Mamma Mia! vs. ABBA
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- ABBA songs vs the Mamma Mia! The Movie version.
Let me know in the comments which version you like better.
Song used in outro:
ABBA - Mamma Mia (instumental)
Find me on social media:
Twitter - / grandelukather
Instagram - / nadiehiwana
Goodreads - / nadieh
![[UA] NAVI проти G2 Esports | Blast Premier Fall Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QWlIm4FGESQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Mama Mia = the best movie ever made /// ABBA = the best band ever ! It’s a win win 💓
In the end we are the winners and we get it all
IMO beatles better
@@dalenous4413 love the beatles,definitely in my top 5!
ahem I think u made a mistake there buddy, #1 band IS The Beatles
@@beatlesfan9777 aha yes already replied to someone else, love Beatles also! definitely in my top 3!!!
0:07 Honey Honey
0:51 Dancing Queen
1:34 Super Trouper
2:18 Our last summer
3:03 Money Money Money
3:46 S.O.S
4:31 Does your mother know
5:15 Mamma Mia
5:59 Lay all your love on me
6:43 Take a chance on me
7:26 Gimme Gimme Gimme
Hope I helped someone :)
Acting Doglover
Use colons for time stamps :
Wish they had done Voulez Vouz. It’s my favorite.
Heidi Christensen it’s Voulez-Vous, not Voulez Vouz
Yes, thanks
Thank you!
Honestly ABBA is amazing and they are probably better singing but the magic that movie have is EVERYTHING
Probably better singing? Frida and Agnetha are literally amazing vocalists with great range, better than nearly all of pop singers today. They blow everyone in the movie out of the water
The actors did a really good job. But the voices of Agnetha and Frida are just unique. And ABBA is the best pop band of all time.
nina 258 ABBA and The Beatles are the top pop bands ever
CoCo Covers And Queen of course
nina 258 don’t get too wound up lol. There’s better bands out there
Yes true
Not Izzy Queen wasn’t that great they just knew how to make good music. A lot of people make good music. Abba makes great music
Actually I love them both to the moon and back
Regina Lang
Logical
Agreed
For me it's a 50/50 split, the film versions seem to have more body verses Abba who are pitch perfect but some songs lack soul, difficult to explain but I hope you understand! 😄
Only Alamater Royal soprano Cynthia this Century.
Yes you are right!!
Isnt it just the way they sang back then?
None of abba were native English speakers so maybe it made it harder for them to express the story in the song idk
This 👌
I love meryl streep as donna and sophie as amanda seyfried
Don't you mean Amanda Seyfried as Sophie?
Me too
um
@@arwend798 🤣🤣🤣
“That Sam guy can’t sing, but he’s hot so it doesn’t matter.”
- My mom
Madelief haha
Haha lolll😂😂😂😂
I actually like his voice
Madelief Sam can sing
Bull
Mamma Mia characters
0- Donna
1- Sophie
2- Bill
3- Harry
4- Sam
5- Tanya
6- Rosie
7- Sky
8- Pepper
9- Ruby (Donna Mom)
Edit- this is like my most viral comment thank u sooo much 🥺
I’m bill lol
I dont get it. Is it some sort of game? If so, please explain I'd like to play!🙃
G PL the number of your like is your character so if the likes are at 8 and your like is 9 then you’ll be ruby hope that helps
@@reallyweird1768 yeah sure😂
Rosie!
i love both but some songs i really prefer mamma mia versions i don’t know why and meryl is just amazing
Same!
Meryl es maravillosa papel que le dan lo hacé brillar
Make another one with mamma Mia 2
I just posted one today!
Yes! With both!
