Book launch | ‘Choices: Inside the Making of India’s Foreign Policy’, by Shivshankar Menon

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @bhaskarbholo5497
    @bhaskarbholo5497 6 років тому +15

    India will never forget Dr. Manamohan Singh's commonent on demonitization

    • @shankars4281
      @shankars4281 Рік тому

      India was 11th biggest economy in 2004. India remained 11th biggest economy even after 10 years of great economist rule.
      In 2022, India surpassed Britain and became 5th biggest economy in 7 years of BJP rule! And fastest growing economy in the world.

  • @dr.umashankersingh8223
    @dr.umashankersingh8223 7 років тому +18

    Such a pleasure to listen to the great minds of our age.Brilliant discussion!

    • @hariraghavan1999
      @hariraghavan1999 7 років тому +4

      Chidambaram one of the most corrupt politicians in India. Has caused 1000s of crores of loss to India with his son and being part of the scams.

    • @pathylakshman1059
      @pathylakshman1059 7 років тому +3

      hey idiot, we know you are the RSS man. scam is AG's estimatoin of loss by the Govt. It can not be called as scam. First you just count how many people you have killed in VYAPAM scam.

    • @saurabhkumar619
      @saurabhkumar619 7 років тому +3

      these people are such imposing figures that Jhootly tries to copy PC and menon is just Raghu. Rajan of diplomacy.( charming and sharp)

    • @dparamful
      @dparamful 2 роки тому

      Yes, it takes a sort of bright mind to be extremely corrupt to the degree the Chidambarams are.

  • @rigzinyuthok8527
    @rigzinyuthok8527 4 роки тому

    Awesome! Maharathis of modern India 🇮🇳
    👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @muhammedrazadawoodani7701
    @muhammedrazadawoodani7701 7 років тому +44

    a day will surely come when Indians would understand how important Respected Dr Manmohan Singh was to India.

    • @arifkareemkhan2544
      @arifkareemkhan2544 7 років тому +2

      Raza Dawoodani Totally agree

    • @freethinker-educateagitate2252
      @freethinker-educateagitate2252 7 років тому +6

      yes I full agree with you like pv narasimha raoji dr manmohan singh ji will also remembered in future as one of the great prime minister of india

    • @sravanvedala7811
      @sravanvedala7811 7 років тому +6

      What is that, that is so complicated to understand about Manmohan singh for which we need one lucky day? He is after all a puppet of Italians and a dummy prime minister who was at the helm when several scams happened. He needs to be prosecuted and convicted hardest to show an example to other elite intellectuals to not end up in bad hands.

    • @kapilkpmg
      @kapilkpmg 6 років тому +8

      It's quite hillaroius to see indirect hatred towards Modi in the comment section. BJP will definitely be back in 2019 with far more seats than 2014.

    • @naiyayika
      @naiyayika 2 роки тому +2

      This is now. Once Yogi comes, you'll be like, "Oh Modi was a gem"

  • @tejprakash3561
    @tejprakash3561 5 років тому +3

    reminds one of Chamberlaine's response to Hitler. It took a Churchill to confront the evil.

  • @premprasad3511
    @premprasad3511 7 років тому +6

    Well, you probably ended up giving terrorists exactly what they wanted: NOT RETALIATE AGAINST THEM AGAIN FOR THE ASSUMED FEAR OF GIVING THEM EXACTLY WHAT THEY WANTED BY RETALIATING !!!

  • @iMakeSense
    @iMakeSense 2 роки тому +2

    These are the people whom we trusted in whose hands kept ours and country fate. Good for leisurely spending over a scotch and French fries at India Habitat, nothing more than that. These impotents masquerading as rulers! Shame! Shame!

  • @123lenu
    @123lenu 7 років тому +11

    As much as i respect Menon, It is a shame to accept and agree by this elite that we cannot do much but to push the 70yr old problem to the future generations. This shows decision makers does not have a blue print to solve it when Sardar Patel who was ahead of his time written the blue print to solve Kashmir issue in 1948, you can cut the diamond with only a diamond.
    India always played not to loose, rather to win when it comes to terrorism and dealing with PAK. Playing not to loose, Inherently starting with a weakness. It is time you have play to win, and solve future problem not 70yr old issues. Chibbu references to current govt. was very lame, shows his recklessness politicizing it on issues of national interests.

  • @shankars4281
    @shankars4281 Рік тому

    Imagine Modi as PM during 26/11. He would have declared war on Pakistan. For sure.

