Wish You Were Here is my favorite, but this album is close behind it. That first side is such a wonderful collection of songs, and the first time I heard the album, I had borrowed it from a friend in high school. When you have to flip the album at the end of "Seamus", you have no idea what is waiting on side 2! "Echoes" just blew me away the first time I heard it, and it's like hearing it the first time, every time. That ping...and the slow build up is sonic bliss!
The funny thing is that he sings one note wrong in the song. It's actually the right note, but Roger chose to use the wrong note. so when he sings it wrong it's right, but when someone else sings it right it's wrong. The two notes in the word Tropez he sings here are A & E, but Roger sings A & F. It sounds really bizarre at first, but once you get used to it, it sounds really cool.
Roger didn't sing it wrong on purpose, he was/still is pretty tone deaf. Just go listen to some of their live stuff from before dark side of the moon, he barely hits a single right note
Is there an 'official scores'? I mean... If it was recorded 'wrong', how one can say it is not right since the official version is supposed to be the recorded one? Just curious, and thank you for the information!
@Matt He was actually pretty good in his early years (not great but good, for example, on the song If on the album Atom Heart Mother). And secondly, deaf people cannot sing or play music, neither good nor bad.
It sure does. What scale or mode is Rick playing? I don’t play piano but I understand theory, I would love to get a keyboard and play this. It sounds like he’s just improvising over the chords maybe ? I dunno. I LOVE it though!! 😀😀
Wow, I am truly amazed! I wouldn't have noticed, that this is cover, only different voice revealed it. It's one of the most accurate covers that I've ever seen in my entire life. Great job!
I agree with Blatouch96....music sounds right on the money...Only way to tell that this is a cover is by the voice...Great job. I like that you showed all parts being played on a split screen. thanks
Many compliments to all the band. A really beautiful reproduction. Much compliments to the drummer in particular, because it's really really difficult to reproduce the Mason relaxed-laid back way of drumming :). Keep going so.
Thank you for commenting Nicolas. In fact to play each instrument melody takes a time ... As I didn't play the drums I suppose that the process is the same for this instrument... hear carefully each part and practice it
Parabéns pelo trabalho, amigo. Já assisti muitos covers de Pink Floyd, mas tenho certeza de que esse é o melhor que pude ouvir até hoje. Obrigado por isso e muito sucesso!
A very underrated PF song. One of Roger's best in my opinion.
It was written by Rick
@@scarrafune perhaps co-written by Rick?
@Richard S Actually, the song was entirely written by Roger. (lyrics and music). He came to the studio one day with this work fully done.
@@tinkerbell868 Yes, you're historically correct 😂
Meddle is my favorite Pink Floyd album. Came out in rock's greatest year ever... 1971
Wish You Were Here is my favorite, but this album is close behind it. That first side is such a wonderful collection of songs, and the first time I heard the album, I had borrowed it from a friend in high school. When you have to flip the album at the end of "Seamus", you have no idea what is waiting on side 2! "Echoes" just blew me away the first time I heard it, and it's like hearing it the first time, every time. That ping...and the slow build up is sonic bliss!
@@Architectureguy That's the Pink Floyd Anthem
Don't know how many times i've came back here to watch again...
perfect man !
One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs, masterfully interpreted. Congratulations!
The funny thing is that he sings one note wrong in the song. It's actually the right note, but Roger chose to use the wrong note. so when he sings it wrong it's right, but when someone else sings it right it's wrong. The two notes in the word Tropez he sings here are A & E, but Roger sings A & F. It sounds really bizarre at first, but once you get used to it, it sounds really cool.
Roger didn't sing it wrong on purpose, he was/still is pretty tone deaf. Just go listen to some of their live stuff from before dark side of the moon, he barely hits a single right note
Is there an 'official scores'? I mean... If it was recorded 'wrong', how one can say it is not right since the official version is supposed to be the recorded one? Just curious, and thank you for the information!
@Jimmy Page how is Robert ? Do you’ll keep in touch ? When is your new album being released ? Lol .
@@lbragari Right on point! These delusional people don't have a clue it seems!
@Matt He was actually pretty good in his early years (not great but good, for example, on the song If on the album Atom Heart Mother).
And secondly, deaf people cannot sing or play music, neither good nor bad.
Well done guys from India.One of Waters' gem.Songs like these never get played in concerts.
Great cover! The keyboard solo of this song rules :-)
It sure does. What scale or mode is Rick playing? I don’t play piano but I understand theory, I would love to get a keyboard and play this. It sounds like he’s just improvising over the chords maybe ? I dunno. I LOVE it though!! 😀😀
OUTSTANDING.....!
