Steel vs Concrete House. Which Is Better?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 251

  • @hangingamihan4078
    @hangingamihan4078 11 місяців тому +42

    Clearly, Slater’s work ethic is a reflection of his father’s practice, wisdom, and transparency. The family is into steel construction, yet, Slater objectively discussed the pros and cons of steel. If ever Scottie, Sevi, and/or thirdy would be an engineer someday, magiging maayos siya/silang engineer!

  • @shets7988
    @shets7988 8 місяців тому +3

    As a structural designer, I hope future homeowners and house contractors learn from this.

  • @amazingbarley3851
    @amazingbarley3851 11 місяців тому +19

    I am amazed by you and your dad's story sir Slater. Nakaka amaze na ang tagal na ng Dad ninyo sa business.. Next content suggestion : how did you guys started? young entrepreneur here

  • @clarence__
    @clarence__ 11 місяців тому +13

    Kakalesson lang Po namin Ng reinforced concrete vs steel and this video pops up, it really widened my mind. Thanks papsie Slater🤍

  • @MyAnjs
    @MyAnjs 4 місяці тому +1

    As usual, meron na naman akong natutunan from Sir Slater. Thank you so much po. Wala ako sa construction industry pero enjoy tlga ako sa mga ganitong videos. Favorite ko ang channel nyo. God bless.

    • @MyAnjs
      @MyAnjs 4 місяці тому

      Keep it up po sir. God bless.

  • @arniegv
    @arniegv 11 місяців тому +9

    As usual, always have the best content and simple explanation. Kudos sir!

  • @ENGR-DPC
    @ENGR-DPC 11 місяців тому +11

    I remember the RC and Steel topic when I was reviewing pa in Cebu. The topic was basically a cracking moment where in the instructor was talking a lot of the equivalent strength of steel in a concrete dimension. That a small steel when converted into a concrete it is quite bigger when it comes to strength. But when concrete is converted in steel it is quite small when talking about strength.

    • @ENGR-DPC
      @ENGR-DPC 11 місяців тому +3

      @@exia4171 Hi! sir, Mahal po talaga yung steel compare to concrete.
      But we design our structures base on some categories:
      Safety
      Economical
      aesthetic (Beauty of the structure)

  • @tenshimallows174
    @tenshimallows174 8 місяців тому +1

    As a civil engineer, I am really inspired and I really learn a lot from all your videos, thank you Engr.!

  • @ksspguam
    @ksspguam 8 місяців тому +2

    . I am planning to build a house and in the process of researching the most cost effective way to build it. My dream house…Thank you very much for sharing.

  • @clipendo
    @clipendo 11 місяців тому +27

    Sana makagawa po ng content regarding fences, types, that are more or less specailly inexpensive for empty lots na matagal pa bago lagyan ng bahay. Thank you po.

  • @ahbinjae5651
    @ahbinjae5651 11 місяців тому +9

    I LOVE IT HOW SLATER EXPLAINS THIINGS .

  • @glendaburbano7399
    @glendaburbano7399 9 місяців тому

    One of my dream, concrete/steel house even tho its very expensive, pero sa nangyayari sa atin ngayon baha, bagyo lindol.. thata the concern ,thanks for this content sir slater.. always hands down to you

  • @oofiee8833
    @oofiee8833 10 місяців тому +2

    cold rolled steel are starting to get more popular also, with its light weight properties it makes construction faster than hot rolled steel.

  • @brandonangelodiaz8854
    @brandonangelodiaz8854 Місяць тому +1

    Even if I have watched this months ago, I went back again to get to know quick insights between steel and concrete. And since we are planning to re model our ancestral house, I am deciding if what is the best foundation that will last a very long time. We are situated centro in our town here in the province of La Union, and we have the mountains on the east and the sea to the west. My priority is a strong foundation from the ground up and design for me is just second to this aspect. Since we recently experienced 6 straight typhoons in just a month, and even if the house did not budged a bit, I still worry that our house might get damaged in time. Our house is 2 floors, with a concrete base, old wood wall foundations on the 2nd floor with wood flooring above the ceiling from the ground floor and the roof is already old. And our house was more than partially renovated 30 years ago so the integrity worries me a lot and even if the renovation was thoroughly built, 30 years will truly weaken the structural integrity and materials before are not like the modern materials now that are more durable and innovative.

