Man Afghanistan was peaceful modern and progressive back then but today totally opposite. May this good old days will reign over Afghanistan again soon !
Belkan Squadron 1. There was no Taliban it was the Mujahideen 2. If it stayed communist it’d most likely end up like the post communist African countries, under dictatorships and possibly left even worse by communism. Currently Afghanistan is getting better, once ISIS finally dies focus will shift back and if the terrorists groups there don’t die out soon people will eventually kill them and Afghanistan will be peaceful again.
HOLY THIS GUY IS HIGHLY EDUCATED "If it stayed communist it’d most likely end up like the post communist African countries" maybe thats why the Afghanistan in this video is highly underdeveloped and disgusting, while America definitely *_DID NOT_* fund the Mujahideen am i right? which later became Taliban, Al-Qaeda and finally ISIS, OH WAIT IT WAS THE RUSSIANS WHO FUNDED MUJAHIDEEN and yea Afghanistan is getting better i mean could it get any worse from here? 😂
When people say communism/socialism did no good....... It's the US which undid all good doings of the socialist countries.... Like Afghanistan for example
I have to agree on that. America did committed war crimes and crimes against humanity such as the My Lai massacre, prison torture in Iraq and the No Gun Ri massacre in Korea. However, human rights abuses committed by communist regimes were way more worse and horrifying than the American crimes. Would the world be a better place if the Soviet Union would take over the whole world? It's interesting to know that socialism failed in Venezuela and Cuba but it didn’t failed in Afghanistan because according to the comments from actual Afghani people whose relatives or friends lived through socialist Afghanistan, they say life is better in socialist Afghanistan as women have more rights, the education rate was really high and more economic oppurtunities for people. Back to the whole communism committing crimes against humanity, communist regimes have committed way more worse war crimes and atrocities than the Nazi and the US combined but I'm not saying anything to defend the Nazi because one such example is the Soviet crimes when they pushed onwrads to Berlin. On their advance through Poland and, according to an actual Polish guy, the Nazis took the paintings but the Soviets looted everything on their way to Berlin as they looted watches, food, furnitures and everything and I would not left out Katyn when the Soviet NKVD, under the orders from Stalin, took the Polish officers and intellectuals to Katyn forest where they would be shot and buried in mass graves. China, as of right now, began to commit genocide on the Uyghurs and the damn fucking useless UN turned a goddamn blind eye on this crime. So yes, in conclusion, communist regimes committed way more worse crimes than the US and I do not want to left out the Hue massacre committed by the NVA and Viet-Cong to eliminate any suspected political dissents such as ARVN soldiers, American civilians and etc. The South Vietnamese refugees who escaped to America did debunked the leftist myth that the American soldiers died for nothing but in reality, they died for freedom. Don't listen what the communist say but watch what they do.
@@phraya_techapit9910 Mixed economy. Though Socialist nationalization ruined my country's economy. No industry has managed to recover ever since. Also, IMF and WB have been looting my country dry.
ho0k_html im afghan. We have many ethnicities but arab are not one of them. Google it. We speak dari/farsi and pashto. We have more in common with persians, ossetians, central asia.
@@gobimurugesan2411 Were the Russians the only ones who had their own culture? From the Caucasians to the Turkics to the far east Siberians all had their own language and culture even to this day tho many of the ppl living in far east Siberia are forgetting their languages and culture and just speaking Russian
@@gobimurugesan2411 The Soviets also encouraged the teaching of other languages (There wasnt a official language in the USSR until 1990 but Russian was the lingua franca taught in school) thought many stopped learning them and just spoke Russian the Chukchi, Ket, Yukaghir etc for example (Look at the side) wikipedia.org/wiki/Chukchi_language#Orthography
I never knew Afghanistan looked like this, im not saying communism is somehow awesome, but Afghany people could be united, and focus only on industry, that is what communism does, take controll over all country industry... which could really make Afghanistan much more developed than it is now, also it eliminates poverty, all profit what country makes is shared to workers, so everyone would have relativly good housing and food... main idea is, that whatever negatives communism has, for countries like afghanistan it could be way to progress and build decent state with national welth
+Marty toofree nice theory , but then why the fuck would Russian economy nowadays only rely on digging up oils , natural gases and sale them , rather than producing something useful such as toilet papers.
