Dhruv Ji..We as an Islander from Andamans believe that they are most vulnerable group to the external world and Society. It is better to leave them as it is, unless they want to communicate. I feel that The bad habits of civilized people will definitely spoil their culture & Habits too. So make it a better place for the tribes and let them leave a peaceful life with the nature as they want it to be.
This rarely happens that a video above 20 minutes is unskippped, but i never knew Sentinel topic would be so interesting.. Damn how these 23 minutes got over. Deep research n Audience binding video. Well Done
I work in Andaman tourism (Port Blair) People from my neighbourhood have tried to travel to this island a few times with no success. Trust me the Indian Coast Guard ICG is doing a phenomenal job in keeping our borders safe n the nicobarese tribes isolated. There are always some rotten apples who manage to breach the security layer not thinking of the outcome or consequences
keisa hoga aagar in logo ko drone dwara ek bada tablet ko land karke dikhaya jae ki ye duniya kitna bada he and unke alawa iss duniya me kitne sare log he and chitra bichitra books ko unke area me baris Kiya jaye taki wo dekh sake iss duniya ko and kuchh jine ka naya idea paa jaye and hamare sath communicate bhi karle😊
Can't believe still some Isolated Island exist and out of curiosity went to check google Maps for the ship, and I was shocked to see it 😮. Thank you for educating us!!!
Ye island india ka koi kam ka nehi,ise humare pass sell kar do🇧🇩 kiyuki ye territory wese bhi india bhoj hain hain, sirf kehne pe hi india ka hain lekin koi control nehi hain india ka..indian citizens to ja bhi nehi sakti waha par...isliye better hain ki ise Bangladesh ke pass acche kimat par bech do bangladesh is island ki saari mystery find out karegi or is land ki logo ko modern bana neka kam karegi
Ye island india ka koi kam ka nehi,ise humare pass sell kar do🇧🇩 kiyuki ye territory wese bhi india bhoj hain hain, sirf kehne pe hi india ka hain lekin koi control nehi hain india ka..indian citizens to ja bhi nehi sakti waha par...isliye better hain ki ise Bangladesh ke pass acche kimat par bech do bangladesh is island ki saari mystery find out karegi or is land ki logo ko modern bana neka kam karegi
I am from Andaman And lots of love because You featured ANDAMAN and also explained details very well ☺️ . Some people are thinking ANDAMAN is a place where only JARWA lives😔 THANK YOU AND LOT'S OF LOVE ❤️❤️❤️ from Andaman
I'm from Andaman and Nicobar islands. Thank Dhruv Rathee for this Wonderful video. As you said about the jarawa tribes absolutely right they addicted towards alcohol, pan masala, cigarettes (bidi) etc and they changed there lifestyle they lost their traditions and lifestyle. We should avoid the contact with the Sentinelese until they don't have any problem or they want to contacts us. Thank you Dhruv ❤
We can send that BJP Pig Praful Khoda Patel to Sentinel Island. He will open some Wine Shops and Hotels there. That's how this Stupid Praful Khoda is trying to destroy the Lakshadweep Island as its Administrator.
Hello Dhruv Rathee Sir! I'm Devayan from Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Port Blair. I would like to thanks for recognising and making a nice and wonderful video on these Islands. I would also like to invite you to these Islands to see the pristine ecosystem, emerald beaches, and eco friendly smart Port Blair City with well connected internet facility to many important Islands, and many more.
Being a Sailor myself, whenever I have travelled to Port Blair, we always have to cross N. Sentinal island..... have always wondered how peaceful are they and am struggling to get on with life.... Hopefully NOBODY disturb their ways of living
Thank you for making video on us, i glad that now indian people know about our tribe, and please we are not interested to contacted by outside world please don't contact us.
I think I will also go with the second option because I feel that it is good that atleast in some part of the world human species are not trying to overpower, instead trying to live harmonically with nature. It is good to have some prehistoric culture in the world
Being one of the Islander of Andaman, we are very proud that they still preserve their culture and live happily there. We too are curious about them because that Island is completely untouched and prohibited.
@@helper5846 nope sir.. they are untouched.... Even the administration never entered there... The other 5 tribes living in Andaman & Nicobar are known to us: Jarwa, Ongee, Shompen, Great Andamanese and Nicobaries.
@@helper5846 only the sentenalese still live apart and untouched. They are fine user of bow nd arrow and live naked without any vegetation or rearing as per my knowledge. They are completely depended on hunting and gathering as said by Dhruv Sir like that of Paleolithic Stone Age.
It is highly possible that someone in the past successful made contact with these people and it had a very bad impact on the tribe like disease that they weren't immune to. Taking that as a base, the tribes would consider anything outside their community as a threat to their life. And about the expedition which was successful, that might also have yielded the same result as in it might have become the reason for several deaths within their community concreting their belief even more. Maybe that's the reason they become so aggressive seeing the outside world as it becomes the question of their survival. We should let them live their life peacefully as they have developed a sustainable lifestyle with the available resources.. Modernisation would only put them into more risk.
We can try again while maintaining proper sterilization, so they know that we are not their enemy. This could be helpful for both, we could learn so much thing from them and they too.
I also prefer the second option for the same reasons that you've mentioned and also because we can study or monitor them from afar to get an idea about how humans have evolved in the past to this current stage
Thank u so much dhruv sir !!! I am from Andaman Islands!!! Love to see that, someone is really intrested in our islands ... Because, the main stream media are boycotting our islands every time. We are also , the part of the same country. Love and best wishes for the entire team of DHRUV RATHEE from these Islands
I think the govt was right keeping them isolated. Let's preserve them and let them be on their own. They are living a sustainable life, contact with the modern world will only make things worse for them. But I think we should definitely keep a track on them using high flying drones so that they don't get shot down by an arrow or makes its presence noticeable.
