Ty! Though this content right here is still not my end goal, I am still striving to improve the writing which is quite stale at times and maybe make some backgrounds I can reuse
Interesting video on the Japonic languages! Can you maybe help me on my projects on German history in the near future? You can also maybe help me pronounce some German words too (if I ever do make a video that involves German) :)
While it's slightly more likely for Japanese to be related to Ainu, saying that seems to just be kicking the can down the road, since it too is a language isolate. There are many Japanese rice-related words that seem to be borrowed from Austronesian. OJ/PJ PAN English *kəmai *Semay cooked rice *wasara *baCaR millet *usu *lusuŋ rice mortar *sisi *Sesi meat *ka *ka(n) Food (eat in PAN) *paCu-Ci, *poy *Sapuy Fire *wayi *way Water *pusu *pujek navel *titi *susu Breasts (tutu or cucu in multiple Formosan languages) *pi-tau *tau Person *pata *paCan Pair *si *si 3rd person singular pronoun *kaCu-Ci *kaSiw Tree *tsaka-Ci *sakat climb up, ascend *koma *Cumay Bear (kumay in multiple Formosan languages)
Japanese is a dialect of North Korean Korean China is a rightful part of Korea(Qing were Manchu, Manchu were dominated by Koreans) So you aren't associated with China, China is associated with you
I just remembered I literally did the research for Altaic at 2am at the Düsseldorf Airport while waiting for my flight to Spain And that was in like April
12:02 it is mentioned here a tiny bit however only as part of a wider theory that doesn't even always include Japonic so I might have to do a follow up for just austroasiatic
@@luca_historyalso you miss the tai kradai theory Vovin (2014) says that there is typological evidence that Proto-Japonic may have been a monosyllabic, SVO syntax and isolating language; which are features that the Kra-Dai languages also exhibit. He notes that Benedict's idea of a relation between Japanese and Kra-Dai should not be rejected out of hand Paul K. Benedict (1992) suggests a genetic relation between Japanese and the Austro-Tai languages, which include Kra-Dai and Austronesian. He proposes that Kra-Dai and Japanese form a genetic mainland group while Austronesian is the insular group.
guy did not scream at me and cares about the subject, did not do a betterhelp ad, i don't get it :(
Peak video this is your best video yet but all of your videos are your best video the editing is so top tier ate down
Tysm(deliberately did the editing more shitty than in his other videos to finish it quicker)
You took a few years break but you make good content!
Ty!
Though this content right here is still not my end goal, I am still striving to improve the writing which is quite stale at times and maybe make some backgrounds I can reuse
Interesting video on the Japonic languages! Can you maybe help me on my projects on German history in the near future? You can also maybe help me pronounce some German words too (if I ever do make a video that involves German) :)
My German expertise is more Post Napoleon so very modern history but I can help with the pronunciation
My Discord is lucabazooka1007
@@luca_history Sure! I would love to have you to help :D
@@luca_history I sent a request :)
While it's slightly more likely for Japanese to be related to Ainu, saying that seems to just be kicking the can down the road, since it too is a language isolate. There are many Japanese rice-related words that seem to be borrowed from Austronesian.
OJ/PJ PAN English
*kəmai *Semay cooked rice
*wasara *baCaR millet
*usu *lusuŋ rice mortar
*sisi *Sesi meat
*ka *ka(n) Food (eat in PAN)
*paCu-Ci, *poy *Sapuy Fire
*wayi *way Water
*pusu *pujek navel
*titi *susu Breasts (tutu or cucu in multiple Formosan languages)
*pi-tau *tau Person
*pata *paCan Pair
*si *si 3rd person singular pronoun
*kaCu-Ci *kaSiw Tree
*tsaka-Ci *sakat climb up, ascend
*koma *Cumay Bear (kumay in multiple Formosan languages)
Very good point
Sorry... Are you pronouncing ch and j as [ɬ]? That is super cool and the first time I've heard that!!
Getting a comment on my accent that isn't negative is refreshing ty
The reason why a lot of people in Japan prefer the altaic theory (despite it making no sense) is because we dont like to be associated with China.
Japanese is a dialect of North Korean Korean
China is a rightful part of Korea(Qing were Manchu, Manchu were dominated by Koreans)
So you aren't associated with China, China is associated with you
0:23 WE'RE GONNA WHAT 💀
Rank?
@@luca_history ok I heard "wank" lol
Wait till you hear which verb I used instead of to google
Also not my fault English doesn't know how Rs work 😤
@luca_history yeah, I agree. The old English r sounded much better
Longest video yet
It took so long that between from the first word of my script to uploading it I probably went from Japanese N7 to N6
I just remembered I literally did the research for Altaic at 2am at the Düsseldorf Airport while waiting for my flight to Spain
And that was in like April
Actually it was 1am I think
I think this may be the first time I ever see a Nordrheinwestfahlen ball.
banger
Where is Austroasiatic theory?
It also interesting it supported by dna haplogroup and rice farming agriculture
12:02 it is mentioned here a tiny bit however only as part of a wider theory that doesn't even always include Japonic so I might have to do a follow up for just austroasiatic
@@luca_historyalso you miss the tai kradai theory
Vovin (2014) says that there is typological evidence that Proto-Japonic may have been a monosyllabic, SVO syntax and isolating language; which are features that the Kra-Dai languages also exhibit. He notes that Benedict's idea of a relation between Japanese and Kra-Dai should not be rejected out of hand
Paul K. Benedict (1992) suggests a genetic relation between Japanese and the Austro-Tai languages, which include Kra-Dai and Austronesian. He proposes that Kra-Dai and Japanese form a genetic mainland group while Austronesian is the insular group.
SUMERIAN MENTIONED LETS GOOOOOO 𒆠𒂗𒄀 NUMERO 𒁹
S tier ofc ofc
Sumerian is actually proto world
@@luca_history Real
@@luca_history based