his magic ability?
i know this might sound stupid but what if buck and darko are brothers?
this would explain why both of them are able to controll garnok and why they look similar..🤔
i've been thinking about how rania lost her eyesight ever since the mistfall series came out, and i taught it had something to do with the incident with blaze
In the series that might be the case, but Skye is not in the game so idk 🤔 I'm just overall very confused about how the Mistfall series translates to the game 🙈
She could've been born with it
@@Pixemie maybe in canon, but the mistfall series denies it
@@eleanornightwalker I'm pretty sure that sometime in the future the Mistfall characters, especially Skye, will return
I don't think SSO would create such a complex character just to never use
I think that if they will put her in game, which I'm pretty sure they will, that putting her backstory into a series is actually quite a good way to show the character stuff kinda behind the scenes
@@thekorppu yeah
I'm never getting over the fact that Maya x Alex is canon
I'm weak for these two...
that's pretty epic but tbh i thought alex and anne were girlfriends lol
Same, I'm happy SSO is including LGBTQIA characters.
@@idk-vx7vm 😔
@@Pixemie same! I love it 😻
How is it canon? Literally no proof
Regarding the Glue Man riddle: Glue used to be made out of dead horses. So the Glue Man probably wants to make our horses into glue - that's what he'd do. I can't know IF Igor is a metaphorical Glue Man, but at least that explains the riddle itself.
That's true 🤔 but I still wanna know why he eats horses 🙈🙈🙈
He probably wants glue to put hair on his head 🤣
@@eleanornightwalker he could also reference renfield from Dracula. He ate weird creatures all the time. Maybe Jorviks version would eat horses.
HORSES TASTE TERRIBLE! It’s super hard by horses hav ton of muscle and tastes gross.
its funny cuz your buttergood vampire theory was confirmed in recent quests XD in the newest wildwoods questline they call him "blood sucker" and make other vampire puns
I don't think Lisa is lesbian, she seems bi to me! Alex is definitely lesbian tho, she has seem like one from the very beginning. :D
Me too! And i'm glad cause bisexuality erasure is sadly strong these days :'( you're either gay, straight or confused, which is very offensive to me cause i'm bi myself :(
@@VivianaSilverback yeah,people say they apparently support LGBTQ+ while they don't think that bi,pan,ace,aro,etc exist.
@@andjelakljajic3123 EXACTLY! Like wow, that's such a disrespectful thing to do.
I always headcanoned Alex as ace... but only because I'm asexual myself and I definitely ship her and Maya
hi I'm 6 what des bi mean
I love the first and last theory. Honestly wish you were the one who called the shots in Starstable because you'd make the best story quests and game quests in general. It pains me where sso is headed and i just wish they did better than now. The starshine legacy games were THOUSAND times better than Starstable in that sense. I also have to say i think you seem like such an incredible and unique person. Never stop being you. Like i could just listen to your videos even if they weren't about sso. You are such an interesting and mature person to listen to which is awesome! Thank you for today's video ☺️
This comment was so sweet, thank you so much 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
The theory of aideen being pandorian has been in my thoughts for a while. We are the 5th soulrider and the reincarnation of aideen herself? Or atleast reincarnation of catherine. I dont remember if catherine was aideen's reincarnation but if she was then this next thing im gonna say would make more sense.
So we have the ability to go to pandoria whenever we want to and we have not had any weird side effects whatsoever (or i have missed those if there were any) also i have seriously forgotten if we are aideen herself as the 5th soulrider but if we were and she was originally a pandorian, then so are we! Visiting pandoria frequently has not affected us and it makes it weird that we can have the access to pandoria even when there is nothing to do. Why would sso put the portals up and going if there was such a risk as to get lost, sick and die from the curse of pandoria? Aideen being a pandorian sure has no problem there since the curse of pandoria does not affect her nor us since we are aideen. Epic.
During one of the Fort Pinta Beach Festivals we could talk to Buck. I don't remember his exact words but he said he was actually hunting for James Cloudmill. He heard that James was doing business in some fort near the sea so Buck went there but couldn't get in. He apparently mistook Fort Maria for Fort Pinta.
