Israeli Holocaust Scholar Omer Bartov on Campus Protests, Weaponized Antisemitism, Silencing Dissent

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 кві 2024
  • Support our work: www.democracynow.org/donate?c...
    As Biden administration and U.S. college and university administrators increasingly accuse peaceful pro-Palestinian protesters on school campuses of antisemitism, we speak with Brown University professor of Holocaust and genocide studies Omer Bartov, who visited the student Gaza solidarity encampment at UPenn alongside fellow Israeli historian Raz Segal. "There was absolutely no sign of any violence, of any antisemitism at all," says Bartov, who warns antisemitism is being used to silence speech about Israel. "There's politics, and there's prejudice. And if we don't make a distinction between the two, then what we are actually doing is enforcing a kind of silence over the policies that have been conducted by the Israeli government for a long time that ultimately culminated now in the utter destruction of Gaza."
    Democracy Now! is an independent global news hour that airs on over 1,500 TV and radio stations Monday through Friday. Watch our livestream at democracynow.org Mondays to Fridays 8-9 a.m. ET.
    Subscribe to our Daily Email Digest: democracynow.org/subscribe

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,6 тис.

  • @Stop-and-listen
    @Stop-and-listen 16 днів тому +827

    “The biggest insult to the memory of the Holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to commit genocide against the Palestinian people.” - Norman Finkelstein

    • @LAFITZ10
      @LAFITZ10 16 днів тому

      who would have thought ISRAEL who RECEIVED a Genocide would next PERPETRATE IT - it's OBSCENE

    • @user-xu5vl5th9n
      @user-xu5vl5th9n 16 днів тому

      He is the one plundering the Holocaust for political purposes: to dehumanise Israelis and white-wash genocidal racists like Hamas.

    • @corysher
      @corysher 16 днів тому

      Nice quote from the biggest antisemite in this Century. Nice job. You condone a bigot.

    • @leilaoksanen5142
      @leilaoksanen5142 16 днів тому +9

    • @brazejan1
      @brazejan1 16 днів тому +9

      Yup so simple

  • @naziirani2773
    @naziirani2773 16 днів тому +378

    Respect to these Jewish scholars who stand up for humanity, defend Palestinian rights, and oppose genocide.

    • @larryfloyd5111
      @larryfloyd5111 16 днів тому

      Some of these scholars are "liberal Zionists" who are against the right of return of Palestinians.

    • @azalia423
      @azalia423 16 днів тому +6

      Absolutely!

    • @Tom-ym7bm
      @Tom-ym7bm 16 днів тому

      If only they spoke of God’s laws
      Love

    • @QUINTUSMAXIMUS
      @QUINTUSMAXIMUS 16 днів тому +1

      Raz Segal has called it a genocide. Bartov when asked maybe 4 months ago wouldn't say it was, but wouldn't say it wasn't. I think he respects Segal's opinion and is probably closer to his opinion by now.

    • @Tom-ym7bm
      @Tom-ym7bm 16 днів тому

      @@QUINTUSMAXIMUS America was a pro life culture until the 60s it took on the culture of death ( people are fooled thinking things are so forward thinking & benevolent & they’re making a difference)
      In the end, it’s not our opinion but God’s. He has told us how the world works. About life & death.
      Christianity works to redeem man! People have become so desensitized by movies including sex & violence. Help us reclaim the value of human life. God relies on our obedience. Our roots- our motto- Pro America - America 1st

  • @Lovewins0356
    @Lovewins0356 16 днів тому +500

    "Being Anti Zionist is Not being Antisemitic."

    • @user-wd5pb3up4r
      @user-wd5pb3up4r 16 днів тому

      Arabs are Semites. Ashkenazi jews - are not so.

    • @nosuchthing8
      @nosuchthing8 16 днів тому +21

      Yt banned me for a while because I DARED make that claim.

    • @valm9462
      @valm9462 16 днів тому

      Being Zionist is being Antisemitic

    • @LunarTikOfficial
      @LunarTikOfficial 16 днів тому

      *Maybe that loud mouth german was right about "them"..*

    • @spiritualpath8888
      @spiritualpath8888 16 днів тому

      @@nosuchthing8lol me too but now i say anti ge no ci dal ma ni acs

  • @emiliobello2538
    @emiliobello2538 16 днів тому +545

    No one should have to face a genocide

    • @PauloAdriano-zo2ng
      @PauloAdriano-zo2ng 16 днів тому +12

      When you purposefully leave a statement like that, you're leaving this comment section open to certain folks saying that what's happening in Gaza isn't genocide.
      So one must ask, was that your intention? 🤔
      Let's hope not.
      But you're correct, *No one should have to face genocide.*

    • @MA-sk4fg
      @MA-sk4fg 16 днів тому +3

      @@PauloAdriano-zo2ngso true!!!!

    • @sihammaalal-mh4ul
      @sihammaalal-mh4ul 16 днів тому +8

      Especially innocents 😇

    • @teresia748
      @teresia748 16 днів тому

      If you believe that then these students should stop calling for Death to America and Death to Israel

    • @meshzzizk
      @meshzzizk 16 днів тому +1

      what about people who chew with their mouths open

  • @Viper1924
    @Viper1924 16 днів тому +439

    The irony of these campuses complaining about illegal encampments being set up while supporting a colony who does exactly that in Palestine.

    • @KyleRuggles
      @KyleRuggles 16 днів тому +17

      HA! True!
      True true true!

    • @OneSixSun
      @OneSixSun 16 днів тому +9

      Yes.

    • @wyno2661
      @wyno2661 16 днів тому

      That's exactly what I have been saying for a while now! Noticed how all those politicians complaining about the illegal invasion from across the border, while sponsoring the same actions in another part of the world!

    • @oliveoil5789
      @oliveoil5789 16 днів тому

      If these encampments were peacefully protesting climate change you wouldn’t hear a peep from anyone.

