Who Was The Best English Monarch? David Mitchell Rates The Royals!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @wordtothewise9723
    @wordtothewise9723 Рік тому +2779

    I loved his take on the British invading France.
    "A burglar often find himself outnumbered in the house he's burgling, but that doesn't make him plucky."

    • @wargey3431
      @wargey3431 Рік тому +102

      mind you the french did change the law of inheritance to stop Edward being king
      so its a bit like the brother arriving with a smaller force of men against a larger force to capture a farm he believed his even though the butler said it went to the other cousin

    • @Trebor74
      @Trebor74 Рік тому +55

      ​@@wargey3431he was the legitimate heir. That's the whole point. But points get ignored by certain people

    • @thomasdequincey5811
      @thomasdequincey5811 Рік тому +3

      Do you know what that actually means? 'Cause I don't. To me, it sounds like he's afraid of hurting "France's" feelings and doesn't want to be cancelled.

    • @wordtothewise9723
      @wordtothewise9723 Рік тому +78

      @@thomasdequincey5811 I doubt it. That's not David Mitchell's style. He has a talent for taking constructive and truthful point of view, and arguing his case superbly.

    • @drachna
      @drachna Рік тому +64

      ​@@Trebor74A ruler who doesn't live in the country they claim to rule is never going to be recognised as legitimate by a sizable amount of the population.

  • @rebecca-georgiawood8947
    @rebecca-georgiawood8947 Рік тому +1512

    Idk, something about David saying “sometimes history just happens to you and there’s nothing you can do when your a victim of it” Been having a rough time lately but this really just hit me in the feels today

    • @johnhiscott-walsh5198
      @johnhiscott-walsh5198 Рік тому +4

      👍

    • @timburdsey
      @timburdsey Рік тому +37

      Hope everything’s Ok now, Rebecca. Keep your chin up. 👍🏻 Hope you get back on your feet and can enjoy making your own history. 😊

    • @curiousman3655
      @curiousman3655 Рік тому +18

      In a rough patch atm. Hope ur okay and we will make it out

    • @shentser01
      @shentser01 Рік тому +6

      Hope you’re feeling a bit better soon Rebecca

    • @sethshaffer681
      @sethshaffer681 Рік тому +8

      If you're a fan of the ONLY correct way to interpret history, Historical Materialism, you'll find that this is the case for every single human that's ever lived from the grandest emperor down to the lowliest slaves and prisoners. Some individuals just happen to have a hold onto more of the reigns of the thing to move a bit more of the resources, influence and power towards their own direction.

  • @ArcCushion
    @ArcCushion 11 місяців тому +711

    This is the most comfortable I've seen David in any interview, ever.

    • @grahamstrouse1165
      @grahamstrouse1165 9 місяців тому +3

      I know, right? 😁

    • @lindarockafellow5058
      @lindarockafellow5058 9 місяців тому +20

      He was great on Graham Norton. What a package... historian with a sense of humor!

    • @blondie9422
      @blondie9422 9 місяців тому +19

      His whole face is lit up 😂
      Bless him ❤

    • @Outside85
      @Outside85 7 місяців тому +9

      He is worried that the (ancient) QI 'teachers pet' fanfare will sound at any moment.

    • @jaybestnz
      @jaybestnz 5 місяців тому +9

      He looks so happy talking about it.

  • @EleanorPeterson
    @EleanorPeterson Рік тому +761

    My late mum was a keen historian and named me after Eleanor of Aquitaine (Queen of England from 1154 to 1189). As a monarch she was reputedly somewhat less than awful; I have based my life on striving to be somewhat less than awful.
    It's something to work towards.😁

    • @patwilson2546
      @patwilson2546 Рік тому +23

      Eleanor was an amazing person. Just too much to say about her in an internet comment. Anybody interested in early Norman England absolutely must look into her.

    • @peartree460
      @peartree460 Рік тому +23

      Keep strivin. I have, in this later stage of life, achieved the right amount of awfulness.*
      Excluding wedding parties with free wine after 11:43 p.m. (im still working on that😂😂😂

    • @benbeasant3443
      @benbeasant3443 10 місяців тому +14

      It's a beautiful name regardless

    • @Silver_Owl
      @Silver_Owl 10 місяців тому +8

      It's a lovely name.🙂If I'd had a daughter, I would also have called her Eleanor. (I have sons.)

    • @ripdbtpoo1441
      @ripdbtpoo1441 10 місяців тому +1

      Yes, but here we're talking about Mitchell and the monarchs of England and Britain, not about you. There's too much of this.

  • @UPalooza
    @UPalooza Рік тому +96

    He's not even joking, and I'm smiling the whole time. We are lucky to have you David.

  • @Simian-bz7zo
    @Simian-bz7zo Рік тому +1536

    I could quite happily sit in a corner and listen to Dan and David talk about history for hours.

    • @funkophone
      @funkophone Рік тому +15

      They play well off of each other.

    • @lindala2602
      @lindala2602 Рік тому +23

      Yes, this video is much much to short

    • @thehearingaid
      @thehearingaid Рік тому

      It's a shame i missed him at Cheltnam lit fest.

    • @-Blackberry
      @-Blackberry Рік тому +26

      I like how they dont dumb it down, they're just enjoying talking about interesting facts of different kings without patronising the audience having to explain the context behind every little thing.

    • @doctor_gibbo1392
      @doctor_gibbo1392 Рік тому +8

      Chance would be a fine thing. A very fine thing indeed.

  • @RemoteEars
    @RemoteEars Рік тому +4947

    A David Mitchell history rant? All my interests align

    • @caitlinb
      @caitlinb Рік тому +69

      And he narrates the Unruly audio book! I've never made a audio book purchase faster

    • @WHITERAGS
      @WHITERAGS Рік тому +30

      Love David Mitchell!

    • @13thcentury
      @13thcentury Рік тому +11

      I strongly suggest he goes back to school, and acquires an 11 plus level of history.
      Absolute cringe.

    • @WyattRyeSway
      @WyattRyeSway Рік тому +20

      Oh I have to buy it now! I love David Mitchell. I’m an American and you can’t find him on TV here, which is sad! Sometimes our TV and movies suck because the Brits have the funniest most talented guys.