Omg 😱😱
(I haven’t finished the story quests yet so this may be wrong) but if Buck had tentacle legs, it means he can change form to have human legs. What if something happened to his hand, like it’s stuck in a tentacle form, which is why he always wears a glove, and the dark riders said they could fix it if he works with them? Idk, like I said, I haven’t even met buck in game, he might’ve taken off the glove before 🤧
I've not long unlocked epona and I just thought maybe he lost a hand or something but that would make sense as he does bang and check his arm!
I've been theorizing for MONTHS that aideen is actually pandorian.
In addition to what you said, the fact that the magic the Druids use is the same/similar shade of pink as most of pandoria and Ydris' magic was always a bit suspicious in my opinion. If magic in the game was generally pink, shouldn't Pi's/Galloper Thompson's cauldron and the magic the Singing Yew used while performing the Whispering Cry be pink, too, instead of green? I know sometimes the symbols that appear while the Soul Riders use their magic are blue, but since there are, at least in the SSO version, blue tunnels in Pandoria that could still fit. I mean, color usually is pretty important when it comes to magic, and the ones the Druids use has generally always been pink.
Also, the only green portals in game are the ones connecting the portal in Dino Valley with the one in Epona, so what if "natural" magic is the one the witches and galloper (who is immortal because of witches) use while the druids use pandorian magic?
Idk probably just me putting too much thought into colors
I agree with you
No, no, wait! You got a point...
Call me crazy, but Buck could be Garnoks son.....
Believe it or not, but I've thought the same thing
I've thought about pretty much everything at this point 🙈
@@eleanornightwalker The drawing looks an awful lot like Garnoks....
I think Lisa is bisexual,and Alex is gay!! Alex has a tomboy vibes for me👁️👁️🖐🏻
I've been thinking about the last one, with Buck. We know from the books that Dark Riders aren't human. I think that they aren't anything, they were just created by Garnok to portray some level of normalness. The Dark Riders may not exist at all. And if they don't exist, or are just some imitation of a real person, Buck could be the same way. At this point in the game, we know that Katja, Jessica, and Sabine are bad news, but we know nothing about Buck. Maybe he's a spy, someone the Soul Riders wouldn't think twice about looking for, and reports back to the Dark Riders, which could be why he hangs around Katja in Starshine Legacy.
Maybe they took over other bodies because I remember seeing somewhere that Jessica wasn't always bad and liked birds but idk
Buck remindes me a little bit on Darko. Maybe they are family ?
My favourite theory that isn’t really to do with quests but more with the horses sso are releasing is we’ve entered gen4. The BREED_CROSSBREED_breed glitch on starters could mean they are being updated soon, and there’s more reasoning. The jf, Gotland pony and finnhorses can wear a special bridle, and we know older generations cannot wear newer tack. Therefore, it would be logical to call them gen4. I know sso calls them gen3, but I feel like the theory with the special bridles is probably real and we’re getting updated starters soon. Eventually sso will probably drop the gen3 tag and go with gen4, or perhaps gen3.5. That’s my reasoning, again it isn’t much evidence but I like the theory.
THE THE THE THE BUCK THEORY YES THAT'S BEEN BOTHERING ME FOR A LONG TIME AAAGH
and like he's katja's brother, did you mention that?
I've heard someone else say that but I don't understand where they got it from 🤔 they never say they're siblings
@@eleanornightwalker starshine legacy..?
No, they never say they're siblings 🤔 are you thinking of when he says "oooh, here comes big sister!"? Cause he's referring to Alex sticking up foe James, not Katja
@@eleanornightwalker no, but i'm 100% sure they say that buck is katja's sister somewhere
@@eleanornightwalker brother*
There's a video on SSO's UA-cam channel, where GM Ylva, Matilda and Stacy (I'm not sure about her) were talking about spooky stories, involving the Glue Man one. If I remember correctly, it was stated that Glue Man turned your horses hooves into glue and than turn the rest of them..? I'm not really sure on the second part of it, so I recommend watching the video!
I must say, that the idea, that Aideen is from Pandoria is really, really creative and fun to think about! I like to write fanfictions based on Jorvik universe, and this theory really help me to create new ideas, so, thank you :D
Ok....Did any of you ever thought who are our charecters parents???
same like...? we kinda just appear in jorvik? it would be awesome if we got more back story about how family.
Rania is one of my favourite characters in the game and I've often wondered about who her father is, but never linked it with who her father is. This was really interesting.