    • @giuseppers1956
      @giuseppers1956 16 днів тому

      I guess they are giving America a small taste of what Israel is doing to Palestine!

  • @goldenwarrior5664
    @goldenwarrior5664 16 днів тому +398

    We need to call for Blinken to step down

    • @kouklepartali
      @kouklepartali 16 днів тому

      Because he is a Jew! Blinken, is a Jew.

    • @rational-public-discourse
      @rational-public-discourse 16 днів тому +9

      ok. We are calling for Blinken to step down.

    • @d0ntbeevil
      @d0ntbeevil 16 днів тому +33

      And tried for war crimes and crimes against humanity for aiding and abetting genocide.

    • @lindahaltam6535
      @lindahaltam6535 16 днів тому +2

      Why Blinken is just our relayer. The negotiations were moved from Qatar to Egypt last I heard.

    • @billytheadult6247
      @billytheadult6247 16 днів тому

      Blinken is a tool of a foreign government, not the US. This is clear for all to see. His actions speak louder than his vacuous words.

  • @mdshamimshamim7585
    @mdshamimshamim7585 16 днів тому +254

    Stop genocide. Save the humanity 😢 Historical protest by students ❤

    • @LunarTikOfficial
      @LunarTikOfficial 16 днів тому

      *Maybe that loud mouth german was right about "them"..*

    • @brazejan1
      @brazejan1 16 днів тому +2

      Your either on the right side or the wrong side of history so choose wisely...

    • @CallThemAllOut
      @CallThemAllOut 16 днів тому +3

      Very well said. Although, some have already chosen and refused to see anything that's taking place

    • @LunarTikOfficial
      @LunarTikOfficial 16 днів тому +7

      @@brazejan1 *I choose NO GENOCIDE*

    • @soheirkhattab5832
      @soheirkhattab5832 16 днів тому +4

      @@LunarTikOfficialgood for you .free Palestine 🇵🇸

  • @lydiamilanovic1761
    @lydiamilanovic1761 16 днів тому +337

    Many thanks to Omer Bartov for distinguishing between anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism. As a non-Jewish person, I felt guilty about speaking up against Israeli right wing Zionist policies. I'm relieved that these two terms are now being separated and that being an anti-Zionist is not at all the same as being anti-Semitic.

    • @MA-sk4fg
      @MA-sk4fg 16 днів тому

      Zionists know that. but they are weaponizing it to silence students and others who are outraged to witness the massacres.

    • @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
      @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings 16 днів тому +8

      Mind Begs the Question:
      - If a Semitic State
      - Engage in Genocide/Apartheid
      - To speak,act against it
      - Is Anti Semitic or Pro Freedom?

    • @may7127
      @may7127 16 днів тому

      Zionism was founded by Theodor Herzl in 1897 while Judaism was founded around or before 1800. B.C.
      That's when I learned that they arent the same.

    • @ErikWeinstein
      @ErikWeinstein 16 днів тому +2

      They always have been

    • @stevelarrosa4462
      @stevelarrosa4462 16 днів тому

      its called brainwashing, in history, movies Evil creeps up slowly but surely

  • @jackintosh
    @jackintosh 16 днів тому +292

    Thank you! Being against the genocidal actions of the government and military of Israel is not antisemitism.

    • @LunarTikOfficial
      @LunarTikOfficial 16 днів тому

      *Maybe that loud mouth german was right about "them"..*

    • @keesvan52
      @keesvan52 16 днів тому

      Calling the actions of the government and military of Israel "genocidal actions" is antisemitism.

    • @bostonphotographer20
      @bostonphotographer20 16 днів тому

      There is no genocide in Gaza. It's a war. There is genocide in Sudan and ethnic cleansing in Pakistan, but you don't care about that, do you?

    • @kwokeva
      @kwokeva 16 днів тому

      They pro hamas

    • @jackintosh
      @jackintosh 16 днів тому +7

      @@kwokeva being against Israeli genocide does not equate to support terrorism

  • @Motorfreek1969
    @Motorfreek1969 16 днів тому +197

    In 2008, Professor Norman Finkelstein, who comes from a family deeply impacted by the Holocaust, was deeply outraged by what he saw as feigned sorrow or "crocodile tears" from a student at Case Western University in Cleveland, Ohio.

    Finkelstein's father was an Auschwitz survivor, while his mother survived the Warsaw Ghetto and Majdanek concentration camp. Having experienced significant loss within his family during the Nazi Holocaust, he was infuriated when confronted by a Jewish student questioning his pro-Palestinian stance.

    He said: "I don't respect the crocodile tears - if you had any heart in you, you would be crying for the Palestinians.

    • @sajidpatel2705
      @sajidpatel2705 16 днів тому

      That was an epic response by Dr. Finkelstein to those brainwashed indoctrinated young pro - Israeli Jews.

    • @hagnuj1070
      @hagnuj1070 16 днів тому +8

      They cornered the market of sympathy.

    • @mytboss
      @mytboss 16 днів тому +7

      Permission to use/share your comment, please...

    • @talppp
      @talppp 16 днів тому +3

      Fink is one of the more famous anti semantic professors!

    • @celestesmith6060
      @celestesmith6060 16 днів тому +24

      @@talppp Except he's not anti-semitic. He opposes the Israeli government's treatment of Palestinians.

  • @mikiafu
    @mikiafu 16 днів тому +101

    Stop the genocide in Sudan

    • @HughJass-jv2lt
      @HughJass-jv2lt 16 днів тому +8

      Yep!!!!!!
      DIVEST U.S. TAX DOLLARS.

    • @greatmahatmagandhi4713
      @greatmahatmagandhi4713 16 днів тому +8

      Free free Palestine 🇵🇸

    • @greatmahatmagandhi4713
      @greatmahatmagandhi4713 16 днів тому

      Stop our tax dollars for genocide

    • @mimi-ur8pc
      @mimi-ur8pc 16 днів тому +3

      @@greatmahatmagandhi4713 Your own people in Jordan and Egypt don't want to take you into their country. I wonder why?