@@grandepayne oh, okay lol
Boa tarde segue orçamento pra rygscgzgxg o seu retorno o mais o que os outros irmãos e Cris minegirl Tex Zagor Mônica recarga do cartão de crédito pra você eu já vi e gostei tanto que eu não sei o que é e como é a gente se fala de ver um dia de hoje você Cris é a melhor forma de decoração e buffet de churrasco de ver um vídeo de ver o quebrantamento a nossa massacre você não for destinatário desta mensagem e de quatro anos de vida que eu entrar no site do banco central do ru e e aí a nossa massacre de Eldorado do sul RS CEP é bairro a nossa massacre de Eldorado do sul RS a gente não se irrite a gente não se você quiser eu posso fazer a lateral esquerda TB te que é a melhor forma de pagamento da Júlia e eu não tenho nada contra mas o que os alunos que eu entrar em contato com o dinheiro da Mauriony está em casa sei se você quiser eu posso na quarta feira de Santana Bahia e do morder a língua
hi
Is it just me that prefers mamma Mia? Bc I just enjoy the choreography and how fun they make the songs although ABBA is amazing.
I know exactly how you feel. The crispness of Mamma Mia’s versions definitely help too
it’s just you
Not just u I'm the same😂
I like both. If I want classic rock and my childhood, then I listen to ABBA, but for energetic and "fun" versions of these songs, then Mamma Mia! Not to say that ABBA isn't "fun" though, but that is the main difference between the two for me.😊
I know I totally agree . Mamma Mia is way better , with all the dancing and things more motivated to be listening to 8t . ABBA still a good band
Mamma Mia is awesome but you can NEVER beat ABBA
👏👏👏👏
Trueeeeeee ❤️❤️❤️😍😍😍😍
Rhirhichu only Meryl Streep’s version of The Winner Takes It All can beat ABBA’s version
ABBA was an amazing group, thanks Mamma Mia many people r remembering them & the new generation now knows who they were, it’s absurd to compare.
Rhirhichu gzq
ABBA was an amazing group, thanks to Mamma Mia many people r remembering them & the new generation now knows who they were, it’s absurd to compare.
as someone who now loves both versions and knows of abba now from watching mama Mia with my mom as a kid I definitely agree
Everyone in Mamma Mia! is really talented, but nobody can compare to the immaculate talent ABBA has :)
Meryl strep is so pretty
But she cant sing
Brage Eide hahah when I showed my parents mamma Mia they were wondering why Meryl Streep was picked for Donna cause she’s not a good singer
True
Joshmnmket 😃♥️😃
Brage Eide Couldn’t disagree more, she’s my absolutely favorite actress of all time so I love everything she does, especially when she sang The winner takes it all, she killed it👊🔥
ABBA hands down! The vocals of ABBA easily outstrip those of the Mama Mia actors (1 and 2). Sure the Mama Mia movie scenes and performances are fun, but ABBA's voices always send the songs to a higher level.
Absolutely love ABBA without a doubt but also love how the film animated the ABBA songs for me beyond the original videos . Giving them a new meaning that I hadn’t thought of before.
I love mamma Mia for introducing me to ABBA
Me too
It's my favorite movie and it helped me to know more.
I like them both equally but they're good in different ways if that makes sense
H Factor I agree
All these songs😍
Oui
I agree
H Factor so true
I grew up watching mamma Mia so when I heard the ABBA versions for the first time it was hard to like them better however the more I listened to them the better they became and now I definitely agree that ABBA is the best.
The production and sound quality is obviously way better in mamma mia since they were recorded with more advanced technology (2008 vs 1970s). So that's why I think most people prefer the movie soundtrack. But Abba's vocals are way better than the actors in Mamma Mia with the exception of Amanda. Also for me abba sounds more nostalgic.
someone94 The instrumentals are better quality but I prefer the originals for even that.
dita parlo Yeah me too. I love Abba
ABBA
someone94 Are you saying Meryl isn't as good as Amanda?
Manhattan Man - Maybe I should've specified, but I meant the clarity of the production if that makes sense, and not the production itself. Also, didn't Benny and Bjorn also produce the mamma mia soundtrack as well?
Both versions are great, but I grew up watching Mamma Mia, so I prefer their version
olivia yea same
Same
olivia Oml same
SAME!!
Me too. 😍
Amanda wins in Honey honey and Lay all your love. Take a chance on me : Erasure wins.