Excellent.
A beautiful performance of less known Pink Floyd themes!....
Dude. I still haven't learned just the guitar after 25 years of hearing that song.......Bravo 👏
OUTSTANDING cover, guys!
I can't believe this. Every note... every drum beat... unreal...
Absolutely flawless.
Muchas gracias Nicolás
Wow, I am truly amazed! I wouldn't have noticed, that this is cover, only different voice revealed it. It's one of the most accurate covers that I've ever seen in my entire life. Great job!
A WONDERFUL rendition!!!
Absolutely brilliant. Note perfect and totally awesome. I'm horribly envious :)))
No way!!! NO WAY!!! It's like Waters, Gilmour, Wright, Mason, and the whole recording studio staff in one person!!!! Insane.
Thank you Joy
Very good cover thanks
great cover for a great song
Brilliant!
Brilliantly done. Bravo.
Big hat tip from South Shields, England, UK.
Very interesting chords. Love it
Saudações do Brasil!! ;) Awesome play!
Gorgeous tele
Thank you Michael
What a great cover. Well done guys! I'll study this as a humble student, because it is a masterclass. Thanks for your generosity.
Got this !! Excellent...thank you MobyDick
Meddle and Atom Heart Mother are two favorite albums complements Pink Floyd. Love this simple tune.
Unbelievable song. I always underrated it
Absolutely great stuff very well put together
Excellent
you're a great musician. very accustomed to each instrument and each song. well done
Very well done! Thank you
Thanks for your comments!!
Muy Buen Sonido!!! espectacular cover!
I love how u can hear that Eastern European accent in there haha overall GREAT job! Thanks for sharing
Fidelidade absurda
love this song great cover guys
Thanks from Brazil
Splendid. Just splendid.
Greetings from Portugal.
sensacional muito bom parabens
Obrigado Marcelo..
Muito Bom!
Parabéns!
Marcos Alipio
Wow! Very nice indeed. Bravo.
I also have this song in my wish list...but now I am working in another great Gilmour song: Out of the Blue from the album About Face
Fantastic
SEEMS FINe ALL THE INSTRUMENTS . NICE COVER . I wanteD pf PLAY TI LIVE
Beautiful 💕 great video 😊
Awesome guys! Sounded great!! One of my favorites!!!
great song....
Grato pelo comentário Marcos. Fico contente que tenha gostado.
Thank you Nicole
Thanks for listening
I agree with Blatouch96....music sounds right on the money...Only way to tell that this is a cover is by the voice...Great job. I like that you showed all parts being played on a split screen. thanks
Obrigado Diogo!
excellent, congratulation!!!, saludos desde Argentina
Super awesometastic.
Great!!!
Thank you for watching
Great work! Very nice cover! Cheers, -Mike.
wowww!!!
Great surprise.
Grato Ronaldo. Fico contente que tenha gostado.
Thank you
Thank you for watching and commenting!
Thank you Ed...I would love to do live shows but it would be only with the drummer and I...
Many compliments to all the band. A really beautiful reproduction. Much compliments to the drummer in particular, because it's really really difficult to reproduce the Mason relaxed-laid back way of drumming :). Keep going so.
Amazing cover man!!
One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs.
Thanks for watching
Obrigado!
Thank you. I am happy you liked it!
Thank you Derp
Superb cover!!
Thank you for commenting Nicolas. In fact to play each instrument melody takes a time ... As I didn't play the drums I suppose that the process is the same for this instrument... hear carefully each part and practice it
Thank you!
amazing
Parabéns pelo trabalho, amigo. Já assisti muitos covers de Pink Floyd, mas tenho certeza de que esse é o melhor que pude ouvir até hoje. Obrigado por isso e muito sucesso!
Thank you Fleck
un EXCELENTE cover!!! gracias por esta excelente melodía de los grandes!
tks for watching
Love that cover, very Good job 😎
Really beautiful, nice work on the slide guitar and piano outro
tks
that was so smooth... superb!
Perfeito.
Wow, very, very nice. Great work Carlos! Nice sounding mix too.
beautiful! very people appreciate saint tropez!
Impressive cover!! My congrats!!
Superb!
Very nice!
Fantastic job! This cover sounded terrific!
Really really really good!
GREAT JOB
thanks
Amazing!!!
Very well done, sir!
Fantastic cover! Has to be one of my favourite floyd songs.