    • @BumMcFluff
      @BumMcFluff Рік тому +22

      Any facts to back that up?@@13thcentury

  • @-Blackberry
    @-Blackberry Рік тому +1237

    Glad he is taking time to cover the Anglo-Saxon kings, I always find it weird how many make out that English history starts at 1066.

    • @robtyman4281
      @robtyman4281 Рік тому +1

      It actually starts before this, but the Normans were very efficient at getting rid of alot of the symbols, traditions, and way of life of Anglo-Saxon England.
      They essentially tried to 'erase' it from history. I think I've finally realised after all these years that the Normans very much saw 1066 as a 'year zero' .....in mych the same way Pol Pot did in Cambodia in 1975.
      We need a reappraisal on William the Conqueror, as we've got him all wrong. If anything, he was worse than the Vikings. At least they didn't try to destroy all vestiges of Anglo-Saxon England. Because remember Britain wasn't created until 1707!
      I think we celebrate William the Conqueror in the wrong way. Far from being a saviour figure, he was an even more ruthless ruler (and killer) than Henry VIII.

    • @-Blackberry
      @-Blackberry Рік тому +52

      @robtyman4281 Yeah he was a genocidal psycho, in a time when that wasn't very unusual he still stands out. The Anglo-Saxon nobility was pretty much completely replaced, the harrying of the north was devastating.
      However, one thing they were never able to wipe out was our language, which carried on through the common people. A hostile elite can never truly eradicate the culture of a people when they remain in high enough numbers at least.
      Ironically a result in later centuries was the french speaking ruling class finally had to embrace an English identity in opposition to the French enemy and the English kin had the last laugh imo with their language consigned to immortality all the way into our day, albiet altered considerably throughout the centuries.

    • @zapkvr
      @zapkvr Рік тому +2

      And I. Most peculiar

    • @jonbaxter2254
      @jonbaxter2254 Рік тому +15

      Yeah, English literally mean "Land of the Angles" who arrived in the 5th century!

    • @gerardodwyer5908
      @gerardodwyer5908 Рік тому +12

      ​@@-BlackberryTrue, the Germanic Anglo Saxon Anglishe identity did rebound through inter-marriage with the Franco Normans. Although, only the French language, not German, remains on the front cover of the modern British passport.

  • @Deluxedracula
    @Deluxedracula 2 місяці тому +22

    These two dudes are truly fascinating to listen to. On one hand a bloke with supreme knowledge and intelligence and wit and on the other hand a bloke with supreme knowledge and intelligence and wit.

  • @bovisjeaks
    @bovisjeaks 11 місяців тому +62

    I love David Mitchell. I wish there were more people around that speak as well as he does about absolutely anything. Top bloke.

    • @dalemevans
      @dalemevans 7 місяців тому +2

      Yes and none of that cod S. Fry coyness

  • @glassberg5018
    @glassberg5018 Рік тому +714

    David Mitchell is one of the greatest entertainers of the last 50 years and I will watch anything he makes.

    • @numberonedad
      @numberonedad Рік тому +25

      i love mitchell but the viking/covid analogy is something mark would come up with

    • @sealand4950
      @sealand4950 Рік тому

      He did business studies
      @@numberonedad

    • @rimstieskorsakovs
      @rimstieskorsakovs Рік тому +2

      @glassberg5018 i absolutely concur.

    • @chunkylover48
      @chunkylover48 Рік тому +1

      * David Mitchell sits on jar *

    • @newtexan1
      @newtexan1 Рік тому +6

      “Upstart Crow” is a brilliant series.

  • @TheNordicHermit
    @TheNordicHermit Рік тому +432

    I can't express why I find so much joy in seeing a celebrity of comedy (like Mitchell) or from any field, showing that they have deep interest in another field, like history, philosophy, or physics.

    • @grahamstrouse1165
      @grahamstrouse1165 Рік тому +65

      UK comics tend to be pretty cerebral. Not all of them, mind you, but if you were trying to put together a curriculum & you were short on teachers you could probably put together a decent lineup from The Edinburgh Fringe, last week’s panel shows & Taskmaster.

    • @DanielVerberne
      @DanielVerberne Рік тому +17

      I find myself wishing some of these wonderful individuals were my real-life friends. David Mitchell would make a fascinating addition to almost any occasion.

    • @jennytmaher
      @jennytmaher 11 місяців тому +23

      History is what David Mitchell has a degree in.

    • @grahamstrouse1165
      @grahamstrouse1165 9 місяців тому +1

      @@DanielVerberneSame!

    • @oliverchambers2544
      @oliverchambers2544 9 місяців тому +5

      @@jennytmaher but that's all ancient history now!

  • @swaffelkonijn5166
    @swaffelkonijn5166 Рік тому +417

    I really like David Mitchell the comedian, but as someone who also has a MA in history it is really cool to also see something of David Mitchell the Cambridge history graduate.

    • @joedwyer3297
      @joedwyer3297 Рік тому +23

      Yeah hes not just a one dimensional funny posh guy getting bullied by Lee Mack and as much as I enjoy that I also enjoy him speaking about the Subject which hes passionate about

    • @oisinquinn9469
      @oisinquinn9469 11 місяців тому +3

      Ancient history

    • @louisetrott5532
      @louisetrott5532 10 місяців тому +8

      Agreed. I have a PhD in Old Norse, and I loved this interview.

    • @LindaLinda80Linda
      @LindaLinda80Linda 8 місяців тому

      What is the name of the book? You mean the one on the shelf just to your right? Just pick up the book, say the author’s name and the book’s title and say goodbye. I mean, we can see the book right there.

    • @ripdbtpoo1441
      @ripdbtpoo1441 7 місяців тому +2

      Why do you awful people who comment always talk about yourselves ? "I, who have a degree..." There are quite a few out there, sir, but are we not here to discuss Mr Mitchell's book ?

  • @MichaelCWBell
    @MichaelCWBell 24 дні тому +3

    Enjoyed the use of the word clobber.
    Mitchell has that manner of pleasant brightness one occasionally finds in someone who has a passion or two. It’s very affirming (thank you both).

