I was there, I couldn’t believe when he came out and surprised everyone. It was dark so nobody could really tell at first who it was, and then people lost their minds
Wow. Kicking myself now for not overdrawing my bank account to see this. Im a preschool teacher and the beginning of the school year after summer break is always tight money wise. Bob will always have a piece of my heart ❤️
What a Beautiful Dream-- Bob Dylan with the Heart Beakers Band. Tommy Would ❤ This. Am Sure he's Looking Xown from Heaven & Smiling. 😊 This is My FAV Bob Dylan song from the '60'. Brings Tears to my eyes Hearing Bob sing It. THANX Bob for Such Beautiful, Lovely SURPRISE@ 💋 ❤✌
Dylan performing with The Heartbreakers & a new Stones album on the way in 2023…my heart can’t take it! One of the greatest lines ever in this song…”you’d know what a drag it is to see you” Rock on Zimmy
Michael McLoughlin It's great having Bob do this song-the songs he sings are as relevant as they ever were. He still sounds great-I first heard these songs back in the '60s
This performance great enough to shake up even those of us who recognize, but distance themselves from the "worshipers". Spectacular on multiple artistic and human levels.
Bob Looks SO Young Compared to Many of his Peers. U Can See the Silver Sparkles on His Jacket. My ♥ Just Flows Bacto those Beautiful Times in Our Coutry. Hearing him Sing this Song AD Playing Guitar isBessig MyHeart SoMh. That Music is So MAGICAL..& SoIsBob Dylan. 👍 ♥ 💋 xxxooo
Much Thanks to Whomever shot Bobby from thos Angle. Ya Know, This Is My Favorite BD song from the '60's. It's Just Magical to My Heart with All the feelings of that Timme & Era flooding back. Very sweet w just a little bitter. Think is Very Cute how Bob almost chastizes ( is it Mike of HB's) the Guitar player who was standing perhaps too close to Next to him & Bob suddenly flashing his disapproval with just a whip of his head & Mike the guy quickly retreats to the piano player for a couple minutes. Bob's a BOSS & They Respect him ALOT. ♥ Bobby 4ALWAYS 💋 💋 🌹 xxxooo ♥ ✌
The vocals do not quite come through but still : this is Dylan with one of the great songs of his "most classic"period. I write "most classic" because he had lots of them. After a few lesser albums in the seventies he rebounded with BLOOD ON THE TRACKS. Still one of the very best albums of that period. And let us not forget that what he is doing currently is so bloody great. ROUGH AND ROWDY WAYS is another classic !
❤Wonderful Bob he keeps on going Strong he's Amazing I ❤ hearing him sing.I play his songs EVERY DAY and watch videos /concerts. so hes❤❤❤ with me EVERYDAY 😊❤
Babe , Your out there in the world handing out your love and carrying to everyone that hears you...they hear your song...I have total faith and trust....while you are rocking the world; I'm studying Psalm 35 and studying Isaiah...
This is great. Saw him on his most recent tour. He only sits at the keyboards. Maybe he'll change his mind after this. This is my favorite Dylan song. Is that Mike Campbell on guitar?
Love this tune always have just wondering..why does Jacob Dylan not play with his father? Maybe they have a sense of completion on this song they would sound terrific together..Go Bob Go Jacob ..don't be afraid to walk in each others shoes...♥️♥️
His only concession to being an octogenarian is occasionally sitting during parts of a performance. I’ve seen him over 40 times these past 50 years and I’m always honored to be breathing the same air he.
Awesome!..Honestly, every time Dylan does something new I always hope he’ll at least try to sing the songs and not mumble..But he hasent done that since “Time out of Mind”.
Literally one of the dumbest things I have ever heard. Go listen to some of his singing on Rough and Rowdy Ways, he sounds the best he has in like 30 years on that album.
