If your like of him is based on the case that is in court your like of him is premature the case is not concluded unless if you say you like him because he can speak english and afrikaans equal big up to you and him as for the case in court I doubt him so many witnesses as if Senzo was killed in police academy.
If you have a law degree and you were properly trained on criminal law and the law of evidence there is no way you can conclude that the accused are not guilty.
Thank you🙏🏽at least we have one of those few competent fellas with massive insight 👏🏿👏🏿….this case has purely proved to us that the average population is way below average …🤞🏽
Ratha you are the best Judge and doing an excellent job.The issue here is that people want you to declare the accused as innocent, and that will never happen because they killed Senzo.Their fans are calling you bias etc because they can't accept facts presented in court.
True people are poisoned 🤢 with the idea that the judge is biased because they are people who made their story on what happened in that house of mama Kelly Instead of listening 👂 very closely on what the proceedings have
this Natis evidence was clearly not in the Pre-trial if the affidavit is from September 2023. what was the point of Ratha asking if they had a pre-trial or not? Mnisi already said that this is a trial by ambush, the investigation is ongoing as we are on trial. I have a strong feeling that if the trial drags till next year, there will be affidavits made in 2025.
This is very relevant coz the accused initially claimed not to know each other..this evidence also proves that Sibiya lied that he was in KZN and was never in Gauteng for the whole of 2014.. if there is nothing to hide, why would one lie about his location
You really need to get the story correct. Legal Aid appointed Ramos for accused 1&2. Mngo was called only for Trial within a Trial. Legal aid didnt appoint him for the main trial as such they are not in position to pay him. Family of accused 1 fired Ramos and appoint Mngo hence they should be the ones to pay him as a private lawyer.
@@ndabezitha1000: You are spot on. Just like a subcontractor demanding payment from the client, the subcontractor has no relationship with the client but with the company/person who hired them
@ndabezitha1000 I was literally asking a question, based on Mngo's statement. I did not make utterances as a matter of fact. Now, what you could have done, is respond to the question respectfully without the "get your story straight". What story am I not getting straight when I am literally asking a question, in order to get more information because Mngo's statement did not provide more details. Go flex your muscle elsewhere. Better yet, type out your own comments instead of adding rude replies to other people's comments.
My concern is that the state has so many officers to testify in the senzo meyiwa case against the people who where in the house when meyiwa was shot😂😂😂😂....... If this judge was honourable as he claim to be....that alone should be questioned
That simple shows that Gininda did his job and beyond he did not rely on the confessions alone he continued to invistigate even after, he closing all the loop holes
@nontuthuzelombuthuma5864 shouldn't those in the house be called, your Kelly, your Longwe even the mother? Where are they instead it's police after police covering for one another while the most important are nowhere to be seen
Any evidence from any department brought forward by investigation officer that can assist in resolving the case is necessary. Natis is here to clarify some issues. This Baloyi Prosecutor is a genius. The defence should learn from him❤❤
It actually proves that A1 lied about his whereabouts and now natis is placing him in the province of crime wow wow wow geez funny how the things we do can later harm us.
@@polarloads9084the person who lied in court is Mpimpi Zungu, who testified that he was with the accused @Basothong hostel, showing off his gun to the accused on the day Senzo was killed.
That apology was genuine not because he was forced to apologize but because he wanted to. He could've spinned it and said he said "some black lawyers" not all black lawyers
U now live in his head and brains what a shame. You misconstrue this man listen to the court proceedings and forget about the rest u will not change anything agreed in this court
The apology tendered by Mokgoathleng J today was a sign of bravery....In S v Dalindyebo 1980 (Case of the father of the current abaThembu King Buyelekhaya) Munick CJ in Transkei High Court (as it then was) said "To stand up and apologise to a person you have wronged is a sign of bravery as opposed to cowardice" and i embrace that remark...22/3/2024
This is a gross irregularity.Baloyi is giving evidence under the pretext that he is just giving some background about what the witness will come and testify.This cannot be allowed.I am shocked the judge is not putting a stop to this.The defence are also sitting on their laurels and not objecting.
I hope you can listen and wait for the judge. Don't come in conclusions, because you are going to mislead us as a community. With all due diligence please sir🙏🏽.
u a very right, was that necessary for him to go through the witness profile experience hence the witness is sitting in a witness box😮 nevertheless we are watching, listen and comment of cause.
Strong case presented by state 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿competent work by sharp police officers cracking this case against ALL ODDS and marvellous prosecution and super brilliant ,top judge handling this case .will definitely see justice for Senzo 🤞🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽…..
They don't ask the way he want he want them to put to witnesses that they are lying mara bona they debate. If you remember ka trial within a trial he also mentioned that no one canvassed something I can't remember. From now on they must not ask many questions only 2 questions somaar you put it to the Witnesses that u lie.