    • @ScreenNameLoretta
      @ScreenNameLoretta 16 днів тому +5

      ​@@mimi-ur8pc -- Nice little ad-hominem attack you did on that other person.

  • @user-pf7tf3rf1u
    @user-pf7tf3rf1u 16 днів тому +52

    I also visited twice as a citizen of Philadelphia and brought food to the protesters at UPenn. They were nice kids on the right side of history. These kids care about what is happening to Palestinians. Our politicians and donors are really being cruel slandering these kids.

    • @gregkle9384
      @gregkle9384 16 днів тому

      @user do they care what is happening in Ukraine,Syria,Africa etc were people have been killed in hundreds of thousands? Of course not,no Jews involved.Young antisemites,sorry jew haters

    • @meloneypullen8746
      @meloneypullen8746 9 днів тому +3

      ❤❤

  • @sansoe21
    @sansoe21 16 днів тому +131

    people just forgot arabian is semitic too

    • @celieneohara521
      @celieneohara521 16 днів тому +16

      I have been saying that for months!!!

    • @ErikWeinstein
      @ErikWeinstein 16 днів тому +2

      ​@@celieneohara521hedgehogs aren't hogs. Why aren't people constantly talking about that

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому +18

      ​@@ErikWeinsteinAre you confused dear?

    • @eudyptes5046
      @eudyptes5046 16 днів тому +12

      More to the point, the term semitic is obsolete. Neither Judaism nor Islam are ethnic entities, they are religions.

    • @stevesmith291
      @stevesmith291 16 днів тому +5

      @@eudyptes5046 Hebrew and Arabic are Semitic languages, from the purported descemt of their peoples from Shem, the sone of Noah.
      Also, religion is often one of the factors that defines an ethnicity.

  • @arabicsahlonmsa5303
    @arabicsahlonmsa5303 16 днів тому +62

    Ban AIPAC. Keep money for American FAMILIES in Need

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому

      Not ONLY AIPAC but ALL Zionist influence on our government institutions. ENOUGH.

    • @tzadiko
      @tzadiko 16 днів тому

      So can we ban Arab lobbying groups too?

  • @alvinmitchell1412
    @alvinmitchell1412 16 днів тому +84

    Dr.Martin Luther King Jr.-Injustice Anywhere is a Threat to Justice Everywhere

    • @stonecoldhitman7662
      @stonecoldhitman7662 16 днів тому +2

      TRUTH

    • @sheilamacdougal4874
      @sheilamacdougal4874 11 днів тому

      MLK: "The whole world must see that Israel must exist and has the right to exist and is one of the great outposts of democracy in the world”.

  • @Benshafran
    @Benshafran 16 днів тому +90

    I am Jewish and live in Tel Aviv, ANTI ZIONIST IS NOT ANTI SEMITIC and also DOES NOT MAKE YOU A KAPOS. FREE PALESTINE..!!

    • @gabrielleangelica1977
      @gabrielleangelica1977 16 днів тому +2

      Baruch Hashem! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord.

    • @yevgenigerchikov9830
      @yevgenigerchikov9830 16 днів тому

      If you live on stolen land, you are a Zionist. Tel Aviv is land stolen from the Palestinians, just like Gaza.

    • @simpleman5541
      @simpleman5541 16 днів тому

      I wonder what percentage of Jewish is like you.

    • @mimi-ur8pc
      @mimi-ur8pc 16 днів тому

      Do you know the history of The Muslim Brotherhood who is funding Hamas? They have not changed! They were NAZIs and Hitler's close friends and allies and they are Obama's close friends and allies.

    • @ChrisCresta-hs8cz
      @ChrisCresta-hs8cz 15 днів тому

      Thank you, we need more Jewish people like you. I find myself hating Jewish people because of what the government of Israel is doing. Honestly if what is happening in Gaza was being done to Jews or any other race my hatred of the people doing it would be exactly the same. Netanyahu is just making worse for his own people by carrying out this genocide.

  • @guldenakdemir2493
    @guldenakdemir2493 16 днів тому +33

    Wake up folks, we have NEVER been a democracy, not at home and not abroad.

    • @scotwells7573
      @scotwells7573 11 днів тому

      That’s right we are a Republic

    • @dianacasey6002
      @dianacasey6002 10 днів тому

      What does that mean are you not supposed to be the greatest democracy in the world, the light on the bill. Democracy is thrown around by politicians like confetti at a wedding. So exactly why do ppl have a. OTE, why does it say by the ppl for the ppl. Is that not what a democracy is supposed to be. I don’t think you have a functioning democracy, because voting is suppressed, made as core t and difficult as possible. I think is pretty awful. Yet your politicians still seem to claim it’s a very very democratic country. I don’t understand what it is because it certainly is not a fair and just country. So if that is what a republicans is then it sucks.

  • @howielisnoff
    @howielisnoff 16 днів тому +43

    What I find most shocking today is that the Gaza genocide continues as does suppression of dissent here.

    • @bazjones5282
      @bazjones5282 8 днів тому

      I find the fact that people can't pick up a dictionary and learn what the term Genocide means shocking. It proves how many idiots believe they are smart by parroting what they are told and don't think for themselves.

  • @down-to-earth-mystery-school
    @down-to-earth-mystery-school 16 днів тому +11

    Weaponizing anti-Semitism for political gain, makes it harder to prosecute actual anti-Semitism. It’s also my understanding that Palestinians are Semite peoples, so…

  • @UTubeISphere
    @UTubeISphere 16 днів тому +68

    Thank you, Prof. Bartov, for keeping it real, for speaking up for legitimate student and faculty concerns. And thanks for drawing attention to the abominable treatment of Hebrew University Professor, Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian, and her (sexual and human rights) humiliation in an over-night jail.

