OLD TRAFFORD MANCHESTER BUILDING BOOM | Construction, Demolition Hidden Stories

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 122

  • @tommyhannon4693
    @tommyhannon4693 20 днів тому +2

    Great video I used to live in Trafford park but all the houses were knocked down would be interesting to see whats there now and its history

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      Many thanks - Yes Trafford Park is an intereting case study, I'll have a think.

  • @AidanEyewitness
    @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +17

    This video took a bit longer to prepare than others and it's a little bit longer length at just over 14 minutes. As ever I look forward to your comments, many thanks for watching!

  • @extrude22
    @extrude22 27 днів тому +3

    I remember going for a job interview at the former British Gas building in 2010. Amazing how quickly things change.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому +1

      Very interesting, I think it looks very different inside today. I would never have imagined that a relatively modern building could just be abandoned like that.

  • @ians3586
    @ians3586 26 днів тому +1

    Great catch on "it's", it's a pet peeve of mine also. Thank you for objecting to the demolition of Trafford Town Hall. We still need modern day Sir John Betjemans to preserve our heritage. Good to hear that at least Ireland still has its railings. Good to see the cat at 13:35 waited for the train to pass before crossing. Interesting and Informative video!

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому +2

      Yes, I'm a linguist I write a lot, so I feel strongly about the apostrophe! Many thanks for your comments. I was walking up Falkner Street in Liverpool the other night and I noticed all the railings were there. That's because they were protecting a 10 foot drop down to basement level, so they were needed for safety. The houses are perfectly preserved from the 18th century. It would have been a crime to cut down the railings!

  • @vinimaguire8109
    @vinimaguire8109 Місяць тому +8

    Hi Aiden....Its Vini Maguire here from Australia you may remember I was one of your first subscribers in 1997 when we got in touch as I'm originally from Stretford. The BBC ended up coming to my home to interview me regarding how I logged on to your new ground breaking website "Eyewitness News" ...you ran a pub quiz competition which I think I won. Back in 1997 I was one of the first private individuals to use a dial up modem here in Australia to access the infancy of the World Wide Web or "Super Information Highway" to read the news back home in Manchester the UK. Great to see your still going strong with fantastic content on a fantastic subject....Manchester

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +3

      Oh yes, I remember you well, and it's great to hear from you. Yes, I kept documenting Manchester and also LIverpool. My archive photos are good insert into the new videos. Many thanks for contacting and hope to hear from you again. :)

  • @peterkavanagh1827
    @peterkavanagh1827 Місяць тому +1

    I live in Old Trafford. Great to learn about the area. It is doing okay for
    itself.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      It's great to hear from people who live in or ar from the area, I'm glad you liked the video - I am not from this area, I'm more from kind of general south Manchester / Stockport / south Trafford area. :) Many thanks for your comment.

  • @bizzlemedia
    @bizzlemedia Місяць тому +3

    I'm SO glad the all-seeing algorithm put this video in front of me this morning. Beautifully delivered in an articulate style, demystifying so many curiosities around the buildings I pass every day but know little about. I've lived in Manchester for nearly 3 years now since COVID, and I will never tire of peeling back layer after layer of history within this ever changing city. It's so bitter sweet, as I feel a lot of beautiful relics are falling fowl of the post-millenium planners, BUT the upshot is that new housing stock is being added to the pool, and the city is pulsating with optimism and investment. A great video sir, I look forward to the next one!

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Very glad to hear your comments and many thanks for your positive feedback. I write the script carefully and do a lot of research. After recording I do a lot of tidying up and editing. It's good to be able to put my local knowledge to use.

  • @LizThomas-gk9sb
    @LizThomas-gk9sb Місяць тому +5

    Fantastic video again. Thank you for taking the time to put so much into these videos. Keep up the amazing work! Can't wait for the next one.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      I'm very pleased to read your comment, very much appreciated and many thanks!

  • @KLGnation
    @KLGnation 10 днів тому

    I love how Yimby and pragmatic you are. These traits are severely lacking in people today who are negative about all development and don't like change.