  • @ashleymason4471
    @ashleymason4471 Рік тому +45

    he's absolutely beaming the whole interview

  • @danaglabeman6919
    @danaglabeman6919 Рік тому +713

    I'm SO glad to hear someone who knows what they're talking about put the blame for the English loss at Hastings in the right spot. The number of times I've heard somebody talked about how they lost because they were tired from marching across England after defeating Hadrada...no. David Mitchell gets it. Harold knew how the Normans fought, he knew they'd feign a retreat, he warned his men to hold the line unless he personally ordered them to break formation, and then they fell for the fake retreat and broke their line to pursue. Twice. Being "tired from marching" had nothing to do with it. You don't hold an infantry line against the greatest calvalry in Europe for 7 hours if you're too tired to fight a battle. They fell for the act, even though the boss had warned them about that exact trick.

    • @thepebblesexplore83
      @thepebblesexplore83 Рік тому +64

      You can’t say it had NOTHING to do with it. But it wasn’t the catalyst.

    • @eddieharris6004
      @eddieharris6004 Рік тому +6

      Were you there?....

    • @tonyharrison2112
      @tonyharrison2112 Рік тому +45

      I've literally never heard anyone ever say that hastings was lost because they were tired from marching. I've heard it mentioned as to say that it was incredibly impressive to fight one battle and then almost immediately turn heel after victory and go and fight to defend another invasion. But the supported theory that I've only ever heard in regards to pinning down The Anglo Saxons defeat was because they thought they'd won and the army split and William siezed the oportunity and segmented the Anglo Saxons until they were cut down root and stem.

    • @mrtoothless
      @mrtoothless Рік тому

      The grownups are talking, sit down.@@eddieharris6004

    • @debse.7286
      @debse.7286 Рік тому +12

      No, I think fighting then marching a hundred miles would have a negative effect. But most of all, they shouldn't have fought the army so soon at all.
      They were defending and should have had all the advantage of knowledge of terrain, supplies and locals on their side (I presume). William the conqueror, defeated much larger French armies twice using strategy and keeping his people under tight control. He lured the invaders in and waited until they were vulnerable. Harold had every advantage and still lost. Unless, of course, he wasn't as popular in England as we are led to believe...

  • @bigcat3596
    @bigcat3596 Рік тому +70

    hell of an interview by dan snow, always so refreshing to see two people who care about history talk about what interests them

  • @rebel.taylord
    @rebel.taylord Рік тому +90

    I wish this was an hour, 29 minutes is too short. I can listen to David talk about anything, he is so intelligent, articulate and funny!

  • @snufkinhollow318
    @snufkinhollow318 Рік тому +31

    I must confess that Dan Snow wasn't among my favourite historians until History Hit took off and now he is. David Mitchell always makes me laugh with his 'history rants' but I love the way he puts different, intelligent perspectives forward at the same time. This combination of two people who are passionate about history but also incredibly entertaining has produced one of my favourite history videos in a long time. Thank you.

    • @TehScareM8
      @TehScareM8 Рік тому +5

      Interestingly I'm the same, maybe it's something about working for television with more constraints and procedures whereas Dan can let loose a bit more on youtube.

    • @snufkinhollow318
      @snufkinhollow318 Рік тому +3

      @@TehScareM8 That's a very good point, Long may it continue!

  • @katherinewestbrook504
    @katherinewestbrook504 5 місяців тому +9

    As someone who is struggling mentally with COVID disabling me, I needed to hear that. Thank you.

  • @carolefreeman2544
    @carolefreeman2544 Рік тому +459

    I purchased the Audiobook of Unruly by David Mitchell and I am enjoying listening to David narration of his book. Not only is it interesting but it’s hilarious too! ❤🇨🇦🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

    • @CarlinConnolly
      @CarlinConnolly Рік тому +13

      you've just given me an idea for xmas!

    • @AmazingJane137
      @AmazingJane137 Рік тому +6

      Oh that’s great to hear. Thanks

    • @tuibabbington4869
      @tuibabbington4869 Рік тому +5

      I just bought the e-reader version, never thought of the audio...heading off for a road trip tomorrow, I know what we will be listening too now. 😉

    • @tommonk7651
      @tommonk7651 Рік тому +5

      I got it as well. Looking forward to listening to it soon....

    • @bexp436
      @bexp436 Рік тому +2

      Brilliant. Thanks for that and I will now go and purchase the audio book. Can't wait to listen.😊

  • @Fitaroy
    @Fitaroy Рік тому +368

    The first thing to note when discussing Unruly: A History of England's Kings and Queens by David Mitchell is an acknowledgement that their era was so completely different from our own that almost all cultural, political and, particularly, business parallels we draw between the two eras are bound, by their very nature, to be wrong.

    • @AnjaliSingh-ks1gf
      @AnjaliSingh-ks1gf Рік тому +53

      SURELY Business Secrets of the Pharaohs is due a reprint?

    • @sethshaffer681
      @sethshaffer681 Рік тому +27

      @@AnjaliSingh-ks1gf My favorite quote " Some say that whipping your slaves 40 times a day works for getting the best results. However, kindness goes a long way and I've found that reducing it to 35 really adds to the production speed of building my pyramid."

    • @bobblehat6603
      @bobblehat6603 Рік тому

      This seems a rather curious comment to post on a History Hit, given that the pyramids were built by elite, skilled artisans, rather than slaves, therefore your favourite quote has absolutely no basis in historical fact.@@sethshaffer681

    • @tessie1033
      @tessie1033 9 місяців тому +1

      😂😂

    • @RonniePickaring
      @RonniePickaring 9 місяців тому +2

      That's elementary.

  • @steffantherock
    @steffantherock Рік тому +140

    A very clever man making history more interesting and easier to understand with his comedy and vast knowledge. David Mitchell is a national treasure.

    • @ripdbtpoo1441
      @ripdbtpoo1441 10 місяців тому +1

      Argh, that boring overused expression again !

  • @howwwwwyyyyy
    @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому +7

    Glad to hear David supporting Harold, the more you learn about him the more impressed you are, tragedy for England his loss

  • @jeffwhitehead7990
    @jeffwhitehead7990 10 місяців тому +21

    “THe Holy Hand Grenade” on the book cover is perfect.

