I had thought that the diary was in Lucius' possession because Voldemort gave it to him for safekeeping (at some point before his ill-fated attack on Harry's parents at Goderic's Hollow in 1981), without specifically telling him what it was. I attributed much of Voldemort's scorn for the Malfoys after his return to be due to his anger at Lucius for using the diary so carelessly, leading to its destruction.
The diary was able to communicate with both Ginny and Harry. It might have communicated with Lucius as well. Lucius might not have known about the chamber of secrets or the basilisk. He may have known that Tom Riddle wanted to be resurrected. The diary may have asked him to find a way to get it into Hogwarts without telling him exactly what it was planning to do.
The idea of hiding dark arts materials from the bureau at that point in the story would have made for an interesting spinoff. Maybe not a full TV series, but one movie where a notable manor is raided and the dark arts gets it's moment of glory going down.
I’d like to think that Lucius had a tiny bit of regret for putting such an innocent and young girl in such unbelievable danger, but he’s guilty of attempted murder and domestic terrorism in this situation
Hum 😲 I'm not so sure. There was the Malfoys/Weasley blood feud. So no I don't think so, the only regret Lucius would have was first being found out. Second Riddle reaction to the loss of the diary, of course at that time Lucius thought Riddle wasn't coming back.
He has zero regret. He was going to pin it on Harry until he ran into the Weasley's and then slid it in to her basket. Lucius is a piece of garbage only hoping to get some revenge on someone who he despises.
It makes me wonder why voldemort never bred some basilisks after he was revived in the goblet of fire you think hatching a few chicken eggs underneath a toad would be an easy thing to make some powerfull weapons that he mostly alone can control
Basilisks have a great vulnerability to rooster cries, so they could be hard to raise, hard to use (stare kills indiscriminately), and relatively easy to counter (with a rooster).
Because a bunch of children would’ve been killed in the second book in the series, including one of the main characters. You just have to assume that the basilisk believes its stare to be enough.
The thing I thought about is why does it even have venom when it can kill with its stare, and even if it couldn't for what ever reason it's friggin huge it could be just as threatening with its size and teeth it can just swallow you whole in one bite it doesn't need venom it's overkill at that point
Somebody pointed this out but I can't remember where that the page that Hermione had in her hand when she was petrified is not from Hogwarts because if it was Hermione would never destroy a book. She just copied the information down on a piece of paper instead. Also in the same scene just before Lucius comes in Draco rips a page out of a book. At first you don't realize until later that it might be the same page that Hermione found. She probably was at the library.
he specifically said in the book that he learned it from listening to Harry…hell, he was with Harry when he opened it second year so recalled the soubds
Ron Weasley only imitated what he heard out of Harry's mouth during nightmares and talking in his sleep. He didn't *speak* Parseltongue. Nor did he have the ability to converse or control serpents the way those natural born Dark Wizards tend to be able to do. Sure you could learn it, but I doubt that intangible quality to connect with the serpent is there.
@@auranoxhighpriestess5475 I still speak Spanish despite not being totally fluent. I am mimicking what I've heard. Same works for swedish. I don't fully understand and comprehend the language, yet. I continue to mimic the sounds that I hear in order to communicate with those who are more fluent than myself.
The diary belonged to Mooning Merdel, Tom took as a trophy or something he could use as a horcrux. Remember Merdel was muggle born and she got the diary before school that year, to write down who was teasing her. The only one I can't figure is the Diadem, because who owned, he didn't kill because she already died.
Excellent theory 😊! But I think he was killing 2 birds with one stone. Aside from making sure he wasn't in possession of the diary anymore, I believe he was also wanting to test Harry. After Draco told his parents all of what happened that school year, Lucius wanted to see if Potter had any exceptional magical skills or was it just dumb luck on his side. Even though he wasn't a fan of the Weasleys, he wasn't trying to kill Ginny. And if him and Narcissa knew that diary was a horcrux, who better to destroy it than Harry; since the Malfoys didn't try to look for or help Voldemort in any way.
Basically the Arthur is the catalyst of both plots 2-3. The Muggle Protection Act and taking his family to Egypt results in Lucius’ attempt to discredit his family and Sirius locating Pettigrew due to the Weasley family having their vacation picture taken for the paper.
