Should an IAS officer be allowed to preach?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
  • The IAS officer who has been warned to stop preaching says he will challenge the government over his Fundamental Right to practice his religion. But is his conduct becoming of a serving IAS officer? He joins us on the debate.
    Watch more videos: www.ndtv.com/vi...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 99

  • @paulfoodrecipes7615
    @paulfoodrecipes7615 8 років тому +48

    MUST ALLOWED.,.,!!!IAS UMA SHANKAR IS NOT PREACH ABOUT RELIGION.,,.,!!!HE IS PREACH ABOUT CHRIST,.,!!!

    • @frozenprakash
      @frozenprakash 7 років тому +3

      Worst and disgusting IAS Officer ever seen in my life.

    • @mariadias7058
      @mariadias7058 4 роки тому +3

      @Muthusamy Suppiah religion was created by man. Christ came to have a relation with people. And if you think Christ came to establish a religion then you have no idea who Christ is.

  • @saleshloyola2187
    @saleshloyola2187 6 років тому +53

    Why don't you ask our Uttarpradesh Prime minister Yogi Adithyanath about article 14 of our constitution.

    • @vivekk2536
      @vivekk2536 4 роки тому +1

      Foreign cults are not allowed.

    • @relaxnow9972
      @relaxnow9972 4 роки тому +1

      Lovely!!!!

    • @savedchristian4754
      @savedchristian4754 2 роки тому +5

      @@vivekk2536
      Jesus did parihaarams for human sins but no other gods have done so.

    • @majormohitsharma7701
      @majormohitsharma7701 Рік тому

      @@vivekk2536 then moron target the Brahmins who are also foreigners many of them still have caucasian features and they migrated from Europe and they also follow Aryan supremecy and these small group is not stopped by millions of Indians. Still they are ruling. So go home and sleep kid.

  • @Tysin000
    @Tysin000 5 років тому +24

    Even modi n yogi speak publicly about Hinduism no one say anything, this is indian public..

  • @jesuscatherinejennifer30
    @jesuscatherinejennifer30 6 років тому +51

    I feel to cry for Mr umashanker who is been pressurized by everybody but on the other side I feel very happy for his greatest reward in the heaven JESUS IS WITH U U GO IN SIR

    • @relaxnow9972
      @relaxnow9972 4 роки тому +3

      Very very true....I just for Gods Grace towards those who are against Brother Uma Shankar.

    • @Auspicious777
      @Auspicious777 2 роки тому

      Amen 🙂😇 they never gonna stop us
      Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? Shall trouble or hardship or persecution or famine or nakedness or danger or sword? Nothing can stop us our Lord Jesus with us.

    • @Harivims
      @Harivims Рік тому

      Nobody pressuring him to stop preach whatever religion he wants to preach but not as an IAS officer.

    • @majormohitsharma7701
      @majormohitsharma7701 Рік тому

      @@Harivims an ias officer is not indian ?

    • @Harivims
      @Harivims Рік тому

      @@majormohitsharma7701 did I said he is not Indian?
      Pls read my comment properly, seems you commented while you were boozing.

  • @mananjanger3599
    @mananjanger3599 6 років тому +37

    then why Yogi Baba is Cm of UP

    • @mansibisht6768
      @mansibisht6768 4 роки тому +1

      He is not a preacher ,a politician not an ias

    • @relaxnow9972
      @relaxnow9972 4 роки тому

      Well said..

    • @jeyaseelandevavaram2371
      @jeyaseelandevavaram2371 Рік тому

      @@mansibisht6768 he is a chief minister..not a politician.he should not do propaganda for hiduism or cow-ism since he took oath as minister for his state ...

  • @moorthyc8807
    @moorthyc8807 5 років тому +17

    Umashankar sir you are correct , God bless you

  • @--..--.-.
    @--..--.-. 6 років тому +18

    Preaching and praying for others after working hours is his prerogative.

  • @jeroandrew2742
    @jeroandrew2742 7 років тому +34

    We stand with uma shankar IAS

  • @designstudio2374
    @designstudio2374 7 років тому +27

    i am a hindu and i am against religious atrocities , especially when generated to people who are good disciplined and committed to a good social change. here in this debate i find some of ur views are foolish and it is against a community and it is against a religion. Uma sankar is a very straight forward officer and he is like Sagayam IAS and UMA SHANKAR's CAPACITY HAS NOT BEEN KNOWN TO THE FULL PUBLIC . WHAT A PERSON HE IS!!! U all DONT KNO AND IF U HAVE GUTS ? BETTER U SHUD GO AND INVESTGATE ALL CORRUPT IAS OFFICERS, AND NOT A SINCERE OFFICER LIKE HIM. THE STATE GOVT HAS NOT USED HIS FULL POTENTIAL DUE TO HIS STRAIGHT FORWARDNESS AND FOR HIS RELIGIOUS VIEWS - whats wrong IF HE IS RELIGIOUS .HE BEING RELIGIOUS IS GOOD FOR THE SOCIETY - he can change bad people into good people there by bringing down corruption and reducing crimes. if a person is a dalith , do u all think u can toss him up and down...
    did Umashankar steal money, did he take part in corruption , has he amazed wealth. y r u torturing good people.
    nallavana valha vidungha da
    உமா சங்கர் என்ன திருட சொன்னாரா , மது குடிக்க சொல்றரா, தேச விரோத செயல்களில் ஈடு பட சொன்னாரா.... ஹே நல்ல மனிதனா வாழுங்க தான் சொல்லறாரு .. ஏன்டா உங்களுக்கு வேற ஆளே கெடைக்கலயா , தலித் நான் என்ன வேணாலும் பன்னுவீஙகள