Modern Times came out years after Time out of Mind and Dylan was singing with the kind of diction that did his breakthrough songwriting on that album proud. Check out some of the more imaginative interpreters of his songs, like jazz r&b soul diva Bettye LaVette on her Dylan adaptations album named after Dylan's contribution to the soundtrack of the movie Wonder Boys, album named Things Have Changed. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Things_Have_Changed_(album) After releasing that album Bettye LaVette did an online live set in 2018 with imaginative musicians and some wondrous arrangements she participated in shaping, especially of the Dylan songs she chose to adapt and inhabit from Modern Times. ua-cam.com/video/e2K8HdJ3JtI/v-deo.html Bettye LaVette - Things Have Changed - 4/9/2018 - Paste Studios - New York, NY Paste Magazine 558K subscribers 98K views 5 years ago Bettye LaVette - Things Have Changed Recorded Live: 4/9/2018 - Paste Studios - New York, NY Do go back and listen to Dylan's own singing on Modern Times as he inhabits these new kinds of territory for him. Another woman who brings her experience and unleashes her passion on a Modern Times song that was released as a single with band arrangement and video by the White Stripes Jack White is roots jukebox diva Wanda Jackson's doing "Thunder on the Mountain" from Modern Times. This is hot, even hotter than Dylan's vocal on Modern Times, but just as clearly sung and phrased as only Wanda Jackson can!!!! ua-cam.com/video/3DTKrjplzp8/v-deo.html Wanda Jackson: "Thunder on the Mountain" [OFFICIAL VIDEO] Nonesuch Records 56.7K subscribers 195,811 views Jan 21, 2011 Wanda Jackson's video of the great Bob Dylan song "Thunder on the Mountain," from her Third Man / Nonesuch Records release, "The Party Ain't Over," features producer and bandmate Jack White on guitar, along with the Third Man House Band. A world of muses out there to explore like Dylan clearly enjoys exploring. Recording and artists with imagination and their own associations have a marvelous way of collapsing the Walls of Time (ooops, that's a Bill Monroe song done so well live by Emmlou Harris & the Nash Ramblers at The Ryman....) Mitch Ritter\Paradigm Sifters, Code Shifters, PsalmSong Chasers Lay-Low Studios, Ore-Wa (Refuge of Atonement Seekers) Media Discussion List\LookseeInnerEarsHearHere
I'm over the Dylan thing. For me, his work does not have lasting value. *Yawn* more chord changes, more ostensibly meaningful words and more melodies cribbed from trad songs. *Yaaawwnn*
Someone make this make sense. I dont get Bob Dylan. Nothing catchy or melodic comes from his mouth. It sounds like a drunk guy mumbling, literally. I was sitting closer than this and sat down during this set wishing it was his son instead.
If you haven't poured through his catalog, you should if you want to understand. Start with Bringing it all Back Home; then Highway 61 Revisted. If you still don't like him maybe you'll at least know why. Good luck!
He’s the master he’s Bob Dylan. No ego no fuss. He just loves to play non stop. God Bless Mr. Zimmerman
I was there, I couldn’t believe when he came out and surprised everyone. It was dark so nobody could really tell at first who it was, and then people lost their minds
It's so great to see him on guitar again. Great performance of a great song.
Yeah imagine a tour that was advertised as Bob on Acoustic with his Band.
The GOAT surprises us again
even playing guitar!!
Bob ain't no goat!
@@ronfowlermusicyeah he is
@@jonahn4151 you think Bob is a goat, a loser? I think he's brilliant!
It’s an acronym for Greatest of all Time…
The Heartbreakers are backing him up! ❤
No, but Tom’s guitar player & the Dirty Knobs…
MIKE!
@@johncrowder5505As well as Tom’s keyboardist Benmontench and drummer Steve Ferrone…
@@johncrowder5505❤
@@johncrowder5505ciao John!🙋😊😘💘🌅
💋 💋 💋🌹 THANK U BOBBY ♥ xxxooo
THANKS To BOBBY for This INCREDIBLY BEAUTIFUL G I F T From his ♥. 😭 😢👍 ✌ I ♥ U 4 EVER BD
The master of his craft....