  • @GeorgieGemmell-iw3lo
    @GeorgieGemmell-iw3lo Місяць тому +2

    My old stomping ground! I used live on Rye Bank Road in Firswood and walked to work at Exchange Quay. I thought way back in 2018/19 this is prime land for development. I figured it was just a matter of time and we'd soon see less of the industrial use. Great video and it was very nostalgic for me. I've long since moved away

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      That's great to hear, I really like to hear people talking about their own memories and connections with a place. My cricket fan friend told me the cricked ground wanted to buy the land where the Hardrock stood, but they couldn't afford it.

  • @GriffithsFfestiniog
    @GriffithsFfestiniog Місяць тому +1

    Really enjoyable video which took me back to my childhood. I was born in next to the football ground and lived and worked all around the area. So many memories my mother worked at Manchester United from 1956 for nearly fifty years and the club was an essential part of my life, still a Red through and through. I refer to myself as a Lancastrian from Stretford never a Mancunian, very interesting to see how the area has changed I moved away in 1975.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      That's fantastic, many thanks for your comment. I'm pleased that the video has been interesting to people from this area and that my information about county boundaries has struck a chord! A lot has changed since 1975, my last full year at school!

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      Many thanks for your positive feedback and thanks for sharing your thoughts and reminiscences, it's always great to hear about people's personal connections to buildings and districts. Lancaster, I think I've said enough about that for now!

  • @mattrea9088
    @mattrea9088 Місяць тому +3

    Great video. Can confirm all traditional brickwork on the buildings. Ordsall lane has changed so much in the last year also just down the road. I'm currently working near Salford university which is also on the change and worth a visit ☺️

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +2

      Many thanks for your comment and info about the brickwork. Ordsall Lane, that's on my 'to do' list, there is a big new residential block under construction there. And a modern building in Salford Uni is to be demolished. Must capture that.

  • @Kenners.
    @Kenners. Місяць тому +1

    Another fantastic video Aidan. Gorse hill in Stretford is my old stomping ground, i lived there from early 70s to mid 00s. lots of great memories back then sneaking in to LCCC to watch the Cricket in the 80s and working in Trafford Park. i used to live next to the B&Q, but too young to remember the concert venue. keep up the great work, a coffee is on the way, ;)

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      Many thanks for your positive feedback and many many thanks for buying me a coffee. It's of practical use and gives me great encouragment. Plenty more videos are in planning.

  • @AndrewKylie86
    @AndrewKylie86 Місяць тому +2

    Mate I’m from Ancoats
    Your videos are mint
    I watch them all
    There good mate 😎

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +2

      i'm very pleased to hear that, I'm really glad you like all my videos and thanks for posting the comment, I really appreciate it!

  • @paulmason6474
    @paulmason6474 Місяць тому +2

    Another informative video thank you well done😊

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Many thanks, your comment is very much appreciated!

  • @yosefkorn
    @yosefkorn Місяць тому +3

    When you take the tram between Deansgate and cornbrook, and you look out of the widow, there is so many buildings going up. It's hard to focus on what's what.
    These new neighbourhoods are relatively attractive to look at when walking around.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      Yes, there is a great vista over the ship canal and Salford. There are lots of new buildings under construction. Many thanks for your comment!

  • @Lord_Liverpool
    @Lord_Liverpool Місяць тому +1

    I see AidanEyewitness on my notifications. I immediately click on the video!

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Very good to hear that and I'm sure UA-cam picks that up as well. Thank you for your feedback and your great comments!

  • @davidjb-750
    @davidjb-750 Місяць тому +2

    Used to work at Oakland House many years ago. Sad to see the old entrance to the botanical gardens in such a state. Was always pleased that they kept it despite the many changes that’s happened on that site. Hard to believe there was once a lake there.
    Talking about Old Trafford not being in Manchester, Old Trafford football ground is actually in Gorse Hill…😊

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      I didn't know that the stadium is in Gorse Hill. It's great to hear your impressions as someone who has worked in this area. Many thanks

  • @StephenPritchard-f9j
    @StephenPritchard-f9j Місяць тому +1

    fantastic video love when new ones come along ❤

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      Many thanks, that's great, it really encourages me!

  • @markfaz8689
    @markfaz8689 Місяць тому

    Awesome video, a lot of history you covered from my neck of the woods 👍 Thanks

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому +1

      Many thanks for your comment, much appreciated!

  • @georgeedwards4807
    @georgeedwards4807 Місяць тому +1

    I've got the Now and Then Book ! It's great 👍

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Is that the Manchester United Then and Now booK? I also did the 'now' photos for Manchester Then and Now and Liverpool Then and Now, all out of print unfortunately.