  • @invisibleman4827
    @invisibleman4827 Рік тому +79

    "The standard of conduct is woefully below what we'd expect even of Hollywood."
    Bravo, sir! 😂👏

  • @AK47_ASH
    @AK47_ASH Рік тому +306

    Incredible if only David Mitchell did his own history podcast

    • @Trebor74
      @Trebor74 Рік тому +4

      Please,no

    • @dh7314
      @dh7314 Рік тому +49

      @@Trebor74it wouldn’t be compulsory to listen to it

    • @kaiserjoe2316
      @kaiserjoe2316 Рік тому +4

      Imagine David Mitchell on whizz. I give you Lindybeige.😄

  • @tatlockandfriends
    @tatlockandfriends Рік тому +60

    david is obviously so passionate about this period of history, it's so interesting to listen to his thoughts. thanks for having him on!!

  • @pamjohnson5363
    @pamjohnson5363 4 місяці тому +6

    I am LOVING this discussion with David Mitchell! You both see the greater history, the bigger picture, and say it with such humor and sweeping insightful statements. Wonderful job!

  • @tomwright4969
    @tomwright4969 9 місяців тому +12

    "I'm doing it dad, I'm studying ancient history and there's not a thing you can do about it!!"

  • @nathanthomson1931
    @nathanthomson1931 Рік тому +252

    As a History teacher, I wish I could just conduct my classes like a David Mitchell rant lol. Unfortunately, there are standards and practices and the like 🙄

    • @Prof.Pwnalot
      @Prof.Pwnalot Рік тому +7

      As a History teacher you should take a lot more pride in your conductings than David does.
      His book is a reposting of events, that you can find on most history sites.
      It's nothing new and hardly anything deep delved.
      Plus he just isn't very funny when intellectual.
      You however and speaking on behalf of myself, real fans of history want indepth, accounts, events, and some facts that aren't easy to learn or find.
      David didn't put much effort into his book, historically speaking and especially information wise.
      Comedy wise, king of rants, however time and a place, and despite blowing david out the water, there's a time and a place and he's simply un-engaging
      I'd be fucking pissed if I was a student of yours and you went on a rant.
      I want to learn not fuck around, can do that any other time of the day.
      David lacks intellectual prowess. Being an author when it's mostly reformatted words and copy pasted info exerts is nothing to be proud of / admire.

    • @nathanthomson1931
      @nathanthomson1931 Рік тому +60

      @Prof.Pwnalot omg the rant you just went on because I said I enjoy his style of farcical conversation and said I wish I could teach my classes like that... who asked you!?

    • @CaptainGrimes1
      @CaptainGrimes1 Рік тому +6

      ​@@nathanthomson1931don't be rude

    • @kylehurlburt6114
      @kylehurlburt6114 Рік тому +1

      ​@Prof.Pwnalot I think you suck. So there is plenty of disliking others ranting to go around.

    • @Flooding474
      @Flooding474 Рік тому +8

      @@CaptainGrimes1lol

  • @maartineriksson
    @maartineriksson Рік тому +156

    David's points about the vikings and covid at ~ 1:45 is perfectly on point:
    There is nothing scarier to us humans, than accepting that things just happen for no reason other than coincidence and chance. We always try to build a connection to something else as a reason to it, instead of realizing it just... happened.

    • @vaguelyright6833
      @vaguelyright6833 Рік тому +4

      Shit happens?

    • @beedubree2550
      @beedubree2550 11 місяців тому

      same reason we get conspiracy theories, at least the milder ones like 9/11 or Titanic truthers, I have no idea how people wind up at the "Earth is flat and vaccines will make you a gay communist" stage

    • @kennethlauer4735
      @kennethlauer4735 10 місяців тому +5

      It's even worse when you consider the people advising us through COVID were the ones funding it's research in the first place.

    • @markpower9081
      @markpower9081 10 місяців тому +16

      @@kennethlauer4735 I'd expect health authorities to advise on public health, and also to research it.

    • @monkeydude9192
      @monkeydude9192 9 місяців тому +4

      ​@@markpower9081Research wasn't the best way to say it. Directly and deliberately creating it is much more accurate.

  • @jakewilliamson8807
    @jakewilliamson8807 Рік тому +154

    "They were all right bastards basically" is an amazing opening line

    • @MusikCassette
      @MusikCassette 10 місяців тому +1

      true but Billy the Bastard was an unusual nasty one

    • @livethefuture2492
      @livethefuture2492 9 місяців тому +8

      I love the comparisons to gangsters, cuz in a way that's basically what politics at this time was...

    • @gordondean9189
      @gordondean9189 5 місяців тому +1

      @@livethefuture2492 Some things never change.

    • @kramnam4716
      @kramnam4716 2 місяці тому +1

      Plus ca change

  • @ghostlyamy
    @ghostlyamy Рік тому +23

    10 minutes in and i've already bought the book. david mitchell's writing greatly balances informative and funny

  • @steveshaw6799
    @steveshaw6799 11 місяців тому +6

    What a superb conversation. Thanks Dan and David!

  • @elvisjames
    @elvisjames Рік тому +152

    I'm a 35 y/o African-American listening to this on south beach Miami beach,
    That tickles me

    • @andreaandrea6716
      @andreaandrea6716 11 місяців тому +5

      Wow.

    • @MotionMcAnixx
      @MotionMcAnixx 11 місяців тому +11

      I'm in suburban Sydney reading your comment.

    • @alexanderg1935
      @alexanderg1935 10 місяців тому +24

      This is genuinely one of the coolest comments I've read. I just love the contrast. It's like Miami Vice meets Wolf Hall.

    • @andreaandrea6716
      @andreaandrea6716 10 місяців тому +4

      @@alexanderg1935 Hilarious. And apt!

    • @keepitsteel1993
      @keepitsteel1993 9 місяців тому +4

      You could say this is your.. Miami Vice.
      I'll..get my coat

  • @KairuDeLarge
    @KairuDeLarge Рік тому +26

    I've never clicked on a recommended video so quickly. I love David so much.

  • @Baegitte
    @Baegitte Рік тому +114

    David Mitchell and HH is the collab we never expected, but now always need

    • @samuelgarrod8327
      @samuelgarrod8327 Рік тому +10

      The comment we never needed but always expected.

    • @Baegitte
      @Baegitte Рік тому +2

      @@samuelgarrod8327 lol fair enough

    • @fredhasopinions
      @fredhasopinions Рік тому +1

      ohhh don't make this comment when in germany

    • @rsr789
      @rsr789 Рік тому +1

      @@fredhasopinions Wouldn't that be AH and not HH?

