Are Video Games Getting Too Long?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 435

  • @darkknight11311
    @darkknight11311 2 місяці тому +340

    Gaming with ADHD is a fucking journey. I turn every fun thing into work even when I don't want to

    • @foreignuser_
      @foreignuser_ 2 місяці тому +22

      sounds closer to obsessive compulsive than hyperactive just a heads up. i have the same issue

    • @darkknight11311
      @darkknight11311 2 місяці тому +29

      @@foreignuser_ I hear you, but I mean more in terms of turning everything into progress and gamifying things to feel as though I'm accomplishing something. That and constantly worrying about the next activity I'm going to do instead of focusing on what is in front of me.

    • @foreignuser_
      @foreignuser_ 2 місяці тому +4

      @@darkknight11311 i knew what you meant

    • @weird623
      @weird623 2 місяці тому +6

      i feel you, not sure if I do have ADHD but the same thing has been happening to me nowadays

    • @alexanderackerman3807
      @alexanderackerman3807 2 місяці тому +10

      As someone without ADHD
      I think the games themselves are turning every fun thing into work

  • @awepsalmgamin
    @awepsalmgamin 2 місяці тому +269

    I really appreciate an 8-hour game that has a good story and gameplay

    • @CloneJohn_
      @CloneJohn_ 2 місяці тому +3

      I think that’s why I was able to be fulfilled playing Katana Zero! It was a neat experience that took 6 hours, had a GREAT way of storytelling, fun combat, and the replay value is amazing

    • @iBishopEsquire
      @iBishopEsquire Місяць тому +2

      Dishonored and Resident Evil are both great franchises I that regard. Short games with great replayability.

    • @Ranechannel77
      @Ranechannel77 Місяць тому +1

      Fun is fun, some long games are really boring, like for me Shadow of colossus is very boring.

    • @TimmyJay02
      @TimmyJay02 Місяць тому

      I think 8-12 hours for a game (outside of RPGs or open world games) is a good length.

    • @TimmyJay02
      @TimmyJay02 Місяць тому +1

      @@Ranechannel77boring for me are the dynasty warrior games (or that genre). I mean Hyrule Warriors was so repetitive and brainless.

  • @LBrivet
    @LBrivet 2 місяці тому +96

    Remember when back in the day people thought that "open world" immediately meant a better superior game? Until devs stopped actually exploring the possibilities of being in a fictional living and breathing world and all of them started getting made the same way, just a giant map with repetitive chores to do in. I'm so glad most people grew out of such a childish mindset.
    What I'm trying to say is that thinking "long game = better game" is as childish as that :)

    • @mrblack7302
      @mrblack7302 Місяць тому +1

      I used to think the same, but as time goes on, we realize that newer games aren’t as carefully hand crafted anymore

    • @team3gaming749
      @team3gaming749 Місяць тому +2

      Couldn’t have said it any better myself. This same principle can be applied to graphic fidelity.

  • @SUREILLBYTE
    @SUREILLBYTE 2 місяці тому +106

    I'd much rather pay $70 for a tight, purposeful experience than $70 for an aimless game I will never beat.

    • @Always.Smarter
      @Always.Smarter 2 місяці тому +9

      why pay $70 at all? there's thousands of amazing games at half that price or less

    • @justarandomguy5505
      @justarandomguy5505 2 місяці тому +7

      Or not spend 70€ at all. Not worth the money if the game is extremely short

    • @CaptainJeoy
      @CaptainJeoy 2 місяці тому +1

      @@justarandomguy5505 🤦🏾‍♂🤦🏾‍♂🤦🏾‍♂

    • @anthonyt1t5
      @anthonyt1t5 Місяць тому +3

      *coughcough elden ring

    • @turtleanton6539
      @turtleanton6539 Місяць тому

      Indeed. Ubisoft😮😮😮😮

  • @warcross07
    @warcross07 2 місяці тому +51

    I think the sweet spot is 15-20 hours for a really good story.

    • @benjamindover7936
      @benjamindover7936 Місяць тому +10

      Yea but sometimes 400 hours of elden ring and botw and totk is hella entertaining

    • @turtleanton6539
      @turtleanton6539 Місяць тому

      ​@@benjamindover7936it is but there is not tight story

    • @S.SilverStudio
      @S.SilverStudio Місяць тому +2

      @@benjamindover7936honestly probably less than 5% of gamers if that high. I wish I could but just too much else to do during the day.

    • @benjamindover7936
      @benjamindover7936 Місяць тому +1

      @@S.SilverStudio unemployed summer has its perks

  • @thelasthellfish6719
    @thelasthellfish6719 2 місяці тому +62

    IMO, 8-12 hrs experience with a solid pace it's enough, I want to be able to play other games too, and with all these 50+ hours game it's imposible

    • @justarandomguy5505
      @justarandomguy5505 2 місяці тому +2

      U just have too much money to waste. Most People dont have the money to play every game that comes out

    • @Nitroscion
      @Nitroscion Місяць тому +1

      @@justarandomguy5505you’re right, This is why game pass is gaining subscribers.

    • @turtleanton6539
      @turtleanton6539 Місяць тому

      ​@@Nitroscionwellput😊

  • @Aladelicous
    @Aladelicous 2 місяці тому +43

    The funny thing for me, is the kind of games that get advertised and/or lauded for having hundreds or thousands of hours of content are usually the one's I can't stand playing 10 minutes whereas the games under 10 or 20 hours (or barely even break 1 hour in the case of Arcade games) are usually the ones I'll sink the most time into. I never really understood the appeal of quantity, especially when the quality didn't seem to be there.