+tim truo Because the Russian economy died after the fall of the Soviet Union. The GDP dropped by half, life expectancy dropped by 20 years and hasn't recovered, and GDP Per Capita only got back to it's 1989 level in 2014.
John Doe Soviets came as a request from the afghan government when US backed radical Islamist didn’t like woman going to school and decided to start terrorizing the country because of it.
@lord zilu always support islamic terrorism? You mean even Shia Hezbollah from Lebanon who bombed its barracks in Beirut and held its citizens as hostages? Is that why they didn't send its Navy Seals to rescue the hostages from Hezbollah but rather selling them missiles? (Iran Contra scandal)
Socialism and the Soviet Union gave the people of Afghanistan freedom; the USA took it away. It is hard not to weep for that country what has happened in the last 40 years. They have gone backwards. Millions are dead. Meanwhile, under pragmatic socialist leadership, China and Vietnam completely transformed themselves. If only Afghanistan continued down the path of socialism. If only the CCCP won!
OK I'm a communist and agree that Afghanistan was better under communism, for women especially (although yes they were still one party for most of their existence and there was still political repression) but maybe word that a little differently? There's nothing progressive about suppressing someone's religion, that's a problem Muslims in places like the UK and America have to face constantly
k3kboi 66 And tribal chieftains (feudal landlords) crying about losing the land they didn’t even fucking work. “PDPA took away my plantations and gave it to the farmers who worked it and I can’t throw acid in women’s faces now >:’((((“ “Fidel took away my dads plantations and gave it to the farmers who worked it >:’(((“ Same shit different liberal toilet.
@れをるReol of course there were bad things, there are always difficulties and challenges that any government faces. The difference is that the socialist governments goal is to liberate and develop its country, and the capitalists goal is to make money and make the whole world subservient to the west
@Foro Afghan it's not a "failure" when there are outside forces out right trying to stop Communism from growing, was it the US's business if the people in Veitman wanted be communist was it a failure when during the Spanish civil war when 8 million spanish started up Anarchist/Communist Society and then was killed by Franco and the fascists....is Cuda a failure? You know they have a embargo on them by the most powerful country in the world that same country illegally invaded them? If you say it fails what about capitalism recessions and depressions are failures in capitalism you can look around the world of capitalist countries failing just look at Afghanistan today!!
This is incredible rare footage. Thank you so much for posting this. Do you know the date of this Parade? Edit: I think this is the 1st anniversary parade of the Saur Revolution, on 27 April 1979
haha, this is really good. I am not sure how you find such amazing footage on your channel. You are actually a master of this stuff. The Reason i am so attatched to your channel and the fact that i respond to your other comments on random videos is that i remember back in 2019 i would try and make a channel similar to yours. Your channel is exactly what i tried to be, you actually have the success. Your are a skilled person.
Speaking as an American, the U.S. needs to stop interfering with other countries. If a country wants to be a Marxist-Leninist regime, then just let them be. I mean, Afghanistan under Marxist-Leninist rule looks amazing anyway.
Communism wasn't a bad idea but people and greed could easily destroy the idea itself.USSR must have focused on people and less military supremacy. Socialistic world could never be possible due to these errors. I would have loved to be alive during the Soviet era, just to thank them for the support India got from USSR during liberation of Bangladesh.
They did? I mean its not like their military spending is not at all related to the military spending by the NATO nations And they supported movements like in Afghanistan and Vietnam
Well the US focused on military supremacy and is still around. Cut that curry bullshit, it fell because the U.S. meddled with their politics, just like they do with India and Pakistan today. I ain't saying that the USSR was a saint utopia, but the reason as to why they fell isnt as simple as communism=weak capitalism=good. Heck in that case, China should've collapsed way before the USSR but they survived through supressing uprisings like NATO does time and time again in member countries.
not westernization. Westernization before first and second industrial revolution were not look like today, today's west society were completely modern and secular society, people do not let the religon power control and dominate people's life, fund, money, and the education system. Afaganistan and othet middle east should get rid of the feudal and religious superior power and the ugly and bloody Saudi arabia royals. how? by industrial and socialism revolution and spread the secularism to rest of the world. Then, more people adapt into the modernization society, people will know what's equality, why progressive and socialism revolution is important. No more feudalism, religion extremlism, only modernization!