Next to Beatels
Erasure? They added a Rap part to 'Take A Chance On Me'. Rap and ABBA do not mix. ABBA are Pop. I hate Acts trying to be 'cool' by adding Rap to their Covers of old Songs. No one does ABBA Songs as well as ABBA. Sadly, even Benny & Bjorn have forgotten that! A lot of 'Mamma Mia!' Film Fans, think that the Songs are sung as well as, (or better than), ABBA. Such people remind me of those Teens, who think that every old Black and White Movie is rubbish, because they are used to seeing Films in Colour...
@@stevetimms4100 Oh yes, it is always sad when Benny and Björn forget things. Also, it is sad when ABBA fans cannot write Björn's name right 😰
@@kasperjoonatan6014 - In the UK and other English Speaking Countries, we do not use Swedish Language type. That is why I write Bjorn as I do.Just as Millions of other people write it. His name is typed that way, in every UK ABBA Book, and every ABBA UK Newspaper Article. As well as ABBA Books etc. in the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. We just do not write Bjorn as it would be written in Sweden...
@@stevetimms4100 It is not a SWEDISH language type, ö is used in Finnish, Estonian, German and many other languages. If I were e.g. a Beyoncé fan I would write her name correctly even though we don't have é in my language. The letter ö is very easy to use with a computer, even if you are in the UK or other English speaking countries. So laziness is the only excuse for not using it. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for laziness. Just don't try to be an excellent ABBA fan if you don't even write their names right 😑
personally i prefer mamma mia because i saw the movie before i listened to ABBA and hearing a different version than what you’re used to is weird. however ABBA is great.
edit: meryl streep’s ‘mamma mia’ sounds more like the original compared to lily james, but lily still did a great job
__ itz.missy __ I’ll let Lily know you think that, she’ll appreciate it, she’s my half cousin
This is the way I feel because I found out about ABBA from Mamma Mia
__ itz.miipil
I didn’t find ABBA through Mamma Mia but only the song “Mamma Mia” sounds better. The rest sound cheap af
What how can you say that
Hard decision. I love the harmonies of ABBA but there is something about the vocals of Meryl, Amanda, Julie, Christine, and Pierce that make the songs fresh and new. This music is eternal.
Don’t get me wrong I really like ABBA but as watching mama Mia for the first time at 4 yo I’m more used to the mama Mia version and to me Mama Mia sounds better but that’s my opinion
Lola Miller me to....
Lol it’s your opinion
Your so right
I mean, I grew up around ABBA so I’m more used to it that’s why I like ABBA more.
I feel like people shouldn’t compare ABBA and mamma Mia tho because they are both really great.
I’m only 12, but I grew up listening to ABBA, but the musical is my favourite movie ever. But ABBA wins this one ❤️
MaddieRick same here! But I'm 11
Same but i am 12 to
@@rosepetals4734 same here
Same, I cried during Mamma Mia 2
13 same heree
Everyone's going "well mama mia wont exist w/o abba, so abba!!"
The point of the video is WHICH *version sounds better*
ABBA
Albus Dumbledore If you say so :')
Ethan Ethan Mmmmm
Violator Lenxi I just like it better but if u like mamma Mia I’m not going to say your wrong because I do like it too I just like ABBA better.
Violator Lenxi 💮
Anyone else mind blown how they made a movie out of songs a band have sang, not even just one movie two. I just can’t wrap my head around it 😩
And it could even be a third in the makings. Out of maybe the around 110 songs ABBA made probably a hundred are very, very good.
@@user-mv6he6gl8m Third film was already confirmed by Judy Cramer. It was currently on development
Look, the Mamma versions are fine in the context of fitting in the storyline of a musical. In this video, they also benefit from the stunning backdrops, cinematography and huge choreography. But listen and compare them without the visuals. It's really 'no contest'. Benny and Bjorn's arrangements are superb throughout but the ABBA girls are not only brilliant singers individually but their beautiful harmony is a sound unmatched in Pop history. . There's a reason why they inspired other movies before MM like Muriel's Wedding. Not to mention countless tribute bands. So it's ABBA all the way. Can't wait for these new songs to be released.
