I really enjoy this game though share many of your sentiments - it's quite an eclectic mix of auctions and area control mechanisms. To think this is 20 years old, yet will probably feel fresh to any new players, speaks volumes for how solid Knizia's designs are. While I'd also pick Ra or, perhaps bizarrely, Cyclades over it (I love the simultaneous auction mechanic), I'm really glad Amun-Re hasn't been forgotten about.
Nice video- when explaining the bid you say that you have to move the scribe to a new location if you have been outbid- rather don't you have to use another scribe to bid in a different location? would the bidding turn not be near infinite if you moved the same scribe every time?
@@ChairmanoftheBoard Got it! My mistake, I apologize. It didn't seem clear to me at first but I see now that you eventually auction all 15 locations (In a 5 player game) so each player will end up owning 3 locations?
Just received my KS copy of Amun Re. I really enjoy auction/bidding games like Raccoon Tycoon, Modern Art, High Society. Hope this lives up to my expectations but going by your review it may fall a tad short. Still excited to get it to the table though
I haven't played Amun Re in quite a while. When games have such a 'luck of the draw element', I like to try a community 'river draft' as a means to neutralise/minimise the luck factor - not sure if it would work here.
Since you recently got Ra from UKGE, please share your review about the same. With respect to Amen Re, I feel Ra is a much better bidding game than this one. Also, the mechanism of keeping the stuff on the board and re-start again is there in Blue Lagoon (again by Dr Knizia).
I really enjoy this game though share many of your sentiments - it's quite an eclectic mix of auctions and area control mechanisms. To think this is 20 years old, yet will probably feel fresh to any new players, speaks volumes for how solid Knizia's designs are.
While I'd also pick Ra or, perhaps bizarrely, Cyclades over it (I love the simultaneous auction mechanic), I'm really glad Amun-Re hasn't been forgotten about.
New art looks great!
Great review-
Nice video- when explaining the bid you say that you have to move the scribe to a new location if you have been outbid- rather don't you have to use another scribe to bid in a different location? would the bidding turn not be near infinite if you moved the same scribe every time?
The round ends when everyone is in a different location, so eventually each player will reach their bidding limit and settle on a location
@@ChairmanoftheBoard Got it! My mistake, I apologize. It didn't seem clear to me at first but I see now that you eventually auction all 15 locations (In a 5 player game) so each player will end up owning 3 locations?
Thanks. It looks like it won't be my favorite, but still, I'd love to try it.
Just received my KS copy of Amun Re. I really enjoy auction/bidding games like Raccoon Tycoon, Modern Art, High Society. Hope this lives up to my expectations but going by your review it may fall a tad short. Still excited to get it to the table though
I haven't played Amun Re in quite a while. When games have such a 'luck of the draw element', I like to try a community 'river draft' as a means to neutralise/minimise the luck factor - not sure if it would work here.
Since you recently got Ra from UKGE, please share your review about the same. With respect to Amen Re, I feel Ra is a much better bidding game than this one. Also, the mechanism of keeping the stuff on the board and re-start again is there in Blue Lagoon (again by Dr Knizia).
I've had Ra for years. I only bought the new version at the UKGE. It's one of my favourite games of all time.
This game would be fenomenal if the auction for the terrains was tighter and the cards for points wasn’t so random.