    • @proggz39
      @proggz39 2 місяці тому +1

      Really depends. I love myself a good linear game but I’m not going to sit here and pretend games like Minecraft, Skyrim, Witcher 3, Cyberpunk, Fallout 3, Death Stranding, etc. Aren’t equally great

    • @cherokee180c0
      @cherokee180c0 Місяць тому +5

      @@proggz39Cyberpunk is the poster child for what is wrong in the games industry. That is the single reason I will never buy a day one game anymore. Wait a year, get the game for half price and it is finally to the quality it should have been a year earlier when all the suckers bought a totally unplayable game for $70. Not me anymore. AAA games suck 90% of the time anymore and are always released early to let the players be the real beta testers.

  • @H8Zexy
    @H8Zexy 2 місяці тому +61

    wait until he finds the longest game, having a kid. he's gonna be fuming at that time sink

    • @TonyTheTGR
      @TonyTheTGR 2 місяці тому +5

      It's second place to Paying Taxes

    • @joeyisabsb1
      @joeyisabsb1 2 місяці тому +9

      Step 1: Dont have a kid
      Step 2: ???
      Step 3: Profit

    • @jase276
      @jase276 2 місяці тому +6

      that ain't a game, that's a full time job

    • @H8Zexy
      @H8Zexy 2 місяці тому +2

      @@jase276 debatable lmao

    • @SpecShadow
      @SpecShadow Місяць тому

      Path of Exile while you have family and job? Doable.
      Sweatlords grindfest like Escape from Tarkov? If not SPT mod with Quest Skippers and other savings - no chance.

  • @radicalcentrist4990
    @radicalcentrist4990 2 місяці тому +68

    I just don't waste my time with grindy live service multiplayer trash, open world games that are mainly about boring and repetitive filler content, or sandbox games that have no real goal. Just not having these types of games in your backlog makes things much easier.

    • @shobitchouksey3442
      @shobitchouksey3442 2 місяці тому

      Exactly 💯 most relatable comment to how I choose what to play

    • @HUYI1
      @HUYI1 2 місяці тому +4

      Or excessively long RPGS which I promptly avoid also 😢

    • @radicalcentrist4990
      @radicalcentrist4990 2 місяці тому +3

      @HUYI1 yeah, though there are a few excessively long RPGs that keep me invested throughout.

  • @joeyisabsb1
    @joeyisabsb1 2 місяці тому +28

    I found three ways to help me beat games, or at least experience them, fast:
    1: Play on the lowest difficulty, it helps the narrative flow better and helps you beat it faster
    2: Emulate and use cheat codes. Its faster than an easy difficulty and you can enjoy the story.
    3: Watch longplays/edited longplays on youtube. Youll get the understanding of how its played and enjoy its narrative. Its like when you watch a friend play a whole game.

    • @asifkaka5052
      @asifkaka5052 2 місяці тому +1

      When I was in my pirating days I always wanted to have achievements on the games that I would play, now that I have the money to purchase the games that I loved to play I have been using WeMod to get all the achievements that I always wanted.
      I most definitely support your sentiment on playing the games on lower difficulty to be able to play them to the end, because sometimes the game length is so long that somewhere between mid way and one third way through the game progress you will get bored and stop caring and never be able to complete any game to the end.
      So yeah I will also recommend everyone who has a backlog of games to please play the games you already have to the end before jumping on to the next best thing.

    • @SpecShadow
      @SpecShadow Місяць тому

      I use Easy mode in games that I want to scratch from the backlogs and where "challenge" comes from the content that's mostly bloat and filler and more HP for enemies...
      also Cheat Engine to walk faster and speed up animations because why not

    • @shauncameron8390
      @shauncameron8390 Місяць тому

      I go for 1).

  • @kylespevak6781
    @kylespevak6781 Місяць тому +5

    25:40 I think Tekken is way more intuitive than Street Fighter. It's my favorite traditional fighting game because you can just feel things out due to the limb system.
    Street Fighter is learnable to me, but the arbitrary inputs make it more of a process.

  • @alanuzcategui2591
    @alanuzcategui2591 Місяць тому +5

    Awesome video, the points you made about being grateful for video game really resonated with me. It's such a complex and wonderful art form.

  • @wispyone3702
    @wispyone3702 2 місяці тому +42

    I think the sunk cost fallacy of games can often keep you in that gone enjoyment. When we are so dedicated to this hobby, it’s rough to just appreciate a game less than you have before and leave it in that state of less-appreciation. It almost feels like a break up, but that’s why you have to do it if you’re hating yourself over it.

  • @dashinxkatchin
    @dashinxkatchin 2 місяці тому +19

    5 seconds into the video and I only want to say that it depends on WHAT game is too long

  • @kizunadragon9
    @kizunadragon9 Місяць тому +14

    the 1 dollar spent per 1 game hour BS really needs to die. I'd rather have a 5 hour banger of a game then a 50 hour mediocre one

  • @ividboy7616
    @ividboy7616 2 місяці тому +24

    Okay if you won't be mean about it I will
    I am so goddamn sick of people that would prefer 100 hours of SLOP to 10 hours of absolute fire, and this tendency is making games worse because instead of devs making a tight experience, they instead have to sprinkle in that goodness into hours and hours of filler because otherwise people will complain that "number too low", like the amount of time it takes up is the only point in playing a video game.
    The critique around Metroid Dread's length killed any faith I had in the general public to recognize quality. I have to assume that the people that say "game too short" are just sitting there slack jawed, letting the dopamine flow into their brain, not unlike a sea sponge getting nourishment just by sitting there and filter feeding.
    comedic exaggerated rant over

    • @turtleanton6539
      @turtleanton6539 Місяць тому

      Indeed😊

    • @AkweliParker
      @AkweliParker Місяць тому

      Not exaggerated at all.