Also, I wondered if Blaze could be a Starbreed. She is a Jorvik Wild, but she doesn't fit in with the Warriors, Foresters or Mystics and clearly has magical powers. Like Nightdust and Starshine, she also has unusual colouring.
One more thing I was thinking about is that in the recent Gary Goldtooth quest, Willow had a vision which told us that Cedar was in danger. This made me think could the Mystics be associated with the Moon Circle?
Although it seems like the Mistfall series doesn't really seem to link up with the main story, I think it will be able too, with the help of the newer part of Wildwoods. Maybe there is some sort of magic that even the Keepere of Aideen don't know about.
Edit: 3 weeks later I looked back at this comment and realised I said "I've often wondered about who her father is, but never linked it with who her father is" which makes no sense. I meant to say "I've often wondered about who her father is, but never linked it with how she lost her eyesight".
Maybe each herd ties in to a circle, and maybe one herd is missing, causing the imbalence?
The foresters would probably be the sun circle, taking care of the living things and plants in the forest.
The Mystics probably would be the moon circle with their prophetic visions.
The warriors are probably the lightning circle, strong defenders.
That leaves the missing herd to be the Star circle perhaps? Like how Lisa was the last soulrider to show up in Jorvik, maybe the imbalance has to do with finding the missing herd.
@@sparxmaiden841 Now that's sounds interesting 🤔🤔
@@sparxmaiden841 That's kind of what I was thinking, but further developed. I could kind of see the relationship between the Warriors and the Lightning Circle, and there are even a few similarities between Ash and Alex's personalities as I think deep down, Ash also wants to protect her younger sibling, but I never considered there could be a herd missing. That's a really interesting idea.
@@sparxmaiden841 I think honestly foresters fit more with the star circle, natural healers and helpers. The “heart” of the forest if you will.
That leaves us with out the sun circle, the leader, the one who keeps the other circles in line.
Could that be embermane? Perhaps there only being one or very few could be the reason of the imbalance.
Maybe Gary Goldtooth will have something to do with this later on? There was the whole embermane we saw when we first went on the ride in the mist fall area. (Later on to be replaced with a forester model)
@@artistcat6426 great thinking! I agree, that makes better sense. Perhaps our theories will be right!
ayupp!! Another thing that ensures thet buttergood is a vampire that josh called him a bloodsucker
I loved Lisas old style. They could've kept it and just updated her... She was much more cooler before.
I feel as if my constant talk of Pandoria is rubbing off on you...finally, the Pandorians can take over the earth-I mean, it's nothing, you don't need to worry about it. But yeah, number 2 definitely makes me wonder a lot. Mostly about if Pandoria is actually a planet, since it seems you can get there in a spaceship, like Fripp did. It would make sense, but there's not a lot of things backing it due to Aideen still being a mystery.
You may or may not have rubbed off on me, yeah 😂😂😂 but I mean, all the soul riders got their powers from her, and the battle is always about Pandoria. Surely there's a reason why she gave us these powers? 🤔
Omg what if she used to be the queen of Pandoria or something, and that's why she was so powerful and graceful and seen as a goddess. And maybe that's why Pandoria is all pink - because Garnok invaded and altered it. Maybe it wasn't always like that 👀
(Okay yes, you DEFINITELY are rubbing off on me)
I could see Aideen being some sort of queen of Pandoria. After all, someone's got to rule the other Pandorians. Unless Garnok wiped most of them out...now I have an idea. If some Pandorians went to Earth before Garnok turned everything pink, they wouldn't of been wiped out. But if most stayed in their homeland, I can see how Garnok would wipe them out. Maybe in some sort of vain attempt to take it over for himself? Either way, it would make sense why we know so few Pandorians. And if there are more, maybe they just want to blend in with the humans so Garnok doesn't find them.