  • @pradeepcool1199
    @pradeepcool1199 8 років тому +49

    hatsoff sir......ur reward is in heaven dont worry abt dis sinful world

  • @tamarabala4769
    @tamarabala4769 6 років тому +21

    SANYASI BECAME PRIME MINISTER IN U.P...AND CALLING THE CHRISTIANS TO HIS RELIGION...NO ONE BOTHER ABOUT...BUT...AN I A S OFFICER TRY TO PREACH GUIDE AND TEACH SPECIALLY EDIFY THE PEOPLE TO BE FEAR TO GOD AND MAINTAIN THE HOLY LIFE IS WRONG...WOW...

  • @relaxnow9972
    @relaxnow9972 4 роки тому +6

    Well said Mr.Sanjay Pinto for being unbiased and speaking the truth. May God Bless you and your family greatly....

  • @writerhealthelite6574
    @writerhealthelite6574 4 роки тому +8

    Uma sankar is 100% gentleman

  • @himavarshini3461
    @himavarshini3461 4 роки тому +6

    Rule is Rule, Rule for All. If this question is valid it should imply to every politician and officer. Also, one has the right to preach his religion. Being an IAS officer doesn't mean he is an atheist.

  • @sureshlakshon7109
    @sureshlakshon7109 7 років тому +23

    hatsoff umashanker sir.

  • @saleshloyola2187
    @saleshloyola2187 6 років тому +21

    A Person by name Arnab Goswami (Most intelligent Person in India) Questions this very same Uma shankar. Arnab, Why don't you ask our Uttarpradesh Prime minister Yogi Adithyanath about article 14 of our constitution.
    our mainstream media are cheerleaders of BJP.

  • @Messi-uy4og
    @Messi-uy4og 7 років тому +7

    he can preach gospel without offending other religions...

  • @saffronshadow
    @saffronshadow 7 років тому +20

    Umashankar sir keep preaching we support u

  • @jayasree5130
    @jayasree5130 3 роки тому +3

    God bless you Sir, God be with you Sir 🙏

  • @jayd4895
    @jayd4895 4 роки тому +3

    May God have mercy on all those who have given adverse comments, though they have eyes,they are blind, though they have ears they are deaf.This life here on earth is just a temporary journey, true life is how and where we are going to spend our eternity,May God have mercy on all of you.

  • @sherlinevinisha8689
    @sherlinevinisha8689 5 років тому +5

    God bless u both.u reveal the truth.

  • @neetinsuryawanshi0
    @neetinsuryawanshi0 5 років тому +4

    why yogi adityanath in UP still do pooja ... is he not pandit now? or is he not allowed to preach about his religion .... what a joke you all are talking about. Be honest...n dont use your knowledge n power to dominate other people... you bjp ppl will face God's judgement very soon... Jesus is coming!

    • @mansibisht6768
      @mansibisht6768 4 роки тому +1

      Preaching is different

    • @majormohitsharma7701
      @majormohitsharma7701 Рік тому

      @@mansibisht6768 aah different how ? When Modi and Yogi both use your religion as publicity and millions of people think they are honestly worshipping their gods without anything to achieve however it is better to argue they are worshipping in front of 4k camaras anyways that's not my wish to judge. It is ain't preaching. Who stopped hindu from preaching. Did you ever read what indian constitution offers its citizens ?

  • @christophergnanaoli1369
    @christophergnanaoli1369 4 роки тому +5

    You can see the Hindu temple in side the every government offices campus and also can see every top of the head....

  • @josephprem88
    @josephprem88 8 років тому +8

    its his right to preach but who ask people to listen? its everyones right to do what they like.

    • @sam195027
      @sam195027 7 років тому

      Joseph Prem thats why missionarys gets beaten by us my wish i can do anything

    • @olam123ol9
      @olam123ol9 6 років тому

      Ask those people who beat missionaries, what happen after then? How is their lives? What they are facing ask them?