    • @larryfloyd5111
      @larryfloyd5111 16 днів тому

      With "liberal Zionists" like Bartov, they only keep it real when comparing notes in private.

  • @roberttremaine5620
    @roberttremaine5620 16 днів тому +7

    I have been using the words massacre and genocide to protest about what is happening in Gaza.
    With the latest terrible, terrible news, I think we need to have some stronger words!
    What is happening in Gaza just seems to be getting worse and worse!
    I'm lost for words!
    Protesting students, THANK YOU and may God Bless You all ! 👍♥️♥️♥️

  • @Antarctica2025
    @Antarctica2025 16 днів тому +40

    Another matter is who gets to decide which groups is labeled terrorist! So many good Americans decry Hezbollah, Hamas and the Houthis without any understanding of the outrageous oppressive tactics used by Israel against the Palestinians!

    • @tzadiko
      @tzadiko 16 днів тому +1

      Such outrageous tactics... protecting themselves from Palestinian terrorism 🙄

  • @vincentdesouza4989
    @vincentdesouza4989 16 днів тому +14

    Smart man speaking our politicians need to listen.

  • @normaalarcon9033
    @normaalarcon9033 16 днів тому +63

    The harsh responses from universities may well be influenced by the donors many of whom have to be investigated in respect to their funding of Israel itself. Over 200 CEO's visited Tel Aviv when the Israelis began to bomb GAZA. There are complicities here.

    • @flaggov6949
      @flaggov6949 16 днів тому +3

      They are more likely influenced by the fact congress keeps calling them in to threaten university funding due to allowing student behaviors which are hostile to Jewish students (like blocking their free passage to class).

    • @ruthgallagher9584
      @ruthgallagher9584 15 днів тому +1

      The knowledge of dual citizenship should be available.

    • @normaalarcon9033
      @normaalarcon9033 15 днів тому +1

      @@ruthgallagher9584 Brings up the question of abuse of dual citizenship. Many of us are eligible for dual citizenship somewhere, that's currently the logic for current citizenship claims. So if people are abusing that duality to favor Genocidal intentions and worse, this will have to be questioned and debated.

    • @Uarehere
      @Uarehere 9 днів тому

      ​@@flaggov6949Jewish students were blocked from attending class? LOL, when did that happen??

    • @flaggov6949
      @flaggov6949 9 днів тому

      @@Uarehere Do you need instructions on how to do an internet search? Footage is easy to find.

  • @kaylee8644
    @kaylee8644 16 днів тому +32

    anti war and genocide is not antisemitic

    • @gregkle9384
      @gregkle9384 16 днів тому

      @kay Tell it to Hamas,they still firing rockets at Israel,they started genocide of Jews on 7 th and would carry on if they haven’t been stopped

    • @___michael___7165
      @___michael___7165 15 днів тому

      Who gives a fuck if it’s anti-Semitic ??? We have 1st Amendment right to offend anyone. I hear anti-Anerican comments. Anti-New York, anti-Calufornia, anti-Texas, and such all the time. There is nothing special about anti-Senitic comments. This is real life. Nobody guaranteed you special status or protection.
      The use of "anti-Semitic” is a psy-ops to get us to buy into that bigoted ”chosen" crap. Being anti-Semitic is no more wrong than being anti-Confederate, anti-Russian, anti-Hamas, anti-Fascist, anti-Communist, or anti anything else.
      Get over it. Anti-Semitic is fastly becoming the norm.

    • @brandonleon4068
      @brandonleon4068 11 днів тому +1

      ​@@gregkle9384who the hell is cheering Hamas?? Have u seen any protester saying "we stand for Hamas?" Hamas and IDF are doing the same terrible things, but ur side on the other hand is totally supporting IDF. Basically we're supporting Palestinians civilians, u're supporting ISRAEL GOV AND IDF GE NO CI DES

    • @brandonleon4068
      @brandonleon4068 11 днів тому

      ​@@gregkle9384only an idiot says this started October 7. This started decades ago, with Israeli occupation on Palestinian territory

  • @user-mc7kv3op3c
    @user-mc7kv3op3c 16 днів тому +53

    Israel has violated three of the five acts listed under the UN Genocide Convention.
    These acts Albanese said were “killing members of the group; causing serious bodily or mental harm to the group’s members; and deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part.”

    • @philspd473
      @philspd473 16 днів тому +1

      Free free, free the hostages.

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому +7

      ​@@philspd473Do you get your trolling schedule assignment weekly?

    • @philspd473
      @philspd473 16 днів тому

      @@71suns how exactly am I a troll?

    • @CallThemAllOut
      @CallThemAllOut 16 днів тому +7

      Free the 7000+ Palestinian children in your prisons

    • @user-kr9mw2xp7v
      @user-kr9mw2xp7v 16 днів тому

      @@CallThemAllOut and the 1500000 elephants israel keep in captivity. "children" sure..

  • @keyfiender799
    @keyfiender799 16 днів тому +19

    Amy and Omer, thank you for visiting encampments. Youth activists are always happy to be acknowledged and amplified by their elders.

  • @nosuchthing8
    @nosuchthing8 16 днів тому +19

    This is like an onion headline, 'COLLEGE CLOSED BECAUSE STUDENTS FEEL THREATENED BY OPPOSING IDEAS'

    • @Uarehere
      @Uarehere 9 днів тому

      More like college administrators feel threatened by Zionist lobbies.

  • @syedshah9836
    @syedshah9836 16 днів тому +45

    Exactly, a tool to silence any criticim of the worlds only apartheid regime...

    • @hilarymiseroy
      @hilarymiseroy 16 днів тому

      Do you need to be reminded that Israeli Arabs have legal equality and sit in the parliament.