While parseltongue may not be learnt fluently, some sounds may be repeated. Ron was able to pronounce some of Harry's repeated noises, and was able to open the chamber in the last book, for himself and Hermione to retrieve some basilisk's teeth to destroy horcrux
Lucius only new that the book contained very powerful dark magic and he was instructed by Voldemort to get the diary to school where the events would take place as usual, strengthen him, a whole lot more. It would have meant that Hogwarts would have played host to a phantom version of You know who. If succeeded, the spirt would have come out of the diary and floated around the place, behaving like anyone else. He would have been corporal and not solid. ...mmm.... I would imagine that would be been terrifying. Two of them about and nothing to stop this one. However, he fell before he gave the orders, so Lucius just did it as a power trip and out of spit to destroy the Weasley clan and discredit Arthur because of the fight in the book shop, the rivalry, the ministry raids, and because his so called Embarrassment of them. He then hoped to use his position of governor to remove Albus and Hagrid, use them as scapegoats so he can officially take over the place, turn it into an hostile pure blood extremist place that practiced the dark arts that would have punished those who was involved in making Voldemort disappear. However, luckily his plan failed.
I definitely believe Parselmouth could be learned You have Dumbledore who learned to understand it (he knew what Morfin & Marvolo were discussing when he took Harry into Bob Ogdens memory) And Ron who learned to speak it (he spoke it to open the Chamber of Secrets in DH, explaining that he just copied noises he’s heard Harry make before) Neither Dumbledore nor Ron were Parselmouths
I think Lucius Malfoy had no clear, certain idea what the value of Tom Riddle's old diary was. He was too much of a bungler, much as the British aristocracy of the 18th century is frequently caricatured.
I think you missed one important thing. Lucius knew Tom was a charming teen and Ginny would fall for his charms. That Genny would be an easy target once Tom sapped enough of her life force to appear. Not to mention it would be a double stab at Mr. Weasley when it was learned Genny opened the chamber of secrets and had died in there.
Imagine if Lucious oppened the diary and it started to talk to him (like it did to Ginny and Harry) and instructed him to take the diary to Hogwarts? So how would he do it? Well, giving it to Draco was the safest way, it may seem. But of course, he won't incriminate his son in case things were terribly wrong. So what better way than to give it to one child of his archienemy? 🤔
One other reason. Hogwarts students belonging weren't checked that year so it was a good place to hide anything to do with the dark arts. By giving it to someone who would know little about the dark arts it could easily be used without questioning the danger out of all the younger generation there Ginny was the easiest target since she had just gotten her first cauldron. Its easier to slip something in there as there was no lid than trying to slip it into one of the shopping bags.
Clearly parseltongue can be learned, Ron wasn't born with the ability but he and Hermione were able to gain entry into the chamber of secrets in the deathly hollows bc he heard Harry speaking it in his sleep, now that's a form of learning is it not. 🤷
You can bark like a dog without every understanding the language... ...or as soon as you say woof is that you fluent in K9... ...probably not... Apply the theory to Ron... He had no idea or understanding of what he was saying... ..he did not learn the language
Parseltongue can be learned... Ron uses it to open the chamber so that he and Hermione can get a basilisk fang... and there's evidence that Dumbledor learned it since he appears to be able to understand the Gaunts. While this COULD be something where he "guessed" based on context, if you pay attention to the stuff the Gaunts say in parseltongue, there are a few things that Dumbledor would really only know if he understood the language. People born as parselmouths do seem to have an added benefit of being able to control snake as well as converse with them, and, of course, they wouldn't have to study/practice to learn to be a parselmouth, but there us every indication that people can LEARN it.
Ron Weasley only imitated what he heard out of Harry's mouth during nightmares and talking in his sleep. He didn't *speak* Parseltongue. Nor did he have the ability to converse or control serpents the way those natural born Dark Wizards tend to be able to do. Sure you could learn it, but I doubt that intangible quality to connect with the serpent is there.
Maybe Lucius did, just like Harry, "chat" with Voldemort through the diary. In this case, Voldemort would tell him his true identity directly and ask him to smuggle the diary into Hogwarts.
It can't be 92 as Harry gose to Hogwarts in 1999 as evident by the fact the newest Broom mobile available that year is the Nimbus 2000 just like a car mobile coming out in 1999
Parslemouth can be learnt, Ron learnt some from Harry which he used to get into the chamber during the battle of hogwarts. Also it makes no sense that Hermione ripped a page out of a book due to her love of books
@@donnakay147 he didn’t speak it but he knew how to say open up as Harry said that in English first before saying it in parselmouth. You are right he didn’t speak to a snake but from him being able to copy the noise Harry made I’m sure it could be learnt but I think it’s too much hassle to learn x
@lucybarnard3954 I get the impression it was more luck that opened the chamber over Ron actually speaking sounds with knowing and understanding... ...remember in the books, he had a few goes...and admits himself he didn't know what he was doing... ...that's not learning... ...that's what we call winging it with some luck on the side
All he did was mimic the sounds he heard Harry make when Harry opened the locket earlier in the year. It was even said that it took him a few tries to get it right. Ron wouldn't have been able to communicate with an actual snake doing that, but it was enough to trigger the enchantment on the Chamber entrance.
