Other gay NPC's in the game: 1) The man lefting the mail of Rhodes in the mission of Sadie and Arthur in the beggining of Chapter 3 2) Algernon Wasp 3) Charles Chatein
another gay person, he is the mayor of Strawberry, in fact this is the mayor's secret, the first time the mayor talks to Arthur, he tells him that he ran away from his city because of his family and the way they treated his wife, but if you rummage in the mayor's pocket you find a letter from his sister, where she says that he never married but well yes that he ran away with another professor, who apparently seems to be the owner of the hotel in Strawberry this would explain why the mayor is almost always them
I THINK i was once greeted by a random male NPC that said “hellooo, cutie-pie~!” And i legit took a few seconds to process that and i had to act like a shy school girl after realizing that
I always thought Mr Black and Mr White were a couple, they’re practically cuddling in one of the encounters. Glad I’m not the only one who thought that lol
Yes. Alden has a wife. However, lots of queer people, especially back then, married people of the opposite sex so they wouldn't be targeted, questioned or killed. It still happens today. Marrying someone of the opposite sex doesn't make you straight. It's protecting yourself.
The Murfree Brood gay's in both clips are the same people - just in different locations. Their dialogue is the same. I'm not sure you can actually confirm that Mr. Black and Mr. White are gay. Sure, they have a comradie about them, but then they were on the same chain gang, and shared the same cell, but that don't mean that they are gay. ALDEN is definitely batting for the other team, and the guy at Butcher Creek, well, he all might just be 'gentle' and that ain't the same as frisky after dark, y'hear? As for SONNY, he just likes to hurt and degrade folk. Psychologically speaking it's all about the pain he inflicts on others, with emphasis on men because men are so easily hurt when they are sodomized - and in the macho world of the 1890's, Arthur's brutalizing isn't necessarily a gay encounter. True, he got sodomized, but I would bet that given half a chance, a creature like Sonny would do that to anyone irrespective of age, or gender, in a heartbeat.
Wtf how can not confirm that Mr black and Mr white are not homosexual but you're convinced Alden is?! Mr. B & Mr. W are the only NPC's with overtly homosexual tones. They finish they're story living together in an idyllic log cabin sharing one bed and acting like an "old married couple". Your basis for Alden being gay is: he puts X's on his notes and he speaks theatrically. Which is not that uncommon or a seal of homosexuality. I love reddead but rockstar whitewashed the west vastly. Many people escaped to the "new world" in hopes of being able to express themselves. There were a lot of open homosexuals and what were called cross dressers at the time. But I think even rockstar wasn't that dense to have the intention of Mr. B and Mr. W just being good friends 🤦♀️
@@RoxZombie I'm glad that I don't live in the same world as you. Perhaps it's because I'm a woman and know what to look for - wherein most men base their 'guesses' on their own sexuality and desires. I don't believe that Black/White are gay - it is really sad that you are convinced that their relationship extends to playing hide the sausage after dark. Alden, XXXxxxXXxxxxXxxxx
It's strange that you can notice that Alden is gay which is much less shown and not exactly confirmed but you didn't noticed that with Black and White which is like dude, they are confirmed to be gay, it's pretty obvious from the very first interaction if you pay attention, Arthur notices that from the second interaction and also advices them to be careful about it. And if that wasn't obvious enough for you, literally the last time you meet them it's pretty much confirmed that they are indeed gay.
I always loved how homosexuals were portrayed in RDR2, it feel genuily natural and organic unlike most modern games that just force it down your troath because they have to proof they are woke
Also Dutch and Micah r like… strangely strangely close and together a lot 💀 maybe his actual peace offering to Dutch when coming back to camp was uhm… something else
The man you save from choking at the Saint Denis mayor's party, who you can later collect flowers for with which he makes hats, is most definitely gay.
@@SmoothBur in the mission where the people in the art gallery are mad he is painting their wives naked one of them is like stop looking at my husband or something like that
I feel like rep in this game isn't exactly the best. Especially sonny 💀 Like, I don't think I need to explain why having a Jeffrey Dahmer-like character in the game should not be counted as "gay representation"
I don’t know if they were really trying to have gay representation, considering that it was punishable by jail time as of 1885, people probably would do vigilante justice upon you if you were open, and that it was seen as a mental illness until the ‘50s.