Baloyi is a Giant after each day he goes and read transcripts, case laws and rulings. So when he opens his mouth or objections he is as smart as a judge. He is a future judge and I can't say the same for the defence. Objections are baseless and they can't quote any law to overule Dr Baloyi
@@user-bz7vt6gm6oThey are guilty shem bona and evidence already showed accused number 3 with dreadlocks ,gold tooth and 9mm parabellum belonging to Mncube s the murder weapon .This evidence rebut the one of Mshololo that because the number of accused number 5 not being rica'd in his name doesn't prove it belongs to him .Today it's proven it's his and steyn proved Kelly was phoned by this number umbuzo uthi why communicate with Nkabiz ?Allegedly
Mnisi must wake up from his slumber and lisen to the evidence. It is such objections that make the judge to behave the way he does towards tbe defence Counsel.
The black lawyers association must meet you not with regards to the merits of the case but your unfortunate utterances about black legal professional's etc. of which I believe the judge thinks he is some color. Your apology is void of genuineness, you being involved in BLA does not make you a "LORD", personally as a lay person I don't accept your apology.
Bonke laba abathuka iJaji noBaloyi ngezinhlamba bethi bayabheda kodwa bona banezitifiketi zokuzalwa neze vaccine kuphela batshela abantu abama Honors and Masters. Usuke unhloboni yesidomu ngampela🙆. Ay impela, lack of education is the root of all evil🖐
Nam nginese vaccine ne death certificate kuphela but umbhedo ngumbhedo, even a fool can see how these 2 behave, and how this case was fabricated. We expect to hear eyewitnesses not these suspects.
guys lets learn to agree in order to disagree,this platform is forbid to share views ,and analysis of this meyiwa case,we are all right in our own way,so lets not lets not insults our IQ's pls
Baloyi always playing games and judge will defend him which is no longer a fair trial Mnisi never receiced this documents and Ramosepele only received one affidavit not second one...Always new evidence accepted in during trial
Mna i dont know if im a bit late to study to be a lawyet. In our comments we were saying police are corrupt, lazy, incompetent, uneducated, most popular one-not make sure, same go for nurses but when Ratha comments about incompetence of some black lawyers, which is true at times, we hammered him left right and centre. Im just saying
He was approached by Ramasopele and now the very same Rama is now nasty against Mngomezulu 😢😢he didn't even want to stand in for him while he was not in court on Wednesday 😢😢😢all of a sudden he said he can't because Mngomezulu is more experience 😮😮😮 what a lame excuse 😢😢 🤬 some of them now so against Mngomezulu 💔💔💔💔💔
@@SylviaMitchell-tz2sldidn't even acknowledge that the man did speak to him in the presence of others who also denied any knowledge. What is all this?
I like Ratha, he's not intimidated by anyone. This BLA must just get over it, they must stop being dramatic. Ratha was specially directing the comments to Mngomezulu.
What I can say this system can be updated at any given time by someone who has an excess, especially on Cellphones numbers and addresses. What if it was updated after the cellphone expect testimony? AboGininda ayi ngeke.
I'm working on these types of systems. It is true it can be updated however every change will show date,time and user that made changes. Why do people want to protect these killers that are implicated in so many cases. I believe Baloyi his duty is to bring every evidence before the judge to proof that these people were involved in the killing. People are dwelling on the fact that they were tortured do you think if inkabi can be romanced to give out information. I am still shocked that we can fight people against wrong doing in the name of protecting inkabi unbelievable.
Lol he probably wanted to even say the same black lawyers association I started now wants a meeting with me on the constitution I created how bizarre is that lol
Thi case was supposed to be concluded before the death of mr meyiwa (senior)but because south africa like to play with money it is taking long to be finished because wrong people are in the dock.
But the calling out of Accussed persons IDENTITY NUMBERS I doubt it's the correct procedure, that includes the codes/number for the DLTC employees....... POPIA
Am glad BLACK LAWYERS ASSOCIATION aint happy about that athritis mokoupere's utterances 🤮🤮Germany and Botswana doesnt accept that stinking rude justifying apology🫷🏿
@@timothytshepothobane915 thats the thing aggg he even read it whats that it should come from within his heart meaning it we dont buy that nonsense of apology
But HJ was saying Y mngomezulu to fone HJ,I think DJP, JP JC & JSC must intervene,the trial is already unfair & unConstitutional, the defence may represent their clients in that meeting with BLA,of which some of these defence team might belong to JSC,doesn't mean that if u r founder of BLA u must disrespect us
This witness is a very crucial witness. He proved the phone numbers each accused had and their locations too rebuke the defence they pulled against Zungu.Mshololo said the number of the was not proven under rica to be his manje this guy under Natis proved number+polo belonged to accused 5 and now section 205s are ready phone downloads for accused number 1,2,4,5's phone will be in court 🎉🎉🎉.Defence will object the whole day 😂😂😂
I know of people who go to different provinces to do their licenses.... it happens. this doesn’t mean he was living there, he could have just gone there to apply for a learners since he lived in JHB before. The evidence we need are people from his family, people he lived with or worked for. this learners booking is not substantial evidence that he lived there. Come on.