  • @nouvada
    @nouvada 4 місяці тому +1

    Brilliant! The switching languages is awesome as well. So authentic and anyone in construction around the world who works in a multinational team will get the vibe

  • @kizitodaniel3736
    @kizitodaniel3736 4 місяці тому

    Thank you for your breakdown, your explanation is very elaborate and gives a honest view which is helpful in helping us make the decision

  • @odlanorirom
    @odlanorirom 11 місяців тому +3

    …i’m planning to construct an industrial inspired house elevated on steel beams…roof trusses will be metal tubular, exterior and interior walls will be eps panels (if it would endure the elements)…and lots of insulation…

  • @jamesdaryllgonzales4045
    @jamesdaryllgonzales4045 11 місяців тому +20

    The audio is 🔥🔥🔥 really crispy, feels like im listening to a ted talk

  • @kc5169
    @kc5169 3 місяці тому

    These are exactly the kind of construction videos the Philippines needs. How about a video on different types of roofs.

  • @jimmoca2182
    @jimmoca2182 Місяць тому

    As a bonus I got me a nice lesson learning tagalog too salamat😊

  • @robernisaiah
    @robernisaiah 11 місяців тому +4

    timely info for our house construction, thanks for this

  • @muntingmagsasaka9056
    @muntingmagsasaka9056 11 місяців тому +1

    Agree!!! Yung mga construction barracks namin steel,ung iba steel container tapos lagyan ng insulation, ok na. Kaya sa mga planta steel structure lahat para pag may modification eh madali lng. Pero kung bahay eh no.1 option is concrete, pero kung meron ka naman at may legit kang kilala/alam na gagawa ehdi go😂

  • @RogerBartolay
    @RogerBartolay 7 місяців тому

    Mabuhay, Engr. Slater! Daming learning

  • @niiiqx
    @niiiqx 11 місяців тому +2

    High quality content *chef's kiss

  • @Beyond3Generations
    @Beyond3Generations День тому

    thanks for sharing this .

  • @dakilangt.v.2180
    @dakilangt.v.2180 11 місяців тому +1

    "Slater Young delivers an insightful comparison between steel and concrete structures for homes, exploring the nuances of each material to help viewers make informed decisions for their next project. By dissecting factors like cost, durability, speed, and more, he provides valuable guidance on choosing the most suitable option based on individual needs and preferences. Whether you're embarking on a new build or considering renovations, this video offers a comprehensive breakdown to aid in your decision-making process. A must-watch for anyone navigating the complexities of construction."

  • @thegreatgatsby2738
    @thegreatgatsby2738 15 днів тому

    My house is reinforced concrete. It's rebar with concrete blocks so 21% stronger than poured concrete. 1.5 ft concrete rebar foundation, so house is 1.5ft off the floor. A great thing about rebar with concrete blocks is its super energy efficient. When its super hot, it traps cold air in the house longer than drywall houses, and when its cold it traps warm air in the house for longer, so we don't need to use ac as much compared to a drywall house. ALSO hurricanes, drywall houses are super dangerous if your in a hurricane prone area, my house is a bunker man, even the roof has a mix of wood frames with steel and a bit of concrete blocks, "wood frames are used to frame the roof with steel covering the wood and concrete blocks on all sides".

  • @lynnnunal6478
    @lynnnunal6478 11 місяців тому +2

    This is so informative I like this type of content ,I'm learning a lot 🥰🥰🥰 Slater your such a good teacher I feel like my brain are exploding😂😂😂

  • @Shermug
    @Shermug 10 місяців тому

    All you’re videos are very informative, learned a lot of things..