Don’t forget the guy who owns that little shop in saint Dennis he wears very feminine clothes. Theirs also the mayor in strawberry and theirs a couple living in a log cabin outside valentine. And the drunken artist u meet in the saint Dennis little bar
Alden literally is confirmed gay by the Rhodes bartender saying so, back then gay people couldn't be openly gay, he says she's a bad woman, writes "X" on the bottom of the letters he gives Arthur, which is a love sign
well if we’re trying to be historically accurate here, lots of homosexuals back in that time had wives to cover up their sexuality. like a ton of them.
@@D.The1st How does this make sense? Just admit you're homophobic. They weren't KILLED back then, nececcarily, but it wasn't really accepted yes. Doesn't mean they always were killed. Bill lived. Theres an example
Actually, Bill isn't it's a common misconception also I don't think Alden is either nor is the "beautiful man" I think that was a rhetoric statement to make fun of Arthur for starting
hosea literally makes a joke about couples in the beginning with names that rhyme and he goes "bill and phil" and he also knows sonny and talks to arthur about it... its pretty obvious lol
@@knot5542 You might think so but the beginning "bill and phil" was a joke and they laughed at that one afterwards Sonny is an outlier seeing as he is most likely secluded and not there mentally all the way
@@calebandcohengaming9851 yes it was a joke about bill's sexuality... the game is very obviously trying to hint at it without shoving it in your face because even the other gang members have a suspicion too and they know him better than we do. bill still KNEW sonny and, if you were assaulted by sonny, he teases you about it likely believing it was consensual from sonny's accounts. why would sonny and bill have a conversation like that unless they mutually understood that they were both interested in men?
@@calebandcohengaming9851 after you get assaulted by sonny and if you do not kill him, back at camp bill will interact with you by saying something along the lines of "i was talking to that interesting guy in the swamp, he seemed to know all about you... i mean *ALL* about you.." and arthur reacts very aggressively, hinting that bill WAS referring to the assault rockstar wont say anything because their story games dont seem very keen on spelling things out to you (unless its introducing a game mechanic).. and plus people complain about having lgbt rep shoved in their face if companies emphasize it lol, i prefer this kind of portrayal, its very discreet like you would've had to be discreet during this time period
Sonny: You wanna come in and see-
Arthur: X X
X
X X X
Hi Uncle Dutch!
@@Relâmpago_marquinhos69 Hello son, it's been a while...
@@DutchPlanDerLindeFromTahitiYou two have got to stop meeting like that!
Omg I thought you said
@@williamsmith4563lmfao
We need to prevent other Arthurs from getting clapped. Keep your Arthur safe guys and avoid the swamp man.
Idek where he’s located so I hope my Arthur is safe
@@Leeeauhhh the swamp
@@drr8264 but idk where in the swamp 😭
I know where he is, i sometimes go to him and light him on fire
What does clapped mean
Love how the roasting of Marion was really the only genuine time that Arthur and Micah bonded
Fr 💀
Even tho Micah seemed uninterested in the convo arthur 😂
i think that mission u do after u free him from prison too
Other gay NPC's in the game:
1) The man lefting the mail of Rhodes in the mission of Sadie and Arthur in the beggining of Chapter 3
2) Algernon Wasp
3) Charles Chatein
That and them enjoying killing O'Driscolls together
another gay person, he is the mayor of Strawberry, in fact this is the mayor's secret, the first time the mayor talks to Arthur, he tells him that he ran away from his city because of his family and the way they treated his wife, but if you rummage in the mayor's pocket you find a letter from his sister, where she says that he never married but well yes that he ran away with another professor, who apparently seems to be the owner of the hotel in Strawberry this would explain why the mayor is almost always them
Oooooohhhhh nooo I thought his secret was that he was a drug dealer or something so I murdered him….
That's sweet 🫠
That should explain why he the mayor of a town named after a fruit
And Micah
@@astral5263 i laughed way too hard at this lmfao caught me off guard
We just forgetting Arthur got kissed by a man just because he thought he saw someone he thought he knew
When?