You'd know what a pleasure it is to see you!
One of the best songs ever written Sending love and gratitude to to Bob ❤❤❤
Amazing, Legendary Bob Dylan ❤❤❤❤❤
He transcends time. What a genius.
My favorite love song and his voice is back l! unbelievable
Great Bob! I love you! From Italy
When the rest have gone, the Dylan song remains to lay down the times in any century.
Wow. Kicking myself now for not overdrawing my bank account to see this. Im a preschool teacher and the beginning of the school year after summer break is always tight money wise. Bob will always have a piece of my heart ❤️
he was a surprise guests so don't kick yourself too hard you had no way of knowing he would be there. :)
Nice Bob Dylan ❤️ you are an amazing artist
Wonderful. I love Bobby's voice. So dear!
BOB DYLAN IS MINE & ALL OF OUR's HERO
I ♥ YOU Bobby! Look Mighty Awesome Up There !!
Bob Dylan 2023...... How lucky are we to have this guys all these years?
When folks talk about What if, This is WHAT IS!!!
What a Beautiful Dream-- Bob Dylan with the Heart Beakers Band. Tommy Would ❤ This. Am Sure he's Looking Xown from Heaven & Smiling. 😊 This is My FAV Bob Dylan song from the '60'. Brings Tears to my eyes Hearing Bob sing It. THANX Bob for Such Beautiful, Lovely SURPRISE@ 💋 ❤✌
God bless you, Bob, and one and all ❤
Bob playing his strat beautifully and his voice sounds great! The boys in the band add a magic touch too. Cheers Bob Brault.
That's not a strat.
Go bob!
till the wheels fall off from going
Hey Bob…….that singing was amazing!
Dylan performing with The Heartbreakers & a new Stones album on the way in 2023…my heart can’t take it! One of the greatest lines ever in this song…”you’d know what a drag it is to see you” Rock on Zimmy
Michael McLoughlin
It's great having Bob do this song-the songs he sings are as relevant as they ever were.
He still sounds great-I first heard these songs back in the '60s
nice job!, Bob!
Bob W.!
It's Bob and Bob only.... Now and forever the Greatest!
What a treat to see Bob performing like old times! He's not ready to tap out and isn't that great?!!
Reminds me of the mid 90s shows
Good stuff
Fabulous
😊🏴☠️🎈
Merci bob rithme touchant from algeria
♥ Bobby just KEEPS Inspiring Us All. I Love this Great Man. He's a VERY SPECIAL GIFT To Us All rom God. Long LIVE Bob Dylan, Our HERO ❤✌💋 💋 xxxooo
Muchas gracias por compartir este vídeo. Saludos para todos los dylanianos del mundo.
soy tambien dylanita,desde argentina
Saludos desde España.@@nancymartinez9848
Bellissima performance,per una canzone molto bella...😊🤗😍😘🎶🎸🎶💘💓💋💯🌅
I love you ❤️🙏
I still can't believe Bobby is still on the road, he sure did make it through, amazing 👏👏👏
Heading for another joint.
Wow!
Bob reigns!
Never write him off, his Bobness towers over all.
This performance great enough to shake up even those of us who recognize, but distance themselves from the "worshipers".
Spectacular on multiple artistic and human levels.
Sounds great for his age !!! 🔥🔥👍🔥
Sharp as a knife and tuff as nails. He’s still doin it
true that and with vigor as well as the stuff legends are make, txs for sharing
Fantastic!
Bob never fails to surprise.