This evidence is adduced because he says he has NEVER been to JHB during the time in question which is why this evidence is adduced to rebut his version. People are generally forgetful but electronic data remains the same. Accused one and two have a hand in the death of senzo
@@hopemajoe2577 But having been in JHB for a learners test/drivers license does not prove that he was living in JHB. And to my recollection, accused 1 said he was not residing in JHB in 2014, which could still be true even with this evidence. I still don't see how they had a hand in the death of Senzo from the evidence presented to us, unless you know of other evidence that is still to come. Their DNA was not in the house, the descriptions were not of them, Accused 1 and 2 never had dreads and no gold teeth or tattoos, the gun had none of their DNA or prints, the bullet that Senzo was allegedly killed with had no blood or DNA on it so I don't see how any of the current evidence has anything to do with these guys, whether they remember where they were or not. for some reason just because they can't remember where they were in 2014 on of Senzo's demise, then they did it? even if there is no evidence of them doing it? did you hear their alleged confessions? even those don't align. Remember you can't look at 1 piece of evidence and conclude. its a puzzle with many pieces that must fit to make a coherent picture.
I don’t think his apology is genuine. He should acknowledge that his utterances were inappropriate and unprofessional. It shouldn’t be “if I have offended…). I still sense his arrogance.
If this ratha mkhulu is thinking about constitutional rights of the accused when he must meet with BLA but didn't think of those constitutional rights when Sibiya and Ntanzi told him they were never read their rights when arrested and they were abused by the police and mkhulu ratha went ahead and admitted those confessions who were obtained illegally... Wow ratha you don't seem to amaze SA🤨🤬
Why did they refused to pay him after all this time. Hes a bread winner, he has family to support😢. How do they expect him to survive. Are they botcoating him the way they did Tefo😢
The Judge must focus on the case not venture into political space-he has a tendency to sleep walk into politics-last time he talked about parliamentarians. This old man is not the right judge for this case
I'm just watching the case, tjo Rata wa nanatha he needs to be thought ethics, respect for others and stop telling us about his life history, bo judge Mogweng ba kena kae 🤷🤷🤷
Case closed without the murderers? How are the people in the house will be linked in the murder as they were also in shock except KK. They can't even arrest KK without the 5 nkabis.
How could he have done so as i believe he was in jail unless he was on bail....one must remember that he was arrested on the 9th Feb 2015....in Cleveland case...22/3/2024
Enatis it's cannot taken as proof, because the system can be easely maltipulated. There is alleged corraptions of person doing appointments without even been in tasting station. No caranty of what the officer will be outline
We can try to defend these guys but they're guilty. Evidence is against them. Ntuli choosing to be the State witness now, says a lot. Ntanzi should've taken the state offer and by now he'd be home like Zungu, instead of being someone's enemy because he confessed
Just wait Baloyi is exposing the lies of this two boys Ntanzi and Sibiya. He said when Senzo was killed he was at home Kwa Nongoma.Todays evidence shows he was writing his learners in Branson using Basotho Hostel address
@@robertnheta1935The state has enough evidence.. Next week they are bringing back that cellphone expert. Kuzoba lit because cellphone records shows Sibiya was communicating with Kelly and Umkhulu the Inyanga
@@gladysmkhize4085 They is no valid evidence in this court just a cooked stories. The brother of the late Senzo Meyiwa. His the one who said "Kudlalwa ngalabafethu, abambulalanga uSenzo. This is a fictional story
So if they themselves are telling you that they are involved in this and that they were ordered to kill senzo by Kelly, you still deny that they did it?
Adv Baloyi 🙌 a true definition of black excellence.……As an aspirant prosecutor I look up to you!
We are doomed mos with people clueless as you anyone will be sentenced just to convict
Same sentiment 🙌🏽 Adv Baloyi knows what he's doing
If you can be like Mr Baloyi, our Soouth Africa will be a better place where laws and justice is followed, big up to you
You will make an excellent Court official.
If your like of him is based on the case that is in court your like of him is premature the case is not concluded unless if you say you like him because he can speak english and afrikaans equal big up to you and him as for the case in court I doubt him so many witnesses as if Senzo was killed in police academy.
If you have a law degree and you were properly trained on criminal law and the law of evidence there is no way you can conclude that the accused are not guilty.
True
True
Thank you🙏🏽at least we have one of those few competent fellas with massive insight 👏🏿👏🏿….this case has purely proved to us that the average population is way below average …🤞🏽
I salute you
That bull
Ratha you are the best Judge and doing an excellent job.The issue here is that people want you to declare the accused as innocent, and that will never happen because they killed Senzo.Their fans are calling you bias etc because they can't accept facts presented in court.
Exactly
True people are poisoned 🤢 with the idea that the judge is biased because they are people who made their story on what happened in that house of mama Kelly
Instead of listening 👂 very closely on what the proceedings have
Thats very true
this Natis evidence was clearly not in the Pre-trial if the affidavit is from September 2023. what was the point of Ratha asking if they had a pre-trial or not? Mnisi already said that this is a trial by ambush, the investigation is ongoing as we are on trial. I have a strong feeling that if the trial drags till next year, there will be affidavits made in 2025.
What was the reason for this ENATIS evidence?