    • @CallThemAllOut
      @CallThemAllOut 16 днів тому +6

      Another lie. They are second class citizens

    • @CallThemAllOut
      @CallThemAllOut 16 днів тому +3

      Another Hasbara talking point 😂😂

    • @hilarymiseroy
      @hilarymiseroy 16 днів тому

      @@CallThemAllOut Do you mean like women are in all Islamic countries? It is not a lie. There are areas where you will find only Jews and some areas with only Arabs but they have full equality under the law. They are sometimes referred to as the 'inside' Arabs or the '48' Arabs meaning the ones who chose to stay.

    • @hazaraudi7488
      @hazaraudi7488 16 днів тому

      ​@@hilarymiseroy no they don't and they're called Palestinians not Israeli Arabs. If you actually knew them at all you would know they do not identify as "Israeli Arabs"!

  • @IsraeldoublestandardsIsraeldou
    @IsraeldoublestandardsIsraeldou 16 днів тому +8

    Iof shot 6 year old hind rajab, was that self defense?

  • @AlejandraRodriguez-gx7gb
    @AlejandraRodriguez-gx7gb 16 днів тому +23

    He forgot to mention the fear Palestinians feel when they see the Israeli flag.

    • @tzadiko
      @tzadiko 16 днів тому

      Yeah they fear it so much they choose to live in Israel over any other country if they could

  • @alonelife4147
    @alonelife4147 16 днів тому +29

    Being Anti Zionist anti natanyahu or anti genocide is Not being Antisemitic.

    • @___michael___7165
      @___michael___7165 15 днів тому

      Who gives a fuck if it’s anti-Semitic ??? We have 1st Amendment right to offend anyone. I hear anti-Anerican comments. Anti-New York, anti-Calufornia, anti-Texas, and such all the time. There is nothing special about anti-Senitic comments. This is real life. Nobody guaranteed you special status or protection.
      The use of "anti-Semitic” is a psy-ops to get us to buy into that bigoted ”chosen" crap. Being anti-Semitic is no more wrong than being anti-Confederate, anti-Russian, anti-Hamas, anti-Fascist, anti-Communist, or anti anything else.
      Get over it. Anti-Semitic is fastly becoming the norm.

    • @kovie9162
      @kovie9162 9 днів тому

      Being against Jews having their own country, of whatever nature, IS antisemitic.

  • @faridamazhar5114
    @faridamazhar5114 16 днів тому +27

    The universities should be leading the way to do the right thing! Instead of doing the wrong thing and suppressing the students!

  • @michaelwicks933
    @michaelwicks933 16 днів тому +37

    Imagine putting a wikipedia ‘context link’ to the holocaust over someone like omer bartov - he probably wrote half the books that article is based on.

    • @barrya9391
      @barrya9391 16 днів тому +1

      It’s automated based on keyword

    • @lapimano2
      @lapimano2 16 днів тому +2

      Unfortunately the wikipedia description of the holocaust seems to be inaccurate to me: Although im not an expert, i belive the holocaust was not only against the jews, but more like against Hitler's description of the jews. So if someone dont consider themself a jew, or is not considered to be a jew according to the rules of judaism, they might still be considered to be a jew by Hitler, and got murdered. So im not sure the wiki excerpt is very accurate in this form, also i have serious doubt about the integrity of this description which leave out the other murdered innocents who were not jews at all.
      So all this revolves around who we consider to be a jew. Also if we consider everyone to be a jew who were systematically murdered by the nazis, then we kinda accept and utilize Hitler's description. Im not sure if that is a good idea, and im personally against it. I wouldnt want to give Hitler the authority to decide who is a jew.
      Also correct me if im wrong.

  • @boatman222345
    @boatman222345 15 днів тому +5

    I covered the antiwar movement on campuses in New Mexico just prior to the Kent State National Guard riot where 4 student were brutally shot down. I still have a photograph of a peaceful young female protester being dragged to safety by fellow students with bayonet wielding National Guard troops in hot pursuit. Day after day I would circulate around the campus interviewing student protestors without witnessing a single act of violence only to return home that evening to lurid reports on the television claiming that the striking students were violent and dangerous. Do not be misled, power elites and deep pocketed donators to Brown, Columbia, et. al. are pulling the behind the curtain strings to stamp out campus support for the people of Gaza. Take everything they say with a huge grain of salt!

    • @TheElkhornmountains
      @TheElkhornmountains 11 днів тому

      I am of the same generation have drawn the same comparison.

  • @susanWilder2175
    @susanWilder2175 16 днів тому +5

    Defining words from other cultures can be a complicated task. And it can take time, which US media particularly doesn’t care to bother with. I increasingly feel that major media around the world is irrelevant. Thank you Democracy Now for your thoughtful reporting and for giving time to inform.

  • @wyno2661
    @wyno2661 16 днів тому +9

    Well said Mr Bartov!

  • @acobbongcarawan7975
    @acobbongcarawan7975 16 днів тому +10

    God bless the Professor for distinguishing anti-Semitism & anti-zionism.

  • @marckenny3131
    @marckenny3131 16 днів тому +61

    These students are world hero's, fantastic to see kids with a moral compass and bravery.
    The Israeli Nazi's regime will fall.

    • @glennlgg6871
      @glennlgg6871 16 днів тому

      The islamofascists, commies and Nazi's that have hijacked the campuses and the useful idiots that support this will fall.

    • @gregkle9384
      @gregkle9384 16 днів тому

      @marc is it the same Nazi like in Ukraine ,that’s what your hero Putin says,correct?

    • @georgelincolnrockwell6248
      @georgelincolnrockwell6248 16 днів тому

      The NSDAP tried to WARN the rest of the WORLD, and they WERE SILENCED and VILIFIED FOR IT!!!

  • @pedrob3953
    @pedrob3953 15 днів тому +5

    I remeber when Norman Finkelstein was the lone voice talking about the weaponization of the Holocaust memory way back in the 90s.

  • @amazinghappsandevents
    @amazinghappsandevents 16 днів тому +24

    Thank you for standing up for humanity and the oppressed.. Thank you..