I always wonder what if the previous three Presidents from PDPA : Nur Taraki and Hafizullah Amin would never have been lunatic and Babrak karmal would never have been alcoholic or Mohammad Najibullah would have preceded them rather than suceeding them ? After all, Afghan Communists are also responsible for Afghan instability like their successors : Mujahideens and their predecessor : Daud Khan.
I recommend this source I found from a book I read on it. It's an article that dates back to 1979 on how the Afghan coup occurred: www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1979/05/13/the-shah-not-kremlin-touched-off-afghan-coup/2bf25e8f-086a-4d91-90be-ce0f4649382f/
@@johnwright7916 Thank you, sir for your Valuable gift to me. No doubt, PDPA was neither United nor Mass organization as once confessed by Babrak Karmal.
Communism involves a stateless, classless, moneyless society with the means of production held in common, a lack of commodity production which refers to producing things to be sold, a gift economy, "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need" as Marx had worded it, the "withering away of state" as Engels had worded, to achieve a "Communist-Society" as Marx had called it. The nations which you most likely refer to as "Communist" are/were only Socialist and thus merely in the transitory stage between Capitalism and Communism. Socialism has done many good things improved literacy, education, healthcare, rights for minorities, rights for women, standards of living, qualities of life, caloric intake, lifespan, etc. They have also turned feudal backwaters into economic superpowers such as in the Soviet Union's case. According to a study called "Capitalism, Socialism and the Physical Quality of Life" by H. Waitzkin and S. Cereseto PhD published by the World Bank, given equal levels of economic development, Socialist nations had higher standards of living than Capitalist nations, also according to that same study, given equal levels of economic development, Socialist nations had higher levels of caloric intake than Capitalist ones, meaning contrary to popular belief, people in Socialist nations actually ate more food. That study can be found on various .gov and .org sites and has PDFs for you to download, if you want to read it. All of this information can be found from various other sources as well, physical and digital. Socialism had also turns nations into military superpowers such as in the Soviet Union's case. Planned economies are actually proven to be more efficient than markets such as in the case of Project CyberSyn where they used a computer planned economy, this was decades ago in Chile, think about what modern computers with modern computing capabilities could do! The reason for some Socialist nations having bad economies is NOT a fault of Socialism, it is often caused by economic embargoes, sanctions and other methods of destabilizing their economies caused by the United States, or the loss of some of the nations' biggest trade partners such as the DPRK(North Korea)'s economy ranking after the dissolution of the Soviet Union.
Actually, Afghanistan was a prosperous country when it was under the monarchy until 1973, Things started to unravel after the communist takeover in 1973. Religious tensions began to simmer slowly(Afghanistan was an always religious society but radical elements were cut to size ) and further radicalisation was carried out by Capitalist USA with their middle eastern friends
All that hardware + the Red Army on their side...yet these guys still couldn't beat the Mujahideen? Yeah the Mujahideen had the Stinger missiles given to them by the CIA, but still...
Well they got a country like this, the communists did not put any affords to build the country, it was already build by the kingdom of Afghanistan. What they really did was creating social disasters which resulted the present situation. They power hungry men killing and throwing each other for power, they had very weak leadership, they couldn't even survive for 3 years, they are not the one to be credited for the achievements of the Kingdom. Why don't you ask them what is their role in today's Afghanistan under than hiding in the western countries and seeking asylum? They should come and answer the People of Afghanistan for what they did To hell with Hafizulamin and his followers They destroyed our liberal country to what we have now as mafia and terrorist state. They burried alive innocent civilians labelling them as isrealli and american agents.