This is very relevant coz the accused initially claimed not to know each other..this evidence also proves that Sibiya lied that he was in KZN and was never in Gauteng for the whole of 2014.. if there is nothing to hide, why would one lie about his location
When did ntanza say he was not in Gauteng the whole of 2014 or lies is thing?
I like u ,u are Wise I can hear from your commnt
@@sctv8809he said Sibiya. U ppl seem to be obsessed with Ntanzi🤞
True
Sibiya not ntanzi... I don't where you see ntanzi in this comment
Why is Mngo not getting paid. How is anyone expected to work and serve their client, without payment for 5 months.
You really need to get the story correct. Legal Aid appointed Ramos for accused 1&2. Mngo was called only for Trial within a Trial. Legal aid didnt appoint him for the main trial as such they are not in position to pay him. Family of accused 1 fired Ramos and appoint Mngo hence they should be the ones to pay him as a private lawyer.
@@ndabezitha1000: You are spot on. Just like a subcontractor demanding payment from the client, the subcontractor has no relationship with the client but with the company/person who hired them
@ndabezitha1000 I was literally asking a question, based on Mngo's statement. I did not make utterances as a matter of fact. Now, what you could have done, is respond to the question respectfully without the "get your story straight". What story am I not getting straight when I am literally asking a question, in order to get more information because Mngo's statement did not provide more details.
Go flex your muscle elsewhere. Better yet, type out your own comments instead of adding rude replies to other people's comments.
@@ndabezitha1000 I was also not read any further replies from you. I will not entertain idiots who have misplaced superiority complexes.
Go ask him
My concern is that the state has so many officers to testify in the senzo meyiwa case against the people who where in the house when meyiwa was shot😂😂😂😂.......
If this judge was honourable as he claim to be....that alone should be questioned
That simple shows that Gininda did his job and beyond he did not rely on the confessions alone he continued to invistigate even after, he closing all the loop holes
Lavelekwa ijaji
Who was not supposed to witness according to you.
nd he is targeting the pedis to be witnesses aggman
@nontuthuzelombuthuma5864 shouldn't those in the house be called, your Kelly, your Longwe even the mother? Where are they instead it's police after police covering for one another while the most important are nowhere to be seen
Baloyi is well prepared for this trail until the end, it needs to go to High court of appeal he is ready today
He's more experienced more than all the defence councils combined
Those who asked about relevance of evidence there you have it
what is suspicious about this evidence is that it is from 2023
The officer gave a traffic fine and took Fisos address but did not state the place of the offence.
The judge is doing his job as a residing officer they must just shush
Lol
Presiding officer
Mxm it’s a typo
Where does the judge reside? I hear you say residing officer.
It is presiding officer and not residing officer.
Any evidence from any department brought forward by investigation officer that can assist in resolving the case is necessary. Natis is here to clarify some issues. This Baloyi Prosecutor is a genius. The defence should learn from him❤❤
It actually proves that A1 lied about his whereabouts and now natis is placing him in the province of crime wow wow wow geez funny how the things we do can later harm us.
@@polarloads9084the person who lied in court is Mpimpi Zungu, who testified that he was with the accused @Basothong hostel, showing off his gun to the accused on the day Senzo was killed.
It takes a real man to apologise
HE HAS NO CHOICE IN CASE U DON'T KNOW YET 😅😅😅😅😅
He was forced to apologize by the black lawyer's association
@@sushelarajkumar367You are such a shame-
He’s not genuinely apologetic
That apology was genuine not because he was forced to apologize but because he wanted to. He could've spinned it and said he said "some black lawyers" not all black lawyers
Mr Mnisi is now trying hard to get the likes. How can all lawyers be given the affidavit except him? For sure
Mageba I was very surprised too ...I suspect he was not honest...22/3/2024
He is acting dump
Nnnn
Jj
Why was docket 375 not shown to court?
Ratha reading his apology from his cellphone 📲 nothing but trash 🚮 apology. He doesn’t mean what he said.
U now live in his head and brains what a shame. You misconstrue this man listen to the court proceedings and forget about the rest u will not change anything agreed in this court
@@xxxxxxx9249 GTFOH with that nonsense
,true
Trash indeed!
The apology tendered by Mokgoathleng J today was a sign of bravery....In S v Dalindyebo 1980 (Case of the father of the current abaThembu King Buyelekhaya) Munick CJ in Transkei High Court (as it then was) said "To stand up and apologise to a person you have wronged is a sign of bravery as opposed to cowardice" and i embrace that remark...22/3/2024
It's not like he had a choice. Otherwise he would be on the losing side.
This is a gross irregularity.Baloyi is giving evidence under the pretext that he is just giving some background about what the witness will come and testify.This cannot be allowed.I am shocked the judge is not putting a stop to this.The defence are also sitting on their laurels and not objecting.
They did object at the beginning and the judge wasn't firm enough. Ramsey did and Mnisi.
Mnisi object Judge said Baloyi must continue
You are wrong
I hope you can listen and wait for the judge. Don't come in conclusions, because you are going to mislead us as a community. With all due diligence please sir🙏🏽.
u a very right, was that necessary for him to go through the witness profile experience hence the witness is sitting in a witness box😮 nevertheless we are watching, listen and comment of cause.