  • @UnbelievableEricthegiraffe
    @UnbelievableEricthegiraffe Місяць тому +1

    Is that why there is a Metrolink station a few stops down the line towards Sale called Dane road?.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому +1

      Yes, it was previously a British Rail station and unlike Old Trafford Metrolink stop, it kept its original name of Dane Road.

  • @watcherzero5256
    @watcherzero5256 Місяць тому +1

    The Red Routes are in a few places in Greater Manchester (Trafford has the red lines installed this year, while Bury and Wigan have had the red bus lanes for many years that allow other traffic outside certain daytime hours) but they are at the moment considering a mass roll out of Red Routes in GM. The main place you see red routes is London, I don't think you find them in many other parts of the country, Coventry a couple of months ago decided to roll them out after a consultation (mainly covering the Coventry Very Light Rail Route and a few neighbouring roads).

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      Many thanks for this information. I always associate red double yellow lines with London. I don't know of any in other parts of Greater Manchester.

    • @johnburns4017
      @johnburns4017 11 днів тому

      @@AidanEyewitness
      There are also red route single lines, which have more restricted conditions than single yellow.

  • @apunkman
    @apunkman Місяць тому

    I used to go to the Hardrock & Village, I remember Bowling Alley there, once went to the village night club, years later, Slade played there too! Also stock car racing at White City. I lived close to Ayres Road next to Seymour Park. Went to the Carlton club in Whally Range. I worked at Old Trafford Cricket Ground as a kid serving tea and selling ice creams 15p an hour In 1972. I have driven down Ayes road It’s a shame the place looks so neglected and run down these days.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      That's fantastic, I love hearing about people describing their familiar area from a long time ago. It's important that we don't forget how it was. Very different to today. 15p an hour - that's very interesting! A concert ticket to the Hardrock was £1.50. How times have changed!

  • @footballfanar9717
    @footballfanar9717 Місяць тому

    The modern Lancashire map at 4:23 must be inaccurate as Blackburn is part of modern day Lancashire

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      No, it's correct. I have followed the red dotted line as given on the Google map which marks the current boundary of the Lancashire County Council area. Blackburn with Darwen is a unitary authority that isn't part of Lancashire County Council, along with Blackpool. There is the 'ceremonial' county of Lancashire, that's the one created in 1974 but since then those two areas left it. So you could say there are three Lancashires - the original one, the ceremonial county set up in 1974 and the current Lancashire County Council area. When you drive out of Blackpool past Starr Gate at the south end of the promenade, you'll see a sign saying 'Welcome to Lancashire'. Many thanks for your comment

  • @johnburns4017
    @johnburns4017 11 днів тому

    Was that British Gas building called _Watson House?_

  • @hungbearlover
    @hungbearlover Місяць тому +1

    What’s the electronics tune at the 3 minute

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      Normally I write down the tracks I use but unfortunately not this one and I can't find it! It's from the UA-cam Audio Library. I'll keep looking out for it and comment again when I find it!

  • @johnburns4017
    @johnburns4017 11 днів тому

    The actual City of Manchester *_is_* small as you pointed out Aiden - about the size of Leicester being 8th or 9th largest city in the UK. It happens that the metro county is called Greater Manchester, so all these towns are classed as being in 'Manchester'. However Wigan and Bolton take umbridge at being classed as being in _Manchester_ as they do have firm individual identities in their own right. It is like saying Southport is a part of Liverpool.
    BTW, I preferred the old name of _SELNEC_ to Gtr Manchester.

  • @paulwild3676
    @paulwild3676 Місяць тому +1

    The only Lancashire cricket club ground actually in current Lancashire, is in Lytham. All the others are now in Metro counties. Aigburth in Liverpool, Southport and Old Trafford are now no longer in Lancashire, yet Lancashire play at them.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      I didn't know that, many thanks for pointing it out.