You Go Bobby! ❤
So good. Thank you Bobby
Bob Looks SO Young Compared to Many of his Peers. U Can See the Silver Sparkles on His Jacket. My ♥ Just Flows Bacto those Beautiful Times in Our Coutry. Hearing him Sing this Song AD Playing Guitar isBessig MyHeart SoMh. That Music is So MAGICAL..& SoIsBob Dylan. 👍 ♥ 💋 xxxooo
MAGICAL STILL EXIST IN THIS WORLD
PRAISE GOD FOR HIS GIFT OF BOB DYLAN TO US. ✌ ♥ 👆 x xxxooo
Thank you! This is amazing!!!!!! ❤🧡💛💚💙💜🤎🖤💘💝💖💗💓💞💕💟❣
❤❤❤❤Danke ❤❤❤❤
He sounds great!
bob on guitar !!!
Much Thanks to Whomever shot Bobby from thos Angle. Ya Know, This Is My Favorite BD song from the '60's. It's Just Magical to My Heart with All the feelings of that Timme & Era flooding back. Very sweet w just a little bitter. Think is Very Cute how Bob almost chastizes ( is it Mike of HB's) the Guitar player who was standing perhaps too close to Next to him & Bob suddenly flashing his disapproval with just a whip of his head & Mike the guy quickly retreats to the piano player for a couple minutes. Bob's a BOSS & They Respect him ALOT. ♥ Bobby 4ALWAYS 💋 💋 🌹 xxxooo ♥ ✌
The vocals do not quite come through but still : this is Dylan with one of the great songs of his "most classic"period. I write "most classic" because he had lots of them. After a few lesser albums in the seventies he rebounded with BLOOD ON THE TRACKS. Still one of the very best albums of that period. And let us not forget that what he is doing currently is so bloody great. ROUGH AND ROWDY WAYS is another classic !
Dear God ~ thank you for Bob Dylan
❤Wonderful Bob he keeps on going Strong he's Amazing I ❤ hearing him sing.I play his songs EVERY DAY and watch videos /concerts. so hes❤❤❤ with me EVERYDAY 😊❤
He sounds good!
I hope he pays guitar for the fall tour❤❤ You go Bobby....
Stay forever young my friend
Amazing
Ol Bob keeps on nice with all the turmoil goves me a respite
Great to see Bob trying guitar again. hopefully he mixes things up for this upcoming leg of his tour
Many thanks for sharing this. It's so nice to watch espacially when you weren't there!
❤❤😂❤Danke für den Song 😂❤❤❤😂😂
Mike Campbell!!!
With Benmont Tench on keyboards and Steve Ferrone on drums!
@@charlesarnold6812 awesome the video I saw only shows Mike
This is a great version of this song .. This will stay in my mind. I'll bet everyone's excited about those 6 strings..
BD Has SO MUCH ♥ STILL
I want a Bob Dylan wig.
this is history for sure
BD KEEPS DELIVERING !!! 👍❤ 😂 xxxooo
Babe , Your out there in the world handing out your love and carrying to everyone that hears you...they hear your song...I have total faith and trust....while you are rocking the world; I'm studying Psalm 35 and studying Isaiah...
Wow! Love it
Makes it sound like a love letter to his enemies
The last man standing.
This is great. Saw him on his most recent tour. He only sits at the keyboards. Maybe he'll change his mind after this. This is my favorite Dylan song. Is that Mike Campbell on guitar?
Yes.
Are you sure that's Dylan?
I can understand every word?
Ha, JK.
Love you, Bob.
Love this tune always have just wondering..why does Jacob Dylan not play with his father? Maybe they have a sense of completion on this song they would sound terrific together..Go Bob Go Jacob ..don't be afraid to walk in each others shoes...♥️♥️
I always wondered why to but I get it. Bob loves Jacob but not to play together.
His only concession to being an octogenarian is occasionally sitting during parts of a performance. I’ve seen him over 40 times these past 50 years and I’m always honored to be breathing the same air he.
Megggaaa@
he is fckin 82, unbelievable still to this age he can perform, and me a 25 years old feels like a dead b*tch
He needs to record his concerts. He has the money. Plenty of it and he can't take it with him.