    • @fredhasopinions
      @fredhasopinions Рік тому

      @@rsr789 I was thinking of “Heil…”, but u right

  • @scriven-shafts
    @scriven-shafts 8 місяців тому +22

    I just finished the audiobook, which David narrates himself. It was lovely, I highly recommend it.

  • @d8o8m8
    @d8o8m8 Рік тому +32

    I love his book, Business secrets of the Pharos. It was a challenging read as the text went into the binding.

    • @bruhbruhrza4925
      @bruhbruhrza4925 9 місяців тому +7

      That wasn't his fault, that was a publishing error by British London and they even spelt his name wrong.

  • @johnkitchen4699
    @johnkitchen4699 Рік тому +108

    As an Englishman living in America, where my grandchildren live, I decided to write a poem on the history of England for their ‘education’. The research was transformational as far as my knowledge of the detail was concerned. To my delight, I found Messrs Mitchell and Snow were very much in line with the content of said poem, and in an enjoyable way. I feel this discussion will reinforce their understanding in an entertaining way. Thank you.

    • @Active_Sun_Particles
      @Active_Sun_Particles Рік тому +14

      We, the terra firma English, command you to share this piece.

    • @Mattyboyzie
      @Mattyboyzie Рік тому

      Show us the poem broooo

    • @devyanilimaye8560
      @devyanilimaye8560 Рік тому +1

      Interested to read the piece

    • @gemh89
      @gemh89 Рік тому +2

      Yup, Scot here concurring, out with the poem

    • @alexsilva-vn7jc
      @alexsilva-vn7jc Рік тому

      Could you adopt me as an extra grandchild please?

  • @arliafrink3043
    @arliafrink3043 Рік тому +155

    When David talks of how Henry VIII won at being a king if his goal was to create interesting content, I about died laughing, because I suddenly pictured HRH as a social media influencer creating content 🤣😂 Love David Mitchell's work!

    • @fatbadboy329
      @fatbadboy329 Рік тому +8

      A bit like Trump with the presidency if you think about it, doesn't it?

    • @argusfleibeit1165
      @argusfleibeit1165 Рік тому +13

      @@fatbadboy329 Is that what happened? They elected a content creator, instead of someone who actually cared about trying to properly run the government? Everything was just for "likes", and to attract advertisers? It all make so much more sense now.

    • @ジ金
      @ジ金 11 місяців тому

      HRH is twitter but it keeps banning itself.

    • @Outside85
      @Outside85 3 місяці тому

      And all I am seeing there is that fat guy from South Park at the computer...

    • @signals356
      @signals356 20 днів тому

      I'm imagining a follow up to The King's Speech now, let's call it The King's Tweets. "In the past all a monarch had to do was smile for the cameras and remember the lines for the Christmas speech. This family's been reduced to those lowest, basest of all creatures: we've become influencers. But before we continue, I just want to give a quick shout out to today's sponsor..."

  • @MrChalac
    @MrChalac Рік тому +73

    Awesome! Would love to see more David Mitchell on the channel!

  • @shannab4
    @shannab4 9 місяців тому +4

    What a great conversation. David Mitchel has been inside my brain. I’m in American with an obsession for English history. It’s better than any Game of Thrones series. I agree with almost everything he said

  • @laurabrowning7973
    @laurabrowning7973 2 місяці тому +2

    This was so enjoyable and informative! PLEASE have David Mitchell back for more discussions!!

  • @thetinmanify
    @thetinmanify Рік тому +20

    Finally a Business Secrets of the Pharaohs interview!

  • @AJC508
    @AJC508 Рік тому +45

    I live quite near to Château Gaillard (Les Andelys, France … look it up). To think that this was the place that the balance of power in Europe shifted forever, and to be able to visit it still, is fabulous. The village where I live actually used to be Norman territory and there is a marker stone for the boundary between France and old Normandy about 7k from here. History, when made interesting, never goes away.

    • @xenotypos
      @xenotypos Рік тому

      Technically, Normandy was always inside the kingdom of France, so I assume it was the limit between Normandy and the domain controlled by the king. France was a heavily decentralized kingdom, so many duchies, counties etc... were at some point or another de facto independent. But not de jure.

  • @PokhrajRoy.
    @PokhrajRoy. Рік тому +39

    Congratulations to David on his new book! 🎉

  • @danbev8542
    @danbev8542 25 днів тому +1

    His book is good! David reads it for the audio version. Highly recommend. Thanks for this interview!

  • @CeasarJames
    @CeasarJames Рік тому +1

    Dan Snow is so knowledgeable and is a legitimate historian and a pleasure to listen to ❤️👊🏼

    • @howwwwwyyyyy
      @howwwwwyyyyy Рік тому

      He's a bit taken aback by Davids knowledge, Emma of Normandy etc

  • @yohojones
    @yohojones Рік тому +48

    Love David! I hope he contributes more to History Hit.

  • @PokhrajRoy.
    @PokhrajRoy. Рік тому +66

    Omg both of them are such a delight 👏🏽
    P.S. What an interesting Tier Ranking video.

    • @vonvard
      @vonvard Рік тому +3

      Two absolute Gents. I feel blessed watching this

    • @piccalillipit9211
      @piccalillipit9211 Рік тому

      I cant stand Dan Snow. Married the Duke of Westminster's daughter and used her money to dominate and crowd out the historical UA-cam and Podcast arena whilst making a massive loss until everyone either went bust or worked for him. Leaving him to clean up.

  • @kateliias1838
    @kateliias1838 Рік тому +27

    What a fun video! Loved listening to these two. I feel like I learned more from them in this little video than I have in other long form documentaries.

  • @MTMMoonlight
    @MTMMoonlight Рік тому +3

    I love this type of format, no BS just a great convocation!

  • @nichollelindner
    @nichollelindner Рік тому +43

    Wonderful to hear David Mitchell talk about British history and the resulting politics. Loved his hilarious show “Ambassadors” and wish he’d do more episodes. 😂

    • @Outside85
      @Outside85 3 місяці тому

      David is really good at these kinds of things because he doesn't sugarcoat or gloss over that some of the most important people in history were just a bunch of bastards.

  • @JohnDoe-px4ko
    @JohnDoe-px4ko Рік тому +86

    Totally agree with David about the Normans and the Tudors.