Dhruv sir your videos have always been informative. Please make a video on the flood situation in Assam. As many as 54,57,601 people, including 11,67, 219 children, from 4,941 villages have been affected. A total of 845 relief camps and 1,026 relief distribution centres have been opened in the affected areas. A total of 2,71,125 people are staying in the relief camps while over 99,026 hectares of crops have been damaged.
This is brilliant research. After the 2018 incident in news, I was also fascinated and did some research on internet but was nowhere close. Hats off. Very good content 👍
Seriously my friend, I loved your content! Hats off to you and your team for research work, editing, and other skill sets! Loved this video. 👌🏼 Keep growing :)
I really like it when you make videos on indigenous people of the world 👌🏼i hope you soon make some videos on indian tribes and problems they’re facing right now ( i want you to show others what are the true reasons of naxalvad and their land rights and all that)
They are better off if left alone. Look at the indegenous people in the mainland, for examo,e adivasis of jharkhand, their population has decreased thie eco system / habitat diaturbed., in the name of development they get marginalised displaced
Well articulated story telling. I would agree to let them live their own life - “eyes on and hands off” is a great strategy. A silent drone view can be kept as a schedule monitoring - just to see if they are doing ok. We did enough urbanisation and let some piece of land keep as it is, as we can learn from that too how to go along with Mother Nature. Would be a classic subject of study from global warming’s perspective. I think there is lot to learn, no need to teach … since it’s an Indian territory so it’s our responsibility too to keep them safe from outsiders. Coast guard and Navy should be more effective so that no journalist or travel blogger don’t sneak into this space for their story…
We can send that BJP Pig Praful Khoda Patel to Sentinel Island. He will open some Wine Shops and Hotels there. That's how this Stupid Praful Khoda is trying to destroy the Lakshadweep Island as its Administrator.
I am still wondering how they are surviving based on such small territory. Do they live in a society, is there a group leader, how they handle any dispute among themselves??
12:07 If you go on google maps you can still see this exact same ships remains around the coast. It gave me chills first time i saw it. You can technically say, they have access to iron or they have discovered iron now.
I have been to Andaman and travelled through the Jarva territory. Seeing them is a great reminder of our ancestry. How much humans have evolved since the past 30000 years because our ancestors chose to live together in diversity and had so much technological advancement to make our brains grow from a stone age mindset. I also pity them being stranded there, sort of being arrested, even if they want to, they cannot move out because it will be dangerous for them. I feel we should leave them the way they choose to live now, their ship of evolution has sailed, with time. We are very far apart. They serve as the reminder of what we were. The place they live is like a museum to us, reminding us that if we don’t live with diversity, accepting people of different faiths and nationalities to co-exist, stop exploring, we’ll stay un-evolved and eventually die out, bringing an end to the human story.
Wow. I am in Andaman from 20 days and was so interested to know more about North Sentinel Island and you just uploaded everything for this. Loved every min of this video. Thank you so amazing research you have done.
I am surprised Dhruv Rathi, you didn't talk about Bakhtawar Singh.Jarawas He started efforts and succeeded to win over Jarawas, who used to be very hostile towards inlanders, in 1974. He was the only man who could communicate with them...
It's good to hear our ancestors are still alive in this generation. It would be good not to make changes in there island or habitat. They are surviving without any technology, only depends on nature. This is the power of NATURE
Interesting to know about such tribe's but we being advanced and they being still behind kinda hurts and looks injustice to them. As of now 2022, Mother earth@ has left with last 100 years of evolutions. Once this gets over those tribes and us will be no more. So before this happens and history repeats itself, let's just all introduce them with the rest of the world.
I am from Andaman Islands...and by far this is the best informative video about the north sentinelese I had ever seen on UA-cam....loved your work sir and kudos to the team ❤️
I am assuming they must be having some kind of tribe's head system like we have our leaders. The time when they were able to have a friendly connection is maybe that time the head of the tribe was welcoming.
One of the best youtubers around! Not only do I gain valuable, well researched information but I also get to learn some important Hindi words that I would not have come across any other way. "Dhanush" for example. Had no idea that's what a bow is called in Hindi!
If you ever try to read the Hindi translated version of our ancient scriptures like Vedas,Ramayana and Mahabharata,you will know more Hindi words than any youtuber could tell you in your lifetime
@@waahidahmed8467 The place is so close to nature and people are hospitable. Its overall a fun place. I visited around 5 different islands via a ferry ⛴️ ✨️
If some one is dying to communicate and help, go to any , any village of India, the people there will surely communicate with you and be too happy to take your gifts.
Wow... This was soo much informative. Had no clue about the reason and why this island is isolated and that too its in India. Thank You for spreading such precious knowledge. Would love to see if you make videos on other such mysterious places in India. Thank you once again.
I loved their sustainability thing and belive we should learn from them on how they manage to live on this island so peacefully without a need to explore other island
I didn't knew they exist 👀 Thanks dhruv for such a valuable information ❤️ I don't think we should interfere with them if they really wanted to contact outside world they could have visited and explored the close islands but they didn't we should just leave me alone and who knows whole world will die one day only they will survive coz they are so much rooted into nature and sustainable development 🙌 I hope our plastic waste doesn't reach to them 💀
Plastic is everywhere my guy, even at the deepest end of Mariana Trench and it is to be believed that every human has micro plastics in their blood Today. I think they must have been introduced to atleast a plastic bag or a can, it is Dangerous tho.