  • @JayceeMartin-xl3gm
    @JayceeMartin-xl3gm 10 місяців тому

    Hi Slater, great content as always! Thanks!

  • @Aqualastic
    @Aqualastic 7 місяців тому

    For what I’ve noticed, steel and precast concrete combination is the more efficient solution for building and home construction in the Philippines, it’s typhoon, earthquake, termite and fire proof. It’s what mega factories in the west are made of. If we could only have more suppliers in this industry that could offer more affordable prices, this could become a commonplace structures in PI.

  • @ryanhinlayagan8975
    @ryanhinlayagan8975 10 місяців тому

    Thank you. This video is very helpful. More power Sir!

  • @tonyweshopped8665
    @tonyweshopped8665 10 місяців тому +1

    how about po strength. Sino po mas safe like if there is an earth quake. and Also if 3 story budilding. sino po mas matibay na di talaga mag cocolapse

  • @franxiswilliam647
    @franxiswilliam647 2 місяці тому

    Best explanation.... correct not all welders are structurally sound trained

  • @jacepro2827
    @jacepro2827 10 місяців тому

    you should do a vlog regarding your dad and your family's business. good job explaining it too slater!

  • @jsnmad
    @jsnmad 5 місяців тому

    I appreciate the knowledge shared. It helps in decision-making.

  • @graemescebuphilippines363
    @graemescebuphilippines363 11 місяців тому +9

    Hi Slater As New Zealand Builder (retired) I used 3 materials Timber Steel Concrete.
    General use of steel factory houses timber and concrete
    Our Cebu house is Concrete and steel. However in Cebu Concrete is definitely the preferred material.
    But I love steel fast to build with . When it comes to steel Filippo welders believe a tack is a weld however I would use more bolts . The other thing I noticed on our subdivision the use of to smaller steel far to ligh for the loadings 😊

    • @thechriswhewell
      @thechriswhewell 11 місяців тому

      I'm considering Light Steel Framing for our forthcoming house in Bohol because the walls can be insulated, whereas concrete has a huge thermal mass to dissipate through the night. I'm also going to build Australian style, with a 4m wide verandah all the way around, and a roof thickness of 450mm, stuffed full of rockwool insulation and topped with solar panels. Underneath, to help with the sloping lot, there will be a concrete 'box' beneath the main living rooms - something that avoids those rooms being in direct contact with the hot earth below. I'm hoping to minimise the need for aircon.
      What do you think of that? Is there any other way you would consider building such a structure? Obviously timber is out in the Philippines because of the termites, and CHB are next to useless, particularly if made on site. But I would be interested in knowing what you think.

    • @graemescebuphilippines363
      @graemescebuphilippines363 11 місяців тому

      ​@thechriswhewell Hi I do like the concrete as the main frame rather than steel to the fact earthquake and typhoon plus steel has the corrosion aspects as well. Definitely roof truss needs to be steel. I do like Rockwool insulation. When it comes to the walls AAC blocks seems to be a trend.
      For me hollow blocks seems be quite good as they add 30 or 40mm plaster inside and out with concrete in fill giving good insulation.
      The big problem is windows and ranchsider single glass and low quality. Bohol is loverly location but limited suppliers .
      Compared to Australian electric standards Philippines is way behind and for me I prefer RCD with earth ground and I hate the fact that no switch to power outlet.
      Definitely include surge protection.
      With solar I would still have aircons during the day free.
      Good luck with your build

  • @paoloochangco6072
    @paoloochangco6072 11 місяців тому +1

    building a house, what are the benefits of using I beams? love the passion!

  • @junsantos9629
    @junsantos9629 10 місяців тому

    Thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience. Keep it coming!