    • @bryan8638
      @bryan8638 24 дні тому

      Just like cars all having 700hp and 0-60 times under 4 seconds, how long can the number keep going up/down? We can't even use what we've got now

  • @clevelandsteamer420
    @clevelandsteamer420 Місяць тому +5

    If halo 3, assassins creed 2, uncharted, dead space, or metal gear solid 3 came out today, people would scoff at them for only being 15 hours and not worth 60$.

    • @Particle_Ghost
      @Particle_Ghost Місяць тому +4

      Exactly. People these days confuse length with replay value, and longer games need to spread the content more thinly, the gameplay loop often becomes more repetitive quicker as well. True replay value means when you play a game multiple times, is it just as fun as the first time you played it. Pretty much the games you mentioned as well as many others, I actually have more hours invested and those games than I do many 100-hour games. Due to the content being more condensed and focused, I'm more than likely to replay many of those games at least once a year and sometimes more often than that.

  • @sandwichboy1268
    @sandwichboy1268 2 місяці тому +25

    It's not that players actually prefer the constant dopamine cycle, they just got too used to it. They got used to the fun bits of gameplay being spread out with oceans of mindless grinding with micro-rewards between. So, when something short and sweet comes along, they don't know what to do.
    Some games really are hundred hour adventures with tons of content. Many are not, but felt the need to pretend to be anyways. Ignore what the skinner box addicts think. Play fun games.

  • @bearcats513
    @bearcats513 Місяць тому +5

    Sometimes the length isn’t even the problem, it’s the fact that they just shove so much unnecessary shit into it to pump up the playtime.
    Pokemon Diamond and Pearl locking the postgame behind seeing every pokemon is a notorious example. It’s not particularly fun or fulfilling to track down the one trainer you missed to see their Drifloon just so you can go to the battle tower.
    “But that game came out 20 years ago get over it!”
    Ahhh, you’d have a point… BUT THEY CARRIED OVER THIS DUMB REQUIREMENT INTO THE 2021 REMAKES

  • @EllipsesMusicc
    @EllipsesMusicc Місяць тому +2

    Some games turn into a chore that you feel like you are playing just to beat at some point. The best games leave you wanting more not exhausted 😆

  • @andresilm
    @andresilm Місяць тому +4

    I enjoyed so much the 30 hours I played Paper Mario TTYD .. I did not need more, it ended in the right moment

  • @ronniefazzio6979
    @ronniefazzio6979 2 місяці тому +15

    I know you were just talking about how big your backlog is but I highly recommend you check out Prince of Persia the Lost Crown. It’s a Metroidvania that focuses on tight platforming and stylish combat with a surprising amount of depth. The devs were inspired by Hollow Knight, Celeste, and the Ori games. If you liked Dread I definitely think you’d like Prince of Persia the Lost Crown.

    • @Drstrange3000
      @Drstrange3000 2 місяці тому +5

      After realizing how done I was with any open world game or games that last 50+ (XBC3), I decided to play more of Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown to see if it wasn't me just done with gaming. Thankfully, I was enjoying myself a lot! I really wish that game was more of a success. It is so overlooked and unfairly dismissed. It is such a great game!

    • @BeatBrat
      @BeatBrat  2 місяці тому +2

      I’ll definitely consider it! It seems right up my alley

  • @RealCoachMustafa
    @RealCoachMustafa 2 місяці тому +19

    I don't like when people say PS+ games are "free." You have to literally pay for a subscription, so it's not free. Free would mean you're not paying anything at all for it. Also, at this point in my life (I'm almost 40) I prefer shorter games. When I was a kid, I didn't like how short MGS was because back then, I didn't have a giant library of games and games were expensive. Today, I have literally hundreds of games in my backlog and no time to play any of them. I'm too busy working or spending time with my family.

    • @murderman8578
      @murderman8578 2 місяці тому +7

      Well you shouldn't have made a family

    • @Cheddar_Wizard
      @Cheddar_Wizard 2 місяці тому +2

      @@murderman8578 Family is more fulfilling than gaming.

    • @Rico-yt1tw
      @Rico-yt1tw Місяць тому +2

      It's people like him why Sony takes advantage of us

    • @RealCoachMustafa
      @RealCoachMustafa Місяць тому

      @@murderman8578 I played lots of games that I regret. I don't regret building a family.

  • @ArksideGames
    @ArksideGames 2 місяці тому +9

    So modern slot machine games are literally messing with our brains.

  • @sebbyterasu78
    @sebbyterasu78 2 місяці тому +11

    My solution to the problem: play that which gives you an itch and be more selective in your preferences. I enjoy single player games. I have lost interest in the MMOs and Live Service Games. I spend intimate time replaying classic from my library to carefully veto the newest game releases. That way, I'm more conscientious of my time and expenses and I'm able to enjoy myself. Right now I'm replaying FFXIII after playing through the Mass Effect Trilogy. Next game I'm itching on playing is Darksiders 2 while I wait for the Soul Reaver remaster.
    Just play what you feel like playing.

    • @canaandurham7158
      @canaandurham7158 13 днів тому

      As I’m getting older, I’m experiencing the same. While I do have a wishlist, I’m also pickier with my new purchases while I go through the backlog. I’m rediscovering Fire Emblem 3 Houses after a friend was talking about it. I’m doing casual mode so I can just enjoy the story and building my units. And I rotate between a couple games in case I start getting burned out.