Pandoria mostly has purple-pink theme here. Though the issue I have with this theory that we are Aideen's reincarnation. When we turn into a horse, we pick up a gold theme and not pink cracks or purple ones. There is no hint on how did Aideen actually looked like beside the statue in Aideen's Plaza. Or at least haave no clue what she actually looks like with colors, you know. I would imagine that perhaps Aideen is just an alter ego of a powerful pandorian creature. (Also purple and yellow/gold are complimenter colors, so that is also possible)
i heard a few years ago that buck is actually katjas brother, so if that helps you with the theory about him then...well here ya go
I've heard some other people saying that too, but I think that's a misconception. I can't find anywhere in the game or elsewhere where it says that they are, and they don't look alike... it may come from when he says "oooh, here comes big sister!", and then Katja shows up behind them. He's referring to Alex in this moment 🤔
Eleanor Nightwalker tru tru. here’s an idea tho, maybe he has some sort of shape shifting ability? if he really is that tentacle thing and he really is a magical being, maybe he uses a more human form so he’s not as..well, sus? idk just an idea that came to my mind
@@eleanornightwalker Not all sibling with the same two parents look that much alike and some don't have the same parents
This is pretty random, but I think Buck might be related to Darko.
In one of a Star Stable magazines (2017) was comic it was shown that Ranja lost her eyesight from when she run to forest to find some berries. She was just picking up berries, and then an animal (or other thing i don't clearly remember) has scared her, she begin panic, tripped and lost her eyesight.
Buck could be one of garnoks underlings but just not apart of DC? I remember I saw somewhere that while Garnok was being taken somewhere by Fripp, his generals were there too. Since we see Garnok as having tentacles maybe his generals had them too which explains why Buck had tentacles?
Also I remember how you said Rhiannon was somehow connected to that new woman (forgot her name but she was mentioned in the new wild woods quests) and some kind of magic happened that messsed with Rania
Amazing video once again! I have some thoughts on this so here they are:
1#: Lisa screams gay with how she looks like. She definitely had a crush on Alex but it's just from the way they are almost always together.
2#: Aideen is definitely Pandorian for her being supernatural. She gives off that vibe but still feels like she isn't. Pandoria is full of dark magic so it doesn't make sense for her to be Pandorian yet have beautiful powers of life.
3#: I do think that Rania got her blindness from magic like you said. About her father, I have figured out that her mother is married/ dating the vet girl who helped us in quests (I forget the name). It's clear in the character book and hints the affection between the 3 of them.
4#: Igor is definitely the glue man for his weird "love" for horses. I don't have to say much as it explains for itself.
5#: Buck gives me "related to Darko" vibes because of his hair looking close to Darko's hair. He gives the Darko look off to me. Kind of want to throw him off that cliff now-
So that was my thoughts on this. What do you think?
Glad you liked the video! I know that Sigry and Dr. Eiren are married, but I'm sure Rania used to have a father too.. she doesn't refer to Dr. Eiren as her mother, and there are similarities between her and Sigry, so I highly doubt she's adopted 🤔
I've also thought about Darko and Buck being related, but there's nothing that suggests it so idk 🤔 if you put them side by side they don't look that similar anymore either 😕
I think that Buck having tentacle legs could mean that he is associated with Garnok- if not maybe even BEING garnok? (i know that sounds crazy, but it would explain why he was associated with the dark riders?)
About the "Lisa is gay" theory. You said that Helena Dahlgren was only referring to the "new" Lisa. However in the books Lisa is described as being a red-head with green eyes (just like the old lisa used to be). So yeah ig this is more proof that Lisa has been gay since the starshine legacy games.
That's true! 🤔
Actually talking about Igor he has always scared me when ever i have seen him in quest lines. Cause the look gives a creepy vibe and how he acts and talks. Also could you maybe make more videos about Igor cause i want to know more about him
POV: Buck is Garnok JK
2:07 this is brining me to a whole other theory of the ufo and doors. What if when she came to earth she fled and Darkcore came in the ufo to search for her. They might of made the underground doors to get to places faster and to keep her if they did find her. She could be the main power source of them if they do have her. Maybe in a later quest we go and save her from Darkcore
Hey , I know this has nothing to do about this video and you might already know this but it could be IMPORTANT so I was reading about Darko and it said this: FOR A MAN WHO HATES HORSES SO MUCH HE IS AWFULLY OBSESSED WITH THEM and it seemed like he is trying to get dark riders thery own horses ? I thought dark riders hated horses , do you think this could mean something, Eleanor ?