@@The_Punisher mission with the painter guy that everyone hates, he dresses up as a girl to escape Saint Denis without being caught
I think this one was a fake kiss
Yes I thought that was an unrealistic and progressive response from Arthur when that happened. No man would continue to help him after that kiss.
Funny thing is, this is the only fucking kiss Arthur gets in the entire game, and it's with a dude. XD
another gay person in the game is me when i saw arthur for the first time
Nah💀
Valid
arthur can make a straight man gay
Too relatable
Repent that’s weird
Micah: "You're secret is safe with me, Marion."
Arthur & Sadie: "Hello, gentlemen."
Your pfp scares me wtf
Don't forget Tilly
👁👁 "Your secret is safe with us, too."
I THINK i was once greeted by a random male NPC that said “hellooo, cutie-pie~!” And i legit took a few seconds to process that and i had to act like a shy school girl after realizing that
LMAO I REALLY HOPE YOU DIDN’T MISHEAR THAT BECAUSE THAT WOULD BE SO FUNNY IF IT IS TRUE
I always thought Mr Black and Mr White were a couple, they’re practically cuddling in one of the encounters. Glad I’m not the only one who thought that lol
based on the film The Defiant Ones, which... well you can read a lot into that film too
Bill literally asks for pomade, which used to be used as lube
You can see him on the camp after giving it to him with his hair pomaded though
And bill's hair is always dirty anyways lmao
😂😂wtf
Yeah, it's funny how awkward Arthur feels about giving the pomade to Bill haha, it's clearly alluding to that.
wtf? there were other substitutes for lube, and pomade works fucking awful as lube. he probably wanted it for literally anyone else, maybe even dutch
Alden also writes “x” and “xxx” at the end of his coach robbery tips that he gives to Arthur. Do with that what you will.
Yep! I think it's adorable 😊 I always love getting those
What do the Xs mean
Kisses@@chillycoldchomper9389
@@chillycoldchomper9389 kisses
@vanessawaring4954 thank you, lad
Arthur literally called him the local *hard* man
Bro...
ill never forget when I first started RDO and my guy and Alden were giving eachother full BEDROOM EYES mid cut scene.
huhhh 😂
If you have a female character, he talks about how hes not good with women
I never thought Mr. Black and Mr. White were gay.. until I went into their treehouse and saw that single bed 😂
it was very obvious 😭
Wow, I feel stupid. I didn't know they had a treehouse! Where can you find it? Is that the tree they're always sitting by?
@@AirGoddess1087I have 100% and I did not know ether 💀
@AirGoddess1087 no it's in big valley west elizabeth north of hanging dog ranch i think.
Yes. Alden has a wife. However, lots of queer people, especially back then, married people of the opposite sex so they wouldn't be targeted, questioned or killed. It still happens today. Marrying someone of the opposite sex doesn't make you straight. It's protecting yourself.
@Uncle Sure. No hard feelings
@Uncle Hey boy. Don’t use my name it’s mine.
Sometimes lesbians will marry gay men in order to assure safety in situations like this. We call this having a “beard”
Someone finally said it, thank u sm
Sim cara, é triste isso 😔
The Legendary Bear of the Van der Linde Gang will always be my number one gay NPC in the game...
Bro 😭😭
AMEN
Ngl, I like Alden lol. He's pretty funny, even if he adds a tad too many x's on our coach robbery tips.
Arthur commits hate crimes for 5 minutes and 14 seconds
last one isnt
None of them will really hate crimes when you think about it. Just doing the right thing lol
@@AnthonyKing-fr1dl okay Adolf
@@fartsforeyes7651 lol, his profile pic is even a kitler
He wants to be the only gay
1:12 it is too funny how everyone unanimously agrees that Alden is gay simply because of his voice.
I honestly thought it was Seth MacFarlane doing his Bruce voice
he also writes x and xxx (kisses) on his robbery tips because arthur is hot
3:51 Somebody had to have laughed in the recording studio that day.
3:49
“what the hell is wrong with you-“
“AAHAHGHHHAH AHAHAGG”
Sonny: ''You wanna come in and see my collection of sk-''
Arthur:
*Boom*
*BANG*
He deserved it
Plz, if you' re playing this game, don't let your Arthur's cheeks get clapped by the swamp dude
I let John have it instead
Why? What would a swamp guy do?