  • @shellacamilledelacruz3190
    @shellacamilledelacruz3190 9 місяців тому

    Basta bakal, Regan ❤

  • @Raygun8888
    @Raygun8888 10 місяців тому +1

    How about po sa manila common station(bayani fernando part)? Mas ok ba na steel ginamit nila instead of concrete? Sa ngayon kasi parang dami na agad kinakalawang di pa napapakinabangan. Then after nun di ba mas magastos maintenance?

  • @amparomejala5164
    @amparomejala5164 10 місяців тому +1

    Hi, do you used your lite block?

  • @desan6061
    @desan6061 8 місяців тому

    Salamat kaayo ug daghan sa mga content nimu sir.. naa free consultation sir? Estimate lng hehehe.. pila kaha cost 2 story small house lng made of steel 1 bedroom level 1, level 2 2 bedroom, tapos roof deck pang 3rd level… hahah bka sakali lng idol hhahaha ky dli gyd ko mka afford nimu engr. Or sa inyong company mn heheh ky mga bigatin mn gyd kaayo oi.. Ky ng plano mi tukod sa among dream house 🏠unta 😊. Been watching your channel and salamat kaayo ug dako gyd interesting and informative kaayo. God bless Engr. Slater!!! Dakong tabang namo mga low budget ang imung mga content 🙏🏼😊🙏🏼😊😊🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @QuantumDoze
    @QuantumDoze 9 місяців тому +1

    What about Rammed earth?

  • @andy-in8lj
    @andy-in8lj 11 місяців тому

    Great info. Specially to us na wala masyadong idea when it comes to construction
    Hoping to watch sir slater explaining the process and fee's getting a building permit

  • @charrisgonzalez
    @charrisgonzalez 11 місяців тому +1

    How to hang heavy items on fiber cement boards?

  • @vincentice57
    @vincentice57 6 місяців тому

    Gudmrn pls I build a church but d pillars are H beam after building and plastering d building I noticed the lines where the beam are use as pillars cement is not holding even after cement there are cracks on where d beam are so how do I correct it by re plastering / covering d beams wit cement

  • @Elliedri
    @Elliedri 6 місяців тому

    Do you still need to have a beam for a 2 storey house with an area of only 24 sq meter? The height of the colum per floor is 10 ft

  • @MyRealEstatePhilippines
    @MyRealEstatePhilippines 8 місяців тому

    Awesome video. Very precise on everything!

  • @PaulRamone356
    @PaulRamone356 10 місяців тому +1

    is the steel structure you moved(after a few years) a house?

  • @shaveegracegutierrez5930
    @shaveegracegutierrez5930 11 місяців тому

    Saved References for future House 🥰 Thank you.. Sir Slater, san nyo po nabili yang sa wall left nyo po kanang acoustic panel, or decorative echo Absorption and diffusion panel wave ba na?
    Thank you sa advance response ☺️

  • @ERIK52033
    @ERIK52033 11 місяців тому +1

    alin po ang mas tatagal at mas matibay kapag may lindol? steel or concrete at bakit?

  • @gc1653
    @gc1653 4 дні тому

    can you compare walls for warehouses. Is concrete better than steel walls?

  • @danecaracena
    @danecaracena 10 місяців тому

    this is very informative. thank you, Slater.

  • @maalat
    @maalat 4 місяці тому

    How about a combination of your floating cement block and steel.

  • @LiveLifeSn
    @LiveLifeSn 11 місяців тому +2

    Part 2 please🤩

  • @justinvittoriomanalo4265
    @justinvittoriomanalo4265 11 місяців тому

    Very informative and well made video. 👌
    However, its proper to use “reinforced concrete” sa title and when referring to concrete with reinforcement, which is mostly what you are describing in your video.

  • @pipolebnene
    @pipolebnene 5 місяців тому

    Can you do a video on how to save costs with examples when building a house on a budget with concrete? I am from lebanon and i think we build similar to you guys. I also feel like bali design houses are cheap from looking at it since they dont need alot of tiles and use the concrete floor and alot of benches and kitchen islands etc made of concrete. Thank you

  • @JaijieRuzol-k3h
    @JaijieRuzol-k3h 10 місяців тому

    Hi Slater. Plano namin magpagawa ng coffee shop, rooftop - beach front. Ano po ung best materials na pwede namin magamit, flooring, wall and roof, since beach po ung area, ung hangin po sa itaas mejo malakas kasi.