  • @nourmessaoudene4780
    @nourmessaoudene4780 16 днів тому +10

    I propose that Jewish scholars against weaponizing antisemitism to silence any criticism of Israel should address an open letter to congress and to the president to voice their opinion.

  • @Bavafa1
    @Bavafa1 16 днів тому +32

    Events of past few months have left little doubt that there are two different factions of Zayo NOT-Z:
    Those who are denying the Palestinian Hollowcost and those who are insisting to carry on with a Palestinian Hollowcost
    *Rest* *in* *Power* *Aaron* *Bushnell* I will never forget you and your last words of " *Free* *Palestine* "

  • @SA-km3oh
    @SA-km3oh 16 днів тому +2

    Rare honest Man! Massive Respect to Professor Bartov 🙏

  • @platypass8294
    @platypass8294 16 днів тому +24

    Anti-Zionist is not Anti-Semitism.

    • @georgemetesky5519
      @georgemetesky5519 15 днів тому

      Actually it is, if you consider that most of us support Israel, and half our Tribe lives there.

    • @brandonleon4068
      @brandonleon4068 11 днів тому

      ​@@georgemetesky5519I've seen more Jewish people against genocide than favour it. Glory to them, shame on genocide supporters

  • @ellennassiri9419
    @ellennassiri9419 16 днів тому +12

    Please stop saying ‘they don’t feel safe’ or ‘they feel threatened’. They don’t feel these things. They SAY that they feel these things. It is a form of intimidation of pro Palestine people.

    • @youredelusionaldude
      @youredelusionaldude 8 днів тому

      Stop gaslighting and telling other people how they feel. Abusive tactics of yours.

  • @amazinghappsandevents
    @amazinghappsandevents 16 днів тому +45

    Thank you Omer for your views...full support tp what you said.... There is no clear evidence that the lives of the Jewish, israel students in USA are threatened... People should stop spreading lies that Jewish students are being attacked... Natanyahoo regime should be hold accountable for what's currently happening in Gaza and the protests in USA and around the world.... Remove natanyahoo....

    • @haroldsmith7044
      @haroldsmith7044 16 днів тому

      So you're saying all those Jewish students who say they feel threatened are lying?

    • @based4573
      @based4573 16 днів тому

      @@haroldsmith7044 Zionist are threatened, not Jews. Are non-Zionist Jews threatened?

    • @kappa82
      @kappa82 16 днів тому

      @@haroldsmith7044the pro Hamas , pro Iran left will always hate the Jews

    • @OmANnIe
      @OmANnIe 16 днів тому +3

      ​@haroldsmith7044 I think they're saying "Feeling threatened isn't the same as "being attacked." There are people saying they've been attacked for being Jewish. People being caught lying and even hurting themselves to pretend that pro-Palestinian protesters attacked them.

    • @down-to-earth-mystery-school
      @down-to-earth-mystery-school 16 днів тому +2

      Jewish feelings do not trump Palestinian lives. No one’s feelings trump another person’s life.

  • @robertroest7619
    @robertroest7619 16 днів тому +10

    One of the leading scholars on genocide and Holocaust, a Jew himself, joining the students give me hope! So thanks to fit humans like him!!

    • @elainegoodfriend775
      @elainegoodfriend775 8 днів тому

      That's no proof. There is a long history of Jews turning against the Jewish people. Look for article titles with the phrase, "As a Jew."

  • @nathanrussell1538
    @nathanrussell1538 16 днів тому +26

    Well spoken Omer Bartov.

    • @larryfloyd5111
      @larryfloyd5111 16 днів тому

      Just because he's right on this one issue doesn't make his "liberal Zionism" any less pernicious.

  • @yvonneyork1263
    @yvonneyork1263 16 днів тому +8

    Proud of these brave students risking their academic and professional careers to stand up for justice.

  • @MrHuadong1
    @MrHuadong1 16 днів тому +2

    It’s disturbing that a generation of parents have worked hard and paid the police to raid their kids due to peaceful protests.

  • @leilaoksanen5142
    @leilaoksanen5142 15 днів тому +2

    Professor Mr
    OMER BARTOV
    And
    DEMOCRACY NOW
    THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

  • @basschepers7819
    @basschepers7819 16 днів тому +14

    STOP THE GENOCIDE

  • @vaughancreighton9994
    @vaughancreighton9994 16 днів тому +4

    How many Israeli protesters have been arrested?

  • @iantoshkiev
    @iantoshkiev 15 днів тому +3

    Justice for the people of Palestine

  • @jcpt8365
    @jcpt8365 16 днів тому +7

    Thank you students you are putting your future on the line to defend human rights! You are the best of us! Much respect for your courage from Portugal 🇵🇹 I also like to add that the reselience of the Palestinian people facing genocide and opression both humbles me and breaks my heart!

  • @Thiscannotbetruebutitis
    @Thiscannotbetruebutitis 16 днів тому +10

    Thank you Prof. Omer.

  • @iqbaluddin
    @iqbaluddin 15 днів тому +3

    The people of the world are watching what kind of American democracy! American political leaders and Israeli political leaders are two branches of the same tree.

  • @fsmon1753
    @fsmon1753 13 днів тому +3

    Justice for Palestinian people

  • @Sofia-lc1qo
    @Sofia-lc1qo 15 днів тому +2

    Thank you for being voice for silenced👏

  • @warrinbang1191
    @warrinbang1191 16 днів тому +16

    Netanyahu's right wing extremist govt is what's causing people to form a negative opinion of Jewish people. So I really love the Jewish people who are standing for liberty, justice, and equality for all.

    • @edithrowland
      @edithrowland 9 днів тому

      Yeah but there are few and far between.

  • @markd.holloman5187
    @markd.holloman5187 15 днів тому +5

    We need more and more of this Journalism. Thank you Amy, I always check in with you for headlines and more indepth reporting. Keep up the work.

  • @jagoruk55
    @jagoruk55 16 днів тому +1

    Hat off to Professor Omer Bartov, every word of his speech may resist killing a life in Gaza.