Strong case presented by state 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿competent work by sharp police officers cracking this case against ALL ODDS and marvellous prosecution and super brilliant ,top judge handling this case .will definitely see justice for Senzo 🤞🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽…..
True!
Hallelujah, u have spoken it all👏👏👏🙏
Always judge is intervening when it comes to defence but Baloyi he is always right
They don't ask the way he want he want them to put to witnesses that they are lying mara bona they debate. If you remember ka trial within a trial he also mentioned that no one canvassed something I can't remember. From now on they must not ask many questions only 2 questions somaar you put it to the Witnesses that u lie.
Baloyi is a Giant after each day he goes and read transcripts, case laws and rulings. So when he opens his mouth or objections he is as smart as a judge. He is a future judge and I can't say the same for the defence. Objections are baseless and they can't quote any law to overule Dr Baloyi
It's the state case so he should lead evidence.
Wemame ngaze ngachazeka nge evidence esenkantolo kade sasithukwa 😂😂😂😂
BesiQuestioner nange IQ yethu.
State evidence is spot on .Sibiya and Ntanzi has been lying .lying and lying 😢😢😢
Now I’m confused 😢😢😢
@@user-bz7vt6gm6odon't be follow the evidence brought before court and forget about social media theories
No spot on these things happen before 26 October. A person can move from one place to another so this evidence mean nothing
And we said it from the beginning that these nkabis are liers and not to be trusted.
@@user-bz7vt6gm6oThey are guilty shem bona and evidence already showed accused number 3 with dreadlocks ,gold tooth and 9mm parabellum belonging to Mncube s the murder weapon .This evidence rebut the one of Mshololo that because the number of accused number 5 not being rica'd in his name doesn't prove it belongs to him .Today it's proven it's his and steyn proved Kelly was phoned by this number umbuzo uthi why communicate with Nkabiz ?Allegedly
Huu the judge is teaching advocates their job how to probe yuu where did they do their LLB
UNISA
Thanks Mnisi 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
So state has been investigating whilst this case has been on
That's allowed , investigation doesn't stop , that's the reason they always say they don't rule out any possibility of more arrest
They continue to investigate as the mastermind is yet to be arrested
Mnisi must wake up from his slumber and lisen to the evidence. It is such objections that make the judge to behave the way he does towards tbe defence Counsel.
100% correct Gabisile...22/3/2024
Mnisi makes me wonder sometimes, it’s like he sleeps on his brains
@@Wele1012😂😂😂😂😂
Baloyi ur da best
The black lawyers association must meet you not with regards to the merits of the case but your unfortunate utterances about black legal professional's etc. of which I believe the judge thinks he is some color. Your apology is void of genuineness, you being involved in BLA does not make you a "LORD", personally as a lay person I don't accept your apology.
Axactly
He doesn't mean it
Apology wasn't meant for you any way
He has felt the pressure hence The apology,he messed up big time
You on point ❤ judge is not sincere he just likes to brag and he thinks by bragging he must be rude 😤😤😤 envelopes ✉️ talking here
Baloyi is on the ball😢😢😢
Ai some other lawyers you won't believe they went to varsity
Yes Ratha. My judge,, likes to brag...
Bonke laba abathuka iJaji noBaloyi ngezinhlamba bethi bayabheda kodwa bona banezitifiketi zokuzalwa neze vaccine kuphela batshela abantu abama Honors and Masters. Usuke unhloboni yesidomu ngampela🙆. Ay impela, lack of education is the root of all evil🖐
Nam nginese vaccine ne death certificate kuphela but umbhedo ngumbhedo, even a fool can see how these 2 behave, and how this case was fabricated. We expect to hear eyewitnesses not these suspects.
Ubani owathi mawufundile uhlakaniphile
@@mzwandilemanqele1644 are you for real? ngeke ube ne Master"s degree ungahlakaniphile. Kanti kuhlwile impela la kini. Yo plz stay in your lane🖐
@@ConnieMorakeDeath certificate 😮😮😮😮
guys lets learn to agree in order to disagree,this platform is forbid to share views ,and analysis of this meyiwa case,we are all right in our own way,so lets not lets not insults our IQ's pls
Baloyi u are too much, keep it on
Guys, have you forgotten about eyewitnesses in the house? Let us consider their innocence only after their being tested in a witness stand.
This is not a reality show
Why is he saying it here?? He is not even sorry about those comments he made Wednesday, 2024. Eish!! Blacks neh!!!
Why are you here- you are a disgrace- you don’t want peace-
Yuu these advocates no listening skills 🎉🎉😂🎉😊😊😊😊
Baloyi always playing games and judge will defend him which is no longer a fair trial Mnisi never receiced this documents and Ramosepele only received one affidavit not second one...Always new evidence accepted in during trial
Naye wathol eyodwa kodwa iJudge alitsho nex ngalonto
Ratha's apology is not genuine.