So Harry didn’t need to say open? They just needed to make snake sounds at the door? Also hearing a language and repeating patterns is how language is learned. I’m standing by my thing.
I hear Spanish and can sound Spanish but I don't understand the language and what it means therefore I did not learn Spanish.... ...apply this theory to Ron... ...he learned nothing except how to sound like a snake
Perhaps the room was used for something else at the time Slytherin created the Chamber, as "restrooms" in castles in the 900s (known as "garderobes") were much smaller and built into small, closet-like recesses in the castles outer walls . It may have been centuries after Slytherin's time that the room whare the Chamber's entrance was made into a girls' restroom. The staff of the school at that time would have been completely oblivious to the fact that the entrance to the Chamber was located there...
the diadem, locket, and ring were all hidden by Voldemort personally. Nagini and Harry were never hidden. Huffkepuff’s cup was sent to the Lestrange vault for protection but never given to Bellatrix. that leaves just the diary given and may well have been stolen instead of given especially as Voldemort wouldn’t trust something like that to a sneaky weasel like Malfoy
@bostonrailfan2427 Actually...when Bellatrix loses her "stuff" over the sword being in the possession of Harry and company the words that she used gave Harry the notion that something else might be in the Lestrage vault...this is what gives Harry the idea to go to Gringotts in the first place This is how we know Lestrage had an item...it is speculated she knew neither what it was or its function but she knew it was there (a pretty trinket of hufflepuff) given to the Lestrage's to look after...whether Voldemort personally gave it to her or he sent it to the vault it maths out to be the same... ...he gave it to her for protection And yeah...you're right about the other horcruxes..he did keep those quiet...although he did have Regulus be a part of the hiding of the locket horcrux, i would have to read the Hallows again to remember specifically if Regulus was aware of what the horcrux was... ...but he certainly knew it was dangerous item of sorts and trusted Kreature the house elf to detroy it...giving his own life in the process...which suggest his death eaters were installed with some type of trust in protecting some of Voldemorts interests whether they knew what they were or not
I had thought that the diary was in Lucius' possession because Voldemort gave it to him for safekeeping (at some point before his ill-fated attack on Harry's parents at Goderic's Hollow in 1981), without specifically telling him what it was. I attributed much of Voldemort's scorn for the Malfoys after his return to be due to his anger at Lucius for using the diary so carelessly, leading to its destruction.
The diary was able to communicate with both Ginny and Harry. It might have communicated with Lucius as well. Lucius might not have known about the chamber of secrets or the basilisk. He may have known that Tom Riddle wanted to be resurrected. The diary may have asked him to find a way to get it into Hogwarts without telling him exactly what it was planning to do.
The idea of hiding dark arts materials from the bureau at that point in the story would have made for an interesting spinoff. Maybe not a full TV series, but one movie where a notable manor is raided and the dark arts gets it's moment of glory going down.
I’d like to think that Lucius had a tiny bit of regret for putting such an innocent and young girl in such unbelievable danger, but he’s guilty of attempted murder and domestic terrorism in this situation
😑
Hum 😲 I'm not so sure. There was the Malfoys/Weasley blood feud. So no I don't think so, the only regret Lucius would have was first being found out. Second Riddle reaction to the loss of the diary, of course at that time Lucius thought Riddle wasn't coming back.
He didnt seem to have an issue trying to cast the killing curse on young, innocent Harry when he gave him back the diary
I think confused regret with amusement
He has zero regret. He was going to pin it on Harry until he ran into the Weasley's and then slid it in to her basket. Lucius is a piece of garbage only hoping to get some revenge on someone who he despises.
It makes me wonder why voldemort never bred some basilisks after he was revived in the goblet of fire you think hatching a few chicken eggs underneath a toad would be an easy thing to make some powerfull weapons that he mostly alone can control
Basilisks have a great vulnerability to rooster cries, so they could be hard to raise, hard to use (stare kills indiscriminately), and relatively easy to counter (with a rooster).