The most tragic time ever afghans experienced because of the fail socialism which collapse afghan economy. Thinking of Afghan woman to be like in PDPA government is just Utopia.
first of all I will say that islamic system is the best system.Which have rulled all over the world more then ten centuries. After that communism is much better then capitalisam .Althouhgh communism is much related to islamic system.
Look at what the evil socialism did to Afghanistan! thank goodness the Americans liberated Afg and saved them from god awful things like Electricity, Food, proper paved roads, _NOT GETTING BOMBED_ and more awful things!
Man Afghanistan was peaceful modern and progressive back then but today totally opposite. May this good old days will reign over Afghanistan again soon !
@@mrmindful4528 Amen to that!
The best Afghanistan we have ever known. The Socialist Afganistan.
afghanistan would be a very peaceful country of nobody messed it up
Chandini Mohan we can thank Ronald Reagan for offering Stingers to taliban.
Belkan Squadron 1. There was no Taliban it was the Mujahideen
2. If it stayed communist it’d most likely end up like the post communist African countries, under dictatorships and possibly left even worse by communism. Currently Afghanistan is getting better, once ISIS finally dies focus will shift back and if the terrorists groups there don’t die out soon people will eventually kill them and Afghanistan will be peaceful again.
Communism forever!!!
HOLY THIS GUY IS HIGHLY EDUCATED "If it stayed communist it’d most likely end up like the post communist African countries" maybe thats why the Afghanistan in this video is highly underdeveloped and disgusting, while America definitely *_DID NOT_* fund the Mujahideen am i right? which later became Taliban, Al-Qaeda and finally ISIS, OH WAIT IT WAS THE RUSSIANS WHO FUNDED MUJAHIDEEN and yea Afghanistan is getting better i mean could it get any worse from here? 😂
@@kingfoxclaw8698hahahaha buen cuento payasito imperialista
As my personal opinion, the only guy who has unliked this video will/should be a radical Pakistan sympathiser.
Or an arab working for Al Jazeera
Or an American.
Hindutva negative extremist Endian spotted
Yes exactly.
Yes a Pakistani American or Saudi
This video bears testimony of how Afghanistan used to be a better country 40 years ago
@NoRublesNoGas and now a taliban extremist country. Sounds like a “great democracy” doesn’t it
@NoRublesNoGas The Soviet Union subverted and destroyed the Afghan government.
It’s sad how much of their history and culture was lost in the process.
When people say communism/socialism did no good.......
It's the US which undid all good doings of the socialist countries.... Like Afghanistan for example
I agree
I have to agree on that. America did committed war crimes and crimes against humanity such as the My Lai massacre, prison torture in Iraq and the No Gun Ri massacre in Korea. However, human rights abuses committed by communist regimes were way more worse and horrifying than the American crimes. Would the world be a better place if the Soviet Union would take over the whole world? It's interesting to know that socialism failed in Venezuela and Cuba but it didn’t failed in Afghanistan because according to the comments from actual Afghani people whose relatives or friends lived through socialist Afghanistan, they say life is better in socialist Afghanistan as women have more rights, the education rate was really high and more economic oppurtunities for people. Back to the whole communism committing crimes against humanity, communist regimes have committed way more worse war crimes and atrocities than the Nazi and the US combined but I'm not saying anything to defend the Nazi because one such example is the Soviet crimes when they pushed onwrads to Berlin. On their advance through Poland and, according to an actual Polish guy, the Nazis took the paintings but the Soviets looted everything on their way to Berlin as they looted watches, food, furnitures and everything and I would not left out Katyn when the Soviet NKVD, under the orders from Stalin, took the Polish officers and intellectuals to Katyn forest where they would be shot and buried in mass graves. China, as of right now, began to commit genocide on the Uyghurs and the damn fucking useless UN turned a goddamn blind eye on this crime. So yes, in conclusion, communist regimes committed way more worse crimes than the US and I do not want to left out the Hue massacre committed by the NVA and Viet-Cong to eliminate any suspected political dissents such as ARVN soldiers, American civilians and etc. The South Vietnamese refugees who escaped to America did debunked the leftist myth that the American soldiers died for nothing but in reality, they died for freedom. Don't listen what the communist say but watch what they do.