Hands down Abba every day! All my love to Mamma Mia, one of the best films ever made. But the music /piano and guitar in the Mamma Mia films were actually the Abba musicians & Bjorn and Benny anyway so?!😂😂 Bjorn and Benny managed to change key signatures then play their songs just for the actors who withstanding Amanda Seyfried can’t sing anyway hahah! Agnetha and Frida have my heart, their vocals can’t be beat.
This is not a "who did it better" it's just a side to side. I adore Mamma Mia and it's a great tribute to Abba.
I just love Meryl Streep's voice 😍
But I really love ABBA to
Meryl streep is the worst singer in the world
Brage Eide
What you talking about. I love ABBA way more but even I can’t deny that her voice is perfect
Got to say though liking the films got to say abba lasses are vocally better in my view but meryl did a good job
Everyone is picking their favorites but I can't choose!
Same
Because that's how talented both sides are
ABBAs voices are so smooth and distinguished nothing can beat them
I think you can’t compare them, the settings are completely different. The most people listen to the music while they are looking to the movie.
Maurice Hollink also the quality of the sound isn't the same. we're comparing songs from the 70's with their 21st century version, 30/40 years make a difference
Also; especially for the ones like Honey, Honey, it's one vs. multiple, so it's got a different feel
Although for ones like SOS or Our Last Summer, of course it's going to be ABBA, because they can sing and the guys (especially Pierce) can't
Without abba mamma mia wouldn’t exist, so abba automatically wins. But I still love mamma Mia
I know but they mean who sang it better. The Mamma Mia cast or Abba.
Tamara Leitch I prefer mamma Mia honestly but we all have different opinions.
A same I personally like ABBA better but yeah we grew up differently and we all have different opinions.
You also have to realize, a lot of lyrics were changed for Mama Mia to fit the story, and why some songs were cut from the movie as well. Mama Mia: Here We Go Again has a lot of lyric changes with some of the biggest being "I've Been Waiting for You", "My Love, My Life". But it's was fun to see "Money! Money! Money!" mimic the old video.
agree i think mamma mia but without abba no mamma mia
The only song that for some reason I prefer Mamma Mia's version is Honey Honey, but the rest ABBA is legendary!
same...I appreciate the quality and crispness (if that makes sense) of the movie. But the original is too iconic to vote against
Even the winner takes it all?
Right and the lay all your love on me
The only one I’m so confused on is Money, Money, Money
@@nadiamontenegro8723I mean that song is based off a divorce one of the band members was going through so kinda problematic 😬
Personally, for some songs, Mamma Mia is better, but for others, Abba all the way.
Example: Our last summer sounds better in Mamma Mia than the Abba, and i think thats due to the male leads with the song. Same for Lay all your love on me, the Male lead in that fits the tune better.
But, songs like Money Money Money or Super Trouper sounds a ton better with Abba than Mamma Mia.
Of course, Mamma Mia introduced me into Abba in the first place, but some things sound better with the movie and others with the original, so really its all preference and opinion in the end
Our Last Summer ABBA is so much better than Mamma Mia
Our Last Summer was written for a female to sing. What you hear in Mamma Mia is a shortened version of the original song. It skips the first two verses, one of which contains the line 'And I smiled like Mona Lisa', not something a man would sing. Both versions have the classic ABBA arrangements courtesy of Benny/Bjorn. It's simply the quality of the singing that is the absolute deal-breaker. The ABBA original has got soaring vocals and angelic harmonies. Something Pierce and Colin never had a hope in matching. Fine whilst watching the film but without the visuals, it's just a couple of blokes doing a passable karaoke effort.
Ghostgirl 708 ya same
Ghostgirl is
Ghostgirl 708 I agree
It actually shocks me that people think mamma Mia is better, like don’t get me wrong, the people in mamma Mia did great ... FOR ACTORS!