  • @K9-Mentality
    @K9-Mentality 2 місяці тому +7

    This guy is spitting straight facts, imma have to watch this guy more

  • @TheQuietTimes
    @TheQuietTimes 2 місяці тому +18

    I wish that when I was a kid games were as long as they are now.
    I think games used to use challenge in place of length, but that slowly changed, and now games use length, scope, and scale in place of depth, challenge, and intentional game design. _"Just make it bigger, they'll love it!"_ is like the motto of modern design.
    And again, that might have been okay when games were mostly consumed by kids under 18... But nowadays I'd say there are probably as many, if not far more over-18 gamers than back in the 90's... And that means a majority of gamers are working with a more restricted schedule, and don't have as much time to dump into games as they once would have.
    And with games going out of their way to disrespect the player's time, I've noticed that gamers are making it to the end credits far less than they once did. And as a developer, that should be your primary goal... To create an experience that players want to see through to the end... Not just give them something so unwieldly, awkwardly, and unreasonably big that they never get around to finishing it.
    It's like, you can give someone an overcooked shank steak that will be so rubbery and chewy that they're munching on it for hours... Or you can give them a perfectly portioned cut of medium-rare filet mignon that is so tender it falls off the fork and melts in your mouth like cotton candy. Sure, they'll finish the filet far sooner than the shank... but they'll enjoy it more and they'll actually finish the entire meal.
    And that's more important than giving someone the cheapest, biggest portions you can.

    • @Hypno_BPM
      @Hypno_BPM 2 місяці тому +2

      replaying some older games , they used to make us use our heads more when playing. modern games are way too “hand holdy”. i hate that the most. i’d rather figure something out on my own than just follow a marker on my map on where to go next.

    • @Superdude-rd2gs
      @Superdude-rd2gs 2 місяці тому

      don't forget you actually come back for the filet mignon

  • @iangoodwin2103
    @iangoodwin2103 Місяць тому +1

    Wow, this video was so well put together and voiced so many thoughts I’ve had myself, I could help but subscribe. Keep up the great work I’d love to see more!

  • @timeeater2007
    @timeeater2007 2 місяці тому +11

    I've told myself it's okay not to finnish games. The money I pay is a ticket to experience, how long I stay, is up to me. But the best part is that I can come back to it.
    Well, exept heavy RPG's I really like em but MAN. Puttning down an RPG and coming back to it a year later just dose not work 😱

    • @Kstamper
      @Kstamper 2 місяці тому +1

      Same here. As long as you enjoyed the time you had with a game, if you haven't finished it's all good. Baldurs Gate 3 was my Goty last year and I am not close to finishing that thing.

  • @newtable2580
    @newtable2580 2 місяці тому +9

    Final Fantasy Brave Exvius milked almost 3K from me like half a decade ago. It shut down a month ago.
    Learned my lesson the hard way.

    • @KaptainKerl
      @KaptainKerl 2 місяці тому

      I don't know whats worse: $3k or 3k hours

    • @zuufettegt133
      @zuufettegt133 2 місяці тому +1

      I think that the hours are worse, but that's my own personal bias in regards to Elder Scrolls Legends. I've been playing it since before the closed beta, and it breaks my heart to see my favorite card game die.

    • @streamingnowstreamingnow2568
      @streamingnowstreamingnow2568 2 місяці тому +2

      @@KaptainKerlwhen you get older time is way more valuable.

  • @lovelydumpling
    @lovelydumpling Місяць тому +2

    That "consider getting tested for ADHD" hit me like a freight train.

  • @JAMESGRANER
    @JAMESGRANER 2 місяці тому +4

    The only game that I ever thought was WAY too long was Assassin’s Creed Valhalla

  • @Ijustusethistocommentstuff
    @Ijustusethistocommentstuff 2 місяці тому +5

    One of my FAVORITE styles of games are those games where it's "Do a few missions quickly, hop off", action experience.
    Not like Genshin or COD multiplayer or anything, but stuff like Monster Hunter or EDF. Just some quick carnage to satisfy. They don't try to be deep, and I love them for that.
    (I also LOVE COD zombies, so that's probably another thing.)

    • @mayteexxis
      @mayteexxis 2 місяці тому

      You might enjoy warframe

  • @Jack-nj9pi
    @Jack-nj9pi Місяць тому +2

    My lord you pretty much nailed everything in this video lol

  • @foreignuser_
    @foreignuser_ 2 місяці тому +6

    wait ya'll are out here getting joy out of things?

  • @Atticus_Moore
    @Atticus_Moore 2 місяці тому +3

    I see so many people get addicted to something like MOBA's and they all hate the game, but they're so addicted to it that they're like yeah I mean I still kinda like it and it's so sad. I feel bad for them

  • @halfbakedberserker
    @halfbakedberserker 2 місяці тому +4

    Lost me at the fighting game community being non toxic 😂

  • @jamesbarnett5157
    @jamesbarnett5157 2 місяці тому +2

    Over time i've been able to figure out what kind of games tend to make me feel like im forcing myself to finish it(usually the games that have that ubisoft style of open world) so i usually avoid those or wait for them to go on sale and i usually pick out a long game and few shorter games. When i start to feel burned out of the longer game i can go to one of the shorter games that i know i can beat in a few days and then go back to the longer game without feeling like i have to restart cause i haven't played it in a year. By the time i've finished whatever longer game im playing i've usually also finished 2-3 shorter games

  • @VegaIllusion
    @VegaIllusion 2 місяці тому +7

    I really appreciate you sharing your experience with ADHD. I also think that is important for this information to be presented in a good way, so here are some details that are nice to have.
    - ADHD has become progressively a more accessible diagnosis, so skepticism is actually a good thing.
    - Medication is not always needed. My country cannot give/test medication without a diagnosis so ADHD being more accessible is actually quite useful, yet profitable. Medication is usually implemented after different forms for psychotherapy have been applied first, so in no way should we look at medication as a problem solver. There are also tons of side effects that we have to keep in mind.
    - ADHD can easily be comorbid with something else such autism, anxiety and/or depression. The symptoms of ADHD are rather general in some aspects and very common in some ages, so other psychopathologies should always be considered.
    - Explaining how ADHD works and how both therapy and medication affects it is crucial if you want to have good results with therapy.
    - On a sadder note, there are many who get the diagnosis at a young age (preteen) and know nothing but medication and their condition. If they were misdiagnosed or simply given the diagnosis and medication (basically treated in a not very professional way), they might even not have ADHD or at least a form of it that is too problematic. If anything, at that point they would have Munchausen by proxy. This to say that we should always be careful with diagnosing such serious conditions at a young age.