    • @anantguru8244
      @anantguru8244 3 роки тому

      @@sam195027 Thats crime, preaching a faith is fundamental right

    • @majormohitsharma7701
      @majormohitsharma7701 Рік тому

      @@sam195027 yeah moron propagate your religion like Islam and then blame them for being not 'peaceful'. Yet here we are. Go around the world proclaiming Hinduism is a peaceful religion but deep down beat the ones who are in minority not even in majority shows how much weak you are. The man who prays on weak is a small cat.

  • @anishalenin2896
    @anishalenin2896 4 роки тому +3

    Sir you will preach about Jesus
    Jesus always with you.

  • @gretapicardo9516
    @gretapicardo9516 5 років тому +2

    listen to the testimony of shrinivas bhattacharya rajkumar rajkumar anand pillai Fatima

  • @bendangwatilongkumer4829
    @bendangwatilongkumer4829 5 років тому +1

    What is wrong with preaching or chanting gods name..under what crime this chanting of God's name will be lodge. Doesn't all normal person of every religions who believes in God... Do that.. Why is it a big issue for a Christian who do that... Isn't india a secular country where no one will be discriminated on the basis of religion where he or she can practice any religion..why this has become a big issue.. Rather focus on development, racial discrimination, abuses on women, religious intolerance.. Rather focus on indian Constitution and Preamble... Where everyone s equal in the eyes of the law..

  • @IUSB28
    @IUSB28 6 років тому +4

    Umashankar super da

  • @indnamelord7125
    @indnamelord7125 6 років тому +1

    Wt a pitty arnoub. If one is a government officer. Bt he also hv his private life. Wt he wnts to do. Does ne one hs d power to question yoghi adtyanat. Y is HW a cm though being a public service man

  • @manjunathnayak8158
    @manjunathnayak8158 5 років тому +1

    Sub....sami is not constitution they are astrol person what are telling about Jesus followers first go to read well our constitution don't un educate type taking about religion so.... IAS officer they are not terrist give the respect

  • @ravitrichur6350
    @ravitrichur6350 5 років тому

    One is by the service rules . The contract between the employer and the employed. If the employer objects then UMA SHANKAR has to give up his preaching. Mr Uma shankar can resign and preach inside a church in which case he can preach and exercise his fundamental right. If everything goes by fundamental right then service rules has no meaning and it becomes ULTRA VIRES at the foundation itself and no contract can be executed on the basis of fundamental rights. In UP whatever the YOGI does there is no objection by the government and he is a elected representative. Mr Uma shankar is an employee of his employer. We understand that Uma shankar is engaged in conversion also but asking friends to come to church which fact can be verified. .

  • @miltonmoses
    @miltonmoses 4 роки тому

    Sick people like you can't stop the spread of Word Of God.
    Whether I'm IAS or PM my constitution provides right to practice my religion.
    Preaching is not an other Job for the officer so why all of you are debating leaving all the nonsense going on in the country.
    This is the reason we're undeveloped.
    This is the reason for Indian media houses has no respect.
    Remember that you people are troubling one clean soul for nothing...

  • @AjayKumar-vt5mb
    @AjayKumar-vt5mb 8 років тому

    y u people doing debut on this issue. So many issues in the world y should be on this, why because your getting many from other issues but hear no many. you bleady..

  • @JESUSCHRIST-jw3tb
    @JESUSCHRIST-jw3tb 3 роки тому

    🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷

  • @pazhanirajarv6013
    @pazhanirajarv6013 7 років тому +3

    Let him preach after tendering his resignation, and prove his worth.

    • @majormohitsharma7701
      @majormohitsharma7701 Рік тому

      Then our pm and cm of up should step down and then show off their religious status.

  • @stagss
    @stagss 8 років тому +5

    umari shankar is not only preaching about Christ but offending Hinduism and Islam. put him in jail if he don't obey.

    • @alphapolarfrequency2787
      @alphapolarfrequency2787 7 років тому

      Sunil Nair Where?

    • @alphapolarfrequency2787
      @alphapolarfrequency2787 7 років тому +2

      Sunil Nair Even you guys complaint about islam.

    • @sofy937
      @sofy937 6 років тому +4

      U guys are comedy when are u going to realise the truth. Jesus is the only one god in this universe.

    • @Attitudezero884
      @Attitudezero884 6 років тому

      Sofiya Manivannan for u not for us engalluku keka avasimiyam illa u r free to leave india if u don’t like us hindus

    • @relaxnow9972
      @relaxnow9972 4 роки тому

      @@Attitudezero884 No one forced you to listen...

  • @gayathiriyatri2413
    @gayathiriyatri2413 7 років тому +1

    uma shankar made joker

    • @majormohitsharma7701
      @majormohitsharma7701 Рік тому

      Nope i think he is more sensible if we compare him to religious customs and beliefs of the major religion of India.

  • @jayamsiva9816
    @jayamsiva9816 5 років тому

    umasankar ollso mendal

    • @relaxnow9972
      @relaxnow9972 4 роки тому

      First of all please confirm if you are sane, then criticize others...