He is full of himself
Bloody agent
To whom did he apologized, I only heard Judge Ratha reading Mngomezulu's written letter apologizing to the court👌🤔
Ooh OK now I see, thanx for opening my eyes 🙏
@@mcdeemhlanga7562He read some flimsy apology prior to reading Mngo's email. Just rubbish
Mna i dont know if im a bit late to study to be a lawyet. In our comments we were saying police are corrupt, lazy, incompetent, uneducated, most popular one-not make sure, same go for nurses but when Ratha comments about incompetence of some black lawyers, which is true at times, we hammered him left right and centre. Im just saying
This judge has already made up his mind about this case.
Absolutely. These boys are going straight to jail
@@nette2144kubi makunj cz abanacala labafana
People are forward
Jp must also attend to this judge behavior towards the defense
Mngomezulu, you got kids to feed. Prioritize cases that bring money not this lying nkabis you're representing without being paid.
He was approached by Ramasopele and now the very same Rama is now nasty against Mngomezulu 😢😢he didn't even want to stand in for him while he was not in court on Wednesday 😢😢😢all of a sudden he said he can't because Mngomezulu is more experience 😮😮😮 what a lame excuse 😢😢 🤬 some of them now so against Mngomezulu 💔💔💔💔💔
@SylviaMitchell-tz2sl he said it will be conflict of interest not what you saying
@@SylviaMitchell-tz2sldidn't even acknowledge that the man did speak to him in the presence of others who also denied any knowledge. What is all this?
I like Ratha, he's not intimidated by anyone. This BLA must just get over it, they must stop being dramatic. Ratha was specially directing the comments to Mngomezulu.
Mngomezulu is a Black lawyer
And Mungomezulu apologised. Haters of Judge Ratha not even mentioning Mungomezulu's apology
Ok
Oh yeah... kana Ratha is a white judge. Nice
Chicco twala kuyeza nakuwe
What I can say this system can be updated at any given time by someone who has an excess, especially on Cellphones numbers and addresses. What if it was updated after the cellphone expect testimony? AboGininda ayi ngeke.
My thought also
So you just going to disagree with any piece of evidence because you want to protect these nkabis?
Bro, I'm not protecting anyone but m just following this court case, n my thoughts can not be anyone's thoughts.
You are on point! Evidence keeps coming in trickles as the case is continuing! Why is this even allowed!
I'm working on these types of systems. It is true it can be updated however every change will show date,time and user that made changes. Why do people want to protect these killers that are implicated in so many cases. I believe Baloyi his duty is to bring every evidence before the judge to proof that these people were involved in the killing. People are dwelling on the fact that they were tortured do you think if inkabi can be romanced to give out information. I am still shocked that we can fight people against wrong doing in the name of protecting inkabi unbelievable.
Where did Fisokuhle get the traffic fines as there must be an address of the incident. Street name please
This apology has some extras on the side like sphahlo, doesn’t seem genuine.
Is this how black judges apologize😂😂😂
@@user-kp2vj3pl2w Nope
Lol he probably wanted to even say the same black lawyers association I started now wants a meeting with me on the constitution I created how bizarre is that lol
😂😂😂
Thi case was supposed to be concluded before the death of mr meyiwa (senior)but because south africa like to play with money it is taking long to be finished because wrong people are in the dock.
2.3 M viewers! SA Unemployment needs new gov in May 2024 hleng!!!!!
I used to watch it while at work blast year
It does not mean the nr of people watching 😊now.... that is the nr of subscribers to this channel on anyone day
We are watching using work WiFi 😂
subscribers not views
Yes because u need the whole day to follow this case
So these guys were all born around the same time 1985/86....and people are here saying they have nothing to do with this case
And what is the age has to do with this?
Ntanzi 1990
Exactly same thought here, same what's app group these ones.
yabona " wena lost in translation", that's why SA can't solve this case....we simply can not join the dots
@@zanelemadikane9467
But the calling out of Accussed persons IDENTITY NUMBERS I doubt it's the correct procedure, that includes the codes/number for the DLTC employees....... POPIA
Mnisi is annoying, to say the least.
Annoying for wanting the fair tril?
He plays to the gallery not what the laws says. Baloyi is well versed
Very annoying coz whatever he is saying is out of order and it leads to a situation where u ll doubt whatever he is saying ...22/3/2024
Adv Baloyi knows the application of the Law...
100% correct...22/3/2024
Yah ubukeka efundile yena seningamzonda nje and if ewina le cala uyothola more respects
His very smart indeed
100% correct
His a big respected prosecutor in SA
Lol he ain’t sorry.
BLA should not behave like cry babies, black people don't want to be told when they are wrong.
When is the next trial date
Wena awunayo into ephathekayo ngalelicala
He needs to listen and not be a commentator please.