  • @English_Dawn
    @English_Dawn Місяць тому +2

    Thank you for your film.
    The area was once the Saxon "Stretford". However the Normans couldn't pronounce it and pronounced it as "Trafford".
    Trafford Hall dated back to those times.
    👉 Manchester Cricket Club played near Talbot Road and the de Trafford family, aping Crystal Palace, wanted an Arts Exhibition on the site.
    👉They offered MCC a new site on the site of an old racecourse 🐎. This then became Old Trafford Cricket Ground, the second oldest Test ground (after the Oval).
    👉Queen Victoria and Prince Albert arrived at Victoria Station before travelling by carriage over Victoria Bridge, which they also opened, before travelling to the Arts Exhibition site which, as you say, became later a Botanical Gardens then later a sports ground, England played New Zealand at Rugby Union there. 🏉
    Nearby, near Trafford Bar, is the famous Throstle Nest Junction named after The Throstle Nest Hotel near Henshaws Blind Institute which was a major landmark. The Mersey & Irwell Navigation Company in the 1700's built numerous locks including one near Henshaws Blind Academy.
    Later MSC kept the existing lock at Mode Wheel (near the BBC) but demolished the above lock.
    Throstle Nest Junction was the famous rail site where trains from London St. Pancras etc bifurcated on the Midland Railway, going right to Mcr Central and left to Liverpool Central.
    👉So many building projects pass planning permission then enter torpor. Devolpment is complicated, contracts need to be signed and money raised.
    One Heritage Salford is a case in point. It is a shame because it's one of the most elegant designs.
    The big boys, Renaker and Salboy are usually well organised and usually have their ducks in row.
    So hopefully One Heritage can jointly develop or sell to one of the big boys.
    👉 On Thursday planning was given for another residential tower in Piccadilly, at Sparkle Street.
    👉Planning permission isn't permanent it's time limited (I think usually 3 years) to give the developer time to get their act together or they have to reapply for planning permission.
    👉This brings us full circle to Park Place. Great Jackson Street Estates were given planning permission for two 56-storey towers but apparently went into torpor over a disagreement with the council. Long story short, peace has broken out and they have just signed a 106 Agreement, which resets it. They now have another three years to get boots on the ground or have to further apply.
    N. B. Brian Statham (pron. "Staytham" was a fast England and Lancashire County Cricket Club bowler that was a contemporary of Freddie Truman and operated in tandem with him for England.
    👉 Kellogs has famously been associated with the area and was one of the last regular commercial users of Hulme Locks.
    👉Jim Ratcliffe has big plans and hopes to get goverment money for the £2b project.
    👉For-the-record the Freightliner depot had previously being Trafford Park Shed, the motive power depot of Manchester Central. It's associated carriage sidings were at Cornbrook which became an industrial estate and road.
    Utd's previous ground was Bank Street (Their second ground). It is now the location of the Velodrome near City's ground and where they changed their name from Newton Heath and their colours from green and yellow halves.
    Last Tuesday, early morning, City lifted the frame of a new landmark, the SkyBar into position on the extended Family Stand. Aesthetically in a different league to the proposed Old Trafford stadium.
    Much obliged for the film. 😀

    • @watcherzero5256
      @watcherzero5256 Місяць тому

      History is a bit off, the name predated the Normans. The family and the their holdings including the hall was actually established after Cnut Viking conquest of the area in 1016, after the Norman conquest in 1066 they changed their family name to the De Traffords to blend into Norman society.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Very interesting information, I wasn't aware of that. Many thanks!

    • @SirFlashman-zv7ue
      @SirFlashman-zv7ue Місяць тому

      Nobody's seen the proposed new United ground because it's not been designed yet. The only model was part of a massing plan for the whole Old Trafford area, not an actual design of the stadium.

    • @johnburns4017
      @johnburns4017 10 днів тому

      _"Jim Ratcliffe has big plans and hopes to get government money for the £2b project"_
      High hopes I would assume. HMG is unlikely to dole out money to former Tory supporting Ratcliffe. Also concerns from other regions would emerge. One of HMGs prime focuses for public money is getting energy bills down by solar, wind, batteries and pumped water - and energy independence. Reeves has said that Energy is priority for money for HS2, ditching any HS2, or HS2 light expansion. Her priority is not giving money to demolish a perfectly good stadium for another.

  • @jacquijohncartman49
    @jacquijohncartman49 Місяць тому +6

    Brian Statham is pronounced as if it were spelled "Staytham".

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Many thanks for pointing this out. I've added an apology in a linked short video, with the correct pronunciation.