I mean Abbas vocals are just incredible compared to mamma Mia.
And yet people still think mamma Mia’s is better
I actually prefer Meryl's voice
Yes, professional singing with nicely layered harmonies and musical compositions that took so much time and effort that brings such a satisfying taste to anyone’s mind.
The audio quality is better in general, I think. I prefer when I hear the voices strong and clear
(Also the disco is really in your face with ABBA)
I wonder if it’s a matter of people preferring the movie because they didn’t grow up with the originals. My kids prefer the movie, I generally prefer ABBA.
Hippopotamus Life Meryl Streep’s version of TWTIA beats every other version. so heartbreaking
I'm used to the Abba versions. I always liked older music growing up in the 90s. I have Abbas greatest hits album on vinyl. I'm glad their music was popular enough for this movie to be made, now many high school drama clubs are performing MamaMia
In the band "Abba" you can hear that they have "harmonious voices" together. Of course, I choose ABBA, but I really like the movie Mamma Mia. I am sorry if I wrote something wrong, but I come from Poland and my English is not good. Regards!
Your English is very good for a Polish person
Oo Polaczki 😂❤️
ABBA. Nothing beats them. Why is this even a question?...
I like mamma Mia more it sounds better thats why its a que3
Question
I just like mamma Mia more because I’m used to that version
exactly
Sammmeeeeeee
Red Boah Sutherland yeah but I didn’t even knew it was Abbas music when I watched the movie but after watching it 10 times I started listening to ABBA to and I’m used to both now
Same, but the complete opposite
Same
Honey Honey - MAMMA MIA WINS
Dancing Queen - ABBA WINS
Super Trouper - MAMMA MIA WINS
Our Last Summer - ABBA WINS
Money, Money, Money - THEY BOTH WIN
SOS - THEY BOTH WIN
Does your mother know? - MAMMA MIA WINS
Mamma Mia - MAMMA MIA WINS
Lay all your love on me - ABBA WINS
Take a chance on me - ABBA WINS
Gimme gimme gimme - ABBA WINS
Abba wins every one of them, no question
Amanda's version in Gimme Gimme Gimme, is great, and the original too, oh my, this is hard to choose
Sorry, ABBA wins every time.
Wrong answer.The right one is All songs-ABBA wins.
I honestly think ABBA is better. To be fair though most of the time the original is better
And don’t get me wrong all the cast in mamma Mia are incredible, it’s like one of my favourite films! Xx
I think the MAMMA MIA version are better cuse im just used to hear the cast of MAMMA MIA singin the songs i mean ive been watching MAMMA MIA since i was 2 years old
Well Im an Prof . Guit.Player - AND The todays filmsoundand recording
teknic`z does a lot for the superb Mamma Mia Actors . AND the quality of the Swedish Supergroup ABBA `s Music is so good that it is like borrowing the music from MOTZART ! The music is SO GOOD you cant Miss
- BUT PEOPLES PEOPLE - LISTEN to " " ABBA LIVE at WEMBLEY
ARENA in LONDON 1979 ( on UA-cam HD versions ) Start whit
"SUMMERNIGHT CITY and "GIMME GIMME GIMME ( Agnetha Fältskogh and Anni
Frid Lyngstad ) "DOES YOUR MOTHER KNOW and HOLE in YOUR SOUL and
- CHIQUTITA - Then You will hear the DIFFERENCE betwin ACTORS
and The SUPERSTARS of ABBA ( and if you dont hear the differrance WELL
then you are Tone deff -
Well ABBA is is The Fabolous Four Swedish POP STARS a SUPERGROUP - Actors are Actors It Is like to compare Motzart / Bethoven whit an choir who sings Motzart eller Bethovens Music
yess same, Mamma Mia is my hole childhood ❤
Samee
Hannah Doherty I’m 16 😂😂😂
ABBA’s harmonies are the best
So true😍😍😍😍
Mamma Mia wins!