  • @jcjcvlogs27
    @jcjcvlogs27 11 місяців тому +1

    Very informativeeeeee 👍🏼 Pero habang nanood ng matagal bakit si scottie na nakikita ko talking 😅 hahahahha sorry na po engineer slater!

  • @jennydeeyoy7691
    @jennydeeyoy7691 11 місяців тому

    Your videos are always useful engr.❤️
    Thank you for this another vid. 🫰
    God bless u, kryz, and kids.
    A very little observation lng.. Can you correct the spelling "Maintainance" to "Maintenance"?.. nsa title kasi tlg 😊..
    But majority, your video is really commendable 👏👏👏

  • @nevinkuser9892
    @nevinkuser9892 9 місяців тому

    How about building a house from 316 square tube frame? Concrete foundation. Mostly windows.

  • @romadevil
    @romadevil 9 місяців тому +1

    Excellent video.
    How to get a good architect for a steel house structure in panay ?

  • @edwinlayron8585
    @edwinlayron8585 2 місяці тому

    Thanks for sharing this video God bless 🙏

  • @echckaravhotski8092
    @echckaravhotski8092 10 місяців тому +1

    good day sir
    gusto ko po sana maging isang epliyado nonyo.. san pwede mag apply? thanks😊

  • @lourylapasaran5992
    @lourylapasaran5992 11 місяців тому

    Very informative, nice timing! i need this info. thanks Engr.❤

  • @rolllinnn
    @rolllinnn 6 місяців тому

    Is it advisable to have this steel design if you live near the beach?

  • @kagome5271
    @kagome5271 10 місяців тому

    Very informative!
    I'm seing Radleigh.😊

  • @MsLearner2009
    @MsLearner2009 10 місяців тому

    Good explanation! Thank you for the explanation.

  • @khentmangoba
    @khentmangoba 11 місяців тому +1

    So much insight after watching this video!

  • @nonamesoyouwontsearchitupi372
    @nonamesoyouwontsearchitupi372 4 місяці тому

    Hi engineer! Gaano katagal kung magpatayo ng bahay na bato na traditional sa labas, modern sa loob?

  • @JheffDGamer
    @JheffDGamer 10 місяців тому

    hello sir meron po ba kayo video for retro fitting? meron kasi kame 3 storey house.. my nakikita na kame crack hairline pero tagusan kaya mejo worry lang

  • @GaniduGayashan
    @GaniduGayashan 3 місяці тому

    Is it good for coastal area?

  • @ronwyl
    @ronwyl 9 місяців тому

    Great review. I’m curious, can you make a review for cast in place concrete

  • @daotorres26
    @daotorres26 11 місяців тому

    Another very informative content from you Sir... Thanks!

  • @musicchannelsmoothgroove7098
    @musicchannelsmoothgroove7098 10 місяців тому

    Are you able to use stainless steel to build a warehouse?

  • @ryannolarte1788
    @ryannolarte1788 11 місяців тому +1

    question po sir slater, bakit po sa america di more on steel at cement ang gingamit nla for their houses, halos mga kahoy at halos walang biga ang ginagawa nla? dahil din po ba sa weather na meron sila (no typhoon) and dahil madalang din ang earthquake?

    • @nadine2962
      @nadine2962 6 місяців тому

      Matindi din typhoon at earthquake Doon SA us may hurricane pa nga😂..

  • @MikiNoodles1984
    @MikiNoodles1984 13 днів тому

    question sir! would it be safe to combine concrete structural members with steel frame? ok lang ba yung steel beam attached to a concrete column? Or can you please point me to a reference sir kunsakali na meron? 😄thank you very much!!