Plus Death Eaters and Nagini can follow his orders on who to kill or spare and capture unless needed.
I think Lucius Malfoy is the reason why Voldemort has failed.
Thanks to Malfoy Harry and Dumbledore learned about Voldemort horcruxes.
Huge plot hole, why didn't the basilisk bite the victims it petrified?
bites those that threaten it, petrified aren’t threats to it…
Because a bunch of children would’ve been killed in the second book in the series, including one of the main characters. You just have to assume that the basilisk believes its stare to be enough.
The thing I thought about is why does it even have venom when it can kill with its stare, and even if it couldn't for what ever reason it's friggin huge it could be just as threatening with its size and teeth it can just swallow you whole in one bite it doesn't need venom it's overkill at that point
Possibly because they’re petrified? Meaning turned to stone this no longer a threat.
For fear of chipping a tooth?
Somebody pointed this out but I can't remember where that the page that Hermione had in her hand when she was petrified is not from Hogwarts because if it was Hermione would never destroy a book. She just copied the information down on a piece of paper instead. Also in the same scene just before Lucius comes in Draco rips a page out of a book. At first you don't realize until later that it might be the same page that Hermione found. She probably was at the library.
Nope
in the book, it explicitly states that the page was torn from a library book
2:05 Uhm Ron spoke parseltongue to open the chamber. Having heard Harry he imitated from memory....or am I from a different universe?
Nope, he did it in book 7 and 7 part 2 movie.
he specifically said in the book that he learned it from listening to Harry…hell, he was with Harry when he opened it second year so recalled the soubds
Ron Weasley only imitated what he heard out of Harry's mouth during nightmares and talking in his sleep. He didn't *speak* Parseltongue. Nor did he have the ability to converse or control serpents the way those natural born Dark Wizards tend to be able to do. Sure you could learn it, but I doubt that intangible quality to connect with the serpent is there.
@@auranoxhighpriestess5475 I still speak Spanish despite not being totally fluent. I am mimicking what I've heard. Same works for swedish. I don't fully understand and comprehend the language, yet. I continue to mimic the sounds that I hear in order to communicate with those who are more fluent than myself.
I thought I misheard what he said. I also remember Ron using it to open the chamber of secrets
The diary belonged to Mooning Merdel, Tom took as a trophy or something he could use as a horcrux. Remember Merdel was muggle born and she got the diary before school that year, to write down who was teasing her. The only one I can't figure is the Diadem, because who owned, he didn't kill because she already died.
Excellent theory 😊! But I think he was killing 2 birds with one stone. Aside from making sure he wasn't in possession of the diary anymore, I believe he was also wanting to test Harry. After Draco told his parents all of what happened that school year, Lucius wanted to see if Potter had any exceptional magical skills or was it just dumb luck on his side. Even though he wasn't a fan of the Weasleys, he wasn't trying to kill Ginny. And if him and Narcissa knew that diary was a horcrux, who better to destroy it than Harry; since the Malfoys didn't try to look for or help Voldemort in any way.
Basically the Arthur is the catalyst of both plots 2-3. The Muggle Protection Act and taking his family to Egypt results in Lucius’ attempt to discredit his family and Sirius locating Pettigrew due to the Weasley family having their vacation picture taken for the paper.
Awesome as always thanks ❤
While parseltongue may not be learnt fluently, some sounds may be repeated. Ron was able to pronounce some of Harry's repeated noises, and was able to open the chamber in the last book, for himself and Hermione to retrieve some basilisk's teeth to destroy horcrux
Would be more interresting to know why Lucius had the diary. Who gave it to him ? And why ?
That's been answered. Read the books.
It says it in the video
@FrostDJakki3529
I love that comment
And here I thought he did it because he thought it would bring back Voldy.
Lucius only new that the book contained very powerful dark magic and he was instructed by Voldemort to get the diary to school where the events would take place as usual, strengthen him, a whole lot more. It would have meant that Hogwarts would have played host to a phantom version of You know who. If succeeded, the spirt would have come out of the diary and floated around the place, behaving like anyone else. He would have been corporal and not solid. ...mmm.... I would imagine that would be been terrifying. Two of them about and nothing to stop this one.
However, he fell before he gave the orders, so Lucius just did it as a power trip and out of spit to destroy the Weasley clan and discredit Arthur because of the fight in the book shop, the rivalry, the ministry raids, and because his so called Embarrassment of them. He then hoped to use his position of governor to remove Albus and Hagrid, use them as scapegoats so he can officially take over the place, turn it into an hostile pure blood extremist place that practiced the dark arts that would have punished those who was involved in making Voldemort disappear.