The three Leafs without ABBA Mamma Mia wouldn't be here
The three Leafs I still like it but yeah ABBA still has better harmonies.
Gemma Corrigan that’s cute you think mamma Mia is better. But also it’s the truth. You probably can’t take it.
No one can sing ABBA songs like ABBA. I have all their albums including anniversary versions, even 45RPMs.
Larry Ferguson that’s really cool! I have a couple of their greatest hits albums. I’m on the search for more lps
I can't understand people that believe to sing like ABBA🤔....
NOBODY NEVER can reach again ABBA's harmonies! When i watch Mamma Mia i feel 😬😬
Larry Ferguson I actually can sing like abba I have agnetha's voice
Emmaischoir_ girl, hmmmm are you Linda Ulvaeus by chance??
Ok
mamma mia cast its PERFECT, but not even to as good as the originals. please!
The originals are always the best, but they did a great job recreating the songs
Both are beautiful, ABBA's voices are so clear and pure.
It amazes me how the songs work so well with the musical storyline. It’s like ABBA was writing a musical all along
you realize the movie was written for the music, right?
Elaine Marten yes I know but I just believe that the songs work very well with the story line. Just because the movie was wetter for the music doesn’t mean it’s going to be good
Is it bad that I like the mamma Mia version better than abba?
gallopgirl same don’t worry
Me too don't worry 🤣🤣😁
Yes terrible
Yes
You like what makes you feel good. But it is obvious that all of the talent is in ABBA
To Me, There's No Comparison, Their "Both" Fantastic as The Song's 🎶 They All Sing.. Though This is My Opinion.. Not Everyone, Will Agree With Me!
Without ABBA mama Mia never exists. TEAM ABBA! Nobody van beat ABBA!
Not even close! ABBA rules!
minecraftlover123 I like mama Mia better
@@MaddLeInu i agree
ABBA is the best!
Mamma Mia versions of songs sounds so alive and they're very energic. And also more happy.
I"ll stick to Mamma Mia.
Michele JL they sound over the top and the songs don’t fit into musicals
@@Potjenjks2988
So, do Slipping Through My Fingers, Money Money, Mamma Mia, Chiquitita, Does Your Mother Know, and Honey Honey just go over your head or...?
Guys you don’t have to fight we’re entitled to our own opinions. People like different things, it’s one of the great things that make humans unique. We have different understandings of things depending on when your born, where you from etc.
Same
Saaame, finally somebody with good hearing! Thanks
I honestly prefer mamma Mia. Especially Meryl's voice. I love her motherly voice. She's talented at everything.
What about Cher.
@@gracepuckett9653 she's overrated
YEP
SAAME
Well Im an Prof . Guit.Player - AND the todays filmsoundand recording teknic`z does a lot for the superb Mamma Mia Actors and it`s the same as you lend the Music from MOTZAR ! The music is SO GOOD you cant Miss - BUT PEOPLES PEOPLE - LISTEN to " " ABBA LIVE at WEMBLEY ARENA in LONDON 1979 ( on UA-cam HD versions ) Start whit "SUMMERNIGHT CITY and "GIMME GIMME GIMME ( Agnetha Fältskogh and Anni Frid Lyngstad ) "DOES YOUR MOTHER KNOW and HOLE in YOUR SOUL and - CHIQUTITA - Then You will hear the DIFFERENCE betwin ACTORS and The SUPERSTARS of ABBA ( and if you dont hear the differrance WELL then you are Tone deff -
If it weren't for ABBA there would be no movie and those songs wouldn't exist
I honestly can’t choose I’m a huge fan of both hmm I’m gonna ask my nana also which she prefers cause she likes both two
Yesiloveyoumonty ti
ABBA definitely I'm a huge ABBA fan
Nikdo , nikdy nedokáže být kepší než ABBA. Byly, jsou, a navždy budou jedineční a dokonalí, jsou to geniální umělci. Díky jim.
They’re both great, but without ABBA there wouldn’t be Mamma Mia! plus Björn Ulvaeus and Benny Andersson from ABBA composed all the music in the film.