    • @johnwalker6736
      @johnwalker6736 Місяць тому

      Well done,Aidan…….Brian Statham was a fast(ish) bowler for LCCC as well as England.

  • @youngmurphy7556
    @youngmurphy7556 Місяць тому

    I did my YTS in that abandoned building just after it was built. It was the HQ for Norweb who later merged with North West Water to become United Utilities. In fact, working with the electricians I got right inside that building, inside the huge aircon on the top and under the false floors. They say the shape was meant to represent the old NW logo of Norweb from above. I find this only slightly plausible.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      That's very interseting. Ah yes, Norweb, later UU. I really find it interesting to hear from people who have worked in or on a building. Designed to look like the Norweb logo? Hmm, not sure about that!

    • @youngmurphy7556
      @youngmurphy7556 Місяць тому

      @AidanEyewitness That's just what the full time maintenance team said to me. Google "norweb 1980s Preston" in image search and you should get a shop front with the old logo. If you look at the building on Google maps above the entrance, you'll see a zig-zag edge. That's supposed to be taken from the logo. Possible but not completely convincing to me.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому +1

      Fascinating, I'll have a look at that!

  • @nicolasnicolas3218
    @nicolasnicolas3218 Місяць тому +1

    As Manchester United fan, I’m finally really pleased to watch a video where you talk about OT and Man Utd. 🏟️💪

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      Regarding football I am neutral. The topic came up because of the big construction plans announced recently. Looks like I'll have to do one on east Manchester and Sportcity, to keep the other lot happy! Glad you liked the video!

  • @rinkydinkmcruk
    @rinkydinkmcruk Місяць тому +5

    If Westminster is in London then old Trafford is in Manchester

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      @@rinkydinkmcruk i agree!

    • @WS_UK
      @WS_UK 28 днів тому +1

      @@AidanEyewitness So do I. If it’s good enough for (Greater) London then it’s good enough for (Greater) Manchester. If Greater Manchester wishes to sell itself as one ‘City’ then so be it…
      I say this as a born Brummie.

  • @johnburns4017
    @johnburns4017 11 днів тому

    Man Us stadium is supposed to be built next door on the rail freight terminal, which is supposed to be moving to a superior location in the Liverpool City Region next door with better access to main rail lines and Liverpool's port by motorway and rail. The idea is the rail terminal moves, the site is cleared, then the stadium is built on the same site, then OT is demolished. This will take many years in the future to see completion of a new stadium as the new rail terminal at Parkside has to be built first. There is no imminent construction.
    One suggestion was Man U to use the soon to be vacant Goodison Park, Everton's current ground, while the current stadium is renovated on the existing site - after all most of the structure is perfectly fine. Man U played home games at Everton just after WW2 due to Old Trafford being bombed, so there is a precedent.

  • @69Phuket
    @69Phuket Місяць тому +1

    Bowie does B&Q. Who's a thunk!

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +2

      It was a long time before the venue became a B&Q warehouse when David Bowie played there. I once went to a New Year party there, that was Dec 31 1974.

    • @69Phuket
      @69Phuket Місяць тому

      @@AidanEyewitness Was in New Moston at the time. St. Mary's Road. Bomb sites it was. Behind us was the Ferranti Factory and the security guy had pips on his lapel;, we didn't mess with him! But there was an old Women that my mates used to throw stones at as she bravely went to the corner shop. Shocking to witness. My Stepdad was a hippie escapee from Derbyshire. He had all the albums you could want to hear over the decades. Anyway I love local history. Thanks for replying. @'77' we located to Woodhouse Park. Wythenshawe. Yeah that was awesome...Lost all my friends. Became a lost soul in a council estate.

  • @watcherzero5256
    @watcherzero5256 Місяць тому +2

    13:35 brave kittie

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Sometimes I accidentally catch interesting individuals in my photos and videoclips, whether pussy cats or Manchester United legends!

  • @pippin9466
    @pippin9466 Місяць тому +1

    I thinl they ahould rebuild th hard rock concert theatre on the plot were B&Q used tp be.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      I don't think that will happen as we now have the Co-op Live on the other side of Manchester, where Paul McCartney played the other night and Paul Heaton is playing this evening. It's likely that a residential development will be built on the site. Many thanks for all your comments!