@@SachinNayak-v6kto sheher ke log konsa jaanwaron se kam ki zindagi jee rahe hain ...yaha ton pare likhe jaanwar rehte hain ...rape murder chori sab hota hai is educated duniya me teri
No, we should not contact them for the reasons u mention in the video. About Madhumala, u mentioned half story. It was beyond coconut. She took their kids in her hand. Even when she told one of the woman that she has also such kids, that sentinelse woman immediately recognized Madhumita is vergin by keeping her hands on Madhumita's waistline and stomache.
You are giving all of us such great information by making a insight video, about which most people do not even know. You are the real GK of today's world.
Woh log sache hai.. unhe hamari polluted life se dur rakhe tho achcha hai. unke pass koi Na jaaye vahi achcha hai. hamare Jo bimariyan hi unse dur rakhen... Kuchh bhi Ho jaaye aapane bahut acchi subject chunkar duniya Ko iss stane age manav ka Parichay Kiya hai ...thankyou Dhruv Rathi
So much to learn from these tribes. How to be in a symbiotic relationship with nature. How to be self content. How to be minimalistic. How to live in a community. How to protect your clan. We unfortunately have lost this Primal and Powerful way of living.. Thank you Dhruv .
@@roflkohli2853 They're uneducated and uncivilized, but they're surviving sustainably. They haven't cut down massive chunks of forests and leave plenty of animals and trees for their sustenance.
@@TomiusMeme What have we doneby becoming Developed? Making others life terrible by doing politics. Crimes like hell in all society. Dividing each other by religion. Actually trying to be developed we became inhuman. It's a fact but we don't admit it.....
* Coconut is not found on North Sentinel Island, that's why they were friendly. * Britishers who went into these Island found that, they have a leader with extra ornaments on his body, He used to gather people and speech from a height stone. These points I found in some videos, these may be true or not.
They should be left alone and isolated. Let them live peacefully in their own way. Dhruv you are an amazing orator with very good voice and excellent ability to explain complex things in a very simple way. Please keep doing this. Thanks for this video.
In my opinion : its always better to leave them alone rather making them vulnerable to our environment. Also The research for this video really subtle no doubt great team work appreciate 👏🏽 it's like visual representation of what I read about them
I totally agree that we should leave them isolated forever. They're like pure and natural in their own way and if they come in contact with toxic people like us then they're definitely not going to survive for long or might kill each other in the name of religion or materialistic things. Live and let live...
Very informative and mysterious content. I really like such contents , thanks a ton to make these videos. I guess we should respect their decision, if they don't want to contact with the outside world then let them be as they want to be, atleast they're living an healthy lifestyle with incredible sustainability, thankfully escaped from harmful food, toxic social media, social, religious and political riots, heinous crimes and horrible criminals and all the problems that modern world suffering from.
Watching this video, staying at port Blair and my working site is just 40 km away from this location. We talk so much about this topic and these people's. Really a great explanation in this video.
I am from Andaman, make more vedios on Andaman and Nicobar islands -- The historic event of hoisting the national flag in Port Blair in 1943 marked a watershed in the history of the freedom struggle, declaring the Andamans to be the first island to be liberated from the British hold. But ajj v q Andaman mainland k compre me bohot piche hai....ho kya raha hai yeha....i will be waiting for ur vedio....
As an anthropologist myself ,I would definitely choose to leave them alone with control monitoring and allowed trained experts to visit in timely manner for updates information.
Sir ek question tha. Video mein food culture sab batalaya hain. Iss island par water ka source kya hain iske bare mein kuch nahi bataya. Pine ke pani ka kya karte honge. Coconut water only ..??????
Which other similar topics would you like to see videos on?
History of canada
And the rise of british
Md. Hamid Ansari ki gaddari pe bhi video bnao na....Mr. sold dhruv Rathee
Any interesting phase in Indian history with some mysteries ( your explanation is on another level ) you should be a History professor 🤗 .
About top mysteries that has been unsolved
Dhruv Ji..We as an Islander from Andamans believe that they are most vulnerable group to the external world and Society. It is better to leave them as it is, unless they want to communicate. I feel that The bad habits of civilized people will definitely spoil their culture & Habits too. So make it a better place for the tribes and let them leave a peaceful life with the nature as they want it to be.
Modi nahi chodhega lakshadweep andaman ko re baba 👴
Agreed 👍
Agreed and fun fact is that....i think u r the first one to get a heart from Dhruv jii🤭
And are these tribals pure hearted? Don’t they have any bad habits. It irritates me when people just glorify murderers.
@@caelum2185 lmao. they are not murderers. They are just trying trying to protect themselves from 'modern' people.
This rarely happens that a video above 20 minutes is unskippped, but i never knew Sentinel topic would be so interesting.. Damn how these 23 minutes got over. Deep research n Audience binding video. Well Done
Exactly
Binod
R
Binod
L
So true brother
I am from Andaman Island
It’s so interesting to think that a place like this , isolated in time still exist in today’s world 😳
Maine Ishki Book Pahle he Pad li hai KUku fm par.. yeh dhruv Vanhi se gyan Lekar yanha chep raha hai..
@@jayendrasinghkirar7214 book name
@@jayendrasinghkirar7214 I Love KUKU FM.
RUMBLING INCOMING
@@jayendrasinghkirar7214 books se hi aata h sab information aur kaha se ayega
They are the happiest in world. No greed, no war, no famine, just living together.
nope such places have their own tradiations like sacrifices n other rituals. fight for women n stuff like that.