  • @sumeetbhosle7627
    @sumeetbhosle7627 3 роки тому +4

    Fragile people trying to look smart on security matters of india..Corporate style talk but inaction and lame.. Waste of time.

  • @prasadnarasimha6284
    @prasadnarasimha6284 4 роки тому

    .
    As long as Kashmir is a dispute and we don't accept it the India Pak imbroglio will be insoluble

  • @saurabhgopal1953
    @saurabhgopal1953 4 роки тому +10

    This man, being an ex PM, cannot even take a seat on his own in a talkshop and stands on the podium cluelessly like a statue with hands folded, and they want us to believe manmohan had a say in governance for 10 years. Oh, please.
    Subservient men cannot be an administrator, only god knows how good an economist he was.

    • @zarvanali888
      @zarvanali888 4 роки тому +5

      He is the only reason you morons got respect around the world. His economic policies made you a economic power and Modi is making sure that you loose all the progress you made.

    • @jayaramj8497
      @jayaramj8497 3 роки тому +2

      classy people do not want to take the center stage and have all the cameras pointed at them all the time...

    • @naiyayika
      @naiyayika 2 роки тому

      @@zarvanali888 😂

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 2 місяці тому

    Quarrel is some thing like you are not like me.

  • @archanakrishna6240
    @archanakrishna6240 6 років тому +5

    this is ridiculous..
    y wasent dr.singh not amongst the panel of people who would discuss the issues..i feel its insulting to just invite someone so eminent just to open the ribbons..wer there a shortage of one more seat? i stopped watching the vid wen i saw dr.singh being ushered away!he was the most intelligent person in the upa its a shame v din get to hear him speak

    • @aleph0x
      @aleph0x 5 років тому

      I am quite sure that he would have been asked, after all it is a book launch and publicity is the primary purpose. A former PM participating in a public discussion on recent affairs would have been a coup. He must have refused. Thankfully there is no shortage of his writing or speeches.

  • @mc7685
    @mc7685 7 років тому +9

    One can see how lame and lackluster they were with absolutely no spine and no one was in charge of anything. So now When Modi is decisive and takes action, and people praise him all they can do is become jealous. Could this govt think of anything even remotely close to surgical strike?

    • @gowtham236
      @gowtham236 5 років тому +3

      You either didnt watch the video or you couldnt understand it.

  • @tarunkadian2
    @tarunkadian2 2 роки тому

    Needs no introduction
    *Goes on to Introduce him*

  • @sravanvedala7811
    @sravanvedala7811 7 років тому +8

    Oh my god... all the scoundrels are in one place...

  • @paragvade
    @paragvade 7 років тому +2

    Disappointed with the arguments of members of panel. Giving credit of less external aggression between 2009-2013 to daily meeting of chidambaram with defence secretary, nsa, etc and attributing recent attacks on military camps to the discontinuation of the such meetings is childish and unintelligent of former defence minister.

  • @KM-ff2gm
    @KM-ff2gm 4 роки тому +4

    Why do they speak in a way that they know it all and they are like pundits, and people who witness things are fool? Indian military is the weakest under UPA thus...Pakistan was ok with everything...the moment we started increasing strength the cease fire risen. UPA let them do what they wanted to do...so everything was quiet. BJP stood up to Pakistan's ill thoughts...thus they retaliated. It's simple.

    • @ssaravinth
      @ssaravinth 4 роки тому

      You are absolutely right sir.. what we can expect from the flock which looted this country and the reason for many downtrodden systems, despite these, they are derisive this present Government. this is where Shashi ji and Jairam had come up with statements that demonizing the NDA Government for the their good deeds will not lead the INC anywhere and will also earn the annoyance from the people.

  • @NoobMaster-or2jf
    @NoobMaster-or2jf 4 роки тому +6

    I just wasted over 1 hour of my life for this useless interview.

    • @rigzinyuthok8527
      @rigzinyuthok8527 4 роки тому

      Apne local adda pey jao... Arnab is waiting for you with the new exclamation, ‘Thukta hai Bharat’ 😅😅😅🤫🤫🤫

  • @hamanthkumar3843
    @hamanthkumar3843 7 років тому

    Better take back that word

  • @iMakeSense
    @iMakeSense 2 роки тому

    Shameful! Covering up in Linguistic jugglary.

  • @Roman-br2qr
    @Roman-br2qr 6 років тому +4

    jokers

  • @Trader--_Nitin
    @Trader--_Nitin 6 років тому +2

    I'm shameful these cowards are leading us ..shame

  • @shivambisht
    @shivambisht 8 років тому +5

    brookings called manmohan whose foriegn policy was broke..job well done