I think I heard that rania actually lost her eyesight when she was a kid picking berries in the forest. And about rania's father, I think I remember there was a piece of dialogue where rania states that she guessed people like the mayor guy and her dad kept telling her mom that she's too ambitious. I'm pretty sure this is literally the only time someone mentions rania's father, but from what I can deduce from that single piece of dialogue, rania's dad acts like the mayor. Which is pretty sad. What jerks.
Theory: The Dark Riders are animals.
Okay, hear me out here. I've been reading the SSO books (I haven't read the third one yet though it's coming in the mail) and I must say, there is sooooo much lore in them. Now, to my theory, there is so much proof to back me up.
Sabine is a tiger or a lion.
For one, her personality shows this a lot, as she can be tame and calm until tampered with, then she goes full rage mode. Two, at one point in the first book, it says (spoilers for the SSO books) 'She finished her convocation with the pale driver, and seemingly slinked towards the bushes where Lisa, Alex, Linda and Anne were hiding. She walked around the bush edge, sniffing the air like the tiger Lisa had seen in a zoo when her mum had taken her when she was little. She eventually walked away, grunting like some sort of animal.' UHH HELLO!?! If THAT doesnt scream tiger or lion I don't know what does!
Katja is a arctic fox.
This one was a bit harder and took a lot more research, but it's kinda obvious now. I was stuck between the idea of her being a snow wolf or arctic fox, but fox seems more likely. At one point in the second book, it reads: 'I knew I would find you here, coming to rescue your poor precious pony. What a shame, you can't do anything to help him!" A voice echoed across the room. She looked up. A bright white girl sat above her in a loft. They met each other's eyes. Lisa couldn't look away, stuck staring into Katja's lifeless white eyes. She eventually looked away, then disappeared into the darkness.' Okay, sure, maybe not that alone, but after researching, I found this: 'One way to describe a fox's attack towards animals like chickens is they will stare into they're eyes, causing them to freeze in fear. The fox will then pounce, killing the animal.' Like that sounds like a fox when you put them side by side.
Jessica is a spider.
This you kinda went over in one of your videos, but not in detail. I think you have read the bit where Jessica crawled into the car with Mr. Sands like a spider, so I won't really explain that since I think you know.
We don't know about the fourth general, but I'm hoping the third book will answer some of questions about that.
Feel free to make this into a video, and yes, basically all I do in my free time is draw, write and theorize. I've basically figured out the whole story line for Minecraft haha. Thank you for reading if you had made this far, and remember to drink some water, eat healthy food, and get the rest you need for tomorrow's great day. You're all amazing
!! People consider this theory !! Very well written Izzy :P
Why thank you Kay ;)
>:)
*I wonder who the very first soulriders were, in a quest, it said that Linda, Alex, Lisa, and Anne, weren't the first soul riders. I was very confused when it said that.*
elizabeth cathrine and anne's mom are from a previous genaration, and there was probably around 5 or somthing before that
I wanted to point out how the cover of Glueman's song is blackish/grayish and how the weird man's(forgot his name) outfit is those same blackish/grayish color.
And for Eideen's theory... I think you can make a wgole video on this if you search for every single time Eideen was mentioned. I am sure if it's sso world h1ve gave us more hints.
I know this is late but whatever. I found it weird that Buck was portrayed with tentacles because the only other character that I know of that has been associated with tentacles was Garnock. Since Buck hangs out with the Dark Riders, what if he only bullies James because he knows that his sister (Alex) is a soul rider whose life mission is to stop Dark Core's plans. He can use James to get information or to spy on the soul riders. THINK ABOUT THAT!
I always thought Lisa is in love with Anne, just the way she responded about Anne in one of the quests
The Buck thing has been driving me crazy as well. I'm POSITIVE there was some canon content of him standing in front of the Fort Maria with tentacles coming out of the ocean behind him (the ones we saw when Darko used Garnok to attack us) but I can't find it anywhere for the life of me. I'm 100% sure either HE'S Garnok himself or at least he's very closely tied to it.
Abot Aideen being pandorian:
YES! i always thought about it, it makes sense in my head. Why would her powers and the seals from each one of them be in Pandoria if she wasn't one of them? In my headcanon I always thought she was kinda like an ideal rather than a goddess to pandorias, a girl that from nothing came to be really powerful, showing the strongest bond between rider and horse. Also, how else would you explain Fripp's existance? he too is pandorian, just as old as Aideen herself, when Garnok ended on earth they had to search for someone to be able to destroy it and save the planet, they neede to find somene willling to do it, that would porbably be a pandorian
Theory: Igor is Mrs. Packard's husband, and Andy's grandfather, which explains why he had a picture of Andy at his room at Wolf Hall Inn.