🌲🎼🩷
At 82 voice starting to go.
He's still favorite music icon
Awesome!..Honestly, every time Dylan does something new I always hope he’ll at least try to sing the songs and not mumble..But he hasent done that since “Time out of Mind”.
Literally one of the dumbest things I have ever heard. Go listen to some of his singing on Rough and Rowdy Ways, he sounds the best he has in like 30 years on that album.
Modern Times came out years after Time out of Mind and Dylan was singing with the kind of diction that did his breakthrough songwriting on that album proud. Check out some of the more imaginative interpreters of his songs, like jazz r&b soul diva Bettye LaVette on her Dylan adaptations album named after Dylan's contribution to the soundtrack of the movie Wonder Boys, album named Things Have Changed.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Things_Have_Changed_(album)
After releasing that album Bettye LaVette did an online live set in 2018 with imaginative musicians and some wondrous arrangements she participated in shaping, especially of the Dylan songs she chose to adapt and inhabit from Modern Times.
ua-cam.com/video/e2K8HdJ3JtI/v-deo.html
Bettye LaVette - Things Have Changed - 4/9/2018 - Paste Studios - New York, NY
Paste Magazine
558K subscribers
98K views 5 years ago
Bettye LaVette - Things Have Changed
Recorded Live: 4/9/2018 - Paste Studios - New York, NY
Do go back and listen to Dylan's own singing on Modern Times as he inhabits these new kinds of territory for him. Another woman who brings her experience and unleashes her passion on a Modern Times song that was released as a single with band arrangement and video by the White Stripes Jack White is roots jukebox diva Wanda Jackson's doing "Thunder on the Mountain" from Modern Times. This is hot, even hotter than Dylan's vocal on Modern Times, but just as clearly sung and phrased as only Wanda Jackson can!!!!
ua-cam.com/video/3DTKrjplzp8/v-deo.html
Wanda Jackson: "Thunder on the Mountain" [OFFICIAL VIDEO]
Nonesuch Records
56.7K subscribers
195,811 views Jan 21, 2011
Wanda Jackson's video of the great Bob Dylan song "Thunder on the Mountain," from her Third Man / Nonesuch Records release, "The Party Ain't Over," features producer and bandmate Jack White on guitar, along with the Third Man House Band.
A world of muses out there to explore like Dylan clearly enjoys exploring. Recording and artists with imagination and their own associations have a marvelous way of collapsing the Walls of Time (ooops, that's a Bill Monroe song done so well live by Emmlou Harris & the Nash Ramblers at The Ryman....)
Mitch Ritter\Paradigm Sifters, Code Shifters, PsalmSong Chasers
Lay-Low Studios, Ore-Wa (Refuge of Atonement Seekers)
Media Discussion List\LookseeInnerEarsHearHere
What language is this? It isn't English..
I'm over the Dylan thing. For me, his work does not have lasting value. *Yawn* more chord changes, more ostensibly meaningful words and more melodies cribbed from trad songs. *Yaaawwnn*
He's A LAMB
No thanks. This stuff is not for me. I prefer real music.
Always loved The B3 playing. Bob is way past his prime.
Someone make this make sense. I dont get Bob Dylan. Nothing catchy or melodic comes from his mouth. It sounds like a drunk guy mumbling, literally. I was sitting closer than this and sat down during this set wishing it was his son instead.
Don’t criticize what (by your own admission) you can’t understand.
Something is happening here and you don't know what it is, do you Mr Jones?
Man, just consider yourself lucky you were there. Millions of us wish we could have bern in your place!
If you haven't poured through his catalog, you should if you want to understand. Start with Bringing it all Back Home; then Highway 61 Revisted. If you still don't like him maybe you'll at least know why. Good luck!
I am just watching on my phone and I understand every word maybe just like a good moan se how good you will be at 82