True
Still can't escape biology and nature
@@KintaxXx12 🤡🤡
Who knows there might be wars among themselves
I am from Andaman and I completely agree with your opinion about respecting their boundaries and letting them live their unique lifestyle.
Ohhu u r so lucky
It's called a great content, such people need us a lot.
I really want to visit Andaman.
I love that place.
There is no Electricity there
@@vishakhathakur5154
J
This is called quality content.
We need more people like you to spread more knowledge among people
Bimod
I
Binod
I
@@BinodTharu-Official vele
It's called a great content, such people need us a lot.
Kyun ye achhe se nai kr rha kya?
I work in Andaman tourism (Port Blair) People from my neighbourhood have tried to travel to this island a few times with no success. Trust me the Indian Coast Guard ICG is doing a phenomenal job in keeping our borders safe n the nicobarese tribes isolated. There are always some rotten apples who manage to breach the security layer not thinking of the outcome or consequences
keisa hoga aagar in logo ko drone dwara ek bada tablet ko land karke dikhaya jae ki ye duniya kitna bada he and unke alawa iss duniya me kitne sare log he and chitra bichitra books ko unke area me baris Kiya jaye taki wo dekh sake iss duniya ko and kuchh jine ka naya idea paa jaye and hamare sath communicate bhi karle😊
@@ldsrealnature6538 intresting
@@ldsrealnature6538 they'll surely shoot the Drone nd Tablet with arrow nd bury it in beaches 😂
@@AmanKhan-fx6gk 🤣🤭😆😁
Vayam rakhsham!
We protect(ICG)
COAST GUARD is Lil bit underrated but people should start praising it!
Thanks for appreciation
Can't believe still some Isolated Island exist and out of curiosity went to check google Maps for the ship, and I was shocked to see it 😮. Thank you for educating us!!!
I did same😮 checked on Google map and found the ship this is mind blowing 😳
Kya search kra bro
Ye island india ka koi kam ka nehi,ise humare pass sell kar do🇧🇩 kiyuki ye territory wese bhi india bhoj hain hain, sirf kehne pe hi india ka hain lekin koi control nehi hain india ka..indian citizens to ja bhi nehi sakti waha par...isliye better hain ki ise Bangladesh ke pass acche kimat par bech do bangladesh is island ki saari mystery find out karegi or is land ki logo ko modern bana neka kam karegi
They live in a whole different world of their own. Their own history, stories, language, way of life, routines, traditions...
In the same way christianity is spreaded by destroying local traditions
Binod
F
Binod
P
Binod
T
And should be left as such
Amazing documentary... being an Indian I never knew about Sentinelese tribe and thanks to you i got so much info.. Dhruv bhai you are knowledge king..
Shame
@@sr3yu same to you
Google king
This documentary it's just a Hindi translation of that documentry which was uploaded by "Be Amazed" 3 year ago
bhai omkar with your comments andh bhakths got burn their ass.
Nice Video.Let North Sentinels live their own way of life.Modern world Should not disturb them
Ye island india ka koi kam ka nehi,ise humare pass sell kar do🇧🇩 kiyuki ye territory wese bhi india bhoj hain hain, sirf kehne pe hi india ka hain lekin koi control nehi hain india ka..indian citizens to ja bhi nehi sakti waha par...isliye better hain ki ise Bangladesh ke pass acche kimat par bech do bangladesh is island ki saari mystery find out karegi or is land ki logo ko modern bana neka kam karegi
I am from Andaman
And lots of love because
You featured ANDAMAN and also explained details very well ☺️ .
Some people are thinking ANDAMAN is a place where only JARWA lives😔
THANK YOU AND LOT'S OF LOVE ❤️❤️❤️ from Andaman
Love u Bhai up se ♥️♥️
I also spent 2 years in Nicobar ..Really a Amazing memories....
don't you feel isolated ?
Bhai andaman ma kaha se
Hi from Andaman Islands bhai!
I'm from Andaman and Nicobar islands. Thank Dhruv Rathee for this Wonderful video. As you said about the jarawa tribes absolutely right they addicted towards alcohol, pan masala, cigarettes (bidi) etc and they changed there lifestyle they lost their traditions and lifestyle. We should avoid the contact with the Sentinelese until they don't have any problem or they want to contacts us. Thank you Dhruv ❤
Hey What work you do there in Andaman? I have a business idea!
We can send that BJP Pig Praful Khoda Patel to Sentinel Island. He will open some Wine Shops and Hotels there. That's how this Stupid Praful Khoda is trying to destroy the Lakshadweep Island as its Administrator.
Where do you live 😅
@@darkrio2856 Karnataka Are you interested??? No spam nothing genuine buisness
@@cenationrko4445 hey.. what is it . Im from Andamans too
Hello Dhruv Rathee Sir! I'm Devayan from Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Port Blair. I would like to thanks for recognising and making a nice and wonderful video on these Islands. I would also like to invite you to these Islands to see the pristine ecosystem, emerald beaches, and eco friendly smart Port Blair City with well connected internet facility to many important Islands, and many more.
Hello devayan
Are there any local myths or stories about these people
@@mediflash612 haven't you learned history in the past.😒
@@mediflash612 zeenews he dekhte raho tm.
@@mediflash612 bokachoda netaji bose nahi hai Subhash Chandra Bose hai.