    • @rickrudd
      @rickrudd Рік тому +7

      I think Henry VII's life was nothing short of amazing. Never knew a moment's peace.

    • @balabanasireti
      @balabanasireti Рік тому

      Cool, that means that I don't care about you either

  • @mitzloo1933
    @mitzloo1933 Рік тому +110

    I'm not sure I ever felt more simpatico with a character than I did with Mark Corrigan. I would have loved to hear Mitchell's take on Richard III, but this was delightful!

    • @kurtmac
      @kurtmac Рік тому +4

      Well considering that Richard III reigned for only two years, barely a footnote when it comes to English monarchs, but we should be grateful to him for being so awful that he ushered in the House of Tudor!

    • @margo3367
      @margo3367 Рік тому +2

      I was waiting to hear about him too.

    • @ImpossiblePinwheel
      @ImpossiblePinwheel Рік тому +16

      Simpatico normalo or simpatico maximus?

    • @jmwilliamsart
      @jmwilliamsart Рік тому +22

      @@kurtmacRichard III probably wasn’t as horrible as the Tudors would have us believe.

    • @guyharandonmusic
      @guyharandonmusic Рік тому +20

      @@jmwilliamsart True, he lowered taxes massively and wanted to intoduce equal education throughout the country. The Tudors definitely did him dirty!

  • @SecondSince
    @SecondSince Місяць тому +1

    Anything with David Mitchell is incredible! The wit of that man!

  • @katfromthekong414
    @katfromthekong414 11 місяців тому +39

    "It used to be vikings, now it's sewage." 😂😂
    I love how David Mitchell's mind works!

  • @conwaysmith9167
    @conwaysmith9167 Рік тому +11

    Its always a pleasure when two different public personalities who I follow for very different reasons do collaborations together. Great video!

  • @harrisonrawlinson5650
    @harrisonrawlinson5650 Рік тому +34

    I recently went to the Bayeux tapestry and it was very interesting to see the Norman perspective of Harold Godwinson compared to what I’d always heard about him. Then I went to Battle a few days later and seeing the perspective in an English museum was a stark contrast. I think that’s part of what makes history so interesting

    • @patwaddington
      @patwaddington 2 місяці тому

      Yeah I went to the bayeux tapestry last year around June. Was absolutely amazing. wanted to get a beach towel in the gift shop and it was the only thing they didn’t have 😂

    • @harrisonrawlinson5650
      @harrisonrawlinson5650 2 місяці тому

      @@patwaddington ahaha, I got a mug

  • @mohammedosman4902
    @mohammedosman4902 Рік тому +18

    this is a great discussion. I love both David Mitchell and Dan Snow

  • @reppinTV
    @reppinTV Рік тому +3

    Would love to see more of David and Dan just talking about history

  • @livethefuture2492
    @livethefuture2492 9 місяців тому +2

    This was endlessly entertaining! I would love to see a talk show just about 2 men cracking jokes nerding out about history like this! 😅

  • @dreamcrusher112
    @dreamcrusher112 Рік тому +20

    All good and reminded me that I am actually a historian. Emma's words are recorded through the Encomium published for her after her time in exile, designed to legitimise Edward and Harthacnut while delegitimising Harefoot who was king before, and had killed one of her sons already. It is an excellent source and I wrote extensively using it at Univeristy. A great primary source.

  • @adam_p99
    @adam_p99 Рік тому +36

    What a great mix, the viewpoint of this brilliantly funny mind and British history. More please!!

  • @Sue474
    @Sue474 Рік тому +7

    I'm reading "Unruly" at the moment. Thoroughly enjoying it, as it combines my two favourite things, which are history and humour.

  • @brianferguson7840
    @brianferguson7840 Рік тому +6

    Every year hundreds of people visit Agincourt where I live asking where the battle field is.
    Only to be told it is 300 kilomètres away in Azingcourt. One of the most oft repeated spelling errors in history.
    Azincourt is near Etaples, near the coast (where the battle was) Agincourt is in the Mosell near Nancy

  • @obscurazone
    @obscurazone Рік тому +7

    More of this please! A perfect duo! Can we have a series, thanks.

  • @andrewclayton4181
    @andrewclayton4181 Рік тому +24

    That was Brilliant. I think David must have read the same books as I have, his opinions mesh with mine perfectly. The only difference is he is articulate enough to express them in a coherent way. His new book is definitely top of my Christmas list this year.

  • @klackon1
    @klackon1 Рік тому +30

    Surely Athelstan was the first recognised King of the English. He gave the combined Welsh, Irish, Scots and Viking armies a good kicking and was recognised both in England and continental Europe as King of the English. He was a much revered king, both at home and abroad.

    • @andremaines
      @andremaines Рік тому

      What about King Arthur

    • @-Blackberry
      @-Blackberry Рік тому +10

      @andremaines King Arthur was a legendary King of the Britons, following the depature of the Roman empire he fought against the Anglo-Saxon incursion, those who would become the English. So he is very much not an English king. Ironically and to confuse a lot English kings latched onto the legend because Arthurian stories were all the rage in the middle ages so everyone wanted to 'own' King Arthur.

    • @nadialittle5821
      @nadialittle5821 Рік тому +1

      THIS!!!!!!!

    • @tomben6180
      @tomben6180 Рік тому +3

      @@andremainesdidn’t exist and wasn’t English anyway

    • @tomben6180
      @tomben6180 Рік тому +1

      If we can’t have Alfred, Athelstan is mine.

  • @SunnyBeetle1922
    @SunnyBeetle1922 Рік тому +6

    What a fantastic and fascinating look inside the mind of David Mitchell!!!… I hope to hear his new book ‘unruly’ on audio as I love to listen to books while sowing , solo walks and pottering around the house and it’s also great to listen to when winding down at the end of the day!!!… Can’t wait to hear/ read David’s work!!!

  • @wearwolf2500
    @wearwolf2500 Рік тому +1

    I like how much fun these two seem to be having with this conversation.

  • @annaclarke7643
    @annaclarke7643 Рік тому +2

    I thoroughly enjoyed this conversation. Please do something like this again.

  • @sherrylandrum7901
    @sherrylandrum7901 Рік тому +32

    I feel like I’m watching an Anglo Saxon and a Viking talk to one another about their mutual past. Great conversation and very informative. Thanks!