  • @arabicsahlonmsa5303
    @arabicsahlonmsa5303 16 днів тому +15

    If BRIBERY is a criminal act for all employees , likewise it should be a criminal offense for the LOBBYISTs and lawmakers/congressmen

  • @user-no2bh3tp2d
    @user-no2bh3tp2d 16 днів тому +36

    Stop the crime man stop Netanyahu

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому

      And his administration. And the military commanders. And every single IDF psychopaths committing crimes against humanity

  • @kathya.9184
    @kathya.9184 16 днів тому +7

    "Members of Congress threaten ICC with retaliation if arrest warrants issued against Israeli officials" [for war crimes against Palestinians].
    ~ The Jerusalem Post (4/30/2024)

    • @rhetorical1488
      @rhetorical1488 16 днів тому

      not the first time

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому

      What did they threaten them with?

    • @user-eo3db3mi1e
      @user-eo3db3mi1e 16 днів тому

      That is normal modus operandi they get away with genocide N heinious crimes by threatening ppl who want to take them to task how unjust

  • @ZZ-ls5hv
    @ZZ-ls5hv 16 днів тому +2

    Looks like it is imminently important for Myanmar to bring democracy to the USA...

  • @chessman70
    @chessman70 16 днів тому +2

    It's the same thing they've always used skirt any criticism of Israel, it's anti-Semitic...

  • @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
    @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings 16 днів тому +9

    Mind Begs the Question:
    - If policies of Starvation,Death Camps,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Dehumanization,Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc are repeated
    - Doesn't amount to Holocaust?

  • @cubuffs12345
    @cubuffs12345 16 днів тому +3

    My question for Israeli govt supporters, just because you CAN say antisemitism and do crimes with a green light, SHOULD you?

  • @operasinger2126
    @operasinger2126 16 днів тому +1

    Thank you Amy, Democracy Now, and Omer for trying to bring peace to the world.

  • @absiddique139
    @absiddique139 16 днів тому +9

    U.S is Democratic and the Earth is Flat.

  • @Antarctica2025
    @Antarctica2025 16 днів тому +11

    Thank you! Yes a forced silence which we have been under in America for decades!

  • @gmedeiros5748
    @gmedeiros5748 15 днів тому +1

    “ the enemy is within the gates ; it is our own luxury , our own folly , our own criminality we will need to contend “
    Cicero

  • @sandraabudubai
    @sandraabudubai 16 днів тому +11

    IDF former should not be aloud on US campus.

    • @garypuckettmuse
      @garypuckettmuse 11 днів тому

      well vote for Trump I believe this is one of his promises to you. Next we won't allow Chinese or maybe people with blue eyes. Such easy solutions!

  • @MichaelRogers-mg4ot
    @MichaelRogers-mg4ot 16 днів тому +7

    Americans need to learn about the SS LIBERTY! You should think differently about Israel.

  • @comitelulalivreengland_oxf9343
    @comitelulalivreengland_oxf9343 15 днів тому +2

    We’re very proud of these Americana students because not only they’re Americans but also they have a better life living than the Palestinians and they know that what is happening in Palestine 🇵🇸 is not correct !

  • @balabani
    @balabani 16 днів тому +15

    Hats off to professor Omer Bartov.

  • @kentallard8852
    @kentallard8852 16 днів тому +3

    did the former IDF serviceman at Columbia get his hands on IDF ordnance? How was it brought into the country undetected?

    • @thomasfplm
      @thomasfplm 11 днів тому

      As far as I understand, it was a spray can similar to a pepper spray for self defense.
      He probably had it in his luggage and no body cared.

  • @rebecaaltaji7087
    @rebecaaltaji7087 16 днів тому +3

    I was at Columbia very peaceful ❤

  • @ruthgallagher9584
    @ruthgallagher9584 15 днів тому +1

    Due process must be followed.

  • @sholeha6894
    @sholeha6894 9 днів тому +1

    The right to freedom of assembly and association is enshrined in several international human rights instruments, including:
    1. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), Article 20: "Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association."
    2. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), Article 21: "The right of peaceful assembly shall be recognized. No restrictions may be placed on the exercise of this right other than those imposed in conformity with the law and which are necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security or public safety, public order (ordre public), the protection of public health or morals or the protection of the rights and freedoms of others."
    Besides, divesting from an Apartheid state in not unreasonable demand.

  • @JackFieldBand
    @JackFieldBand 16 днів тому +6

    Instead of asking pro-Palestinians to condemn Hamas, do an experiment and ask them the following question: "If Israel could eliminate Hamas without harming women and children, would you support that?" You will be surprised by the answer.

    • @mickeyoshea2035
      @mickeyoshea2035 16 днів тому

      Why would anyone support the annihilation of the freedom fighters? Did you support annihilation of South African freedom fighters? Did you wish death upon Nelson Mandela?

    • @joshuaiosevich3727
      @joshuaiosevich3727 16 днів тому

      You’ll get an answer of “no fucking shit I do”

  • @AlonsoLayena
    @AlonsoLayena 16 днів тому +6

    Students are teaching us a big lesson about humanity, integrity, unity, and courage!! I hope between them is a future president of the U.S.

  • @neviocapodagli4742
    @neviocapodagli4742 8 днів тому +1

    This interview is very important, there is so much prejudice and misinformation on this topic also in Europe...

  • @mc-lb9dk
    @mc-lb9dk 16 днів тому +9

    zionism is a political issue. like communism, capitalism, fascism, etc.