May the god bless you
यही लोग का जिंदगी है, ना पैसा का टेंशन😢
😂
@@SalinaG.R251 😊
To chala ja
@@AsifAnsari-vr4vw😂😂
@@SalinaG.R251 badya zindagi jina ho to laalach chhodna hoga 😢
Being a Sailor myself, whenever I have travelled to Port Blair, we always have to cross N. Sentinal island..... have always wondered how peaceful are they and am struggling to get on with life.... Hopefully NOBODY disturb their ways of living
OHH YOU ATRE A SAILOr
😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
Such a brilliant video, with in-depth research from history to present to discussing solutions and consequences. Hatsoff
Mohak ka naam suna hai? 1 saal pehle bana chuka wo video ispe.
Thank you for making video on us, i glad that now indian people know about our tribe, and please we are not interested to contacted by outside world please don't contact us.
@@anorthsentineli8192 🤣🤣🤣🤣 So now North centinal people have phone 🤣🤣🤣
@@Paaaaaaaaaaal haa par kuch bhi dhruv ka video dekhne me maja aata hai ,,editing mast
@@PuneMicroVlogs and who says we cannot communicate with them. See he can speak English 😅
I think I will also go with the second option because I feel that it is good that atleast in some part of the world human species are not trying to overpower, instead trying to live harmonically with nature. It is good to have some prehistoric culture in the world
I agree with second option
Sentinels should be leaved in isolated situation if they want to leave alone very knowledgeable video Dhruv Bhai
Being one of the Islander of Andaman, we are very proud that they still preserve their culture and live happily there. We too are curious about them because that Island is completely untouched and prohibited.
Do you have any folk lore or any story of these north sentinel tribe ?
@@helper5846 nope sir.. they are untouched.... Even the administration never entered there...
The other 5 tribes living in Andaman & Nicobar are known to us: Jarwa, Ongee, Shompen, Great Andamanese and Nicobaries.
@@helper5846 only the sentenalese still live apart and untouched. They are fine user of bow nd arrow and live naked without any vegetation or rearing as per my knowledge. They are completely depended on hunting and gathering as said by Dhruv Sir like that of Paleolithic Stone Age.
How do you get Interenet connection there???
@@technophileguy1639 visit andaman u ll love it...
It is highly possible that someone in the past successful made contact with these people and it had a very bad impact on the tribe like disease that they weren't immune to. Taking that as a base, the tribes would consider anything outside their community as a threat to their life. And about the expedition which was successful, that might also have yielded the same result as in it might have become the reason for several deaths within their community concreting their belief even more.
Maybe that's the reason they become so aggressive seeing the outside world as it becomes the question of their survival.
We should let them live their life peacefully as they have developed a sustainable lifestyle with the available resources.. Modernisation would only put them into more risk.
Same thought. The sudden change in their attitude during the 90s makes this theory quite believable.
@@Economics-i6g this is illogical comment.
Search European colonisation in Andaman and Nicobar
We can try again while maintaining proper sterilization, so they know that we are not their enemy. This could be helpful for both, we could learn so much thing from them and they too.
@@Economics-i6g you are free to go and try
I also prefer the second option for the same reasons that you've mentioned and also because we can study or monitor them from afar to get an idea about how humans have evolved in the past to this current stage
Right
We already have enough research on that topic.
Right
Good idea
THere might be a kid who is curious about outer world . and he will one day sail to explore the outer world .
He is the one who is educating Indians and not spoiling them like other influencers.
Hats off to u Dhruv sir.
❤😊
We need people like brother Rathee❤
ok
not only Indians but everyone who understands Hindi. Like me, a Pakistani.
Yes
Ÿou are ryt but some blind bhakts are so brainless
Thank u so much dhruv sir !!! I am from Andaman Islands!!! Love to see that, someone is really intrested in our islands ... Because, the main stream media are boycotting our islands every time. We are also , the part of the same country.
Love and best wishes for the entire team of DHRUV RATHEE from these Islands
Very informative, I did research on Sentinel Island for around 3 years ago and you have covered each and every aspect of this
I am from Andaman & Nicobar Islands and you have explained very well about the tribes 👍
Bro you are always right.
Your opinion is suitable for our new generation.😊
I think the govt was right keeping them isolated. Let's preserve them and let them be on their own. They are living a sustainable life, contact with the modern world will only make things worse for them. But I think we should definitely keep a track on them using high flying drones so that they don't get shot down by an arrow or makes its presence noticeable.
Yes, hand off, eyes on is the best approach. Advanced drones which are far from ground are the best way to keep an eye on them
@Jai Hind lol lol lol 😆
Government usko preserve hi kr rhi hai....
Nahi to 2 min me ....
@@jemuel6222 go to Europe then
@@dv9239 yes next year
Dhruv sir your videos have always been informative. Please make a video on the flood situation in Assam.
As many as 54,57,601 people, including 11,67, 219 children, from 4,941 villages have been affected. A total of 845 relief camps and 1,026 relief distribution centres have been opened in the affected areas. A total of 2,71,125 people are staying in the relief camps while over 99,026 hectares of crops have been damaged.
he alredy has a video on assam 's flood , he made it in 2021, go and check out
I am an Andamani myself. I feel some people should be best left alone to preserve their culture and we should respect their sentiments
U r tribe??
@@Priyanka-rawat.154 Not a tribe but a settler
@@lishajoseph1007 I want to travel andmans kabhi aunga
They are very innocent & should be left alone.They even survived after the deadly 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami...
Thumbs up to them
This is brilliant research. After the 2018 incident in news, I was also fascinated and did some research on internet but was nowhere close. Hats off. Very good content 👍
It's called a great content, such people need us a lot.
English documentary ko Hindi mein bol diya. Koi reasearch nai kari hai
@@mahi.6919 konsi english documentary?
Seriously my friend, I loved your content!