    • @BeatBrat
      @BeatBrat  2 місяці тому +3

      I appreciate you sharing all of this!
      I definitely support solutions that don’t involve medicine and I actually do wish I was never diagnosed as a child for this reason. No one told me how it worked. No one told me how the medicine was affecting me. I remember it made me noticeably less enthusiastic, while having little affect on my school performance.
      Taking it as an adult after understanding it more thoroughly, I can more confidently say that it’s having a positive effect. The big thing to realize is that it makes doing the things you WANT to do easier. It’s not gonna magically make you want to do chores or homework. But it can make it a lot easier to take the boring steps needed to move towards the thing you want, without quickly losing motivation. This realization changed everything for me and I wish I understood something this basic before being pushed medication as a kid.
      Mental health diagnoses are confusing and obviously imperfect, so I think it can be scary and hard to know whether medicine is a good decision, but I do believe it’s important to avoid stigmatizing medicine as a solution and I worry too many people are moving towards this mindset. It’s easy to convince yourself it’s a scam, or a placebo. Or even worse viewing it as evil or as a “shortcut.”
      Again I appreciate the comment. And thanks so much for watching!

    • @VegaIllusion
      @VegaIllusion 2 місяці тому +1

      @ stigmatizing medicine is definitely a real issue, but at the same time it is an industry that does prey on people (internationally). This is why good information, especially about something as abstract as mental health, is crucial. Like I mentioned, in my country, to treat ADHD with medication you have to have diagnosed the person with it and have engaged with psychotherapy. Having psychotherapy also implies that psycho education is being taught to the patient and thus teaching and informing them about important stuff. Simultaneously, it is helping the patient develop good strategies to better handle every day life even without medication, so it is a win-win situation. Here, medication is used and presented in a way that is clearly part of the process rather than a shortcut.
      Different countries have different laws and practices, and those who prioritize medication should be criticized because they are hurting the end result by taking a shortcut in the treatment. Without a more holistic approach, the patient will experience a poor outcome similar to what you’ve described.
      I wish that more clinical psychologist who are good at their job were to engage with entertainment and informative content similar to how Dr Mike does. Right now we have many content creators who make a living by talking about their conditions, such as ADHD and autism, but their content is often extremely biased and even misleading. We have had several cases, at my university clinic, of teenagers and young adults seeking psychological help due to watching such content and it has been weighing on our system quite significantly. This is why I appreciated your story because you made it very clear that it was about you and your experience, rather than using your personal experience as a starting point to then act as a pseudo psychologist and give information that is generalized and misleading.

    • @orangeslash1667
      @orangeslash1667 2 місяці тому

      @@BeatBrat You can play indie games, for shorter adventures.

    • @KaptainKerl
      @KaptainKerl 2 місяці тому +1

      @@BeatBrat imagine not being diagnosed as a kid and wondering for 30 years what the hell is wrong with you and why is everyone normal excep you? why is nobody struggling with everyday tasks as much as you do?
      I wish I was diagnosed as a kid. getting diagnosed is always the right thing to do. It makes you and your social circle stop blaming you and instead blame ADHD for certain behaviour. you basically stop worrying and stop hating parts of yourself because you now know the reason for it.

    • @KaptainKerl
      @KaptainKerl 2 місяці тому

      you got any numbers of misdiagnosed vs diagnosed children or is it just made up/ gut feeling?

  • @SlyKooper1029
    @SlyKooper1029 Місяць тому +2

    Bro, with all the things you mentioned throughout the video, we’re literally the same person 😂
    Been playing SF6 more lately, and it made me realize I picked up another repetitive comp game to suck most of my hours away.
    I always catch myself putting hundreds or thousands of hours into games like Valorant or Overwatch but I could’ve spent that time going through my backlog of games.
    Games like Metroid Dread definitely was a breath of fresh air since it felt rewarding for how short it was.
    Then you mentioned ADHD and it made me feel relieved that I’m not alone with the feeling I’ve been getting whenever I play games made these days. Medication has helped me a lot too for getting through gaming.

  • @pie6088
    @pie6088 2 місяці тому +4

    my favorite thing is food

  • @hoelweetbred2200
    @hoelweetbred2200 2 місяці тому +3

    i loved long games when I was a kid but now that i have a job i like a game i can kill in like a weekend when i have time off. sucks.

  • @SolidBren
    @SolidBren Місяць тому +1

    This was extremely relatable as a 30 year old dude with a backlog of hundreds of games, but mostly addicted to playing fighting games online with friends like SF6, BBCF, UNI2, multiple GG games. I also juggle multiple gacha games. They are chunking into time and I probably should just axe some of them. They do give me some enjoyment. But sometime I think I gotta draw the line. They are feeding into likely making my ADHD more severe.