Am glad BLACK LAWYERS ASSOCIATION aint happy about that athritis mokoupere's utterances 🤮🤮Germany and Botswana doesnt accept that stinking rude justifying apology🫷🏿
That apology was not genuine, Y he wouldn't lift up his head or face
@@timothytshepothobane915 thats the thing aggg he even read it whats that it should come from within his heart meaning it we dont buy that nonsense of apology
But HJ was saying Y mngomezulu to fone HJ,I think DJP, JP JC & JSC must intervene,the trial is already unfair & unConstitutional, the defence may represent their clients in that meeting with BLA,of which some of these defence team might belong to JSC,doesn't mean that if u r founder of BLA u must disrespect us
@@timothytshepothobane915 this man is a disgrace i hope your ramaphosa will act
Is it necessary to read apology
Sekukhulunywa ngamalicence yo!! Lecase ayisoze iphele kuhanjiswa iskhathi ngezingane zabanye abantu buya Jesu umhlaba wonakele😢😢😢
Wonakele mawuvuna izinkabi
😂wonakele mawngenamali ufela ejele crc imbi lento yenziwa ngubaloyi no gininda no zungu kodw asbuke iyaqhubeka maybe siyaya ku 375
@@paulntokozobuhali9022akho nkabi la longwe and Kelly abakhulume qiniso
My fellow brothers and sisters,can you see that this case does undoubtedly implicacates this inkabi s ,every evidence implicated them.
💯
This case does not implicate these guys
On the day Senzo was killed, were the accused @ the hostel with Zungu or were all applying for driver's licenses???????
Except the DNA evidence.
They are going down, the dots are coming together
Fabrication story .We are tired of this nonsense this is a circus indeed.he should call the relevant witnesses instead of this one .
This witness is a very crucial witness. He proved the phone numbers each accused had and their locations too rebuke the defence they pulled against Zungu.Mshololo said the number of the was not proven under rica to be his manje this guy under Natis proved number+polo belonged to accused 5 and now section 205s are ready phone downloads for accused number 1,2,4,5's phone will be in court 🎉🎉🎉.Defence will object the whole day 😂😂😂
Your faves are guilty
There is no fabrication here, only you are coming with conspiracy theories.
Eish kunzima kelly and longwe plzz khulumani akukho kuhle makunj usenzo waziwa nini 😢😢
I know of people who go to different provinces to do their licenses.... it happens. this doesn’t mean he was living there, he could have just gone there to apply for a learners since he lived in JHB before. The evidence we need are people from his family, people he lived with or worked for. this learners booking is not substantial evidence that he lived there. Come on.
This evidence is adduced because he says he has NEVER been to JHB during the time in question which is why this evidence is adduced to rebut his version. People are generally forgetful but electronic data remains the same. Accused one and two have a hand in the death of senzo
@@hopemajoe2577 But having been in JHB for a learners test/drivers license does not prove that he was living in JHB. And to my recollection, accused 1 said he was not residing in JHB in 2014, which could still be true even with this evidence.
I still don't see how they had a hand in the death of Senzo from the evidence presented to us, unless you know of other evidence that is still to come.
Their DNA was not in the house, the descriptions were not of them, Accused 1 and 2 never had dreads and no gold teeth or tattoos, the gun had none of their DNA or prints, the bullet that Senzo was allegedly killed with had no blood or DNA on it so I don't see how any of the current evidence has anything to do with these guys, whether they remember where they were or not.
for some reason just because they can't remember where they were in 2014 on of Senzo's demise, then they did it? even if there is no evidence of them doing it? did you hear their alleged confessions? even those don't align. Remember you can't look at 1 piece of evidence and conclude. its a puzzle with many pieces that must fit to make a coherent picture.
@@rita_TMwatch all court proceedings, you’re messy
@@leeta28 I do watch all the court proceedings. You can bring your argument no need to call me messy.
It's his lawyer that make such unfortunate evidence tha the accused was never the
Ratha, recuse yourself.
Ratha for President
Mnisi uyatatazela kyabashubela manje ba objecta ngisho impukane idlula😅
Ngiyakuchazela abahlalisekile
😂😂😂😂😂😂 object to impukane...22/3/2024
😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂 Yeka imbanje
😂😂😂
Reflection yani wenze ngamabomu
Soo does it give u right to disrespectful
I don't understand oll this isisa kuphi ngoba baloyi mosha isikhati nihlangene no rhata ningamasimba niyangi nyanisa why ningalethi Kelly azokhuluma qiniso raktha ungumkhulu ongena qiniso wena ngedlela uqhuba ngayo kulo court
Baloyi want to prove the lies of the accused as one of them said he wasn't there during that period but ke wena ngoba uyisidom you won't see that
I don’t think his apology is genuine. He should acknowledge that his utterances were inappropriate and unprofessional. It shouldn’t be “if I have offended…). I still sense his arrogance.
Is this a political discourse? Really Ratha is a character. Too opinionated. 😂
Banyise Baloi, loyi them😂😂😂😂
Postponement postponement...yoh
If this ratha mkhulu is thinking about constitutional rights of the accused when he must meet with BLA but didn't think of those constitutional rights when Sibiya and Ntanzi told him they were never read their rights when arrested and they were abused by the police and mkhulu ratha went ahead and admitted those confessions who were obtained illegally... Wow ratha you don't seem to amaze SA🤨🤬
Why did they refused to pay him after all this time. Hes a bread winner, he has family to support😢. How do they expect him to survive. Are they botcoating him the way they did Tefo😢
Who is supposed to pay him?
The Judge must focus on the case not venture into political space-he has a tendency to sleep walk into politics-last time he talked about parliamentarians.