Hats off to you and your team for research work, editing, and other skill sets! Loved this video. 👌🏼
Keep growing :)
True that 🙌🏼
Really, even I loved the video ❤️
True bro..
I'm from Andaman and Nicobar Islands.....I'm ur big fan sir....I watched all your videos....thank you for giving us knowledgeable videos...
😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
hehehehhe
Haha
hohoho
hihihi
Amazing and goosebumps giving information.. my first video which I didn't skipped and watched completely without forwarding or skipping ...😮
I was Today years old when I get to know about this!!
Dhruv Really brings unique content in most researched way!!👏👏
Love your profile pic
I really like it when you make videos on indigenous people of the world 👌🏼i hope you soon make some videos on indian tribes and problems they’re facing right now ( i want you to show others what are the true reasons of naxalvad and their land rights and all that)
Binod
I
It's called a great content, such people need us a lot.
Yes ❤️
Yes tribes of India who came from Africa ;)
They are better off if left alone. Look at the indegenous people in the mainland, for examo,e adivasis of jharkhand, their population has decreased thie eco system / habitat diaturbed., in the name of development they get marginalised displaced
Well articulated story telling. I would agree to let them live their own life - “eyes on and hands off” is a great strategy. A silent drone view can be kept as a schedule monitoring - just to see if they are doing ok. We did enough urbanisation and let some piece of land keep as it is, as we can learn from that too how to go along with Mother Nature. Would be a classic subject of study from global warming’s perspective. I think there is lot to learn, no need to teach … since it’s an Indian territory so it’s our responsibility too to keep them safe from outsiders. Coast guard and Navy should be more effective so that no journalist or travel blogger don’t sneak into this space for their story…
We can send that BJP Pig Praful Khoda Patel to Sentinel Island. He will open some Wine Shops and Hotels there. That's how this Stupid Praful Khoda is trying to destroy the Lakshadweep Island as its Administrator.
Yeah, i agree with you but I think drones might be not possible to keep a check on them!!
💯
Well Written💯......Government should take steps for their Complete Isolation from urban World
I am still wondering how they are surviving based on such small territory. Do they live in a society, is there a group leader, how they handle any dispute among themselves??
12:07
If you go on google maps you can still see this exact same ships remains around the coast.
It gave me chills first time i saw it.
You can technically say, they have access to iron or they have discovered iron now.
15:36 I think, those who were friendly, were killed by the other Sentinels.
Wow.. last few days I have been researching online about this island.. but not got much details.. Here is Dhruv trying to save my time🥰
Check out soch my mohak mangal for the video on same topic
just type north sentinnel island, dhruv rathee is pretty late in covering this dude.
There is video of soch by mohak nd also a video by Bisbo in Hindi and English Both
🧢
@@yashtalati6678 reallifelore yt channel also made vedio on this
I have been to Andaman and travelled through the Jarva territory. Seeing them is a great reminder of our ancestry. How much humans have evolved since the past 30000 years because our ancestors chose to live together in diversity and had so much technological advancement to make our brains grow from a stone age mindset. I also pity them being stranded there, sort of being arrested, even if they want to, they cannot move out because it will be dangerous for them. I feel we should leave them the way they choose to live now, their ship of evolution has sailed, with time. We are very far apart. They serve as the reminder of what we were. The place they live is like a museum to us, reminding us that if we don’t live with diversity, accepting people of different faiths and nationalities to co-exist, stop exploring, we’ll stay un-evolved and eventually die out, bringing an end to the human story.
Maine Ishki Book Pahle he Pad li hai KUku fm par.. yeh dhruv Vanhi se gyan Lekar yanha chep raha hai..
@@jayendrasinghkirar7214 Gyan toh Gyan hai… kahin se bhi mile knowledge hee badhata hai.
Agree
Ye afriki hapsi hai.
Thats a great thought 🙌
I agree with you. If they're happy, let them live as they want. Your arguments are true & right. I'm your great fan.
❤ Love from Pakistan.
Wow. I am in Andaman from 20 days and was so interested to know more about North Sentinel Island and you just uploaded everything for this. Loved every min of this video. Thank you so amazing research you have done.
North Sentinel Island jaake dekh Bhai..aur interesting lagega👍
I think we should not disturb them and let them live peacefully ! Dhruv your videos are getting more interesting covering variety topics i love it !
Exactly
I also think that they should not be brought to the outside world
They're happy living peacefully,
Let them do so
I am surprised Dhruv Rathi, you didn't talk about Bakhtawar Singh.Jarawas He started efforts and succeeded to win over Jarawas, who used to be very hostile towards inlanders, in 1974. He was the only man who could communicate with them...
We could never take for granted the hard work you do. We see it, and we appreciate you.
Binod
K
Binod
I
Ek deshdhrohi dusre deshdhrohi ko hi na janega
@@Mbbs.lover.14267 Ek baat btao, is video me aur is comment me aisa kya deshdrohi hai?
It's called a great content, such people need us a lot.
It's good to hear our ancestors are still alive in this generation. It would be good not to make changes in there island or habitat. They are surviving without any technology, only depends on nature. This is the power of NATURE
They r not ohr ancestors bro....
India is very diverse with huge diversity in race
Not our ancestors bruuuh 😂
😂😂😂😂
Interesting to know about such tribe's but we
being advanced and they being still behind
kinda hurts and looks injustice to them. As of
now 2022, Mother earth@ has left with last
100 years of evolutions. Once this gets over
those tribes and us will be no more. So before
this happens and history repeats itself, let's
just all introduce them with the rest of the
world.