@@phraya_techapit9910 Communists and capitalists are two sides of the same coin. Both are evil.
@@maquacr7014 I know capitalism is not perfect but it's way better than Communism. Are you a centralist or a mixed-economy?
@@phraya_techapit9910 Mixed economy.
Though Socialist nationalization ruined my country's economy. No industry has managed to recover ever since. Also, IMF and WB have been looting my country dry.
Then western freedom and democracy arrives...
And now Islamist notions of freedom inundate western ideas of freedom.And may you live in interesting times !
"DeMocRaCy"
It was capitalist demoncracy..
Most Afghans aren't Arab they are closely related to Iranians and South Asian people.
Philip Smith Aren’t Iranian’s Arab
@@hassankhan-jg1dx No u stupid fuck.
NO afghan is arab.
ho0k_html im afghan. We have many ethnicities but arab are not one of them. Google it. We speak dari/farsi and pashto. We have more in common with persians, ossetians, central asia.
"MOST" Afghans are not Arab, You say? Afghanistan has many different ethnic groups. Arab is not one of them.
It's look like a Soviet Union nation with their own culture.
So the Soviet union didnt have their own culture?
@@Ida-xe8pg u mean Russian culture?
@@gobimurugesan2411 Were the Russians the only ones who had their own culture? From the Caucasians to the Turkics to the far east Siberians all had their own language and culture even to this day tho many of the ppl living in far east Siberia are forgetting their languages and culture and just speaking Russian
@@gobimurugesan2411 Religion too
@@gobimurugesan2411 The Soviets also encouraged the teaching of other languages (There wasnt a official language in the USSR until 1990 but Russian was the lingua franca taught in school) thought many stopped learning them and just spoke Russian the Chukchi, Ket, Yukaghir etc for example (Look at the side) wikipedia.org/wiki/Chukchi_language#Orthography
I never knew Afghanistan looked like this, im not saying communism is somehow awesome, but Afghany people could be united, and focus only on industry, that is what communism does, take controll over all country industry... which could really make Afghanistan much more developed than it is now, also it eliminates poverty, all profit what country makes is shared to workers, so everyone would have relativly good housing and food... main idea is, that whatever negatives communism has, for countries like afghanistan it could be way to progress and build decent state with national welth
+Marty toofree You have no idea what your talking about.
+Marty toofree nice theory , but then why the fuck would Russian economy nowadays only rely on digging up oils , natural gases and sale them , rather than producing something useful such as toilet papers.
+tim truo Because the Russian economy died after the fall of the Soviet Union. The GDP dropped by half, life expectancy dropped by 20 years and hasn't recovered, and GDP Per Capita only got back to it's 1989 level in 2014.
> Russian economy died after the fall of CCCP
then why US space projects still using Soviet propellants?
Communism does seem to perform better in third world countries since wealth is distributed and industry is a main focus.
what hapèpened ? murican change regime ??
John Doe Soviets came as a request from the afghan government when US backed radical Islamist didn’t like woman going to school and decided to start terrorizing the country because of it.
@lord zilu always support islamic terrorism? You mean even Shia Hezbollah from Lebanon who bombed its barracks in Beirut and held its citizens as hostages? Is that why they didn't send its Navy Seals to rescue the hostages from Hezbollah but rather selling them missiles? (Iran Contra scandal)
Even though I am not communist but afghanistan was so better under communist
I wish afghanistan was still communist
Socialism and the Soviet Union gave the people of Afghanistan freedom; the USA took it away. It is hard not to weep for that country what has happened in the last 40 years. They have gone backwards. Millions are dead. Meanwhile, under pragmatic socialist leadership, China and Vietnam completely transformed themselves. If only Afghanistan continued down the path of socialism. If only the CCCP won!
Man, Afghanistan used to be so different before the Taliban came and drove it to shit. Afghanistan has not fully recovered, to this day.
Taliban and the US
@@infinite1483 Who created the Taliban? Its all the USA
Just lyk at those women no burqa no hijab........