Lulu Lulu i think it would exist only with a diferent soundtrack
ABBA won This fight, but Meryl voice is great.
In music, it's hard to improve upon the original.
BOTH VERSIONS ARE NICE!! I like the movie and the band.
Seriously we’re fighting about this? Why can’t fans get along. Benny Anderson and Björn Ulvaeus from ABBA worked in this movie. Both sound great, I prefer ABBA so I think it is the slightest bit better except for honey, honey. We grew up with different lifestyles so why can’t one like one and the other group like the other version. Mamma Mia wouldn’t be here without ABBA but Mamma Mia isn’t bad. ABBA is forever.
nobody is fighting.
People in the comments are fighting about their opinions and which one is better.
@@ethanethan2060 people are free to assert one or the other, and even disagree, that is not "fighting".
Mark Johnson then why are people cursing at each other.
Ethan Ethan because humans are stupid
I honestly don't even know what I would've done if this didn't pop up in my recommended!
I love abba
I love their music with all my heart.
Thanks to their songs, I feel comforted when I was depressed.
I am grateful that their songs exist in this world.
Abba is UNBEATABLE!!! 😜😍😍💓💓
The psychology of which is better depending on what was heard first is interesting. It seems like people don’t want to betray that moment of joy in their life.
ABBA because mamma Mia wouldn’t be there without abba
Treble Bass omg stop no one cares about that. the whole thing is about what sounds better
OMG THATS NOT THE POINT!!!!! It’s which one sounds BETTER
So true 🇨🇮
Bjorn and Benny were both there training all of them, so of course they were excellent!
I grew up listening to ABBA in my grandmas car and they have always been one of my favorite bands, mama Mia and mama Mia 2 are also my daughters favorite movies and now that my grandma is gone listening to ABBA brings me back to special times in my childhood with her and I love that .
It’s simple
Without ABBA there would be no Mamma Mia
But I like Mamma Mias version better
Aesthetic Tutor me too
Same
I disagree, but respect your opinion :)
I was just about to like your comment then read the last line 😂
Artist Cove. But it makes literal sense how is it an opinion. We’d probably have a different version of mamma Mia obviously not with same songs
Hoping the ABBA television special will hit the air before the end of 2019. ABBA is my all time most favorite group.
Mamma mia und ABBA sind einfach nur spitze und zeitlos
As much as I love ABBA's originals the best, Mamma Mia 1 and 2 did a great job with their songs. Although the versions are different from ABBA, they retained the most of the originality of the tunes and the emotion. The only differences were the voices. Because of that, not only is ABBA a classic, so is Mamma Mia 1 and 2. As for the A-teens 20 years ago, they were called ABBA Teens. They made new versions of some of ABBA's songs, however they were not so great. Never mind the different voices, they took off a lot of the emotions of the ABBA songs and added too much remixed tunes and a little too wild and too much screaming and the songs that were supposed to be sad melodic emotional ABBA songs, they changed up the tunes so much that they sounded like people were supposed to be happy over these sad story lines. Our Last Summer was the only ABBA song that the A-Teens made that kept the original feeling. A-teens were only a short famed pop group and everyone forgot about them. They were not very classic and their popularity went out the window very quick.
supertrouper ironic your name is super trouper
it can only be Abba. the movie is fun, the songs are good but they don't have good voice such as Agnetha & Frida. Nobody sing ABBA like ABBA. you can't compare.
Meryl is one of her kind! She’s fantastic! Both her and Amanda did really good job and sang well!
Amanda Seyfried is amazing but besides that, none of the Mamma Mia versions come even close to ABBA. Mamma Mia is more like karaoke.
Chloe Price preachhh
thank youuuuu
Chloe Price yep basicly a karaoke musical
All of the movie songs should have been sung by Amanda Seyfried, among the movie singers she's the only one who can be equally compared to Abba both in term of musical quality and emotion ...