These are not our ancestors. They are Africans as shown in the start of the video
I am from Andaman Islands...and by far this is the best informative video about the north sentinelese I had ever seen on UA-cam....loved your work sir and kudos to the team ❤️
R u human 😜
I am assuming they must be having some kind of tribe's head system like we have our leaders. The time when they were able to have a friendly connection is maybe that time the head of the tribe was welcoming.
One of the best youtubers around! Not only do I gain valuable, well researched information but I also get to learn some important Hindi words that I would not have come across any other way. "Dhanush" for example. Had no idea that's what a bow is called in Hindi!
You should explore more. Soch by Mohak does better research. Good place to start
@@pranavkanttripathi2971 Thanks man! Pretty sure Dhruv has credited him a few times in his videos so yes, I will check him out. :)
If you ever try to read the Hindi translated version of our ancient scriptures like Vedas,Ramayana and Mahabharata,you will know more Hindi words than any youtuber could tell you in your lifetime
I recently visited Andaman Islands. It was a great experience
Really ? How was it
@@waahidahmed8467 The place is so close to nature and people are hospitable. Its overall a fun place. I visited around 5 different islands via a ferry ⛴️ ✨️
@@nousheennaaz1848 woww, it must be a great experience
If some one is dying to communicate and help, go to any , any village of India, the people there will surely communicate with you and be too happy to take your gifts.
Iam from Andaman this is a real story very good
For them we are like aliens , same as we think about different planets , great works dhruv rathee ❤
yess even i thought same
It's so helpful for the anthropology and sociology optional subject aspirants ...thank u so muchhh Dhruvvvvvvvv bhaiya
U are a UPSC aspirant?
Finally a detailed video on' The North Sentinel island'. You explained the historical and exploring part really well.Truly informative 💯.
Hello vishakha
Hello vishakha😊😊😊
@@SudhanshuKumar-fy4xq hello Sudhanshu
@@SudhanshuKumar-fy4xq koshish jari rakho , koi na koi to pategi 😂
मुझे खुशी हुई है कि सेंटिनल वास किसी धर्म या पाखंड में नहीं फंसे हैं
वह दुनिया की सच्चाई पहले से जानते हैं
Bhai unka dimaag itna viksit hi nhi hua, wo kisi par viswas to kar nhi sakte aur tum andhviswas ki bat karte ho
Wow... This was soo much informative. Had no clue about the reason and why this island is isolated and that too its in India. Thank You for spreading such precious knowledge. Would love to see if you make videos on other such mysterious places in India. Thank you once again.
I loved their sustainability thing and belive we should learn from them on how they manage to live on this island so peacefully without a need to explore other island
I didn't knew they exist 👀
Thanks dhruv for such a valuable information ❤️
I don't think we should interfere with them if they really wanted to contact outside world they could have visited and explored the close islands but they didn't we should just leave me alone and who knows whole world will die one day only they will survive coz they are so much rooted into nature and sustainable development 🙌
I hope our plastic waste doesn't reach to them 💀
Plastic is everywhere my guy, even at the deepest end of Mariana Trench and it is to be believed that every human has micro plastics in their blood Today. I think they must have been introduced to atleast a plastic bag or a can, it is Dangerous tho.
Jaha insan khush raho khushia mile unhe wahi Hal me rehne dena chahie....
12:50 I literally found this boat on Google maps 😮😮😮
Your every video is like a research paper. The amount of effort you put in perfectly reflects in each video. Keep on informing netizens. 😊
अच्छी बात है ये लोग इस मतलबी दुनिया से दूर है ।कोई टेंशन भी है। धोखा प्यार सब से दूर है।
😂
Janwaro jesa zindagi jee rahe hai or tujhe acha lag rha h
kab kataa ??
@@Tradingfield-j2p 😂😂
@@SachinNayak-v6kto sheher ke log konsa jaanwaron se kam ki zindagi jee rahe hain ...yaha ton pare likhe jaanwar rehte hain ...rape murder chori sab hota hai is educated duniya me teri
No, we should not contact them for the reasons u mention in the video. About Madhumala, u mentioned half story. It was beyond coconut. She took their kids in her hand. Even when she told one of the woman that she has also such kids, that sentinelse woman immediately recognized Madhumita is vergin by keeping her hands on Madhumita's waistline and stomache.
You are giving all of us such great information by making a insight video, about which most people do not even know. You are the real GK of today's world.
Very informative!! Salute to your hardwork and research work❤
They must be isolated, not to be disturbed.
Oh modern man!
Let them live in peace.
Thanks Rathee
Exectly 👍
Curiosity.
@@mehra764 dedia behn ka rishta?
Woh log sache hai.. unhe hamari polluted life se dur rakhe tho achcha hai. unke pass koi Na jaaye vahi achcha hai. hamare Jo bimariyan hi unse dur rakhen... Kuchh bhi Ho jaaye aapane bahut acchi subject chunkar duniya Ko iss stane age manav ka Parichay Kiya hai ...thankyou Dhruv Rathi
22:40 I think we should follow "Eyes on hands off' Policy🙏🙏
So much to learn from these tribes. How to be in a symbiotic relationship with nature. How to be self content. How to be minimalistic. How to live in a community. How to protect your clan.
We unfortunately have lost this Primal and Powerful way of living..
Thank you Dhruv .
They eat Rats, pigs, birds & other animals. Not a symbiotic relation in my book
@@roflkohli2853 They're uneducated and uncivilized, but they're surviving sustainably. They haven't cut down massive chunks of forests and leave plenty of animals and trees for their sustenance.
This would be a terrible way to live.
That's definitely not a good way to live. Too underdeveloped.