VISHNU KUMAR KR Afghanistan women are beutiful.
This is what happens when religion is suppressed: progress
@VDG better than being a religious shithole, i say that as someone who is not a fan of communism in general
OK I'm a communist and agree that Afghanistan was better under communism, for women especially (although yes they were still one party for most of their existence and there was still political repression) but maybe word that a little differently?
There's nothing progressive about suppressing someone's religion, that's a problem Muslims in places like the UK and America have to face constantly
@@pikachucetthesecond4296 Islamaphobia is different from not having laws based on religion
@@warcriminal4183 He specifically used the term "suppressing religion" though.
Islam is A Barbaric Religion.
No allahu akbar..... How peaceful and happy afghans were back then.....
@れをるReol and the bad sides were? Old people being pissy about not gettin 12 year old wifes? The burka industry doing bad?
k3kboi 66 And tribal chieftains (feudal landlords) crying about losing the land they didn’t even fucking work.
“PDPA took away my plantations and gave it to the farmers who worked it and I can’t throw acid in women’s faces now >:’((((“
“Fidel took away my dads plantations and gave it to the farmers who worked it >:’(((“
Same shit different liberal toilet.
@れをるReol of course there were bad things, there are always difficulties and challenges that any government faces. The difference is that the socialist governments goal is to liberate and develop its country, and the capitalists goal is to make money and make the whole world subservient to the west
😂 Nowadays u dont even have good sides in Afg for a good propaganda video all of afg looks like the same now
@@Ida-xe8pg thats the point. Today you can't can't even make proper propaganda. like wtf.
I want communism again in afghanistan 😓😓😭😭😭😭😓
@Foro Afghan it didnt
@Foro Afghan it's not a "failure" when there are outside forces out right trying to stop Communism from growing, was it the US's business if the people in Veitman wanted be communist was it a failure when during the Spanish civil war when 8 million spanish started up Anarchist/Communist Society and then was killed by Franco and the fascists....is Cuda a failure? You know they have a embargo on them by the most powerful country in the world that same country illegally invaded them? If you say it fails what about capitalism recessions and depressions are failures in capitalism you can look around the world of capitalist countries failing just look at Afghanistan today!!
We want communism in India
@Foro Afghan How do you define a failure? The Soviet Union became a strong superpower that rivalled the USA
Communist Afghan can become a better country like Communist Vietnam.
Unlike the Islamic Afghan today
This is incredible rare footage. Thank you so much for posting this. Do you know the date of this Parade?
Edit: I think this is the 1st anniversary parade of the Saur Revolution, on 27 April 1979
haha, this is really good. I am not sure how you find such amazing footage on your channel. You are actually a master of this stuff. The Reason i am so attatched to your channel and the fact that i respond to your other comments on random videos is that i remember back in 2019 i would try and make a channel similar to yours. Your channel is exactly what i tried to be, you actually have the success. Your are a skilled person.
Speaking as an American, the U.S. needs to stop interfering with other countries. If a country wants to be a Marxist-Leninist regime, then just let them be. I mean, Afghanistan under Marxist-Leninist rule looks amazing anyway.
that was a great time.
Communism wasn't a bad idea but people and greed could easily destroy the idea itself.USSR must have focused on people and less military supremacy. Socialistic world could never be possible due to these errors. I would have loved to be alive during the Soviet era, just to thank them for the support India got from USSR during liberation of Bangladesh.
They did?
I mean its not like their military spending is not at all related to the military spending by the NATO nations
And they supported movements like in Afghanistan and Vietnam
Afghanistan was Socialist, not Communist at that time.
Well the US focused on military supremacy and is still around. Cut that curry bullshit, it fell because the U.S. meddled with their politics, just like they do with India and Pakistan today. I ain't saying that the USSR was a saint utopia, but the reason as to why they fell isnt as simple as communism=weak capitalism=good. Heck in that case, China should've collapsed way before the USSR but they survived through supressing uprisings like NATO does time and time again in member countries.
