This is such a great example of the INCREDIBLE control Mariah has over her voice when she’s singing, which is extremely hard ESPECIALLY with nodules. But she powered through and still managed to sound absolutely breathtaking.
@@patricktilsley9164 Please read to understand instead of reading just to respond. I wasn’t clearly referring to the fact that I did not know the performance was dubbed in the first place.
I feel like if she didn't dub those performances, people wouldn't be so hard on her! For example, we watched the decline of Whitney's voice and she was very honest about it, her I Will always Love you note was very different through the years as her entire range! So I think because Mariah dubbed so many perfomances, people expected perfection and when the vocal decline became evident people started being so Hard on her because it happened so suddenly! But I love Mariah no matter what! And I would love to go see her show!
I don't think it would have made a difference. Even when she lost the ability to hit the G5s and F#5s as easy as it is for her to drink a glass of champagne and honey, she was still able to pull of a lot of signature notes, especially the whistle register which she only stopped doing noticeably as much from 2007, and she stopped belting F#5s all together after 2004 (minus one in 2008 and an accidental one in 2015). And I think a lot of that is due to laziness, drinking (she's drinking whilst singing Touch My Body on TBR), weed smoking, and a lack of rest (three nights in a row recently!!!). It's not because she's a lost a huge amount of her voice, it's just that she doesn't care anymore, and people notice that. When she did care back in 2013 (because of American Idol and album) she was giving pretty solid performances including one that easily rivals Daydream performances (Jimmy Fallon).
ummm sorry but what you're saying is not a Mariah choice and doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Maybe people doesn't seem to know what dubbing means???
amazing. i love her technique. many singer now without nodules dubbed her performance or lip re record. she just need more warm up her voice to less raspy
This just looks and sounds - from the comparison at the end a difference between raw audio and mastered audio. Its clear that the 'dubbed' version is actually just post production and has effects on the raw audio. It doesnt sound at all like a "redub" ie singing again the vocals post performance- Which she did for Madison Square Garden VHS/DVD concert. It just sounds like some good post production audio mastering, smoothing out vocals with echo effects, normalising the mic feed so that the vocals are on the same level, taking out the grain which is her rasp. I say this because her flicks and runs and volume placement are all identical.
They're identical, because it's the same person who knows how to sing the song the way she planned to. However, there are very clear differences in the diction, the fluidity. It's not the same vocal.
@@chimierc5920 I think it's the same vocal just produced and "polished" to reduce the rasp. She always said that her voice was naturally raspy and hated how they overproduced her early records to remove the rasp.
Mariah is a very insecure and shy person. You could sense her nervousness. You can compare her confidence with solo performances versus awards shows or tv shows like this especially with another super performer.
OMG I can almost FEEL how nodules are stopping her from producing sound even though I never had them. It must have been painfully hard for her to try to sing around her nodules. I feel like her prime would've at least extended to 2005 if she never had had them.
There is no doubt she can still hit whistles. I don't remember exactly but she didn't lip all the whistle on her shows and tours even lately. Plus even though she lipped many of them, she still constantly records new versions of them which proves that she can hit them fine in studio.
The mother of MUSIC ! She deserve a statue in Time Square and millitary honors after her dath....For the humanity to remember about the GODES of Music here on earth !
I love when she sings live... everytime everywhere!!! I prefer some imperfections but I know we know honestly that her voice is that when she sings you say "ah ok, it's Mariah"... other singers are powerful, more powerful in some moments but not a tipycal tone!!
Basically Mariah mastered all the vocal techniques, but for those ppl who still say she can't sing, she's under control, she has NODULES. That's why she can hit higher notes/whistle notes although she is an alto. When she's in a good day, she can shut your asses all the way down!!!!
Mariah is the opposite of contralto, my friend. She was a light lyric coloratura who was never meant to belt or harbor greats amounts of power. Her head voice is very light bright warm and agile as you can hear in songs such as the roof where her "whispery " head tone is always in the 5th or 6th octave.
@@lougomes2912 hasn’t she said that she has lower voice. I would put her in mezzo category, with extended range on both ends, her sound is so rich and full she is not light lyric soprano (she supported f2 no soprano will be able to do that)
There is a distinction between dubbing and filtering vocals in post. This is completely undubbed but they certainly finessed the vocal to achieve a smoother sound.