The Buck one is so interesting. Maybe its not coincidental that he picks on the younger brother of a soul rider
I think buck might be garnock, or somehow related to him. If he was portrayed in a history book with tenticles, and put up against a soul rider, he defiently can't be a normal bully like we're lead to believe.
No evidence for this though, just my thoughts
To me Buck is like a "host" body. Maybe they need someone with enough bad feelings/energy to use it for carrying Garnok's soul and reach us in an easier way ? It would be like a possession. And Buck is probably unaware of this, he could simply be happy that some of the dark riders want to hang out with him as Katja is quite pretty and can easily manipulate people. His interaction with Rin shown us that he's ready to change his mind for a pretty girl. He would be a good choice as he's close to James ( not in a good way I have to admit ) , one of the soul riders' siblings. It'd be a perfect way to spy on them and hit a the right moment.
Watching these makes me think SSO is a much deeper game than I think... And I'm so addicted to your channel! I can't wait to see all of these theories finished! I'm so exited! ❤️
love this channel for real
Maybe Buck might be the dark rider they r missing??
And I liked the theory about Rania :)
So... You know how Garnok has tentacles? Maybe he doesn't live in Devil's Gap... At this moment. It seems like a leap but... MAYBE BUCK IS GARNOK! I don't know much about that history book but I just thought "GARNOK" once I saw it.
Wow. Okay. Lots of theories!
So. . .first of all. . .I think the Igor theory is perfect. Even before I had heard of Igor, any time the song Glue Man mentioned. . .Well. . .The glue man, I've always pictured someone like him.
About the Buck theory. . .Wow! I think that is possible. And as one of the comments down there said, I think Buck may very well be Garnok. I mean, his arms and legs are unrealistically oversized, especially for a bully in school. I think that may be because he is just wearing a disguise to cover his tentacles.
Hey,
About your Buck theory, I have something to add:
1. At fashion week 2018, you could speak to a lot of different Npc's, including Buck. He says a lot of things, but this dialogue in particular caught my attention:
„Devil's Gap? Yeah, the rumours are true. Place is totally haunted. Something about which is from, like, a thousand years ago. I hoped the fence once and shot some sick video. Weird lights, freaky people in hoods, talking horses... it was total cult stuff. I posted it all to jortube but someone took 'em down. It's a conspiracy, I'm telling you!"
I find it odd that Buck seems to have no memory of what happened in Devil's Gap, maybe an easter egg from the developers, since it seems that what happened in Starshine Legacy is no longer canon. Or maybe was Buck controled/hypnotized by Katja and now doesn't remember anything.
2. Again, at the 2018 fashion week, he says this:
„James thinks he's so smart, holing up in Fort Maria. You heard me - FORT MARIA. I know that's where he's hiding, and I'm gonna stay camped outside the gates until he shows his pimple face. We'll see who gets the last laugh!"
That explains why he is in front of Fort Maria.
3. Some people in the comments suggested that he might be related to Darko somehow. Here's what Buck had to say about him (Again, at the fashion week 2018):
„"Darko"? Is that dude for real? He's trying way too hard. Sweet cane, though.
(Here is a link to a video where you can read most of the Npc's dialogue, and they all have something interesting to say: ua-cam.com/video/rAGYJCcuisI/v-deo.html )
Actually, I think this is a detail that not a lot of people saw, but today I logged on sso and I was standing next to Fort Maria's entrance when I saw Buck, ironically I wanted to take a screenshot with him but then I noticed that his animation is not the same one in this video!! I know the video is already old but the fact that they changed his iddle animation, might mean they're working on him, I don't think a developer would take their time just casually checking Buck's files and changing his iddle animation, this is just a theory but I think in the upcoming main story quests we will get to see him with the dark riders and the arrival of the new dark rider. (This was just a fun detail but it might mean something :) )
WAIT , NO WAY. I LEFT THE AREA AND I CAME BACK, HE NO LONGER HAS THE DIFFERENT ANIMATION. . . It might have been just a mistake but it's curious, I took a couple of screenshots of his mysterious other iddle animation tho, it's a little bit of my proof (I was so happy that it was a possibility to see him in new quests but my hopes are almost gone)
i wouldn't be surprised if all soul riders or at least most of them are in some way in the lgbtq+ community 🏳️🌈
Eleanor: 'Lisa could be LGBTQ+'
Alex: 😅 'wait where do i hide my pride flag'
I definitively like the last one about Buck. Been thinking about it myself, and yeah there really isn’t much evidence on this
Hey I Hope you read this but my theory with buck is that he may be the son of garnok and we will fight him before garnok that could be why he hangs around the dark riders and why he is portraits with tentacles in that history book, because garnok also has these tentacles
im happy sso has/will have some LGBTQ+ characters!