In Socialism the state get the power of the Economy and well they can keep the money instead of redistributing the wealth and spend it on themselves
Golden days of Afghanistan
@VDG with government of Islamists?
@VDG destruction of country and unprogressive ideology is something good?
The previous three Presidents from PDPA : Nur Taraki and Hafizullah Amin and Babrak karmal
Mohammad Najibullah.
USA trained Mujahideen to fight USSR.... and such a beautiful country got destroyed
Women regiment of Afghanistan. That's great
زنده باد حزب دموکراتیک خلق افغانستان
د افغانستان ډموکراتيک جمهوريت ♥️♥️♥️
@@PeePeePooPoo2412 زنده باد🚩🇦🇫
I wonder... the USA gave help in the 1980's to the taliban fighters... so was that smart ?
Where are these people now? Dead, run sways, a society needs people like this who desire democracy freedom and westernization
not westernization. Westernization before first and second industrial revolution were not look like today, today's west society were completely modern and secular society, people do not let the religon power control and dominate people's life, fund, money, and the education system. Afaganistan and othet middle east should get rid of the feudal and religious superior power and the ugly and bloody Saudi arabia royals. how? by industrial and socialism revolution and spread the secularism to rest of the world. Then, more people adapt into the modernization society, people will know what's equality, why progressive and socialism revolution is important. No more feudalism, religion extremlism, only modernization!
@Shahin Shahin or they just like adapted to the new way of life...
What song played in the parade
If only you could go back in time and warn them about the future
😭😭😭❤️
> This is what they took from you
6:08 to 6:10 is that an afghan sikh soldier?
They are officers from Indian armed forces 🇮🇳.
I wonder if the people lived in those time still alive ,what is their feeling??
I’m pretty sure most people welcomed a fundamentalist state. Minus all the war of course. Don’t let all the smiles and tiny skirts fool you
@@Dasanie that's their idiocracy.
A lot of them left Afghanistan over the years..
@@Dasanie
Are You Taliban?
BRAINLESS BULLSHIT
@@b0leg23 not really for the most part the majority did at the time.
👍👍
I always wonder what if the previous three Presidents from PDPA : Nur Taraki and Hafizullah Amin would never have been lunatic and Babrak karmal would never have been alcoholic or Mohammad Najibullah would have preceded them rather than suceeding them ? After all, Afghan Communists are also responsible for Afghan instability like their successors : Mujahideens and their predecessor : Daud Khan.
I recommend this source I found from a book I read on it. It's an article that dates back to 1979 on how the Afghan coup occurred:
www.washingtonpost.com/archive/opinions/1979/05/13/the-shah-not-kremlin-touched-off-afghan-coup/2bf25e8f-086a-4d91-90be-ce0f4649382f/
@@johnwright7916 Thank you, sir for your Valuable gift to me. No doubt, PDPA was neither United nor Mass organization as once confessed by Babrak Karmal.
I hate communism, but I'd prefer a communist Afghanistan…
Communism involves a stateless, classless, moneyless society with the means of production held in common, a lack of commodity production which refers to producing things to be sold, a gift economy, "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need" as Marx had worded it, the "withering away of state" as Engels had worded, to achieve a "Communist-Society" as Marx had called it. The nations which you most likely refer to as "Communist" are/were only Socialist and thus merely in the transitory stage between Capitalism and Communism. Socialism has done many good things improved literacy, education, healthcare, rights for minorities, rights for women, standards of living, qualities of life, caloric intake, lifespan, etc. They have also turned feudal backwaters into economic superpowers such as in the Soviet Union's case. According to a study called "Capitalism, Socialism and the Physical Quality of Life" by H. Waitzkin and S. Cereseto PhD published by the World Bank, given equal levels of economic development, Socialist nations had higher standards of living than Capitalist nations, also according to that same study, given equal levels of economic development, Socialist nations had higher levels of caloric intake than Capitalist ones, meaning contrary to popular belief, people in Socialist nations actually ate more food. That study can be found on various .gov and .org sites and has PDFs for you to download, if you want to read it. All of this information can be found from various other sources as well, physical and digital. Socialism had also turns nations into military superpowers such as in the Soviet Union's case. Planned economies are actually proven to be more efficient than markets such as in the case of Project CyberSyn where they used a computer planned economy, this was decades ago in Chile, think about what modern computers with modern computing capabilities could do! The reason for some Socialist nations having bad economies is NOT a fault of Socialism, it is often caused by economic embargoes, sanctions and other methods of destabilizing their economies caused by the United States, or the loss of some of the nations' biggest trade partners such as the DPRK(North Korea)'s economy ranking after the dissolution of the Soviet Union.