  • @tonisiret5557
    @tonisiret5557 Рік тому +57

    David could do documentaries as well as Starkey, Wood, Robinson & Snow. Let him come forth! 👏🏼

    • @coloneljackmustard
      @coloneljackmustard Рік тому +3

      And don't forget the Jew Schama!

    • @RalphBrooker-gn9iv
      @RalphBrooker-gn9iv Рік тому

      Like an angelic horde :)

    • @parkerbrown-nesbit1747
      @parkerbrown-nesbit1747 Рік тому +5

      ​@@coloneljackmustardwhat does Schama's being Jewish have to do with his writing?

    • @Murdo2112
      @Murdo2112 Рік тому +1

      @@parkerbrown-nesbit1747 Coloneljackmustard is probably Starkey's secret youtube account.

    • @tommerker8063
      @tommerker8063 Рік тому

      he could read the phone book and it would still be hilarious

  • @ineffablemars
    @ineffablemars Рік тому +5

    It’s really nice listening to david talk about things he clearly loves. I feel that way whenever listening to anyone talk about things they’re interested in.

  • @Poinatowski
    @Poinatowski 9 місяців тому +10

    As a 24 yr old chap, For some reason Im also fascinated by history, always have been. I dont study it or teach it or anything. Always just independantly absorbed A ton of historical Knowledge in my own time. This mini podcast was fantastic though, love this channel keep up the grand work! :)

  • @fathertedczynski
    @fathertedczynski Рік тому +8

    I'd love to hear more from David about Alfred the Great, he's one of the greatest rulers with a good underdog story that doesn't involve expansion into France

    • @lunaholiday8585
      @lunaholiday8585 Рік тому +2

      I was hoping for Alfred as well.

    • @myamdane6895
      @myamdane6895 Рік тому +1

      Well let's not credit him for not expanding into France as the English claim to France did not yet exist

  • @yourmammu
    @yourmammu Рік тому +58

    Elizabeth I is the most interesting monarch for me and arguably the most effective there is. Imagine, being an unmarried woman, ruling a nation in the 16th century successfully, staying into power for a staggering 45 years and drag a kingdom from being a nobody to a worldwide powerhouse. Also her talent of collecting very competent and brilliant men to run the nation with her and protect her is also remarkable. She may not been a saint at all but let's face it, the world would've been soooo different if she have not ruled. She wasn't just a fantastic monarch, she was also a well-skilled and great-minded politician.

    • @octavianpopescu4776
      @octavianpopescu4776 Рік тому +15

      Honestly, I agree with them: she is overrated. She was an extremely unpleasant person (e.g. what she did to Lady Katherine Grey showed how cruel, petty and vain she could be or what she did to the sailors after 1588 or how she lied about the English Counter-Armada which failed miserably, but conveniently no one talks about that). She governed based on her mood and I think the stability of the period is owed more to people like Cecil who had the skill to balance her randomness. I don't think she collected the competent people, as much as she got lucky. Monarchs didn't really have much of a choice who the nobility were. This is something her sister Mary discovered on day 1. She had to work with people who had declared her a bastard, but that was the nobility of the realm, that was who she had to work with.
      The people who turned England into a powerhouse were the Stuarts, not the Tudors. When she died, England had exactly 0 colonies. It was the Stuarts who started accruing territory with the first colonies in North America. Plus, she didn't start the exploration bit either... Edward VI and Mary I also promoted exploration, but again that is forgotten. However the Stuarts weren't as popular and so, a legend was built around Elizabeth, a legend which is basically a big lie. She was good, but not that good.

    • @debse.7286
      @debse.7286 Рік тому +10

      @octavianpopescu4776 I think people say Elizabeth was changeable because she constantly changed her mind about suitors. Well of course she did. What else could she do? She knew it was really dangerous to get married. Look at how marriage turned out for every royal woman around her. But her court would accept a straight refusal. So she pretended and made excuses. As a woman the men around her would not accept straight commands. So she had to fight to do anything and use guile. It was incredible she even survived. She brought relative peace in a time of conflict.

    • @octavianpopescu4776
      @octavianpopescu4776 Рік тому +4

      @@debse.7286 No, it wasn't just about suitors, she did it with a lot of other policies. People focus too much on her staying unmarried... I get that part for herself... speaking of which: why wouldn't she allow others to get married? Even her best friend, the Earl of Leicester married in secret. There was an entire epidemic of secret marriages, because she imposed her "Don't get married" policy on others. It wasn't just for herself. As for peace... the war that included the Spanish Armada episode lasted about 20 years and only ended after her death in a draw...
      And she failed in her most important duty: assuring the succession. Fact is, she never said who was her heir, she kept postponing it. You know what happened? After her death, the Council simply called the King of Scotland... they did it on their own. It was basically a coup that brought the Stuarts to power, because it wasn't grounded on any law. In fact, they broke some laws. The Council avoided a civil war then and cleaned up after her.

    • @balabanasireti
      @balabanasireti Рік тому +1

      ​@@octavianpopescu4776Nah

    • @debse.7286
      @debse.7286 Рік тому +1

      @@octavianpopescu4776 I bet she thought if she said James was her heir, the courtiers would stop listening to her. Was there an alternative Protestant heir? I have not heard of one. I guess it was kind of embarrassing to say Mary Queen of Scots was the legitimate heir after killing her.

  • @pmuk4
    @pmuk4 Рік тому +7

    love David's enthusiasm for the subject, bought the audio book of this interview alone!

  • @barbarabaker3056
    @barbarabaker3056 Рік тому +11

    Very interesting and enjoyable. I liked the mentioning of Athelstan, Edward the Elder and Emma. They are too often overlooked.

  • @xedwyn6244
    @xedwyn6244 Рік тому +4

    I’d love him to write a book someday on the rulers of Ancient Egypt and any cultural, political, and especially business parallels with our own era.

  • @headerahelix
    @headerahelix 5 місяців тому +1

    I'm so happy I found this channel, it's criminal it's not more popular.