Wow, I never ever knew this was dubbed, all these years. She was just a tad raspier live, not that big of a deal... I'm sure Whitney could have stood up just like Mariah did for her though. Anyhow, thanks for this!
This performance wasn’t even dubbed. The “undubbed” with the additional rasp is exactly what aired (you can see on full episode clips on UA-cam). That same weird hater just created a “dubbed” version to imply the duet was dubbed as well.
That's my opinion too. But they added the "youuuuuu and meeee" head voice note. It was not audible in the undubbed clip. I don't know if she recorded two takes of this performance tho.
Has anyone notice Whitney Houston smiling in the background while MARIAH CAREY is hitting those notes it just warms my heart omg😩😢🙏🏾❤️ #R.I.P Whitney Houston
2:54 That glorious whistle register peeking through without her permission. Lol. You have to be a very skilled singer to be able to sing around those nodules. Yet she still sounded good and a tad better than anyone nowadays.
It's interesting how you can see how her body language also changes when the rasp starts kicking in. Makes me want to look for other performances where she might have hidden that gorgeous rasp.
You look into my eyes And I get emotional inside I know it's crazy but You still can touch my heart And after all this time You'd think that I I wouldn't feel the same But time melts into nothing And nothing's changed I still believe Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again I had a dream Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again Each day of my life I'm filled with all the joy I could find You know that I I'm not the desperate type If there's one spark of hope Left in my grasp I'll be holding it with both hands It's worth the risk of burning To have a second chance No no no no no no I need you baby I still believe that we can be together If we believe that true love Never has to end Then we must know that we will love again I still believe Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again Oh, baby, yeah, yeah I had a dream You and me Will find ourselves in love again I still believe (Uh, baby I do) Someday you and me Just give me one more try And love again I had a dream (I miss your love) Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again I still believe Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again
this is my favorite era because her voice just matured into the adult age, thats why it became harder for her to sing as the years go by, shes gonna go down a note or two, thats just puberty🤷🏾♂️
mario123m Actually. Depending on the format of wherever she is performing sometimes you HAVE to lipsync or get things processed to match the pitch of the certain format, unless they have the means to do a live format.
I get the feeling that in this performance, she gave a lot more effort, because Whitney is watching, like dang she's like I don't wanna disappoint my girl
![[Unedited vocals] One Sweet Day - Mariah Carey and Boyz II Men (live at Madison Square Garden) 1995](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HwXrLwbP7nI/mqdefault.jpg)
I prefer the undubbed version, the raspiness was such a trademark for that era. Ugh.
Kkkkk. Oh my God. Why people cant accept
2:04 too much rasp here
Kopter Vachiravit it’s beautiful
Hell yes!
what does dub mean
I love how Whitney watches like a proud mom in the background! That grin like "yes baby SING!" XD
I agree. These Mariah lambs are so catty. Whitney was very supportive and classy.
The girl can SANG!!
Proud mom? Thats the dumbest thing I've ever heard!!!!
@@sweetsweetfantansy Stop being hateful. Whitney was like a big sister to Mariah. Mariah has even said so herself. Grow up and behave yourself!
@@Niko-mc4zl Immature and catty
2:07 Whitney was smiling at those beautiful raspy belts. Two biggest Divas in one room. The audience is soooo lucky
Yeh. Like idk what will happen when I am there but I was not born at that time yet lol.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 omg hi
@@Fishriah_Ari Hiiii queen.
@@Fishriah_Ari omgg hi
Whitney knew ❤😊
She sang the everlasting shit out of this song!
Yes tf she did!!!
So mildly stated!!!🤣🤣🤣👍👍👍
Also, because Whitney was behind her
2:53 her whistle came out with her head voice. Polyphonic. Luvit ♡
thought i was the only one who heard it. it isn't healthy tho
@@angel127_ why not?
preferred the undubbed version more, raspyriah.
2:07 Whitney smiling to those belts and Whitney was like: That's my fellow diva!! Slaayyy darling. Saaaannggggg gurrrrlll
i choose the undubbed version, her raspy voice is sooo beautiful
A little raspy, but her tone was gorgeous. 😍
Nobody can sing so beautifully. OMG her tone is unmatch in this era!
Her voice is so loud, strong and beautiful. Her tone as so many layers is so emotional yet so versatil. 🤷♂️
No reason to dub it though. Raw version is way better. Imperfections are good. Those raspiness makes it more emotional.