    • @pippin9466
      @pippin9466 12 днів тому

      @@AidanEyewitness you’re very very welcome

  • @mazinnasralla2036
    @mazinnasralla2036 29 днів тому +1

    If you argue, as you did, that a City's boundary is defined by the continuity of it's buildings then Salford should be subsumed within Manchester. This is an argument of convenience and it's not very convincing. Yes the City of Manchester is small. I like that Manchester is small. I can visit all aspects on foot unlike sprawling cities like London which I don't like much.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому +1

      The City of Manchester is not small and the city centre is also not small. It is expanding outwards and across the River Irwell into Salford. The districts of Greater Manchester already work together across boundaries under a Combined Authority. Please use the apostrophe correctly. Many thanks for your comment.

  • @youngmurphy7556
    @youngmurphy7556 Місяць тому +2

    "One if the most famous parts of Manchester isn't actually in Manchester"
    There are quite a few districts of the ancient parish of Manchester that are in the current admin boundaries of Manchester but weren't in the original municipal borough of Manchester. They ended up being part of Manchester at the whims of some bureaucrats. Other districts, e.g. Heaton Norris, Failsworth and Stretford, were left out. No one really quibbles about them not being Manchester just because they have a different coloured bin. And some bits of current Manchester (historically Cheshire) are nowhere near the city centre. OT is a stone's throw from the centre.
    It's like saying Parliament isn't in London because it's the City of Westminster, not City of London. Pointless comment.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +2

      Yes, all very good points. It's not boundaries that matter but urban development and transport links. Many thanks for sharing your thoughts, I agree totally.

  • @roverchap
    @roverchap Місяць тому +7

    That thing about civic boundaries in metropolitan areas gets very silly and parochial. Saying Old Trafford isn't in Manchester is the same as saying that Westminster Abbey and the Houses of Parliament aren't in London because they're in the City of Westminster, not the City of London.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +2

      That's right but a commenter was adamant that Manchester was only what was inside the city boundary. I think he was from Birmingham.

    • @stevenhoughton1406
      @stevenhoughton1406 Місяць тому

      But it's not in Manchester just like West Bromwich is not in Birmingham. We have boundaries for a reason.

    • @WS_UK
      @WS_UK 27 днів тому +1

      @@stevenhoughton1406 If it’s good enough for (Greater) London to sell itself as a ‘City’ , it’s good enough for (Greater) Manchester. That’s what MOST international Cities do (some like Birmingham don’t though). Council boundaries mean little to the world.
      West Bromwich may not be in the City of Birmingham but it’s definitely in Brum’s wider metropolitan area! That’s what matters to international businesses/travellers etc.
      WSUK, a born Brummie.

    • @stevenhoughton1406
      @stevenhoughton1406 25 днів тому

      @@WS_UK So by your logic the city of Wolverhampton and Coventry are part of Birmingham and Bolton and the city of Salford are part of Manchester. Lol

    • @WS_UK
      @WS_UK 24 дні тому

      @@stevenhoughton1406 Wolverhampton is part of the Birmingham Urban Area and both Coventry and Wolves are part of the Birmingham Metro Area. It’s up to the areas if they wish to sell themselves as one ‘City’, which is something London and Manchester do, which in turn is what many Cities around the World do.

  • @grahamtowers5513
    @grahamtowers5513 Місяць тому

    I live in Manchester which to me is Lancashire, when I was born it was Lancashire & to me it will always be Lancashire, I don't recognise it any other way and I never will

    • @footballfanar9717
      @footballfanar9717 Місяць тому

      You must be olden, but golden as Manchester hasn't been a part of Lancashire since the early/mid 70's.

    • @grahamtowers5513
      @grahamtowers5513 Місяць тому

      @@footballfanar9717 Born in 1957, I was here in 1974 when that happened, like the old saying, you can take the man out of Lancashire but you can't take Lancashire out of the man, all of my correspondence is with Lancashire as my county and always will be.

    • @grahamtowers5513
      @grahamtowers5513 Місяць тому +2

      @@footballfanar9717 The legislation that currently defines counties for the purposes of administration of local government is the Local Government Act 1972 (as amended by various Orders in the 1990s). This legislation abolished the previous administrative counties, which were established by the Local Government Act 1933. However, these Acts did not specifically abolish traditional counties, so traditional counties still exist, but no longer for the purpose of the administration of local government

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Correct.