  • @gipsyking5683
    @gipsyking5683 Місяць тому +1

    As a dredge fun I like my games short and sweet, no massive grind or way too many collectibles, just a short rememberable experience

  • @kylespevak6781
    @kylespevak6781 Місяць тому

    5:41 I felt burnt on grinding competitive games, so i switched to my single player backlog and got burnt on that too.
    Moderation and variation is key, i think

  • @karayi7239
    @karayi7239 2 місяці тому +1

    I wrote a whole essay until I found out you have ADD.
    I hope you start one of those daunting 100hr games. ER and BG3 most recently, the kind of immersion and payoff at the end is simply incomparable to shorter games regardless of how good they are.

  • @Suarvae
    @Suarvae 2 місяці тому +4

    I dont appreciate you calling me out like that 05:00

  • @gamefreakadamy
    @gamefreakadamy 2 місяці тому +5

    I don’t think length is the problem. I think the moment to moment substance and gameplay are lacking. I could play a god of war type game for 500 hours if the quality didn’t drop. My job be damned.

    • @Karlito1738
      @Karlito1738 2 місяці тому +2

      exactly it's the fact that a lot of long games aren't usually as packed with ideas as shorter games are. Not saying every long game is like this, but there's a lot which just drag on and take far too much time to do much of anything, compared to shorter games where you're constantly doing shit

  • @Star-Hole
    @Star-Hole 2 місяці тому +34

    UA-cam videos are too long, and there are too many of them.

    • @BeatBrat
      @BeatBrat  2 місяці тому +4

      True!

    • @Hard2Find
      @Hard2Find 2 місяці тому +1

      This comment is so fire is almost makes watching the video arbitrary.

  • @Dark_kage
    @Dark_kage 2 місяці тому +2

    Great video keep making high quality videos like this, I've subscribed. I'm not a big pokemon unite guy but I might check out those videos too.

  • @kylespevak6781
    @kylespevak6781 Місяць тому

    8:54 Reminds me of Smash 4. The starting roster was large, and characters were quick to unlock. This was seen as a negative, so for Smash Ultimate they made you start with like only 8 of the 80 characters

  • @guillepankeke2844
    @guillepankeke2844 2 місяці тому +9

    Developers should reduce time waste as a strategy. The time you spend killing the same evil characters, the time you spend recognizing a labyrinth with same bricks on every wall, etc. There are many more games than before and many are great, there is no reason why to waste time on games, you wont get any real deep feelings for them that way.

  • @bareto
    @bareto 2 місяці тому

    Thank god UA-cam finally recommended a good, new channel. I love this. Subscribed. Please consider making long-form in-depth content. You would be amazing at that.

  • @mikedrzi5240
    @mikedrzi5240 2 місяці тому +2

    Do you want more Hellblade 2 type of games?

  • @SweBeach2023
    @SweBeach2023 Місяць тому

    We really need to make a distinction between games with replay-value and those without. A game with amazing replay-value can be as short as 4-5 hours and still be worth an asking price of 70 dollars.

  • @Zessifml
    @Zessifml Місяць тому +1

    Yeah, games are getting long, and sometimes that’s what makes it better, especially when the story is good. But 20hrs max long is what I want 😂

  • @Reralex
    @Reralex 2 місяці тому

    I don't play games but I love watching these videos, nice one

  • @ocemious
    @ocemious 2 місяці тому +1

    Love the topics discussed and how you discussed them, agreed with most of what you said, and bro, SF6 is the best. Great video thanks for a great listen while driving home.

  • @awesomeanimal
    @awesomeanimal 2 місяці тому

    I’ve said for years that i’m more likely to replay a perfect 10 hour game 3-4 times than i am to finish 30-40 games even once, especially if that game shows me all it has to offer after 10 hours.

  • @Badylird
    @Badylird 2 місяці тому

    thanks for uploading again. I love your videos

  • @davidhegarty7500
    @davidhegarty7500 Місяць тому

    Great video, the fog from silent hill was carried over from the limitation SH1.

  • @C-View1
    @C-View1 Місяць тому +1

    Some games need to be long for the sake of things like story, but I can definitely understand why king games aren’t liked by everyone. Personally, I love a game I can dig into.

  • @notme6753
    @notme6753 Місяць тому +1

    Wow I can relate to you so much!!! Nowadays I don't enjoy playing games as I used to (maybe because there aren't much games to play in the current gen). But still... It's like I grew over it. I'm working and also studying part time now so it's understandable that I won't have much time to play games... But after my semester break just when a have more free time now I dont really miss gaming like I thought I would. Most of the time I would on my ps5 but not to play games but to watch Netflix instead 😂

  • @brandonedwards9102
    @brandonedwards9102 Місяць тому

    I've learned as I've gotten into my 30s games 15-25 hrs is about my sweet spot . Games 50 hours plus might take me the whole year to beat just one

  • @Goovytalks
    @Goovytalks Місяць тому

    My personal solution I've found for this is the pc indie scene. I find a genre or specific type of game I like and then that leads me to someones passion project where you can feel that it was truly built with care.

    • @Goovytalks
      @Goovytalks Місяць тому

      Some of my favorite games ever made were made by a team of like 5 people

  • @wjl2068
    @wjl2068 Місяць тому +2

    I love long games especially rogs

  • @Karlito1738
    @Karlito1738 2 місяці тому

    For me this one of the reasons why the Mario series (and by extension a few other Nintendo series) are my favorite games to play, they pack so much ideas with an insane amount of creativity into a single level/section. Not picking on any game in particular, but where other games may take hours to introduce new ideas and game mechanics, Mario has already threw several ideas at you and keeps moving on to the next new idea.
    A great example of this is Wonder, yes it's quite short but almost every level will have some unique twist that doesn't overstay its welcome. This also helps replay ability as you never spend too long on the one idea, at least for me personally

  • @mrafflin
    @mrafflin 2 місяці тому +1

    Man I wanted to watch this but I’m trying to avoid metroid dread spoilers

  • @christophertaylor8202
    @christophertaylor8202 2 місяці тому

    This video hit home I’m 36 with a 1yr old and full time job it’s alot of games I DL and never play so I just play games I know imma have fun Fighters,COD,Sports and soulslikes

  • @kamikazezebra
    @kamikazezebra Місяць тому

    I agree 100%. There are some long games that I feel are worth my time and I can get lost in (Elden Ring immediately comes to mind), but otherwise I'm sick of so many shallow games feeling like they need to be 100+ hours. Starfield was a great example of quantity over quality gone horribly wrong. I want to enjoy lots of different games and that's why I appreciate a good 10-30 hour game.