This is such a great example of the INCREDIBLE control Mariah has over her voice when she’s singing, which is extremely hard ESPECIALLY with nodules. But she powered through and still managed to sound absolutely breathtaking.
2:01 - 2:15 is absolutely heavenly. Love the beautiful rasp, emotion and always love her graceful stage movements.
Whitney’s smiles gets me 😭😍
Didn't even know this was dubbed. She really didn't need to dub it though. Raspy but still great❤❤
Christopher Wilson it was undubbed, as mentioned in the title
@@patricktilsley9164 and the comparison, as per the title, which is referring to the dubbed version which I had no idea existed either.
@@patricktilsley9164 Please read to understand instead of reading just to respond. I wasn’t clearly referring to the fact that I did not know the performance was dubbed in the first place.
It wasn’t dubbed, lol, watch the video and read the title again.
this must be the first time that the imperfections of the vocals make me love the undubbed performance over the dubbed ...
Ugh that rasp is everything!!!
Mesmerized 4Life hey boo ❤️
Ax'l Sister Hey :)
Always undubbed! We don't need the perfection, it's a human! And I love her imperfections
Nem sempre
The undubbed is better actually!
Omg Whitney in the back !!! Idk how she did it
I LOVE this. Absolutely NO reason to remaster a live performance of Mariah. Especially back in her prime.
Her sopranish tone here is everything.
Thanks for the credits ;)
goosebumps.I am still watching march 2019.
I feel like if she didn't dub those performances, people wouldn't be so hard on her! For example, we watched the decline of Whitney's voice and she was very honest about it, her I Will always Love you note was very different through the years as her entire range! So I think because Mariah dubbed so many perfomances, people expected perfection and when the vocal decline became evident people started being so Hard on her because it happened so suddenly! But I love Mariah no matter what! And I would love to go see her show!
Frankie Nardi i know wot ur saying but people still tore whitney to shreds. i doubt whether it wud make much difference as to how people treat mariah
Frankie NS the bar was raised too high
I don't think it would have made a difference. Even when she lost the ability to hit the G5s and F#5s as easy as it is for her to drink a glass of champagne and honey, she was still able to pull of a lot of signature notes, especially the whistle register which she only stopped doing noticeably as much from 2007, and she stopped belting F#5s all together after 2004 (minus one in 2008 and an accidental one in 2015). And I think a lot of that is due to laziness, drinking (she's drinking whilst singing Touch My Body on TBR), weed smoking, and a lack of rest (three nights in a row recently!!!). It's not because she's a lost a huge amount of her voice, it's just that she doesn't care anymore, and people notice that. When she did care back in 2013 (because of American Idol and album) she was giving pretty solid performances including one that easily rivals Daydream performances (Jimmy Fallon).
ummm sorry but what you're saying is not a Mariah choice and doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Maybe people doesn't seem to know what dubbing means???
@@Solo-vh9fm Mariah is smoking weed? Source please
How beautiful they are😭❤️❤️They are the true talent......I guess there's nothing like those anymore
Mahendra Harimurti you said it all.there is nothing like this anymore.. #mariahcarey.. #withneyHouston
amazing. i love her technique. many singer now without nodules dubbed her performance or lip re record. she just need more warm up her voice to less raspy
This just looks and sounds - from the comparison at the end a difference between raw audio and mastered audio. Its clear that the 'dubbed' version is actually just post production and has effects on the raw audio. It doesnt sound at all like a "redub" ie singing again the vocals post performance- Which she did for Madison Square Garden VHS/DVD concert.
It just sounds like some good post production audio mastering, smoothing out vocals with echo effects, normalising the mic feed so that the vocals are on the same level, taking out the grain which is her rasp.
I say this because her flicks and runs and volume placement are all identical.
Chris P people don't know what dubbing means.
They're identical, because it's the same person who knows how to sing the song the way she planned to. However, there are very clear differences in the diction, the fluidity. It's not the same vocal.
Eric Winter There’s portions of the studio acapella thrown in the mix.
@@chimierc5920 I think it's the same vocal just produced and "polished" to reduce the rasp. She always said that her voice was naturally raspy and hated how they overproduced her early records to remove the rasp.
Wow the undubbed is so good I thought it was the dubbed version
lol Imagine how is hard to sing with whitney houston sitting behind you
Maráia Kérei Br both are in the same league
Ginx Mesalaz she was smiling at 2:12 when Mariah sang 'NOO, No no no' part and it gave me life lmao
Emancipation of an Infamous Pothead superiority smile LOL
iMAGINE how hard it is to sing while Ms. Mariah is sitting Behind You.