  • @Helpme-zh8wo
    @Helpme-zh8wo 9 днів тому

    I am your sister from Yemen, and by God I only spoke out of hunger and distress. My mother, my brothers, and I lessons and tears. We are in a situation that only God knows about. God is sufficient for us, and He is the best disposer of affairs for those who brought us to this situation. By God Almighty, I did not write this appeal out of distress and distress. Poverty, O world, they have felt it So, I hope for you. By God Almighty, Lord of the Great Throne, he ate what I had in the house. By God, my brothers, he is my brothers by sitting in the house. Who has no food? By God, we are in a very difficult situation. We have 4 people entering the house, and my father has died, and there is no one who can depend on us and who lives in it.We live in a rented house because we cannot pay the rent we owe. '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ''''''''''''' My brother, my first words are: I swear to God on the Book of God that I will not lie to you, nor deceive, nor deceive. I am a Yemeni girl displaced from Taiz. My family and I, Ait Al-Shahrb, have 20,000 Yemenis among us, and now we owe 60,000 for 3 months. The owner of the house is one of the people who does not have mercy, by God, my brother. He comes every day, insulting us, talking about us, and moving from the house to the street because we were unable to pay him the rent. The neighbors saw us crying and came back.They came back to talk to the neighbors and we were given the weekend. So we made him swear by God. He will take us out into the street. Have mercy on him and us. Our country is due to this war and we do not find food for our day, and my brothers and I live in a difficult life. Our father died, may God have mercy on him, and we have no one in this world who was with us in these harsh circumstances. My younger brothers went out into the street and saw...The neighbors eat and stand at their door in order to give them bread even if they break it. By God, to whom belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth, they closed the door and expelled them and came back crying. They are dying of hunger. No one has mercy on them and a holiday is returned. I have made a living, and now if one of us helps us with a kilo of flour, I swear to God, I am dying of hunger. My brother, I am an alien to God. Then, I ask you to help me for the sake of God. I ask you, by God, to love goodness and to help me, even if you can, by messaging me on WhatsApp.On this number 00967779509554 and ask for the name of my card and send it and do not be late and may God reward you with all the best, my brothers Sagar, see how they are and help us and save us before they throw us out in the street, you will be lost or we will die of hunger. My family and I ask you, by God, if you are able to help us, do not be late and may God reward you well.`/--~~« ««~~♡~♡~♡~~•~•~♡~♡~♡~~♡~♡~♕~♡~♡♡♡~~~~: ~: ~! ~! ~! ~;g.g.g.g.g.g.g.g.gsffjwg....🎉

  • @kadyrov3218
    @kadyrov3218 7 днів тому

    It's nice to see Omer Bartov. I used his research when i did some research as part of my MA on the Wehrmacht's attack on USSR in WW2.
    I appreciated Bartovs rebuke of the idea that "only the SS did war crimes in German occupied Russia".
    He's one of the world's best scholars
    on German war crimes in WW2.
    I deeply respect this man because he clearly has a love of truth and he appears to have compassion towards the Palestinians.

  • @MA-sk4fg
    @MA-sk4fg 16 днів тому +7

    Stop insulting people who perished in holocaust .It is outrageous when you have members of your family who have been tortured and killed in those concentration camps. NEVER AGAIN TO ANY LIVING BEING.

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому

      I wonder who you would be if you no longer saw yourself as perpetual 'victim' of your own life as your core identity?

    • @youredelusionaldude
      @youredelusionaldude 8 днів тому

      @@71sunsask palis

  • @Hassan-lx5kj
    @Hassan-lx5kj 15 днів тому +4

    Free palestine people and land

  • @RonBittner
    @RonBittner 15 днів тому +1

    What an excellent and important distinction between anti-semitism and anti-zionism

  • @aminaausman2947
    @aminaausman2947 9 днів тому

    Thank you Professor for discussing the importance of pro Palestinian protests on American universities campuses , in US democracy!

  • @faisalhomaid4624
    @faisalhomaid4624 16 днів тому +3

    Treating anti-genecide like anti-sementic will have dramatic negative effect on anti-sementic.

  • @misafir716
    @misafir716 16 днів тому +10

    Historical protest by students

  • @dockalra
    @dockalra 7 днів тому

    Thank you for your courage. It would be wonderful if one an American president will speak up with this conviction.

  • @River_Sea_2024
    @River_Sea_2024 16 днів тому +1

    Great scholar! Thank you for your honesty and integrity ❤

  • @arabicsahlonmsa5303
    @arabicsahlonmsa5303 16 днів тому +7

    ISRAELI enjoy universal healthcare coverage AMERICANS do not. who needs most to keep his TAX money for internal needs?..

    • @desireedebellis6766
      @desireedebellis6766 16 днів тому +3

      they also enjoy free schooling as well as monthly checks ,,more than what most seniors receive on social security,,, we are tax slaves for the united states of Israel

    • @desireedebellis6766
      @desireedebellis6766 16 днів тому +2

      they also enjoy free schooling as well as monthly checks ,,more than what most seniors receive on social security,,, we are tax slaves for the united states of Israel

    • @Uarehere
      @Uarehere 9 днів тому

      All this time we've been propping up a little Soviet Union in the middle east, and most of us didn't even know it.

  • @sammydsouza4379
    @sammydsouza4379 16 днів тому +4

    Why is it these people are so hated.? Not the Students, the Chosen Ones..

    • @71suns
      @71suns 16 днів тому

      Chosen for what specifically?

    • @CowboyConan
      @CowboyConan 16 днів тому

      They aren’t 😂

    • @CallThemAllOut
      @CallThemAllOut 16 днів тому +2

      Chosen ones were brown 😂

  • @gregorybible7610
    @gregorybible7610 16 днів тому +1

    Thats like accuseing blacks for being races when they say the n word

  • @edbaranovsky9095
    @edbaranovsky9095 7 днів тому +1

    For 7 millions Jews living in Israel, that don't have academic degree in Holocausts and American citizenship, Anti-Zionizm is Anti-Semitism. The Jewish students at american campuses have a reason to fear for their life when they hear chanting "Free Palestine" and "Globalize Intifada", prior to 1933 Jews felt very secure in Germany, they were also sitting on the loan with their German peers and discussing authenticity of "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion" but then came Holocaust.