I'm not you are ignoring that they were fundamentalists.
Fundamentalist socialist which is good.
And now, you are happy :/
Oh my God. Khalq and parcham and Shola as well were totally communists. Happy that this Time has past!
It was the same as the iraqi monarchy it was better in iraq under the monarchy and in Afghanistan when it was under communism
the mujahidin destryed everything for gaol of america and soviet
Actually, Afghanistan was a prosperous country when it was under the monarchy until 1973, Things started to unravel after the communist takeover in 1973. Religious tensions began to simmer slowly(Afghanistan was an always religious society but radical elements were cut to size ) and further radicalisation was carried out by Capitalist USA with their middle eastern friends
Communist takeover occured in 1979. Not 1973. You're making things up
Well at least this one is better
Women have rights than what will Afghanistan will be today
The afghan monarchy was removed in 1973 by Doug khan
This country was destroyed by both SU anf US.
USA are worse
no islam
@@Scapone2001 Islamists and USA are same
Islamism is coming again..congratulations
Eeeew
Afghanistan ka inkilab donya ka inkilab ta durrani bajur
All that hardware + the Red Army on their side...yet these guys still couldn't beat the Mujahideen? Yeah the Mujahideen had the Stinger missiles given to them by the CIA, but still...
@A S W Where's the lie tho? Commie asswipe
@@ArachKing bruh them how did US got beaten by the Vietnamese?
Vietnamese rice farmers with AKs and RPGs?
Ghol communist afghanstan di murdakhoran dictators
The darkest period of afghan history
This was the PEACEFUL time in Afghanistan. What happened after the US interference was dark
*brightest
Well they got a country like this, the communists did not put any affords to build the country, it was already build by the kingdom of Afghanistan. What they really did was creating social disasters which resulted the present situation.
They power hungry men killing and throwing each other for power, they had very weak leadership, they couldn't even survive for 3 years, they are not the one to be credited for the achievements of the Kingdom.
Why don't you ask them what is their role in today's Afghanistan under than hiding in the western countries and seeking asylum? They should come and answer the People of Afghanistan for what they did
To hell with Hafizulamin and his followers
They destroyed our liberal country to what we have now as mafia and terrorist state.
They burried alive innocent civilians labelling them as isrealli and american agents.
The better question is what did the so called mujahideen did after they took over in Afghanistan.
The most tragic time ever afghans experienced because of the fail socialism which collapse afghan economy. Thinking of Afghan woman to be like in PDPA government is just Utopia.
Such videos are called communist propaganda.
Communists were cruel.
But many don't understand here .
look at Afghanistan today and think about wich is better.
first of all I will say that islamic system is the best system.Which have rulled all over the world more then ten centuries. After that communism is much better then capitalisam .Althouhgh communism is much related to islamic system.
Cruel against the opressors
Afghanistan is already screwed by the US imperialism
waqar arif May I ask how communism, where people starve, is better than capitalism?
LOL SOVIET PROPAGANDA
Soviet Russian propaganda
This Afghanistan was way better than today's mess thanks to the US
😂 Nowadays u dont even have good places in Afg for a good propaganda video all of afg looks like the same now
Look at what the evil socialism did to Afghanistan! thank goodness the Americans liberated Afg and saved them from god awful things like Electricity, Food, proper paved roads, _NOT GETTING BOMBED_ and more awful things!
@@Ida-xe8pg well said
@Нинтен i am living only few kilometres away from the border of Afghanistan
very interesting video
where i can find copy of this videos?
(i mean vhs)