This old man is not the right judge for this case
Nawe kuyafana uthengwe ngu Gininda no Baloyi uyaloqa nokuba ungababneminyaka engakanani uyaxoka maan ayisuka
Advocate baloyi reminded batlou what he said on his statement. There was no reason to read the statement.
I'm just watching the case, tjo Rata wa nanatha he needs to be thought ethics, respect for others and stop telling us about his life history, bo judge Mogweng ba kena kae 🤷🤷🤷
“Marlon, gang of eight””? What’s that got to do with this case. This judge is having a laugh. These jokes are beginning to irritate!!!!
I feel sorry for the judge as this case is frustratingHe should please get the family members on the stand and case will be sorted
Case closed without the murderers? How are the people in the house will be linked in the murder as they were also in shock except KK. They can't even arrest KK without the 5 nkabis.
We really need justice,kungaba kuyibo abasthathela ugoalkeeper wethu
How could he have done so as i believe he was in jail unless he was on bail....one must remember that he was arrested on the 9th Feb 2015....in Cleveland case...22/3/2024
Mapedi are taking mazulu to jail, most of the state witnesses are Pedi speaking people
Then what is your point here?
Angithi isgameko sasiseGoli ukube bsesisethekwin ngabe amazulu asenkantolo
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Joh!! Tribalism, pedis, shangaan, vendas are very intelligent and Zulus are inkabis😅, if want us also to be tribalism like u.
@@thandyglorymorgan9506 pedis?
Enatis it's cannot taken as proof, because the system can be easely maltipulated. There is alleged corraptions of person doing appointments without even been in tasting station. No caranty of what the officer will be outline
People who always say “systems can be corrupted “….where do you work?????? Do you use any systems? Do you have a clue how IT works?
Is this
No they have adjourned until Monday. There was only one witness today
Why does it seem like Nxumalo Mshololo and ramosepele are working with the state/ its me whose exagerating
Really?
Teffo will mislead you 😂😂😂😂
Question for you, if the accused on Monday stood up and all admitted that they did it, and how they did it would you believe them?
Baloyi is working with Sebande. Where did you get that?
They are NOT! They are trying their best under the circumstances
Mnisi forgot to take his medication today😮😮😮😮
😂😂😢😅😂
Ngiyakuvuma Baloyi no Ratha
kodwa ingane pakit uBongani mxoleleni tuuuh
We can try to defend these guys but they're guilty. Evidence is against them. Ntuli choosing to be the State witness now, says a lot. Ntanzi should've taken the state offer and by now he'd be home like Zungu, instead of being someone's enemy because he confessed
Which evidence?
But kunzima ukuqambela abantu amanga sazi kahle ukuth usenzo wabulawa ulongwe nawe wakuzwa lokho kodwa uzozenza islima la why untanzi wayezoba istate witness ngoba ejabulisa ugininda ukhuluma umsuzo wena la kuthiwa icala lembula ingubo lingene asethembe ukuth kuwe angeke yenzeka into enjalo damm kop
@@KhanyiNala I was like you but don't worry you will catch up. Next time don't curse or insult people. You're too old for that
Is Ntuli the state witness?
@@KhanyiNala this is just fabrication of the accused. They are innocent n innocent until proven guilty😊
Irrelevant this is nonsense has nothing to do with this matter the judge is the state 210 is clear
Useles evidence people buy learners and licences. If i was Sibiya was going to say so. I bribed never wrote anything. Simple.
So you would lie inorder to getaway with murder.
Then he won't be on the system
Even though you have buy it by bribing officials officers, you have to be there physically. So no way to run here.
All that he said doesn't warrant his utterances
When is Kheli going to testify in court?
Kelly will testify if these 5 are found guilty
Just wait Baloyi is exposing the lies of this two boys Ntanzi and Sibiya. He said when Senzo was killed he was at home Kwa Nongoma.Todays evidence shows he was writing his learners in Branson using Basotho Hostel address
@@robertnheta1935The state has enough evidence.. Next week they are bringing back that cellphone expert. Kuzoba lit because cellphone records shows Sibiya was communicating with Kelly and Umkhulu the Inyanga
Ask again.....
@@joerathokolo5106😂😂😂kuningi
Akaboshwe unamanga lo ntanzi wakhona
The time you say this, Trayali aah
Dannym nkabi izinqa zakho lezi ezinukayo ezingagezwa
If...
The truth will come out one day..This accused are Innocent..no matter how BALOYI can try to pine them
How do you know? If you have any evidence, you can use it to help the accuse
The evidence in court don't shows their innocent only gossip outside the court
@anthonynchabeleng2664 Warrant officer Makhubo & Co.. have evidence
@@gladysmkhize4085 They is no valid evidence in this court just a cooked stories. The brother of the late Senzo Meyiwa. His the one who said "Kudlalwa ngalabafethu, abambulalanga uSenzo. This is a fictional story
So if they themselves are telling you that they are involved in this and that they were ordered to kill senzo by Kelly, you still deny that they did it?
wena Baba awnanhlonipho amazulu uyaweyisa nje kwaphela