Mariah is a very insecure and shy person. You could sense her nervousness. You can compare her confidence with solo performances versus awards shows or tv shows like this especially with another super performer.
OMG I can almost FEEL how nodules are stopping her from producing sound even though I never had them. It must have been painfully hard for her to try to sing around her nodules. I feel like her prime would've at least extended to 2005 if she never had had them.
Zheng X The only problem is by Getting them removed she might loose her big range and will for sure loose her whistle register
I heard a rumor that she can't whistle anymore anyway? Not sure if that's true though..
Stephen Scaccia of course she still can but now she's going into a phase she already had from 94-98 Where she focused more on her chest voice
There's a video on Instagram of her singing whistle notes acapella from a year or two ago. She definitely can still hit them.
There is no doubt she can still hit whistles. I don't remember exactly but she didn't lip all the whistle on her shows and tours even lately. Plus even though she lipped many of them, she still constantly records new versions of them which proves that she can hit them fine in studio.
The mother of MUSIC ! She deserve a statue in Time Square and millitary honors after her dath....For the humanity to remember about the GODES of Music here on earth !
Undubbed WAY better!!! Raw and emotional!!!! Love the raspiness too! All her live performances of this song were on point!
I love when she sings live... everytime everywhere!!! I prefer some imperfections but I know we know honestly that her voice is that when she sings you say "ah ok, it's Mariah"... other singers are powerful, more powerful in some moments but not a tipycal tone!!
I prefer the undubbed. You hear the true emotion and grit in her voice.❤❤❤❤❤
Ditto
Damn it still sounds sooooooo good!! ❤❤❤
both sounded exactly the same to me.
Basically Mariah mastered all the vocal techniques, but for those ppl who still say she can't sing, she's under control, she has NODULES. That's why she can hit higher notes/whistle notes although she is an alto. When she's in a good day, she can shut your asses all the way down!!!!
Mariah ñ é contralto
Mariah is the opposite of contralto, my friend. She was a light lyric coloratura who was never meant to belt or harbor greats amounts of power. Her head voice is very light bright warm and agile as you can hear in songs such as the roof where her "whispery " head tone is always in the 5th or 6th octave.
@@lougomes2912 hasn’t she said that she has lower voice. I would put her in mezzo category, with extended range on both ends, her sound is so rich and full she is not light lyric soprano (she supported f2 no soprano will be able to do that)
@@Zinger2999 She never claimed to be a lower voice type. I'm sorry but I am exhausted of this topic so won't proceed
@@Zinger2999 She didn't support down to F2. She can extend her lower register down to F#2 but it is not supported.
I prefer the undubbed version. Love the raw vocals and raspy sound.
3:37 that run reminds me of Daydream interlude during her concerts
when the un-dubbed and dubbed versions both sound really good.
Just watching this was making me run out of breath, all that breathing and raspyness. I was like go Mariah, dont mess that note. Incredible voice.
Absolutely beautiful. Her imperfections are perfect.
A another great singer. I love Mariah Carey music.
A blessed present from heaven!!!
I still was written in the moment when I was born and is fantastic Mariah Carey thank you for all the music that you make up .
love love love the undubbed. so raw and truly heart-felt.
Love both if I'm honest
There is a distinction between dubbing and filtering vocals in post. This is completely undubbed but they certainly finessed the vocal to achieve a smoother sound.
Wow, I never ever knew this was dubbed, all these years. She was just a tad raspier live, not that big of a deal... I'm sure Whitney could have stood up just like Mariah did for her though. Anyhow, thanks for this!
Amazing....undubbed. so much talent
This performance wasn’t even dubbed. The “undubbed” with the additional rasp is exactly what aired (you can see on full episode clips on UA-cam). That same weird hater just created a “dubbed” version to imply the duet was dubbed as well.
Really?
Now I understand, Mariah really sings through her throat.
Even with rasp.. It sounded soooo heavenly...
I loveeeed so much when miss carey sing live......i enjoy it...
Love this !
2 of the best singers in the world in one room. ❤️
That us young lady sing from heart ! Faith ever !
The Queen ❤️
I honesty dont understand why her videos are not undubbed. Really sound so much better and natural, and she doesn't no one edit because is The One!!!