@@TomiusMeme What have we doneby becoming Developed? Making others life terrible by doing politics. Crimes like hell in all society. Dividing each other by religion. Actually trying to be developed we became inhuman. It's a fact but we don't admit it.....
Almost one week before, I did a deep research on this island.
Amazed to see that you released next video on it.
Same here did one month ago though
What else interesting things did you find apart from the things mentioned in the video?
@@madihakhan1003 he mentioned all the things which are known about this island
* Coconut is not found on North Sentinel Island, that's why they were friendly.
* Britishers who went into these Island found that, they have a leader with extra ornaments on his body, He used to gather people and speech from a height stone.
These points I found in some videos, these may be true or not.
It's called a great content, such people need us a lot.
13:30,ladki ka charkar babu bhaiya 😂
Ye बड़ी अच्छी बात कही आपने 😂
Men will be men😂😂
Aakhir kon hai ye log kaha se aate he 😂
😂😂
Hats off to Dhruv Ji he explain everything in a specific and deep way of details
Being a anthropologist I completely agree with your statement.they must be left isolated to save them from Their cultural exploitation.
An
Is there any scope in India for anthropologist
@@mehra764 sapne tu har koi dekhta ha tatto ko dekh lene dee kabhi nhi hoga ye
Thank you so much Rathee sahab for enlightening us on this interesting aspect of our nation
जो जैसा है वैसे ही रहने दिया जाए , उनको बदलने की कोशिश नही करना चाहिए , जब तक वो खुद बदलना नही चाहते हैं तो ❤❤❤❤❤❤
I was teaching the same thing to my students a, couple of weeks ago but i couldn't find a good video.. Thanks to @Dhruv
This is actually called quality content.
Always comes with fresh topic and fresh ideas .Keep it up brother👍❣️
Maine Ishki Book Pahle he Pad li hai KUku fm par.. yeh dhruv Vanhi se gyan Lekar yanha chep raha hai..
U think this is fresh topic. This happened many years ago and video posted now.
@@jayendrasinghkirar7214 q
@@pickmeup4me abe post kiya kuch pata chala to shant raho na
Nope mohak covered it first
I will visit there one day
They should be left alone and isolated. Let them live peacefully in their own way.
Dhruv you are an amazing orator with very good voice and excellent ability to explain complex things in a very simple way. Please keep doing this.
Thanks for this video.
12:52 i didn't believe him until i saw it on google maps... damn this guy goes in such a detail..🧐🫡
In my opinion : its always better to leave them alone rather making them vulnerable to our environment.
Also The research for this video really subtle no doubt great team work appreciate 👏🏽 it's like visual representation of what I read about them
I totally agree that we should leave them isolated forever. They're like pure and natural in their own way and if they come in contact with toxic people like us then they're definitely not going to survive for long or might kill each other in the name of religion or materialistic things. Live and let live...
they won't kill each other. if we land there. the diseases will kill a lot of them. same thing happened when north america was discovered by coloumbus
💯 agreed
1000% agreed
But i think they need to see the world and it's progress and be part of it as everyone. They are missing out on so much.
Haa fir se religion aa gya beech main
Very informative and mysterious content. I really like such contents , thanks a ton to make these videos.
I guess we should respect their decision, if they don't want to contact with the outside world then let them be as they want to be, atleast they're living an healthy lifestyle with incredible sustainability, thankfully escaped from harmful food, toxic social media, social, religious and political riots, heinous crimes and horrible criminals and all the problems that modern world suffering from.
Watching this video, staying at port Blair and my working site is just 40 km away from this location. We talk so much about this topic and these people's. Really a great explanation in this video.
Kindly see my comments .
1:26- John allen chau : wanna know jesus ?
Sentinelese : wanna see jesus ?
💀
Bro god ko kuch mat do
@@professionalcommentor_405 it's a joke
bruh☠️
Good One
I just realised india covers so much diverse land and ocean regions. Hats off to all the defence personnel
I am from Andaman, make more vedios on Andaman and Nicobar islands -- The historic event of hoisting the national flag in Port Blair in 1943 marked a watershed in the history of the freedom struggle, declaring the Andamans to be the first island to be liberated from the British hold. But ajj v q Andaman mainland k compre me bohot piche hai....ho kya raha hai yeha....i will be waiting for ur vedio....
As an anthropologist myself ,I would definitely choose to leave them alone with control monitoring and allowed trained experts to visit in timely manner for updates information.
Sir ek question tha. Video mein food culture sab batalaya hain. Iss island par water ka source kya hain iske bare mein kuch nahi bataya. Pine ke pani ka kya karte honge. Coconut water only ..??????
@@jparun007 sister, the region witnessed enough rainfall throughout the year so they don have any problem with drinking water .hope u got ur answer.
Hi, how can we become anthropologist in India?
In tamil language, Sen meaning Red and thinal => has meanings like destruction, cutting, biting
Thank you Dhruv sir for this!!!
Andaman is such a beautiful place that you can’t imagine ✨✨
Love from Andaman ❤️❤️❤️
Baht behtreen vedeo tha mza aya kafi informative tha and thank u soo much ese vedeos bnane kliye sir ..
This is very interesting to know this type of people are still exists
After know about them it feels like that I am travelling to ancient history😲
Hello aksnsha
I think yours is the only Channel I don't feel bored while watching...even though it's educational and I end up learning a lot new🙂
Yes same
Dhruv your content is unstoppable love from Pakistan..🇵🇰
Mai ek new youtuber hun kay ap allah ke waste kuchh support karenge
Very knowledgeable video Dhruv Bhai