  • @ashdabs2928
    @ashdabs2928 8 місяців тому

    Would you recommend a Steel Construction Contractor in Puerto Princesa, Palawan?

  • @josephcoloso2847
    @josephcoloso2847 11 місяців тому +1

    How about building a house...one story or a 2 story house. . is steel better?

  • @robbingabrielsen6515
    @robbingabrielsen6515 11 місяців тому +1

    I'm interested particularly on the expenses side. Pangabang for second floor mabigat din Kc buhos

    • @kevintin1992
      @kevintin1992 11 місяців тому +1

      Steel structure used for High rise buildings , will be more expensive than RC structure, but for non-high rise buildings( warehouses, supermarkets mall) steel structure is save

  • @jetfu400
    @jetfu400 11 місяців тому

    This is the information i needed! Thanks

  • @joysie.dee26
    @joysie.dee26 11 місяців тому +1

    Lezgoo engrs! ❤

  • @amadorbautistajr591
    @amadorbautistajr591 7 місяців тому

    Sir slater yang steel bar po pedeng buhusan pa po ba ng semento po?

  • @50whatnomadtravelnursemtb5
    @50whatnomadtravelnursemtb5 11 місяців тому +1

    For sure concrete is cheaper and stronger WITH steel rebar reinforced..BUT steel has been used for way longer…the first skyscrapers were all steel(Empire state building), big bridges like the Golden Gate Bridge. I like the looks of both especially when they are exposed.

  • @wilkayecayabyab6672
    @wilkayecayabyab6672 11 місяців тому +1

    Steel column na cinover up ng reinforced concrete? Hindi ba nadoble ba yung cost no'n?

  • @jamesmidas6021
    @jamesmidas6021 11 місяців тому +1

    Babe wake up, slater uploaded a vid!!

  • @HelmarcMula
    @HelmarcMula 11 місяців тому +1

    Slater always said he is more on details and always base on standard.. so if you are not slater you can build in concrete a year but if you are slater it takes that years, where you will see the quality, concrete had time frame to make it stable, where steel is just a ligo...less in building structure more on time in details for archi works

  • @lloydocio998
    @lloydocio998 11 місяців тому

    Hello sir slater. Pls. Make part 2 about bakal. Thank you.

  • @janjasperjugarapdevera
    @janjasperjugarapdevera 11 місяців тому +2

    Sir slater, ask lang po if contractor na po bahala pumili ng supplier for the materials or mas mabuti po bang ang client ang pipili ng supplier for the contractors to work with.

  • @erlinavicente7411
    @erlinavicente7411 10 місяців тому

    Ty, very well put together video.

  • @MaidoEsguerra-DelaCruz
    @MaidoEsguerra-DelaCruz 11 місяців тому

    Great video! 😀

  • @jhomepatricksalazar
    @jhomepatricksalazar 11 місяців тому

    Hi engineer, do you have experiences on building structures for a substation?

  • @aydapadistudio
    @aydapadistudio 11 місяців тому +1

    Off-topic, but: Did you change your mic? 😅 Cos the sound here is 🤌🏼

  • @Cakebrix
    @Cakebrix 11 місяців тому +1

    Noticed that the video pacing/editing slightly changed. Kinda miss your old editing style. Still good and informative video btw 😁

  • @lesssteg
    @lesssteg 11 місяців тому

    Love this!!! 👏🏻

  • @ArkEmerD
    @ArkEmerD 11 місяців тому

    Nice video Engr. Concrete vs Steel. Thanks

  • @maalat
    @maalat 4 місяці тому

    The Philippines has iron, from pig iron to totally transformed steel. Once the Philippines have local steel making factory, Baka magiging mura.

  • @unknowned1113
    @unknowned1113 9 місяців тому

    Ano pong tamang Column size for 2 Storey building?

  • @scatto365
    @scatto365 Місяць тому +2

    Please consider 100% English comments. You're limiting your audience adding 40% Tagalog