@@y.s-n5tviolates Arthur
@@y.s-n5tSA him
@@coffinboy556why? That made no sense
When Arthur pointed his gun at Alden, Alden wasn’t even scared, just annoyed.
I appreciated the Beautiful Gay NPC 3:19
Albert mason (the photographer) looked like he had a fat crush on Arthur 😂😂 dont blame him though
"Your secret is safe with me"
Sadie literally on their side:
3:56 the way my smile and mood dropped the moment I saw this mf
0:51 just witnessed a hate crime
He hearted it, so it's true
3:52 What the fuck, man?!!😂😂😂
bro forgot abt hosea and dutch
Best bromance I’ve seen tbh
TRUE. The curious couple!!
The curious couple LOL
they've made out at least once and you can't convince me otherwise...
The curious couple and their unruly son 😊
2:50 the way he says is so funny
Alden is so sassy
"Your secret's safe with me, Marion"
John in RDR1: "Marion Williamson!"
3:50 THAT CUTOFF THO😂😂😂 I LITERALLY SPAT MY DRINK ALL OVER MY SHIRT LMAOOOO
You forgot the mayor of Strawberry.
Yep the secret of strawberry
@Hitler Loves Anime UA-cam channel "Strange Man" made a video about it.
ua-cam.com/video/aklh6mA20I8/v-deo.html
@Hitler Loves Anime the UA-cam channel called "Strange Man"
The Murfree Brood gay's in both clips are the same people - just in different locations. Their dialogue is the same. I'm not sure you can actually confirm that Mr. Black and Mr. White are gay. Sure, they have a comradie about them, but then they were on the same chain gang, and shared the same cell, but that don't mean that they are gay. ALDEN is definitely batting for the other team, and the guy at Butcher Creek, well, he all might just be 'gentle' and that ain't the same as frisky after dark, y'hear?
As for SONNY, he just likes to hurt and degrade folk. Psychologically speaking it's all about the pain he inflicts on others, with emphasis on men because men are so easily hurt when they are sodomized - and in the macho world of the 1890's, Arthur's brutalizing isn't necessarily a gay encounter. True, he got sodomized, but I would bet that given half a chance, a creature like Sonny would do that to anyone irrespective of age, or gender, in a heartbeat.
I agree
Wtf how can not confirm that Mr black and Mr white are not homosexual but you're convinced Alden is?! Mr. B & Mr. W are the only NPC's with overtly homosexual tones. They finish they're story living together in an idyllic log cabin sharing one bed and acting like an "old married couple". Your basis for Alden being gay is: he puts X's on his notes and he speaks theatrically. Which is not that uncommon or a seal of homosexuality.
I love reddead but rockstar whitewashed the west vastly. Many people escaped to the "new world" in hopes of being able to express themselves. There were a lot of open homosexuals and what were called cross dressers at the time. But I think even rockstar wasn't that dense to have the intention of Mr. B and Mr. W just being good friends 🤦♀️
@@RoxZombie I'm glad that I don't live in the same world as you. Perhaps it's because I'm a woman and know what to look for - wherein most men base their 'guesses' on their own sexuality and desires. I don't believe that Black/White are gay - it is really sad that you are convinced that their relationship extends to playing hide the sausage after dark. Alden, XXXxxxXXxxxxXxxxx
i don't think bill is either
It's strange that you can notice that Alden is gay which is much less shown and not exactly confirmed but you didn't noticed that with Black and White which is like dude, they are confirmed to be gay, it's pretty obvious from the very first interaction if you pay attention, Arthur notices that from the second interaction and also advices them to be careful about it.
And if that wasn't obvious enough for you, literally the last time you meet them it's pretty much confirmed that they are indeed gay.
Sonny is giving Jefferey Dahmer..
nah bruh he thinks we're blind 💀. blud got a few looks on sadie 2:50
Bro just wanted a peek🇦🇸
5:06
Jumpscare warning next time?!? That freaking scared me 😆
you must be on full volume
@@Kermit4415 nah the gator coming out freaked me out
@@3DInnovations70 how????