Technically Skye from the mist fall series is in the game, even if we have never met her. Don’t you remember that at the New Years party for 2021 Rania and the rangers mentioned Skye and that she was new to Mistfall and kind of a fish out of water we still have not met her but we know that she actually exists.
Glue man turns your horses into glue.
buck is still at fort Maria watching us trying to break into the fort but …. not doing anything about it so...
Buck is secretly Garnok!
In the german version it says that the Glue Man makes your horses hoofs into glue so I guess he's not eating them
Yeah I recently finished playing the starshine legacy series. I’m sure that buck is a warrior for garnok, sent to act as katja’s ‘champion’ as depicted in the last episode. He does not seem to possess any magical properties though, so he’s probably just some muscled body guard for katja.
I have a theory about Rania's father. As we all know and as it was being said, we do not know him. However in the Mistfall's series we can observe in one of the last episodes that she can see magic-linked things (she saw her friend and her horse, both using magic). Maybe her dad is a druid and that druids are special people, meaning that they cannot "become" but are born with special abilities such as controlling magic and seeing it. And again, maybe some types of druids are forbidden to have children like priests. And if her father is a druid, there's obviously a moment where her abilities awaken and maybe the awakening happened in her early ages and that process shouldn't be interfered with, however maybe her mom did interfer as she was clueless about all of this druid thing which led to her blindness. This theory may explain her abilities in the series, her blindness as well and the unknown identity of her father. :)
Buck could be the kraken. Cause the game does talk about that.
There is also a legend from Starshine Legacy that can prove your theory about Aideen roots.
When we enter Pandoria Throught "path of winds" we can find horse statues, pretty similar to this located in Epona. Moreover There are Stone tablets with pictures on it and they tell story of Pandoria's origins. If we Pay attentoion to all elements on Stone tablets, we can see human-like character in few pictures.
In my opinion this might be Aideen But I am not 100% sure...
honestly kinda wish they still kept lisa's punk look i liked it a lot
I think Lisa is les or bi too 🏳️🌈
i have a small thing to add to the rania theory. sso actually released a comic about her in one of their magazines and it sort-of-kinda touches on the topic of her blindness and confirms that her father left them. i translated the comic to english a while ago, so i can send the link to anyone who’s interested. (youtube keeps deleting my comment with the link so that’s a bummer)
Thank you, I have already found the comic after the making of this video 😊
2:31 look at the right...kind of behind her .....lmaoooo
Buck maybe is Garnoks son, he was portrade with tentacle legs.
I think she lost her sight with something to do with the fire horse. (Forgot names its 2am) hence why she can see the horse
If the legend says Aideen came from a falling star (outer space) then isn’t it possible the secret spaceship location is how she got here and where she landed?
About the glue man one I think it it is true because in one star stables weekly videos they posted something about the glue man, but i cant remember which video. :/ I love your video by the way ( the video was about 3 girls talking about haunted stuff and specially the glue man )
I think Buck is a remnant of the old backstory to ssl and sso, now that they've changed the main storyline he is not relevant anymore which is why he has had little to none part of quests or stoey line and probably wont have any in the future either.
