Dark Psychology of the YTTD Character You Didn't Know Existed | Your Turn To Die Analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
  • A delve into a character who plays a major role in YTTD's story, who you've seen over and over, but who you may not have recognized as a character.
    YTTD & Humanity: Why Dolls?: • YTTD & Humanity: Why D...
    We were WRONG about the Logic Route | YTTD Theory: • We were WRONG about th...
    Final YTTD Theories: • FINAL YTTD THEORIES - ...
    Twitter: / melancholihoiic
    Discord server: / discord

КОМЕНТАРІ • 35

  • @VividVirid
    @VividVirid 5 місяців тому +89

    The scarf is very interesting. It was never explained how Shin ended up having it since it is implied to be owned by Midori first

  • @mono_mono_bear
    @mono_mono_bear 5 місяців тому +107

    I love how nankidai writes the character's psychology so much

  • @OsakaREALL
    @OsakaREALL 5 місяців тому +9

    I LUV UR WAY OF THINKING SM !!!! out of any person to explain thingz abt yttd yur videoz have alwayz made the most sense to me and helped me understand so well thank yu !!!!!!

  • @ashy_inking1476
    @ashy_inking1476 Місяць тому +2

    I love this analysis so much 😭💖

  • @pawepawski5610
    @pawepawski5610 2 місяці тому

    Wow I didn't expect this video to be so good

  • @PIMKAMINA2
    @PIMKAMINA2 5 місяців тому +119

    I always saw "Sou Hiyori" as a persona, a mask handed from Midori to Shin as a way to (unhealthily) cope with the situation. Sou represents that worst of the death game, the betrayal, the manipulation, and the nihilism. Accepting Sou *is* giving up hope on trust and friendship and accepting the philosophy of the death game.

    • @Melancholiholic
      @Melancholiholic  5 місяців тому +27

      From a certain perspective this is the case. In Shin's case, it's likely the only healthy outcome is to part with Sou, unless he himself can find his own way to redefine it. Personally I believe the ultimate outcome of the Logic Route will be an end to Sou; where the Emotion Route Shin dies and Sou lives, instead Sou will die and Shin will live.
      But Sou is also defined by the people who knew him. Kanna, who saw his kindness and love, didn't know Sou to be that at all. Even after everything she still calls him Sou, because to her Sou was a good person.
      Thanks for the comment and chance fo elaborate on things I couldn't really put in the video due to getting off topic.

  • @pattywu9301
    @pattywu9301 5 місяців тому +52

    9:57 yeah! The ambiguity here is genius to me. It’s easy to blame Joe’s death on Sou in one’s first play through, but there’s never evidence of that.
    (Side Joe spoilers in comments)

    • @pattywu9301
      @pattywu9301 5 місяців тому +24

      And there comes the truth-kind of. Joe was going to assemble everyone and met Sou and Kanna while they were walking out of the bar.
      Their conversation then was exactly like when Sou lied to Sara about voting Joe in second trial that Mishima died of. Sou didn’t led Joe into picking up sacrifice.
      But one, if they wanted to paint Sou as the villain so badly, can still argue that Sou said something about rest so Joe would go into the bar! (I don’t buy that at all)
      Trusting your fellow humans really is the key! I love this game and your analysis are very interesting!

  • @jacobkakyoin6882
    @jacobkakyoin6882 5 місяців тому +50

    FACT: midori made up sou hiyori so shin would feel bad for him, and in general

  • @superuniverse5974
    @superuniverse5974 5 місяців тому +40

    You can't just jumpscare me with Higurashi footage like that.

  • @AKIROKORO
    @AKIROKORO 5 місяців тому +20

    OMG IS THE YTTD FANDOM ALIVE TO MAKE ANALYSIS VIDEOS AGAIN?!?! IM SO HAPPY

  • @pattywu9301
    @pattywu9301 5 місяців тому +21

    dang play tag is such a nice interpretation of Sou

  • @tom-r3z
    @tom-r3z 5 місяців тому +13

    This video just unlocked something in my mind…JUST YOU WAIT WORLD THE NEXT DANGANRONPA/YTTD INSPIRED DEATH GAME FAN GAME WILL BE OUT SOON BABYYYYYYYYYY!!!

  • @CloverPegs
    @CloverPegs 5 місяців тому +12

    what an incredible banger of a video

  • @punnybun
    @punnybun 5 місяців тому +5

    i honestly love this video and how it puts a different perspective on sou as a character :) i found your channel kinda recently but your work is great!! keep it up 😤❤️

  • @MsAnimefan95
    @MsAnimefan95 4 місяці тому +5

    For a second there I thought this was going to branch off into a theory that the scarf is haunted and anyone who wears it turns evil, but Sou Hiyori was up to his shenanigans even on days he wasn't wearing it, so that theory was short lived.

  • @willow3po
    @willow3po 5 місяців тому +5

    A DAY AGO?? LETS GOOO

  • @AnachronisticAstronaut
    @AnachronisticAstronaut 5 місяців тому +4

    !!! Epic video

  • @LouisRobinLouisRobin-i9b
    @LouisRobinLouisRobin-i9b 19 днів тому

    Rodriguez Eric Hernandez Michael Taylor Timothy

  • @zillynfox
    @zillynfox 5 місяців тому +3

    This is super interesting, awesome video!

  • @kat1652
    @kat1652 2 місяці тому +2

    wow, this video essay is just so well done. perfectly encapsulates shin as a person and the circumstances that pushed him into his persona, becoming the reason why he acted the way he did during the death game. thank you for pointing out the scarves representing sou hiyori as an identity! i didn’t realize there was such a stark difference when he embraced his death as shin in the emotion route, as compared to keeping the scarf and his identity as sou during the logic route. amazing work!! ❤️

  • @РусланДавлетханов-ч5к

    Hernandez Mark Wilson Sharon Hall Elizabeth

  • @Givenall
    @Givenall 5 місяців тому +4

    Yo new vid!!!

  • @teddyboucher1848
    @teddyboucher1848 5 місяців тому +3

    Very Good 👍

  • @yunowhoitisss
    @yunowhoitisss 5 місяців тому +2

    i always absolutely adore these in depth analyses

  • @andresalquicira6762
    @andresalquicira6762 2 місяці тому

    AGATA good name :3

  • @sarapinkdiamond866
    @sarapinkdiamond866 3 місяці тому +1

    Shin i so misunderstood in the fandom thank you for the lovely video ❤🎉

  • @TheCaliMack
    @TheCaliMack 2 місяці тому

    You could also almost say one viewed themselves as...furniture. 😏😉

  • @Youheeep
    @Youheeep 5 місяців тому +1

    Finally a new yttd video it’s been too long since I’ve seen one

  • @AbdurRaheemMahomed
    @AbdurRaheemMahomed Місяць тому

    i really like this take. sou is just a facade. i never fully understood why kanna trusted him but this video makes it so much clearer! thank you! nankidai really put alot of effort into creating him. so now im thinking, everytime hes kind and humble hes shin but when he loses all of that he becomes sou. it shows how hes a good and bad character who either dies a noble for saving kanna or redeems himself for being sou. this is such a interesting perspective i rlly enjoyed it!

  • @deadlysinsdeath4830
    @deadlysinsdeath4830 5 місяців тому

    Where is the chapter 3 part 2?

    • @Ray.Beam_
      @Ray.Beam_ 2 місяці тому

      It’s currently in progress I believe! No idea when it’s coming out but I am waiting