  • @chrislethbridge1759
    @chrislethbridge1759 Місяць тому +4

    It always annoys me that the (very small) City and all its boroughs are always quoted for the population and geography of London, but the same principle is never applied to the country’s other major conurbations. Anyone might be forgiven for thinking there was an attempt to diminish the size and status of the regional metropolitan areas in relation to the capital…😂

    • @steveygee1
      @steveygee1 Місяць тому +1

      I wouldn’t say 600k people is small.

    • @chrislethbridge1759
      @chrislethbridge1759 Місяць тому +3

      @@steveygee1 I was referring there to the ‘municipal’ City of London which has a population of around 10k -which of course is crazy to take from its wider context.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      The difference is that the London Boroughs came together into one administrative unit, but Manchester and Liverpool and surrounding boroughs remained separate, though nowadays they work together under combined authorities.

  • @JohnnyZenith
    @JohnnyZenith Місяць тому

    I was going to bed. Now I'm forced to watch this. I forgive you. The stadium does need replacing. Greater Manchester is Manchester.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      I made it live at 3:45 in the afternoon, you had plenty of time to watch it!! It's okay, I forgive you! Many thanks for your thoughts as ever!

  • @youngmurphy7556
    @youngmurphy7556 Місяць тому

    That map with Blackburn not in the "new" Lancashire is seriously awful. By the way, Middlesex and Surrey don't have their main grounds in the county either. In fact, the county of Middlesex doesn't even exist. And Kent has one of its second grounds outside the county too. It's almost as if someone just redrew lines on a map with no regard for actual realities.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Yes, they should have left the original counties and created new administrative areas completely separate to them. Blackburn and Darwen and Blackpool left (new) Lancashire to become unitary authorities. Heading out of Blackpool you see signs saying 'Welcome to Lancashire'.

    • @youngmurphy7556
      @youngmurphy7556 Місяць тому +1

      @@AidanEyewitness I was commenting on the Google maps boundary. The one you used in the video. It doesn't show the actual boundary of current Lancashire. It shows the jurisdiction of Lancashire County Council, not the actual county.

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      Well, there are three Lancashires - the original county which dates back centuries, the one created in 1974, which is no longer significant for local government purposes, and Lancashire County Council, which came up in Google maps when I typed 'Lancashire'. It's confusing.

  • @woodcote103
    @woodcote103 25 днів тому

    With manchester united...over £700...million...pounds in debt....will the glazers and radcliffe cough up for a new stadium...or even refurbish the present stadium.?

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      I'm not the person to answer that question, but I think it's a valid question to ask.

  • @jasongray4517
    @jasongray4517 Місяць тому +2

    Build a new stadium by all means, but i see no reason why taxpayers should have to chip in. Jim Ratcliffe take note
    P.S I rather like the old British Gas building. I assume you believe it to be "unreusable" for safety reasons?

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому +1

      Yes, it's a nice building but my gut feeling is based on its size, the amount of money required to restore it and the fact the nice design probably wouldn't be considered good enough to save. There may also be toxic materials present. Maybe I'm wrong and it will be completely renovated, but I'd doubt it. We'll see.

    • @kenjoy7404
      @kenjoy7404 Місяць тому +1

      Taxpayers aren't "chipping in" for the stadium, only the infrastructure...

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  12 днів тому

      Thanks for the info.

  • @UnbelievableEricthegiraffe
    @UnbelievableEricthegiraffe Місяць тому

    I believe that the Old Trafford football ground has not been rebuilt. Utd should merge with either Altrincham FC or Trafford FC. No future for Manchester United 😮😊

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      I wouldn't know about that as I don't follow football, but many thanks for sharing your thoughts.

  • @RotiJohnPrata-h9o
    @RotiJohnPrata-h9o Місяць тому +3

    ManUre... at Old Tractor.. d'pub'clup is falling apart.... bring Ollie back...

    • @AidanEyewitness
      @AidanEyewitness  Місяць тому

      Many thanks for your comment!

    • @paul-ht7fq
      @paul-ht7fq Місяць тому

      WOW that was an embarrassing comment 😬

    • @RotiJohnPrata-h9o
      @RotiJohnPrata-h9o Місяць тому

      @@paul-ht7fq Olllieee.. rules, fruitcake.. back to work, your cousin's goat is haaangry..go