@@Kermit4415 its was so sudden
@@3DInnovations70 yeah I mean it
was pretty unexpected
“All right i catch u later then” 😂
Yep Bill and Sonny are "friends" probably why he was discharged from the Army or was asked to leave
LMFAO Alden’s closet is crystal clear
3:02. Did you just.... 😮 greet micah?!!!
In one of alden stagecoach tips, he write xoxo in one of the letter
I never knew Alden was gay as in homosexual
Is he going to kiss him or fight him -Arthur Morgan-
He bout to kiss that guy or punch him*
Oh Hi There Mary Williamson.
I always loved how homosexuals were portrayed in RDR2, it feel genuily natural and organic unlike most modern games that just force it down your troath because they have to proof they are woke
"Ok, I'll catch you later then" must be a catchphrase, HE SAYS IT EVERY TIME
I swear that should be on a shirt next to Arthur's face or something. I'd wear it 😅
Alden always sounded like Bruce from family guy to me. Especially when I’m paying a bounty and he says, “Oh, you are a bad person.”
You forgot the mission in that Arthur Kissed Charles Châtenay
4:30 Arthur gets 35 different types of cholera and STI's.
Tb was a blissing at this point
Also Dutch and Micah r like… strangely strangely close and together a lot 💀 maybe his actual peace offering to Dutch when coming back to camp was uhm… something else
Sadly no, if it was like that Dutch wouldn't flirt on Mary-Beth
Or, he can be Bi, who knows
@@InfinityGxWhy sadly ?
Stop these theories. Mika was trying to make himself closer to Dutch than Arthur, which is why they're close you say..
@@y.s-n5t Dude its a joke, why there is a people that couldn't understand, lol
Rarepair fr
It's fade on sight as soon as I see Sonny
When Arthur is just carrying the wolf
Micah: “oh don’t get on that”
0:50 that was personal
John is gonna have some fun dealing with them.
So far I've found 6 gay NPCs in rdr2.. There can be more idk and This video is just for the info.. Ty
the mayor in strawberry
@Uncle Idiot
Why is alden gay
Two were scrapped and cut. Arthur and Charles
@@maulressurected4405 yup.
The man you save from choking at the Saint Denis mayor's party, who you can later collect flowers for with which he makes hats, is most definitely gay.
Should have included the scene with Bill and Kieran lol
NPC: "Wanna b my special friend?"
Arthur: "U the local hard man, huh?"
😂😂😂
lowkey love murfree broods dialogue, it’s just hella funny to me 😭
3:50
What the hell is wrong with y-
(Proceeds to get dragged)
I think Charles Châtenay deserves an honorable mention since he's bisexual.
Is that canon or Something like that?
@@SmoothBur in the mission where the people in the art gallery are mad he is painting their wives naked one of them is like stop looking at my husband or something like that
I find it hilarious how Arthur has less of a reaction to Charles cross-dressing than he does to a prostitute calling herself a lady.
I feel like rep in this game isn't exactly the best. Especially sonny 💀
Like, I don't think I need to explain why having a Jeffrey Dahmer-like character in the game should not be counted as "gay representation"
I don’t know if they were really trying to have gay representation, considering that it was punishable by jail time as of 1885, people probably would do vigilante justice upon you if you were open, and that it was seen as a mental illness until the ‘50s.
1:27 they're homies, not gay, stop making everything gay
John himself writes that they remind him of himself and Abigail lmao
@reflect628 not in a romantic way, in the way they act with each other.
unserious, dumb and arguing for stupid reason
@@THE_RAT99arthur or john even warns them they don't like "groups of men" around here. They are absolutely gay.
I was pretty confused if Alden was gay or it was just a weird accent, after he did have a misses.
Bro😂😂😂😂 3:49 that was funny as hell!!!
1:45 MR. WHITE 🤨
Mr black
Sadie definitely told everyone
5:08 blud got clapped by the crocodile
4:23 😳🏃💨
Alden said he has a misses in the Josiah mission
It was a common cover up back then.
@@chandlerbraaten847 yes, back in old Rhodes.
3:51 had me dying🤣😂
3:17 beautiful gay npc is wild💀
0:52 homophobic arc
/j
Relatable
3:59 WAS THAT A BILL COSBY REFRENCE!!?!