I dont think its dubbed with separately recorded vocals. They just reduced the extreme rasps and added effects for more resonance.
That's my opinion too. But they added the "youuuuuu and meeee" head voice note. It was not audible in the undubbed clip. I don't know if she recorded two takes of this performance tho.
That's exactly what dubbing is all about....lol
when they dubbed it, they added some reverb to it. well I like the undubbed too😍
I love her rasp omg. Like he just made herself a new register and it is rasp. It doesn't sound that forced that much. Unlike xtina.
OMG she's Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Beautiful...
It's difficult to compare because the volume is different.
undubbed. untouched. untouchable!
I love her so much
I love this song so much.. 😘
I love the raspiness of the voice. It makes the song more desperate and meaneingful. She should embrace it more.
Has anyone notice Whitney Houston smiling in the background while MARIAH CAREY is hitting those notes it just warms my heart omg😩😢🙏🏾❤️ #R.I.P Whitney Houston
i prefer the undubbed versionnn, its amazing
And that ladies and gents is how you knock right out the PARK 🙏👏👏👏👏👏😍😍
that damn nodules :( but still very good performancr and shows how can Mariah sing just the nodules didnt let the brightness came out.
2:54 That glorious whistle register peeking through without her permission. Lol. You have to be a very skilled singer to be able to sing around those nodules. Yet she still sounded good and a tad better than anyone nowadays.
It's interesting how you can see how her body language also changes when the rasp starts kicking in. Makes me want to look for other performances where she might have hidden that gorgeous rasp.
Imagine dubbing over raw beautiful vocals
i love the realness and rawness of her Godly Gifted Vocals
Sound better undubbed , amazing i notice all her armonic and vocal tecnic she is using to process the sounds sing
love hearing when she pauses to take a breath, you know something great is about to happen! i even like the sound of her taking a breath.
I always felt this was the best live performance of this song...and better than the recorded version
You look into my eyes
And I get emotional inside
I know it's crazy but
You still can touch my heart
And after all this time
You'd think that I
I wouldn't feel the same
But time melts into nothing
And nothing's changed
I still believe
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
I had a dream
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Each day of my life
I'm filled with all the joy I could find
You know that I
I'm not the desperate type
If there's one spark of hope
Left in my grasp
I'll be holding it with both hands
It's worth the risk of burning
To have a second chance
No no no no no no
I need you baby
I still believe that we can be together
If we believe that true love
Never has to end
Then we must know that we will love again
I still believe
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Oh, baby, yeah, yeah
I had a dream
You and me
Will find ourselves in love again
I still believe
(Uh, baby I do)
Someday you and me
Just give me one more try
And love again
I had a dream
(I miss your love)
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
I still believe
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Muito obrigado pela letra!
THE RASPINESS THAT SOUND BEAUTIFUL
Undubbed is so good all notes are hitted like wow❤
this is my favorite era because her voice just matured into the adult age, thats why it became harder for her to sing as the years go by, shes gonna go down a note or two, thats just puberty🤷🏾♂️
Do we know if When You Believe was also dubbed? Now I have doubts
LEGEND!!👏👏👏😊🎼🔊🍻
I didn't know there was a dubbed version. I recorded the undubbed on VCR when it aired in Australia in 1999
Adele n Bey could never
Wish she did the Whistle that day too. I love Mariah so much
I love how at the 'no no no no' part she's just as resonant as the dubbed one
I wish they hadn't dubbed so many performances of her, it sounds great undubbed
What do people have against rasp? I love rasp in some people's voices. For example- Brandy.
Oh for these two women to have sung one after the other during their prime.
Actually I prefer her undubbed version. More texture in the voice and still right on spot.
lovely
2:53 whistle ?
I don't know but that sound was also on the dubbed version.
those are her nodules- it happens to me sometimes
I don't think it was dubbed, I think they just put her live vocals through a filter to make it smoother.
Sterling Ross That's kinda was dubbing is. You just switch out some vocals.
Sterling Ross There is no 'they'. It's Mariah herself who decides to dub her performances.
mario123m wasnt she still under Sony contract?
mario123m Actually. Depending on the format of wherever she is performing sometimes you HAVE to lipsync or get things processed to match the pitch of the certain format, unless they have the means to do a live format.
I get the feeling that in this performance, she gave a lot more effort, because Whitney is watching, like dang she's like I don't wanna disappoint my girl
I miss yooourr loove !!!
Fantastica aaaa