  • @syedsaim3470
    @syedsaim3470 22 дні тому

    You are like me i also have big backlog of videogames to play but let's chill and then move forward with it

  • @andycanoy863
    @andycanoy863 Місяць тому

    I enjoy playing long games but love shorter games just as much or even more. Lifestyle is a factor if you have time to play specific videogames.
    Most importantly, there's a difference between being a fan and fanboy. Let people enjoy what they like and if you disagree, have a conversation or write about it in a respectful rather than a contest involving who can be louder than a megaphone.

  • @ceeece
    @ceeece 2 місяці тому

    I appreciate the effort that goes into large games. I am an older gamer and need quick fixes. I have bypassed some great games due to the length. I also like to keep games to replay more than once or return to later. Then a sequel comes out before i am thoroughly satisfied with my first experience. I would care more about trophies but the backlog is real.

  • @gotinogaden
    @gotinogaden 2 місяці тому

    Splendid analysis. The most common reason I'd usually drop a game is too high of a learning curve, a high level of investment that is required to master just the basics, let alone become proficient. If it's a title that demands high levels of technicality before it can hook you in with its plot or potential rewards, forget it, it will automatically hit the bottom in terms of completion priority. On a more general note, such willingness to let go of multiple games in succession can really be indicative of another issue entirely, like depression, anhedonia, or a general dissatisfaction with life itself. There doesn't seem to be a universal solution to the issue, and the existence of backlogs coupled with the paradox of choice is a whole other can of worms.

    • @MrBlurryEyes_
      @MrBlurryEyes_ 2 місяці тому

      I'm the opposite without learning new mechanics and an up there learning curve dark souls/sifu/sekiro ext. I almost never complete them.

  • @fishbones3650
    @fishbones3650 Місяць тому

    My issue before is that Games end too quick, I find no issue on it being long tbh

  • @GiordanDiodato
    @GiordanDiodato 2 місяці тому

    in a way, I think the long length of some games was a response to people complaining about Call of Duty campaigns being "too short"

  • @dayman1730
    @dayman1730 Місяць тому

    An example of a short but sweet, well worth its price, is Mouthwashing in my opinion. It manages to weave together such an interesting story, with such engaging themes in a short 2.5 hour run-time. It is well worth the 12$ price tag, especially given how worth replaying it is given its depth

  • @ThousandairesClub
    @ThousandairesClub 2 місяці тому +1

    I love a 5 hour monster with unlimited replay value 😍

  • @blamejohnath
    @blamejohnath 2 місяці тому

    the Draconic Tree Sentinel got me to finally try Titanfall 2 :-)

  • @chozochiefxiii3298
    @chozochiefxiii3298 26 днів тому

    For me, the only single-player games that need to be 20+ hours are rpgs, and maybe strategy and rts games since they have a lot of dialogue and are usually long missions.
    Everything else: 8-12 or 15 hours is the sweetspot for 3d games and for 2d arcadey games 8 hours or less. Since I appreciate when games are small enough that I feel encouraged to replay them over and over. Plus, games used to be able to tell stories as good and sometimes better than today in less time in generations past.

  • @millabasset1710
    @millabasset1710 Місяць тому

    I own a business and work a lot, when I do game, I need something I can beat quick and be satisfied with. I don't have time for RPGs and open world games anymore.

  • @Eroil
    @Eroil 2 місяці тому +2

    Damn had to look at the channel to remember what it was and if I didn't click sub by mistake lol

  • @Me_Myself_Maly
    @Me_Myself_Maly Місяць тому

    While I don't mind Metroid Dread being short, GOD I wish they gave it some better post game content! That game was probably my Switch game if they year. But I finished it sooo quickly and now it just collects dust in my collection

  • @stevenyoung1141
    @stevenyoung1141 Місяць тому

    My favorite games of all time are 8 to 10 hours because it is just long enough to make it an investment but not so long i lose interest and get overwhelmed. Shorter games are generally more memorable and shareable too. With really long games, it's like "wait until the 15th hour the story gets really good." I can tell you how many reviews that say something similar to that. Also, there are sooo many games I can easy just jump to a new game, without finishing the one I was playing. One more thing, the replayability is much higher one shorter games, long games you wouldn't dream of doing everything all over again to get to the 15th hour when it starts getting good. I have I have beat a game like Ori 3 times and enjoyed it everytime. It's not like when I was young I only had the one game to play, now I have an online library. Great video, I share the same feelings.

  • @bowebusi
    @bowebusi Місяць тому

    Brain rot really got a chokehold on a lot of people. Holy.

  • @KCIsMe
    @KCIsMe 2 місяці тому

    ADD medication helped me enjoy games too! It helped me not feel as overwhelmed by my backlog and open world games and also stick through tutorials and slow sections in games

  • @conchobharkhan4167
    @conchobharkhan4167 2 місяці тому +2

    Preach my brother

  • @arandomthought9001
    @arandomthought9001 Місяць тому

    See this is why I lowkey like the Spider-Man insomniac games for what they are. Usually max 18 hour campaigns with another 5 or so hours of extra content (first game has dlc but I digress) they don’t overstay their welcome. I spent the most time with the first one which was 50 hours, but Miles Morales was only 18 for me and 2 was 30. Not too long for the other two, which I was able to finish while working full time within a few weeks while playing other games as well.