  • @skiker4560
    @skiker4560 Рік тому +53

    Favorite Ranting Comedian ☑️
    History Hit ☑️
    Sarcasm - Comedy - History ☑️
    ❤❤❤ ☑️

  • @Scraggledust
    @Scraggledust Рік тому +5

    Always enjoy the discourse and always learn a tidbit I haven’t heard before❤ literally taking photos of the monarch butterfly while listening to a discussion about monarchs 👑 🦋 Ty and all have a weekend that’s above average 😉

  • @robmartin525
    @robmartin525 Рік тому +46

    Did anyone else have a brain stutter when they said Elizabeth the Second?
    I have been programmed to say 'The Queen' all my life!
    That's history for you! And that's why I like it!

    • @DodderingOldMan
      @DodderingOldMan Рік тому +8

      I wasn't properly listening and my brain just assumed they meant Elizabeth I. So the rest of that section didn't make as much sense :P

    • @Thought_Processing_
      @Thought_Processing_ Рік тому +2

      Not really whenever someone said ‘the Queen’ I just added Elizabeth the second subconsciously.
      Similarly I think ‘the King’ Charles the third.

    • @TesterAnimal1
      @TesterAnimal1 Рік тому

      @@Thought_Processing_same. Other monarchs do exist in the world.

    • @junbh2
      @junbh2 Рік тому

      I didn't realise it was that queen until you said so.

    • @alexanderg1935
      @alexanderg1935 10 місяців тому

      Yeah I got mixed up and thought of Elizabeth I. As as result I took offense to the comment that her job was just to stand around holding flowers and being nice. I should have listened properly.

  • @matthewwalker5430
    @matthewwalker5430 Рік тому +14

    Am I the only 1 who has a sneaky suspicion that Edgar Aetheling had some sort of hand in William II's "unfortunate accident"? Edgar is SUCH an interesting guy and he really needs his own book in my view. Despite losing his birthright once the Norman's invaded he somehow managed to keep himself around and influencing history in the background. He was the one who appears to have encouraged Robert Curthose to rebel and, once Robert failed, Edgar somehow manages to keep himself around and continue meddling, whether it is by going up to Scotland where he is responsible for putting a King on the throne or by encouraging mischief in England. He vanishes off to the continent almost perfectly in time with William II's "accident" and then joins the First Crusade where he remains highly influential, potentially also serving in the Varangian Guard. It's amazing that Edgar then returns to England and encouraged Robert Curthose to rise against Henry I and Henry imprisons his brother yet pardons Edgar ... could that perhaps be because Henry felt he owed Edgar in some way for what happened to William that ultimately put Henry on the throne? (I know that Henry had married Edgar's niece by then and people give that as a reason for his pardon, but honestly, she was only his niece and I don't think that would have bothered Henry 1 bit - Curthose was Henry's actual brother!). I don't think he actually wanted to be King, but I think Edgar would have made an excellent King of England in that time. He certainly seems to have known how to play politics, how to win people over and how to stay relevant and despite living through some of the most turbulent times in our history, despite going on the First Crusade, Edgar died in England of old age. It's sacrilege that more people do not know of his exploits today

    • @onsitehistory228
      @onsitehistory228 Рік тому

      Great comment 😊

    • @meth4163
      @meth4163 10 місяців тому

      THIS. Edgar Atheling was the true claimant to the throne and deserved it imo.

    • @perniciouspete4986
      @perniciouspete4986 8 місяців тому

      I refuse to read the above--too damned long.

    • @matthewwalker5430
      @matthewwalker5430 8 місяців тому +4

      Why chose to reply to a comment to notify everyone that you won't read it? I could even call you pernicious ... oh, wait, you got me

  • @pegm5937
    @pegm5937 2 місяці тому +1

    2 minutes in and I'm already muttering "brilliant analogy of COVID and the Vikings!" Love ❤ David Mitchell's humour and writing so much. His book "Unruly" became an instant favourite of mine.

  • @pureroadie
    @pureroadie Рік тому +6

    still love his first book "Business secrets of the Pharaohs"

  • @FCGroningen1987
    @FCGroningen1987 Рік тому +9

    I'd nominate Henry VII. I'd agree that the Tudors are generally overrated, but he not only managed to get the throne against bad odds, but also managed to secure his line of succession. He used art and literature wisely, managed to quell all uprisings to his realm and left a full treasury. There's not many kings that managed to both leave England financially secure and leave a clear line of succession. Failing the latter often ended in disaster. Henry II not being able to control his family led to the eventual downfall of the Angevin Kingdom. For the same reason I'd not put Henry I in a top spot either.

  • @leemarlin9415
    @leemarlin9415 Рік тому +11

    Very nice to see David again. I am an American but really enjoyed all the panel shows he used to be on. Very sensible intelligent man. You can tell that by the quality of the lady he married.

    • @junbh2
      @junbh2 Рік тому +2

      He's still on panel shows.

    • @ericadunn9435
      @ericadunn9435 9 місяців тому

      I could not care less about his wife. David Mitchell is interesting because he's David Mitchell.

  • @KseniaSotnikova
    @KseniaSotnikova 8 місяців тому +1

    Edward IV is totally underrated. He was also 6'3 and famously handsome. His portrait shows he at least had Robert Pattinson's jawline.

  • @ShastaMcYpes
    @ShastaMcYpes 10 місяців тому +2

    It’s so bizarre because all through the pandemic I kept coming back to the Vikings as a similar historical moment. To hear him say it is such an eerie coincidence

  • @Arkantos117
    @Arkantos117 Рік тому +12

    Alfred the Great certainly earned his moniker.

  • @doggowoof3411
    @doggowoof3411 Рік тому +5

    I got the book recently just cause of the cover and the fact it was written by David Mitchell. Happy I did it's really good I am not much of a history buff but this has got me interested. I hope he writes more

  • @Dzokhar
    @Dzokhar Рік тому +8

    I'm sorry, are you telling me Dan Snow and David Mitchell are going to slag off history for half an hour? Because I'm so here for it.

  • @EvelyntMild
    @EvelyntMild 8 місяців тому +1

    "Sometimes a bit of history just happens to you." David Mitchell. ❤

  • @dh7314
    @dh7314 Рік тому +7

    This is genuinely amazing. This would be an excellent spin-off podcast

  • @christinepage181
    @christinepage181 10 місяців тому +5

    I have seen another side of David Mitchell, I have now got an enormous respect for him, he has made that history lesson so interesting, he should have been a history teacher. If I had had a teacher like him, I would have found history so much more interesting.