My favorite one is ranya ,Lisa and alex.Also I am interesting on what did happen to ranya's dad. From Lily and as princess roseball on sso
Omg guys.... So you showed the picture about the History book. I can see the 4 soulrider, and GARNOK. With a hockey stuff and EXACTLY look like that bully boy except the legs. Garnok's legs. Doing the quest with Missisippi Jones in Epona he said it was a library. But why someone guard in front of a library?! That place is just a mistery. But he can be Garnok.
theres a reason lisa was always my favorite character... pretty sure i thought of her as gay before i even knew i was myself !
the buck one i think that hes like some sort of recreation of garnok and only darkcore knows just like how were the recreation of aieeden but he does not know but he knows magic is real and that's why he was with katja when james was stolen.
not sure buttt yeah
At Rania, in jorvikpedia it said that she lost her eyesight collecting berries and she wasn t careful. Still,she saw Skye with Blaze
At Buck: he might be katja`s brother,because in ssl at ep 4 is about and James,Alex`s BROTHER.So,yeah
I thought Aideen created Pandoria🧐
Nice theories btw!😊
YES, WHY IS BUCK STANDING THERE???
I'm sorry for that. But finally somebody said it. :-D It is in my head for months.
I believe Buck have powers like dark riders. And I think he is alien too. And even he looks young, I think he is not. And I have very crazy theory, but unfinished too.
It starts with Avalon. I found about him on Jorvikipedia that he worked at Fort Maria's library as a librarian, until an unknown incident. This info is from some holidays in game. I saw pictures with it on some web too.
WARNING!!!
There is ending info from game. And I didn't read books or comics so I don't know if we have more info about this. Now is just my crazy theory a no facts. :-D
I think maybe Buck and Katja have to do something with that incident. I think maybe they wanted steal something from that library? Because I think there are very interesting and dangerous books. Maybe some of them are full of magic. But Avalon defended and something go very wrong there. Maybe they hit in fight some magic books or something. So now nobody can go inside.
And I always wonder, what if Avalon started hide his face after that incident? He didn't hide when he was young. And no, because became druid is no explanation!
And now Buck is watch Fort Maria. For right moment when Katja will know how enter library. And Buck watch to be sure nobody else will enter than Katja or somebody from Dark Core.
Sorry for comment long like eternity. :-D
4:15 maybe the father turned into a horse when she was little, since she could see him despite being blind, maybe they're related in some way, I don't have any proof tho so it's just a thought lol
I know this video was made over 2 years ago, but i'll say it anyway. What if Buck is Garnok, but he uses "Buck" as a disguise so that no one will not that it's him. That would explain why he is hanging out with the dark riders/katja in starshine legacy and why he is standing near Fort Maria. But the reason his powers in starshine legacy are not as strong as Garnoks powers normally are could be "the benefits" from his disguise (being a teenage boy). The reason why he is using a disguise could possibly be for spying on the soul riders with them thinking he's just a normal bully who plays hockey. This would also explain why he has tentacles in that one picture, and why he is "fighting" all four soulriders in it. That means that they are lying about Garnok lying on the bottom of the oceon, and that the real reason they want something from the soul riders is because they need it to get Garnok into his normal self, with his powers and everything so that they can end the world or whatever it is that they want to do. Cause maybe it's a curse, maybe Garnok can't turn himself back bc of the lack of powers he has. But who knows? I mean Buck literally having tentacles in the book/picture really makes me belive that he is Garnok in disguise. Btw, I love your theories, they makle me so much more intressted in the game and it's a lot more fun getting to know things that aren't said in Starstable Online, like from the comics, legacy games and just mainly lore/mysteries that I have never heard of before. :)
I think that rania 's dad was a druid and there was some sort of accident that caused rania being blind like an expiriment going wrong and rania being caught in the middle of it
Parents are screaming at the first theory
this is a genuine question, Garnork right and Buck, do they have same number of tenticles?
Igor creeps me out
New theory: Buck is garnok
So my theory behind the new Lisa is that with the release of the mess full series they decided to mix the original Lisa and Skye Into one character
The glue man story is a reference to some factories supposedly using horse hooves to make glue. There is no glue "man" it's just a metaphor for the corperations.
Ok so I am wondering: Who is Mrs. Holdsworth's husband? I mean, if she did not have a husband, she would be adressed as Ms. Holdsworth. BUT MRS. HOLDSWORTH! I was thinking, bc she does some magic, could it be Gary Goldtooth?
Good question 🤔 but he would be called Holdsworth too 🤔
Eleanor: And Helena-
Me: What!?Why my name? Do you know me? OH... She means the autor.... 😅