Alden does sound like that one guy from Family Guy
Don’t forget the guy who owns that little shop in saint Dennis he wears very feminine clothes. Theirs also the mayor in strawberry and theirs a couple living in a log cabin outside valentine. And the drunken artist u meet in the saint Dennis little bar
If you're talking about the guy who wants exotic feathers, he's a dandy not gay, dandies just dressed in a fancy "show offy" kind of way
That first guy sounded like juicy (from the boys channel) for five seconds-
E
E
E
E
E
I remember ALden saying he had a wife but yeah come on
Arthur got filled with milk
Noooo 🤮
Other guy got filled with lead
Stop it
@@Slapnuts9627 no
@@victorx6635 I feel like throwing up too tbh
I have a question is Alden the same voice actor as Cleveland Brown?
Yes
@@henselmolina3977 oh cool always thought they sounded similar
alden literally has a wife, he talks about her in the first alden mission with trelawny. mr black and mr white are probably just friends
Alden literally is confirmed gay by the Rhodes bartender saying so, back then gay people couldn't be openly gay, he says she's a bad woman, writes "X" on the bottom of the letters he gives Arthur, which is a love sign
Why did you try too shoot alden?
I dont think Alden is gay. He mentions his wife in one of his lines.
yup, just because his voice may seem it doesnt mean he is gay.
well if we’re trying to be historically accurate here, lots of homosexuals back in that time had wives to cover up their sexuality. like a ton of them.
Look into beards lol
Lots of guys had their facial hair styled to Mutton Chops like that. Its more accurate to history than Arthurs default 5 o clock shadow and stubble.
@@nogunk147 I appreciate your knowledge on facial hair but I was referring to Beard, as in the gay slang term
Yooo! Why he on him like that 🤣 1:24
Best video title ever
"ok ill catch you later then"
So cool that they added LGBTQ people in the game
Not cool at all and it also doesn't make sense because back then gay people would be killed
@@D.The1st That's so dumb.
@@D.The1st How does this make sense? Just admit you're homophobic. They weren't KILLED back then, nececcarily, but it wasn't really accepted yes. Doesn't mean they always were killed. Bill lived. Theres an example
@@D.The1st They still existed you walnut
Alden complained about his wife or girlfriend when he went to him with Trelawny
There's also Vandermatthews!
3:48 ok that was really funny lol
no competition to the gta v barber
Alden's just slightly fruity dawg what😭😭
Honorable mention the Saint Denis vampire.
I had a feeling Alden was gay
Actually, Bill isn't it's a common misconception also I don't think Alden is either nor is the "beautiful man" I think that was a rhetoric statement to make fun of Arthur for starting
hosea literally makes a joke about couples in the beginning with names that rhyme and he goes "bill and phil" and he also knows sonny and talks to arthur about it... its pretty obvious lol
@@knot5542 You might think so but the beginning "bill and phil" was a joke and they laughed at that one afterwards Sonny is an outlier seeing as he is most likely secluded and not there mentally all the way
@@calebandcohengaming9851 yes it was a joke about bill's sexuality... the game is very obviously trying to hint at it without shoving it in your face because even the other gang members have a suspicion too and they know him better than we do. bill still KNEW sonny and, if you were assaulted by sonny, he teases you about it likely believing it was consensual from sonny's accounts. why would sonny and bill have a conversation like that unless they mutually understood that they were both interested in men?
@@knot5542 I'm a little lost when did Bill talk to Sonny? I see your point but unless rockstar says something im not convinced
@@calebandcohengaming9851 after you get assaulted by sonny and if you do not kill him, back at camp bill will interact with you by saying something along the lines of "i was talking to that interesting guy in the swamp, he seemed to know all about you... i mean *ALL* about you.." and arthur reacts very aggressively, hinting that bill WAS referring to the assault
rockstar wont say anything because their story games dont seem very keen on spelling things out to you (unless its introducing a game mechanic).. and plus people complain about having lgbt rep shoved in their face if companies emphasize it lol, i prefer this kind of portrayal, its very discreet like you would've had to be discreet during this time period
sonny is the legendary gay😂