However, luckily his plan failed.
the flaw in that is that there are people at the school who knew him: Dumbledore would have recognized him and countered him
I definitely believe Parselmouth could be learned
You have Dumbledore who learned to understand it (he knew what Morfin & Marvolo were discussing when he took Harry into Bob Ogdens memory)
And Ron who learned to speak it (he spoke it to open the Chamber of Secrets in DH, explaining that he just copied noises he’s heard Harry make before)
Neither Dumbledore nor Ron were Parselmouths
I think Lucius Malfoy had no clear, certain idea what the value of Tom Riddle's old diary was. He was too much of a bungler, much as the British aristocracy of the 18th century is frequently caricatured.
Notorious and cunning Lucius is...
Surprised none of the Weasleys didn't eventually gut Lucius and leave him to bleed out.
I think you missed one important thing. Lucius knew Tom was a charming teen and Ginny would fall for his charms. That Genny would be an easy target once Tom sapped enough of her life force to appear. Not to mention it would be a double stab at Mr. Weasley when it was learned Genny opened the chamber of secrets and had died in there.
Imagine if Lucious oppened the diary and it started to talk to him (like it did to Ginny and Harry) and instructed him to take the diary to Hogwarts?
So how would he do it? Well, giving it to Draco was the safest way, it may seem. But of course, he won't incriminate his son in case things were terribly wrong. So what better way than to give it to one child of his archienemy? 🤔
One other reason. Hogwarts students belonging weren't checked that year so it was a good place to hide anything to do with the dark arts. By giving it to someone who would know little about the dark arts it could easily be used without questioning the danger out of all the younger generation there Ginny was the easiest target since she had just gotten her first cauldron. Its easier to slip something in there as there was no lid than trying to slip it into one of the shopping bags.
How did Lucius get the Diary? Do you know? That is something I am very curious about that. I love your videos and I really enjoy them.
Clearly parseltongue can be learned, Ron wasn't born with the ability but he and Hermione were able to gain entry into the chamber of secrets in the deathly hollows bc he heard Harry speaking it in his sleep, now that's a form of learning is it not. 🤷
You can bark like a dog without every understanding the language...
...or as soon as you say woof is that you fluent in K9...
...probably not...
Apply the theory to Ron...
He had no idea or understanding of what he was saying...
..he did not learn the language
Parseltongue can be learned... Ron uses it to open the chamber so that he and Hermione can get a basilisk fang... and there's evidence that Dumbledor learned it since he appears to be able to understand the Gaunts. While this COULD be something where he "guessed" based on context, if you pay attention to the stuff the Gaunts say in parseltongue, there are a few things that Dumbledor would really only know if he understood the language.
People born as parselmouths do seem to have an added benefit of being able to control snake as well as converse with them, and, of course, they wouldn't have to study/practice to learn to be a parselmouth, but there us every indication that people can LEARN it.
Ron Weasley only imitated what he heard out of Harry's mouth during nightmares and talking in his sleep. He didn't *speak* Parseltongue. Nor did he have the ability to converse or control serpents the way those natural born Dark Wizards tend to be able to do. Sure you could learn it, but I doubt that intangible quality to connect with the serpent is there.
@@auranoxhighpriestess5475 so you didn't read my whole comment... seeing as I addressed that point... but thanks for the response?
@@gabrielesh7916parseltongue can't be learned it's hereditary
@@gabrielesh7916dumbledore learned to understand it not speak it
Maybe Lucius did, just like Harry, "chat" with Voldemort through the diary. In this case, Voldemort would tell him his true identity directly and ask him to smuggle the diary into Hogwarts.
It can't be 92 as Harry gose to Hogwarts in 1999 as evident by the fact the newest Broom mobile available that year is the Nimbus 2000 just like a car mobile coming out in 1999
Instead of selling couldn't the dark objects be kept in one's gringott's vault?
Parslemouth can be learnt, Ron learnt some from Harry which he used to get into the chamber during the battle of hogwarts.
Also it makes no sense that Hermione ripped a page out of a book due to her love of books
Ron didn't speak actual parselmouth he only made the noise and never understood what he said or spoke to any snake
@@donnakay147 he didn’t speak it but he knew how to say open up as Harry said that in English first before saying it in parselmouth. You are right he didn’t speak to a snake but from him being able to copy the noise Harry made I’m sure it could be learnt but I think it’s too much hassle to learn x
@lucybarnard3954
I get the impression it was more luck that opened the chamber over Ron actually speaking sounds with knowing and understanding...