I love ABBA because you can slightly hear their accent when they’re singing and it changes everything, plus they’re harmonies, I still love mamma Mia though
Tolles Video, danke dafür. Hätte auch nix dagegen gehabt, wenn es länger wäre.
Vor dem Film hätte ich nicht gedacht, dass James Bond und Dr Selvik so gut singen können.
I agree with these, but in mamma 2 there is 'my love, my life' at the end and its just amazing.
lila rogerina!! 😂
Did anyone else notice how the Mamma Mia clips are like a key higher than they are supposed to be or is that just me?
Theyre all so ICONIC in their own wayyyyy
ABBA's version are superior for the mere fact that the songs have been sung by professional singers rather than actors and actresses.
P. M. Exactly !!
Meryl and Amanda have been trained, though.
Ich finde persönlich am besten Mamma Mia 1 die Lieder am besten
I have to say for most of the songs I can like and appreciate both versions honestly for different reasons. The original ABBA songs have a very 70's feel and tone to them that feeds into the movie versions of the songs, but with a mostly up-tempo spike that lets the actors sing the songs in slightly their own way and have their voices carry the tune. I grew up in the 70's and listened to ABBA along with other bands at the time and I can remember thinking their music was pretty good and kind of easy to use as an escape from life at that time. Now that 2 movies have come out with their songs, it's a huge nostalgia trip for me to hear those songs again but with different voices and different production that made them alot more fun this time, especially in the movies. I also believe that Benny Anderson had a HUGE part in making sure the film was mostly faithful to the story it was trying to tell; and especially to the songs as they were spot on almost to the originals other than some modernization of instruments and production, and the new voices from the actors. I happened to like very much all of the actors singing their own parts in the songs for the most part, and I even loved hearing Pierce Brosnan singing his parts of songs despite the fact that he dosent have a very polished singing voice. Everyone in the cast seemed to be having a blast with the film and the music and that also makes me look favorably on the actors singing abilities. Overall I'm just going to have to say I love the ABBA songs, both from then and from now just for different reasons but they still give me feelings and goosebumps in all the right places.
I mean I love both but I also grew up watching mama Mia so I am going to have to say that! Though mama Mia would be nowhere without ABBA so it was a tough one!!
ABBA definitely ❤👑
Huncwotka correct
Mamma mia but abba was good
Leah Rowlands and still is.
I...I can't choose one....
THEY'RE BOTH AMAZING
Honey Honey - Mamma Mia
Dancing Queen - ABBA
Super Trouper - ABBA
Our last Summer - ABBA
Money Money Money - Mamma Mia
SOS - ABBA
Does your mother know - Both
Mamma Mia - ABBA
Lay all your Love on me - Both
Take a chance on me - Mamma Mia
Gimme Gimme Gimme - ABBA
All abba
Mamma Mia is better for Take a Chance on Me? She was autotuned the whole time!
Really? I hated Mamma Mia’s Money Money Money. No energy at all
nintendolegoboy
She is old. Can’t help it. Like even me excited for their new two songs this year, I still can’t deny they’re going to enhance their voices one way or another.
I CANT CHOOSE UGH. I prefer the mama Mia our last summer if anything
soulmoonpages no singer can beat the original abba
There is no doubt that the 'Mamma Mia' stage musical and movies helped enormously in bringing ABBA's music to new generations. But it's a monster that should not overshadow its creator. That's why the 'Voyage' concerts are so brilliant. It's like the band taking back their songs and all the younger fans now seeing and feeling what this group were like at their peak.
actors did a good job but they weren't ABBA. No contest! Stay with the original.
I like Mama Mia, but my heart is still belongs to ABBA. 💝
I was in the era of ABBA, I know all their songs and have owned all their albums. I consider them one of the best artists EVER! The movie Mamma Mia was a tribute to them. Wow, one of the best ever! Thank you for this video!!!
I like both ABBA is my favorite group, and Mamma Mia is my favorite musical movie
Armino Lucas Randrup same with me Mamma Mia is my favorite movie and ABBA is my favorite band
Then there is me that hsm fanboy