  • @arthurgcab
    @arthurgcab 2 місяці тому +3

    My problem isn’t on length of the game, just why is it lengthy. absolutely love FF, but just the hours of traversing between battles… 5 minutes of walking for 10 seconds of battle I mean cmon hahaha played an old game recently and really liked that between areas where I had to do something, it was maybe a minute exposing whatever I had to do next. Metroid might be short, but if it is 10 hours of playing it for real, I’m down for it.
    Another good example of massive game that you sink HOURS in just walking around is Mario Odyssey. Even if the purpose is you walk and explore the map, it does not feel like going to the glowy spot or whatever

    • @Superdude-rd2gs
      @Superdude-rd2gs 2 місяці тому +3

      mario odyssey is a platformer, platformers are meant to make movement feel good

    • @Karlito1738
      @Karlito1738 2 місяці тому

      Mario Odyssey has a lot of walking yes but it's a 3D platformer that's meant to be intrinsically fun tbf

  • @KriskayART
    @KriskayART Місяць тому

    Thanks for this video!

  • @CoRxx9
    @CoRxx9 2 місяці тому

    Are we JUST NOW figuring this out?

  • @DEEPANSHUGulia88
    @DEEPANSHUGulia88 Місяць тому +1

    what is the game at 10:59 ??
    I am interested in buying it.

  • @shauncameron8390
    @shauncameron8390 Місяць тому

    LOL. Just 2 (console) generations ago, people complained about video games being too short which only applied to action, some platformer and shooter games.

  • @TheProfanedSamurai
    @TheProfanedSamurai 2 місяці тому

    I feel the same way. I have rise of the ronin, dd2, horizon forbidden west, and many other games that I WANT to play, but i barely have time to invest in them for 1, and 2 which is probably my biggest problem is, the dark souls series is my comfort games that I can play and feel like rather playing in my short moments of game time. Because playing the others I feel like im forcing myself to playthrough for the sake of saying I did, but I can’t have fun with them anymore, im no longer a kid with no responsibilities, that can game forever.. so my backlog got out of hand..

  • @hollowedboi5937
    @hollowedboi5937 2 місяці тому +4

    Games don’t have to be so expensive tho. CEO’s can take off a fraction of their self imposed income and allow games to stay normal price and not have microtransaction or exploitation

    • @ForceofNature99
      @ForceofNature99 Місяць тому +1

      Unfortunately that would require CEO's to be pious, charitable beings. CEO's don't become CEO's by being pious, charitable beings.

    • @shauncameron8390
      @shauncameron8390 Місяць тому

      The CEO's salary is determined by shareholders.

  • @Ant_370
    @Ant_370 Місяць тому

    When it’s done right, I don’t mind a long game. Like BOTW and TOTK

  • @gomezfreshh9897
    @gomezfreshh9897 2 місяці тому +1

    Why is Doki Doki on your backlog? Are you trolling?

  • @watson3047z
    @watson3047z 2 місяці тому

    A game usually needs to feel like progress is being made. Games will have some amount of repetition, but if a series' games are more of the same, then gamers get bored. I was late to playing the Arkham games, knowing they are highly praised for the most part. I made the mistake of playing three of them in a row, and the boredom set in. If I had played these games years apart, like when they were released, I think all the games would not have seemed repetitious.
    Another point is there are so many games to play that are in game libraries. It seems daunting to try to play through most and at times I feel like I'm just trudging through games to get them done. It doesn't necessarily make a play session boring, just not fun.
    10:53 The Messenger is a really fun game!

  • @SpecShadow
    @SpecShadow Місяць тому

    Long games are one thing - but when it's mostly filler when it's a problem. Had no regrets abusing Cheat Engine in games (mostly with a lot of walking or whatever) like Dragon Age Inquisition where some grind was necessary to progress.

  • @puno_de_leyenda3299
    @puno_de_leyenda3299 2 місяці тому +1

    Great video! I thought I was alone feeling this! Lol
    But yeah, the realization I've been having is that I have so many games, so many big AAA things and open-world things and even non-triple A stuff-so much of it, I just don't give a shit anymore. If I feel like I have to play to progress it incrementally for whatever reason, that feels like work to me.
    That’s not fun. Playing for the sake of playing sucks, as opposed to finding more fun.
    So that's led me to just start dropping things off my wishlists and backlogs-I just don't care and don't need all these big games.
    And the ones that I'm playing, I'm just dropping them too. Elden Ring? Great game, just beat Fire Giant, but I'm bored now-feels like it should have ended back at Leyndell.
    I feel like I'm just playing it to beat bosses-let me just skip to those or something lol
    Anyways, I've reduced my scope to a narrow scope of games, because I just don't have the time and money to waste on these "great games".
    My fighting games, like Street Fighter 6(Respect for that bro!), Yakuza games(Yes, they're long, but I just love the series and they have so much fun with all the minigames and stuff and are just funny af-be warned the Judgment series feels more like busy work compared to Yakuza, Beat em ups like Streets of Rage 4, 2D and 3D platformers, Zelda and Nintendo stuff in general(Shout out to Metroid Dread too! My first Metroid game and loved every second of it! Tried Metroid Prime and uninstalled lol), Indie stuff, retro games
    In fact, retro and indie stuff is where you find the best experiences overall! Those games just get it...
    Thanks again for the video brother, I fully agree and am happy to finally realize how to fix my gaming habits.