...remember in the books, he had a few goes...and admits himself he didn't know what he was doing...
...that's not learning...
...that's what we call winging it with some luck on the side
@@donnakay147 I’ve not learnt much in life then I’m just winging it 🤣
@lucybarnard3954
Me too...
🪶I'm surprised the human race hasn't evolved feathers the amount of winging we all do in life 🪽
A very Good Video 👍🏻
If you can’t learn to be a parseltongue then how does Ron open the chamber in the last book?
All he did was mimic the sounds he heard Harry make when Harry opened the locket earlier in the year. It was even said that it took him a few tries to get it right. Ron wouldn't have been able to communicate with an actual snake doing that, but it was enough to trigger the enchantment on the Chamber entrance.
He Heard Harry Speak it in his Sleep..And Just Practice Speaking Parsle-tongue.....
So Harry didn’t need to say open? They just needed to make snake sounds at the door? Also hearing a language and repeating patterns is how language is learned. I’m standing by my thing.
I hear Spanish and can sound Spanish but I don't understand the language and what it means therefore I did not learn Spanish....
...apply this theory to Ron...
...he learned nothing except how to sound like a snake
@@kevins.hollis6433 He copied the word he used to open the locket, he didn’t hear it while Harry slept, read the books.
Was the basilisk in hibernation the whole time, or was it just feeding on rats
Why not just send draco to dramstrung school which was only for pure blooded
Agree.
😊🎉🦁
Harry can prove it.
In the pensieve
Why the Slytherin design his chamber to open in Girl's bathroom?
Me just wondering why he put the entrance to the chamber in the girls restroom to begin with. Kinda creepy, in my opinion.
Perhaps the room was used for something else at the time Slytherin created the Chamber, as "restrooms" in castles in the 900s (known as "garderobes") were much smaller and built into small, closet-like recesses in the castles outer walls . It may have been centuries after Slytherin's time that the room whare the Chamber's entrance was made into a girls' restroom. The staff of the school at that time would have been completely oblivious to the fact that the entrance to the Chamber was located there...
🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁 THE LION WAS HERE 🦁🦁🦁🦁🦁 No. 712
Ginny is the only Weasley girl and the chamber of secrets is located in the girls lavatory 🚺 so it had to be out of all the Weasley children
I thought he did it for sh**s and giggles
Voldemort gave Lucius the diary...
...just like he gave the other horcruxes to the other death eaters....
It's in the book
the diadem, locket, and ring were all hidden by Voldemort personally. Nagini and Harry were never hidden. Huffkepuff’s cup was sent to the Lestrange vault for protection but never given to Bellatrix.
that leaves just the diary given and may well have been stolen instead of given especially as Voldemort wouldn’t trust something like that to a sneaky weasel like Malfoy
@bostonrailfan2427
Actually...when Bellatrix loses her "stuff" over the sword being in the possession of Harry and company the words that she used gave Harry the notion that something else might be in the Lestrage vault...this is what gives Harry the idea to go to Gringotts in the first place
This is how we know Lestrage had an item...it is speculated she knew neither what it was or its function but she knew it was there (a pretty trinket of hufflepuff) given to the Lestrage's to look after...whether Voldemort personally gave it to her or he sent it to the vault it maths out to be the same...
...he gave it to her for protection
And yeah...you're right about the other horcruxes..he did keep those quiet...although he did have Regulus be a part of the hiding of the locket horcrux, i would have to read the Hallows again to remember specifically if Regulus was aware of what the horcrux was...
...but he certainly knew it was dangerous item of sorts and trusted Kreature the house elf to detroy it...giving his own life in the process...which suggest his death eaters were installed with some type of trust in protecting some of Voldemorts interests whether they knew what they were or not
@@donnakay147 actually read the hook, he didn’t give it to her to keep: he gave it to her to protect and hide
@bostonrailfan2427
Read what I said...
...I said..
"Given to her to look after"
"He gave it to her for protection"
So I guess we agree then??
❤️⚡️❤️
Ron and Dumbledore both were able to speak parseltongue.
I think that Ron only knew a couple words of parseltongue.
No not at all
Ron only knew one word
No, not at all
Ron knew only one word
Parseltongue -Not exactly , because after all Ton could repeat after Harry some "phrases", right?
Why dose all the Potter youtubers use the saddest track from the movie. I’d like to enjoy the video with out feeling sad lol
Amazing video.